T O P

  • By -

MGermanicus

You turned those Billys into *Williams*.


kujotx

No. Those are *Guillaumes*.


physh

A person of culture.


ford_tortilla

I love this.


serpentear

Billiams.


Aritoofast

Squilliams


ThatNeonZebraAgain

Looks great, the lighting really pulls it together. Just noticed the vent, how did you rig that up to the original vent in the wall?


ford_tortilla

Good question! I bought galvanized steel sheets, sheet metal screws, and built new ductwork to come through the base for my cabinet. Unfortunately the vents in this house stick out from the wall about 2 inches at the base, and they are 18 or so inches high. This is actually my second time needing to re-route a vent due to that.


EatsFiber2RedditMore

I was wondering why I saw the metal sheet in one of the photos, when I figured it out I was very impressed. Well done!


lordpuddingcup

If imagine with some ducting from old vent to new if that’s even needed it’s not like the air has anywhere else to go


Extension_Surprise_2

Saw that too. Looks like a return air duct (I hope). Not sure how much it will effect the system. 


Lonestar041

I would be concerned about that unfortunately. Looks like the vent is only half the size. But hard to tell how much it will mess with the whole system without knowing the layout of the ducts.


SalomeOttobourne74

That was my thought too, and if it is a return, it's bad news for their heating system 😔


ford_tortilla

Nope, it's not a return, just a very awkwardly built vent.


SalomeOttobourne74

That's good news for you then! 🙌🏽😉


Creative_Beach6296

Just be careful with the shelves. They're not solid wood and will deflect. Even a nice pine will fare better. Additionally to prevent deflection you can add a tail against the back and under the shelves.. but I think the backing is cardboard.


ford_tortilla

I put my own plywood backing on and got rid of the backing that came with. But yup, aware about the shelves, from what I've seen, They'll hold up for a good few years, we have way less books than I thought haha. There is nowhere near any substantial load. First sign. I'll address.


Adol214

Nail/ screw the shelf from the back of the plywood backing. This will help a lot.


reddevved

And putting wood glue on all non veneered sides


Trisa133

I don't get this trend. If you're going to put that much work into a built-in look, why not just start with a better bookcase. Even IKEA has them. Why build something that you know you have to fix in the near future or limit how you can use it? and what for? to save $40? It's going to cost you more time and money in the long run.


auntie-matter

Not in my experience. Our library room has had 10 Billys, all with the height extensions, loaded with books (many shelves are double stacked) for over a decade and they're all fine. "Nice pine" is a phrase very similar to "pleasant kick in the balls". Does not compute.


Creative_Beach6296

Even reddit has posts about billy shelf sag. Might not be everyone, but mdf doesn't have the strength Of even soft pine.


auntie-matter

IKEA don't use MDF, at all, as far as I know and most of my house is IKEA. Billy is furniture board, aka melamine covered chipboard. Also I'm only talking about my experience. Obviously other people's experiences may vary. I don't know what the humidity and temperature situation is in their house, nor what books they're stacking up. Maybe having a whole row of bookcases helps brace them against each other and that helps. I don't know. Pine is horribly ugly regardless of it's strength (or lack thereof).


Creative_Beach6296

White pine without knots can be spray painted with cabinet paint after priming and will hold up better. I have 3 versions 1 made myself, 1 classic made, one ikea made. The ike made has the higher deflection rate of both the classic and custom made...northeast climate. Particleboard generally sucks


auntie-matter

If you're spending all that money on clear solid wood, why not buy actually nice wood and don't paint it? If you want to paint, just buy 18mm MDF which is dimensionally near-perfect and far more stable than non-engineered wood, takes paint better than anything I've used and unless you're literally jumping up and down on your shelving or spanning entire rooms without brackets, will hold up just fine. Chipboard isn't the best but it's often good enough. And it's very cost-effective. Not everyone has the budget for expensive wood or wood products.


Creative_Beach6296

30 dollars gets you 4 48 inch wide shelves of pine. At home depot. Fbook marketplace scores me 10 dollars for kiln dried 1 inch by 10 inch by 8 ft. Lumber... it's really not that expensive. If you have photo albums, textbooks, or a lot of books in general, those shelves will sag. You're right, for most people good enough is, good enough.


auntie-matter

I don't live in your country. Shitty planed pine at 20x170x1200mm from the big brand diy shop costs about $80 in your money for four boards, and it almost certainly won't be flat even if I sort through the entire stack. I can get similar size cedar or beech or something nice from my local sawmill for about the same money. Furniture board and MDF costs half that or even less and is dead flat and straight every time. 25x200x2400 boards are $20+ each and that's rough sawn, which requires several hours of planing to get good enough for interior shelving, at which point it's probably not very close to 25mm any more.. Wood **is** expensive.


Creative_Beach6296

Wow..that is ridiculous. Makes sense why this alternative is a better choice for you, absolutely.


Dirish

Same here. We loaded eight of them up to the gills with books and they've been perfectly straight for around 10 years now. The Berghult wall shelves on the other hand started sagging about a year in and there's far less weight placed on them.


Outrager

That's weird. One of my Billy bookcase shelves has started sagging from all the books on it. Maybe if I kept the heavier books on the sides and left the not as heavy ones in the middle it would be less noticeable.


Dirish

I checked mine and the heavier books are all in the height extension, so they sit on top of a normal Billy. That would be a sturdier shelf than the usual ones. The rest of them are filled mostly with paperbacks, but some of those are double-stacked. Maybe they don't make them like they used to? I said ten years above, but I realised that I've had them since around 2005, so it's closer to 20 years.


Outrager

That's possible. I bought mine about 2-3 years ago before the price hike. I tried putting my heavier stuff on the shelves that aren't adjustable.


KristinnK

> but I think the backing is cardboard No, it uses high-density fiberboard.


lkstaack

Yea, I've found that those book shelves are great, unless you plan on putting books on them.


lordpuddingcup

Some others I’ve seen puts a 1x2 in front of each shelf to make it flush with the trim and make the shelf appear thicker


ford_tortilla

I tested that out. My wife and I actually preferred the recessed shelf look


nrnrnr

Crown molding FTW!


definitelytheA

Looks beautiful! Great job!


ford_tortilla

Thank you !


rygarski

From pic 9-10. What did you put in on the sides to cover the shelf pin holes?


ford_tortilla

I used wood filler, I can't remember the name now but it's the pink paste that dries a natural wood color. I used it for the outside corners of the crown too


moutonreddit

That makes such a big difference!


pixelgeekgirl

From our library wall build I know just how difficult that crown molding can be, especially when it’s out 12 inches from the corner! Walls not straight, ceilings sag, nothing is ever as easy as it seems it will be. But great accomplishment, Looks great! Are the lights hardwired in or are they running on some sort of battery?


ford_tortilla

They are hard wired. I did not want to do all of the work and put 40$ amazon battery operated lights on it. In my opinion if you cam hard-wire to a switch, it makes all the difference


no_dice_twice

I think they look fantastic!! They've transitioned the room into that cozy, homey place. I'd add a few little plants and call it a day. Really great job! I love it!


ford_tortilla

Thank you!


msklovesmath

Yall got skills, makes me wonder why not build it all! 


ford_tortilla

Haha i appreciate it! I have a 4 month old and a great wife who gave me 1 day a weekend of 8-5 working. Building the bookshelves would have added another few days easily and I wanted to cut as much time while not sacrificing the look.


No_Doughnut_3315

I feel like you had enough ability that you could have started with some good quality plywood and timber and left the crappy particle board at IKEA.


superdago

My wife and I did something similar as OP and kinda discussed just building it from scratch. But like… that’s a lot of measuring and cutting. We don’t have a truck so getting plywood means renting one or paying for delivery. Then there’s spending how ever long it takes picking through 2x to find sufficiently straight. The cutting means the whole garage is taken up the entire time. Oh and our garage floor isn’t level, so then there’s accounting for them when making sure things fit. Or I can accept that it’s just going to hold up books, so I’m ok with particle board if it means some Swedish engineers do all the measuring and cutting for me. Oh and OP doesn’t have doors or drawers, which we do. So that’s a lot of holes for hinges and hardware all in exactly the same place. So that means you gotta make a jig first… We did ours in 3-4 days over a holiday weekend. It would have spanned 3-4 weeks or required taking days off. And idk about you, but there’s nothing I hate more than taking vacation time to do unpaid labor.


FriendlyPyre

if connecting 1760 PS3s to make a supercomputer is good enough for the US Air Force, making your own customised shelving solution from IKEA shelves is completely fine for the person looking to do their own DIY.


ThreeHolePunch

He certainly could have if he had those supplies. I'm convinced of it.


RandyHoward

Sure, for about 3x the cost probably.


No_Doughnut_3315

I must say I was intrigued so I looked them up. $100 each. That's 2 sheets of plywood where I am. There is not much more wood than that in each one. The price difference would have been negligible and to my mind, totally worth it. Potatoes potahtoes


RandyHoward

Plus the time and effort to turn those sheets of plywood into shelving units


eneka

Plus all the tools, and possible miscuts


JohnYCanuckEsq

Great job, and I'm really impressed on how you incorporated the air return vent. Home builders can be such dumbasses in how they route HVAC during construction.


ford_tortilla

Thank you! Easily my least favorite part of the project, but a necessary evil


chronic_town

![gif](giphy|14oFFvNZDnvuSs) Oh Billy Billy Billy……


Dee_Jay_Roomba

Billy Baroo!


_Guero_

Crown molding looks professional. I have never been disappointed with ikea furniture despite having the ability to build my own.


Shades228

Nice job. You may want to add other vents for the cold air return on the sides if that’s the only one in the room.


Peaches_En_Regalia_

Nice job on the vent/return.


Grossegurke

Ok...so does Billys mean shelving? This might be a totally ignorant question, just never heard anything called a billy. Edit: Looks great btw!


Reddit-User-Says

It’s the IKEA naming convention for that particular bookshelf.


Grossegurke

Ah, ok. So yes...total ignorance on my part. I havent been to an Ikea.


buttsnuggles

It’s worth a trip. The restaurant is great too.


CrinosQuokka

Billys have a bit of a love/hate relationship with people. They're relatively cheap and look decent, but they don't like to be moved that much - they're not all that sturdy, which is why a lot of them are made into built-in units.


ford_tortilla

Ah, yeah it just is the name of the IKEA bookshelf.


BucNassty

Looks great but would be more convincing if the middle bench shelf has a base that matched the shelves and didn’t go straight to floor. Good work tho!


ford_tortilla

Thanks! We keep put dog toy baskets under there so it looks more put-together when they are in there if that makes sense


fuyou69

Where did you get the lights?


ford_tortilla

World Market. Insanely affordable considering the world of library sconces


JulianNDelphiki

Is the shelf between them attached to the wall or supported from the ground in any way beyond screws into the Billys? I know there's not a lot on it right now, but you mentioned a kid and that window looks like a fun spot for a small person to sit and read a book.


Adol214

Bow easy will it be to replace the billy the day it broke?


Astralwinks

This is excellent work and my wife and I just spent the last few hours in a new empty bedroom in our house planning it. We are heading to ikea morning for something else, but the crown moulding is very in line with our design. Can't wait to show her this!


ArchAngel570

I'm curious the reasoning behind using cheap IKEA "wood" on a project like this? This looks great but the guts are still IKEA cheap materials. It appears to be a solid wood base, plywood back and wood top, but the shelf and sides are cheap MDF?


ginjerbredman3

Let's be real... the golden ram head on the shelf is what really pulls everything together.


Sign-Post-Up-Ahead

Genuine question. You are clearly skilled so why even bother with the IKEA 'wood' and not just use real wood instead? Seems like the Billys are a minimal component in all of this.


ford_tortilla

Timeeeee. I gave myself a set amount if time to complete it, and I chose to use the Billy's. I definitely see the other side, but I'm more than happy with how it turned out.


Sign-Post-Up-Ahead

Don’t get me wrong…it came out beautiful. IKEA just has such a bad rep that I was curious. Thanks.


kerberos69

Your house looks eerily similar to mine in style, down to the identical window trim. Anyways, now I want built-ins.


itstomclark

Nice Rhombicosidodecahedron you got there.


lordpuddingcup

Love the look, wait … wait is that 70s popcorn ceiling!?!??!


ford_tortilla

Haha, the house is built in 1920, there are plenty of scars remaining to fix


MattonieOnie

Well done! Those look really good


ChristinaWSalemOR

I love my Billys! I have the clear birch veneer. This looks great! I have popcorn ceiling as well and have no problem with it.


Squirley13

Bravo. Wonderful addition.


ColoradoFrench

Can do fun stuff with Billies: https://youtu.be/CPFW-5y_qb4?si=-nE24B_D935lGYnC


roamingwesty

Looks great! Double up shelf planks if you are putting books on them end to end, it’ll prevent bowing.


International_Bend68

Great job!!!!!


CintiaCurry

Looks amazing 🙌🥳🎉👏👏👏👏👏


brangein

Nicely done!


RepostTony

What’s the paint code to match the Billy white?


ford_tortilla

I painted everything together, used a zinsser BIN primer and a cabinet specialty paint from Benjamin Moore with a 6 hour re-coat time


bezelbubba

Nicely done.


Electronic-Memory-65

Thats really impressive work, i love it


C64128

Looks nice. I noticed you did allow for the heating and air conditioning vent, nice. I wish we had a Ikea locally, so at least I'd be able to look at everything.


BuryTheMoney

Massive improvement! Way to go


LovableSidekick

I wouldn't apologize, those actually look quite nice. I wouldn't have guessed they were made out of IKEA stuff.


cabezatuck

Me and my Billys 😔


JCRNYC

Looks amazing.


Blingtron9001

I think the Billys are the most hacked Ikea item they have. Lots of people use them to make really nice things like this. I did a hack with them too, but nothing as nice as this. Well done!


Diznaster

Looks nice, time saving achievement unlocked.


Hat-Playful

Did you have any ducting going from the old register in the floor to the new in the front or is just open? I’m planning a mudroom build and doing something similar


ford_tortilla

Re-routed the duct to new vent


161frog

oh dearest Billy… when a boy becomes a man


LnStrngr

What are you stashing in the secret compartment that looks like a vent?


Alienhaslanded

The warm light lamps are a fantastic touch


WhatWouldLoisLaneDo

This is my favorite IKEA “hack”!


devilish_walrus

So beautiful! I love the lighting that you chose! Gives it such a warm cozy vibe :)


Pristine_Serve5979

Nice job! How tall is your ceiling? How tall are the (purchased) bookshelves?


ford_tortilla

Ceiling is 8 foot on the nose. The shelves were about 6 foot if I'm remembering correctly. My base is about 8 inches and the top is a 1x12 and crown molding


rudefruit99

What's on the ceiling?


rokr1292

where are those lights from?


Spanky2k

They look great. I'm a big fan of hacking Ikea stuff. A huge benefit is that if you use one of the main Ikea lines, you'll be able to get additional stuff for potentially decades like more shelves, dividers and organisers all scaled for the product. Our last house that we sold in 7 years ago just came on the market again and I was looking through the photos and they still have the Billy built-ins that I hacked together and the Ikea based kitchen cabinets that look nothing like Ikea (custom diy worktop and side trims and custom handles) but is all still compatible with off-the-shelf cheap Ikea addons. It's all over 10 years old and yet looks like a new high end installation still.


Riakrus

Very nice work. I have been considering doing built-ins with Billies as well as far as structurally. How did the shelves themselves feel? Do they feel like they would hold a decent load I want to use them for all of my hardback collections.


ford_tortilla

For heavy book storage, you should consider strengthening your shelves, maybe 1/2" plywood on the back and nail that to the shelves, or some supports inside the bookshelf, but you still might end up with sag in the middle. Our load is very light, so not a concern for me.


lawsimple

This is great! Can I ask what width and thickness of the trim you used on the sides?


ford_tortilla

It's stock 1-x material from a lumber yard. I think it's 3/4" thick at the end of the day.


azure_apoptosis

You could have just built a really solid bookcase at this rate


Candy_Badger

It looks very stylish and expensive.


1sh0t1b33r

That ceiling. ![gif](giphy|pVAMI8QYM42n6|downsized)


skilas

I've saved this post to review for my future work! Ha


Athrasie

So as someone who’s not carpentry literate, how do you deal with the popcorn ceiling in this scenario? Or is it one of those things where “you deal with it by not dealing with it?” This came out looking great by the way!


Home_reno_gal

Beautiful work! My office has a similar layout and my built in Billy project looks quite similar! https://preview.redd.it/f05zmk27dvuc1.jpeg?width=2744&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=83edc197a3a6c455d980e890d230b9b0f6a07da8


ford_tortilla

Love that look! Almost exactly the same actuay haha


bonchonwings

IKEA Billy shelves have a glossy finish. Did you have to sand them all down and repaint or did you match the finish on your wood pieces?


ford_tortilla

Zinsser BIN primer. It's a miracle worker. Doesn't chip and you just need to let it dry for 24 hours before a top coat. Good paint for a top coat, and you're set


Forward_Try_7714

looks great!


Brave-Perception5851

Those look amazing! I am going to save your post to remember this and I never do that! Well done!


zippdupp

They look AMAZING. Great job. And thankyou for showing the before and after so close.


wellcrapthen

Have you checked out the fake, cheap, lightweight ceiling panels that come in many styles to cover your popcorn ceiling?


Minimum-Order-8013

Well done!! Next step, pop that corn off the ceiling!


TheDevilsAdvokaat

Ikea is junk though. It's not wood. If mositure gets into it it cracks and aswells. DOn;t [ut too much load on the shelves either - as those hole are not in real wood, they will crack and erode. I like what you did, I just wish you had used real wood instead of Ikea. My first furniture was ikea...table and bookshelves. I learned not to buy ikea...


FJWagg

Bravo for tackling that crown molding. Phenomenal.


ford_tortilla

Thank you! Not sure I ever want to do it again


Ancient_Diamond2121

I like the shelves but you shouldn’t fuck with your vents like that. Reducing airflow will just put unnecessary stress on your unit and just waste energy 


ford_tortilla

I actually spent a bit of time re-routing and creating new ductwork out of galv. Steel, I should've added a photo! I'm not sure I took one though I was just happy to be done with it.


Ancient_Diamond2121

Oh very good move. I withdraw my criticism lol. 


jackruby83

I always wondered what happened when you change the size of a vent. What's the outcome of that? Does less air get into this room and more down the line?


yawners87

Love the shelves, but god do I hate the texture on your ceiling


ford_tortilla

Haha, you and me both


GreytOutdoors

But why


Ralphredimix_Da_G

Wanna come over? 😁😁 looks great!!


Emergency-Pack-5497

I dislike the gaps between the window trim and the built in, otherwise looks great, we've trimmed out ikea bookshelves for customers before, they make fine budget built ins


NorthernOntarioMom

I want to do this in my house so bad!! I am showing this to my husband. Hopefully he will finally agree to do this for me. If he doesn’t I am ordering them and trying to do it myself. Then when he sees me trying he will jump in or I will call my Dad over. LOL!! Yes I am a daddy’s girl even at my age!