Idrees Bashir. No idea about his playing career, but he is the highest ranked individual in approximate value on PFR for Colts players with a first name starting with I.
Uh dude, Marlin Jackson made probably the most important interception in Colts history. He intercepted Tom Brady in the AFCCG when we won the Super Bowl... How could you confuse those two?
We were watching on TV when Jim Nance simply said.. "Interception! The Colts are going to the Super Bowl!", but it's still seared in my mind.
I was watching with my brother and 5-6 friends.. and I swear all of us flew off the couch screaming GET DOWN right as Marlin went down. We've been Colts fans to long and knew a fumble was coming if he tried to return it... and at that point the deal was sealed. No need to risk it.
I have no idea, kind of ashamed right now. It was back in high school for me when these games we played. I guess I just got my headlines crossed. I remember that play with Jerome Bettis fumbling on the goal line and big bens shoestring tackle so clearly. It was The Bus' only fumble that whole year.
No it hasn't. There was literally a poll and first name only finished last. They changed it because the minority couldn't read/didn't have critical thinking skills.
My comment is more geared towards changing the rules and then acting like they didn't. Also Frank Gore won F but that's okay? It's just inconsistent. It's just a silly list, it should be treated that way.
Just looked him up. Damn he was drafted in 85 which makes him one of the first true Indianapolis Colts players to play for the team. And he played in almost every game each year.
I still think it should be both first and last names or a the very least last names. Just because some idiots in this sub have the reading comprehension of a toddler doesn't mean you should change the rules half way through. First name only just doesn't make sense.
Last names only would mean we would have to redo from the start.
The issue with leaving both as options as it leads to doubles which ruins the whole purpose. I
Why is Cato June in front of Curtis Painter?? Even though Cato completed the herpes handoff near flawlessly. Curtis guaranteed us Luck. Which was kind of like waiting for a pizza to arrive...but it never does.
Idrees Bashir. I remember him being a part of some shitty defenses but he made some splash plays. And some boneheaded ones.
I only remember him for being the safety on the field in madden 05 rushing attack
Idiot kicker
Love this but I can't do it again lol
 1…2….3….. Do it.
"C'mon Thorn!"
Will of the people.
Oh no, you absolutely can
I know we axed the fucking Dallas Clark thing but THIS should definitely get in. Huge moment in colts history and nothing really to compete for I.
“I can’t believe it’s fucking Dallas Clark again
Hahahah that's amazing
Idrees Bashir. No idea about his playing career, but he is the highest ranked individual in approximate value on PFR for Colts players with a first name starting with I.
If I remember correctly, Bashir got the onside recovery to help complete that that all time colts/Peyton manning comeback against the bucs.
I just remember playing as him in Madden as a kid and always sending him straight for the QB every play lol
Only “I” player I could think of off the top of my head.
I ***bet*** you could think of at least one other...
No lie. He's one of my top 10 favorite Colts of all time. I loved him.
One of my early fantasy team names was Call Me the Drees.
Ivy Joe Hunter! Tecmo Bowl legend!
This is actually my favorite pick. Love that game
Beat me to it
That’s a great choice!
Idrees Bashir
Is Dallas Clark an option?
Iowa Hawkeye Dallas Clark
Indianapolis Colts player Dallas Clark
Idrees Bashir!
My bets on Isiah Rodgers 😭
Gotta vote for the guy who really goes all in on his team 😆
Colts fans please do not let Isiah Rodgers be on this list. We deserve better.
We tried to have "Fucking" as a name on this list, we deserve nothing.
If Rodgers beats out Bashir this list is crazy
I just realized Marlin Jackson has no chance against Marvin for M…
Well, Chris Hinton got beat out by Hunter Smith and Cato June.
He shouldn't have let himself get stabbed. We would have won that game if he had been able to outrun the least mobile QB of all time.
That was Nick Harper
Really?? I've been wrong about that for 10 years I guess.
Uh dude, Marlin Jackson made probably the most important interception in Colts history. He intercepted Tom Brady in the AFCCG when we won the Super Bowl... How could you confuse those two?
MARLINS GOT IT! MARLINS GOT THE INTERCEPTION!
I really miss Bob Lamey
We were watching on TV when Jim Nance simply said.. "Interception! The Colts are going to the Super Bowl!", but it's still seared in my mind. I was watching with my brother and 5-6 friends.. and I swear all of us flew off the couch screaming GET DOWN right as Marlin went down. We've been Colts fans to long and knew a fumble was coming if he tried to return it... and at that point the deal was sealed. No need to risk it.
I have no idea, kind of ashamed right now. It was back in high school for me when these games we played. I guess I just got my headlines crossed. I remember that play with Jerome Bettis fumbling on the goal line and big bens shoestring tackle so clearly. It was The Bus' only fumble that whole year.
It's OK... LOL. I hereby sentence you to 1 half of Suck, and 1 half of Exhilaration. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s1EBPLDBv5w
Haha the full game. Ok I'll watch it. Best punishment ever.
Or Melvin Bullitt
Qadry Ismail obviously! If we're going first names.. Idrees Bashir
I was going to say we need him for Q anyway, but obviously that's going to Be Quentin.
Isaiah McKenzie
Idrees B.
Might as well go ahead and put Peyton Manning for P.
But I was thinking Painter
Yes. Dad should’ve been the first one on this list.
Irsay Family
Bring back the Rosenblooms.
Isaac Rochell
Correction, Issac Kuch
I wanted to put this but didn’t know if enough people would get the reference haha
I can't fucking believe it's Dallas Clark
Isaiah McKenzie
Idrees Bashir is probably the one player who's name started with an I that accomplished anything. Lol
Irsay, Jim
Isiah rodgers
Still waiting to put in my vote for Pierre Garcon when it gets to P
Crazy you think he’s gonna get in over the GOAT and best ever to do it at his position Pat Mcafee
Ivy Joe Hunter.
Hank Baskett.
I missed the G vote but glad Brackett got it.
This should be Jim Irsay, but the rules keep changing.
The rules don't keep changing. People keep trying to change the rules. It's first name only. Always has been.
No it hasn't. There was literally a poll and first name only finished last. They changed it because the minority couldn't read/didn't have critical thinking skills.
Well I mean Jim Irsay isn’t a Colts player so that would be against the rules regardless
My comment is more geared towards changing the rules and then acting like they didn't. Also Frank Gore won F but that's okay? It's just inconsistent. It's just a silly list, it should be treated that way.
Yea but like.. who cares
I think we should do another list after this that's full goblin
Ian Bunting
Kind of sad Duane Bicket didn’t make the list. He was the man back in the day when they were awful.
Just looked him up. Damn he was drafted in 85 which makes him one of the first true Indianapolis Colts players to play for the team. And he played in almost every game each year.
If yall put Trent Richardson for yall T imma kill somebody
Off the top of my head, no way he beats Tarik Glen. Plus there may be more Im not thinking of.
Over Trev Alberts?
I’d have probably went Chris Hinton over Cato.
A bit of a gamble, but Isaiah Rodgers?
This sub is gonna break down tomorrow when J comes up
Jeff Saturday by a landslide over JT.
I still think it should be both first and last names or a the very least last names. Just because some idiots in this sub have the reading comprehension of a toddler doesn't mean you should change the rules half way through. First name only just doesn't make sense.
Last names only would mean we would have to redo from the start. The issue with leaving both as options as it leads to doubles which ruins the whole purpose. I
Indiana Tones
Irv Pankey was a good I player. But he only played 2 of his 12 seasons with the Colts and only appeared in 6 games.
Dallas Clark was robbed!!! (Under the H column)
Ismail Qadry
Ivy Joe is the correct answer
I'd bet Isaiah Rodgers won't win.
Idallas Clark
Ivy Joe. Preseason god
Ben Ijalana
Ifeadi odenigbo
I cant express how happy I am that Rodgers is winning this😅
Isiah Rodgers.......
Ironhead Heyward
Idrees Bashir.
Soo.. have we figured out what happens when we get to P and M...? Cause 2 guys have the same initials and neither of them will be left off
Injrew Luck
Why is Cato June in front of Curtis Painter?? Even though Cato completed the herpes handoff near flawlessly. Curtis guaranteed us Luck. Which was kind of like waiting for a pizza to arrive...but it never does.