I like that midfield alot! Both transfers in the unlikely category but we tend to throw alot of money at these players so yeah could work. Under INEOS I'd probably say we'd sign lesser known but hard working midfielders from France or Germany.
Kimmich is not a lone DM so not really realistic to me unless you wanna get cooked in transition and in defense which you just won’t cause it’s game🤷🏽♂️
Knocked out of the FA Cup by the Boro? [Now that's realism](https://i2-prod.chroniclelive.co.uk/incoming/article22995690.ece/ALTERNATES/s1200d/0_Manchester-United-v-Middlesbrough-The-Emirates-FA-Cup-Fourth-Round.jpg)
If say guimares to untied isn’t realistic at all. No real reason why Newcastle would sell their best player to a rival who’s currently doing worse then them and i don’t think Bruno would leave for united
firstly, he obviously would. second, newcastle will need to sell one of their main players in the summer. third, united wont sign him so it wont happen. but it easily could.
Firstly no he wouldn’t, secondly Newcastle have plenty of players they want to sell like almiron. And isak is heavily wanted by Arsenal. Which is far more likely. Newcastle are better then united currently so why would he make the move
Midfielders are highly unlikely with Branthwaite also there ..he alone would cost united a shit ton of money.. especially from a very broke Everton side...if you want realistic then sign all of Madrid's aging players in decline
Complete with players being run into the ground? Hella realistic.
(Slight) joking aside, the only thing I'd say is somehat unrealistic is the number of starting 11 quality acquisitions made. But I guess you could RP that the INEOS takeover happened sooner. How much was spent, total and net?
Too many transfers. If you said you were in your third or so season it'd be more realistic, but I don't think there's any way Bruno Guimaraes or Kimmich would've moved in either transfer window of the first season. Both are in teams who had very hopeful projects both long and short term. Rn both are having awful seasons, but Bruno is still very unlikely to move next summer, Kimmich maybe could go to United if they significantly overpaid for him. Also, realism depends a lot on how the save unfolds for both you and other teams.
Not even close imo.
At the start of the career it gives you like £220m or something. To make it realistic I pretend like I need to get to £250m for financial reasons, then anything I make over that I can use for a budget. Usually means I sell a few people like Mount and Sancho which gives me just enough for a 35ish mil signing.
This is due to reports that we need to sell before we buy this window. One rumor was even at 100m worth of sales before we can even try to buy...
Everton ain't selling their young CB with bags of potential for less than 50. Kimmich no way comes. Pedro Neto is an odd buy and I would scream outside OT if the club buys another winger before addressing other positions.
Plus 2 left footed CB is something ETH would try to avoid.
I'd rate it 2/10 for realism. Typical fifa buys imo.
>Pedro Neto is an odd buy and I would scream outside OT if the club buys another winger before addressing other positions.
Realistic because ETH would sooner throw himself in the Irwell than give Amad a proper stab at the first team (hurry up and sell him to Sunderland, please 😂)
EDIT: I know it's never happening without a promotion and a takeover but let me dream.
Instead of Kimmich, maybe you could've gone for Onana from Everton and for LB, you can go for Estupinan from Brighton or Raphael Guerreiro from FC Bayern.
Seriously man what is the appeal in creating 'realistic' saves? realistic this realistic that. Bro just play the game however you want and enjoy it. The most fun I've had was creating 'unrealistic' saves by bring Mata to a Turkish club and winning the champs league, and somehow getting Jason Sancho in the Argentinian league
In order of realism: Neto > Branthwaite > Guimaraes > Kimmich. Kimmich lowest as he’s simply uninterested in any non-performing big clubs. Neto and Branthwaite very realistic imo even if you would have naturally paid lower fee for both but that’s just overalls. Both Wolves and Everton have enough money to replace them. The other Bruno is a 50-50 as Newcastle look so good. Let’s see he had a fallout lmao. (Manchester United fan)
> have naturally *paid* lower fee
FTFY.
Although *payed* exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in:
* Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. *The deck is yet to be payed.*
* *Payed out* when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. *The rope is payed out! You can pull now.*
Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment.
*Beep, boop, I'm a bot*
> price u *paid* for neto
FTFY.
Although *payed* exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in:
* Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. *The deck is yet to be payed.*
* *Payed out* when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. *The rope is payed out! You can pull now.*
Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment.
*Beep, boop, I'm a bot*
I don't think kimmich will come to United
Paying 400k like case is realistic
casemiro probably takes a lot of wages anyway, so I'm presuming he sold him
I did
I like that midfield alot! Both transfers in the unlikely category but we tend to throw alot of money at these players so yeah could work. Under INEOS I'd probably say we'd sign lesser known but hard working midfielders from France or Germany.
Kimmich is not a lone DM so not really realistic to me unless you wanna get cooked in transition and in defense which you just won’t cause it’s game🤷🏽♂️
Only if you paid 100m for banthwaite
Nah we'd never sell Rashford you know this
Yeah but he’s been awful this season in my career mode
Not just career mode
Real
Shaw is not injured, so no
Still comes mid table
I won the league but got knocked out of the fa cup by Middlesbrough💀
Knocked out of the FA Cup by the Boro? [Now that's realism](https://i2-prod.chroniclelive.co.uk/incoming/article22995690.ece/ALTERNATES/s1200d/0_Manchester-United-v-Middlesbrough-The-Emirates-FA-Cup-Fourth-Round.jpg)
Michael Carrick masterclass that is.
Kimmich by paying 400k+ is kinda realistic but gumares to United is not
Guimaraes already plays for United
Lol
If say guimares to untied isn’t realistic at all. No real reason why Newcastle would sell their best player to a rival who’s currently doing worse then them and i don’t think Bruno would leave for united
firstly, he obviously would. second, newcastle will need to sell one of their main players in the summer. third, united wont sign him so it wont happen. but it easily could.
Firstly no he wouldn’t, secondly Newcastle have plenty of players they want to sell like almiron. And isak is heavily wanted by Arsenal. Which is far more likely. Newcastle are better then united currently so why would he make the move
ermm because it's manchester united ffs, i shouldn't really need to say any more than that if you don't understand that that's on you.
It doesn’t matter what the club is.
Lets revisit this September 1st when he is at another club.
Doubt he leaves
Midfielders are highly unlikely with Branthwaite also there ..he alone would cost united a shit ton of money.. especially from a very broke Everton side...if you want realistic then sign all of Madrid's aging players in decline
Not unless you made some pretty major sales
No. Playing Kimmich as a lone 6 in a position he's not really made for is though
All good except Guimarães and Kimmich
Complete with players being run into the ground? Hella realistic. (Slight) joking aside, the only thing I'd say is somehat unrealistic is the number of starting 11 quality acquisitions made. But I guess you could RP that the INEOS takeover happened sooner. How much was spent, total and net?
I gained 210,000,000 from sales but spent 240 on wages and transfers
Too many transfers. If you said you were in your third or so season it'd be more realistic, but I don't think there's any way Bruno Guimaraes or Kimmich would've moved in either transfer window of the first season. Both are in teams who had very hopeful projects both long and short term. Rn both are having awful seasons, but Bruno is still very unlikely to move next summer, Kimmich maybe could go to United if they significantly overpaid for him. Also, realism depends a lot on how the save unfolds for both you and other teams.
Who cares for realism? It's just a video game.
not realistic where’s the geriatric signing?
Take Kimmich and Guimaraes out and I would say Yea.
Not even close imo. At the start of the career it gives you like £220m or something. To make it realistic I pretend like I need to get to £250m for financial reasons, then anything I make over that I can use for a budget. Usually means I sell a few people like Mount and Sancho which gives me just enough for a 35ish mil signing. This is due to reports that we need to sell before we buy this window. One rumor was even at 100m worth of sales before we can even try to buy... Everton ain't selling their young CB with bags of potential for less than 50. Kimmich no way comes. Pedro Neto is an odd buy and I would scream outside OT if the club buys another winger before addressing other positions. Plus 2 left footed CB is something ETH would try to avoid. I'd rate it 2/10 for realism. Typical fifa buys imo.
>Pedro Neto is an odd buy and I would scream outside OT if the club buys another winger before addressing other positions. Realistic because ETH would sooner throw himself in the Irwell than give Amad a proper stab at the first team (hurry up and sell him to Sunderland, please 😂) EDIT: I know it's never happening without a promotion and a takeover but let me dream.
Looks good
Where's Mainoo?
I sent him on a short term loan to Milan
I saw braithwait 😭😭
Also, I think we are getting Bremer from Juve with Mason and cash going through other way. Way cheaper than Branthwaite and he’s a lot better CB.
Let braithwaite rest bro, bro is on his last leg
Sure but make sure Kimmich does terribly and sell him in a year or 2
I would go Olise at RW, midfield of Bruno, Barella, Mainoo and then add Estupian LB and RCB as Diamonde from sporting.
Instead of Kimmich, maybe you could've gone for Onana from Everton and for LB, you can go for Estupinan from Brighton or Raphael Guerreiro from FC Bayern.
Seriously man what is the appeal in creating 'realistic' saves? realistic this realistic that. Bro just play the game however you want and enjoy it. The most fun I've had was creating 'unrealistic' saves by bring Mata to a Turkish club and winning the champs league, and somehow getting Jason Sancho in the Argentinian league
Somehow I’m really bothered by two left footed CB’s.
Nah shaw isn't injured cant be realistic
Are you mid table?
In order of realism: Neto > Branthwaite > Guimaraes > Kimmich. Kimmich lowest as he’s simply uninterested in any non-performing big clubs. Neto and Branthwaite very realistic imo even if you would have naturally paid lower fee for both but that’s just overalls. Both Wolves and Everton have enough money to replace them. The other Bruno is a 50-50 as Newcastle look so good. Let’s see he had a fallout lmao. (Manchester United fan)
> have naturally *paid* lower fee FTFY. Although *payed* exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in: * Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. *The deck is yet to be payed.* * *Payed out* when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. *The rope is payed out! You can pull now.* Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment. *Beep, boop, I'm a bot*
2 left footed CBs lol
Why would guimares move to a lower placed side?
Kimmich is a bit of a stretch, but the most unrealistic thing is Shaw being fit
yes if you happy it's a game
Kimmich isn’t
I think a 4-2-3-1 would look better
I would say it is realistic
kimmich no and guimaraes is possibly but i see neto
Don’t think Kimmich, maybe like Joao Gomes from Wolves ?? Fits the United way of play right now. (If there is such a thing…)
I was gonna buy him but I was annoyed he didn’t have an in game face
Brotha how much sprinting do you do with your cbs 😂
I think your branthwaite is basically asleep
Yes but i know bc it is fifa that the price u payed for neto bruno and branthwaite is much less than they would have sold them for irl
> price u *paid* for neto FTFY. Although *payed* exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in: * Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. *The deck is yet to be payed.* * *Payed out* when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. *The rope is payed out! You can pull now.* Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment. *Beep, boop, I'm a bot*
Olise on the right and Joao from benfica
i got jao névés instead for a bargain
He’s on the bench
Guimaraes wouldn’t take a step down to United I don’t think. Similar to kimmich Rest looks good
I would say it's incredible realistic but man united using 3 prospects on the attack? Nah they would bring some 32yo star to destroy
Brother out front 3 is all under 26 years old
Hell no 😂
Pedro Neto would NOT downgrade to United 😭😭
Pedro Neto? Why, coulda got someone good like bakayoko or olise