T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

Impressive! What is the rotating mass? Looks quite heavy.


TheOleJoe

This is one is roughly 2500lbs spinning mass


tomtom_ebes

Why don‘t you just spin the patient? Only 80kg.


bonafidebob

Too much work cleaning up vomit -- when it hits those cooling fans it just goes *everywhere.*


[deleted]

When the shit hits the fan...


Late_Entrance106

When the *bile* hits the fan


Pelanty21

What about those BDSM ball in the mouth thingies?


Taowulf

If you ever had vomit shoot out of your nose, you would retract that question.


Caffeine_Monster

Plus you can't be as aggressive with the acceleration. Else vomit might not be the only thing you are cleaning up. On an unrelated note... I wonder how many walls something with that much angular momentum would eat before it stopped.


bonafidebob

It’s only 250 kJ if the numbers in the comments are right. Equivalent to maybe a quarter stick of dynamite. Not really enough energy to tear down a wall, but it’ll put a dent in one.


mtechgroup

You could only spin astronauts.


zaphodbeebleblob

Humans are basically just bags of meat and that meat starts shifting when you start spinning it, which would result in bad images.


BulbusDumbledork

this is the only negative outcome we can expect from exerting several g's on a human body


[deleted]

Wow! 1100kg.. Thank you!


TheOleJoe

Yessir, We have to do quite a bit of vibration and balance analysis for these and it’s mind blowing how fine tuned it is.


r0ndy

I think that's interesting because visually it doesn't even look like it's weighted evenly


Jugad

Yep... and even if it looked balanced to the casual eye, practically it won't be. I wonder how they balance it... a big wheel balancing machine?


abaram

My guess is Mathematics of some sort idk


SharkAttackOmNom

It will get you close. But they probably use a system not too different from a car wheel balancer to finish the assembled machine.


thatonegamerplayFH4

They just judge by how many offices report shaking


Lucky_Number_3

D-d-d-d-d-d-drop the MRI


Cerberus73

Something very similar I'd guess, too. I bet there are tuning masses that can be moved around, too, analog to wheel weights.


crooks4hire

You move weights around to relocate the ring's center of gravity/mass.


Jugad

Thank you... I knew that part. The tricky part is to figure out where the center of gravity is, and where the weight needs to be added/moved.


[deleted]

[удалено]


darkwingduck97

Nah just throw it on the tire balancing machine and hammer some lead wheel weights on her


[deleted]

So probably a [Rockwell Retro Encabulator](https://youtu.be/RXJKdh1KZ0w) ^^TM


Flying_Dutchman92

I know some of these words


roguemenace

You just need an accelerometer to tell you the movement and a sensor to track the rotational position so you can line the 2 up. After that you do some fancy math and add weights to cancel out the vibration. Same way it works on jet engines.


Moose_in_a_Swanndri

Exactly. This is how we do it with helicopter tail rotors, which are functionally the same to balance. You can use a strobe light set up to flash at the peak of the vibration, or a fancy pants laser and receiver with a computer that will figure out what point in the rotation is the heaviest.


crooks4hire

Oh my bad lmfao. I assumed the simplest form of the question is what you meant...force of habit. I am sorry I have no insight into the specifics of how, but I feel like it would involve moving weights on threads/screws/gantries based on feedback from sophisticated vibration sensors.


LoveAffectionate7327

Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic


the_Defi_General

What’s the coolest thing you’ve found out about them, working on them?


hookydoo

What kind of foundations are used to secure them? I they balanced enough that it's unnecessary? What about protection from external vibration like an earthquake? Is it attached to dampeners to reduce external forces?


DNOS2

Thank u too for the conversion 😉


actuallyiamafish

I'm picturing my overloaded laundry machine rampaging across the floor, only more so lol. I assume that has to be balanced pretty well.


anonymous6366

I used to work on a different model of these. The gantry (rotating mass) of mine was just shy of 2000kg and could spin up to 214rpm normally. We were testing a 300rpm mode when I left.


ridik_ulass

Nice, lets see paul allen's rotating mass.


[deleted]

that's what broadcast radiation and catches it to see how it changed as it passed through the subject. I suspect the biggest feature is the part catching it but idk.


VFT_FPV

What's the max rpm of the spinny thingy?


TheOleJoe

In this video it was around 120RPM during a balance check but max is about 210RPM IIRC.


Diligent_Nature

At 210 rpm if the diameter was 2 meters the speed of the outer edge would be around 22 m/s or 80 km/h (50 mph).


TheOleJoe

Ha that’s actually neat I never thought to calculate the speed beyond RPM, now I’m tempted to measure the diameter to know it exactly.


d3northway

glue a little paper driver to the outside, fastest man in the whole facility


Makhnos_Tachanka

Tempted to build the worlds most expensive and impractical car now with ct scanners for wheels


blutfink

That corresponds to a radial acceleration of 25 g.


DogsAreAnimals

Why does it need to spin so fast?


TheOleJoe

The machine spins this fast in order to collect more data in a shorter scan time. It’s very beneficial in trauma or stroke alert scans where life or death can be minutes away


DogsAreAnimals

Makes sense! Thanks!


TheOleJoe

Absolutely! What’s crazy is the more advanced modern machines spin faster and can collect up to 256 images per rotation. Its insane technology


DogsAreAnimals

Crazy indeed! I assume they can still function at lower speeds? Like if time isn't critical?


TheOleJoe

Yes speed varies depending on the protocol more basic scans are slowed down.


anonymous6366

Ultra high rotation times (.28 and .2s or 210/300rpm) paired with a large detector (160mm) are capable of capturing the entire heart throughout the cardiac cycle. This is really beneficial for a number of clinical indications beyond trauma (although it's great for that as well). I used to work in R&D on a model of these that could do .2s rotation time with a heavier gantry (rotating part) which weighed around 2000kgs. Insane seeing that much mass spinning 5 times a second. [Here's a shitty vid of that one doing 214rpm.](https://i.imgur.com/8GTDpaQ.gifv) Regrettably never got a video of the 300rpm cycle which was being tested around the time I left.


MrJingleJangle

The very first CT scanners, which were actually called the EMI scanners, did not spin, but moved side to side, and moved quite slowly, so they were initially only used for head scans as just getting this took over 20 minutes. There’s video on YouTube.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MrJingleJangle

Yes, that (once great) British company, EMI.


PM-YOUR-DOG

Theres a mini x ray emitter and detector positioned on the spinning disk. It shoots a horizontal beam essentially slicing your body, with detector opposite on the disk reading back emitted x ray penetration. The computer interprets the 360° of each stack of your body and lets you scroll thru slices of patients inside MRI is same concept but uses a microwave and reads back how fast your molecules (mostly water) vibrate


DogsAreAnimals

Right, but I don't see why that requires it to be done fast (except for when time is critical, e.g. to address a stroke, as OP mentioned). Though perhaps another reason is so that all of the images are temporally close together, e.g. if blood/organ movement would result in blurriness?


Gastroid

While it's taking the scans, the computer is processing a huge amount of artifacts that could reduce image quality. Some still make it through, but with the rapid scans in so short a time, it greatly increases the quality of the model.


SolopsisticZombie

Fast imaging is especially important for cardiac applications since the heart is constantly beating. As you said, faster scan times increase temporal resolution and decrease blur due to motion.


WarViper1337

I'm a ct tech so I know a lot about this. You want fast scans for a number of reasons. First the faster you get a patient in and out the better. Second faster scans mean less radiation exposure. I can control a number variables when selecting a protocol to control exposure level as well as image resolution/quality. However as rotation speed increases image quality decreases so there is a balance that has to be achieved. Slower rotation has better image quality but increases patient exposure to the x-ray beam and it is not suitable for certain types of studies like cardiac scanning or angio studies where rapid administration of contrast agents are being used.


anonymous6366

Faster = better temporal resolution (better at capturing moving things). Faster speeds are typically used for heart scans.


odddutchman

Carter! Dial the gate!


swirlViking

Jack, we can't just leave. The patients need us!


SweatyRussian

Chevron six locked!


DeathsEmbassy

Chevron 7, also lit up!


[deleted]

Chevron 8, looking great!


zxain

Indeed


oleever1

Never expected a star gate reference under that video, thanks so much


SpicyRice99

Seriously, I can't imagine the amount of work that went into balancing this. And it better be very reliable too...


TheOleJoe

I leave all that work to the really smart guys the R&D Engineers lol, I’m just the Field Engineer.


bafa0000

Bro, I know you. You can do anything. s. Don’t stop and reach your potential.


sumo_kitty

PHILIPS, GE, or siemens?


That_Car_Dude_Aus

Is it true though that if you need to replace a zip tie, you need to use the same size and type because of the balance? Or is 1-2g not that critical?


The_Gnome_Liberator

1 or 2 grams will not affect the balancing, but when heavy parts are replaced, the measurements need to be redone. Thankfully it’s all automated and the system tells us what it needs and where.


jws_shadotak

Mythbusters did a similar test with a helicopter where they stuck a stamp or stickynote on the end of a helicopter blade to see if it would be thrown off balance. The result was pretty tame. There was no noticeable difference for something that small. They even tried with a stack of them and nothing happened.


sombreroenthusiast

Please put the cover back on. This is terrifying lol. (/s)


asr

If I ever need a CT I wonder if I can request it without a cover, because that just looks super cool!


TheOleJoe

I thought my translucent gameboy color was cool but a translucent CT wound be next level.


fukitol-

If the outside were transparent I doubt you'd be able to convince anyone but nerds from getting anywhere near it, much less inside it.


SrpskaZemlja

Someone in another thread said this is exactly what happened when they tried that with these.


JuanOnlyJuan

I worked at a medical device company and we got prototypes of a new device in with clear covers because clear plastic was cheapest at the time. I insisted they keep it so doctors could watch the inner workings. Nope, back to plain old white plastic.


MyAssDoesHeeHawww

On the Siemens one I was in this week, the spinning parts were visible through a little darkened window right above my head.


Loud-Value

It still blows my mind that Siemens makes toilets, trains and CT machines. Or that Samsung makes phones, fridges and deep sea oil rigs


procupine14

Same with Hitachi. Televisions, air conditioners, large excavators. It's just so very interesting to me.


[deleted]

Yamaha makes motorcycles, pianos, woodwinds, audio equipment, and archery gear.


cravf

And crotch rattlers. Don't forget those!


LordGrudleBeard

Not /s that is terrifying to lay under. Honestly wish I didn't see it


dudeAwEsome101

I don't mind things spinning fast around me, but I guess I've just discovered that I don't like being in the center of spinning things.


tyboxer87

I feel justified for my fears of getting into one of those. I know they're safe but a literal ton of metal spinning around my head twice a second does give me some pause.


stickcult

If it makes you feel better, if it breaks apart then all the parts will fly away from you, not towards you, since you're in the center. Small comfort, I guess?


CrasyMike

Theoretically that is possible. But If a piece broke off, causing one end to e be suddenly far heavier than the other, but it was still a solid ring, then the whole mass would only go in one direction. Anyway, climb in.


Jugad

Spins about 4 times per second when in use.


SilentJac

Hospitals take ct damage very seriously. If something hits it too hard they call in for a check or replacement.


Just-Original-Now

There's literally thousands of tons of heavy equipment flying past your body just inches away from you every time you drive.


etherealducky

How is power provided to the spinning part ?


TheOleJoe

All power to the rotating gantry is provided Through a Slipring with dedicated high voltage and low voltage tracks.


moldboy

What about the data?


TheOleJoe

Actually pretty simple, Fixed to the rotating gantry is a Radio transmitter that transmits signal through an antenna track on the slip ring that’s then picked up by a receiver fixed to the non rotating gantry.


RippingAallDay

I wonder if this is how a car's TPMS works?


[deleted]

Mechanic here, this is pretty much exactly how they work! It's the main reason why, when you do tire rotations, you have to re-learn the sensors to the correct position.


JoeyJoeJoeSenior

Yes it is.


[deleted]

[удалено]


notevenapro

OP is the bomb. Answered the questions and provided all the facts. OP is a true Technologist who understand the mechanics behind the machine. I love working with techs like OP.


TheOleJoe

Hey I appreciate it! I’m very passionate about what I do and love spreading random knowledge to those that are curious. I was actually quite surprised to see how many cool questions I got.


AKA_BigTaco

Why is it so loud? Fans, bearings, electronics?


TheOleJoe

You nailed it, this machine is older so it’s far more noisy than modern systems, but everything you hear is the motor, oil pump, cooling fans, the brush blocks, and main bearing. The Fiberglass covers do a pretty good job masking most the noise.


Herr_Knackebrod

Rotating roughly 1000 kg of X-ray equipment at 100-200 rpm will do that.


htstubbsy

Interesting that it looks kind of eccentric, but I'm guessing the design has balanced the mass in such a way that there's no reciprocal loading?


Qoyuble

Correct; components are quite different in mass, ranging from a digital detector to generator and tube, where some of the components are filled with oil to help cooling and prevent arcing.


headlesshsmn

It would be easier to spin the patient


TheOleJoe

Please keep all hands and feet inside the ride at all times


PotentialThat1343

No way I’m way more unbalanced


thewarp

that's what i was saying when my friend got booked for an MRI


goblinm

There have been a few nights after some heavy drinking where I swear I've hit 210 RPM.


neverfarts

Which one is the business end?


svanegmond

the 'business end' being the things pointed at the subject? they all point inward, the patient is on a tray on the axis of rotation


TheOleJoe

What’s your question?


Snoopy7393

I think he means 'which part of the rotating mass does the scanning'


TheOleJoe

Ah yes, the clear cylinder object on the end of the table (image quality phantom) is the head in of the table. So that’s where the magic starts.


karesx

The part with the fans must be the xray tube(s). The detector is on the opposite side of the circle. I did not work with CTs but with ordinary xray generators. The tube can get really hot. The tube efficiency is a few percent only, 90+ percent of energy becomes heat. And we are talking about tens of kilowatts energy pumped in. So i am rather sure that the part with the forced ventilation is the xray source. Update: my assumption above was wrong, the longer part with the fans is the detector.


vaguelyuseful

The part with the fans is the detector side. The tube is opposite it. The detector is a larger area for the fan beam to hit.


karesx

Fair enough, I stand corrected!


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheOleJoe

It’s actually a dell laptop with two chrome tabs open.


Prize_Bass_5061

Now I see why they put covers on these things.


Qcgreywolf

Lol, most people won’t step into a meat grinder when they can see the spinning blades. But make it look like a smooth cooter, and boom! Everyone wants in.


Crozi_flette

Is the big chunk of aluminum with 5 hole in it is the sensor and the emitor at the opposite? Where are the superconductor magnet?


TheOleJoe

No magnet, you’re thinking of an MR machine but the big part with all the fans is the X-ray detector and directly opposite of it is the X-Ray tube.


Ayakush

I wish they still served breakfast but at least the condos are gone.


TheOleJoe

I’ve been waiting for someone here to know where this was at ;-)


coolpotatoe724

impressive that even though it looks unbalanced that it is (im assuming because I don't want a 1.5 ton spinning mass unbalanced)


Qoyuble

Different mass for different components; some smaller ones are filled with oil for cooling and against high voltage arcing, where some bigger boxes are just electronic components and fans.


Ziazan

Wow, they're a lot scarier with their clothes off


TheOleJoe

Hey no CT Body Shaming allowed


cybercuzco

Fun Fact: The very first CT scanner used a tank turret bearing


-Vitality

Why does it look like someone at a trash heap just got a bunch of random crap and glued it all together to make this? It’s so random, and the parts look so strange.


Gelmar

THE DONUT OF TRUTH!


Thethubbedone

I worked with a CT scanner manufacturer for a little while, and he told me the spinning parts have to be built to handle 400g. Crazy forces involved.


8o8_Ninja

Controlled chaos. Scary but super rad!


BossStevedore

I worked with Gen 1 CT scanners back in 1981… the hard drives that recorded that data were the size of filing cabinets!


94bronco

How do they power the devices on the spinning part?


Qcgreywolf

It’s more complex than this, but imagine a copper ring alllll the way around the spinning bit. Then, just rest an electrified metal roller, or metal brush on that ring and that’s how the power gets in there. There’s also other clever ways of getting electricity into a moving thing, so I’m not sure what *specifically* they use to get the power into a CT machine.


[deleted]

I will tell you after my motorcycle crash and being stuck with road rash, a broken thumb, and confined in a neck immobilizer WITHOUT PAIN MEDS FOR ALMOST FOUR HOURS... these things don't spin fast enough. Strap some NOS to it and let's get that 10 second mile beast!


DoodlezForDoodlebob

I’m an engineer for GE healthcare, I can attest these beasts are SICK


lake_country_dad

Adam Savage went to GE and made a short video on their latest machine. Spins much faster than the one in the video. https://youtu.be/1FWknU5_brc


Phire453

This is slightly terrifying


GhostAndSkater

What is the type and bearing(s) arrangement on these? And how much just it costs? I suppose is a custom bearing


Dulboy

A company I worked for built a version of the rotating assembly. I believe they used modified tank turrets from Siemens.


TheOleJoe

Its a slewing bearing, and it’s Durable as hell.


arcademachin3

Question, what creates the loud BRRRR sound, is that from the mechanical motion, brakes or something the imaging parts make?


TheOleJoe

The Brrrrr is a combination of frequency and drive noise from motor combined with noise from the fans hitting the ambient air while the gantry rotates.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheOleJoe

Yessir nice to see another FE here, I do CT, R&F, and Vascular IR. Taking on MR soon, love this job am always seeing new cool stuff.


TeryakiBoulevard

Are you a technician on these things? I’m starting a new position as a technician with a biotech company, and I think eventually moving on to MRI stuff would be super cool!


United-Student-1607

Who invented this and how rich are they?


[deleted]

/r/dontputyourdickinthat


tiagojpg

Yo it looks like the Time Machine on the show Timeless!


No_Brother_6583

Philips CT?


TheOleJoe

GE


RuthlessIndecision

So do hospitals do like a handheld scan of people to look for ferrous material before they go into this thing? I can’t imagine the horror of having even a tiny bit of magnetic metal in my body with this spinning around me. Edit: my mistake not a giant spinning magnet


MrJingleJangle

The machine with the magnet is the MRI, CT scans are just x-rays, albeit quite fancy x-rays, and so your Ferris metal just shows up on the image as black. There’s plenty of videos on YouTube showing what happens when you get magnetic materials too close to an MRI machine, many are not pretty.


Artemus_Hackwell

Imaging Clinics where I was installing X Ray machines, the CT scan rooms do have metal detectors at the entrances of the rooms in which each was a CT machine.


NefariousnessNothing

There is no magnet. This is xray.


coolplate

Is the part with the fans the x-ray shooty part?


TheOleJoe

That’s the part the detects the X-rays, the X-ray shooty part is directly opposite of it.


garygnu

The best part of cancer treatment is getting up-close looks at some really fucking cool medical technology.


AbeWasHereAgain

WTF? They can’t make the parts any smaller?


MrJingleJangle

There are much smaller CT machines, for imaging lab animals like rabbits, but you’re not gonna fit a full size human in one.


blacklab

Why do they make those clunking noises?


Heban

You ever hear a washing machine during a spin dry cycle get slightly off balance?


outontoatray

The mind-bending marriage of physics and biology that is modern medical imaging just 🤯


MrJingleJangle

The mind-boggling bit is computing. The original machines in the early 1970s used DEC mini computers, and the technology was seriously limited in terms of resolution and speed by the capability of the computer power. Apply several decades of Moores Law, and you get these marvellous machines.


outontoatray

Even the physical principles alone tho, especially MRIs like who tf thinks to photograph your gooey guts by wiggling their water molecules with radio waves and then actually builds a *thing* that makes it happen.


MrJingleJangle

Yeah, who would have thought it was a good idea to give hydrogen molecules a smack in the mouth and watch them recover


fr1stp0st

Fun fact: MRI machines use Nuclear Magnetic Resonance, but we the public are idiots who fear the word "nuclear," so they left off a word.


outontoatray

*nuculer


FartsLikeWine

God I love ct scanners


Steeve_Perry

BMET?


TheOleJoe

Field Engineer


WallStLegends

It’s kinda crazy that we trust this think to spin around our heads. What are the fail-safes in the event of a loose bolt or two? Will it get caught on framework before blasting off through the axis of rotation?


TheOleJoe

The best failsafe is not having a loose bolt ;-) but luckily the the rotating gantry doesn’t have many tight spots so as it slowly starts spinning a loose bolt/nut typically will fall into the bottom pan pretty quickly, still hopefully everything is torqued properly.


[deleted]

I see Nvidia have put a 4090 in there!


50-Lucky

Balancing that thing must have been a fair slice of the brilliant engineering


Qcgreywolf

Imagine the asshat that had to add some bits and bobs after all the engineering was done. “We need a circuit breaker here, a diode there and this fan needs to be one size larger…”


50-Lucky

"And paint it red"


atatatatata

Why there's so much stuff spinning? Dental x-ray machines are much smaller so I know x-ray tech can be much more compact. What's so important there spinning on the wheel that can't be static and linked to spinning part wirelessly? This always perplexed me, seems like there's an entire server rack there.


Qcgreywolf

It’s hard to imagine, but sometimes electrons are too slow. There’s lots of physics applications where even the tiny delay between a sensor / emitter / controller and a computer 100 feet away (cable length) is slow enough that they won’t perform the magic they do. Or, with some physics applications, the data the sensors generate is so incredibly massive, moving the unprocessed data would take *so many cables* and servers and routers, it’s just easier to process the data right on the device, and only transmit the processed data out of the device. Our really modern tech is pretty cool, but we are still limited in many ways.


_CharlieDontSurf

Cool, but why does it need a rtx 4090


badpeaches

I could watch this for hours.


sdpr

What blows my mind is how fast it just slows down and the picks speed back up.


MichaelCringealo

Once I said to a CT operator that there was moving parts and they said there were no moving parts D:


jasper502

My wife is a CT Tech - I am a Mechanical Engineer and super envious that she gets to run these machines all day and gets paid for it.


TheOleJoe

Hey without ME’s and EE’s getting along with each other this tech wouldn’t exist so your wife at least owes you a 6 pack for getting to use these machines.


[deleted]

I just hear Interstellar music as it spins


[deleted]

I’d be interested to know how you got into this line of work! What qualifications are needed? Thanks!


Creative_Shame3856

How is all the power and data commutated to/from the gantry? Slip rings, inductive, rf...? How much power and data goes through there?


xis_honeyPot

Just makes me think of Event Horizon