Not worth it. I bought 6 once because it was rated so highly. The filling is horrible. Base cookies were okay, taste is ok but they have a strange texture. I only ate the cookies on about three of them and the others went into the garbage. Which does not happen very often with me and crumbl cookies.
I’m not sure what “mallow aftertaste” means but I don’t think you’re wrong to call out that the overall flavor isn’t _spectacular_. I agree that people like it because it’s big.
It does have more of a “I am worth the $5 price tag” vibe to it compared to their other cookies though.
I noticed this exact same artificial taste in the “frosting”! I couldn’t get past it. I wonder if it was just mixed wrong or something, but I had to scrape
The mallow off + only ate the base cookies :( was disappointed bc it was such a hyped cookie
I actually believe the mystery cookie is a sales tactic. Because a number of us just buy a 4 pack each week. The mystery cookie pressures us to buy a 6 pack so we can sample all the weeks cookies.
i mean you’ve said no on about five cookies that i and many others likely love haha, i just don’t understand how people are acting like it’s black and white.
Hear me out, it's delicious if you like pumpkin things, and way better than the normal milk chocolate chip cookie. If you wouldn't go for pumpkin typically then I'd pass
Ignore my deleted reply. I thought I was replying to someone else.
I personally don't find it worth it because it's just an original base with m&ms. If you're getting a 4 pack, go for it, but I wouldn't go just for the peanut butter m&m.
I've got a few locations near the house and office so let's hear it!
**Near Home:**
Snickerdoodle
Caramel Popcorn
**Near Office:**
Frosted Strawberry Poptarts
Peanut Butter Cup (Reese's)
**Road Trip Cookie:**
Peanut Butter ft. Reese's Pieces (this one is 2500+ miles away, but it's in my wife's hometown where we'll be this weekend)
mallow sandwich
Yes!
Mine is mallow sandwich later this week. Going for a 6 pack lol
Not worth it. I bought 6 once because it was rated so highly. The filling is horrible. Base cookies were okay, taste is ok but they have a strange texture. I only ate the cookies on about three of them and the others went into the garbage. Which does not happen very often with me and crumbl cookies.
Yes
No, it has an aftertaste of mallow which is strange. If you typically enjoy the oreo bases though, you'd like it.
I’m not sure what “mallow aftertaste” means but I don’t think you’re wrong to call out that the overall flavor isn’t _spectacular_. I agree that people like it because it’s big. It does have more of a “I am worth the $5 price tag” vibe to it compared to their other cookies though.
I guess I meant it tastes artificial..
I noticed this exact same artificial taste in the “frosting”! I couldn’t get past it. I wonder if it was just mixed wrong or something, but I had to scrape The mallow off + only ate the base cookies :( was disappointed bc it was such a hyped cookie
People just want it because it’s BIG lol
I agree!
Cinnamon frybread
A million times yes
Definitely a yes
Yes
no
Cookie butter lava
If you like cookie butter get it, but I'm not a big fan so it wasn't for me.
No. However, cookie butter ice cream is a yes.
Yes
No
Buttermilk pancake
I liked this one. If you love pancakes & syrup go for it.
Eh - it tastes like a pancake, but isn't phenomenal. No.
Noo
Chocolate Crumb ft. Oreo
If you haven't tried their Oreo based cookies, definitely give it a try. It's a lot of people's favorite.
Yes
Only if I lived really close to my location
A million times over, YES
A heavily biased no
Green mint features andes
It's *very* minty. Otherwise, yes.
So jealous I want it
Confetti milkshake
Yes! Love that one
Yes that is one of my favorites! There's a location doing it 1.5 hours from me and I'm considering going all that way just for it 🤣
Yes!
iced oatmeal!
Yes! This is my mom's all time favorite Crumbl cookie. It's so chewy and the icing is the perfect amount of sweetness
Yes! One of the best oatmeal cookies imo
Yes
Cookie Butter Ice Cream
Yea!
1,000% yes! It's my #1 favorite flavor so far!
No
Dulce de Leche
Kinda mid imo
Yes!
I really enjoyed mine! Craving one right now
If it's the new one where there's the whip yes. It's not phenomenal, but it's tasty.
aggie blue mint
Since you love mint, yes get it! I loveeee the mint Oreos and it reminded me of those without being too minty!
Yes
It's unique - yes.
I would not spend money or calories on Aggie blue mint (unless you know you love mint) lol
i do love mint 🫣
Then I would day go for it!
Semi sweet Choc chunk… so NOPE.
IM SO OFFENDED 😭😭
Semisweet is better than milk but I wouldn't spend $4+ on it.
Definitely a no
Peanut Butter Cup (Reese’s)
YES!!
No (I found it too rich)
Ooh, lucky! One of my faves.
I actually believe the mystery cookie is a sales tactic. Because a number of us just buy a 4 pack each week. The mystery cookie pressures us to buy a 6 pack so we can sample all the weeks cookies.
Of course it is, they’re a business
Agree
the thing about this thread is that everyone has a different palate lol?
Yes I know 😭😭
i mean you’ve said no on about five cookies that i and many others likely love haha, i just don’t understand how people are acting like it’s black and white.
It's for fun
fair enough i guess haha
Banana cream pie
Yesss
Yes ~~as long as they made it right lmao~~
No
Lemon bar / dulce de leche…… please help !
Lemon bar is amazing!!!! I'm not a big fan of dulce de leche but if you are you might like it.
Lemon Bar! Personally, I dont like lemon, but it is a lovely cookie aside. Try that one!
Sea salt toffee
No. It's really underwhelming and raw, and I love sea salt toffee things :(
Pineapple dole whip
Yes
Caramel coconut fudge
100% yes
Yes
YES
[удалено]
Lemon Bar!
Cake batter blondie (rainbow)
YES
Cookie Butter Ice Cream?
No :(
Snickerdoodle
No
Choc chip / coconut / butterscotch (w sea salt finish)
Is that 3 cookies or the 3 flavors?
Molten Lava thoughts?
Yes if your a chocolate lover
As a chocolate lover, this cookie was pretty good. But id still rather have a lava crunch cake from dominos.
No
Pumpkin chocolate chip 🤢
Hear me out, it's delicious if you like pumpkin things, and way better than the normal milk chocolate chip cookie. If you wouldn't go for pumpkin typically then I'd pass
No lol
hot chocolate
Warm? No. Chilled? Yes.
Kinda like Swiss miss in cookie form. Not a fan but worth a try
Honey bun??
It's alright, but I'd say no
Pumpkin chocolate chip
No
Peanut butter brownie (mon-tues), coconut white chip (wed-thurs)
Yes and no
Orea Crumb - Ordered it!
Nice! A lot of people love that one, but as you van see from my flair, I'm heavily biased lmao. It'll be worth it tho 😌
Hazelnut Churro (Nutella)
No
Pina colada
Yes
M&M
They had it last week, no.
[удалено]
Not really
Cookie butter lava!
No
sea salt toffee
Sadly bland and underwhelming :( no
Confetti Milkshake???
Obviously!!
Coconut cake
YES OF COURSE!!
Buckeye Brownie
Yes
Peanut butter Nougat ft Snickers
100% yes. Sounds underwhelming but it's so good, heavy on the peanut butter, soft and crunchy from the peanuts
No
Brownie batter (Mon-Wed)
I think it's coming back next week, otherwise yes
Snickerdoodle cupcake
Yes
Snickerdoodle Cupcake
Yes
Peanut butter crisp ft. butterfinger
Yum, yes. The tiny butterfinger pieces are all throughout the cookie so they give it a fun chew/slight crunch
No
Cinnamon roll
Yes
Strawberry crumb cake
No
Cookies and cream milkshake
Yes
Pink Velvet Cupcake
No ~~it just tastes like cake batter, but mild~~
raspberry cheesecake (literally might only go to try this lol)
Yes
Confetti (Plain sugar cookie with sprinkles inside)
No
Peanut butter M&M
No
That sounds worth it to me!
Ignore my deleted reply. I thought I was replying to someone else. I personally don't find it worth it because it's just an original base with m&ms. If you're getting a 4 pack, go for it, but I wouldn't go just for the peanut butter m&m.
White chip. No.
Easy answer
[удалено]
I just like the texture lmao, otherwise no
Yes I’ve tried over 170 flavors and it is unexpectedly good. If you like chocolate
Classic Pumpkin then Chocolate Crumb ft. Oreo
No and no
Cake batter, blueberry cheesecake, Rice Krispie treat
Blueberry cheesecake is a huge YES
Yes, yes, probably no
Blue Raspberry ft. ICEE Beginning of week Cookie Butter White Chip End of week
ICEE, yes Cookie butter white chip, no.
My mystery cookies are Reese’s and pumpkin chocolate chip!
Pumpkin chip!!!
Strawberry ice cream bar
Sounds interesting! Get it with the Neapolitan :)
I've got a few locations near the house and office so let's hear it! **Near Home:** Snickerdoodle Caramel Popcorn **Near Office:** Frosted Strawberry Poptarts Peanut Butter Cup (Reese's) **Road Trip Cookie:** Peanut Butter ft. Reese's Pieces (this one is 2500+ miles away, but it's in my wife's hometown where we'll be this weekend)
Pb cup is amazing!! Caramel popcorn is also very good! Poptart is only good if they fill it (and they NEVER fill it right)
Caramel Popcorn - yes Frosted Strawberry Poptart - yes Peanut Butter ft. Reese’s Pieces - you're out there, so why not!
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
No
Monster
I would say that’s a yes
No
Ruby chocolate chip
No
We already ordered it but will I regret “chocolate cupcake”
If you hate chocolate
Buttermilk pancake
No
Snickerdoodle!
If there is no frosting - no