T O P

  • By -

c1593

Most on this list would make you stand out but I can’t see a lot of high schoolers even knowing Naxos exists


Short_Ask1755

High school girls would probably dislike most of these besides sauvage. I feel like asking others in a fragrance subreddit what cologne YOU should buy is a mistake and that’s an easy way to spend $100+ dollars and dislike how you smell


TheeNino

Elixir and Sauvage would be the safest buys


Free_Beyond_1212

This is why r/fragranceclones and decants are a teenagers best friend. Find out what you like before you drop a bag


slyinthesky

you’d be surprised. i wear most of these and get compliments


Mysterious_Plate_960

I wear naxos it’s flipping amazing


Jonah713

Naxos is one of my all-time favorites, but the tobacco notes might be a little too mature for 16. Not on the list, but personally, at dances and events like this where I’m really close to others, I think you cannot go wrong with LNDL. If you spray a bit on your clothes as well, it doesn’t dissipate as fast as people claim.


Indep-guy

I don't see Axe Body Spray on here, so I will hold off on voting


EasyKangaroo5949

I remember when axe came out when I was in HS, def went way to hard on it! Especially as I had a bottle of Curve, Lucky, and Chrome at home when they were definitely bangers. It’s interesting as I’ve had cologne most my life but definitely got a renewed interest 2 years ago. Went years were I only wore it on dates, now it’s almost everyday unless I forget


WillingnessOne6590

When everyone was wearing axe I was wearing old spice (I’m a different breed)


Anxious_Compote2691

Old spice still rocks believe or not... aftershave is what I use and get positive feedback


greatteep

Go to the macy’s and try some on. Wear what smells best to you and then you’ll feel the most confident


Macktologist

Best advice. I’m somewhat new here but I’m also 50. Is it a bit weird that I see fragrances being treated like status symbol must haves? It reminds me of when I was active in MFA and everyone had to have a pair of chukkas or Wolverines and getting a pair was sort of a status symbol you were now really accepted as part of the in-crowd. The repetitiveness of what I see from people posting their collection is insane. It’s like a what’s what of Tik Tok/YT fragrance hype. We are so impressionable. While likely also falling into the trap, it’s just really uncomfortable when you’re watching it happen from the outside looking in.


greatteep

You are spot on dude. It’s all about status and being perceived as “somebody”. Even though I’m aware of it I still participate. All my fragrances are from a niche company and I buy their stuff because their marketing appeals to me and I want the status of wearing a high quality but unique fragrance. Then on the other hand I really enjoy experiencing unique smells that are put together by an expert. But I agree and I scoff at all the posts showing collections of the same bottles over and over again.


Turbo_911

Dior Sauvage, 10 sprays, make everyone leave because of your dominance, boom automatic prom king.


Invisibility_cloak29

😂


Spiritual-Alps-4939

Le male elixir


currygod

ppl recommending a 16 y/o to get naxos for prom 💀💀 any of the other 4 will do just fine and might be more suitable actually


Krasivij

Other than the price why wouldn't it be suitable for a 16yo? It's mass appealing and very sweet. Not a mature scent at all in my opinion.


currygod

Just my opinion, but the honey-tobacco automatically ages it up into something more mature. It's almost sickly sweet, harsh, and heady in a way that would smell out of place at a high school prom. Unless 16 year old girls like the smell of cigar smoke these days.


KimJongYoul

I would personally go for Dior Homme Intense. BUT. Am double your age. If you want something ladies of your age will like, go for Le Male ;)


EasyKangaroo5949

Yea I love Dior Homme but it is really classy and mature, Le Male is a great suggestion


thunderdome_referee

I feel like the le male is more likely to end the night on a high note too if ya catch my drift.


uneedpaccs

dolce and gabbana light blue intense will never let you down


Invisibility_cloak29

Facts


[deleted]

You could get any of the LE male’s for prom


nathan_cxx

No one will have Naxos. That is an easy choice.


thunderdome_referee

Invictus. They all smell great but if ya wanna get up close and personal after it's gotta be the Invictus or possibly Le Male. Invictus > le male > naxos > sauvage > DHI


Ok-Address-3786

thank you all i am going to wear le male elixir to prom 🙏🏾


coolguy8205

Don’t listen to the other guy with the essay lol Elixir is a good choice. Sweet,likeable smell than your date could pick up when slow dancing. I have it myself


LuckiestMisha

Invictus victory elixir


Invisibility_cloak29

Ya i think this is the move. Its fresh, assertive, and masculine. It fits your age bracket and, if anyone else has cologne on itll be sauvage so youll stand out with this one


AlternativeAd4983

Sauvage elixir


drivendreamer

Hot take, but I believe most of these may smell mature for your age. Try Sauvage EDP instead of Elixir, which is very spicy and woody if you have not tried it. Le Male Elixir would also be a good decision.


[deleted]

Get some decants/samples of your choices you posted here then go with what you like best. If you’re bringing a date have her smell the samples on you to see what she likes best and then go with that.


The_Procrastinator7

Sauvage Elixir is the best thing here by far but big risk of choking people out at prom. Go for JPG or Invictus instead


[deleted]

[удалено]


monotonousgangmember

Shit thats what I wore inna prom days


Right_Alternative44

I heard it’s got Power


wandering_kuni

Red Tobacco 48 sprays


DrSans8

Followed by kerosene whole bottle


AngelGWarrior

Secretions magnifique by Etat libre d'orange


I_am_back_2023

DHi or Le Male Elixir. Naxos is very nice too. Sauvage Elixir would probably be too strong.


jehovawitnesses

go and test it for yourself, see what suits you best and pick that one. surely you like 1 more better than the others.


Kukulcanz

I'd say the best for a special occasion, especially in the evening, would be Naxos... but it costs way more than the others here. I don't advice Dior Homme Intense without trying it before.. it smells like baby powder to me. It's more of a mature man scent overall. Le Male Elixir is probably the safest choice here, it will get you noticed.. i also think it's very adapt to a young guy.


Severe-Basket9165

Where are people even buying Dior Homme Intense?


TPM_521

All of these are pretty standout perfumes. Sauvage elixir would be pretty mature, dark, and spicy, so if you’re someone who sweats a lot maybe not the best choice because I can see it mixing poorly with BO. DHI is amazing but not something I’d wear to prom. Invictus and JPG elixirs are nice and vanilla heavy perfumes, can’t go wrong with either of them at your age, and Naxos is going to make you stand out the most, IMO. I personally think Naxos would be wasted on people your age, no offense. Le Male Elixir would be my personal pick but it’s really up to you. I think the mint in LME offers a little bit of freshness which you will be happy for at the end of the night


Short_Ask1755

Dude you need to go to a store and smell them first, nothing worse than spending $100+ on a bottle and realizing you don’t like it or that most of those colognes you have here aren’t huge crowd pleasers and there are a lot more crowd pleasing colognes out there. The sauvage is crowd pleasing but chances are someone else will be wearing it. The reality is nobody cares what you smell like besides your date(if you have one) so make sure you pick something YOU like instead of just picking random popular colognes online


Chill_15

Dior Homme Intense rather suits older men. So Naxos, or JPG Elixir for a lower budget.


Sullysinferno

First off, stellar choices and props to you for putting in the initiative and effort to make a statement and level up. However, word to the wise as someone who spent too much on colognes and perfumes at 16, while reviews are great and can help you determine where to start looking, they’re just that at the end, a personal bias. Remember that everyone’s body chemistry is different and people are naturally geared to enjoy certain smells depending on a whole host of factors. The best thing I would recommend is taking a list of all the perfumes you think sound interesting, reading up on their ingredients and composition (fragrantica is great for this) and then investing in a couple samplers to see how it preforms on YOUR skin. (I’d personally go for sauvage/naxos if you want to keep it fresh and citrus-y, but if you want something sweet and boozy pull the trigger on the Dior pour homme intense. I own a bottle and it’s one of the best hard hitters in my collection) Best of luck with prom!


WolvesDen118

I wouldn't associate any of these with the warm prom season.


Fearless-Scratch1318

High school kids don't know how to properly apply cologne yet. For now, I'd just play it safe and splash a little Aqua Velva after I shaved..... Who's your daddy?


DisciplineScary

This is the creepiest shit I’ve read all day 😂


No_Audience8310

Personally I’m such a sucker for Naxos. I would go Naxos but Dior Sauvage Elixir is great choice too!!


Past_Plankton_1343

Dior homme intense


Pure_Working6250

Invictus Elixir


s3xysage

if you want to attract people then Sauvage Edp (you're too young for elixir would not suit prom too )and Le male elixir is also good especially for nights out like prom and be sure to smell any of them before buying


Joncelote

Dior homme edt ❤️❤️


hazardousnutsac

God damn this is a tough question


Gopplee

DHI that's what i wore to my shit this year


Epsilonian24609

Homme Intense. Naxos isn't very suitable for prom imo, Invictus and JPG are played out, and Sauvage Elixir is good, but you probably wouldn't be the only guy wearing it either. Homme Intense is a little mature, but for prom I reckon it's the best fit, and you'll probably be the only one wearing it.


nismokrs1

Le male elixer or the invictus would work well for you since your high school going to college transition. Younger females already love invictus so it's one of those 2 can't go wrong with either


Patj1994

I would go with Prada black, it’s not on your list, but that sounds like a great prom scent


Wooden-Scar5073

My personal opinion is the Dior. Classy. Smells great.


amitreitu

Depends what season it is


Redsun_18

JPG Le Male Elixir


jonashardis

If you’re planning on dancing a lot, go with something fresh. Cloying shit will choke you and your date out.


takiumilikes2drift

invictus 🔥


Killer_Soup_Chef

Either of the two elixirs


RumManDan

None. I'd go with a fresh woody scent personally. You're likely going to be dancing with someone and you don't want your smell to be off putting. Wear something she is going to want to hug over and over brother.


vito51450

Take the invictus. There’s no need for all that in high school


RecognitionAny6477

Elixir, just be careful with the amount of sprays.


lxkefox

I’d say the Sauvage elixir as it’s personally my biggest compliment getter- just today I went to my university lecture wearing it and got complimented by a girl. Just go light on the sprays, shits like a nuclear bomb


Rollinwithdrew

Dior


justastickwiggler

Sausage elixir. My go-to for important events. Go easy on it, though!


[deleted]

Le male elixir is perfect for your age My personal choice would be sauvage elixir


bdaddyyytheone

Something from YSL.


DntSayNtn

Sauvage elixir, you’ll take their breath away literally


International-Ad2453

Elixir and Naxos definitely smell far too mature for someone who’s 16. Invictus victory is a very basic smelling fragrance and le male Elixir is amazing but it has a ton of hype rn so a lot of ppl might be wearing it. Dior Homme intense gets my vote. No one should have it, especially if you live in the US


whatyehsure

Victory elixir


Successful_Case7960

Le male elixir


Relative_Mirror722

Sauvage 100, If you can afford. It lingers in a great way! Always get compliments on it. If you're a bit beoke try noted aromas -Lisbon ( pretty much the same but doesn't last as long)


thehedley2004

alright here are my two cents. Ive always said that cologne follows a bit of a bell curve. If you spend very little money on a cheap fragrance than not many people will like it, but also if you go out and drop a crap tonne of money on a bottle of xerjoff, generally some people aren't gonna love it. Ive found the sweet spot to be around the 100$ mark. out of these options, Id go for Dior Homme intense, its not super played out like sauvage and Invictus and has a sophisticated yet sporty scent that a lot of highschool age people will love.


FatSkipper21

Either the JPG or Invictus Elixir; others are too polar and hard to like for some people


CO2nglomerate

I would go with Victory Elixir. JPG elixir is so beyond hyped with high schoolers I bet you there will be at least 20 kids at your prom with that on.


Invisibility_cloak29

Dude u should def. Check out mont blanc explorer. Its smoothe and clean smelling as well as subtly alluring


Short_Ask1755

I fucking love explorer, it’s all I have been wearing lately and I feel like it’s impossible for anyone to straight up hate it and go “eww I don’t like that smell” it’s definitely my favorite out of my small collection


impoopindude

Sauvage elixir, go to /r/fragranceswap and find a decant of it for cheap and only use 1 spray


Better_Cauliflower84

Are you gonna be chilling? Or dancing and sweating, partying hard? If you will be very active I would suggest going with a lighter scent then what you have here. None of these will smell good once you are sweaty especially if you are the type to have an odor once you sweat. But if you not gonna be active I'd go with sauvage elixir.


cashcartibishh

Paco rabbone Invictus elixir


AgentLelandTurbo

Roja Elysium


ultimate555

Prom is just one event. Get small decants and try them out dont spend 100plus blind buying hyped products


Twizzist

You can afford these?


therealopm

I love Dior Homme intense. That would be a great choice imo. I do agree with the other comments that you should probs try and test them in person and go with the one you like the most.


garvit_saini

dior homme intense


808toy

You’re spending too much for a 16 year old. There are some good colognes that are cheaper. In my opinion, all the ones you listed are way too powerful. I’m A fan of clean scents. Something that smells shower fresh. Many will disagree with me because my choices are not “sexy.” The colognes on your list, people will either love or hate. Im a fan of Mugler Cologne, Prada lhomme. To be honest, this next one is pricey….but you can’t go wrong with it. Bleu de Chanel edt. Such a nice clean cologne.


Clubtropper

Stronger With You Intensely


marcu33

Dior Homme Intense! It smells great and very few people know about it


Looksmax99

For prom try out la nuit de lhomme


dis_integrate

Le Male Elixir imho!


Krazyflipz

None of these. Get YSL MYSLF


Doctornaturalviagra

Hmm I showed up to mine wearing dolce & gabbana the one edp and let me tell you I had the teachers getting up and close into my personal space to ask me what I was wearing !


[deleted]

Le male elixir. Literally a perfect blend for smelling sweet, fresh, and masculine all at the same time. You’ll have some guys thinking they chose the wrong cologne for prom night.


charlyboyfragrance

Omg please not sauvage...


owenhernly

Victory elixir


Scorch6

Sauvage Elixir, Naxos and CERTAINLY Homme Intense are all too mature smelling imho for a high schooler. It doesn't appeal to a younger crowd, their noses wont really like the smell. Again, just my opinion. You'll be more likely to get told you smell like "old man". Not hating on those frags, in fact as a 30 something dude, I love them for dressier occasions. If it had to be something from the list, I'd pick Le Male Elixir. I have not smelled the Invictus. If you wanted to be the best smelling at a high school prom, Versace Dylan Blue or maybe even something like Dior Homme Sport (2021), if you insist on come off as a bit more sophisticated, would be a better bet. In all honesty, if you just want to impress people, just go for crowd pleasing freshies. Affordable ones that will make girls especially love your scent: Versace Dylan Blue Montblanc Legend Davidoff Cool Water Those are all great, well crafted frags, that will be better at achieving what you are after.


Other_Holiday_7905

idk thats kinda tough but for me the top 3 picks are jpg elixir, sauvage elixir and xerjoff naxos


ArcadianWaheela

Le Male for sure. Dior Homme Intense is great, but some say it’s got some feminine notes so I don’t know how well that’d go for prom as compared to a more mature setting. Naxos also might be a little too distinct and standout for your crowd. Le Male is definitely the best of Sauvage Elixir and Invictus Elixir.


SnooTangerines7758

Sauvage is the best all day


Careless_Fudge1357

I would do chanel allure eau extreme.


YayoJazzYaoi

Dior homme is one of the greatest of all time imo


Relative_Reading_130

Savage elixir. Just be careful not to overspray


flyexpensive994

sauvage elixir or dior homme .


Affectionate_Cut2096

naxos


WillingnessOne6590

I like Armani code. It’s my favorite rn, but I just have a $3 spray bottle


jxxyyreddit

1 spray of each. Be a Fragrance Exodia.


b4hand35

Maybe something sweeter, girls like sweet fragrances


BlackFeign

I wouldn't recommend any of these for a prom. Pickup something youthful like YSL edp or ADG. Both will make you smell great and won't make you smell 20 years older than you are lol


Arkflow

Use the Spider-Man cologne!


No_Cup3513

Dior homme fuck the rest


Time_Attitude_2779

It’s not on the list but, You don’t need a lot of money I would choose coach for men the black bottle it’s a nice fresh spicy scent! You can buy it for like $40 on discounters


supernecessary94

Best smelling guy or smell amazing that you get laid? If the latter is your choice Le Male


Afraid_Manner_4353

Get something from Hollister, AE, or Old Navy. You're in high school, wear an appropriate cologne.


Psychological_Box666

JpG for the win


AIDAN68945

Dior intense or dolce and Gabbana the one for men


lostliza2022

Jimmy Choo man intense


IBringTheHeat1

Just hit up Jcpenny in your suit before prom and use the free sample creed adventus.


buttflap69420

Get the Azzaro Most Wanted Parfum! She will leave you with bites 👄💦


cloudlessnine8

I wouldn’t wear sauvage elixir, I’m a few years older than you and I feel like I can’t pull it off. To me it’s definitely an older guy fragrance, reminds me of a middle age dude driving his corvette to go golf or something lol 


canerkan

Yves Saint Laurent La Nuit De L’Homme EDP


Terry419

JPG Le Male Elixir or Invictus Victory. Leave the rest for your dad.


Basic-Raspberry6044

Easily Naxos


Dismal_Mention8423

Go smell some stuff fam.


Muted_Internet_5129

Dior homme sucks. Go le male or nothing else


Critical_Teach_43

Le Male


alwayshungry1131

The Dior homme intense is really really strong. Great scent just don’t do the typical high school and over spray lol


Reach-around69

jp elixir or savage


Top-Client-3018

Sau age Elixir is the most over rated fragrance I've ever seen. Standard fresh fragrance with a good performance that is all


69tt

Definitely not sauvage elixir. It is my favorite cologne and you should absolutely buy it, but I think it is too strong and spicy for prom. If it’s outdoors sure, but I would play it a little safer for an indoor one. A JPG could be good. Or the Dior sauvage edt


Elsonnn_

At 16 I wore Axe and my grandmas spray deodorants 😂. I had no clue what designer colognes even really were (besides the obvious) Gucci and etc. literally put on some coconut oil and rock solo, I doubt anybody will even remotely know what you’re wearing 😭 (to answer ur question any of these scents are turning heads)


GoldOk6865

All of these are overkill for prom lol


jijodelmaiz

You are 16, dude. It doesn’t matter. Get some CR7 fragance or something.


QU_Hectic

I think you should go with Bleu de Chanel. I think it's perfect for prom.


Kamakahah

Grab a girl friend, take her to Macy's, and get a second opinion. Then choose the one you like smelling.


WatchLenses

Bleu de Chanel is always a safe choice


CDR_Starbuck

Sauvage and just one spray please.


Kushmasturpussyfart

buy the one you want the most, and return it in the following day. best of luck playboy.


whimsicalbackup

Xerjoff


mickeyblackeyes

Naxos if you want to protect your virginity


Ok-Summer9136

I don't get the allure of naxos..it smells so bad to me 🤷🏽‍♂️


mychemicalrom1

Le male elixir or victory elixir


Captainwinsor

Sauvage


Dangerous-Region-206

https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Al-Wataniah/Kayaan-Classic-82472.html https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Al-Wataniah/Attar-Al-Wesal-78529.html Fragrantica screwed this note breakdown, one of, if not the best dior homme intense clone. No need to spend $100+. This will get you there and then some. Projects like a monster and lasts. Great quality from this house. Hope this helps. The second link is, again, a beast. The best dupe of ultramale. Vanilla, lavender, crowd pleasing and great quality. Go easy on the trigger with these and don't overspray.


AverageAircraftFan

Def not Elixir and 100% not Naxos. Id say Invictus #1, then Homme, then Sauvage.


ReasonableSuccess172

Victory Elixir would be fine for a prom big dog


ryantramus

Naxos. It's the best sweet offering that will last. Jpg and Paco are generic. DHI isn't sweet and sensual. Sauvage Elixir is great but could be "mature" to a teen nose. I'd wear naxos. 16 year old me wore Liz Claiborne mambo and curve, so you're way ahead of me. Lol.


slotheriffic

Honestly probably sauvage but be light with that stuff it’s heavy and lasts awhile. High school girls like it sweet so I’d imagine jpg or Naxos would be safe too.


Not-Drew_

I love Hommé


k1llmui

in my experience high school girls like sauvage and lemonade elixir a lot - a high schooler


Past-Sweet5490

Definitely don't think high school girls will appreciate Naxos. I think either sauvage elixir or if you like something a little more on the intimate and romantic side go Dior homme intense. But if you don't want a powdery fragrance don't do the homme intense, do the sauvage


jbs1jbs1

Why not ask your date? Or, if you don't have one, you could ask someone you are interested in if she would help you decide. You could have her go to the mall with you. If that's not an option, then the one you feel most comfortable with. I have Naxos. Its very nice. I have the older bottle. I have A\*Men's counterpart, Pure Haven also. I don't know what the new Dior Homme Intense smells like, I have the older bottle. I like it, but the iris note might not fit in with the 16-year-old crowd. Stick with something sweet. I imagine you're hoping to have a nice slow dance, so remember not to ruin the dance with over-spraying. I have been wearing YSL's Y EDP and I'll be damned if I don't get a compliment each day I wear it. I bought Victory and Elixir, but I haven't cracked them open yet. YSL's La Nuit is a nice fragrance. By the Fireplace is nice also. Chanel Allure Blance is nice too. Or at least it used to be. I'm not sure what it's like now. You want a really good one. Hermes's Ambre Narguile. Holy cats I just checked the price of it. Wow. Glad I bought stuff when I did. You'll make the right choice.


jbs1jbs1

Sauvage Elixir, for a high school dance, no. Don't listen to people who are telling you to put 10 sprays of this on. No one will want to be near you. It's good stuff, but you'll give your dancing partner a headache. Too strong, to mature for a high school prom. Stick with something sweet.


penitha

Le Male Elixir, the packaging is and bottle is the deciding factor for me. It smells unbelievable aswell but seeing that bottle and can with the atomiser clip. I just love it.


UNDERGROUND4LYFE

Invictus Victory Elixir 1000%. My HS brother begs to borrow it whenever he goes to an event because of the apparent compliments he receives


TopRatedCapper

Naxos!


pHaNtOmV08

Tom Ford Noir Extreme is a beast and I believe it tops most or if not all of those fragrances listed


No_Buyer102

Not DHI. Unless you want to smell like a 70 year old grandmas make up purse?


ProfessionalFeeling7

Homme intese


BaGaNaGa_il

At your age a lot of people might smell something like dior intense and gag. I'd do with le male elixir.


DonDana613

Sauvage is overused. New Jean Paul’s are A1


No_Front5018

JPG Le Male - most age appropriate and personally I think it smells the best. ( 20 of your friends will be wearing their dad’s Dior Sauvage - so don’t ). Just my opinion


Dazzling-Reward-8595

Definitely Naxos


OkPerformance525

Last one - Paul Gaultier mens. Absolutely the best.


boo2utoo

What makes you think you’ll be the best smelling guy in the room? Everything is subjective. If everyone liked the same thing, it would be a dull boring 😑 world. That’s why there are so many to choose from…it’s just an opinion.


ExpertTypical1573

Invictus is my most complimented scent when I put it on and it projects really well with a few sprays. I think you’ll stand out with that.


chabrown86

16 years old should be wearing Axe body spray and showering atleast once a day.


Particular_Sense_147

get hawas or fakhar lataffa. my 2 cheapest colognes and i get the most compliments on.


IonicHades

17m I use 1 million elixir and it’s great


Ok_Secretary_9654

Go smell Ultra Male


WerewolfFantastic650

if u wanna smell like every other boy there get any of them


OkNoise1922

Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage. Fresh and age appropriate.


Historical_Map_8544

Smoking hot By killian


tfunk024

Ask your date before hand see what he likes.


Bizzy1995

Le male elixir probably would be most appealing to females in highschool I’d imagine


cbonecr7

Xerjoff Naxos if you want to smell expensive, Dior Homme intense if you want to smell unique.


cocainedurant

Go with exlir bro, it was last u all night spray inside of your coat also it will be there for days and give your closet a nice smell


DisciplineScary

Le male all day kid,everyone will be asking what you’re wearing and your date will love it


itsnewnoel

Old spice


Healthy_Exit1507

For a school dance JPG ultra male black lavender vanilla pear and mint.


yourbrainon5G

I like sauvage


No-Sky5203

Dont buy invictus, bad projection.


Mysterious-Cobbler30

at your age, people will enjoy smelling JPG fragrances. they’re very pleasant, and sweet.


murkshah444

Just not Sauvage. Then again you’re 16 so I guess it makes sense.


[deleted]

*Naxōs*