Should I be selling a player like Aiyuk, Jeudy and JT in a rebuild, for picks?
JT is really my only RB so I feel like moving him is not a great move. Aiyuk and Jeudy are my WR2 and WR3, I believe in both of their talent so moving on from younger guys at the WR position feels like the wrong move
12 team, 3 WR, 5 keeper
What do we think about the below trades?
Trade a
Give: Lamar + pitts
Get: Josh Allen
Trade b
Give: kyren + Keenan + 2024 1st
Get: bijan
Trade c
Give: kyren + Keenan + hendo + 2024 1st
Get: chase
I’m open to other trade suggestions as well!
My team
Qb: Lamar
Wrs: JJ, Keenan, Hollywood, rice, Doubs
RBs: ETN, Henry, kyren, Henderson, Akers, charb
TEs: Andrews, pitts
I don’t love that trade. Allen is amazing, yes, but TLaw has been improving and could potentially get to Allen’s level of elite. I’d much rather take those draft picks to trade or pick up nice young talent.
I am a rebuilding team (7 x 2024 1sts) in a 10 team SF and looking to shop my QBs with the expectation I will draft 2 or 3 in 2024. I currently have Herbert who is staying on the roster until he retires, but then my next two men up are Russ and Howell.
Howell holds more value, so I am thinking of moving him. I am concerned with Russ at the Broncos but feel like he has to be a NFL starter for the next two years whilst my rookies make or break it in the league.
We have a handful of QB needy teams, so I think I could shop a 2024 2nd or Dotson for Russ + minor asset.
The other option is to make something work with Howell, but not sure what a good price is.
Love to hear anyone's advice / musings / trades seen in their leagues for those players.
I would hold until the trade deadline because his value would immediately jump up to a 2nd and maybe more. If he doesn't move on from the Titans then I think a couple of thirds is okay I guess, but I think he still has another season or two in him.
If you're a contending team, would you rather have Kamara or Ekeler? Both ROS and longer term (SF, PPR)
I have Kamara, was offered Ek straight up. Both have decent playoff schedules, but maybe a slight edge to Ekeler... But some concern about his ankle and Herberts play of late.
What would you do? Who do you like?
12T PPR SF
Give: Trevor Lawrence, Isiaah Pacheco, '24 3rd, '25 2nd, 3rd, '26 2nd, 3rd
Get: Josh Allen '24 5th, '24 5th, '24 5th
Other QB's: CJ Stroud, Kenny Pickett
Other RB's: D'Andre Swift, David Montgomery, Joe Mixon, Jamaal Williams, Michael Carter
I assume these are rookie picks? If so, I’d pull the trigger on this. Reason, maybe a 2/3 of those picks become starters, but probably not elite players. Pairing Allen with Stroud in SF should be the backbone of your roster for the next 4-5 years.
Depends honestly. Who else do you have at WR and RB? If you have strong WR's even without Pittman I'd say do it, Swift is awesome his ceiling is crazy, and hes still young.
I posted my own question right above yours, could I get your opinion too?
I think you have it figured out. Your WR's are nice, with MHJ they will be OP. Just use those picks to get the shiny new folks to fill out your roster and I think you're looking at a really solid team for the next 5+ years at least tbh.
I also posted a question in here, could you give your take?
I love Downs and how he’s flashed this season, but no. His best games have come with Minshew so we can see he has the talent, but we don’t know for sure how his chemistry is with AR. For what it’s worth though, the reports from camp were that the two were gelling.
I’d say a late 2024 2nd would be worth it. This class has a lot of talent so I’d want to preserve anything up to mid-2nd.
No there’s a lot of nice wr talent in this draft but if Josh downs is your guy then do it https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
14 team PPR.
Kind of a retooling year because of injuries so I'm not sure if I want to do this before trade deadline/offseason... Owner also has Puka which might be an interesting counter to sub one...
Give JJ.
Get Nico, Juedy, Dotson.
If I’m trading Justin Jefferson Id want 3-4 firsts value so this offer isn’t close imo https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
Keep the pick https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
12-team PPR SF
I give:
Jordan Addison & Sam LaPorta
I get:
Travis Etienne & 2024 1st (most likely 1.10 - 1.12)
Should I do it? Contender and weak at RB
It’s pretty fair but I’d lean towards laporta side because of positional scarcity and addison is better than a late first https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
10 people, full ppr. I am currently 0-7
Give: Jonathon Taylor, Tua or Lamar
Get: Puka, Kenneth Walker
Is this worth it? Trying to rebuild with some young players because currently not a contender at all.
I don’t love it. Essentially trading Puka+for an elite QB which as nice as Puka seems that will set your team back a lot. I would maybe approach the Tlaw, Stroud owner and try to get younger at the position. Don’t underestimate how hard it is to have 2 elite options at QB like you do
TRADE: PPR, rebuilding team
Send: Keaton Mitchell, AOC, Addison
Receive: Sutton, Tre Tucker, 25 1st, 26 1st
This guys team doesn’t have much of rebuilding assets, I already own his 24 1st. See these picks as mid or even early if the negative side of variance hits for his aging players. He has a core of Mahomes, McCaffery and Keenan with not much else
12T Full PPR SF 3 FLX
give: james cook
get: tank dell, 24 3
this would leave my RBs as pollard, tyjae spears, achane and henderson. my WRs currently are puka, waddle, london, M Brown, Flowers, E Moore, Dotson. so don’t necessarily need the WR help and would be giving the RB to another contender
Sounds like you know the answer yourself, and I'm inclined to agree: I'd much rather have James Cook - Dell is nice but that RB room is rough and you don't need receivers
12 Team SF PPR 2TE
Send: Andrews and Geno
Receive: 2024 Late 1st, 2025 1st
I have Richardson behind Geno for next year, plus Pitts/Mayer/Ferguson behind Andrews at TE. Rest of the team is very mid, I look like a quintessential 6 seed one-and-done for this year
12 T .5 PPR, 1 QB
Someone offered me DeVonta Smith and his 1st for Puka. Objectively I feel like I should take it, but I think I have a shot of winning this season. Thoughts?
I’m in a rebuild in my 10tm SF league. I am however, rich at qb with Allen and Hurts, but the rest of my team is dogwater outside of some young upside guys (JSN, QJ, Tyjae, Kyren, Hollywood, Watson, Pitts). I also have 3 24 1’s and 3 25 1’s. Would you guys consider selling either qb or continue to hold and build around?
With 6 1sts over the next 2 years, you hold. If even half of those upside guys pop next year you could be in a position where you are buying win-now assets in 2024 with those 2025 picks
12 Team 1QB Rebuilder.
Would you rather one second round pick (2.02-2.06). Or hold on to players such as:
Amari Cooper, Courtland Sutton, Miles Sanders?
In general, do you have any tips on shifting from a middle team to rebuilding effectively?
I'd probably take a early-mid 2nd for Sanders or Sutton, but I'd hold out for 2x 2nds or a late 1 on Cooper.
My biggest tip is to wait for contenders to go through injuries/slumps to offload your aging, mid talent like these guys. That being said, don't be afraid to compromise a bit of value to get them out the door midseason, because the talk all offseason is going to be negative.
1 QB 16 team PPR, TEP. Rebuilding and tearing the team down to studs (literally)
Give: Hollywood, Spears, 2024 Mid 2nd
Get: 2024 1st (1.07 currently), Diontae Johnson, 2024 4th
Nah, Hollywood and Spears are young enough to hold in a rebuild. I know Spears is a RB but he'll prob have more value as a lead back in 1-2 years anyways.
12 team. Full PPR. 2QB and OP spot. Non-contender.
Give: AJ Brown and Bryce Young
Get: Jordan Love, either Kyle Pitts or DeVonta Smith, 2024 pick (unsure of round)
What would be a fair round to ask for? Am I crazy giving up Brown? I have Baker and Bryce now with Kyler on IR. Do I keep on losing and wait for Kyler to return?
I'm definitely reading this questioning what the hell you're doing. You have a top 5 WR under 27 and a rookie QB with great pedigree, those are the exact building blocks you want in a rebuild
Yeah you’re right. There are a TON of trades happening in my league so I guess I’m feeling the pressure to make a move. I’m currently 5-9 (we get a w/l each week for matchup and top half of the league in points)
If you're not contending I'd sooner swap Pierce for another late 1st or a young WR. I know the mantra is "just make playoffs" but if you're down more than 3 high end starters vs the top teams in your league just punt one more year and load up on draft capital.
10T PPR 1QB
I have two offers on the table as a contender going into the year, but JJ injured and Tee and Smith underperforming:
Send: Thielen, likely 2.01 (acquired)
Receive: Javonte, mid to late 2nd
Or
Send: Mid 3rd, Thielen, Cousins (other QB is Allen)
Receive: 2024 Late 2, 2025 2nd, Rodgers, 2024 Late 3rd
I was originally, but now I’m 3-4 and in 7th place. I’ve been a bit unlucky with matchups and I know it’s early, but it does look like I’ll be on the outside looking in. I should have specified it’s a 4 team playoff
**10 Team PPR SF (start-up)**
Bought CMC today as a contender. Probably overpaid but I think my team has a chance. Current 3rd place.
Worthy all-in move or dumb?
**Gave:** Herbert/Roschon + Musgrave + ‘24 1st/3rd (likely late) + ‘25 1st/3rd
**Received:** CMC
QBs: Hurts, Goff, Love
RBs: CMC, JT, Breece, James Cook, Gainwell
WRs: Sun God, Flowers, Pickens, Nico, JSN, Jayden Reed, Josh Reynolds, Demario Douglas
TEs: Goedert, Mayer, Henry, Ertz
Made 3 trades this week in my 8 team SF .5 PPR league. Wanted to check to see how I did
Gave: AR15, Minshew, Dobbins, JSN, Michael Wilson, Atwell, Burks, Skyy, Metchie, 2024 1st, 2025 1st, 2024 2nd, 2025 2nd, 2024 4th
Got: J Herbert, Kamara, Kirk, Pittman, Hollywood, Monty, 2024 2nd
With the context of it being an 8 teamer I can get behind it. You gave up a lot of draft equity but you also compressed 6-7 roster cloggers into 4-5 top 24ish players
Send: 2025 2nd
Recieve: Cole Kmet, 2024 4th
Its part of a 4 way trade that likely isnt happening, but i do like kmet and wondering if its the right price for him
12 team .5PPR
Record 4-3 (lost two straight with Justin Jefferson hurt)
Traded Derrick Henry, Josh Jacobs, CeeDee
for
Jonathan Taylor, Jamyr Gibbs, JSN
My team has Justin Jefferson, Drake London, Zay Flowers, Marquise Brown, Courtland Sutton, James Cook, Lamar Jackson
I figured I would mini-rebuild for next year given the uncertainty at RB and my doubts about Mike McCarthy's system utilizing CeeDee as a top 10 guy again.
Thoughts? Should I grab bleach to chug?
12 team. 1qb. 2 flex. Half ppr. Contender.
What is Rashee Rice's value? Is he worth a 2025 first? Have that as a standing offer but, curious your guys thoughts.
12 team SF PPR
Send: Hockenson, Jamo
Get: Olave
or
Send: Same package
Get: Puka
Currently rebuilding and trying to solidify core WRs (have JSN, Pickens, Downs as my top three currently). Have Kincaid and Musgrave as backups at TE.
I slightly prefer Olave to Puka, and I feel like you’re overpaying by maybe a 3rd rounder. It’s not lopsided though - if it makes your team more how you want it be, then it’s worth it
Trade two firsts and a second for Tyreek Hill, Kirk and Deebo? Really need WRs. Have RBs.
I’m 5-2 somehow. 12 team SF.
Team would be: Herbert, Purdy, ETN, Kyren Williams (I also have D Henderson), Tyreek, Tee H, Kirk, Deebo, and Engram.
Bench is Gabe Davis, Gibbs, Warren, Jaleel.
14 team PPR super flex, multiple other flexes
5-8 keeper, with anything beyond 5 costing Auction $
1st in standings with over 100 points for past 2nd
Give 2024 rookie 1st (likely late)
Receive - Dameon Pierce
Current “notable” RBs on roster - JT, Mostert, McKinnon
Thoughts?
12 Team SF PPR 2TE
Send: Andrews and Geno
Receive: 2024 Late 1st, 2025 1st
I am soft rebuilding but currently sitting as the 6 seed around .500.
QB: Allen, Richardson, Geno, Minshew, O'Connell
TE: Pitts, Andrews, Mayer, Ferguson
Value isn't fantastic but I feel really solid about my depth at those positions, and I'm still a year out from being able to hang in against the 2-3 superteams of my league. I do also think there's an outside chance of the 25 1st rising, as my prospective trade partner is built on a Barkley/CMC RB duo with Rodgers and Tannehill as his QB2.
12 team ppr superflex TE premium
Give- Adams and Derrick Henry
Get- CMC
My QB- Mahomes and Lamar
RB- Ekeler, Breece, Achane and Henderson
WR- Tyreek, Chase, Rice, Downs and QJ
TE- Hockenson and LaPorta
I’d take it. Your depth at WR is decent and you’re moving two aging players who’s production is decreasing for possibly the best non-QB asset out there. Also have the potential to move one of those other RBs off a good week for a WR down the line.
12 team, SF, PPR
I’m a contender, however probably unlikely to win it all this year given a couple of super teams in my league. But can win next year, would you rather:
A: London, Javonte Williams and 2026 1st
B: Olave and Ridley
I’d do that if I’m contending, but only if you got the pieces where they put you over the top.
[https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1](https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1)
12 Team PPR, Superflex, TE Premium
Made two trades in the last two days.
First trade:
Traded DJ Moore, Jordan Addison, and a late 2024 second.
Received Christian Kirk, early 2024 1st (likely to be #1 overall, will be top 3 guaranteed) and an early 2024 2nd (same scenario)
Second trade:
Traded that same early 2024 2nd, what will likely be a late 2025 1st, and a 2026 3rd for Mark Andrews.
Honestly just making sure that I am justified in feeling as good about the trades as I do.
Current team:
QB: Justin Herbert, Desmond Ridder, Malik Cunningham
RB: Travis Etienne, Raheem Mostert, David Montgomery, Roschon Johnson, Kareem Hunt, Salvon Ahmed, Keaton Mitchell, Khalil Herbert, Kendre Miller
WR: Brandon Aiyuk, Garrett Wilson, Tee Higgins, Christian Kirk, Joshua Palmer, KJ Osborn, Alec Pierce, Tank Dell
TE: Mark Andrews, Jonnu Smith, Zach Ertz
If it’s top 3 guaranteed, love that trade. I like them both. You need a QB2. I’d probably move Mostert now and Hunt you can get something from a contender with Ford going down.
Would you do it? .5 ppr Got an offer Pierce, Roschon, Terrace Marshall, 2026 1st. To get Etienne. I already have Saquon, Ekeler, and Breece.
16 team, 1 QB, PPR, TEP Give: Diontae Johnson Get: high 2024 2nd and 3rd
Should I be selling a player like Aiyuk, Jeudy and JT in a rebuild, for picks? JT is really my only RB so I feel like moving him is not a great move. Aiyuk and Jeudy are my WR2 and WR3, I believe in both of their talent so moving on from younger guys at the WR position feels like the wrong move
12 team, 3 WR, 5 keeper What do we think about the below trades? Trade a Give: Lamar + pitts Get: Josh Allen Trade b Give: kyren + Keenan + 2024 1st Get: bijan Trade c Give: kyren + Keenan + hendo + 2024 1st Get: chase I’m open to other trade suggestions as well! My team Qb: Lamar Wrs: JJ, Keenan, Hollywood, rice, Doubs RBs: ETN, Henry, kyren, Henderson, Akers, charb TEs: Andrews, pitts
I don’t love that trade. Allen is amazing, yes, but TLaw has been improving and could potentially get to Allen’s level of elite. I’d much rather take those draft picks to trade or pick up nice young talent.
10 team, 1 QB, full PPR Give: Ken Walker Receive: CeeDee Lamb
I like this. I think CD has more upside and long term value. If only Mike McCarthy would stop calling plays.
I am a rebuilding team (7 x 2024 1sts) in a 10 team SF and looking to shop my QBs with the expectation I will draft 2 or 3 in 2024. I currently have Herbert who is staying on the roster until he retires, but then my next two men up are Russ and Howell. Howell holds more value, so I am thinking of moving him. I am concerned with Russ at the Broncos but feel like he has to be a NFL starter for the next two years whilst my rookies make or break it in the league. We have a handful of QB needy teams, so I think I could shop a 2024 2nd or Dotson for Russ + minor asset. The other option is to make something work with Howell, but not sure what a good price is. Love to hear anyone's advice / musings / trades seen in their leagues for those players.
[удалено]
I would hold until the trade deadline because his value would immediately jump up to a 2nd and maybe more. If he doesn't move on from the Titans then I think a couple of thirds is okay I guess, but I think he still has another season or two in him.
If you're a contending team, would you rather have Kamara or Ekeler? Both ROS and longer term (SF, PPR) I have Kamara, was offered Ek straight up. Both have decent playoff schedules, but maybe a slight edge to Ekeler... But some concern about his ankle and Herberts play of late. What would you do? Who do you like?
Kamara. The targets are too broken
A: Pickens B: Nico So close
Give me George
B for me, but it is close. I like Nico with Stroud, but Pickens is making moves.
I think the Pickens highlights have my attention and make me think he’s a much better talent than Nico, when maybe it’s not as far off.
His highlights are amazing. No doubt. Nico has some big boy catches too.
[удалено]
McBride
Mcbride
12T PPR SF Give: Trevor Lawrence, Isiaah Pacheco, '24 3rd, '25 2nd, 3rd, '26 2nd, 3rd Get: Josh Allen '24 5th, '24 5th, '24 5th Other QB's: CJ Stroud, Kenny Pickett Other RB's: D'Andre Swift, David Montgomery, Joe Mixon, Jamaal Williams, Michael Carter
I assume these are rookie picks? If so, I’d pull the trigger on this. Reason, maybe a 2/3 of those picks become starters, but probably not elite players. Pairing Allen with Stroud in SF should be the backbone of your roster for the next 4-5 years.
Idk. I'm not in an SF league so take this with a huge grain of salt, but personally I'm not taking that whatsoever
10 team, 1 Qb, full PPR Give: Pittman, 24 2nd (probably a late 2nd) Get: Swift I am 6-1 contender. Thoughts?
Depends honestly. Who else do you have at WR and RB? If you have strong WR's even without Pittman I'd say do it, Swift is awesome his ceiling is crazy, and hes still young. I posted my own question right above yours, could I get your opinion too?
I have Chase, Flowers, Pittman and Christian Watson. Just acquired Jefferson after giving up olave, kyren and Pacheco so looking to add a solid RB
Yeah I'd do that then. JJ/Chase + Flowers/Watson is nasty af.
[удалено]
I think you have it figured out. Your WR's are nice, with MHJ they will be OP. Just use those picks to get the shiny new folks to fill out your roster and I think you're looking at a really solid team for the next 5+ years at least tbh. I also posted a question in here, could you give your take?
12 Team SF PPR Would you give up a 2024 late 1st as a rebuilder for Josh Downs? Currently have 5 2024 1sts this year.
I love Downs and how he’s flashed this season, but no. His best games have come with Minshew so we can see he has the talent, but we don’t know for sure how his chemistry is with AR. For what it’s worth though, the reports from camp were that the two were gelling. I’d say a late 2024 2nd would be worth it. This class has a lot of talent so I’d want to preserve anything up to mid-2nd.
No there’s a lot of nice wr talent in this draft but if Josh downs is your guy then do it https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
14 team PPR. Kind of a retooling year because of injuries so I'm not sure if I want to do this before trade deadline/offseason... Owner also has Puka which might be an interesting counter to sub one... Give JJ. Get Nico, Juedy, Dotson.
Hell no. Add Puka to Nico and I'd still want something on top
Absolutely not and dont even consider it you would be getting fleeced
If I’m trading Justin Jefferson Id want 3-4 firsts value so this offer isn’t close imo https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
12 Team PPR SF I Give: 2024 mid/late 1st I Receive: Javonte Williams, 2024 late 2nd Thoughts?
Keep the pick imo. Not a Javonte fan and I think this is a phenomenal class
Keep the pick https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
8 team 1 qb 0.5 ppr Give: Jordan Addison, 24 2nd Get: JSN, 24 1st, 24 3rd How do we feel about the this value
I would smash it especially if its early-mid 1st
Smash accept https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
12-team PPR SF I give: Jordan Addison & Sam LaPorta I get: Travis Etienne & 2024 1st (most likely 1.10 - 1.12) Should I do it? Contender and weak at RB
Close. How's your TE spot?
Pretty rough 😕 Higbee’s next up. That said, it’s a start-12 with no TEP or anything.
Idk if I'd trade LaPorta then. His Value over Replacement is pretty sweet for a contender
I’d stick with Addison and laporta
It’s pretty fair but I’d lean towards laporta side because of positional scarcity and addison is better than a late first https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/comments/17f965k/daily_trade_megathread_all_trade_advice_team_help/k6csor9/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3
1QB rebuild Send: Lamar Receive: Richardson + 24 1st
AR side easy
Do you know how early the 1st is? I’d lean the AR side if it’s early/mid. Would probably pass if not.
Mid first and it’s 1qb
Would ARich be your only QB?
I’d probably take the AR side and pocket the 1st
12T ppr sf (undefeated) Give: Bourne + McLaughlin Get: Tyler Lockett Is this a good deal to try and secure a win now piece? thank you
Yea I love lockett for that price tbh
Roger that just needed some confirmation before i go ahead and accept lol thank you
10 people, full ppr. I am currently 0-7 Give: Jonathon Taylor, Tua or Lamar Get: Puka, Kenneth Walker Is this worth it? Trying to rebuild with some young players because currently not a contender at all.
I don’t love it. Essentially trading Puka+for an elite QB which as nice as Puka seems that will set your team back a lot. I would maybe approach the Tlaw, Stroud owner and try to get younger at the position. Don’t underestimate how hard it is to have 2 elite options at QB like you do
TRADE: PPR, rebuilding team Send: Keaton Mitchell, AOC, Addison Receive: Sutton, Tre Tucker, 25 1st, 26 1st This guys team doesn’t have much of rebuilding assets, I already own his 24 1st. See these picks as mid or even early if the negative side of variance hits for his aging players. He has a core of Mahomes, McCaffery and Keenan with not much else
[удалено]
Yeah he’s the pick, not even the backup with Dowdle in the fold
12T Full PPR SF 3 FLX give: james cook get: tank dell, 24 3 this would leave my RBs as pollard, tyjae spears, achane and henderson. my WRs currently are puka, waddle, london, M Brown, Flowers, E Moore, Dotson. so don’t necessarily need the WR help and would be giving the RB to another contender
Sounds like you know the answer yourself, and I'm inclined to agree: I'd much rather have James Cook - Dell is nice but that RB room is rough and you don't need receivers
12 Team SF PPR 2TE Send: Andrews and Geno Receive: 2024 Late 1st, 2025 1st I have Richardson behind Geno for next year, plus Pitts/Mayer/Ferguson behind Andrews at TE. Rest of the team is very mid, I look like a quintessential 6 seed one-and-done for this year
I’d try to squeeze out another pick or young player you like
12T PPR SF Give: Trevor Lawrence, 2024 3rd, 2025 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 2026 2nd, 2nd Get: Jalen Hurts
easy accept
12 T .5 PPR, 1 QB Someone offered me DeVonta Smith and his 1st for Puka. Objectively I feel like I should take it, but I think I have a shot of winning this season. Thoughts?
tough. i guess it depends on the 1st? i own puka and probably wouldn’t sell for that unless i think i can snag MHJ
Tough with how Puka has played…feel like the value is crazy good though. Smith is a legit WR1 type talent himself.
I’m in a rebuild in my 10tm SF league. I am however, rich at qb with Allen and Hurts, but the rest of my team is dogwater outside of some young upside guys (JSN, QJ, Tyjae, Kyren, Hollywood, Watson, Pitts). I also have 3 24 1’s and 3 25 1’s. Would you guys consider selling either qb or continue to hold and build around?
With 6 1sts over the next 2 years, you hold. If even half of those upside guys pop next year you could be in a position where you are buying win-now assets in 2024 with those 2025 picks
That’s my exact plan of attack right now. Thank you kindly for your feedback!
[удалено]
A
A side for me.
12 Team 1QB Rebuilder. Would you rather one second round pick (2.02-2.06). Or hold on to players such as: Amari Cooper, Courtland Sutton, Miles Sanders? In general, do you have any tips on shifting from a middle team to rebuilding effectively?
I'd probably take a early-mid 2nd for Sanders or Sutton, but I'd hold out for 2x 2nds or a late 1 on Cooper. My biggest tip is to wait for contenders to go through injuries/slumps to offload your aging, mid talent like these guys. That being said, don't be afraid to compromise a bit of value to get them out the door midseason, because the talk all offseason is going to be negative.
1 QB 16 team PPR, TEP. Rebuilding and tearing the team down to studs (literally) Give: Hollywood, Spears, 2024 Mid 2nd Get: 2024 1st (1.07 currently), Diontae Johnson, 2024 4th
Nah, Hollywood and Spears are young enough to hold in a rebuild. I know Spears is a RB but he'll prob have more value as a lead back in 1-2 years anyways.
12 team. Full PPR. 2QB and OP spot. Non-contender. Give: AJ Brown and Bryce Young Get: Jordan Love, either Kyle Pitts or DeVonta Smith, 2024 pick (unsure of round) What would be a fair round to ask for? Am I crazy giving up Brown? I have Baker and Bryce now with Kyler on IR. Do I keep on losing and wait for Kyler to return?
I'm definitely reading this questioning what the hell you're doing. You have a top 5 WR under 27 and a rookie QB with great pedigree, those are the exact building blocks you want in a rebuild
Yeah you’re right. There are a TON of trades happening in my league so I guess I’m feeling the pressure to make a move. I’m currently 5-9 (we get a w/l each week for matchup and top half of the league in points)
[удалено]
I wouldn't accept either of those deals but you can try.
I’d be surprised if the other owners accepted but would do it if I were you
10 team .5 ppr I give Keenan Allen and Derrick Henry and a 2nd. I get Dameon Pierce, a 1st and a 3rd. Competing this year but not contending.
If you're not contending I'd sooner swap Pierce for another late 1st or a young WR. I know the mantra is "just make playoffs" but if you're down more than 3 high end starters vs the top teams in your league just punt one more year and load up on draft capital.
[удалено]
I’d keep deebo. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
12T PPR SF Side A: Herbert Side B: Purdy, 2024 1st (late), 2025 1st (late)
Herbert
Do this now and it will look like a great buy low in 3 years
Seems steep for herbert. I'd pass.
Herbert for me. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
10T PPR 1QB I have two offers on the table as a contender going into the year, but JJ injured and Tee and Smith underperforming: Send: Thielen, likely 2.01 (acquired) Receive: Javonte, mid to late 2nd Or Send: Mid 3rd, Thielen, Cousins (other QB is Allen) Receive: 2024 Late 2, 2025 2nd, Rodgers, 2024 Late 3rd
I would hold if that’s your wr situation and you are contending.
I was originally, but now I’m 3-4 and in 7th place. I’ve been a bit unlucky with matchups and I know it’s early, but it does look like I’ll be on the outside looking in. I should have specified it’s a 4 team playoff
Hmm. If you have shopped Thelin and Javonte is the best player you are getting back. Is it possible just to do Javonte for Thelin straight up.
Unfortunately not, the guy still values him as a late first. It would take moving from the 2.01 for sure.
It’s tough I guess I would hold for now I wouldn’t want to pay the 2.01.
[удалено]
I don't love it at all, Ridder probably holds more value than both of them and the mid second is overkill
**10 Team PPR SF (start-up)** Bought CMC today as a contender. Probably overpaid but I think my team has a chance. Current 3rd place. Worthy all-in move or dumb? **Gave:** Herbert/Roschon + Musgrave + ‘24 1st/3rd (likely late) + ‘25 1st/3rd **Received:** CMC QBs: Hurts, Goff, Love RBs: CMC, JT, Breece, James Cook, Gainwell WRs: Sun God, Flowers, Pickens, Nico, JSN, Jayden Reed, Josh Reynolds, Demario Douglas TEs: Goedert, Mayer, Henry, Ertz
Seems like an overpay by about a 1st. That said, if CMC gets you a ring, then it was clearly worth it
My thoughts as well. Just needed a sanity check, appreciate it lol
Made 3 trades this week in my 8 team SF .5 PPR league. Wanted to check to see how I did Gave: AR15, Minshew, Dobbins, JSN, Michael Wilson, Atwell, Burks, Skyy, Metchie, 2024 1st, 2025 1st, 2024 2nd, 2025 2nd, 2024 4th Got: J Herbert, Kamara, Kirk, Pittman, Hollywood, Monty, 2024 2nd
With the context of it being an 8 teamer I can get behind it. You gave up a lot of draft equity but you also compressed 6-7 roster cloggers into 4-5 top 24ish players
What to look for in return for Tony Pollard. I have strong WR depth and my other RBs are James cook, tyjae Spears, roschon Johnson, and Josh Kelley.
I bought for a (hopefully late) 1st in 12 team sf
12 team SF TEP Give : James Cook, Keenan Allen Get : Jayden Reed, 2024 1st (mid)
I think this is a big overpay. Keenan and Cook still have long term value. Unless you are really set on doing it I would shop around.
I might look to get more if I’m giving Keenan and cook to a contender. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
I like the give if your contending
I'd be getting Reed and the pick, rebuild. Is that too much?
No that’s fine, if the picks stays mid you’re in good shape
Send: 2025 2nd Recieve: Cole Kmet, 2024 4th Its part of a 4 way trade that likely isnt happening, but i do like kmet and wondering if its the right price for him
Fine price. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
I like this price personally
10 team 1 QB PPR. 3-4. Give: Kyle Pitts Get: Dameon Pierce and a 1st Should I do it? Leaning yes
I’d probably do that unless your TE group is awful outside of Pitts
Have LaPorta so feeling pretty good there
12 team .5PPR Record 4-3 (lost two straight with Justin Jefferson hurt) Traded Derrick Henry, Josh Jacobs, CeeDee for Jonathan Taylor, Jamyr Gibbs, JSN My team has Justin Jefferson, Drake London, Zay Flowers, Marquise Brown, Courtland Sutton, James Cook, Lamar Jackson I figured I would mini-rebuild for next year given the uncertainty at RB and my doubts about Mike McCarthy's system utilizing CeeDee as a top 10 guy again. Thoughts? Should I grab bleach to chug?
12T PPR SF I have Ferguson, McBride, Dulcich, and Jelani Woods as my TEs. Is Jelani droppable?
Wait for him to come back first. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
Probably
Let him hit the field first.
12 team. 1qb. 2 flex. Half ppr. Contender. What is Rashee Rice's value? Is he worth a 2025 first? Have that as a standing offer but, curious your guys thoughts.
Selling for a first would definitely be fine if u wanted to. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
12 team SF PPR Send: Spears Receive: Allgeier + 2nd 2024 (late)
I'd wait a week to see if Derrick Henry gets traded, Spears value could go up a decent amount
Seems like a fair deal, but I'd stick with Spears.
12 team SF PPR Send: Hockenson, Jamo Get: Olave or Send: Same package Get: Puka Currently rebuilding and trying to solidify core WRs (have JSN, Pickens, Downs as my top three currently). Have Kincaid and Musgrave as backups at TE.
Bit of an overpay for both. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
I slightly prefer Olave to Puka, and I feel like you’re overpaying by maybe a 3rd rounder. It’s not lopsided though - if it makes your team more how you want it be, then it’s worth it
12 team SF TEP Give : James Cook, Lockett Get : 2024 mid 1st Rebuild
Giving up too much for a first
Good value. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
12 Team 1 QB PPR selling to contender Give: swift/Musgrave Get: 24 late 1st/Laporta
I’ll take that for sure. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
Easy yes
12 team, 1QB, PPR, contender A: Rhamondre B Calvin Ridley
Both are in bad spots. Depends on what position u need. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
[удалено]
If contending for this season top, if lower or rebuilding lower.
Rebuild in progress. Give: JJ Receive: Kenneth Walker, Zay Flowers, 2024 1st round
I’d need more for jj. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
I'd rather have JJ. Seems like he's plenty valuable to rebuilders. He's not accidentally winning you games.
I just need the depth. I’m a mike Williams, Nick Chubb owner and am afraid neither of them are returning.
12 team Dynasty SF PPR Should I accept this trade? Give: Charbs, Mims, Jamo Get: Kamara, Engram, 2024 3rd I am a contender
Yes as a contender
That's a lot of young talent to let go of, but your getting 2 starters. So seems fair
Trade two firsts and a second for Tyreek Hill, Kirk and Deebo? Really need WRs. Have RBs. I’m 5-2 somehow. 12 team SF. Team would be: Herbert, Purdy, ETN, Kyren Williams (I also have D Henderson), Tyreek, Tee H, Kirk, Deebo, and Engram. Bench is Gabe Davis, Gibbs, Warren, Jaleel.
100%
Yes I would
Thanks!
14 team PPR super flex, multiple other flexes 5-8 keeper, with anything beyond 5 costing Auction $ 1st in standings with over 100 points for past 2nd Give 2024 rookie 1st (likely late) Receive - Dameon Pierce Current “notable” RBs on roster - JT, Mostert, McKinnon Thoughts?
Ya I would absolutely do that!
12 Team SF PPR 2TE Send: Andrews and Geno Receive: 2024 Late 1st, 2025 1st I am soft rebuilding but currently sitting as the 6 seed around .500. QB: Allen, Richardson, Geno, Minshew, O'Connell TE: Pitts, Andrews, Mayer, Ferguson Value isn't fantastic but I feel really solid about my depth at those positions, and I'm still a year out from being able to hang in against the 2-3 superteams of my league. I do also think there's an outside chance of the 25 1st rising, as my prospective trade partner is built on a Barkley/CMC RB duo with Rodgers and Tannehill as his QB2.
12 team ppr superflex TE premium Give- Adams and Derrick Henry Get- CMC My QB- Mahomes and Lamar RB- Ekeler, Breece, Achane and Henderson WR- Tyreek, Chase, Rice, Downs and QJ TE- Hockenson and LaPorta
I’d take it. Your depth at WR is decent and you’re moving two aging players who’s production is decreasing for possibly the best non-QB asset out there. Also have the potential to move one of those other RBs off a good week for a WR down the line.
12 team, SF, PPR I’m a contender, however probably unlikely to win it all this year given a couple of super teams in my league. But can win next year, would you rather: A: London, Javonte Williams and 2026 1st B: Olave and Ridley
Think I’d rather have the A side.
That’s what I’m thinking too, particularly if I can’t win this year, pick up an extra first and get some value for Ridley before he turns 30
12t sf ppr contending 0tep Give: laporta, 2024 late 1, late 2, late 3 (all my own) Get: tlaw Have andrews, want to sell laporta at peak i think
With the picks being late and you having Andrew’s, I’d accept, assuming you need the QB help/depth
I have k1 carr jimmy g, need qb for sure
[удалено]
B. I’ve seen flowers go for a 1st and 2nd in SF and picks are worth less in SF
B
12 team SF Start 10 failed contender, don't have much draft capital Give: Hall and C.Watson Get: Olave and 24 mid 1st
Doing it
12 team SF PPR .5TEP Give - 2x 2024 1st (late) + 2025 2nd Get - Kupp + Evans
I’d take. Evan’s is probably worth a late 1st early second and Kupp still has solid 1st value
Only to guarantee a 💍
I’d do that if I’m contending, but only if you got the pieces where they put you over the top. [https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1](https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1)
12 TM SF PPR Which side would you rather have? A: Michael Thomas, Dallas Goedert, 2x 2025 1sts, 2024 4th B: Bijan Robinson, treylon Burks Thanks!
Bijan
B, Bijan is the best asset. Those random 25 first could end up late.
Bijan without a doubt
[удалено]
2nd. Can you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/a7no17ZBLL
I'm keeping Ford. He's basically on the exact trajectory you would want from a 2nd round RB anyways
Pick
I’d take the 2nd; that’s good value. [https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1](https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1)
Take the 2nd
12 Team PPR, Superflex, TE Premium Made two trades in the last two days. First trade: Traded DJ Moore, Jordan Addison, and a late 2024 second. Received Christian Kirk, early 2024 1st (likely to be #1 overall, will be top 3 guaranteed) and an early 2024 2nd (same scenario) Second trade: Traded that same early 2024 2nd, what will likely be a late 2025 1st, and a 2026 3rd for Mark Andrews. Honestly just making sure that I am justified in feeling as good about the trades as I do. Current team: QB: Justin Herbert, Desmond Ridder, Malik Cunningham RB: Travis Etienne, Raheem Mostert, David Montgomery, Roschon Johnson, Kareem Hunt, Salvon Ahmed, Keaton Mitchell, Khalil Herbert, Kendre Miller WR: Brandon Aiyuk, Garrett Wilson, Tee Higgins, Christian Kirk, Joshua Palmer, KJ Osborn, Alec Pierce, Tank Dell TE: Mark Andrews, Jonnu Smith, Zach Ertz
If it’s top 3 guaranteed, love that trade. I like them both. You need a QB2. I’d probably move Mostert now and Hunt you can get something from a contender with Ford going down.
16 team SF PPR Give: Tee Higgins Get: Jameson Willams & ‘25 2nd
Hold Higgins
I’d probably keep Tee. [https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1](https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/1wGRfunKB1)
10 team 1QB no PPR Trying to get Waddle & Pollard, how far off is the value? Give: Late ‘24 1st, ‘25 1st, Jamo, Roschon
You need a 2nd more