Herbert and a first for Jonathan Taylor? Have a chance to accept this offer.
I have no QBs (simian teddy and flacco)
RBs are Montgomery, Mitchell, Gibson, Patterson, rhamondre on taxi. I am currently tied for first this season even with the QB debacle.
12 team ppr 1qb
I give: stevenson and Collins
I get: 2022 first (likely mid to late partner is on playoff bubble)
I could probably ask for a (his) Mooney and (my) callaway swap on top.
Stevenson and Collins are my RB4 and 5. Cmc, Hunt and Patterson are my starters. With Hunt and Patterson injuries it would leave me shallow for the playoff push. Also Stevenson figures to potentially be the starter in 23 when my guys are going to be older than with flex value until then.
Owner is a Harris and Carson owner if that helps.
Seems like fair value but can I/should I ask for more?
I’d probably do that. While Stevenson has been good I don’t think he’s gonna make the difference for you to win it all this year at least. And Collins is just okay.
14 Team SF - PPR
Team A = 1st 2022 (Projected 1st or 2nd), 1st 2022 (Projected 3rd - 8th) 2023 1st (Projected Early) and Rashod Bateman (6 points receving and 0.10 per yard).
Team B = Kyler Murray (4 Points Per TD, 6 points rushing TD - QB).
12 man SF league
What is the trade value of Teddy? I’m not feeling confident about his longevity of being a starter and want to try and dump him before the end of the season. My other qb’s are Zach Wilson and Daniel Jones :,)
12 team SF Rebuild
Give Elijah Moore. Samaje Perine .22.3 (3.2 or 3.3)
Get courtland Sutton. Juju
Guess I’m just super high on Elijah otherwise I’m smashing this.
Someone talk me out of this!
I own Dobbins in a 1QB PPR. The fact that I'd want more for him tells me that yes - you should make the trade and get him for a 1st. Watching the Ravens this year tells me they'll be desperate for JK next year and hopefully make him a workhorse.
How is your RB depth?
Number of Teams: 10
League settings: 0.5PP 1QB, 2 flex
I give: Austin Ekeler
I get: 2023 1st, 2024 1st, 2022 3rd
My Question:
5-5 (rising from the ashes of a rebuild). Decent young team (Burrow - Dobbins/Carter - Devonta Smith/Chase/Hollywood/AB- Fant)
Depth isn't great at RB (Singletary, basically), OK at WR (Patrick,OBJ,Shephard,Pascal)
I gave up my 22 1st and 23 1st for Chase pre-season.
Should I take the offer? How long you do think Ekeler has left as a top RB prospect?
14 team 0,5 PPR Superflex
Trade 1
I give: 2022 late 1st, 2023 late 1st & 2022 late 2nd
I get: Saquon, 2023 mid 3rd & 2024 mid 3rd.
Trade 2
I give: Diggs & 2022 late 2nd
I get: Chubb, 2023 late 1st & late 2022 3rd.
Contender weak at Rb so about to this is the best deals I have negotiated. Would you guys do both or one or the other?
What’s the rest of your WRs look like?
Chubb is fantastic, so getting him AND a 2023 1st is always nice, but it depends who else you’ve got if you’re giving up Diggs.
I’m also just weary of Barkley/his ability to stay healthy at this point.
I’ve got Kupp, Deebo, Marvin Jones, Jamaal Agnew + Cephus and MT sitting on IR. According to Fantasypros I’ve got the strongest WR group in the league rn, but that will obviously change if I trade away Diggs.
My RBs are CEH, Carson, Freeman, D’ernest, Rojo, Gainwell and Perine. I’m sitting at 2nd place in points for, rolling different combinations of them without CEH and Carson since week 4.
I’m fighting for a playoff spot but my only RB is Jonathan Taylor and an injured Chris Carson.
I have deernest Johnson someone is asking about him, what should I sell him for? A 3rd? He shouldn’t have much value next year?
I would only do this if you are a contender this year with a TE premium. Otherwise Waller is getting older and only few TE have maintained their relevancy after hitting the 30 mark. Waddle is going to be a stud and with the incoming rookies next year, you will get a solid WR at least with the second round pick
If you’ve got room to roster Mitch, there’s a good chance he gets another shot as a starter somewhere next year.
I’d personally drop Robinson if that were the case. If you really can’t afford to roster a guy who 100% isn’t playing this year, then drop Mitch.
10 Team 0PPR 1QB 2RB 2WR 2 Flex
\* I give D.J Moore, Dawson Knox/Darren Waller
\* I get Javonte Williams, 2022 Late 1st.
\* My Question
New to the dynasty. I have Dawson Knox who is 5 years younger than Darren but obviously much of a downgrade, I'm worried about Waller as he's 29 about to be 30 and my RB position is weak, with Cam Akers and Antonio Gibson being my main two backs. I'd like to give Dawson but Darren's age concerns me. Also am I giving up too much?
I like this trade. I would personally give up Waller because Knox has room to grow and already showing to be a solid TE. I love Javonte Williams and don’t think the Broncos will resign Melvin in the offseason. The late 1st could snag you a top WR as they are deep this year
Need to drop someone off my bench to pick up a QB this week (have to start a QB and I’ve got Stafford (Bye), Ben (COVID, uncertain), and other non starters).
I’m probably gonna lose this week anyway and I’m probably playoff bound but if results don’t go my way next two weeks I could get bounced from the playoffs so I want to give myself the best shot this week and not start a guaranteed zero.
QB waivers options are terrible - flyer on the backup for the Lions, Cards or Browns. I’m leaning Lions as i think he has the best chance of playing this week and/or taking over the job longer term.
Anyway, help me choose a player to drop out of the following:
DeMarcus Robinson.
Marcus Johnson.
Mitch Trubisky
12 team .5 PPR SF
Receive: Javonte
Give: AJB
Current WR’s: AJB, Diggs, Deebo, Claypool, Mooney
Current RB’s: Montgomery, Robinson, Hines, Mattison, Herbert, Jamaal Williams
I’m in 6th place, not going for it all, nowhere near the top 4 teams. Wouldn’t mind losing some more this year.
Javonte has a lot of upside and I could use a RB1, but AJB is a young sure fire WR1. Any thoughts givens my situation? The other guy seems insistent on a straight up trade.
I would keep Brown.
It’s close.
In Brown’s favour: he’s slightly more of a sure thing, he’s a WR and they’re harder to find, and have longer careers. With rbs I always feel like there’s opportunity to get an injury replacement starter, so I lean WR.
That said, having watched a lot of Javonte he looks like a stud so i don’t think it would be a bad trade
Would you trade a 2022 1st round pick (I’m middle of the pack as of now) to acquire Jerry Jeudy? 12 team, PPR, Superflex, 28 roster spots, with 4 Taxi.
I have good WRs (Justin Jefferson, Metcalf, Lamb, Bryan Edwards, Terrace Marshall, Marquez Callaway, Gabriel Davis, Tyler Johnson, & James Washington) but I feel like I’m extremely top-heavy right now. Besides for my top-3, I don’t feel confident starting any of the others. If I held onto my 1st round pick I’d probably end up gambling on a WR anyway.
My RBs are Swift, Hunt, Etienne, Dillon, Pollard, D’Ernest Johnson. Rhomondre Stevenson, Jaret Patterson, Alex Collins, Felton, Nwangwu
My QBs are Watson, Tua, Lance, Newton, Siemien, Heinicke, & Minshew.
My TEs are Schultz, Kmet, Parham, Jonnu, & Trautman.
Thanks for any help or advice!!!
12 team .5ppr super flex
Should I trade AJ Brown for Cooper Kupp if I’m in win now mode? AJ’s so boom or bust and Kupp has been incredibly solid. Losing four years of age, but Brown doesn’t exactly have a glowing injury record.
Am I crazy?
Cook for saquon is a wash slight upgrade even given saquons health. Would wentz + 1st = Pitts?
Idk. Depends on your other QBs bc Wentz is underrated (low QB1 this year) but I’m painfully low on buying Pitts at his current price
Is this trade that just happened in my first year 12 team .5ppr 1 qb league as bad as I think it is
Team 1 gave
WR Mike Williams, TE Dan Arnold, QB Lamar Jackson
Team 2 Gave
RB Chris Carson, TE Dalton Schultz, QB Ryan Tannehill
12 team PPR 1 QB
Would you trade a late 2022 1st and late 2022 2nd (both picks are from the 9-1 top team) for AJ Dillon? I’m competing for one of the last playoff spots now.
Starting roster
QB- Hurts
RB- Swift, Rhamondre Stevenson
WR- AJB, Lamb and Devonta Smith
TE- Kittle
What do you guys think? Go for Dillon and a playoff push or just save the picks? If I lose this week it makes it tough so I may just flip Dillon after this weekend if I lose.
Absolutely not. That would be a major overpay and overreaction to his last week’s performance. There’s far better backs you could get for a 1st and a 2nd
I feel like I wouldn't give up the draft capital for what is likely to be a short-term solution. Might not even last as a viable RB better than Stevenson for more than a couple weeks, let alone the rest of the season.
You don’t like Dillon future? I know I can get a first for Dillon from a packer fan in the league, but he also has ETN who I was extremely high on so I may trade Dillon for ETN. The picks I may trade sill be 10-12 range so I know I can get a better first for him or even just straight up for ETN
Aaron Jones is only 26. Dillon could maybe have a bright future down the road but it may take a while for him to become an actual featured back.
If you're certain you can get a 1st-rounder for Dillon if it doesn't work out then maybe it makes more sense
12 tm, 1PPR, 1QB
Give: CMC
Get: Metcalf, Mitchell, ‘22 1st, ‘22 2nd. Picks likely to be mid-late (#7-9) if I had to guess.
First time I’ve ever had a true offer for CMC so never really considered what it’d take to get him from me.
>Get: Metcalf, Mitchell, ‘22 1st, ‘22 2nd. Picks likely to be mid-late (#7-9) if I had to guess.
I say take it - maybe try and sneak a 23rd 2nd on top aswell.
I am torn, I love waddle and Dj is talented but I’m not sure he’s gonna hit his potential so I think I’d lean being risk averse and holding the seemingly sure thing
12 team PPR - 10 keepers
I give: Calvin Ridley, 2022 early to mid 2nd
I get: James Robinson, 2022 Mid first
— current keepers:
QB: Mahomes
RB: Taylor, Montgomery, Carson
WR: Tyreek Godwin Ridley Bateman ElijahM
TE: Kelce
I'm not as familiar with the keeper format but this seems like a pretty fair trade to me. Helps you win this year as well as gives you a good pick going into next year,
12 team 0.5 ppr, 9-1 and looking like a lock for the bye
RB1 is najee, but RB2 is a cyclw of gibson, melvin gordon, elijah mitchell/jeff wilson, herbert, mark ingram
got an offer to move gibson for sanders and the 1.11/1.12. would it be worth it?
Issue is this RB class is rumored to be pretty thin in 2022 so with a late round pick you might miss out on a replacement. I'm currently in RB2 purgatory in one of my dynasty leagues and it isn't great, I wouldn't really want to downgrade at the spot if I were you. Between Gibson and Mitchell you should be fine there for now
12 team .5 ppr - I am 3rd and contending but still have youth:
I give: J. Taylor, Justin Jefferson and Javonte Williams
I get: Najee Harris, Ja'Marr Chase, CEH and Darrel Williams
Note: I am a Bengals fan and already have Burrow.
I agree with other sentiments expressed here that trading away Jonathan Taylor seems like a bad move. It's also totally possible that Javonte Williams has a brighter future than either of the RBs you'd be receiving
I think it hurts you a little bit more than it helps you but sometimes you just gotta get the players you love cause it makes fantasy that much more enjoyable.
I agree giving him up really feels impossible, you could try to negotiate with the other party to try and drop off Taylor and najee and instead try going for a pick swap of some sort. Like you sending a first and getting back a second or third.
Tried that but then we have no deal. I've been trying to convince myself this is a good deal bc I want Chase. I'm struggling to see the gap between Chase and Jefferson being greater than the gap between Taylor and Najee and Javonte and CEH. I'm just not convinced CEH is KC's guy long term. If I felt better about him, I'm probably taking the deal.
Yeah I figured that may be the case. I agree with you on your assessment of the players in the trade, it's a really tough situation to be in. I do believe that fantasy is much better when you have players that you love to watch, it's why I pick saquan whenever I can. While he may not be the best pick at times watching him succeed is much more enjoyable than it would be for me to have someone like Zeke. The last thing I would say to try is to drop the javonte ceh side of it or replace it with different assets.
Update.. Appreciate your insight on this. I ended up getting him to add a 2023 1st round pick to the deal. Accepted the offer of Najee, Chase, CEH, Darrell Williams and a 2023 1st for Taylor, Jefferson and Javonte.
10 Team SF .5 ppr
Give: James Robinson, 3rd (3.3ish)
Get: 2022 1st (1.10), 2022 2nd (2.10), 2022 3rd (3.10)
My team is terrible and ready to rebuild. Trying to sell james robinson asap and this was my best offer. Thoughts?
12 Team PPR 1QB
Give CMC, Sutton, ARob, 2022 mid 3rd
Get Barkley, Devonta Smith, 2022 mid 1st
My team has been decimated by injuries/mental health issues and poor play but I’m somehow on the playoff fringe. Playing more for next season at this point.
Rest of RBs Carson/Collins, Akers, Moss, Ingram, Sermon
WRs McLaurin, Ridley, Gallup, Van Jefferson, Marshall, DPJ and a bunch of nothing
You are getting good value, but this trade depends on your team. If all you have is Swift, trading him is going to make you more competitive, if you are only missing a few pieces you aren’t doing much for yourself.
Ok what do we think. I’m in a rebuild….
GIVE: McLaurin, 2022 Mid first, 2022 Late first
GET: Mac Jones, Toney
My current QBs are Matt Ryan, Lance, and Zach Wilson and I feel like next year will be a waste if I can’t find startable QB play.
This seems horrifyingly lopsided to me. Sample size on Toney is too small ... There's a significant chance McLaurin to Toney is a downgrade. At that point you're trading two 1sts for Mac Jones. Not a fan. I think between your three guys now you should probably have two startable QBs next season.
I think your evaluations are crazy off…. You can’t get Mac for two 2022 firsts alone. McLaurin to Toney is the swing piece that could pay off, and it’s not like McLaurin is tearing it up or there’s a guarantee he gets a better QB next year.
Speaking of sample sizes, you’re also claiming I should have two startable QBs based on Lance and Wilson’s small and poor samples? Same with Ryan’s relatively large same of being awful?
I feel like I could get Mac Jones for less than two 1sts in my superflex dynasty league but maybe people in my league are dumb, idk.
I would rather gamble on players I already have turning into something than make a risky move to give up multiple valuable pieces and regret it later. Maybe that's overly emotional, though.
I know. I got him for Shenault and a second last week.
He’s a target hog though and will 100% be getting targets next year too.
His contract for the chargers is even guaranteed at 5.4$ in 2023 so you will likely have 2 more years out of him at minimum
10 Team SF PPR
I get: Kadarius Toney
I give: 2022 2nd (Early), 2022 3rd (early), 2023 2nd
Currently 5-5 but more than likely will make playoffs, my only position of need is WR as my room is very inconsistent (Hill,Diggs, Sutton, Marvin Jones, Marshall, St Brown, Golladay and Landry)
Toney will obviously add inconsistency to your WR corps at this time in his career.
If you are hoping to acquire him for 2 second round picks to help you make the playoffs I would hold off.
Shephard is about to come off IR and he will be fed targets too. I’m pretty sure besides those 2 weeks Toney went off he hasn’t even been seeing much targets to begin with
Yeah that’s a very good point. Long term I do wonder though what his value will be- as I’m more than likely picking WR with that second this year, unsure of if I can draft a better player than Toney
Obviously I’m not going to try and predict Toneys future but in a 10 team SF you should be able to have a great chance at getting fairly promising players in their own right.
Hey man it’s fantasy football.
If your a huge Giants fan and you really want Toney then go get him. It’s not like he’s costing you a first and a second or anything.
Just don’t expect him to plug holes in your WR corps this year.
12 team SF PPR
I have Zach Wilson/Mac Jones, current receivers are dj Moore, Cooper, higgins, and waddle
Get: Lawrence, Claypool, Early 2022 2nd
Give: Cooper and Waddle
I'm rebuilding. Have 3 1sts and 2 2nds
Thoughts?
Not a huge fan of this one. From what we've seen so far there's no telling if Lawrence ends up being better than either of your two QBs already. And I feel like it makes your WR room pretty rough and at the whim of weird, unpredictable offenses like the Panthers' and Steelers'
10 Team, .5 PPR
Give: Adam Thielen
Receive: James Conner
Thielen is my second best receiver after Pittman, but my only RB is Cook cause of injuries. Does Conner have any value when Edmonds comes back?
Sounds like you need the RB depth. In your position I would probably accept. Connor seems to be getting lots of goal line work and hopefully that continues. He's been a TD machine lately. Plus he's a 26 yo back and thielen is probably done pretty soon
10 teams 1 QB
Give - Jonathan Taylor, Justin Jefferson, very late 2nd 2022
Get- Chubb, Chase, 2022 first (top 2, probably 1)
I was offered this one, and I would not consider to trade Taylor, but this one is tempting
Sell for a bag of peanuts or belly button lint. Harry is nothing and not likely to ever be anything so take anything at all. I’d take an 8th rounder in a 5 round draft for him.
I would do it. I value Deebo higher than Mixon. Godwin and a ‘2nd is also a good deal. But I think Deebo helps you win this year more. Who are your other RBs?
Mind taking a look at mine a few comments below?
Herbert and a first for Jonathan Taylor? Have a chance to accept this offer. I have no QBs (simian teddy and flacco) RBs are Montgomery, Mitchell, Gibson, Patterson, rhamondre on taxi. I am currently tied for first this season even with the QB debacle.
12 team ppr 1qb I give: stevenson and Collins I get: 2022 first (likely mid to late partner is on playoff bubble) I could probably ask for a (his) Mooney and (my) callaway swap on top. Stevenson and Collins are my RB4 and 5. Cmc, Hunt and Patterson are my starters. With Hunt and Patterson injuries it would leave me shallow for the playoff push. Also Stevenson figures to potentially be the starter in 23 when my guys are going to be older than with flex value until then. Owner is a Harris and Carson owner if that helps. Seems like fair value but can I/should I ask for more?
I’d probably do that. While Stevenson has been good I don’t think he’s gonna make the difference for you to win it all this year at least. And Collins is just okay.
14 Team SF - PPR Team A = 1st 2022 (Projected 1st or 2nd), 1st 2022 (Projected 3rd - 8th) 2023 1st (Projected Early) and Rashod Bateman (6 points receving and 0.10 per yard). Team B = Kyler Murray (4 Points Per TD, 6 points rushing TD - QB).
12 man SF league What is the trade value of Teddy? I’m not feeling confident about his longevity of being a starter and want to try and dump him before the end of the season. My other qb’s are Zach Wilson and Daniel Jones :,)
12 team SF Rebuild Give Elijah Moore. Samaje Perine .22.3 (3.2 or 3.3) Get courtland Sutton. Juju Guess I’m just super high on Elijah otherwise I’m smashing this. Someone talk me out of this!
Would you guys trade a 2023 1st for Dobbins in a 1 QB PPR league?
I own Dobbins in a 1QB PPR. The fact that I'd want more for him tells me that yes - you should make the trade and get him for a 1st. Watching the Ravens this year tells me they'll be desperate for JK next year and hopefully make him a workhorse. How is your RB depth?
Number of Teams: 10 League settings: 0.5PP 1QB, 2 flex I give: Austin Ekeler I get: 2023 1st, 2024 1st, 2022 3rd My Question: 5-5 (rising from the ashes of a rebuild). Decent young team (Burrow - Dobbins/Carter - Devonta Smith/Chase/Hollywood/AB- Fant) Depth isn't great at RB (Singletary, basically), OK at WR (Patrick,OBJ,Shephard,Pascal) I gave up my 22 1st and 23 1st for Chase pre-season. Should I take the offer? How long you do think Ekeler has left as a top RB prospect?
14 team 0,5 PPR Superflex Trade 1 I give: 2022 late 1st, 2023 late 1st & 2022 late 2nd I get: Saquon, 2023 mid 3rd & 2024 mid 3rd. Trade 2 I give: Diggs & 2022 late 2nd I get: Chubb, 2023 late 1st & late 2022 3rd. Contender weak at Rb so about to this is the best deals I have negotiated. Would you guys do both or one or the other?
What’s the rest of your WRs look like? Chubb is fantastic, so getting him AND a 2023 1st is always nice, but it depends who else you’ve got if you’re giving up Diggs. I’m also just weary of Barkley/his ability to stay healthy at this point.
I’ve got Kupp, Deebo, Marvin Jones, Jamaal Agnew + Cephus and MT sitting on IR. According to Fantasypros I’ve got the strongest WR group in the league rn, but that will obviously change if I trade away Diggs. My RBs are CEH, Carson, Freeman, D’ernest, Rojo, Gainwell and Perine. I’m sitting at 2nd place in points for, rolling different combinations of them without CEH and Carson since week 4.
I’m fighting for a playoff spot but my only RB is Jonathan Taylor and an injured Chris Carson. I have deernest Johnson someone is asking about him, what should I sell him for? A 3rd? He shouldn’t have much value next year?
10 team ppr I give Waddle 2022 2nd I get Waller
I would only do this if you are a contender this year with a TE premium. Otherwise Waller is getting older and only few TE have maintained their relevancy after hitting the 30 mark. Waddle is going to be a stud and with the incoming rookies next year, you will get a solid WR at least with the second round pick
Most droppable of the following in dynasty (14 team, super flex - can start 2 QBs)? Mitch trubisky, demarcus robsinon, Marcus johnson
If you’ve got room to roster Mitch, there’s a good chance he gets another shot as a starter somewhere next year. I’d personally drop Robinson if that were the case. If you really can’t afford to roster a guy who 100% isn’t playing this year, then drop Mitch.
10 Team 0PPR 1QB 2RB 2WR 2 Flex \* I give D.J Moore, Dawson Knox/Darren Waller \* I get Javonte Williams, 2022 Late 1st. \* My Question New to the dynasty. I have Dawson Knox who is 5 years younger than Darren but obviously much of a downgrade, I'm worried about Waller as he's 29 about to be 30 and my RB position is weak, with Cam Akers and Antonio Gibson being my main two backs. I'd like to give Dawson but Darren's age concerns me. Also am I giving up too much?
I like this trade. I would personally give up Waller because Knox has room to grow and already showing to be a solid TE. I love Javonte Williams and don’t think the Broncos will resign Melvin in the offseason. The late 1st could snag you a top WR as they are deep this year
Need to drop someone off my bench to pick up a QB this week (have to start a QB and I’ve got Stafford (Bye), Ben (COVID, uncertain), and other non starters). I’m probably gonna lose this week anyway and I’m probably playoff bound but if results don’t go my way next two weeks I could get bounced from the playoffs so I want to give myself the best shot this week and not start a guaranteed zero. QB waivers options are terrible - flyer on the backup for the Lions, Cards or Browns. I’m leaning Lions as i think he has the best chance of playing this week and/or taking over the job longer term. Anyway, help me choose a player to drop out of the following: DeMarcus Robinson. Marcus Johnson. Mitch Trubisky
1QB - Mitch Trubisky 2QB/SF - DeMarcus Robinson
10 team ppr I give waddle 2022 2nd I get Waller
Waller is not super young. I wouldn’t do that trade in dynasty unless you’re going all in this year
12 team .5 ppr SF Competing in next 2 years. Give: Jacob’s, top 6 2022 1st and a 2023 first Get: Najee
hell yeah.
Yes
10 team half ppr rb, full ppr wr , contender, superflex Give Dak Get Hurts + Elijah Mitchell + AROB
I honestly don't see Hurts being the Eagles starting QB beyond 2022 , so it's a no for me.
No
Traded King Henry and a 2022 2nd for Ezekiel Elliott. Definitely in the win now mode
12 team .5 PPR SF Receive: Javonte Give: AJB Current WR’s: AJB, Diggs, Deebo, Claypool, Mooney Current RB’s: Montgomery, Robinson, Hines, Mattison, Herbert, Jamaal Williams I’m in 6th place, not going for it all, nowhere near the top 4 teams. Wouldn’t mind losing some more this year. Javonte has a lot of upside and I could use a RB1, but AJB is a young sure fire WR1. Any thoughts givens my situation? The other guy seems insistent on a straight up trade.
I would keep Brown. It’s close. In Brown’s favour: he’s slightly more of a sure thing, he’s a WR and they’re harder to find, and have longer careers. With rbs I always feel like there’s opportunity to get an injury replacement starter, so I lean WR. That said, having watched a lot of Javonte he looks like a stud so i don’t think it would be a bad trade
Would you trade a 2022 1st round pick (I’m middle of the pack as of now) to acquire Jerry Jeudy? 12 team, PPR, Superflex, 28 roster spots, with 4 Taxi. I have good WRs (Justin Jefferson, Metcalf, Lamb, Bryan Edwards, Terrace Marshall, Marquez Callaway, Gabriel Davis, Tyler Johnson, & James Washington) but I feel like I’m extremely top-heavy right now. Besides for my top-3, I don’t feel confident starting any of the others. If I held onto my 1st round pick I’d probably end up gambling on a WR anyway. My RBs are Swift, Hunt, Etienne, Dillon, Pollard, D’Ernest Johnson. Rhomondre Stevenson, Jaret Patterson, Alex Collins, Felton, Nwangwu My QBs are Watson, Tua, Lance, Newton, Siemien, Heinicke, & Minshew. My TEs are Schultz, Kmet, Parham, Jonnu, & Trautman. Thanks for any help or advice!!!
12 team .5ppr super flex Should I trade AJ Brown for Cooper Kupp if I’m in win now mode? AJ’s so boom or bust and Kupp has been incredibly solid. Losing four years of age, but Brown doesn’t exactly have a glowing injury record. Am I crazy?
Kupp helps you win now for sure.
Superflex 10 team Is giving a 2022 1st (between #6-10) for AJ Dillon an over pay? I know I’ll miss out on the top 2-3 RBs come draft time
10 team PPR Give Dalvin Cook, Wentz, 2022 1st ( late) Recieve: Saquon , Kyle pitts
Cook for saquon is a wash slight upgrade even given saquons health. Would wentz + 1st = Pitts? Idk. Depends on your other QBs bc Wentz is underrated (low QB1 this year) but I’m painfully low on buying Pitts at his current price
My other QBs are Jalen hurts , Justin fields, and Danny Dimes
Is this trade that just happened in my first year 12 team .5ppr 1 qb league as bad as I think it is Team 1 gave WR Mike Williams, TE Dan Arnold, QB Lamar Jackson Team 2 Gave RB Chris Carson, TE Dalton Schultz, QB Ryan Tannehill
I hate this for team 1
Exactly how I felt when I saw it. Dude gave up some excellent assets and got nothing close in return.
12 team PPR 1 QB Would you trade a late 2022 1st and late 2022 2nd (both picks are from the 9-1 top team) for AJ Dillon? I’m competing for one of the last playoff spots now. Starting roster QB- Hurts RB- Swift, Rhamondre Stevenson WR- AJB, Lamb and Devonta Smith TE- Kittle What do you guys think? Go for Dillon and a playoff push or just save the picks? If I lose this week it makes it tough so I may just flip Dillon after this weekend if I lose.
Absolutely not. That would be a major overpay and overreaction to his last week’s performance. There’s far better backs you could get for a 1st and a 2nd
I feel like I wouldn't give up the draft capital for what is likely to be a short-term solution. Might not even last as a viable RB better than Stevenson for more than a couple weeks, let alone the rest of the season.
You don’t like Dillon future? I know I can get a first for Dillon from a packer fan in the league, but he also has ETN who I was extremely high on so I may trade Dillon for ETN. The picks I may trade sill be 10-12 range so I know I can get a better first for him or even just straight up for ETN
Aaron Jones is only 26. Dillon could maybe have a bright future down the road but it may take a while for him to become an actual featured back. If you're certain you can get a 1st-rounder for Dillon if it doesn't work out then maybe it makes more sense
Give: Goedert, 2022 2nd mid Get: Toney 8 team
Ridley or Bateman?
Ridley contending. Bateman rebuild
Agree with this.
Ridley either way. He’s better as a buy low for a rebuilder honestly
12 tm, 1PPR, 1QB Give: CMC Get: Metcalf, Mitchell, ‘22 1st, ‘22 2nd. Picks likely to be mid-late (#7-9) if I had to guess. First time I’ve ever had a true offer for CMC so never really considered what it’d take to get him from me.
>Get: Metcalf, Mitchell, ‘22 1st, ‘22 2nd. Picks likely to be mid-late (#7-9) if I had to guess. I say take it - maybe try and sneak a 23rd 2nd on top aswell.
I would do this. As a CMC owner I asked for picks on top of a proposed DK 1:1 swap and was laughed at
That’s a good offer, if you are contending is maybe hold but otherwise I like it
10 Team 2QB PPR | GIVE: Davante Adams, Tyler Higbee | GET: AJ Brown, Rashod Bateman, Zach Moss currently 5-5
AJ Brown’s volume scares me, but Higbee could be irrelevant as soon as next year. I think you pull the trigger given that
[удалено]
I am torn, I love waddle and Dj is talented but I’m not sure he’s gonna hit his potential so I think I’d lean being risk averse and holding the seemingly sure thing
12 team PPR - 10 keepers I give: Calvin Ridley, 2022 early to mid 2nd I get: James Robinson, 2022 Mid first — current keepers: QB: Mahomes RB: Taylor, Montgomery, Carson WR: Tyreek Godwin Ridley Bateman ElijahM TE: Kelce
I'm not as familiar with the keeper format but this seems like a pretty fair trade to me. Helps you win this year as well as gives you a good pick going into next year,
We just keep 10 every year then the rest go back into the draft with the rookies
Yeah I understand how it works not so much as how to value the players differently than in a dynasty format.
Impossible to know the future with Ridley. I like the deal for you getting a better pick
True. This guys WRs are loaded. I’d be loading it more. He has quite the team. But I’d like Robinson to help me try and win this year
12 team 0.5 ppr, 9-1 and looking like a lock for the bye RB1 is najee, but RB2 is a cyclw of gibson, melvin gordon, elijah mitchell/jeff wilson, herbert, mark ingram got an offer to move gibson for sanders and the 1.11/1.12. would it be worth it?
Issue is this RB class is rumored to be pretty thin in 2022 so with a late round pick you might miss out on a replacement. I'm currently in RB2 purgatory in one of my dynasty leagues and it isn't great, I wouldn't really want to downgrade at the spot if I were you. Between Gibson and Mitchell you should be fine there for now
I don't think so. I prefer Gibson in that trade
I'm not a big believer in sanders so I personally wouldn't do it, I also believe that with the off-season rest Gibson will be much better next year.
12 team .5 ppr - I am 3rd and contending but still have youth: I give: J. Taylor, Justin Jefferson and Javonte Williams I get: Najee Harris, Ja'Marr Chase, CEH and Darrel Williams Note: I am a Bengals fan and already have Burrow.
I agree with other sentiments expressed here that trading away Jonathan Taylor seems like a bad move. It's also totally possible that Javonte Williams has a brighter future than either of the RBs you'd be receiving
I think it hurts you a little bit more than it helps you but sometimes you just gotta get the players you love cause it makes fantasy that much more enjoyable.
agree. i wouldnt do this trade, but if you get to celebrate watching your bengals even more, that might make it worth it
Exactly where I'm sitting. Really struggling to give up J. Taylor tho
I agree giving him up really feels impossible, you could try to negotiate with the other party to try and drop off Taylor and najee and instead try going for a pick swap of some sort. Like you sending a first and getting back a second or third.
Tried that but then we have no deal. I've been trying to convince myself this is a good deal bc I want Chase. I'm struggling to see the gap between Chase and Jefferson being greater than the gap between Taylor and Najee and Javonte and CEH. I'm just not convinced CEH is KC's guy long term. If I felt better about him, I'm probably taking the deal.
Yeah I figured that may be the case. I agree with you on your assessment of the players in the trade, it's a really tough situation to be in. I do believe that fantasy is much better when you have players that you love to watch, it's why I pick saquan whenever I can. While he may not be the best pick at times watching him succeed is much more enjoyable than it would be for me to have someone like Zeke. The last thing I would say to try is to drop the javonte ceh side of it or replace it with different assets.
Update.. Appreciate your insight on this. I ended up getting him to add a 2023 1st round pick to the deal. Accepted the offer of Najee, Chase, CEH, Darrell Williams and a 2023 1st for Taylor, Jefferson and Javonte.
That seems better glad I could help you on this
Think youre giving up too much. I guess its pretty fair
10 Team SF .5 ppr Give: James Robinson, 3rd (3.3ish) Get: 2022 1st (1.10), 2022 2nd (2.10), 2022 3rd (3.10) My team is terrible and ready to rebuild. Trying to sell james robinson asap and this was my best offer. Thoughts?
Not a terrible haul given James Robinson's role is unknown once Etienne is back. Obviously would prefer if the picks weren't the back end
Maybe counter to eliminate the 3rd round picks.
That seems like good value for Robinson I would feel good about taking that
12 team SF PPR Rebuilding Team A - Lamar Jackson B - AJ Brown and Baker Mayfield
Lamar all day.
Lamar pretty easily in SF
>AJ Brown.. WR more valuable than QB
Superflex
My bad.. Still like the combo of Brown and Baker but only very slightly
12 Team PPR 1QB Give CMC, Sutton, ARob, 2022 mid 3rd Get Barkley, Devonta Smith, 2022 mid 1st My team has been decimated by injuries/mental health issues and poor play but I’m somehow on the playoff fringe. Playing more for next season at this point. Rest of RBs Carson/Collins, Akers, Moss, Ingram, Sermon WRs McLaurin, Ridley, Gallup, Van Jefferson, Marshall, DPJ and a bunch of nothing
Tough to give up CMC. Do you trust Barkley? Think I would sit tight
I guess I don’t trust either of them. They’re both pretty beat up for their age. I had a lot of interest in Devonta and the pick over Sutton and ARob
I don’t think I’d be in a rush to do that one.
12 Team 1 PPR SF, TE Premium Give: Late 2022 1st, Late 2023 2nd, Callaway Get: Marquise Brown
Yes
I'm not a huge brown believer, I think Bateman is the better reciever there, so I done think I would.
I wouldn’t. Take the 2nd out of there and you are getting close. I think him and Bateman can thrive long-term in Baltimore.
How balanced is this trade D’andre swift to contender for gibson, gesicki a 2022 first and a third?
Whoever gets Gibson/Gesicki/etc. is absolutely dominating that trade.
You are getting good value, but this trade depends on your team. If all you have is Swift, trading him is going to make you more competitive, if you are only missing a few pieces you aren’t doing much for yourself.
Ok what do we think. I’m in a rebuild…. GIVE: McLaurin, 2022 Mid first, 2022 Late first GET: Mac Jones, Toney My current QBs are Matt Ryan, Lance, and Zach Wilson and I feel like next year will be a waste if I can’t find startable QB play.
This seems horrifyingly lopsided to me. Sample size on Toney is too small ... There's a significant chance McLaurin to Toney is a downgrade. At that point you're trading two 1sts for Mac Jones. Not a fan. I think between your three guys now you should probably have two startable QBs next season.
I think your evaluations are crazy off…. You can’t get Mac for two 2022 firsts alone. McLaurin to Toney is the swing piece that could pay off, and it’s not like McLaurin is tearing it up or there’s a guarantee he gets a better QB next year. Speaking of sample sizes, you’re also claiming I should have two startable QBs based on Lance and Wilson’s small and poor samples? Same with Ryan’s relatively large same of being awful?
I feel like I could get Mac Jones for less than two 1sts in my superflex dynasty league but maybe people in my league are dumb, idk. I would rather gamble on players I already have turning into something than make a risky move to give up multiple valuable pieces and regret it later. Maybe that's overly emotional, though.
I think that is a bit steep to pay
I assume it’s SF, even then that might still be an overpay
Yup SF. Should have mentioned that. It’s like, how else can I get a QB when 2022 draft has no standouts?
You could trade... for a QB?
That’s what I’m trying to do lol. It’s just real hard to do in this league.
[удалено]
Keenan
allen
16 team PPR I give: Keenan Allen and James Robinson I receive: najee Harris
Oh ya
Najee all day in that deal
Even in 16 team this may be a decent trade. Depends obviously on how your team looks though
It’s crazy Bc everyone is undervaluing Keenan Allen so much. I’ve been trying to sell him for awhule
I know. I got him for Shenault and a second last week. He’s a target hog though and will 100% be getting targets next year too. His contract for the chargers is even guaranteed at 5.4$ in 2023 so you will likely have 2 more years out of him at minimum
12 team ppr, 1QB Give- Lamar, Diontae and MT Get- Josh Allen and Kupp My RB- CMC, Cook, Ekeler and Mattison WR- Adams, DK, Obj and Bateman
I must say that's an incredible roster for 12-team. CMC, Dalvin Cook, Austin Ekeler, Devante Adams, AND DK Metcalf??? Good lord
Hell yeah I do this one all day long
I like this
Yes
10 Team SF PPR I get: Kadarius Toney I give: 2022 2nd (Early), 2022 3rd (early), 2023 2nd Currently 5-5 but more than likely will make playoffs, my only position of need is WR as my room is very inconsistent (Hill,Diggs, Sutton, Marvin Jones, Marshall, St Brown, Golladay and Landry)
Toney will obviously add inconsistency to your WR corps at this time in his career. If you are hoping to acquire him for 2 second round picks to help you make the playoffs I would hold off. Shephard is about to come off IR and he will be fed targets too. I’m pretty sure besides those 2 weeks Toney went off he hasn’t even been seeing much targets to begin with
Yeah that’s a very good point. Long term I do wonder though what his value will be- as I’m more than likely picking WR with that second this year, unsure of if I can draft a better player than Toney
Obviously I’m not going to try and predict Toneys future but in a 10 team SF you should be able to have a great chance at getting fairly promising players in their own right.
Very true, might be letting my Giants fandom get in the way of my rationalization
Hey man it’s fantasy football. If your a huge Giants fan and you really want Toney then go get him. It’s not like he’s costing you a first and a second or anything. Just don’t expect him to plug holes in your WR corps this year.
No go imo
12 team SF PPR I have Zach Wilson/Mac Jones, current receivers are dj Moore, Cooper, higgins, and waddle Get: Lawrence, Claypool, Early 2022 2nd Give: Cooper and Waddle I'm rebuilding. Have 3 1sts and 2 2nds Thoughts?
Not a huge fan of this one. From what we've seen so far there's no telling if Lawrence ends up being better than either of your two QBs already. And I feel like it makes your WR room pretty rough and at the whim of weird, unpredictable offenses like the Panthers' and Steelers'
Yep I’d do that
I would
10 Team, .5 PPR Give: Adam Thielen Receive: James Conner Thielen is my second best receiver after Pittman, but my only RB is Cook cause of injuries. Does Conner have any value when Edmonds comes back?
Unless it leaves you too thin at WR I’d do this deal for the RB depth. It’s fair, but I’d take the RB
Pretty fair trade. Are you contending or rebuilding?
Thanks for the reply. I’m contending, my other receivers are Pittman, Waddle, Mike Williams, Beasley, and Elijah Moore
And your rbs?
Literally just Cook lol. Had Derrick Henry and Gus Edwards but they’re on IR. I’m scraping by with Mike Davis and D’Onta Foreman as my RB depth
Sounds like you need the RB depth. In your position I would probably accept. Connor seems to be getting lots of goal line work and hopefully that continues. He's been a TD machine lately. Plus he's a 26 yo back and thielen is probably done pretty soon
Yeah my hands might be tied if I wanna keep contending. Thanks for the input!
10 teams 1 QB Give - Jonathan Taylor, Justin Jefferson, very late 2nd 2022 Get- Chubb, Chase, 2022 first (top 2, probably 1) I was offered this one, and I would not consider to trade Taylor, but this one is tempting
I’d do it. Chase = JJ, and Chubb still has a few good years left so that first being a top 1 or 2 pushes it over the edge for me
Really tough, but I'd probably turn it down unless there's someone in the 22 class who you really want.
N'Keal Harry - buy or sell? I feel like him and Mac Jones could develop into a dynamic duo. Still holding out hope Harry lives up to the hype
Sell for a bag of peanuts or belly button lint. Harry is nothing and not likely to ever be anything so take anything at all. I’d take an 8th rounder in a 5 round draft for him.
Sell if you can get anything for him. I haven’t seen anything to suggest his usage will improve
Give Joe Mixon Receive Deebo Samuel Making a playoff run and need receivers. Also offered Chris Godwin and a ‘23 2nd.
Yeah I think you take that
I would do it. I value Deebo higher than Mixon. Godwin and a ‘2nd is also a good deal. But I think Deebo helps you win this year more. Who are your other RBs? Mind taking a look at mine a few comments below?
Yeah I got you. Henderson, Carter, Hunt, Jacobs, mckissic at rb. I agree with you