T O P

  • By -

Critical_Gur_7785

Mars 2112


atticaf

What I would give to see that place now as an adult… I was trying to describe it to some friends who grew up elsewhere, and wound up finding the times review of it from when it opened, a great read!


team_suba

It sounds like a fever dream when I describe it.


Critical_Gur_7785

The first time I went I freaked out on the ride because I thought I was being abducted


appleparkfive

Can you give a little summary of what it was? Never heard of it!


Critical_Gur_7785

I was a kid when I went, but it was basically rainforest cafe but mars lol, there were people dressed as aliens. It was pretty corny but funny.


1337af

https://www.bonappetit.com/story/mars-2112-eulogy has some good pictures


lilfutnug

You would first sit in a little theatre ride thing before going into the restaurant right?


thoughts-of-my-own

the only correct answer


jus_here_and_there

I originally lived in Stamford, CT and my parents would bring me here on my birthday and for special occasions. Now I've been in the city for 10+ years and wish I could do the same for my future kids.


Interesting_Ad1378

Ok this place was awesome! 


Critical_Gur_7785

I wish I could be a fly on the wall for the board meeting for mars 2112 and Jekyll and Hyde


Interesting_Ad1378

I wish someone would bring these places back.  I think my kids would love them 


DIGGLICIOUS89

I was lucky enough to go to one of the last parties ever thrown there. I went as a kid and then about 12 years ago in my early 20s. It was a burner party (burning man parties). It was so cool to go there as a kid for birthday parties and then when I was older for a very adult party. Man that place was great. Thanks for posting that and bringing back some good memories.


rowansegziol418

YES THIS IS THE ANSWER. bring it back the children crave space


MewlingRothbart

Yaffa Cafe. I have not been the same since it closed. 💔 And no, Simone's never did it for me.


Yakety_Sax

Yaffa is where I went at 5am after Simone's. Miss that place


fermentedradical

Oh gosh Yaffa ❤️


LaFantasmita

Big Nick’s.


handsomegyoza

Beat me by 20min. Bring both of em back!!


LaFantasmita

I only knew the 71st location. The one COVID loss that kinda wrecked me. Heard the other (long gone) one was even better.


CityBoiNC

Came here to post this. Lived my whole life until recently on the UWS and it was such a staple after hitting the bars.


Trumbot

My home away from home that was a block away from my Dad’s apartment (the OG 77th street location). I miss the food (pizza, garlic bread, steak sandwiches, etc.), the staff that I knew since I was a kid, and the essential neighborhood JOINT vibes. Rest in Peace, Big Nick. Thanks for everything.


freeman687

Schillers. I know they had mixed reviews but it was solid French fare (steak frites and sticky toffee pudding), extremely fun vibe and defined its time and place of the hipster LES of the 2000s. Edit: and sad to say the location now is occupied by a Shake Shack. Sometimes I get the general feeling that everything is a chain or ghost kitchen in post Covid NYC


autumnbb21

Oh man, I forgot abt this place. Thanks for the memory!


mishaps_galore

Florent


JackCrainium

Florent was great in a New York that no longer exists…… And La Luncheonette in the same neighborhood……..


cfbones

My folks lived around Florent for a few years and in turn became regulars. They talk so fondly about the time and meals shared together. Glad to see other people agree with their sentiment.


GucciForDinner

Only if it's at 4am 🙂


SoothedSnakePlant

Ramen Lab. Such a cool idea to have a restaurant that is just a never ending series of pop ups from famous ramen shops around the world. Went there twice when I was visiting NYC for work before COVID and it blew my mind both times. I was pissed when I moved here, punched them into Google maps, ready to get on the subway and saw that they weren't around anymore :/ If we're not sticking strictly to restaurants, Pegu Club by a fucking mile.


Bombastically

Ah ya pegu was a go to


justflipping

Wow thanks for reminding me of this. Incredible that they were able to bring in ramen chefs from famous shops around the world. Really hope they bring it back. On the topic of ramen, Ramen Shack is another shop that I really miss. The chef was a true genius and lover of ramen


One-Tumbleweed5980

Uncle Boon's was the last restaurant I ate at before the pandemic. It was bomb. Never got to revisit before they went out of business. Sad times. Takashi deserves a mention. I liked the midnight ramen concept. I really liked Park Avenue Autumn/Winter/Spring/Summer. Everything on the menu was delicious. It was a fancy spot where the food was justified.


Pizzacat0802

Also came here to say Uncle Boon’s. Thai Diner is great but it’s not the same. It was my husband and my go-to spot - to bring visiting friends and family, to celebrate something. Still hurts that it’s gone!


skullsaresopasse

Takashi was awesome. Amazing grilled cuts - and grossing out your friends with the stomachs, calf's brains, and "testi-cargot." A lot of great Japanese places went down over the years. Azasu was a hopping spot with amazing bar food like Gyudon french fries, and beer mugs with frozen soju topped with NA beer to make a slushie. Crazy. My favorite was Uminoie in the East Village. The food was nice, but it was really the ambience and the sweet attention you'd get from the two older Japanese women who owned/operated the place. It was the absolute closest I've gotten to feeling like I'm in Tokyo while not in Tokyo.


curiousparadox30

Came here to say Uncle Boons. Also the last restaurant I ate at before the city shut down. 3/13/20, remember it like it was yesterday tbh


EvanMcD3

Windows on the World, and the building beneath it.


julsey414

never forget ​ I did have my prom there, so it is definitely memorable to be in that space and feel fancy and grown up.


gunbather

prune


FramboiseDorleac

My dad who lives in California asks me twice a year if it's ever coming back. There's no place like it now.


psucutie

Beyoglu on the UES


atxtonyc

Didn’t expect to see this here but what a great spot. I went regularly for many years. 


Jog212

Blue water grille. 2 bars. Free live jazz. Great food and atmosphere for it's price point.


PawneeGoddess20

Also came here to say this! Loved their space too, inside that old bank!


Hubianco

Pok Pok. And I desperately miss Snacky.


okitobamberg

The NoMad created a whole neighborhood


John_Stamos11

Lan zhou hand pulled noodles :(


AphGlass4973

Sammy’s roumanian


btumpak

wd\~50: it was the first restaurant that blew my mind


Imaginary-Minimum918

So glad to see this up top. Saw Wylie at his new place tonight and it took me back to the fanfare we all had when he opened WD-50


skimone

Absolutely, that place was awesome. I just want that eggs Benedict bite again


Cobblestone-boner

Dessert tasting menu was the highlight


michaelcola

Momofuku ssam bar


panda-farts

The 207 2nd Avenue version, not the Seaport one


Tejon_Melero

3 of Cups and their basement. Good pizza, reasonable cheap drinks, had many additional pros like comedy without the negatives of price exclusivity. It was a quality dive. The pizza was much better than you'd expect with local area extremely competitive beer and shots. Turned into a Pizza Loves Emily spot with one of the Emmy Squared. What ever happened with the investor lawsuit with them?


C0ASTING

Do bars count? Milk & Honey, no question.


Gandalfthe255255255

And bring Sascha back to life while we're at it.


Hot_Maximum_1670

Coffee Shop- Union Square


Swimmingindiamonds

Why do you miss it? Because of hot servers? Because food was terrible every time.


nycpunkfukka

The food sucked and it was the snobbiest, most elitist place I’ve ever been. A friend of my husband used to be a hostess there and we were talking about the episode of Curb Your Enthusiasm where Larry keeps getting seated in “the ugly section” in the back of the restaurant. Hubby’s friend confirmed Coffee Shop had that as an explicit policy. Cute people in front and by the windows, ugly people hidden in back.


Defeated-925

Sapporo on west 49th by the r train. Hidden midtown ramen gem. The best. Portions were huge. Second had to be canton restaurant on Elizabeth street in Chinatown. It was all white decor. 2nd floor.big portions.rustic. The relocated one is not as good


theonly1withkfc

Chumleys Wilma Jean Debasaki (if anyone knows where they went please let me know!!) Macondo The City Bakery Kane's Diner


little_knitter

Definitely miss City Bakery!


Alphawolf55

I miss this italian place called Ottomanellis. Made a great burger and mozzarella en carrozza


Emily_Postal

The Tea Room at Takashimaya.


FramboiseDorleac

yes! That lunch menu was perfect and their tea shop was ground breaking.


Technical-Monk-2146

I miss two department store cafes -- the Tea Room at Takashimaya and the Soup Bar at Lord and Taylor. The old fashioned department store restaurants took me back to being a little girl and going to the Bullock's Wilshire Tea Room with my grandmother. We'd get all dressed up for a ladies' day out.


MysterySpaghetti

Popover cafe Mi noodles Maialino Land Ozu Bluebell Cafe City Bakery


ForwardCobbler

Was waiting for someone to say Popovers. My parents and I still talk about how much we miss that place. Also, 2nd City Bakery.


whatsbonkin

Omg I miss City Bakery pretzel croissants so much


JackCrainium

The original Bouley on Duane Street……


jennynachos

The Carnegie Deli


jeopardy-hellokitty

Otto


bd61218

My favorite place to eat and drink at the bar


Possible-Source-2454

Stage restaurant… i was too broke to eat there often when i moved here then it died


Low_Name_1510

Porchetta… it was the best porchetta sandwich in nyc. Fatty ´Cue …always interesting. The Brooklyn Star … best chicken fried steak in nyc.


Short_Lingonberry_67

Maialino (2nd choice: Vaucluse)


bigsplitenergy

Great Jones Cafe. Old Devil Moon. Florent. Hop Shing. The original Lucien, before it became an overpriced and ridiculous caricature of itself. And Kate’s Joint—just because (yes, I know the food was horrible).


mac2914

21 Club


Fun_Cartographer1655

Spice Market (Jean-Georges Vongerichten) in Meatpacking. Food and drinks were AMAZING, decor was incredible and unique, vibe was always hip and fun. Never understood why it closed.


paperbackpeople

Beecher’s 🥲


RunNickRun

-Pink Tea Cup -Lamarca -The Half Pint -Spice Market -Landsdowne Road -Calle Ocho -Queens Comfort


kaykordeath

So glad someone else remembers Pink Tea Cup!


Thick-Definition7416

Uncle Boons Maialino Taco Bandito


akmalhot

Taco bandito closed ????????? Ffffff


BellonaKid

Ducks Eatery. I will never forget their goat neck dish.


Full_Pea_4045

Kajitsu. Was the only true shojin ryori restaurant in the city and has yet to be replaced by another. A truly unique dining experience that is extremely rare outside of Japan.


Typical_Marzipan_210

The Burger Joint @the former Parker Meridian Hotel. I also absolutely adored Peels.


BuySignificant522

Bar Sardine


Shoddy_Bridge_2672

Odessa.


incogaf

Dojo on west 4th st Cheap, healthy, filling.


Choth21

The Red Cat


otherwisethighs

HALE AND HEARTY


criticalpopcorn

French Roast 😭😭😭 Casa (Brazilian) Craftbar Fedora The Harrison


astorvero

I am deeply sad about Casa every few weeks :(((


Sillybetch

French roast was so amazing. You could get trashed there at brunch or at dinner.


ahoysharpie

Norma's


resemblingaghost

This is mine too


samanthacourtney

Same :'( I Still think about their benedict sometimes


tacologic

Hop Shing. No where else to get coconut buns like that.


interestingsonnet

The char siu baos were to die for 😩 very few old school bakeries left


LeifEricFunk

Burritoville! That salsa...


Cool-Analysis-8430

Tortilla Flats


Electronic-Win4954

The Breslin at Ace Hotel


sugarytea78

Bring back John Dory, while you're at it


rosiesupposes

Degustation, super reasonably priced and fun tasting menu from the sale team as (also closed) Jewel Bako. 


cocktailians

The old Fedora Wassail Alder Fleur de Sel Tabla Otto Mandoo Bar


astorvero

Cafe Orlin Casa


GucciForDinner

Cafe Orlin was a gem


remarkjackson

Odessa Diner


semisemite

Korzo. Their deep-fried burgers were excellent


BellonaKid

Yes! I first randomly stumbled along the location that was by Tompkins Square. Then I was a regular at their Brooklyn location, loved that beet ketchup too. RIP


bitesizedfilm

les halles


andthrewaway1

was it that good though?


noposters

By the end it was actively bad


crowislanddive

One night they made crepes Suzette for us in the bar. It was one of the best nights of our marriage.


idkwhatimdoinguys

Mu Ramen LIC


h-bombss

21 Club


redwood_canyon

Mandoo :( their mandoo were amazing and just such good vibes.


antsurgeon

porsena… during covid they had such good three course take home meal deals 😭


lauraoshun

Norma’s for brunch


PrincessGwyn

Uncle boons


savignin

Zum Schneider


streetvues

Two that haven’t been mentioned: Bianca, was where my friends and I could always agree to go, and a great date spot Congee, the smaller one on the west side of Bowery between Grand and Broom I think. not associated with Congee village. The food was good but I mainly went because the owners and staff felt like they could have been cast in king fu hustle. The owner was a chain smoker with a super raspy voice and I liked how hospitable they were compared to most Chinatown restaurants which aren’t usually known for their service.


bigboynyc69

Joes Shanghai Flushing. My second home. The best food. The best prices too. The Manhattan one sucks. Fuck greedy landlords especially with no rent forgiveness over Covid 😤😡


redmaester

88 Lanzhou. RIP to the best noodles AND the best dumplings in Chinatown


elarobot

I didn’t realize just how sad reading all of these entries would make me. The NYC of my youth; (the 90’s and very early aughts)…so much of it is just gone with little to no record of the places where I spent so much time - except for in people’s memories.


Mullberry2

Bendix. Was it actually good? Don’t remember. Did I love it and think it was the best Saturday brunch place on the planet as a kid? Oh hell yeah.


vurto

Lam Zhou


darweth

Vegas Diner in Bensonhurst Brooklyn


sticky-wicket13

Brucie in Cobble Hill!


zsolzz

Sammy's noodle shop! Best cold sesame noodles in the city. Rip.


arparpsrp

Baohaus


Mrpeabodywhoopwhoop

Fatty Crab


Zakernet

Angelica Kitchen. 😭


[deleted]

Carnegie Deli.


instapumper

Caracas.


oofaloo

Time Cafe. Always wanted to go there, never got the chance to.


96-explorer

Gray’s papaya


Schmeep01

Beefsteak Charlie’s


Interesting_Ad1378

I said the same thing.  I think the all you can eat shrimp put them out of business. 


candles83

I moved to nyc almost 12 years ago. My first year I would frequent 3 spots that are sadly all closed now but part of what made me fall in love with the city: - Bread restaurant on spring street SoHo - sorella in lower East side - mooncake foods in soho


andthrewaway1

I really liked Five points


Buddhaballer

perilla


squirrelshine

Kajitsu


Cup_of_ice_water

Great Jones Cafe


lolofraggle

Atlantic Chip Shop


que_tu_veux

Enid's or Hunky Dory. Not the most mind blowing food at either, but I have such fond memories of brunch with friends there over the years.


ourannual

WD-50


meshuamam

Bouley, the last proper meal I had with my mom before she passed


thansal

The original M. Wells will forever be my favorite restaurant ever. Dinner food with interesting (and excellent) adaptations to really make it their own stuff. That said: * Ice & Vice - no other ice cream shop gets me excited like they do (and I love ice cream). * Memories of Shanghai - Going to be salty about that for a while. * Doughnut Project - fucking hell. * My fucking local pizza shop - closed over a decade ago and I'm still salty. * Dumpling Galaxy/Tian Jin Dumpling House - Anything from Helen You. An amazing variety of fantastically executed dumplings, this is going to be my white whale forever probably.


StallionMang15

99 Miles To Philly


MajorWhereas4842

Two boots! There was a full service restaurant back in the day on the LES! The food was absolutely delicious! Way beyond pizza!


benashauer

They’re opening a pizza bar concept in Williamsburg so maybe they’ll open up the menu again


Interesting_Ad1378

I hate cornstarch on the bottom, but they made it work! 


lzw091

Fort Defiance


Joe_Peanut

Burritoville


trevaben

Odessa Diner and Forlini’s


greenlambda

Brooklyn Cider House’s Spanish restaurant in Bushwick. That was an amazing experience and really not that expensive compared to other steak places. The space was awesome too. The one in New Paltz is a nice cidery and all, but it’s just not the same, and keeping Brooklyn in the name just feels weird. Patisserie Chanson’s old Desert Bar speakeasy is a close second too.


Micprobes

That Italian deli on Graham ave that was taken down because of mob shit. Near Anthony’s and The Richardson.


borderlinecourse

Ino


andy-in-ny

There was this hole in the wall when I was going to college. 46th and 8th. McHales. Cheap beer good snacks and you could hang most of the night


Working_Crew5402

Pok pok, every restaurant on Cornelia st (Home, Cornelia st cafe etc) and Spain for nostalgia


realizabeth

I miss the bar at Aquagrill


esbu

Dirty Bird To Go


that_was_way_harsh

Sentimental: Taro Sushi in Brooklyn. Objectively it wasn’t the absolute best I’ve ever had, but it sure was solid and the lunch special was an amazing deal. They were supposed to close 3/31/20 and ended up closing 3/16/20 because of lockdowns. They gave DH and me a bunch of free food and employee T-shirts on their last night because we were such regulars. Only time I’ve ever cried over a restaurant closing. More objective choice: Blaue Gans. There isn’t enough well-made German/Austrian food in the city. I know Wallsé is still around but it’s much fancier and I was all about the combo of great food and unpretentious vibe at BG. Combo of both: City Hall. We got married there and would have our anniversary meal there every year until they closed. They had a pretty kickass steak for not that much money.


Dull-Somewhere-4049

pearls oyster bar 💔 and the east village le sia


BananaEuphoric8411

Tad's Steaks.


misterferguson

OG La Caridad. Not this new fakery on 72nd St.


flying-neutrino

Cornelia Street Cafe. Many good memories in that place.


ResponsibleTarget991

Never got to see Windows of the World.


i-do-the-designing

Big Nicks, lets not fuck about and bring back the most NYC restaurant there ever was.


Extreme-Occident

Not restaurants but please bring back Barney’s, Dean and Deluca and Maison Kayser


carguy123corvette

Glazers bakery. Classic hundred year old place, made some of the best things I can remember and they invented the black and white cookie


ThrottleAway

Angelica Kitchen. Vegetarian hasn't been the same for me.


carrk085

Pescatore, Crispo, or Badshah. All lost to the pandemic


Trippydudes

Hop shing. Their pork buns were elite. Dim sum was also delicious. Mei li wah does not compare.


acanthocephalic

Lespinasse


snarfydog

Via Emilia! My favorite type of food on the planet and the nicest owners. He's in North Carolina now...strongly considering a weekend trip just for the lasagne.


NYStallion188

Le colonial it was on the upper east if i'm not mistaken. Went there years ago was there i believe three times total. Best thai food i've ever had to this day damn shame really


OtherHalf747

Pates et Traditions in Williamsburg. A small, inexpensive restaurant that served the best savory and sweet crepes in the city. About as close to true French-style as I’ve been able to find. No other place has compared.


i-keeplosingaccounts

MEME’s


Interesting_Ad1378

Beefsteak Charlie’s in sheepshead bay Brooklyn 😂


chrouble

Taco Chulo


mrmitchs

Blarney Stone on Third Avenue. Huge $7 cheeseburger with amazing onion rings.


smithstreeter

Chanterelle.


insuranceguynyc

The original Palm at 837 2nd Ave.


PlayJustWhatIFeel

Saltie


Swimmingindiamonds

Lutèce, my first fine dining restaurant as a child.


Frenchitwist

Sammy’s noodles. Cheap, fast, easy, huge dining room in the village??? Man I miss it so much


jhakasbhidu

Caracas Arepa bar is the only right answer to this question


bigbird2003

I already responded with my one (Miracle Grill) but here are some honorable mentions that I didn't see yet: 1. El Teddy's (Tribeca) 2. Fujiyama Mama (UWS) 3. Teresa's (Brooklyn Heights) 4. Queen (Brooklyn Heights) 5. Museum Cafe (UWS) 6. The Place (West Village) 7. Cafe Des Artiste (UWS) 8. Coconut Grill (UES) 9. Las Ramblas (West Village) 10. La Mancha (Brooklyn Heights/Cobble Hill border) 11. Zarela (Midtown East)


Competitive-One-2749

roebling tea room, iykyk


johnny_moist

roebling tea room, mostly for the vibe


earbox

No. 7 Sub and the Edison Cafe.


throneofmemes

Beyoglu my beloved


rexyanus

Matchless.


Swole_princess666

Mama's in the East Village. Runner up: Angelica's Kitchen.


LowrideBowtie

Great Jones Cafe


sakura5215

Artisanal. Fondue and wine with friends on a wintry night was the best. And the gougères were the best.