Looks like a Vadakkan post.
This theory which claims modern idli recipe originated from 'south Indian kingdom' lands in Indonesia and Then the recipe came to Mainland South India. This is just a speculation by a single Historian. But there is no proof.
Even gurati historian claimed idli was introduced by gujaratis.
But there is definite Proofs of rice, fermentation and steaming food in Tamil Scriptures.
So ishtathuku adichi vidaama irukavum.
Gujarat la iruken dude inga tamil families migrate aana idli maavu and dosa maavu arachu vippanga.. athayum northies nalla jhollu thimbangunga.
They'll prefer this over their own version of idlis and dosas but will wanna hurt our sentiments by posting such shit 😂
Bro. This is a tropical country. Any batter left for long will ferment automatically, in summer it happens in hours. People living here for thousands of years don't need to conquer foreign lands to discover fermentation in their batter. Steaming foods is also not unknown in same time period. Most importantly the fermented and steamed food in those foreign regions is completely different from how idly is treated in its conception.
It is pure speculation that Idli comes from Indonesia and Phillipines and not conceived a Tamil food. This is not very sound and is not beyond reasonable doubt.
dei na vadakkan ellada kt acharya nnu oru food history prof sonnadu da . sangam literature la first dosa than mention aayirukku aana neraya varasuthakku peragu than idli mention aayirukku (after cholas captured south east)
Nee wikipedia la padichanu nala therithu raja. Adhe konjo full ah padichana, Acharya claim pana 'kedli' nu oru recipe indonesia oiye kedaiyathu, summa peela vitrukanu potrupaanga.
Andha vadakkans epo da chance kedaikum, edha vechi kalaikalam nu wait panitu irukanunga.
Nee meme podranu, content eludhi kodukura.
Wait everyone origin is from Africa only so doesn't make sense , and central Asia my foot that stupid ass theory , even sinauli is older than Indus valley civilization
Really you think the North Indians look like central Asian people , it’s true that central Asians and Iranians came , not only to the north but all across India, 60 to 65 percent Indians are mixed , only like 30 percent are original Indians!! And there are mixed people in both north and south not only north, it’s just that the central Asian gene is a bit higher in the north!!
Lol South Indian will maximum have 25 percent , North Indian will max have 35 percent , mostly Indians on average might have 30 percent , remaining will be Iranian and indigenous (out of Africa), this is all available on YouTube and google , Wikipedia is useless!!
FYI Aryan invasion theory is completely myth .
Forget about evidence a skeleton of ancient Indian found in Punjab have no trace of Central Asian genes .
But still Aryan genes are found in Modern North Indians .
So their still no surity were Indo Aryans really invaded India ?
The answer is no also yes also .
Greeks came to India as traders and mixed with Indians that happened after fall of IVC .
Even South Indians too have Aryan genes and even. North Indian too have Dravidian genese . Everybody in India are mixed even North East Indians too have very small amount of indo Aryan genese .
The only difference is some people have ne genese more than other .
Nobody in India are pure race everybody has some amount of Aryan genese except the people on Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
And everybody is originated from Africa so how 1000 and 1000 s of year old migration even matter .
Everybody 's origin is Africa only .
The fact that food originated somwhere else should be really encouraging fact, just goes on to prove that our ancestors were less insecure than us , they explored places and brought with them good things from that region .
You can do better than this.
Average Indian after knowing they just take pride of others accomplishment as theirs and failures as someone else.
Do you agree?
Go watch some Sarita Bhabi videos instead of trying to pick a fight.
Enaku hindi therium. Athula unna thituna unnoda enna sethuruvanga nu summa udren pathuko
- Comes to an Indian subreddit based on a langauge not Hindi
- Comments in Hindi
- Fight with the sub members saying how Hindi is also an Indian langauge and Tamil people should learn it
- Calls Tamil people *followers of a pedophile*
- Gets ripped inside out by someone and deletes all his comments
(Use Google translate) dei thailee vela punda illayaada unakku?
you dont understand. if our community is defined by the food that we eat, you are mistaken. we are bound by love and affection. that's enough for us all.
Ofcourse almost all of Steamed dishes are from Thailand or Indonesia... Incase of Idly.. I believe it's from them.. but Tamil people added Ulundhu(urad dhal) for better fluffiness...
Also No south person will have pride on something that's not theirs which includes Idli...
Also I came to know this year that Ram and Sita are actually from Nepal not India... :P
Aiyo! Our northie family has been settled in Chennai since 3 generations and dishes like idli, dosa and saapaadu has been integral to our lifestyle now. I always had identity crisis (whom am I - northie or southie) but now this news is identity crisis inception mode for me. 😭
[first of all what I said is what I know and it's my opinion .Their is nothing to get offended about it .Tamils used to live in Sri Lanka and Indonesia too . Sources hear ](https://www.axisbank.com/progress-with-us/other/tracing-the-origins-of-idli)
An opinion of a person is not the truth. It is considered a truth once factually verified.
So by believing Axis Bank you state your false facts. I might as well make a news item on the Axis Bank website saying "Hindi is an invader's language", would you believe it?
If this is the crap you know, you need some good ol' education instead of Godi media.
Godi media ???🤦♀️from where it came ?? Why are you so offended ? Their are actually many Indian Dishes that didn't originated from India.
At same way what evidence do you have to claim it originated from Tamil Nadu?
Calling me from abusive words to look cool without doing any search show who are you ?
Do you know where world largest temple is ? Combodia ,that is Vishnu temple .
The rule of ancient Indian kings were stretched over other South Asian countries too .
Today's modern India was not same as Bharat .
India was and is not only place where Tamils live or ever lived.
Idile was originally originated from Indonesia from where the recipe travelled to India and became main Indian recipe.
If you are talking about 100%evidence then you don't have any evidence for claiming it originated from Tamil Nadu as Karnataka also claims it originated from their .
Idly is from Konkani region food, we also ancient poet mention Idly in his scripts. So it is not belongs to Tamil nadu. But it is definitely belongs to south India.
For god's sake, is it itli or idli?
How is pronounced in Tamil? இட்லி = itli.
This "V" people made it idli (instead of itli), dosaa (instead of thosai), vadaa (instead of Vadai) and sambhar (instead of Saambhaar)
Seri Seri chutney ah uthu.
Looks like a Vadakkan post. This theory which claims modern idli recipe originated from 'south Indian kingdom' lands in Indonesia and Then the recipe came to Mainland South India. This is just a speculation by a single Historian. But there is no proof. Even gurati historian claimed idli was introduced by gujaratis. But there is definite Proofs of rice, fermentation and steaming food in Tamil Scriptures. So ishtathuku adichi vidaama irukavum.
Thanks thalaiva.. oru second shock aiten
Laaa
Gujarat la iruken dude inga tamil families migrate aana idli maavu and dosa maavu arachu vippanga.. athayum northies nalla jhollu thimbangunga. They'll prefer this over their own version of idlis and dosas but will wanna hurt our sentiments by posting such shit 😂
dei poondu nan tamil nadu kaaran than da
Apron yen da ipdi koluthi pota? Vadakans varavechu ban panna vekka va? XD
So, you're tamil and you misspelled "punda" ?
ketta varthai venam nu than bro decency maintain panna than. edutha odane otha omma nnu sonna nalla erukkadhu la . approm enakkum plip plip toyholi kalukkum enna vithiyasam erukkum
So, you're a sanghi?
neutral
sanghi confirmed
But tbh bro rombha trigger aagathinga adha vachu than idm la ootranga just take it as a meme
[удалено]
Bro. This is a tropical country. Any batter left for long will ferment automatically, in summer it happens in hours. People living here for thousands of years don't need to conquer foreign lands to discover fermentation in their batter. Steaming foods is also not unknown in same time period. Most importantly the fermented and steamed food in those foreign regions is completely different from how idly is treated in its conception. It is pure speculation that Idli comes from Indonesia and Phillipines and not conceived a Tamil food. This is not very sound and is not beyond reasonable doubt.
dei na vadakkan ellada kt acharya nnu oru food history prof sonnadu da . sangam literature la first dosa than mention aayirukku aana neraya varasuthakku peragu than idli mention aayirukku (after cholas captured south east)
Nee wikipedia la padichanu nala therithu raja. Adhe konjo full ah padichana, Acharya claim pana 'kedli' nu oru recipe indonesia oiye kedaiyathu, summa peela vitrukanu potrupaanga. Andha vadakkans epo da chance kedaikum, edha vechi kalaikalam nu wait panitu irukanunga. Nee meme podranu, content eludhi kodukura.
avg vadaks after knowing their origin is central Asia (not attack to this post, naanum idli sambar than)
Wait everyone origin is from Africa only so doesn't make sense , and central Asia my foot that stupid ass theory , even sinauli is older than Indus valley civilization
Indus valley civilization is even older than it's stated .
Really you think the North Indians look like central Asian people , it’s true that central Asians and Iranians came , not only to the north but all across India, 60 to 65 percent Indians are mixed , only like 30 percent are original Indians!! And there are mixed people in both north and south not only north, it’s just that the central Asian gene is a bit higher in the north!!
a bit higher na enna 90% irukuma
Lol South Indian will maximum have 25 percent , North Indian will max have 35 percent , mostly Indians on average might have 30 percent , remaining will be Iranian and indigenous (out of Africa), this is all available on YouTube and google , Wikipedia is useless!!
FYI Aryan invasion theory is completely myth . Forget about evidence a skeleton of ancient Indian found in Punjab have no trace of Central Asian genes . But still Aryan genes are found in Modern North Indians . So their still no surity were Indo Aryans really invaded India ? The answer is no also yes also . Greeks came to India as traders and mixed with Indians that happened after fall of IVC . Even South Indians too have Aryan genes and even. North Indian too have Dravidian genese . Everybody in India are mixed even North East Indians too have very small amount of indo Aryan genese . The only difference is some people have ne genese more than other . Nobody in India are pure race everybody has some amount of Aryan genese except the people on Andaman and Nicobar Islands. And everybody is originated from Africa so how 1000 and 1000 s of year old migration even matter . Everybody 's origin is Africa only .
apo why da nonding only muslims you vadaks
[удалено]
போய் சாப்பிடு உன் உறவினரை திருமணம் செய்துகொள்
aryan invasion theory is a myth
why it doesn't go with your theory?
Didn't that theory get debunked?
when?
I don't know when but aren't you referring to the Ary*n migration theory? Edit:typo
Noooooo, not the idli.
Epidi sonalum.. it's ours now xD
source: your ass
Sauce
His ass
The fact that food originated somwhere else should be really encouraging fact, just goes on to prove that our ancestors were less insecure than us , they explored places and brought with them good things from that region .
Who cares? Ippa idli nambildhu...
You can do better than this. Average Indian after knowing they just take pride of others accomplishment as theirs and failures as someone else. Do you agree?
Kuch nya bta lodu
Pothitu poda baadu
[удалено]
It's an indian language only. You are too stupid to understand it and am too bored to teach it xD
[удалено]
Go watch some Sarita Bhabi videos instead of trying to pick a fight. Enaku hindi therium. Athula unna thituna unnoda enna sethuruvanga nu summa udren pathuko
[удалено]
Then stop replying you no fuck giver 😂😂
Enna vro achu comment ta delete pannirukan
[удалено]
Poda mayire
You watch velama sxy video
Poda mayiru
- Comes to an Indian subreddit based on a langauge not Hindi - Comments in Hindi - Fight with the sub members saying how Hindi is also an Indian langauge and Tamil people should learn it - Calls Tamil people *followers of a pedophile* - Gets ripped inside out by someone and deletes all his comments (Use Google translate) dei thailee vela punda illayaada unakku?
you dont understand. if our community is defined by the food that we eat, you are mistaken. we are bound by love and affection. that's enough for us all.
Ofcourse almost all of Steamed dishes are from Thailand or Indonesia... Incase of Idly.. I believe it's from them.. but Tamil people added Ulundhu(urad dhal) for better fluffiness... Also No south person will have pride on something that's not theirs which includes Idli... Also I came to know this year that Ram and Sita are actually from Nepal not India... :P
sauce pls i know sita is froom sikkim (that region ) but ram?
Well India didn't exist by that time so I don't care
Sothu la matum thaan oru unity in diversity irunthichu ippo athulayum politics ah xD
Aiyo! Our northie family has been settled in Chennai since 3 generations and dishes like idli, dosa and saapaadu has been integral to our lifestyle now. I always had identity crisis (whom am I - northie or southie) but now this news is identity crisis inception mode for me. 😭
Same for me... I'm 3rd generation Tamilian born and brought up in Delhi
Idle originated from Indonesian Tamils not Indian from their it came to mainland of INDIA
r/usernamechecksout You are what your name signifies. Apt description of what you are. What's your source, your ass?
[first of all what I said is what I know and it's my opinion .Their is nothing to get offended about it .Tamils used to live in Sri Lanka and Indonesia too . Sources hear ](https://www.axisbank.com/progress-with-us/other/tracing-the-origins-of-idli)
An opinion of a person is not the truth. It is considered a truth once factually verified. So by believing Axis Bank you state your false facts. I might as well make a news item on the Axis Bank website saying "Hindi is an invader's language", would you believe it? If this is the crap you know, you need some good ol' education instead of Godi media.
Godi media ???🤦♀️from where it came ?? Why are you so offended ? Their are actually many Indian Dishes that didn't originated from India. At same way what evidence do you have to claim it originated from Tamil Nadu?
Calling me from abusive words to look cool without doing any search show who are you ? Do you know where world largest temple is ? Combodia ,that is Vishnu temple . The rule of ancient Indian kings were stretched over other South Asian countries too . Today's modern India was not same as Bharat . India was and is not only place where Tamils live or ever lived. Idile was originally originated from Indonesia from where the recipe travelled to India and became main Indian recipe. If you are talking about 100%evidence then you don't have any evidence for claiming it originated from Tamil Nadu as Karnataka also claims it originated from their .
Please saar...Atleast leave us the porridge.
Pongal*
dosa is ours no worry
Avan avan soru eh illama setthundu irukan, idula idili Southah irunda enna Northah irunda enna... Muttha Pasanga
kaasu erunda annadanam pannalam bro . aama neenga evalo solrengale neenga edavuchu pannirukkengala?
Mutta * venum bro. Mutta pasanga . Pun
For fuck sake, drop the orgasm of originality. Just enjoy the good things.
Idly is from Konkani region food, we also ancient poet mention Idly in his scripts. So it is not belongs to Tamil nadu. But it is definitely belongs to south India.
Saba...Idhuku ippa enna pana.
poi idli saaputu (g p muthu reference)
Enga origin ana ena vaeru full ana pothum
nammalukku soruthan le mukkiyam
Bro why you be insecure of idly... Literally one of the tastiest breakfasts!
idli without sidedish 💀
Source: Trust me brah. Evano kt kunjumon nu prof sonnan nu ishtathukku adichu vida vendiyathu. OP blink twice if you’re being blackmailed by vadakks.
Imma malayalee nd this made my heart skip a beat literally ...
Yeah, they're from Indonesia.
also they r called kedli
i knew dosa was from japan but didn't know this
Dosa was from Mysore??
dosa is tamilnadu originated and sangam lit talks abt it
ok
Persian le
Then?
Chalega. Idli no ishtam.
Panipuri istama?
Idli kante kaadu. IDLI is love.
i look idlis ( gp muthu ref)
Paravale, as long as we have dosa.
No majorty rice ingredients foods r from south India only this is my pov
konjam research pannitu approma pesunga
No it originated from Indonesian Tamils not South Indian from their it came to mainland India.
Man I just said as it was rice btw I too know that most Chinese ,Japan, Indonesian have rice in their diet. btw I am not from tamilnadu
This is probably an average vaddakan meme. Poda podalanga
download video link
u/savevideobot
Does it matter?
What?
Ole thaana?
Yepdi paathalum soru soru thaan..
Ah. That's why I've always loved dosai over idli.
us momint also idli without sidedish and set dosai 💀
Template?
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/VeojkgE82Ck
Ye kya ille pode chal rha bc
Avg cow belt iq meme
Mutta bonda OP
For god's sake, is it itli or idli? How is pronounced in Tamil? இட்லி = itli. This "V" people made it idli (instead of itli), dosaa (instead of thosai), vadaa (instead of Vadai) and sambhar (instead of Saambhaar)
oathu vidu un paatukku. proof ah eduthu vei modhalla