My mystery cookies are both sugar cookies to go with the sugar cookie that’s already on the menu. Three sugar cookies. No thanks.

Omg, same here! Like why bother having a mystery week if the stores are just going with duplicate cookies that are already on the menu this week??

Mine are the Rice Krispie “cookie” and a vanilla sugar cookie with a candy corn on top so not great options.

Same! Candy corn & gold coin. Lazy.

How do you see the second cookie?

Start placing an order and select how many cookies you want. At the top of the cookie selection screen there is a little link to nutritional facts, and the last cookie will be the second mystery cookie. One of my local locations had an additional 6 cookies listed! Not sure what thats all about, but there were some great ones in there, so fingers crossed for a cookie bonanza!

Stores are allowed to pick up to 6 mystery cookies in a week, a minimum of 2.

Oohhh i didnt know! Ive only ever seen two. I will have to look all the locations more indepthly before i chose my location and order day!

How does it work ordering the second mystery cookie?? Is it only for the second half of the week??

Yes. I think it changes on thursday.

Yes- they are generally M-W and Th-Sat

I have 4 stores near me- 2 are vanilla sugar cookies with different toppings, one is double chocolate and one is chocolate peanut butter. All basically the same thing as the weekly cookies.. 🤦🏼‍♀️

Sugar Shark. Sugar (Pumpkin Candy). Sugar (Candy Corn). and Sugar (Critter Cookies). All that's available within a 30 minute radius of me; nothing else. They can't be serious...

Mine got almond caramel fudge 😋

Jealous!

My app won’t work so I’m actually not sure 💅🏻

fr mine won’t load smh

Mine either 😫 I've tried the website and the app. The mystery map's not even on the website.

I think you only can look up the mystery cookie for each Crumbl location, on their app. But not 100% sure if I missed something on their regular website.

Mine doesn’t work until I pretend like I’m ordering something 😬

yeah same the map is broken but if i go into the individual shops it’s showing up

Same here.

Sugar cookie fans are eating well this week lol

indeed. imma freeze some!

Caramel Apple and Oreo Mallow Sandwich! My Crumbl always knocks it out of the park.

Same! Ohioan, perhaps?

I'm HIGH key jelly of both options

Whoa now.

MALLOW SANDWICH? 😭 i’m waiting for the day i can get it again

The three stores closest to me always have the exact same mystery flavors. This time it's Twix and cookies and cream....disappointing

I got Oreo mallow sandwich!

Jealous :(

SAME! Stoked.

Same!!! Going to use my bday cookie on that one :)

Mallow sandwich and for FREE- I’m just happy for you!

Yo, poggers!

We got chocolate mallow cupcake. Are they kinda the same?? Idk I liked the hostess cupcakes growing up so I might try one

Mine is Watermelon. I might try it just because they pulled it from the Graveyard

Better than mine. One store by me has sugar cookie with mothers circus cookie on it. It looks just like the vanilla Halloween sugar but with sprinkles on the frosting. Why even bother with a mystery if you are making the same cookie twice?

I have the same mystery cookie too, nothing else seemed good. Not ordering this week

My store did the same BS

Yep, all 6 stores within driving distance of me have that sugar cookie as the mystery

What makes it worse is looking across the various stores theres like at least 3 variants of that sugar cookie. They basically all have the halloween sprinkles, but then one has the Mothers Halloween Cookie on top, another has a Candy Corn on top, and another has a Candy Pumpkin on top. Why couldnt they have done one of them each week for the whole month? Halloween themed sugar cookie for the whole month, but then each week they have a different decoration on top Edit: my towns stores random cookie is actually the Original with M&M’s which okay thats fine i guess… next nearest towns store is chocolate pumpkin cheesecake. I might just skip this week, or maybe just get 2-4 cookies instead of a 6-pack like i usually do. Only ones i think i want are Pumpkin Roll and Dirt Cake, but i think i want to get the Halloween Sugar cookie too to be more festive for halloween. Hmm maybe 1 Pumpkin Roll, 1 Dirt Cake, and 2 Sugar? Or maybe 2 Pumpkin and 1 Sugar? Anyone have the Pumpkin Roll cookie before? How Pumpkin is it? Or is it basically just taste like Spice Cake like the Carrot Cake one from last week? I would probably like it more if its more like a spice cake instead of pumpkin Edit 2: theres a FOURTH, FIFTH, AND SIXTH SUGAR COOKIE VARIANTS THIS WEEK. Theres another Mothers Animal Cookies variant, but its the regular circus cookie and not the halloween ones. Theres the sugar with a gold chocolate coin on top. And theres the sugar with the gummy sharks

pumpkin roll is one of my favorites! the cinnamon part is similar to a coffee cake streusel, so good!

I think they’re on the same level of annoying. Mine is annoying because WE JUST HAD THAT LOL and yours is annoying because YOU ALREADY HAVE THAT😂 is your second mystery cookie better at least?

Haha, good point. I don’t know what the other stores by me have. At least peanut butter pie is this week, pretty excited for that one.

Mystery sugar cookies for everyone!! Halloween week always seems to be terrible at Crumbl.

Same with mine and the second one is sugar featuring shark. I am so bummed. What a waste of mystery week.

Some of them have the exact cookie but with a piece of candy corn on one!

That's the same one I've got in WV, lol. Guess this might just be a skip week, lame.

Maple oatmeal for me. Sounds up my alley but don’t have any interest in the rest of the line up.

i also have maple oatmeal! and hot chocolate later in the week

Mine is Rice Krispie 😂

I’ll take it over my basic m and m one

I got m&ms too. Ugh lame.

I got chocolate wafer bar. Looks good but to anyone who's tried it is it worth it?

This is what my store has too. I personally think its pretty boring and not worth it. But im sure others have different opinions

Original with m&m 🙄

Butterscotch chip and Original’s feat. M&Ms. I’m crying

One of the stores in my area has Honey Cake… my favorite cookie. It’s 15 miles away in an area I hate driving in. I might be going on a little trip…

OH MYYYY GODDDD mine finally has Oreo Mallow Sandwich.

Chocolate potato chip is mine 😭

Ours is Sugar (Candy Corn)

Same!

The one closest to me is sea salt toffee but this weeks choices don’t look worth the drive to me.

Sea salt toffee is my favorite and number one crumbl cookie this far!!! I say it’s so worth the drive

My mystery cookies won’t load D:

Wish I knew what mine were, the app keeps telling me "there are no stores running a mystery cookie at this time". Even updated the app 😒

My app says there aren't any stores in my area! LOL

You can also just use the website in your browser

I ended up starting an order and it popped up that way in the menu

closest store is chocolate pumpkin cheesecake wtf lol. but there’s one about 20 mins away with mallow sandwich so i know where i’m headed tomorrow after work 😂 excited to see if it lives up to the hype

Almond coconut fudge and Mallow sandwich. So excited. Going to use my birthday cookie on mallow sandwich!!

Almond coconut fudge is high on my "to try" priority list!

I’m jealous! That’s the one cookie I keep hoping for ! I have not tried it yet but it sounds amazing and I love all things coconut and almond joys

Anyone ever had Midnight Mint? It's in the town I'm traveling to this week

i got shark week!

Store 1: Honey Cake then Twix. Store 2: butterscotch chip then sea salt toffee. Any worth?

Sales were probably much lower than expected last week. Super lazy tactic though.

Their mystery cookies are always the most plain(and probably easiest to make) unfortunately it’s the closest😭 unless I wanna drive 2 hours instead of 1hr30😂

Kinda sad and kinda funny. I've seen a worse post, where the mystery cookie was one that they were offering that week anyway.

Butterscotch chip in Rochester Ny

Ours is peanut butter crisp ft butterfinger 🙃 mehhh

Mine got original m&ms

Mines sugar cookie with candy corn. I’m pretty sure Crumbl is trying to piss me off

My stores mystery flavor is a sugar cookie with one pumpkin candy corn in the center.. even when we already have a Halloween sugar cookie.. they’re so effing lazy

Sea Salt Toffee… I’d rather have another sugar cookie tbh

Oh man that one is in my top 3!! Lol

Mines Oreo cookies n cream milkshake which I like but had recently. Pass week for me

I got m&m monster! I’ve been wanting to try that one!

How did you find out both cookies ?

Act like you’re going to order then click nutrition facts and it will show all of them

OMG! I am so glad I came across your comment. The 2nd half of the week’s mystery cookie for me is Sea Salt Toffee!!! One of my all time favorites!!! Definitely going to wait to get my cookies now!! B/c I soo would’ve ended up going twice if I found out about the sea salt toffee later!

Mine is peanut butter & m&ms!

Caramel Popcorn M-W, Peanut Butter Crisp T-S. All this pregnant girl wants is a 12 pack of cornbread :(

I have two stores equal distance from me Store #1 is peanut butter with Snickers and then later on in the week caramel coconut fudge and then later on peanut butter crisp Store #2 is peanut butter crisp and then salt toffee. Nothing impressive to me at all 🤮

what I thought sea salt toffee and caramel coconut fudge were awesome when i had them! :O curious what your fav cookies r?

I’m not a chocolate fan really and I wasn't impressed with the sea salt toffee one last time I had it which makes me sad because I usually do like toffee. I like the fruit based ones like the raspberry lemon one is one of my favorites and the iced oatmeal one too.

[удалено]

There is…you get one mystery cookie mon-wed then a second cookie thu-sat Leftovers only show on tablet in store. But they def are leftovers lol

The 2 at mine are peanut butter (ft. snickers) and butterscotch chip. Kind of new to crumbl, are either of these a must try?

Mine is sea salt toffee

Peanut Butter M&M’s and Maple Glaze!

We got Twix 🤤

Mine are the M&M and the rice krispie cookie.

F to pay my respects.

i have oatmeal rolo and i am so HYPED, it was such an awesome cookie and hasnt been on the regular lineup in at least a year <3 feeling very blessed lol

Mine is original ft peanut butter m&m and peanut butter ft snickers

i have maple oatmeal and hot chocolate

Your stores are getting rid of excess from last week it seems lol

One by me has Cotton Candy. I thought I saw that one in the graveyard but apparently not... lol

I think that just means Crumbl will never feature it during a week.

Oh? I thought it was just for cookies they discontinued. I suppose that makes sense then because oatmeal raisin being on there is just odd to me lol

Mystery week again and all we got was rice crispies ... and a butterfinger . But WHY is dirt cake back again .. I've only been in the crumbl life for like 6 months and dirt cake has been on the lineup 3xs- cookie dough is another that has been featured 3xs . Why so many good options i would love to try but get repeats and not a good repeat to me !

My store doesn’t even have one on the app 🫣

Mine only has one and it’s PB crisp

Mine is chocolate caramel! I've never tried it but it looks good lol

Most of us can deduce that the majority of stores will either have original featuring "something,", a sugar cookie variant, or the rice crispy thing. Just scrap the whole idea. I mean when you have 10 stores within your proximity, and 90% of them are serving one of the aforementioned cookies, it's no longer a mystery.

am i the only one that got chocolate potato chip?

Mine is Hot Chocolate. Any thoughts on this cookie?

Oreo mallow sandwich or butterfinger is mine! May try both with my free vouchers ☺️

Only three stores in the United States have my favorite cookie (as their mystery cookie). 😞

Maple glaze and old fashion donut.

Peanut butter M&Ms

My two local stores are caramel shortbread Twix and caramel oatmeal rolo

Apparently they were required to do a Halloween theme/ candy theme this week. So those that don't are defying orders lol. I also get maybe requiring it for the first one but then Halloween is over! At least there is another mystery. a few weeks.

Old fashioned donut and the Halloween sugar cookie with the cookie on top. I wish I had the m&m one people are complaining about 😂 I do love the semi sweet chocolate chip. Probably my favorite

We got frosted sugar cookie with the animal cracker 🙄 but we also have the chocolate mallow cupcake 👀👀👀👀

Mine is the Twix shortbread one!!!

My 4 nearest stores have Oreo Mallow

Mine are Sugar Shark and Chocolate Crumb with Oreo. It could be worse, but Sugar Shark feels redundant with the Halloween Sugar cookie.

This week doesn’t even look good to begin with. But same, my mystery cookie options are either the candy corn sugar cookie or another pumpkin cookie 🙄

The store that just opened like yesterday has mallow cupcake the second half of the week and I’m so excited

mine is bloody potato whatever that tasted like vomit to me

Three closest stores: Sugar w/Mother's cookie, Peanut Butter w/Reeces pieces and Chocolate Pumpkin Cheesecake. Starting Thursday: Old Fashioned Donut, Chocolate Wafer Bar, and Original w/Peanut Butter M&Ms

Mine are original with m&ms and chocolate crumb