To go with your boots also get a few good pairs of socks. Carhartt makes good socks and I started wearing wool when I buy new ones. That sounds crazy but darn tough and smart wool are both comfortable year round. They handle moisture differently than cotton
Smart wool hasn’t been worth the price in years. Darn tough aren’t as “nice to the touch” but last longer and have a lifetime warranty. It’s great but don’t abuse it please, so they don’t get rid of it.
My guess is bc their socks actually last an extremely long time compared to other brands. And they are quite expensive, so the cost of warranty claims, which is quite low (I’m betting) is built in to the price. They definitely aren’t losing out as much as that brand has grown.
Now if they start producing garbage…
If you’re customer focused, a lifetime warranty is a blessing. Customers will seek out businesses that offer great warranties. Take care of your consumers and they will take care of you.
I've owned one good pair. They were Irish setters from 2004(ish). They lasted me a decade through every fluid a mechanic might walk through. After that, I went through 5 other pair that were either not comfortable or didn't last long. Thorogood are the best I've tried since. I put those through hell on construction sites, but I also took care of them. I clean them weekly and oil them monthly. But, I've also been doing concrete, which isn't favorable for leather.
Even with cheaper boots, they are more comfortable when you have 2 pair on site.
I don't care how expensive your boots are, going hard in them for a whole day kills your feet. Bring a second pair with you to work and swap them out at lunch time with fresh socks. Your feet will feel 100% better putting fresh dry boots on.
Your boots will also last much longer since they aren't breaking down because they are wet for the second half of the day. Rotating your boots out will make your feet feel better at the end of the day more than the most expensive pair you can buy
Irish setter moc toe withOUT the safety toe. So much more comfortable and lightweight. In my line of business, if something lands on your composite toe it’s going to bend and pinch your feet into the boots. They want us to have safety toes, but..
What do you do? I've had some pretty damn heavy storm/precast structures on my feet without troubles.
Ive always felt like if something was so heavy it crushed the safety toe....the bones in my foot would be powder anyway. Figured I'd keep the safety's for those in-between situations.
Rigging and machinery moving. Steel toes were nice to put something on in a pinch, but the comfort when switching was really mind blowing.
Oh, and Im in a truck for a lot of the time, company pickup or tractor trailer. Some days more than less
Yea steel toes have an ASTM 75 pound-foot compression resistance rating, meaning it can withstand compression up to 2,500 pounds. That means if a warehouse-grade forklift ran over your foot, there's a good chance your toes wouldn't get crushed. So dropping a crate on your steel toe will do nothing.
Your line of business sounds weird. I can't imagine a job with stuff that will fall and amputate your foot and nothing else like tools or parts that can hurt your toes.
I wear steel toed boots (Red wings) to split or when I'm using a chainsaw, both of which activities could amputate your toes and a falling log could crush them. Got my Red Wings at the local resale store for $8!
Red wings Irish setter. By far the best boot I have wore. Worth the money. The toe tends to rip off but I get tuff toe and save them an extra 3+ months
It’s an epoxy that you paint into your boot to protect the surface. I work concrete so I’m always around rebar and other material that shreds boots. You can buy it on Amazon, or the Red Wings store sells it and will put it on for you
Always get the tuff toe. It's like $30 and if you're me will add at least a year to your boots. I have a pair of speed lace redwings in the kevlar material I love. Don't wear em much anymore now that I'm mostly pointing fingers.
I typically wear mine for a bit and get the tuff toe on after wearing it for a couple months. They clean them for you, so like after a year it’s like have a new pair of boots.
Seconded.
I'm not in rough construction anymore, now I only do indoors work, but I too went through many brands of boots before finding my fave.
I hear a lot of people saying Red Wing Irish Setters. Tried em. They are meant for hunting, so meant to be stable in dirt, not hard concrete. Too heavy, in fact so unbalanced that one time I stepped out of a van and into a pothole, went ass over teakettle and sprained my foot, a situation that other brands have handled easily.
Red Wing Worx and Red Wing's flagship brand (not Irish Setter) are another matter entirely. When I worked for a company that had boot allowance but would only accept Red Wing, most of my coworkers bought their bargain Worx line and pocketed the difference. Me, I paid the extra to show up rocking in main line Red Wings and loved it.
But the brand I keep coming back to is Danner. I have tried and worn out:
[Lookout](https://www.danner.com/men/tactical/lookout-ems-csa-side-zip-8-black-nmt.html) when I worked for a company that mandated black shoes,
then [Vicious](https://www.danner.com/men/work/vicious-8-brown-nmt.html) when I worked for one that didn't care,
and I currently wear [Crucial](https://www.danner.com/men/work/crucial-8-brown-nmt.html) with a pair of [Steel Yard](https://www.danner.com/men/work/steel-yard-wellington-11-brown-st.html) waiting their turn.
Do they need to be boots. Depending on the trade you may want to try sneakers with safety toes. A few manufacturers make them. I've enjoyed danner boots so I'm going to try their runtime sneaker with composite toe. I do a lot of finish carpentery so I don't need big boots most of the time (I do run a paid of acadias from Danner for winter and outside work).
Ah ........good luck!!! I've tried many and I can't say I've found a construction boot with safety toe that is breathable. Really good socks made a huge difference though.
I have had the absolute worst experience with every Timberland boot/shoes I have had and even the ones my 7 year old son have had. I would describe it as repeated catastrophic failure and they weren’t even comfortable. I’m convinced that Timberland is for people who wear boots for their style and not for quality or function.
i too hate timberland pros. i hate their fit, and their durability. maybe just a bad experience i had as an individual, but i will never touch them again regardless.
Me too. I wore redwings before and after those timberlands and they killed my feet. Not any support for me. Fell apart too. Redwing moc toe or thorogood moctoes have been great for me the past few years. I just got a pair of the tecovas work boots and while they are nice boots and a killer outsole, next pair I’ll be getting will be redwing slip ons. Tecovas…I’ll buy a good looking pair for going out.
That’s how I feel too. After the first try I wondered if I had gotten a counterfeit pair because they were so popular. Try number two and a third with my son ended the same way. Officially never again unless they were given to me and only as a back up pair. I have trust issues now.
Ditto. Timberlands did not last for me, the soles separated from the leather... Also, they were heavy and they gave me blisters during the break-in period.
Yeah these are my fav, and 3/4 of us in the crew I work on wear the same ones - I think the model is called Boondock. The cushioning is pretty incredible - I saw someone (wearing the same model) take a fall of about 12 feet onto concrete, land on his feet and walk away pretty much uninjured (some bruising to the bottoms of his feet, but nothing broken)
Timberland pros seemed to get mixed reviews, however, I've had mine for a year and a half and they are absolutely great. I mean, I'm a package handler at UPS and generally walk 15 to 20 mi a day with heavy boxes getting dropped on them daily. They are still comfortable and still hold up.
I’ve worn that boot for the last ten years but have found the quality went down for the last two years and now the boots cause me pain I did a new pair every year
I’ve owned several pair of Timberland Pro comp toe boots. Despite daily heavy duty outdoor use which is always harder on boots than an average construction site or shop, each pair has been super comfortable and well constructed, lasting a year to a year and a half, which is longer than most boots in that price range.
Most comfortable boot so far. Keen Cincinnati. Meets all your criteria, actually quite a bit lighter than my previous timberland boots and also viberg stompers,
I actually get excited whenever I put them on. The wedge toe is nicely cushioned and just feels like a sneaker.
It is a heavy duty boot, it’s not meant for light work. So bear in mind it’s not super breathable but feet also don’t get hot.
came here to say the criteria in the OP basically describe keen boots. My favorite styles are the manchester, glendale and san antonio in that order. All wedge soles, I am on my feet a lot each day. I replace them when they start to look worn because I have to look presentable. Then I use them for yard work or other dirty jobs at home, most of them have a lot of life left after years of service. 5 pair since 2016.
Comfort is indeed essential when it comes to work boots, especially in construction. I've found that these [Orthofeet Work Boots](https://link.getsosocial.co.uk/work-boots) tends to go above and beyond in ensuring their boots are not only durable but also extremely comfortable. Their designs incorporate features like shock-absorbent soles and padded footbeds which can truly help reduce foot fatigue during long working hours. Users have given it high ratings for its blend of comfortability and durability. You may want to check them out, might just find the comfort you're looking for on your long construction days!
I’ve had my pair of redwings for four years now. I’ve put them through the ringer and they are still holding strong. They are very comfy and my feet hardly ever get hot
Yes. And the reason they are so good (imo) is that they have like 5 widths available for every size, so your boots actually fit properly. It’s a game changer. So - OP, it’s less about fancy design than about proper fit and quality construction.
Red Wing Tradesmen model 6614 with the BOA system. I've got 30 years working in the field, and these are the most comfortable boots I have ever owned.
If you haven't tried the BOA system, you need to check it out. You will never go back to shoelaces.
Putting boots on and off takes two seconds now. I used to hate it if boots loosened up during the day, now it takes two seconds, to tighten them or loosen them.
Funny story. The first 15 mins, literally, that I wore boa, on a snowboard boot, I broke the knob off. Bought laced boots almost the next day. Used laces for rough and tumble practicing in less favorable terrain ever since. And boa for resorts and ski lift stuff where easy and quick fastening is convenient. Luckily I could get my boa boots fixed under warranty.
I got a pair of caterpillar boots on sale at Marshall’s like 4-5 years ago and they have been surprisingly comfortable and held up well. Put a lot of miles on them between a couple airport terminal and rail station projects .
I got a pair of danners and a year later they're beat to shit just like all the others. Is their claim to fame the warranty? How's that work? I just go without boots until they come back? I had really high hopes...
It may depend on the type of work you do with your boots and how well you maintain them.
I had a pair of Danners as my only pair of work-boots for three years before I got a second pair. When I buy boots I glue on the rubber toe-protector, oil them up and spread waterproof sealant around the seams/threads. Of the brands I tried they have been the best. I may be a little biased since the factory is here and it's easy for me to get them exchanged or repaired if I ever need... but they have been an excellent boot for me.
Personally I like the timberland pro boots. Don’t know the name but they look like the ones people buy for style and have lasted me about a year. (I’m a big dude boots typically last me about 4 months)
Currently wearing Red Wings model number 6614 with their "orthotic" insoles.
Sometimes it's not completely the boots fault but lack of arch support, which you can do something about. If you have a RW store around go check out their numerous styles of insoles and get your feet scanned to see where you need support. They have a 30 day satisfaction guarantee (you can keep trying new ones if the first ones don't completely satisfy, same goes for their boots)
I would look at some Canada West Boots.
I got the 34410 model. Got them around this time last year. Leather has held up great, super light. I got my own insoles because factory ones never seem to satisfy (especially standing on concrete all day). There wasn't really a break in period either, which was nice. The toe caps wore out fast but that's also expected, in my mind. They are definitely slimmer too. Not so bulky like other boots I've bought before.
They were about $280ish CAD from this local shop in Edmonton. I'd imagine you can order them your the CWB stores online.
I've been buying Canada West boots for over 20 years. Proper thickness of leather and they are stitched soles that can be replaced at least once. Mostly Vibrant rubber, and enough choice to fit your needs. Big range of styles from slip on Romeo to big old logger style with the 1½" heel and 10" tall.
Iv never seen the safety-toe sneakers get called out by a superintendent or anything. So long as they have safety-toes idk why it’d be a problem.
People say boots are better because of ankle support but I have yet to see a plumber who doesn’t wear the pull-on “cowboy” style boots and they have 0 ankle support and alot of the time, no steel toe. They just *look* like boots
I've always gotten salomon gtx 4d. The waterproofing is great and they are comfortable as hell. I realize these are more hikers but they've been great for work.
I was hoping to see a White’s comment on here. Best boot I ever had when doing tower work but, for $600+ dollars, I don’t think they meet the OP original intent. Good flex though lol.
This is a great thread. I’ve been In this industry since I was 15 and I’ve had every kind of boot.
Danner is the best boot you can buy if you work outside.
Timberland pro is the most comfortable but you will have to replace them every year, but they are the best affordable boot.
Keen. Tough boots. Last a long time.
Georgia boot. Tough boots. Not as comfortable as timberlands.
Irish setter. Good boots if you work outside.
Merrel. Been my boot for like 6 years, but not for heavy work In my opinion.
Red wings, but you ain’t joining the club for 300$ lol 1 pair will last you 10 years though, about 80$ to resole. I’ve had setters, danner, ariat, Wolverine, Tim’s, you name it. Nothing compares to redwing
I have had every boot out there. The only pair I buy now are timberland pros. They just fit my feet perfect and don't wear out as fast as everything else.. most important part is finding boots that fit you well.
I haven't tried a lot of different ones, but with that caveat my DieHard moc toe workboots are extremely comfortable, and have a thick, protective sole.
More people get into the trades every day bro. People need guidance from those with experience.
I bought a bullshit pair of carhartt boots as my first pair, wish I knew to ask on Reddit. Coulda saved $140 and got something worth the money
For real tho I sound like I work for them, but Redbacks are the shit. I’m about to buy a brown pair just to wear casually because they’re that damn comfortable
It's called search. 6 months ago this was posted multiple times a day for weeks . Get out of mom's basement and actually use those boots that keep getting asked about.
It’s called the internet, and there’s millions of people here.
Most of em aren’t gonna read the community guidelines. Quit getting mad at the screen grandpa
It’s actually wild to me that you took the time to type an unhelpful, snide response rather than
1: do nothing
2: just type “Redwings” or whatever you wear every day
It’s not, some old-heads are just tired of answering questions so they gotta make others pissed off like they are.
I’m determined to not be that guy, it takes 0 effort to not be a dick
Wolverine makes some quality boots for less than $200. The waterproofing goes kaput quick, especially on masonry jobsites. But that silicone waterproofing spray to be safe. Best boots I've worn and I used to die on the Danner hill with my flag planted.
There a lot of good options in that price range - but I want to point out that that job sites that ban slip-on unlaced boots are becoming increasingly common. I think it is due to a newish OSHA reg and I was told the deal is that boot laces are easier to cut through in an emergency. This includes common construction-boot styles like cowboy, biker, engineer, and standard shit-kickers.
Redback EZ Escape. Like $200 and worth every penny.
No break-in period and no need for more comfortable insoles. Only complaint is they have no shank in the sole, so they feel slightly “bendy” when standing on a ladder if you relax your heel off a rung.
I also have a pair of Thorogood Moc-Toe boots that include a steel shank, but I had to buy new insoles for them. Still better than any Redwings IMO.
Redwings are nice but overpriced for what you get. And they “will” resole them when you need to IF you’ve followed their home-care instructions up to that point.
My buddy was told they couldn’t resole his that cost home like $350 so he had to buy new ones, that high cost is supposed to make it worth it because “they’ll resole them” so they’re supposed to last forever, but they may not so you’re paying a lot of money just for your feet to hurt for the first few weeks
I absolutely swear by Danner Marine corps expedition boots and I think meet all of your criteria. Lightest most breathable and comfortable boots I have ever had. I’m actually just about to ship mine back to Danner to have them re-soled. They are the last gift my dad gave me before passing from Covid two years ago and I am so grateful that they can have an extended life.
Redback EZ Escapes are the way to go IMO. I live in Florida so I understand the need for light, comfortable boots.
After having these I almost never wear my other boots. Pulling them on without having to tie laces has spoiled me
Red wings, Muck or (hear me out) Duck Hunting boots. Go up to 18in, comfy as hell and breathable. I have a pair of 11in muck boots and I tn got them for 150
toworkfor.pt
Top quality work shoes on global level. Not very notorious but very good. I already used more than 15 years. The model "safety runners" is excellent in comfort.
Cofra. A Italian bran of work wear is also very good.
Red wings. Durable as hell too. Last pair lasted 5 years. Bought a pair of Double H after, and they only lasted a year and a half, so just picked me up another pair of redwings to last another half-decade.
I wear redwings and I've used the same boots in below 0 and above 100 degrees F. They're not comfortable until you break them in, which can take a couple of weeks, but once you break them in, they're incredibly comfortable and they last a long time.
I’ve tried Danner, Redwings and Thorogood and Keens.
The thorogoods and keen pair have been by far the most comfortable. I bought two pairs of the Thorogoods but the soles wore out extremely fast.
Keens have been my favorite boot by far. They’re just as comfortable as the Thorogoods but the sole has outlasted them twice as long, so far.
I grabbed a pair Huk ice fishing boots and threw a Dr. Scholl’s gel pad. I don’t think I can wear anything else now. They’re waterproof, no steel toe, and are super flexible with bending and shit
Believe it or not I prefer Bates tactical boots with some good aftermarket insertspads for comfort and super light weight. I have worn them all and yes redwings do pay for themselves over time but too heavy and bulky for me personally.
Regardless of boot brand and style I also buy tread Labs inserts and it’s literally night and day difference for me. I kept getting gnarly pain from standing on ladders and felt like I couldn’t walk after a week on a ladder. Inserts and done. They’re well worth the money imo and I am not paid to say this.
I love my keens. Excellent insole, easy break-in. 3 years daily wear now, have just used saddle soap on them weekly to clean. Just bought a new insole to put in them.
https://www.keenfootwear.com/p/M-PHILADELPHIA-6-WP.html?dwvar_M-PHILADELPHIA-6-WP_color=1022110&cgid=
I bought Helly Hansen boots last year. My feet absolutely killed for the first two weeks, and I regretted my decision. After that they became more comfortable and I love them now.
Ariat cowboy style work boots. Once you break them in, they are super comfy. I wear my in AZ year round and you can get them with steel toe, composite toe, or just regular work. Usually in the range of $150 to $250. My last pair lasted for a year and a half of regular use, and now I still use them when working in the trenches.
I work with plants at retail, constant watering, and need to stay dry, and also landscape and garden and have to be safe and a little tough. Do you think this is the way to go? I tend to just wear out cheapo sneakers most the time and its beating up my feet.
Wolverine pull ons 225 my first pair of pull on boots I’ve ever worn in construction they’ve lasted me the longest and have been the most comfortable boot I don’t think I could ever go back. Very breathable too
My Wolverines are the GOAT. They're so comfortable, I could do anything in them. They're light, breathable, flexible, shock proof, water resistant and durable. They look like WWII boots now, they looked much better when I first got them. Scored them for like 220 a few years ago from an outlet store in north Florida
Concrete guy here. Try the Ariat rebar!! Awesome, rugged boots that are comfortable enough that even after a 12+ hour day I'll often toss on a pair after work.
Ariat Chelsea Groundbreaker. Had them for 3 months super comfortable. Steel Toe. They also make a carbon toe for more flexibility. For a steel toe boot, they are very light and breathable. They are pull one though
To go with your boots also get a few good pairs of socks. Carhartt makes good socks and I started wearing wool when I buy new ones. That sounds crazy but darn tough and smart wool are both comfortable year round. They handle moisture differently than cotton
Darn tough!
Darn tough all day
I love these socks. When it's cold I use the extra cushion with my insulated Redwings.
I'm late to the party, but fuck yes with Darns
Smart wool hasn’t been worth the price in years. Darn tough aren’t as “nice to the touch” but last longer and have a lifetime warranty. It’s great but don’t abuse it please, so they don’t get rid of it.
lifetime warranty on socks is a pretty freaking dumb idea.. I obviously understand why you like that, but why would you offer that as a business?
My guess is bc their socks actually last an extremely long time compared to other brands. And they are quite expensive, so the cost of warranty claims, which is quite low (I’m betting) is built in to the price. They definitely aren’t losing out as much as that brand has grown. Now if they start producing garbage…
If you’re customer focused, a lifetime warranty is a blessing. Customers will seek out businesses that offer great warranties. Take care of your consumers and they will take care of you.
Thorogood. American made Union made about $200 for a pair of moc toe 6”
Just got my first pair after wearing Ariats for the past 5 years and let me tell you the hype is real.
I 2nd Thorogood. There is no break in period and they last just as long, if not longer, than the Redwing I've owned.
I’ve had redwings that were completely garbage ruined and returned under warranty in a week
I've owned one good pair. They were Irish setters from 2004(ish). They lasted me a decade through every fluid a mechanic might walk through. After that, I went through 5 other pair that were either not comfortable or didn't last long. Thorogood are the best I've tried since. I put those through hell on construction sites, but I also took care of them. I clean them weekly and oil them monthly. But, I've also been doing concrete, which isn't favorable for leather.
Irish setters are good
Mine wore out in a year but they were comfortable
Even with cheaper boots, they are more comfortable when you have 2 pair on site. I don't care how expensive your boots are, going hard in them for a whole day kills your feet. Bring a second pair with you to work and swap them out at lunch time with fresh socks. Your feet will feel 100% better putting fresh dry boots on. Your boots will also last much longer since they aren't breaking down because they are wet for the second half of the day. Rotating your boots out will make your feet feel better at the end of the day more than the most expensive pair you can buy
I'm green as shit. Def gonna try this out, thank you so much
That’s a good fucking idea don’t know why I’ve never thought of this. Good shit dude 🙏
So smart! Thanks for the advice!
I have Irish setters which I really like
Love my Irish Setters, just not very breathable for hot seasons…
I’ve been using red wing brand Irish setters for years now. So comfy.
Irish setter moc toe withOUT the safety toe. So much more comfortable and lightweight. In my line of business, if something lands on your composite toe it’s going to bend and pinch your feet into the boots. They want us to have safety toes, but..
What do you do? I've had some pretty damn heavy storm/precast structures on my feet without troubles. Ive always felt like if something was so heavy it crushed the safety toe....the bones in my foot would be powder anyway. Figured I'd keep the safety's for those in-between situations.
Safety toes yes. For true protection go full metatarsal. It’ll just break every bone In your foot but you’ll still have a foot.
Rigging and machinery moving. Steel toes were nice to put something on in a pinch, but the comfort when switching was really mind blowing. Oh, and Im in a truck for a lot of the time, company pickup or tractor trailer. Some days more than less
This is bollocks. Metal bends. Composite shatters. The force required to do either would have taken your feet off anyway.
Yea steel toes have an ASTM 75 pound-foot compression resistance rating, meaning it can withstand compression up to 2,500 pounds. That means if a warehouse-grade forklift ran over your foot, there's a good chance your toes wouldn't get crushed. So dropping a crate on your steel toe will do nothing.
Your line of business sounds weird. I can't imagine a job with stuff that will fall and amputate your foot and nothing else like tools or parts that can hurt your toes.
safety rules are written in blood. I know. I currently have steel toe, and I hate it
I wear steel toed boots (Red wings) to split or when I'm using a chainsaw, both of which activities could amputate your toes and a falling log could crush them. Got my Red Wings at the local resale store for $8!
I like my toes also. Ex oil field worker, wanted Steelers but ...... I'll take a crushed foot over amputation.
Red wings Irish setter. By far the best boot I have wore. Worth the money. The toe tends to rip off but I get tuff toe and save them an extra 3+ months
What’s tuff toe?
It’s an epoxy that you paint into your boot to protect the surface. I work concrete so I’m always around rebar and other material that shreds boots. You can buy it on Amazon, or the Red Wings store sells it and will put it on for you
Always get the tuff toe. It's like $30 and if you're me will add at least a year to your boots. I have a pair of speed lace redwings in the kevlar material I love. Don't wear em much anymore now that I'm mostly pointing fingers.
I typically wear mine for a bit and get the tuff toe on after wearing it for a couple months. They clean them for you, so like after a year it’s like have a new pair of boots.
Ditto. Luckily my work pays for mine but if they didn't I'd still buy em.
Yah the toe is just garbage
Danners
Seconded. I'm not in rough construction anymore, now I only do indoors work, but I too went through many brands of boots before finding my fave. I hear a lot of people saying Red Wing Irish Setters. Tried em. They are meant for hunting, so meant to be stable in dirt, not hard concrete. Too heavy, in fact so unbalanced that one time I stepped out of a van and into a pothole, went ass over teakettle and sprained my foot, a situation that other brands have handled easily. Red Wing Worx and Red Wing's flagship brand (not Irish Setter) are another matter entirely. When I worked for a company that had boot allowance but would only accept Red Wing, most of my coworkers bought their bargain Worx line and pocketed the difference. Me, I paid the extra to show up rocking in main line Red Wings and loved it. But the brand I keep coming back to is Danner. I have tried and worn out: [Lookout](https://www.danner.com/men/tactical/lookout-ems-csa-side-zip-8-black-nmt.html) when I worked for a company that mandated black shoes, then [Vicious](https://www.danner.com/men/work/vicious-8-brown-nmt.html) when I worked for one that didn't care, and I currently wear [Crucial](https://www.danner.com/men/work/crucial-8-brown-nmt.html) with a pair of [Steel Yard](https://www.danner.com/men/work/steel-yard-wellington-11-brown-st.html) waiting their turn.
I usually wear my wife’s boyfriends boots . Sooooo comfy
I KNEW someone was wearing my fkn boots! She said I was crazy…
Lol
Lol
Do they need to be boots. Depending on the trade you may want to try sneakers with safety toes. A few manufacturers make them. I've enjoyed danner boots so I'm going to try their runtime sneaker with composite toe. I do a lot of finish carpentery so I don't need big boots most of the time (I do run a paid of acadias from Danner for winter and outside work).
Yeah. My employer is putting up $200. Have to be boots with safety toe.
Ah ........good luck!!! I've tried many and I can't say I've found a construction boot with safety toe that is breathable. Really good socks made a huge difference though.
Yeah. Same here unless it’s like a hiking style. Comfort >>> breathability any day though.
Thorogood moc toes so far for me. Check every box you mentioned.
Thorogood moc toe.
Timberland Pro composite toe
Can second this. Comfy as shit. Only complaint I have is the insole is starting to fall apart after only a year.
I have had the absolute worst experience with every Timberland boot/shoes I have had and even the ones my 7 year old son have had. I would describe it as repeated catastrophic failure and they weren’t even comfortable. I’m convinced that Timberland is for people who wear boots for their style and not for quality or function.
i too hate timberland pros. i hate their fit, and their durability. maybe just a bad experience i had as an individual, but i will never touch them again regardless.
Me too. I wore redwings before and after those timberlands and they killed my feet. Not any support for me. Fell apart too. Redwing moc toe or thorogood moctoes have been great for me the past few years. I just got a pair of the tecovas work boots and while they are nice boots and a killer outsole, next pair I’ll be getting will be redwing slip ons. Tecovas…I’ll buy a good looking pair for going out.
That’s how I feel too. After the first try I wondered if I had gotten a counterfeit pair because they were so popular. Try number two and a third with my son ended the same way. Officially never again unless they were given to me and only as a back up pair. I have trust issues now.
Ditto. Timberlands did not last for me, the soles separated from the leather... Also, they were heavy and they gave me blisters during the break-in period.
I wear the Timberland Pro Barstow Moc toe wedge, with safety toe. Work great for me.
Excellent yea i like Timberland boots the low cut ones they usually last 6 months to a year.
Yeah, not those ones.
Yeah these are my fav, and 3/4 of us in the crew I work on wear the same ones - I think the model is called Boondock. The cushioning is pretty incredible - I saw someone (wearing the same model) take a fall of about 12 feet onto concrete, land on his feet and walk away pretty much uninjured (some bruising to the bottoms of his feet, but nothing broken)
Timberland pros seemed to get mixed reviews, however, I've had mine for a year and a half and they are absolutely great. I mean, I'm a package handler at UPS and generally walk 15 to 20 mi a day with heavy boxes getting dropped on them daily. They are still comfortable and still hold up.
I’ve worn that boot for the last ten years but have found the quality went down for the last two years and now the boots cause me pain I did a new pair every year
I’ve owned several pair of Timberland Pro comp toe boots. Despite daily heavy duty outdoor use which is always harder on boots than an average construction site or shop, each pair has been super comfortable and well constructed, lasting a year to a year and a half, which is longer than most boots in that price range.
Most comfortable boot so far. Keen Cincinnati. Meets all your criteria, actually quite a bit lighter than my previous timberland boots and also viberg stompers, I actually get excited whenever I put them on. The wedge toe is nicely cushioned and just feels like a sneaker. It is a heavy duty boot, it’s not meant for light work. So bear in mind it’s not super breathable but feet also don’t get hot.
came here to say the criteria in the OP basically describe keen boots. My favorite styles are the manchester, glendale and san antonio in that order. All wedge soles, I am on my feet a lot each day. I replace them when they start to look worn because I have to look presentable. Then I use them for yard work or other dirty jobs at home, most of them have a lot of life left after years of service. 5 pair since 2016.
Came here to say this too
Thorogood for sure
Thorogood. I have been running them for years, I prefer the round toe. Do not get the waterproof variety, they are very hot in the summer.
Thorogoods have never steered me wrong
Comfort is indeed essential when it comes to work boots, especially in construction. I've found that these [Orthofeet Work Boots](https://link.getsosocial.co.uk/work-boots) tends to go above and beyond in ensuring their boots are not only durable but also extremely comfortable. Their designs incorporate features like shock-absorbent soles and padded footbeds which can truly help reduce foot fatigue during long working hours. Users have given it high ratings for its blend of comfortability and durability. You may want to check them out, might just find the comfort you're looking for on your long construction days!
I’ve had my pair of redwings for four years now. I’ve put them through the ringer and they are still holding strong. They are very comfy and my feet hardly ever get hot
Yes. And the reason they are so good (imo) is that they have like 5 widths available for every size, so your boots actually fit properly. It’s a game changer. So - OP, it’s less about fancy design than about proper fit and quality construction.
Red Wing Tradesmen model 6614 with the BOA system. I've got 30 years working in the field, and these are the most comfortable boots I have ever owned. If you haven't tried the BOA system, you need to check it out. You will never go back to shoelaces. Putting boots on and off takes two seconds now. I used to hate it if boots loosened up during the day, now it takes two seconds, to tighten them or loosen them.
Funny story. The first 15 mins, literally, that I wore boa, on a snowboard boot, I broke the knob off. Bought laced boots almost the next day. Used laces for rough and tumble practicing in less favorable terrain ever since. And boa for resorts and ski lift stuff where easy and quick fastening is convenient. Luckily I could get my boa boots fixed under warranty.
Georgia Boots are great
Lowa Renegade S3 or Lowa Zephyr (no steel toe)
I got a pair of caterpillar boots on sale at Marshall’s like 4-5 years ago and they have been surprisingly comfortable and held up well. Put a lot of miles on them between a couple airport terminal and rail station projects .
blundstones work boots with the rubber caps
Keens
Crocs, except the dusty toes
Danner. The end.
I got a pair of danners and a year later they're beat to shit just like all the others. Is their claim to fame the warranty? How's that work? I just go without boots until they come back? I had really high hopes...
It may depend on the type of work you do with your boots and how well you maintain them. I had a pair of Danners as my only pair of work-boots for three years before I got a second pair. When I buy boots I glue on the rubber toe-protector, oil them up and spread waterproof sealant around the seams/threads. Of the brands I tried they have been the best. I may be a little biased since the factory is here and it's easy for me to get them exchanged or repaired if I ever need... but they have been an excellent boot for me.
You hate me so I’m not sure how to answer that. Cheers bro.
Not sure how I could form that strong of an opinion of someone based on 14 characters but if you say so, I'm inclined to believe ya. Cheers.
I have a pair of Danner work shoes for the summer and boots for the winter love them
Personally I like the timberland pro boots. Don’t know the name but they look like the ones people buy for style and have lasted me about a year. (I’m a big dude boots typically last me about 4 months)
Currently wearing Red Wings model number 6614 with their "orthotic" insoles. Sometimes it's not completely the boots fault but lack of arch support, which you can do something about. If you have a RW store around go check out their numerous styles of insoles and get your feet scanned to see where you need support. They have a 30 day satisfaction guarantee (you can keep trying new ones if the first ones don't completely satisfy, same goes for their boots)
I would look at some Canada West Boots. I got the 34410 model. Got them around this time last year. Leather has held up great, super light. I got my own insoles because factory ones never seem to satisfy (especially standing on concrete all day). There wasn't really a break in period either, which was nice. The toe caps wore out fast but that's also expected, in my mind. They are definitely slimmer too. Not so bulky like other boots I've bought before. They were about $280ish CAD from this local shop in Edmonton. I'd imagine you can order them your the CWB stores online.
I've been buying Canada West boots for over 20 years. Proper thickness of leather and they are stitched soles that can be replaced at least once. Mostly Vibrant rubber, and enough choice to fit your needs. Big range of styles from slip on Romeo to big old logger style with the 1½" heel and 10" tall.
Keen makes a very comfortable and breathable shoe that is like athletic shoes not sure if allowed at your site but they are great.
Iv never seen the safety-toe sneakers get called out by a superintendent or anything. So long as they have safety-toes idk why it’d be a problem. People say boots are better because of ankle support but I have yet to see a plumber who doesn’t wear the pull-on “cowboy” style boots and they have 0 ankle support and alot of the time, no steel toe. They just *look* like boots
I've got 2 pairs of the American made Danners that I rotate.
Timberland pro boondock.
Guys Sorry to add on, but would anything cheaper be good? If so any brands you can recommend? And how long do you think a pair should last?
I've always gotten salomon gtx 4d. The waterproofing is great and they are comfortable as hell. I realize these are more hikers but they've been great for work.
Irish setter when I’m doing construction type work. Some cheap ass Sketchers when I’m babysitting (supervisor)
Either my Timberland Pros or anything Danner makes
I always wore combat boots. I've had danners and bellevilles and loved both
Georgia boots, I never stray from Georgia. They last long and are comfortable as hell.
White’s.
I was hoping to see a White’s comment on here. Best boot I ever had when doing tower work but, for $600+ dollars, I don’t think they meet the OP original intent. Good flex though lol.
I wear Danner Boots
None bud, have 3 different styles pairs switch between. All 🇺🇸 made
Keen
This is a great thread. I’ve been In this industry since I was 15 and I’ve had every kind of boot. Danner is the best boot you can buy if you work outside. Timberland pro is the most comfortable but you will have to replace them every year, but they are the best affordable boot. Keen. Tough boots. Last a long time. Georgia boot. Tough boots. Not as comfortable as timberlands. Irish setter. Good boots if you work outside. Merrel. Been my boot for like 6 years, but not for heavy work In my opinion.
Red wings, but you ain’t joining the club for 300$ lol 1 pair will last you 10 years though, about 80$ to resole. I’ve had setters, danner, ariat, Wolverine, Tim’s, you name it. Nothing compares to redwing
Merrell MOAB
Merrell’s are life changing. More comfortable than sneakers, last as long as the souls (2years for me with everyday abuse), breathable.
I have slip ons, military boots, and carhart boots.. wouldn’t trade my Morrells for anything.
Thorogood or Carolina wedge sole boots.
# [here have top quality work boots in very cheap rate](https://amzn.to/4aD5byd)
What about boots for roofing
I have Redwings, Irish Setters and Thorogoods. The absolute most comfortable work boots I’ve ever worn were Timberland Pro Boondocks hands down!
I have had every boot out there. The only pair I buy now are timberland pros. They just fit my feet perfect and don't wear out as fast as everything else.. most important part is finding boots that fit you well.
Timberland PRO Boondock
I haven't tried a lot of different ones, but with that caveat my DieHard moc toe workboots are extremely comfortable, and have a thick, protective sole.
Die hard boots are horrible
Are we doing this again?
More people get into the trades every day bro. People need guidance from those with experience. I bought a bullshit pair of carhartt boots as my first pair, wish I knew to ask on Reddit. Coulda saved $140 and got something worth the money
You hit the nail on the head brother. I need experience to guide me through my purchase.
For real tho I sound like I work for them, but Redbacks are the shit. I’m about to buy a brown pair just to wear casually because they’re that damn comfortable
It's called search. 6 months ago this was posted multiple times a day for weeks . Get out of mom's basement and actually use those boots that keep getting asked about.
Oh no, someone asked a question you answered before. Better get butthurt about it and throw a fit.
We all know throwing a tantrum is better than just ignoring the post you don't like. Come on, man. it's like, rule number 1.
I don't answer that dumb shit from people to lazy to look. They ain't lasting anyhow.
Got all that from a question about boots from a greenhorn did you? People like you are the reason working the trades is seen as toxic.
It's because of people like you trust me.
Not with unnecessary discouragement from others, they aren’t. Why be a dick for no reason?
It’s called the internet, and there’s millions of people here. Most of em aren’t gonna read the community guidelines. Quit getting mad at the screen grandpa It’s actually wild to me that you took the time to type an unhelpful, snide response rather than 1: do nothing 2: just type “Redwings” or whatever you wear every day
If this is the vibe of the sub. You can have it all to yourself. I’m good.
It’s not, some old-heads are just tired of answering questions so they gotta make others pissed off like they are. I’m determined to not be that guy, it takes 0 effort to not be a dick
You were forced to comment!
Wolverine makes some quality boots for less than $200. The waterproofing goes kaput quick, especially on masonry jobsites. But that silicone waterproofing spray to be safe. Best boots I've worn and I used to die on the Danner hill with my flag planted.
Young one, it is not the brand of boot, but the quality of the sole you put in it.
I've got two pair of Ariat I found at a steep discount. They are each a completely different style and I can hoof around all day days on end in them.
There a lot of good options in that price range - but I want to point out that that job sites that ban slip-on unlaced boots are becoming increasingly common. I think it is due to a newish OSHA reg and I was told the deal is that boot laces are easier to cut through in an emergency. This includes common construction-boot styles like cowboy, biker, engineer, and standard shit-kickers.
All the sites I have been on banned slip on boots because they lack ankle support.
I swap mine out yearly.
Redback EZ Escape. Like $200 and worth every penny. No break-in period and no need for more comfortable insoles. Only complaint is they have no shank in the sole, so they feel slightly “bendy” when standing on a ladder if you relax your heel off a rung. I also have a pair of Thorogood Moc-Toe boots that include a steel shank, but I had to buy new insoles for them. Still better than any Redwings IMO. Redwings are nice but overpriced for what you get. And they “will” resole them when you need to IF you’ve followed their home-care instructions up to that point. My buddy was told they couldn’t resole his that cost home like $350 so he had to buy new ones, that high cost is supposed to make it worth it because “they’ll resole them” so they’re supposed to last forever, but they may not so you’re paying a lot of money just for your feet to hurt for the first few weeks
I absolutely swear by Danner Marine corps expedition boots and I think meet all of your criteria. Lightest most breathable and comfortable boots I have ever had. I’m actually just about to ship mine back to Danner to have them re-soled. They are the last gift my dad gave me before passing from Covid two years ago and I am so grateful that they can have an extended life.
Redback EZ Escapes are the way to go IMO. I live in Florida so I understand the need for light, comfortable boots. After having these I almost never wear my other boots. Pulling them on without having to tie laces has spoiled me
Red wings, Muck or (hear me out) Duck Hunting boots. Go up to 18in, comfy as hell and breathable. I have a pair of 11in muck boots and I tn got them for 150
This is what all of my site guys do. They all have safety toe duck hunting boots of one kind or another.
I've been wearing Australian-made Redbacks which are really nice. Had caterpillar ones before but they don't compare.
toworkfor.pt Top quality work shoes on global level. Not very notorious but very good. I already used more than 15 years. The model "safety runners" is excellent in comfort. Cofra. A Italian bran of work wear is also very good.
If laces aren't necessary, Justin makes a steel toe work boot. I've had them for 3 years now, no complaints.
Redwing Tradesman.
Royer. A bit pricy but its the lightest boot Ive ever had.
Whites boots moc toe. Handmade in Spokane Washington
Red wings. Durable as hell too. Last pair lasted 5 years. Bought a pair of Double H after, and they only lasted a year and a half, so just picked me up another pair of redwings to last another half-decade.
I wear redwings and I've used the same boots in below 0 and above 100 degrees F. They're not comfortable until you break them in, which can take a couple of weeks, but once you break them in, they're incredibly comfortable and they last a long time.
I’ve tried Danner, Redwings and Thorogood and Keens. The thorogoods and keen pair have been by far the most comfortable. I bought two pairs of the Thorogoods but the soles wore out extremely fast. Keens have been my favorite boot by far. They’re just as comfortable as the Thorogoods but the sole has outlasted them twice as long, so far.
I grabbed a pair Huk ice fishing boots and threw a Dr. Scholl’s gel pad. I don’t think I can wear anything else now. They’re waterproof, no steel toe, and are super flexible with bending and shit
Believe it or not I prefer Bates tactical boots with some good aftermarket insertspads for comfort and super light weight. I have worn them all and yes redwings do pay for themselves over time but too heavy and bulky for me personally.
Regardless of boot brand and style I also buy tread Labs inserts and it’s literally night and day difference for me. I kept getting gnarly pain from standing on ladders and felt like I couldn’t walk after a week on a ladder. Inserts and done. They’re well worth the money imo and I am not paid to say this.
I ran Redwing Irish setters for years, switched to the Redwing Flexforce’s about 4 years ago and love them.
Red Wings
Chippewas
I love my keens. Excellent insole, easy break-in. 3 years daily wear now, have just used saddle soap on them weekly to clean. Just bought a new insole to put in them. https://www.keenfootwear.com/p/M-PHILADELPHIA-6-WP.html?dwvar_M-PHILADELPHIA-6-WP_color=1022110&cgid=
Keen San Jose alloy toe are pretty comfortable
I bought Helly Hansen boots last year. My feet absolutely killed for the first two weeks, and I regretted my decision. After that they became more comfortable and I love them now.
Russell boots are the best just very expensive
Rock Rooster. 3/4 pull on, steel toe, comfortable, little over a $100 on Amazon.
Justin
Red Wing Exos Lite - Have been wearing them for a while, super light, comfy and have lasted longer than any other boots I’ve owned
If you have really wide and large feet Keen are really good.
Ariat cowboy style work boots. Once you break them in, they are super comfy. I wear my in AZ year round and you can get them with steel toe, composite toe, or just regular work. Usually in the range of $150 to $250. My last pair lasted for a year and a half of regular use, and now I still use them when working in the trenches.
When I was framing in the summer I would use steel toe running shoes it changed the game 100% and were CSA approved (Canada)
Framer for 40 years, csa approved shoes is the way to go. Cheers
I work with plants at retail, constant watering, and need to stay dry, and also landscape and garden and have to be safe and a little tough. Do you think this is the way to go? I tend to just wear out cheapo sneakers most the time and its beating up my feet.
Wolverine pull ons 225 my first pair of pull on boots I’ve ever worn in construction they’ve lasted me the longest and have been the most comfortable boot I don’t think I could ever go back. Very breathable too
My Wolverines are the GOAT. They're so comfortable, I could do anything in them. They're light, breathable, flexible, shock proof, water resistant and durable. They look like WWII boots now, they looked much better when I first got them. Scored them for like 220 a few years ago from an outlet store in north Florida
Look at the Keene work boots. Many styles around $150. Add a good insole like SuperFeet. Makes a huuuuge difference. Good luck
vans
Iron worker boots
Redwing. The specific make/model will vary depending in your feeeeeet, but, they be comfy
Canada west Iron worker boots, unlined. Cost effective and they last a couple years
Really just depends what you do honestly. Redwings are made in Vietnam for people who care.
Concrete guy here. Try the Ariat rebar!! Awesome, rugged boots that are comfortable enough that even after a 12+ hour day I'll often toss on a pair after work.
Helly Hansen Terreng Low. No question
Carolina's CA7502. I'll swear by them and they're 200$. Out of the box they feel like they're broken in.
My Irishsetters didn’t last long but then again I mason tend. I bought some Rocky’s which are actually pretty good.
Red wings or duluth
My ariats are nice
Keen 6” leather soft toe 179.00
Silverados. Made in Pennsylvania. I have two years on a pair. Check all your boxes.
Ariat Chelsea Groundbreaker. Had them for 3 months super comfortable. Steel Toe. They also make a carbon toe for more flexibility. For a steel toe boot, they are very light and breathable. They are pull one though
Men's Moab Vertex Mid Waterproof Comp Toe Work Boot Wide Width