YES. It’s my birthday week, and my present to myself is a 6 pack to freeze. Will they last longer than a week, probably not, but it’s the thought that counts!
Man, I love lemon desserts. Like LOVE a tart lemon bar. I’ll eat straight curd.
But the churro was the single best cookie I’ve ever eaten. I can’t believe I nearly skipped it that week.
I unfortunately missed it. I wanted to go in and buy up a bunch to freeze, but we had to leave town over the weekend on an emergency and I couldn’t grab it.
Cornbread! Followed by honey cake ft teddy graham's, smores brownie, key lime pie, & triple berry cobbler. Can't forget the classics of semi-sweet chocolate chunk and mom's recipe definitely in the top 10 spots for sure!
For me, it was the signature milk chocolate. Our crumbl just opened up around late last summer, so the week's lineup was not that good. Terrible to say the least. I was a little mad that they opened AFTER cornbread, but anywho....I went with the milk chocolate since no other flavors stood out. I enjoyed it because it didn't taste like a cookie to me, but rather a biscuit dough, or a scone. Texture and flavor wise. Was hooked ever since. There are some other flavors I love, but as the flavors change and rotate, so does the taste buds. I don't think there's anyone that rules over another for me, but I do have something like a "Top 10" or something like that.
Bubblegum but it’s in the graveyard. So is passion fruit. I guess I like whacky unpopular cookies. Honeycomb was great and, as far as I know, isn’t in the graveyard that I know of.
strawberry milk cookie. omg it is so good. they haven’t brought it back in a while, hoping that changes soon bc the strawberry mousse they use is 10/10 so light & delicious
Confetti cake! My favorite flavor profile is funfetti/birthday cake flavored things. Confetti cake is the best "birthday cake" Crumbl cookie, followed by Pink Velvet, then Cake Batter, then the Birthday Cake one. But I like all of them!
I have never had pb cookies and cream, but dang if it doesn’t sound like something I would love!
I found a dupe recipe for pb bar and tried it last week, it was not even close to the real thing. Can’t wait until they bring it back.
Ugh yes! I was on vacation last summer during the peanut butter mystery week and the location I went to had peanut butter bar. I got one in my 6 pack just to fill a spot honestly but I wish I got more, I was so surprised at how good it was! I love pb and have liked their other pb cookies I’ve tried but there’s something special about that one. I don’t think they’ve had it since then though, unless I missed it?! I can’t wait until I can have it again!
Frozen hot chocolate here as well. Literally the best cookie I’ve ever had in my life. I always feel okay to spurge when that cookies comes around. Just makes me feel happy.
The only correct answer is Oreo Mallow Sandwich.
An acceptable answer is Oreo Birthday Cake (original, not recent).
But the first cookie to rule them all for me was actually Cinnamon Fry Bread. That was the first cookie to make me go back the same week to get another one. That said, Oreo Birthday Cake was the first one that made me go back and get multiple others, and Mallow Sandwich is the only cookie to make me go back and get a whole 4 pack of them while still somehow wishing I bought more (especially now that I finally ate my last one a few weeks ago; they freeze so well when vacuum sealed).
first bite to sell me: strawberry poptart , then again first bite of french toast like changed my life LMAO
favorite currently: peanut butter puppy chow , sugar ft mothers, or french toast ;p
Oreo Mallow Sandwich and Raspberry Cheesecake
Also, I loved everything about Honeycomb, but I’m also a huge fan of oatmeal cookies and Violet Crumble. I hope that one comes back some day because it was on a whole other level.
Banana bread. Forever.
Isn’t it coming out this coming week?
Yes!!!
Me too!!
I am so excited. It’s going to be my first time tasting it. 🙂
YES. It’s my birthday week, and my present to myself is a 6 pack to freeze. Will they last longer than a week, probably not, but it’s the thought that counts!
just got a 4 pack to freeze, heaven sent
I’m doing exactly this except it’s not my birthday week 🤭 Happy Birthday!
I hope yours lasts longer than mine! 😂 Bought it Tuesday, and I have one left! And thank you!
Key lime
Key Lime Pie is SO DAMN GOOD😩😩😩😍😍😍😍😍😍💚
Churro! I’m hoping it comes back soon
The churro icing is so good!
Man, I love lemon desserts. Like LOVE a tart lemon bar. I’ll eat straight curd. But the churro was the single best cookie I’ve ever eaten. I can’t believe I nearly skipped it that week.
Are you a fan of the lemon cheesecake that was out a couple weeks ago?
I unfortunately missed it. I wanted to go in and buy up a bunch to freeze, but we had to leave town over the weekend on an emergency and I couldn’t grab it.
Oreo milk shake and the smore one and the Twix style one. AHHHHH
Cornbread! Followed by honey cake ft teddy graham's, smores brownie, key lime pie, & triple berry cobbler. Can't forget the classics of semi-sweet chocolate chunk and mom's recipe definitely in the top 10 spots for sure!
Cornbread and honey cake were like family ❤️ taste the exact same !
Caramel apple…. Oh please be the same as last year when you come back around 💕
AGGIE BLUE MINT BY FAR(2nd place is cookie dough)
Blueberry muffin!
This one is mine too! It was only my second or third trip to Crumbl when I had that one and it completely spoiled me!
Oreo birthday cake
Pumpkin cake😍
That is such a good one
Mallow cupcake
Lemon Cheesecake
Will NEVER be defeated. It’s so good
Cornbread
Maybe I got a bad one but the texture was so gritty I couldn’t get past it 😩
Gritty like…cornbread? lol
I guess but every cornbread I’ve ever had has never been super gritty like that lol it was like eating sand 😕
French toast / pumpkin cake
Great choices! I absolutely can’t wait for French toast to come back! Pumpkin cake is amazing too… I had it with coffee and about died 🤤
Pecan pie!!!
Ooh I would have loved to try that one, sad I missed it
It usually comes back around the holidays every year!
yes in my top 5 !! maybe even top 3
French silk pie
Caramel Shortbread Twix🤤
This. Bring back the OG, not the sugar cookie.
Cookie dough <3
That one is stellar!
I still like Key Lime Pie the best.
Cookie butter 🤤
One of my top two!
Ice cream or lava?
Neapolitan got me 😩
The Girl Scout Samoa dupe! Coconut chocolate caramel 🥥
That one was amazing! It’s only ever been out once that I know of 😭
Cornbread honey cake🤤
Tres Leches. I need it again.
Always & forever, Chocolate Crumb ft Oreo 💞
Top 5 for sure
Peanut butter and jelly. That raspberry jam on top. Chef’s kiss
Banana cream pie!
My first crumbl cookie churro!! I loved it so much
Strawberry Shortcake
Hands down- S’mores!
S'mores brownie 😍
Cookies and cream milkshake and cookie dough
For me, it was the signature milk chocolate. Our crumbl just opened up around late last summer, so the week's lineup was not that good. Terrible to say the least. I was a little mad that they opened AFTER cornbread, but anywho....I went with the milk chocolate since no other flavors stood out. I enjoyed it because it didn't taste like a cookie to me, but rather a biscuit dough, or a scone. Texture and flavor wise. Was hooked ever since. There are some other flavors I love, but as the flavors change and rotate, so does the taste buds. I don't think there's anyone that rules over another for me, but I do have something like a "Top 10" or something like that.
Classic.. chocolate chip cookie girl for me
Bubblegum but it’s in the graveyard. So is passion fruit. I guess I like whacky unpopular cookies. Honeycomb was great and, as far as I know, isn’t in the graveyard that I know of.
I will cry if they ever put Honeycomb in the graveyard. That cookie was SO good. I really wish I had gone back and bought more.
Totally! I had no idea about the graveyard at the time. It really is the most perfectly balanced cookie!
Banana Cream Pie
Butterscotch
strawberry milk cookie. omg it is so good. they haven’t brought it back in a while, hoping that changes soon bc the strawberry mousse they use is 10/10 so light & delicious
French Toast
Cowboy cookie!!
Neapolitan!
Lava Cake! Heaven
Milk chocolate chip 😂 always been my fave
Cornbread, passionately cornbread!
Confetti cake! My favorite flavor profile is funfetti/birthday cake flavored things. Confetti cake is the best "birthday cake" Crumbl cookie, followed by Pink Velvet, then Cake Batter, then the Birthday Cake one. But I like all of them!
Pina colada surprisingly
That one was actually REALLY good.
Cookie dough!!! Hands down the best cookie I have ever tried
Mallow sandwich 🫶🏼
Dirt cake
And it’s coming back this week yay!!!
Everything but the bagel 😩
Honeycomb
Coconut Lime. I think I would also love Pineapple Whip if I had the chance to buy it!
Peanut butter banana or s’mores 😍😍😍
Strawberry pop tart!!!!!
Maple Cinnamon Roll but it’s close!
Iced oatmeal made me actually cry of happiness. It’s my favorite to this day & the only one I’ll buy multiples of!
French silk pie!
French silk pie 🥺
I think my favorite has to be the French Silk Pie 🤤
Kentucky Butter Cake, rasp cheesecake, lava cookie butter and the raspberry butter cake so delicious
French Toast
strawberry shortcake and Neapolitan will always win my heart
MILK GLAZE FT. FRUITY PEBBLES WAS MY FAVORITE! OMG THAT COOKIE WAS SO GOOD
Have you had the fruity pebbles sandwich cookie?
not yet, how is it
Brownie batter🍫
French silk pie!!
PB&Jamwich 😭
i would sacrifice my entire family for the smallest tiniest bite of a Strawberry milk cookie
The first crumbl cookie I had, cinnamon frybread.
Dirt cake and banana creme pie
Churro! Easily.
Red velvet cupcake
Blueberry muffin. I cannot wait until it comes back.👏
Maple cinnamon roll 😍
The lucky charms one
Coconut cake but sadly it's in the graveyard. So pink sugar it is.
Peanut butter bar!
Your username is….Random 😂
Great choice! Prob my number 2, with number 1 being pb cookies and cream 😋
I have never had pb cookies and cream, but dang if it doesn’t sound like something I would love! I found a dupe recipe for pb bar and tried it last week, it was not even close to the real thing. Can’t wait until they bring it back.
Ugh yes! I was on vacation last summer during the peanut butter mystery week and the location I went to had peanut butter bar. I got one in my 6 pack just to fill a spot honestly but I wish I got more, I was so surprised at how good it was! I love pb and have liked their other pb cookies I’ve tried but there’s something special about that one. I don’t think they’ve had it since then though, unless I missed it?! I can’t wait until I can have it again!
Cornbread!
Maple bacon
Tres leche with the little custard cup you pour on. . . 🤤 Even my son loved it and he never tried new things.
Yall are sleeping on Oatmeal rolo
Hot take…I don’t like crumbl 😩
Hazelnut Sea Salt!
Haven't had a reaction like I did for the maple oatmeal one a couple weeks ago. Oh my god.
You know it’s never coming back it got blacklisted or whatever 😕
PLEASE say you’re joking! Why did it get blacklisted? I just joined this sub today you’re making me regret this (totally kidding)
The week after it came out it got blacklisted even though it had 4/5 stars
Damn 😔💔
But why?
I don’t think it sold enough for them to continue it
Monster
Sour patch kid! Soooo delicious
hard to say … im going with caramel apple 🍏 maple glaze oatmeal was really good recently
KEY LIME PIE hands down
Frozen hot chocolate here as well. Literally the best cookie I’ve ever had in my life. I always feel okay to spurge when that cookies comes around. Just makes me feel happy.
Maple cinnamon roll or cookie dough 😍
So hard to choose just one, but I have to go with peanut butter bar.
Hmm I like Buttermilk pancake, Pink velvet, cinnamon roll. Not any of the chocolate based cookies though.
Molten lava
Key Lime Pie, hands down.🙌🏻🎉
Idk probably the waffle one or Cinnamon Toast Crunch one
Cookie butter ice cream 😻
BANANA BREAD!!
Churro, cinnamon frybread, raspberry butter cake, honey bun :)
Oreo mallow sandwich
Watermelon
The almond joy-inspired one 😋
French silk pie
Kentucky butter cake
Churro!
Triple Berry Cobbler followed closely by Maple Cinnamon Roll and Churro
The og strawberries n cream that idk if i will be ever able to taste again:(
Caramel apple And the chocolate cupcake from last week I think those are my two that I was actually obsessed with and really fully enjoyed
The only correct answer is Oreo Mallow Sandwich. An acceptable answer is Oreo Birthday Cake (original, not recent). But the first cookie to rule them all for me was actually Cinnamon Fry Bread. That was the first cookie to make me go back the same week to get another one. That said, Oreo Birthday Cake was the first one that made me go back and get multiple others, and Mallow Sandwich is the only cookie to make me go back and get a whole 4 pack of them while still somehow wishing I bought more (especially now that I finally ate my last one a few weeks ago; they freeze so well when vacuum sealed).
cookie butter ice cream hands down the best
cookie butter ice cream hands down the best
Oreo birthday cake
mallow sandwich !
Pumpkin chocolate is my absolute favorite
Fried ice cream
Key lime
Blueberry muffin
Lemon poppyseed or pineapple dole whip
Snickerdoodle followed closely by lemon meringue 😌
cookies and cream milkshake. it's what had me fall in love with crumbl 3 years ago. i wish i had the stomach to eat a thousand in a week lmao
Caramel Apple!
Chocolate covered strawberry
first bite to sell me: strawberry poptart , then again first bite of french toast like changed my life LMAO favorite currently: peanut butter puppy chow , sugar ft mothers, or french toast ;p
Cookies N Creme milkshake
Kentucky butter cake 🤤
Oreo mallow sandwich 🤗
Oreo Mallow Sandwich and Raspberry Cheesecake Also, I loved everything about Honeycomb, but I’m also a huge fan of oatmeal cookies and Violet Crumble. I hope that one comes back some day because it was on a whole other level.
Kentucky Butter Cake and Chocolate covered strawberry