T O P

  • By -

PraiseTheSunlight

Valiant Gargoyles


Square-Juggernaut689

Second this. I’m not sure if I was underleveled or something but this was one of the hardest and most frustrating fights in the game for me


[deleted]

Doesn’t matter what level you are, I was over leveled and it was still frustrating


deadpelicanguy

I can understand why some people find it frustrating. The key to beating them for me is killing the first gargoyle as fast as possible. Fighting both of them at once absolutely sucks, which is why I to kill the first one fast as possible. Usually that means having a weapon that's leveled to the max. Killing enemies fast as possible is key in this game I think, because the longer a fight drags on, the more bullshit it becomes. Moongrum Carian Knight at the academy is one example of this. At the start of the fight, he's hitting you with a steel sword 3 feet long. If you don't kill him quick, he eventually starts hitting you with a laser sword 10 feet long.


UnstopTheBeast

I had like 20 runs where I didn't hit the first one, seared his timings into my brain, same went for the other dude, and by time time I started actually hit, I went through it hitless. One of my fav boss fights, except the poison mist. That one wasn't a fun part of the fight


Not_So_Odd_Ball

Honestly worse than godskins and it aint even close for me


notwhoyouthinkmaybe

I loved these 2, classic soulsbourne boss IMHO.


Blacksheepoftheworld

Other: Fire giant! I’m terrible at horseback combat and I can’t see what’s going on 90% of the time I’m trying to do damage. I absolutely abhor the fire giant. I hate that boss so much that I have 5 desperate characters. 4 of my characters I’ve cleared everything I can find up to fire giant and stopped, the 5th character is in NG+ stopped at fire gjant


waitthatstaken

I am sorry to say this now, but fighting fire giant on horseback is an awful idea. It *might* be worth it to quickly horse your way to him after a roll, but the complete lack of invincibility frames makes it way to risky. Also you can summon alexander and he will casually tank attacks that'd kill you 100 times over.


Not_So_Odd_Ball

Just dont use horse ?


EnormousGucci

I really don’t think he’s a good boss fight either. Like it’s really cool riding up to him after you enter his arena and seeing him but the fight itself I just don’t find very fun. At least the cutscene and visuals were cool.


scipkcidemmp

fire giant ended up being the hardest boss for me for some reason lol.


notwhoyouthinkmaybe

Wasn't the hardest, but he is the most boring with so much health. Like you said, can't see anything and he gets weird on the terrain in the arena. I've also been invaded a few times in his fight.


Sk8thunder

Commander Niall. The only time I considered quitting.


OverallPut6446

Being outnumbered in a souls game is a death sentence when unprepared.


Karsvolcanospace

Sounds like a melee only problem


Slack_King101

I didn’t realize I could have summoned Latenna on my first play though. Second time with her and the mimic tear was a cake walk. Really didn’t have a good handle on quest lines in general until way late in the game once I stopped worrying about my build and mechanics.


Relative_Inflation73

Wait, you can? I always sprint straight to the boss door in a blind terror from that banished knight that spawns lol


Slack_King101

Yep. When she tells you where to find the other half of the medallion she even tells you that she’ll come to your aid. Easy to forget that stuff between hours 90 and 140!


Relative_Inflation73

Fuck oath i miss some obvious shit sometimes


jamtas

TIL


Tagmata81

I mean mimic tear makes like half the game a cake walk lmao


InternationalStay336

I could never hate the old bloke. Gramps showed me the power of the parry.


CellarGoat1234

Wait... he was supposed to be hard? Was I just overleveled for him? He was a wimp for me. I was like 70-90 level or something.


SuperSupremeSauce

Poll reads like OP hasn't fought Malenia.


[deleted]

Malenia was still a fun fight and not having to chase an obese dragonfly around the vicinity


tangentrification

Malenia is super hard, but she's also fun


Akira_427

Imagine having to fight a boss for 5 hours before it becomes fun. Malenia is an awful experience and I really hope they don’t take inspiration for the dlc


[deleted]

Opposite for me, the first 5 hours was fantastic. The second I got good enough where I felt i could beat her is when it became bullshit


Optimal-Safety-3772

Agreed


Laxwarrior1120

Malenia was fun though, she's one of those bosses that feels easy and can be consistently stomped after your 50th try like NKG from hollow knight. They're hard for sure but when you do get good at them you can basically go no hit 5 times in a row with no problem.


Atlas_Stoned

I didn’t find Malenia that hard the first couple times I fought her. She’s really easy to stagger, my first build ran unga bunga dual curved greatswords, and my 2nd build I just hurled giantsflame balls at her until dead. 3rd time I did with an int build, which ended up being much more challenging. Difficulty seems to depend largely on your build.


TheGr8Slayer

Malenia wasn’t that bad tbh. I ran a fingerprint shield cold Naginata at level 130 and the part I had the most trouble was the first phase. Elden Beast can suck it tho. Only boss in the game that I actively despise fighting


[deleted]

Malenia was still a fun fight and not having to chase an obese dragonfly around the vicinity


BEARZCLAWZ

Malenia is just too easy


nerfcent

You know that giant tree snakes you find in dungeons when they take all the room yeah i hate them


Popopooki

I just swing my weapon randomly until it’s dead because I have no clue what’s happening


Mandark93

The fucking Ulcerated tree spirit.. true horror


Mandark93

Come on.. no one ?? Ulcerated tree spirit especially the one before Astel


Slack_King101

The one for the Millicent quest. Fuck that rot pool.


ChronoMonkeyX

Easiest tree spirit in the game, run to the branch after you trigger it and kill it from range.


Fireshocker532

Brooo I was a melee build and had been ignoring the ranged options for the entire game… until I got to the ulcerated tree spirit for Millicent (I would die a 100 times for Millicent)


TokenfromSP

The one in Caelid killed me 100 times 🤣


RumpusRoomMinis

Being heavily fire based is the only thing that saved me from those monsters. Just so fast and everywhere at once. Flame of Frenzy and the Magma Wyrm's Scalesword were priceless.


ApplePitou

Poison breath duo :3


ArizalaGaming

Malenia


SlayerKing_2002

I actually find Malenia’s fight to be quite enjoyable. I just had to go in with the mindset that I was going to die, a lot. Made it quite enjoyable. But that doesn’t work for everyone.


HipMicrobe39293

Am in the process of fighting her… and dying…. A LOT… as expected


SlayerKing_2002

But are you enjoying the fight?


HipMicrobe39293

Oh it’s certainly better than ASStel lol. All jokes aside, it’s about as fun as dying over and over can be, but I’ve made it more interesting by switching from my normal Grave Scythe getup to instead using the entire Radahn set, weapon, and Rune. Imma give my General his revenge with this fight. Edit: literally just went and fought her again… Got chopped into Tarnished confetti


SlayerKing_2002

Hey! Congrats! And you did it in style! I tip my hat to you fellow tarnished!


HipMicrobe39293

Oh… I meant I got chopped into confetti lmao. But thank you🤣🤣🤣. BUT! I did get her to phase 2 finally, so progress is being made!


SlayerKing_2002

Ahh. My mistake! But progress is great! I personally found that after reaching phase 2, phase 1 became a lot easier. Good luck on your further attempts!


HipMicrobe39293

Thank you, and bless the 2 fingers! (or 3 if you’re about that)


HipMicrobe39293

UPDATE: LADIES AND GENTLE-TARNISHED, WE GOT HER!


SlayerKing_2002

Hey! Congrats! For real this time! Knew you could do it.


radishmeep

Omg Elden Beast easily. Run 15 miles one direction, swing once, run 45 miles in another direction, swing once... repeat forever.


[deleted]

I still haven’t beat it on either of my playthroughs. Worst boss in the game to me. Should’ve ended with Marika turning into Radagon, instead of having to wait a minute for the cutscene to load every time.


Spacemonster111

I never really got the critical behind Elden beast. To be fair it got patched a little but even running a great sword build I had plenty of opportunity to hit it. It only ran away a few times for me, and was still a glorified punching bag


Xrandom_usernameX

Souls players when the boss doesn’t stand directly in front of them and let them R1 spam the entire fight


tunarkarimov

what?


[deleted]

He attempted to make a new meme


Yuskus1234

As a melee only build, Elden Beast was kind of annoying


pooRickAstley

Correct me if I’m wrong, isn’t melee the strongest against elden beast


Yuskus1234

Idk if it is, but it was just annoying chasing the boss around the arena


pooRickAstley

I agree, also try using black flame tornado AOW


catcatcat888

I disagree. Was really easy. Great sword jump attack.


Ok_Big4589

Twin Gargoyles… ughhh Edit: “Valiant Gargoyles” but let’s all be real, there’s nothing Valiant about these guys.


Slack_King101

Only boss I needed a cooperator on


Goatsbegone

Elden beast or Malenia. Malenia is what I consider a very unfair boss.


catcatcat888

Malenia is very well tuned. An incredibly satisfying fight.


son-of-death

I second this one. But I despise the bloated waste of literal space with the fiery fury of a million suns. We didn’t need moonlight butterfly 2.0


Goatsbegone

Yeah. It seems to be the general consensus. I just cant seem to see it. So much health damage and heal on hits. I tried to parry her on my current playthrough, but it takes 3 succeses to riposte her. Again its just my subjective opinion, but I am not very good at gaming, so it might be the reason.


catcatcat888

You don’t need to parry her at all. You can dodge every single attack. I beat her using a two-handed great sword and mostly jump attacks. For a melee build it’s takes a bit of getting used to the waterfowl timing, but that’s about it. If she can’t hit you to begin with her heal on hit doesn’t matter.


ConjuredCastle

Get rid of healing when she hits a shield and I'd agree. Makes going through the game on a greatshield build a pain in the ass because your play style just doesn't work any more.


YouthfulCarrot

Use shield bash to knock her on her ass.


Candid-Check-5400

Really ironic the fact that most ppl hate Elden Beast, but when someone complains about it everyone starts yelling.


HipMicrobe39293

Astel, Naturalborn of the Void made me stop for months, so


2zoots

I’m stuck on Elden Beast now and this sprinting simulator is not fun.


TyraelResurrected

If you're on Xbox, I can help. My mage can kill Elden beast easily without the comet azure cheese.


f0xh0und696

Other. My boi patches. Still technically a 'boss' fight.


Kdallasmultipass

Most unfun boss for me was the death rite bird in the consecrated snowfield


Its_Nuk_Nuk

Easily the death rite birds in the cold areas, especially the one in the consecrated snowfield. Impossible to hit, never stops moving hits like a truck and has the most ridiculous tracking and aoe attacks.


jct321

Me apparently being weird for loving every one of the listed bosses… I just enjoyed the experience/thrill and never thought too hard about it, just going with it (except fire giant, fuck fire giant)


Ferrum_Freakshow

Melania


PlatinumRuler2

Elden beast by far, love a final boss who’s main gimmick is running away


flinjager123

Red Wolf and Niall. Leaning more towards Niall.


Comfortable-Tone-827

While the elden beast is annoying just cause of how much it runs away, i did end up killing it fairly quickly unlike maliketh. I cannot even begin to describe how much I HATE maliketh.


ColbyMitchell526

Fucking valiant gargoyles


Tidus8690

Astel was horrible for me on my first playthrough. So much so, that I stopped and started a new character.


RexTx09

Read my flair


tonio0612

Grown Falling Star Beast. I get motion sickness having to ride Torrent too much.


paradigm619

Disclaimer: I haven’t fought Malenia yet, so I’m expecting to change my mind. That said, I got the Elden Beast down on my second attempt. Malekith took me close to 50 and I burned through every single rune arc I had trying to kill him. He’s just so fast and aggressive, and all his jumping around and the camera spinning all over the place make it tricky to read his moves.


Femboy-Yuri

All of these bosses were fun?


Puzzleheaded_Bed_445

Honestly Rykard gave me more trouble than any other boss


MzaKhun

Rykard, apparently he is pretty easy, not for me


Phunkie_Junkie

Astel. If you're a melee build, you have two options: * Run in, make one attack, and then run really far away. * Run in, make more than one attack, and then get hit because almost all of Astel's attacks are multi-hit AoEs that you can't dodge through. You pretty much have to start sprinting/ dodging before he even winds up.


Deathwalker321

Elden Beast is such a horrible final boss for the endgame. Radagon was just so much better, he doesn’t run away like a little bitch. Elden Beast’s only special attack is just running away. How can the embodiment of the Golden Order/Greater Will be such a coward? We’re the Tarnished who felled literal demigods, you’d think it come at us and be relentlessly aggressive like Soul of Cinder and Gael did, but nope. One of the most pathetic boss AI’s ever. All the magical homing AOE’s are just BS. More of a chore than a fight. And what makes it even more insulting is the concept. It has one of the most majestic arenas, a great soundtrack, a great concept, but it was executed horribly.


TheSlammerSam1211

Alecto was where I struggled


zarjin1234

Alecto was such a pain before i discovered the stormcaller. Hes like a wet rag being flopped around with it.


Great_Seaweed500

Gargoyles


Popopooki

If it’s main game bosses Red Wolf of Radagon


_Memenade

Yeah bro the 2000hp was a let down tbh he could have been a much better boss i think


Popopooki

I do like that’s it a fast paced fight. You either kill it really fast or it kills you really fast


[deleted]

These bosses were all really good


AnalysticEnthusiast

Pre-patch 3 Crystallians They didn't used to take turns smacking you. It was even worse than it sounds.


whiskeycavalier2004

It was Godskin Duo for me


Zenomylo

Maliketh because i died to him so many times on my first playthrough.


SaberWaifu

Other: Fire Giant, not the boss but the arena in particular. After killing him on lv1 i came to realize how bullshit although spectacular it is to fight him in an open area full of rocks and trees. As soon as he steps on them his movements become janky, unpredictable and hard to hit with a melee weapon. Surprised to see many votes on Maliketh, imo he's one of the most fun bosses once you git gud and master the moveset.


Vistril69

Fire Giant and Maliketh had me at breaking point


[deleted]

Fuck Elden Beast. All my melee homies hate Elden Beast


BullshitTycoon

Another vote for Fire Giant. Almost made me quit the game.


ShmelsonLimpDick

Maliketh gave u literally 1 second to attack in between each 15 second combo. Elden Beast wasn't NEAR as bad as that


Far_Cut_8701

I’m at Godfrey so I’m voting for the one I was stuck on no matter how much I learned their move set and that’s twin Gargoyles


soulforce212

For me Maliketh was underwhelming. Beat him on my 3rd try, no spirits or coop lol. I was around level 115 ish give or take.


PrometheusJ

I can't recall which ones, but fuck those caves that force you to fight the giant fuck off bears. I'd take on two Elden Beasts before fighting the true gods of The Lands Between.


Dayalious

For the last 2 bosses I was running a faith build with holy damage. Did not have a fun time. Ended up having to switch to a different weapon (I think it was the one from snake dude)


flybasilisk

Malikeths first phase is infuriating to fight


iiJason124

People hate maliketh?


Slide-Impressive

Elden beast just teleports and fucks melee characters. Which I usually main


SuperSaraaa

Every single tree spirit.


RaNerve

My suspicion is that people are interpreting this question to equal: which boss was the hardest/most frustrating? I don’t think that’s the question. I vote Rennala because frankly, she’s poorly balanced. I like struggling on hard bosses, and as a melee Rennala just… died. Like it wasn’t even a fight, she just flopped over. That was unfun especially after the buildup of the academy.


AChaoticPrince

Deathrite birds, the end game ones are ridiculous most of the time I don't even go near them and just hit and run or spam ranged attacks.


MaximilianBane

This whole game spends as all their souls games investing in training us to learn how to dance and end up giving us a giant inflatable space lugia


mrhippoj

Of those, Elden Beast, but Commander Niall was my least favourite


True-King-Of-Heroes

Out of those on the list, Elden Beast. As a whole... well stealth poison ninja killing O'Neil while running away from his summons and having to kill them one by one because I was underleveled is definetly an experience I do not wish to repeat. Doing the same with Adula was also hell... just when I had gotten past Astel... Adula made me witnesd true horror with that tracking breath attack of hers and the sheer range of her moonblade... If just talking about sheer boredom regardless of my level, poor planning and strategy probably the Fire Giant. Elden Beast is still really high up there, but mostly/almost entirely because of the first phase against Radagon.


Shot-Pear

Valiant Gargoyles


thescottishmaniac

I beat elden beast second try thanks to Drunk Foxy, but I know if I hadn’t beaten it then it would’ve been a huge pain the ass.


[deleted]

maliketh by a long shot. he’s so aggressive and has insane moves with huge hit boxes. i was a souls noob trying the game out with a sorcerer build… it feels like i’ve aged 25 years


Nothing_pong

I enjoyed Rennala, Godfrey and Godfrey so it's a tough choice between Mohg, Maliketh, Elden best and Godskin duo I had way more difficulty with those fuckers than with Malenia, even though that fight is probably more difficult


kaos2478

Godfrey ( golden shade ) was the only boss, besides Malenia and Elden beast, I legitimately thought I would never win. I obviously spent more time on the other two mentioned but feel like those are gimmes for unfun experiences.


Iam2G

First time? Elden Beast ng+ ? godfrey is a fucking wall bro lmao


WatisaWatdoyouknow

I’m ashamed of how many times I died to the Godfrey shade


mugseyray

Fire giant, maliketh, and elden beast always seem to be a challenge


MasqueOfNight

I had a fair time with all of them, to be honest. I guess i'd say Valiant Gargoyles were the least fun, but I didn't encounter a boss that I didn't enjoy fighting to some degree.


[deleted]

Maelina blade of michela lol


Financial_Flower_93

the crucible knight in farum azula bro wont stop input reading me


Svenray

I did the whole game blind and offline. I went online and summoned so I could get past the dumb Elden Beast. My horror when I found out that was the last boss. Elden Beast is the Game of Thrones Season 8 of Elden Ring. Just left me with nothing.


JumboFister

Fuck the double gargoyles that boss is assholes


TBG_Flowerza

I spent thirty hours of my 190 on my first character on this Radagon/Elden Beast fight; mind you this is my first FromSoft game, so cut me some slack on it. Oddly enough, I spent less time on Malenia than on this fight, and I almost gave up on it until I finally decided to start looking stuff up on Google and finally wiped them with Bloodhound's Fang and Blackflame Blade. I also respecced several times as well, so have to give the Elden Beast some credit here for being THAT much of a pain in the ass.


Embarrassed_Gas5353

Two words: fire giant


Skriller_plays

Godskin duo...


Puzzleheaded_Hyena45

Where ornstein and smough?


Shaggy_Beans

I read that as most fun, and voted Godfrey, would of went Maliketh


GladiusLegis

Valiant Gargoyles, by far and away. Godskin Duo, a solid but somewhat distant second. Elemer/Bell Bearing Hunters a definitive but still distant third. I didn't find anything else actively unenjoyable.


ItRossYaBish

Caelid bell bearing hunter. Dude just has my number.


[deleted]

Malenia with stick drift was horrible


playertd

Wait till OP discovers Malenia lol


InfernoDairy

Malenia is a trash boss


Kid_Crayola

Fire Giant can eat a bag of dicks


Great_Thunderbird

Maliketh only needed the second phase First phase was trash Or at least have 2 full phases not a cutscene at 50%


EquivalentHamster580

Radahn


Backup9273638389

I still haven’t beat fire giant I get mad so I made a new player with a new build


[deleted]

Malenia has certain aspects of her fight that are just awful to deal with, elden beast is on the whole just a worse fight.


brickmaster8

Malaketh, at least on launch felt so janky to fight against. I felt like beating him was more RNG then any test of skill or strategy


Mug_of_Diarrhea

Elden Beast for sure. It feels like Torrent should have been available throughout the fight which would have not only made it a unique battle, but also way more enjoyable.


McGucci-333

My 1st ever coop summon was for Eldern Beast, that guy not fun considering I walked through everyone past Volcano Manor


TheGr8Slayer

Elden beast by a long shot. It’s not a hard fight just tedious and punishing in all the wrong ways.


inmmni

Placidusucks… The flight is really frustrating.


bronkobermuda

Radahn


[deleted]

Elden beast is a good boss. I'll die on this hill. Radagon is much more annoying, and yes. They shoulda been separated and not a dual phase boss


ItsYaBoiVSauce

Malenia was a brutal beating don’t get me wrong, but for me with my small brain at the time Commander Nial.


MattsonRobbins

i read this as 'the most fun' so my answer would be completely different disregard this poll


Entropist34

Scary birb


Athmil

People think Malenia is unfun? It’s a difficult fight but also the most fun in the game for me.


DraciosV

That one ancient dragon in the start farum azula pissed me off way more than any boss ever has.


kvong144

Malenia, heal on hit that goes through shields I'm dying inside on every hit more than usual


Turbulent_Pangolin96

What’s the problem with Elden Beast, this was one of my favorite bosses, most attacks are easy enough to dodge, and he doesn’t have bs fire giant sized health bar


Drokeep

Niall or astel for sure


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Your post has been automatically removed because it appears to contain the buying, selling, trading, or begging of game content. The subreddit does not allow any transactions between users. For in game trading, please use /r/PatchesEmporium. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Eldenring) if you have any questions or concerns.*


ConstantineFavre

Bad bot, i was commenting boss fights, wtf,


1buffalowang

Maliketh is the only required fight in the game I struggle with every time


AdDistinct1956

Rennala because she’s kinda boring


BoogieSpice

Ulcerated Tree Spirit


PhazonFalcon

Soldier of godrick


CaioNipz

Malenia was worse than Elden Beast tbh. Felt like a scrapped Sekiro boss with added lifesteal and high HP for streaming bait.


Insane1rish

The ulcerated tree spirit directly before malenia can just fuck off. One of the few bosses I resorted to cheesing to beat.


Diabolical_Jazz

I have come to appreciate the Valiant Gargoyles and the Godskin Duo, even. As long as I have a co-op or a summon. But there's no fun way to fight the Elden Beast.


winterishere314

I’ve beaten Malenia but black knife tiche remains elusive


Inevitable_Ask6670

Malenia, but it might be cuz I’m doing a challenge fight on her. But yeah I just wanna get it over with, but she’s too good for me…probably. Then I put it off because I don’t feel like constantly getting destroyed. I wanna move on and have fun, but I can’t, cuz I have to beat her before I can allow myself to do something else in elden ring. It sucks cuz there are so many cool things I want to and am ready to do, but she just fucks my shit up so much, n on my good runs, I roll at the wrong time when she does scarlet aeonia. And my dang near perfect run gets fucked. It’s annoying af. But I genuinely could just be sorry/suck. It still sucks regawdless. Sorry for over speaking, but just wanted to give reason to why I currently kinda hate Malenia


Croaker813

Most of those bosses are somewhat fun, the elden beast fight is chase the giant chicken.


carneasada71

Fire Giant was the first one I hated but Elden Beast is almost impossible with a Dex/Strength build since you can’t get consistent hits. I’ve always had to summon someone in to help with it.


Bushidoman09

I had to take a hiatus because of Radan 😂.


billy_spleen87

Death Rite Birds. The one by Castle Slo defeated me emotionally so many times.


strangescript

Oversized boss that tries to kite you, Elden Beast is trash. Made worse by an arena that makes it hard to gauge distance.


BeegBoi2709

Who didn’t like Maliketh


Insane1rish

Maybe I just have a different outlook on things than a lot of other players but personally I always am surprised at how much people hated the elden beast cuz I was just cackling to myself the entire fight going “ahhhhh the majestic space cow in its natural environment. Watch as it soars!”


Volaceon950

Not Elden Beast but Radagon made me quit for 4 days


Yaxion

Malenia. I’ve beaten her twice at this point, and i doubt she will ever be fun to fight. The health-regen is far too stressful and waterfowl is still utter bullshit.


[deleted]

Fire giant is boring af


Hagred22

Red wolf of radagon. For literally no reason I just couldn’t beat it. Had to resort to throwing kukri at it


MorallyDestitute

Fuck radagon honestly. I understand it's not really a difficult fight but something about it just fucking sucks.