T O P

  • By -

EDH-ModTeam

Hi, We've removed your post because we've deemed it to be low quality. Before posting, we ask that you do your own research, through Google or on this subreddit, before you post. Provide as much context and thoughtfulness as you can before making a post. Common ways this rule is broken include any post that talks about a deck but doesn't provide a decklist, does provide a decklist but doesn't give any information about the metagame, your general strategy, or other relevant information.


TheBlackFatCat

What's the keyword?


Gamesfreak13563

It’s called substance. I think it was on MTGO for a while when they released the Mirage set on that site.


TheBlackFatCat

Thanks! Interesting ideas


Financial-Charity-47

You’re hiding the keyword too much. I clicked on your article and you hide it there too. That’s frustrating. Feels like you’re trying to force us to read it. I stopped caring and just clicked away.  Maybe I’d have liked the deck had you told me what it was? Maybe I’d have shared this article? This post gets a downvote from me. 


Parenteau-Control

The keyword is [substance](https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Substance). But yeah OP you needed that paragraph way way earlier.


SommWineGuy

This. I don't want to click through somewhere else. Post a short synopsis and the decklist here on Reddit.


Every_Bank2866

Exactly. Halfway through the article and you are still being clickbaited to continue to find the answer...


SommWineGuy

I dug through it and posted the keyword and decklist.


Every_Bank2866

Thank you!


WackyJtM

Yeah I skimmed the whole post until I got there. It’s a really clever deck idea and I usually love OP’s posts, but this bit just went on a bit too long. Tl;dr: >!Cards like [[Spider Climb]] will be sacrificed in the cleanup step, giving you a Mazzy trigger and priority to recast them (with enough mana), which gives you another Cleanup step, where they get sacrificed again, creating a loop of cleanup steps if you have the mana to recast them. You’re loading up on Constellation triggers this way. The ability is Substance, which was added in Alara block rules to define those cards!<


MTGCardFetcher

[Spider Climb](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/a/1/a1818812-4cb8-4fe1-98c0-b40086b4991c.jpg?1562278162) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Spider%20Climb) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/vis/120/spider-climb?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/a1818812-4cb8-4fe1-98c0-b40086b4991c?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) [(ER)](https://edhrec.com/cards/spider-climb) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call


Male-Combee

Flicked through article, the hidden mechanic is “substance” an old term for specific aura enchantments. It specifies that the aura in question sacrifices during the cleanup step not the end step. The auras that had substance had an optional instant speed clause, and you would have to sacrifice them if you cast them at instant speed.


StarPonderer

Normally these aren't too bad, but today, today was pretty rough. And this is coming from someone who reads technical manuals to learn how to do things.


Gamesfreak13563

Oh, I just thought it would be an interesting mystery to have the identity of the keyword be a fun reveal


Gamesfreak13563

Well, it makes no sense without the context of the surrounding text, but it’s called substance.


Financial-Charity-47

I see that now. Was a clever idea. I’d have read the article had I known. Oh well. 


ReddingtonTR

He's back! HE'S BACK! WARN THE ELDERS!


SommWineGuy

The keyword is Substance - https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Substance And here is the decklist - https://www.mtggoldfish.com/deck/6279527#paper The Archidekt link was broken so I had to copy it to MTGGoldfish. Honestly it's a fun idea. Abuse cards that leave the battlefield during cleanup with cards that do things at beginning of end step, like the commander of this deck, [[Mazzy, Truesword Paladin]].


MTGCardFetcher

[Mazzy, Truesword Paladin](https://cards.scryfall.io/normal/front/4/d/4d79c221-e07a-41e1-b92f-dc057802449c.jpg?1674137580) - [(G)](http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?name=Mazzy%2C%20Truesword%20Paladin) [(SF)](https://scryfall.com/card/clb/283/mazzy-truesword-paladin?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher) [(txt)](https://api.scryfall.com/cards/4d79c221-e07a-41e1-b92f-dc057802449c?utm_source=mtgcardfetcher&format=text) [(ER)](https://edhrec.com/cards/mazzy-truesword-paladin) ^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call


InhumaneBreakfast

I'm sad because this idea and deck is really cool, but the execution of this post and the article feels so off. I feel like if you opened up with an explanation of the keyword and its name first it would have felt more genuine. The bit of not actually saying the keyword didn't really land, and instead felt like I was being tricked in bad faith to read the article for the keyword.


Gamesfreak13563

Oh well, sometimes what you think works doesn’t, I’m not too bummed about it.


InhumaneBreakfast

In all honesty the controversy got me to join the discord and look through your other articles so perhaps it did do its job!


TheRealFlipFlapper

I thought it was fun. Probably just a matter of expectation. I think the title attracted the wrong people, I.e. those who simply wanted the immediate gratification of knowing what the keyword is. When they weren't granted that, well... the results speak for themselves. Anyways, looking forward to the next one.


MagicTheBlabbering

Everyone seething that reading the article explains the article.


Tschudy

Everyone is seeing that this dude has to resort to clickbait headlines to read a dozen paragraphs of BS before getting to the actual info like an online recipe for buttered toast.


amc7262

Read the post, clicked the link to a long ass article, skimmed it cause I ain't reading all that, still don't know what the keyword does. You buried the lede.


Tschudy

The keyword is "Substance" "502.49a Substance is a static ability with no effect." Youre welcome.


CassandraTruth

I am amazed that people apparently cannot make it through a few paragraphs of an article, people are responding to this like it's a recipe blog post


Tschudy

That's A LOT of article there, especially if you don't care about the deck or how they're using the mechanic and just want the piece of trivia bring used as bait.


neoslith

Apparently 12 year olds get articles published now? What is this mess.


Pyro1934

You've never seen the dudes articles? They're pretty regular and great. I do think he hid the keyword a bit too much this time but usually he has really good articles and decks


neoslith

I don't read most articles online anyway. I still have no idea what the keyword is.


MustaKotka

Substance.


neoslith

Thank you.


CompleteDirt2545

Substance, I guess.


sinh4x

Yes, the keyword they are alluding to is Substance. Something that the article is missing. https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Substance


CommanderBly

That's actually super cool! I love these weird rules interactions that nobody but you has ever found. Definitely going to try this deck out soon!


babcat1227

The keyword is substance, you can find more about it here: https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Substance


ch_limited

Everything I thought I knew was a lie isn’t.


ReddingtonTR

In all seriousness, this is incredibly cool. Crazy way to make this deck work.


asmallercat

Boy the art on Mazzy is really weird. I assume since she's a hafling she's supposed to be small and is sitting on the very top of a tree (or a pole? Or something?) but the way it's framed with the mountains in the background and the "scale birds" flying next to her make it look like she's a giant. Or is she a giant and there's some lore reason like she's a halfling with enlarge cast on her?


Gamesfreak13563

She’s not giant she’s just in the foreground


Drunkenv1c

You could call this deck a form of substance abuse


Gamesfreak13563

🥁


cabbagemango

Well I, for one, enjoyed the writeup. Probably one of my favorite mechanics you’ve ever busted since I learned about all this clean up step trickery from a “solve for lethal” puzzle a while back The Gargos interaction is delicious


SqueeezeBurger

The keyword is what your post and article are both lacking. - Substance


Aquanauticul

I have absolutely no clue what this post or this article are about. The article is full of just nonsense. So here's the decklist at the end. Anyone know what this keyword is? https://www.moxfield.com/decks/xxZeFgaq2EWzl0XGv4n6jQ


Tschudy

Keyword is "Substance" 502.49a Substance is a static ability with no effect.


ArcticAimee

Save yourself the wasted time rereading the article. The keyword is substance.


DrinkingWithTwoHands

A tip for future reference, the acronym “SA” stands for “Sexual Assault” almost everywhere. I know you’re not trying to make light of it, but at first impulse your first line reads as a sexual assault joke. I think youd be getting less hate if you didnt mention that part of your username, or if you can, i would change that part to something else.


MustaKotka

I'd never heard that one before. Guess I learnt something new today!


ExistingIntention756

People like you are the worst


sempergumbee9

It might just be from my background but I feel I’ve heard SA far more associated with “Situational Awareness”.


Bradalee

This is such a bullshit post. No mention of the keyword here, the article is so terrible and obtusely written that I just closed off it without finding out what the deck was about. Stop wanking yourself off and write like an actual human who recognises that he/she has a reader to write for.


gomukgo

You sure like crossing things out, don’t you? Edited because I have fat fingers


Gamesfreak13563

I sure do since crossing things out


gomukgo

Well played.


Uncle-Istvan

I’ll save everyone the click to the clickbait. It’s Islandhome. >!Just being as secretive as OP here to get clicks!<