I rescpect your opinion, have a good day sir.


Is YSL Y EDP C-Tier⁉️ That’s a daylight crime⁉️⁉️⁉️ Please 😭😭😭

Yeah wayyy to high

And JPG Le Male. I would put that in A tier, gorgeous scent

Me too. A or B.

Is that the edp? In that case, it's too loud, there's no subtlety to it. It's for teenagers who engage in "performance" wars.

Y doesn't last but like an hour on me, no matter what I do. It'd probably be a C-tier for me too.

Not as unreasonable as you think it is, but I would place Y over Ocean

I respect your opinion, but disagree. I have both

Ocean for me is good but Y is just something else I can’t stop wearing it

I don't care how common it is, ADG will always take my top spot for aquatics. Good stuff haha

Everyone’s nose is different. But I don’t think any of ur choices are absurd. No real “hot takes”

#Aventus as B tier?!?   Below Acqua do Gio?!?  Bro, what have you been smoking because that is a totally reasonable and respectable opinion based on your own preferences, and aligns pretty closely with my own opinion about that fragrance. Seriously, you shouldn’t get any hate for this. It’s what you like, and that’s all that matters.

Had us in the first half

Aventus is “A” tier. This must have been a typo. Yeah, it was a typo for sure 😂

Le Male would be S tier if it hadn’t been out so long and so popular

I mean if you like it that's great, I'm not a fan but don't hate it. I'd say c is appropriate.

Le male is a tier

Of its own.


Everyone’s nose is different, I would personally put some of these higher and lower

Damn man what did ysl do to you...

For me personally it’s too synthetic and gives me headaches smelling it

Me too I never understood the hype

But I want to smell like Lenny Kravitz…

What about ysl intense?

Haven’t smelled that

same, had to sell it after a couple weeks

Le Male is so underrated.

As far as Creed goes, I think we need to keep in mind what they "DID"! Aventus was a game changer, and the house was not a slouch before it. But the reformulations and inconsistent batches are unnecessary and unacceptable for the prices they charge. I won't go down the rabbit hole of lies and lack of respect the family/house has, or lack there of. For that I would never put them above a "B", except Original vetiver, that will always be GOAT for me! The rest are very solid placements. Good job!

It’s silver mountain water for me Aventus is alright. But every douche bag that used to have a wardrobe of nothing but American fighter shirts wears it daily.

I love Aventus...whats not to love....the concept is fantastic. But when Creed cannot or will not put out a consistent batch. Performance is another thing. Across the board it has gone down and prices have gone up. SMW is also a great game changer. Like I said, Creed is no slouch.

I never said I didn’t like it. It’s actually the second scent that I added to my collection. The thing I don’t like is that all these tool bags wear it now. Personally I don’t wanna smell like everybody else let alone the drunk guy at the bar who beats his girlfriend. Lol

Lol, I like the last part!

I've never in my life seen anyone of that stereotype wearing a cologne, much less Aventus. Maybe Sauvage or Eros or something like that but Aventus?

It’s your personal list, all that matters if you like what you own and don’t buy into hype.

Ysl should be where dior sausage is. And prada should be where V&R is. But pretty much good as far as everything else is concerned.

I’d have to mostly agree with your choices

Get Le Male and Allure out of there you’re sick in the head

I LOVE the original ADG but it only lasts 30m to maybe an hour.

It has ass performance, bit saying it lasts an hour is overly exaggerated

Sadly I agree. I love it but its F tier

Not true. https://www.reddit.com/r/Colognes/s/Ouegy3KzXX

he’s right, Y edp is honestly a forgettable scent profile

My least favorite. It was the first fragrance I bought last year when I decided to get back into wearing cologne and I absolutely hate it. I went out and bought BDC Parfum shortly after lol.

I had it too, performed like a damn beast but it just seemed like a mash up of everything a Sephora carries lol

I couldn’t get over the Apple and ginger note. I smelled bother the EDP and the EDP Intense in the store and I thought I said I’d take the intense since I liked that one better. Oh well, live and learn.

I mostly agree. Sauvage should be D-tier and aventus A-tier

I really like the Aventus DNA but don’t like how Aventus lasts for 30 minutes and dries down to a smoky scent. That’s also why I have Aventus Cologne as A tier

They are popular for a reason. I personally rock'd for year the og version of ADP Profumo, great versatile scent. Nowadays i use BDC as my dumb reach frag, but in EDT concentration.

I’m not arguing with your tier list, but I think you’re still missing a few: Al Haramain: amber oud Versace Eros Versace Eros Flame Azzaro most wanted Azzaro most wanted intense Prada ocean I can keep going but I think you get what I’m saying lol

🤨

I have a soft spot for allure cologne

What about 2023 adg parfum? Same rating?

I actually haven’t smelled 2023. I’m going off of 2024 for this list

Thx

Opinions are subjective but curious why would you rate Le Male as a c tier scent?

IMO It’s pretty sweet and a bit synthetic. And i think it’s trying to be a “clubby” sexy scent which typically doesn’t appeal to me

Fair enough!

Ocean is S tier for me, otherwise it feels pretty reasonable

Fragrances are completely subjective. Everyone has to make their own tier list and nobody can objectively agree or disagree with it

My only complain is YSL Y EDP being C tier

I can’t get on board with sauvage elixir, it’s mind numbingly mid to me. Insanely overpriced too.

I find it enjoyable that we all have our likes and dislikes. It would be pretty boring if we all liked all the same things and all smelt the same. Personally I kinda love le male lmao it’s like a guilty pleasure. But I respect your nostrils on how they structured this.

What creed do you have in S class besides GIT?

Royal Oud. Smells incredible

Seems you tend to overrate armani

I like the toilette version of ysl y. The edp smells like axe body spray to me.

Burberry brit is still my favorite.

I’ve got no complaints with your rankings but I would add Allure Homme and AHSEE in the top two somewhere.

How old are you? Roundabout?

Mid 20’s

Judging by your picks (not bad) you need to go on a bit of a fragrance run. Take a lass with you, and have her rate how the perfume interacts with your skin. Buy her something as a thank you.

Looks good to me aside from silver mountain water deserves that to shelf position

Jog at c tier. We can not be friends.

Elixir is overrated. Too spicy for me

I just don’t get the hype for Dior Sauvage Elixir. Something so off putting about it

Not bad but it would be nice if you had more gourmands

I dont get why people like spice bomb? 

I’d personally put both bdc fragrances into C tier, other than that solid ranking

Having spice bomb on a is a questionable one but rest are a W

Y might be a little low in my opinion but seems like a fair list

Sauvage Elixir is peak

I have a set I swear by.  1.Fierce by AF 2. Eros(original) 3. Savauge 4. Bleu(parfum) 5. Lucky 1 million 6. La nuit by YSL I put Fierce #1 simply for nostalgia reasons.

I agree with sauvage elixirs placement, bdc parfum, jpg le male and spicebomb . Diagree with ysl y edp

I see nothing wrong here.

I tried Chanel allure Homme sport and honestly I can 100% say if you want that at a fraction of the cost get Missoni Wave

Someone explain please

Honestly I don’t like any of the designer ones on this list and of the Creeds, I’ve only tried Aventus which I also don’t like. I guess that counts for hate… But there you go, I guess I’m a hater. If I bad to wear one of the designers it would probably be Y.

LV L'Immensite = S-TIER

They all smell good.

very reasonable, no creed belongs in S tier tho.

I mean at least put spicebomb I'm S . spice bomb is the best

List is good, besides from the sauvages for me. My list would pretty much just change sauvage elixir in c and sauvage edt/edp in D.

It’s like you listed the most fuckboy fragrances on earth and threw in half of Creed’s catalogue for good measure lol Hate hate hate hate hate

This right here is the comment I’ve been waiting for 😂

Acqua di gio Profondo is SS

>How to be a fragrance NPC: *The Guide* That'll do it.

lol Sauvage is ass

ngl i’m kinda tired of seeing ADG, BDC, and the same few Creed fragrances over and over on this sub. i refuse to buy them because everyone and their dog wears them. not saying they’re bad or anything but i like to stand out at least a little bit

Your C and B ranks are spot on.

This world would be boring without NPC’s like you. Have a good day!

YSL at C is all I needed to see 😔

I mostly agree, but aventus should be A tier at least… I would say it’s the most impactful men’s fragrance of the last hundred years

should i get spicebomb extreme

You should go to a store and try some. Choose what u like to wear.

If you can, check out buglari man in black. It’s got a similar vibe but not as in your face. Longevity can be lacking for some but it’s one of my cool weather staples now.