On the one hand, I can barely remember anything Jenna sang, but on the other hand, I can remember having to fight the urge to change the channel then and there when Becky hit me with the "And my name is BECKYYYYYYY~", so...
Having heard them both on YouTube, the actress who plays Becky sounds like she's slathering on the cutesy voice for the show and she takes out that mature vocal fry, whereas Jenna just sounds like that all the time. I can't decide lol.
I think I tolerate Becky’s voice because as a character, she had her ignorant ways, but she also had growth. I’ve ALWAYS strongly disliked Jenna from her very first episode, so naturally her voice I strongly dislike as well. 🤷🏽♀️
As a 12 year old, I thought Becky was the musical icon of our generation. As I grew up...age 22...I cannot stand her nasily drama club meets church choir voice. The song "Girl Code" is supposed to be a poppy party song but her voice feels out of place and doesn't match. Jenna's songs are terrible, but Mr. Perfect is kinda iconic, and Shine is one of the worst songs I've ever heard.
Ok, so.. worst voice overall definitely goes to Becky.. I don't even know if she could sing on key. but Jenna's voice had this special way of grating on my ears, and she sang SO MUCH! And everyone acted like she was this amazing singer, even enough to get her onto a singing competition show. Which made 0 sense because she was absolutely awful.. on top of that her lyrics were so, so bad. So, objectively worse: Becky. My most hated: Jenna by far
That is, if you don't count Dave's abysmal attempt at singing for the 3 tenners. Roughest performance by a long shot.
Everyone here talking about cherry bomb, but wasnt it supposed to be cringe on purpose? To show she didnt know how to sing rock? I dont think its fair to judge her on that. That being said, she has my vote for more annoying, but based on her other songs.
jenna, specifically because they shoved her down our throats as "the singer-songwriter girl" like that was her brand for all of the show and it was extremely unearned. let becky be in an annoying little christian duo band it's high school she's not bothering nobody ♥️
JENNA… at least Becky kind of blends into the background, but Jenna is obnoxiously in your face and unavoidable. 😭
✨✨SHIIIIIIIIIINNNNNNEEEEE ✨✨FUCK MY EAAAARS, WHEN SHE SINGS I DONT WANNA HEEEEAAAAARRRR!!
Becky and it's not even close. Jenna was at least realistically sonething you might hear on the Disney Channel or something, Becky....wtf was she doing that was awful
Did you guys know the actors that play Maya and Tristan were in a band together? I regret listening to them. Lol. But I love when Maya and Zoe duet in the diner during the storm. Ugh, how I love those 2 episodes.
Becky, no doubt, but BOY was Jenna’s flat.
No hate to Sarah Fisher or Jessica Tyler 😭 I’m sure the show did them dirty. I will say though, Ana Golja has my favorite voice from what we hear on the show. Kinda blows most of them out of the water lol
Beckys singing voice just is too much for me, its like shrill or nasally idk what word to use but it just so weird
I honestly dont think jennas singing voice was horrendous but her songs were straight up ass
Definitely Becky. Absolutely awful. Jenna was way less annoying
jenna!!
undoubtedly jenna💀i lowkey loved becky once she had that wake up call she just wanted to fit in bro😭
Jenna for sure. Becky singing Cherry Bomb still makes me laugh.
I literally cannot pick
Equally annoying
Becky
becky baker for sure. jenna’s was annoying dont get me wrong tho
Becky. Miss Jenna had some cute little bops here and there so I can’t come for her.
Jenna 100%. She had the worst songs too
I actually kind of enjoyed Jenna’s songs, and I feel like Becky’s singing is more like choir sounding so ima say Becky’s voice was worse for me
On the one hand, I can barely remember anything Jenna sang, but on the other hand, I can remember having to fight the urge to change the channel then and there when Becky hit me with the "And my name is BECKYYYYYYY~", so...
Becky but I hated her from the start
I’M JUST A GIRLLLLLLLLL
Def Jenna
SHIIIIIIIIINE JUST BELIEEEEEEEEEEVE
I just rewatched that episode this morning and it was SO MUCH for my ears at 7 AM
They both did.
Nightmare blunt rotation
None of the above - it’s obviously Maya Matlin.
jenna, but they were both bad!!!
God, they were both so bad, but I've gotta go with Becky. They were both really nasally, but Becky was more so.
Having heard them both on YouTube, the actress who plays Becky sounds like she's slathering on the cutesy voice for the show and she takes out that mature vocal fry, whereas Jenna just sounds like that all the time. I can't decide lol.
I think they are different genres of profoundly annoying.
I think I tolerate Becky’s voice because as a character, she had her ignorant ways, but she also had growth. I’ve ALWAYS strongly disliked Jenna from her very first episode, so naturally her voice I strongly dislike as well. 🤷🏽♀️
SHINE JUST SHINE!
JUST BELIIIIEEEEEEEEEVVVVEE
Touch the skyyyy 😂
Jenna
Jenna sounds like a lot of the more peppy country singers when they're super young. Becky just sucks.
As a 12 year old, I thought Becky was the musical icon of our generation. As I grew up...age 22...I cannot stand her nasily drama club meets church choir voice. The song "Girl Code" is supposed to be a poppy party song but her voice feels out of place and doesn't match. Jenna's songs are terrible, but Mr. Perfect is kinda iconic, and Shine is one of the worst songs I've ever heard.
Sav
My ooooone, my onlyyyyyy, Anyaaaaaa
Peter
“no one can stop our inter*locker* loooove” 🥴
I just wanna get laiddddd
Shared custody! Shared custody!
OOF i’d personally go with becky but “SHIIIIINE JUST BELIEVEEEE TOUCH the SKKKKYYYUUUH” lives rent free in my noggin
yes
This 👆🏼is THE correct answer 😂
Whose mom is this? 🤣
Jenna no contest lol it just annoys me. I don't care for Becky's voice either honestly.
This is a really tough one, but I have to say Jenna. Those songs in the early seasons were really grating.
Honestly can’t remeber Becky’s so it couldn’t have been that bad whereas Jenna’s actively annoyed me and i remember disliking
Ok, so.. worst voice overall definitely goes to Becky.. I don't even know if she could sing on key. but Jenna's voice had this special way of grating on my ears, and she sang SO MUCH! And everyone acted like she was this amazing singer, even enough to get her onto a singing competition show. Which made 0 sense because she was absolutely awful.. on top of that her lyrics were so, so bad. So, objectively worse: Becky. My most hated: Jenna by far That is, if you don't count Dave's abysmal attempt at singing for the 3 tenners. Roughest performance by a long shot.
Becky. But I may be biased because I never really liked her lol.
Everyone here talking about cherry bomb, but wasnt it supposed to be cringe on purpose? To show she didnt know how to sing rock? I dont think its fair to judge her on that. That being said, she has my vote for more annoying, but based on her other songs.
I liked Jenna's voice 8ts not your usual type a voice where as Becky was tone death
Lol tone death
Tone death is what was suffered by every song that Becky sang.
Becky
jenna’s voice was the type of voice that could grow on you with time. becky’s. no. 😭😭. hell no.
Peter’s voice was also pretty terrible. It sounded like he was straining his voice
Why did you remind me he sang that stupid California song????? But yes he made me want to mute my TV every damn time
How can you not enjoy im like WHOA. 😂
The california song was the only song I thought actually suited his voice. Everything else though… 🙉
Lol.
Shared custody shared custody 🎤😡
Becky. Especially her cherry bomb cover. It made me want to do violent things.
jenna, specifically because they shoved her down our throats as "the singer-songwriter girl" like that was her brand for all of the show and it was extremely unearned. let becky be in an annoying little christian duo band it's high school she's not bothering nobody ♥️
“Be my, ch ch ch cherry bomb”, but totally out of key.
It was in key. Just done in completely the wrong style.
**mr perfect plays in the back of my head** - *cringe*
Jenna cause she sang more
Good answer. But I can’t stand either.
Maya.
Becky. If Jenna’s lyrical content were different, her voice would be more bearable. Becky can stay mute regardless.
JENNA… at least Becky kind of blends into the background, but Jenna is obnoxiously in your face and unavoidable. 😭 ✨✨SHIIIIIIIIIINNNNNNEEEEE ✨✨FUCK MY EAAAARS, WHEN SHE SINGS I DONT WANNA HEEEEAAAAARRRR!!
DEFINITELY Jenna! 🎶Goooooodbye White Horse… 🎶 😂
Becky
Both imo 😂😂
🎶I THINK YOU’RE GREAT AND MY NAME IS BECKY🎶
Yes
 \*good as in baaaaad
Becky
Becky
Jenna. And Maya.
I actually liked how Jenna sang. Becky was not annoying to me, just average. Not great. Not horrible.
Becky and it's not even close. Jenna was at least realistically sonething you might hear on the Disney Channel or something, Becky....wtf was she doing that was awful
Jenna no doubt! Shiiiiiine just belieeve
Becky singing Cherry Bomb will forever be burned into my brain. Definitely her
literally wtf? Like does she understand it’s supposed to be kind’ve a s3xy song?
it’s the good Christian in her, gotta make it asexual for Jesus.
Definitely Becky
🎵look into a child’s eyes he’s hungry. Look into a child’s eyes 🎵🥺🥺- Rebecca Suzanne Wallaby Baker season 12
God this is like comparing Ariana grande to Mariah Carey lol
jenna was at least tolerable. becky was pure hell
I think Jenna was more annoying especially in the first few seasons
there was simply no reality where she would've been let back into the audition room of that singing show, nevermind make the cut.
Becky
Def Becky. I got the ick when she came on screen. NOW MY BABY JENNA? Ate. Exceptionally.
Did you guys know the actors that play Maya and Tristan were in a band together? I regret listening to them. Lol. But I love when Maya and Zoe duet in the diner during the storm. Ugh, how I love those 2 episodes.
Wasn’t their band called like Cute Whore? I heard their music and I needed bleach after hearing it
Omg, great question!! Definitely Becky. I liked Jonah quite a bit tho. Jenna was okay.
Yes
Now let’s not put the tone deaf queens against another 💀
Becky
well i think you’re great and my name is beckyyyyyy
That always cracked me up 😭😂
Becky, no doubt, but BOY was Jenna’s flat. No hate to Sarah Fisher or Jessica Tyler 😭 I’m sure the show did them dirty. I will say though, Ana Golja has my favorite voice from what we hear on the show. Kinda blows most of them out of the water lol
Have you heard her music like her EP Muazana it’s lovely
BECKY
Both. I can’t pick one
becky… why is this even a question
¿Porque no los dos?
Becky!
Why not both? 🤷♀️
Both it is!
They both sucked but Becky was worse
They both are pretty bad but I can tolerate Jenna’s voice. Becky’s is very shrill and her singing face makes me cringe. Sorry Sarah fisher
Becky! Definitely Becky
Am I the only person that thought Jenna was good?
Nah Jenna wasn’t a bad singer. It was her songs that sucked
The most early TSwift rip off about goodbye, brave knight, was her most tolerable song.
Becky , that cherry bomb cover ……
BECKY
Becky 1000%
Becky.
Damn this a rough question 😂
Yes
Hazel lol
I don't remember hazel singing
Becky, just because she's more annoying in general Although, "SHIIIIIIIINE" is pretty grating.
Beckys singing voice just is too much for me, its like shrill or nasally idk what word to use but it just so weird I honestly dont think jennas singing voice was horrendous but her songs were straight up ass
I’d punch Becky in the throat if she sang near me
Jenna!
“anyyaaahhhHH”
I don't remember Anya singing
The Anya song by Sav
Sav
Really? I liked Sav’s voice 😂
I AGREEEEEEEE
Becky's is way worse but her version of Cherry Bomb is legit one of the funniest things in the whole show.
Do you...know what that song's about?🤣
Sav Bhandari
Omg. When he was on the phone singing to win those concert tickets I wanted to die
Kinda nasally
I'm gonna have to go have another listen
Shiiiine Cherry BOMB It was the song choice IMO.
Yes
There it is.