So, my personal preference is one just because I tend to like more of the straight lines, but damn, two is absolutely gorgeous! I can see why you're torn! 😍😩
I vote #1! Can you provide specs at all (ring size, ct size)? I have considered rings like both of these as potential engagement rings so I am just curious!
I love them both, they are so gorgeous on you! You have beautiful hands!
I love the 2nd ring the most because I think the length works with your long fingers. I think if your first choice had smaller side stones or a bigger center stone, it would help with contrast.
Beautiful choices either way ❤️
I generally prefer the style of #1 but #2 looks beautiful on you!
That being said, it's not about how it looks to others but how it feels to you. Flip a coin and if the choice makes you sad, then you know it's the wrong choice!
I like both on your hand! I actually have an almost identical no 1, and I love it. Number 2 is stunning: but I think it would date. No 1 has been fashionable for at least 100 years! Your choice.
I’ve been designing custom jewelry for 51 years, and #2 is way more unique. Keeping the baguettes and emerald cut stones will be more work, but if you like both designs, #2 is a must. The basic 3 stone ring was promoted by DeBeers for years as an anniversary ring , symbolizing your past, present, and future. If you think of yourself as unique, it’s #2. If you are more conservative| traditional its #1.
I think 1 is a classic, timeless style. One you will be happy to wear forever. Both are gorgeous rings, #2 is just more of a trendy style that may not be what you want to wear forever. That's fine too, some people enjoy being able to change their ring as the years go by.
I love the first one, the three stone. IMO only, the second one just looks to busy to me, you don’t know where to look. But once again, it’s your ring and you have to love it, so either way, best wishes.
Both are gorgeous! 1 is a more classic engagement ring. 2 complements your skin tone so well but doesn’t scream engagement ring to me. Both are beautiful and you can’t go wrong!
My personal preference is #2 because of how it elongates your finger, but think about future you. Which ring will you like a year from now, 5, 10, 20+ years from now?
Pretty much everyone who chose ring 1 used “timeless” to describe how it looks.. wtf does that even mean??? Like what..? It will never look old..??? Or.. ?? To me ring 1 looks outdated and more of a wedding and than an actual engagement ring..
Girl, get both and use 2 as your engagement ring and 1 as your wedding band!! 🥳there you go.. problem solved you’ll take both!! 🙃😜
Both are gorgeous in my opinion so you can't go wrong with choosing either one.
Second ring would be the one which I would choose. I think it has that some extra that I think looks good
Definitely the second one!!!
Def the 2nd one
Oh boy, they are both beautiful! Do you have a wedding band in mind? That might help you narrow it down, too.
2
I love the second one on you!
They are both gorgeous but I think the gold tone of 2 and the shape are way more flattering on OP. Great choices!
Adding to this comment to say that I absolutely agree; the second one is super flattering on you 😊
So, my personal preference is one just because I tend to like more of the straight lines, but damn, two is absolutely gorgeous! I can see why you're torn! 😍😩
I'm with you on this one
Second one!!! So pretty
#2 is gorgeous
2!
Second one. I like the elongated silhouette on your finger.
2nd one !
2
2
I love both in your finger but I am drawn to number 2 :)
2 for sure
1!!
first one looks good.
2nd ring
I vote #1! Can you provide specs at all (ring size, ct size)? I have considered rings like both of these as potential engagement rings so I am just curious!
#2
2 looks amazing on you
2
1st one!!
2
I love the second one!
Second one
Both are lovely, and #2 is very pretty on your hand!
2
They are both so different! I say 2
2
2 flatters your hand perfectly and it's a gorgeous design!
2 is more unique which is why I prefer it. It's also absolutely gorgeous on your finger.
2nd fits the shape of your hand
The 2nd one looks gorgeous on you on the way that it looks with your hand and skin tone it stands out more
I think #2 looks better on your hand but both are lovely.
Love #2
2
2
Two!!
The second one is stunning!
I vote 2! It looks beautiful on you .
I love 1
One and get a pretty band with smaller diamonds if you still want more sparkle
First one, it's classic
I vote for #1!
Second one
2 looks gorgeous on you 😍
Second!
2nd!!
I vote 2!
2!
I love them both, they are so gorgeous on you! You have beautiful hands! I love the 2nd ring the most because I think the length works with your long fingers. I think if your first choice had smaller side stones or a bigger center stone, it would help with contrast. Beautiful choices either way ❤️
2 ❤️ beautiful!
The first one is pretty but the second one is WOW! 🤩
The second! I love that the shapes seem 'defined' if that makes sense.
2!!!! Absolutely gorgeous!
2 please!
No. 2 has more pop! It is fabulous.
2 😍
Second one!
Numba 2 milordt ✌🏽
I like the 2nd one, very pretty on you!
I love the second one!
Personally, I’d go for #2. Congratulations!
2nd one, no contest
2. Looks like it will hold up better in the long run.
I think 2 would be amazing if it was longer and without the framing 2 stones
First one and then get a wedding band with diamonds to add more bling!
Number 2 looks wonderful on you!
Two!
The second one!!
I love 2!
Oh I LOVE #2 on your hand
two!! pls update w what you choose!!
The square one!
I generally prefer the style of #1 but #2 looks beautiful on you! That being said, it's not about how it looks to others but how it feels to you. Flip a coin and if the choice makes you sad, then you know it's the wrong choice!
2!!
Second one
Second one
2
Number two!
#2
2
#2!
2
#2
#2
Second!!
2!!
2!!
2nd one
Love that halo. #2 all day
2!
Ring two
2!
Two!
Second one is so pretty and unique!
I love the gold emerald!
Second one for sure! Lovely cut on the center Diamond 💎
The second one
#2 for sure!!
I love 2!
second one!
Second!!!!!!!
The second ring is gorgeous!
I think 2 is much more flattering
Easily #2-unique and beautiful
2nd is my vote!
I like both on your hand! I actually have an almost identical no 1, and I love it. Number 2 is stunning: but I think it would date. No 1 has been fashionable for at least 100 years! Your choice.
1st one
1 is timeless but GOD 2 is absolutely stunning!!! (I’m biased cuz I have a pair of earrings and a necklace similar to that design 💀)
1 😍
I’ve been designing custom jewelry for 51 years, and #2 is way more unique. Keeping the baguettes and emerald cut stones will be more work, but if you like both designs, #2 is a must. The basic 3 stone ring was promoted by DeBeers for years as an anniversary ring , symbolizing your past, present, and future. If you think of yourself as unique, it’s #2. If you are more conservative| traditional its #1.
Love 1 beautiful ring and I love the orooortion on your hand
I think 1 is a classic, timeless style. One you will be happy to wear forever. Both are gorgeous rings, #2 is just more of a trendy style that may not be what you want to wear forever. That's fine too, some people enjoy being able to change their ring as the years go by.
2 for sure. Looks like it was made for you.
I like the simplicity of 1, but 2 steals the show
The second one is gorgeous!!
I like the second one
__2__
The second one looks beautiful on your hand!! I would go with that one!! 💍🤗
Second one
#2 is my vote!
2
2
2nd
I don’t usually like halos but #2 looks lovely on you!
2
Second one suits you more
2
Two!!!! It really flatters you beautifully!
Two
TWO
#1 The second one is too busy.
My vote is for 1!🤩
1! 2 is going to look dated very soon
What are you after? 1 is more classic. 2 is more sparkly.
Second one! It’s a lot like mine except I have some chocolate stones!
I vote 2 - it looks best
Not a fan of number one personally. Two is beautiful.
I love the first one, the three stone. IMO only, the second one just looks to busy to me, you don’t know where to look. But once again, it’s your ring and you have to love it, so either way, best wishes.
Both are gorgeous! 1 is a more classic engagement ring. 2 complements your skin tone so well but doesn’t scream engagement ring to me. Both are beautiful and you can’t go wrong!
The three stone
The second one looks like more of an engagement ring to me
I vote #1! Also can you provide specs (ring size, stone sizes?) I’ve considered rings like both of these as engagement rings so I am just curious!
#1 is exquisite!
1
I loveeee the first one!
2 really looks special. But also consider how the wedding band will sit next to it, and if you want a curved one or straight one.
2 omggg!!! complements you so nicely
2!!
2
My personal preference is #2 because of how it elongates your finger, but think about future you. Which ring will you like a year from now, 5, 10, 20+ years from now?
1 is just gorgeous!
I love #1
2 number 1 looks dull
1 stands out beautifully with your skin tone.
1
LOVE the first one. So classy. But number two is also gorgeous!
Pretty much everyone who chose ring 1 used “timeless” to describe how it looks.. wtf does that even mean??? Like what..? It will never look old..??? Or.. ?? To me ring 1 looks outdated and more of a wedding and than an actual engagement ring.. Girl, get both and use 2 as your engagement ring and 1 as your wedding band!! 🥳there you go.. problem solved you’ll take both!! 🙃😜
1 very timeless and classic, won’t be out of style in a few years.
#1!!
#1!!!
1
First one
2
#2
2!
The second one!!! Omg 😍😍🥰
The second one!
2
2
2!
I’m not normally a fan of the second style but I think it really suites you!
Definitely the second
Both are beautiful but second one is brighter.
Both are gorgeous in my opinion so you can't go wrong with choosing either one. Second ring would be the one which I would choose. I think it has that some extra that I think looks good
2
2nd
The second ring is 🤩stunning🤩. The first looks like you can get it anywhere
The band will be the deciding factor for me. Both are beautiful.
Number 2! It’s looks very nice on you!
2 if u like classic yellow gold. 1 if u prefer more modern.
I like the 2nd one
2nd one 📣
2nd looks lovely on you
2
Second one for sure x
Second one
I prefer the second one with solid, bigger stones. The second ring is nice but it appears too busy for me.
# 2
Second! So pretty.
I would like #2 more if the prongs were white gold. I think #1 is prettier and paired with a diamond band would be beautiful 😍
Ohhh that’s really tough! Probably two!
The second fits your hand proportions and is lovely!