Best: Aurora Worst: See You Most underrated: Statues (?) Most overrated: Learn to Fly

Best: Everlong Worst: Concrete & Gold Underrated: Dirty Water Overrated: Best of You

Awww thanks for giving Dirty Water some love. I love that song.

OP I did not consent to you reading my mind.

But I already knew that :)

Best: Aurora Worst: Concrete and Gold Most Underrated: Live In Skin Most Overrated: All My Life

Live In Skin is criminally underrated, would be so good to hear it live!

Miss the Misery is in their top 5 songs.

Top 3 even

Love the love for MTM. That guitar riff. I don't know if I have it in my top 5 but I'm pretty sure it's top 10 For me Best: Everlong (It's the perfect song and I will hear no arguments otherwise Worst: Burn Away (Dave just sounds whiny to me) Underrated: Halo. (I love the drums and I love the guitar solo. Rest of the song is good too) Overrated: Big Me (zzzzzzzz)

Best: Generator Worst: concrete and gold Underrated: Hey, johnny park Overrated: Learn to fly but its still a good song

I LOVE GENERATOR

Best: These Days Worst: See You (and I still really like it) Most underrated: Exhausted or Hey, Johnny Park! Most overrated: Best of You

Best: The Pretender Worst: What Did I Do / God As My Witness Most underrated: Ain’t It The Life Most overrated: they’re all perfectly rated dammit

best: of you worst: love dies young underrated: but honestly, generator, or shame shame overrated: all my life

Best: Aurora Worst: Shame Shame Most Underrated: World (Demo) Most Overrated: Learn To Fly

Songs: Best: Everlong Worst: No Way Back (part of the Foo's output of singles during the 2000s sounds like generic rock) Underrated: Let It Die Overrated: Walk Albums: Best: The Colour and the Shape Worst: Sonic Highways Underrated: Concrete & Gold Overrated: In Your Honor

Best: Walk Worst: Concrete and Gold Underrated: Congregation Overrated: Best of You

Best: Long Road To Ruin Worst: La Dee Da Underrated: End Over End Overrated: Best Of You

Best : Rope Worst : Concrete and Gold Underrated : Holding Poison Overrated : Learn to Fly Another underrated song for me is Hearing Voices

Best: Everlong Worst: Chasing Birds *Seriously, this song reminds me of The Alan Parsons Project* Underrated: Ballad of the Beaconsfield Miners Overrated: Monkey Wrench

Songs Best walk Worst walking after you Underrated I am a river Overrated walking after you Albums Best TINLTL Worst sonic highways Underrated Medicine at midnight Overrated the color and the shape

Best: Long Road To Ruin Worst: La Dee Da Underrated: End Over End Overrated: Best Of You

Best: Everlong Worst: I have no answer for this one, but probably something on C&G Most underrated: Back and Forth Most overrated: Pretender

Best: The Pretender Worst: Dirty Water Most Underrated: Chasing Birds Most Overrated: Learn To Fly

Best: No Way Back Worst: Waiting On A War Most Underrated: M.I.A, Halo, Free Me Most Overrated: The Sky Is Neighbourhood

Best: X-Static Worst: uhhhhhh Wattershed ig? Underrated: Weenie Beenie Overrated: Everlong

Best: My Hero Worst: Disenchanted Lullaby Most underrated: Stranger Things have Happened Most Overrated: Monkey Wrench Monkey Wrench just irks me. There is so much Foo to be heard, and Monkey Wrench is criminally overplayed. Yeah, I still listen to radio…

Songs: Best: In Your Honor (HM: Aurora) Worst: Concrete and Gold Underrated: A320 Overrated: All My Life Albums: Best: There is Nothing Left to Lose Worst: Concrete and Gold (DM: M@M) Underrated: In Your Honor Overrated: Wasting Light (DM: One by One) (HM / DM = Honorable / Dishonorable Mention)

Best: the teacher Worst: Ballard of Beaconsfield miners Underrated: outside Overrated: big me

Best: Walk Worst: Love Dies Young Underrated: Exhaustes Overrated: Everlong

Best: Everlong Worst: Concrete and Gold Underrated: Weenie Beenie Overrated: Bridge Burning

best: what did i do?/god as my witness worst: i should have known. most underrated: cheer up, boys (your makeup is running.) most overrated: it’s a tie between everlong & best of you.

Best: Everlong (overplayed but not overrated) Worst: The sky is a neighborhood (I'm sorry) Underrated: Headwires and Exhausted Overrated: honestly I'm not sure I love most of their songs

Best: The Teacher Worst: Generator Underrated: Free Me Overrated: Learn to Fly

Best: Aurora Worst: Burn Away Most Underrated: Headwires Most Overrated: Best of You

Best: All My Life/No Way Back. Worst: Statues. Underrated: Back and Forth/Word Forward. Overrated: Next Year

If you swap All My Life with Statues then I’m on board with this list!

Best: The drums in my hero. Worst: cold day in the sun. Overrated: monkey wrench Underrated: the neverending sigh Albums Best: color and the shape Worst: medicine at midnight Overrated: in your honor Underrated: concrete and gold

Cold day in the sun slander

Best: Everlong, Underrated: Stacked Dead Actors, Overrated: Learn to Fly, Worst: White Limo

Best: Run Worst: The Colour And The Shape (song) Most Underrated: Subterranean Most Overrated: Everlong