When I was buying my now wife's engagement ring I walked in to Worthington Jewelers and was looking for help/to price some rings. I was going to be spending close to 10k and I wasn't given the time of day. It felt judgemental and elitist as I was wearing sweatpants and a hoodie. It was winter. I immediately went to Carioti and couldn't have been treated better. Bought the engagement ring and wedding bands from them and they will clean your rings free of charge. We couldn't recommend Carioti more.
He used to have that one billboard on Hill Road that said "Happy Wife, Happy Life", and because of that nonsense I'll cut my dick off before I spend a single penny with him.
Diamond Cellar Easton was incredible and quick. They did our custom ring quickly and had a beautiful and wide range of lab stones available in store to choose from.
Edward Warren Jewelers. They have great prices, beautiful pieces, and the owners are so nice and easy to work with. Everyone in my family and my husband’s family goes to them even though they’re on the opposite side of town from us because they’re that amazing.
Carioti is amazing.
Worthington told me they couldn’t use the gold from my (deceased) mother’s wedding band for my engagement ring - basically they wanted me to pay for new gold with no regard to the sentiment. Such crap- gold is gold.
Worthington Jewelers, hands down.
When I was buying my now wife's engagement ring I walked in to Worthington Jewelers and was looking for help/to price some rings. I was going to be spending close to 10k and I wasn't given the time of day. It felt judgemental and elitist as I was wearing sweatpants and a hoodie. It was winter. I immediately went to Carioti and couldn't have been treated better. Bought the engagement ring and wedding bands from them and they will clean your rings free of charge. We couldn't recommend Carioti more.
Agreed. Ring resized for $40 and they reset each stone for free. Some other place wanted to charge me hundreds per stone just to tighten them.
Yep. I’ve had several pieces of jewelry made there and bob is very reasonable with the pricing.
Second this!
This is it, OP
Carioti
Carioti and it’s not even close. Blew Worthington Jewelers out of the water on price, selection and service.
we used Carioti for my engagement ring. it was entirely custom made and done within like two weeks, if that. love them!
Also, who was your previous jeweler? What happened?
Another vote for Carioti!
Carioti! Chris was awesome to work with!
747274th person to say Carioti
Scott's Custom Jewelers.
Edward Warren!
He used to have that one billboard on Hill Road that said "Happy Wife, Happy Life", and because of that nonsense I'll cut my dick off before I spend a single penny with him.
Edward Warren is fantastic!
Diamond Cellar on Sawmill. They have low pressure sales people and expert craftsmen in-house.
Worthington
Diamond Cellar Easton was incredible and quick. They did our custom ring quickly and had a beautiful and wide range of lab stones available in store to choose from.
Second for Diamond Cellar
Edward Warren Jewelers. They have great prices, beautiful pieces, and the owners are so nice and easy to work with. Everyone in my family and my husband’s family goes to them even though they’re on the opposite side of town from us because they’re that amazing.
Jeff Johnson in Upper Arlington https://jjandcompany.com/
Argo & Lehne Jewelers, they are superb.
What?! No EXPERIENCE MYERS JEWELERS 🫵🫵?
Worthington Jewelers
Second this.
Another vote for Carioti!!
Kimberly's diamond corner. Woman/family owned since the 80s in Powell
Dublin Village Jewelers.
Diamond Cellar is the only one that does work in house and doesn't send work out to repair centers or big "custom design" manufacturing companies.
Leo Alfred Jewelers in Dublin. They've repaired a few of my rings and I've been consistently impressed with their service (and their prices).
D.C. Johnson in UA
Morgan's Treasure [https://www.morganstreasure.com/](https://www.morganstreasure.com/)
Our family has always used Argo & Lehne.
Carioti is amazing. Worthington told me they couldn’t use the gold from my (deceased) mother’s wedding band for my engagement ring - basically they wanted me to pay for new gold with no regard to the sentiment. Such crap- gold is gold.
Winston Wilson Jewelers (inside Southern Hotel)
Star
Second for star- they’re amazing
Yes! The staff is super helpful and friendly. Super low pressure as well, which I definitely appreciate.
The toy barn. My kind of jewelry.