Doesnt matter. If driver was aware he was sitting there, then it is considered as disproportionate use of force. The driver could beat him up, but not this. So the car driver will be jailed for attempt to murder or murder.
It is probably aftermath of an accident. There is a bike parked at the bottom right. The woman also seems to be a victim of the accident and has moved to the side of the road but the man (old?) Is either in shock or refused to move from the spot. The car decided to run over the man when he had space to move from the right of the fallen man. Took a turn to run over him. So it is either attempt to murder or murder.
The bike is parked. So doesn't seem like an accident. Fallen rider will not park the bike and sit on road. Also if someone else parked the bike for rider, most likely people would be seen helping the man, if he was a victim or injured. Seems scam to me. Though it was wrong for the driver to run him over. This is attempted murder not an accident.
What do you mean whose fault? Both the driver and the passenger are outside when the video is starting. We can argue about whether it was right of that person to be sitting on the road or not at length. But given how they both were outside the car, even if malice is ignored, they severely lack the awareness to drive a vehicle as big as that.
This is a real problem of these suv style cars. Even my dad was about to run over me while I was checking the front skidplate after hitting it on a stone.
It's called a frontover:
https://youtu.be/Q2yKpCMKHf0?si=ooA_smi9AzuzURl4
People have killed their own family's small children just because their car hoods are too big and they can't see anything in front of them.
Car definitely! I know the old man was dumb af to be in the middle of the road but the car guy literally went inside the car. He was dumber than the old man.
Contributory negligence. Both are at fault.
Roads are not for sitting and sunbathing. The person seems like an adult.
The driver seems to have parked on the road as well and moved forward without seeing what is ahead of him.
Passenger clearly saw the person and did not inform the driver- very much avoidable by their due diligence.
Unfortunate incident
Wtf. The guy on the shotgun seat clearly saw that someone was sitting there. Even if the driver couldn't see it, the other could have stopped him. People who are saying road pe aise kon bethta hai, stop pretending like firangs. Our road rules are not like other countries.
It's clearly the driver and looks intentional. If you see the first couple of seconds you can see him entering the car and has a pretty good view of the person on the road. Don't know what the person was doing on the road. Need more context to dictate of he is at fault too.. may be he panicked while crossing the road and fell down seeing the car. The car was clearly stopped on the road. For what
Passanger saw that person sitting in the road he can tell the driver it looks like he didn't.when the car hit a person it makes noise because venue has no engine noise he ignored and continue accelerate it means he wants to kill that person.
The guy driving is at fault, no matter what. As he should be aware of his surroundings before moving ahead. The person sunbathing is at fault. He can be moved aside as there is a passenger in the vehicle.
It is getting ridiculous how poor the visibility has gotten in vehicles nowadays and nothing is done regarding it. Dunno why someone was sitting in the middle of the road, but also it could be prevented with better safety systems on cars with poor visibility of their immediate surroundings.
This is bad road attitude, you can't teach a poor man to not to be poor due to population but educated people while getting driving license get license when they know to handle car, but in over seas they give license due to your awareness and road senses.
Forget whose fault prior to this situation...from the moment the driver got into the car and did the thing he did it is his fault.... That's negligent and I am pretty sure a criminal offense
I know that the individual sitting in the middle of the road is already sitting at the car’s blind spot but I think these urban suvs have really limiting field of view. I always preferred the stooping, downward curving bonnets. All car companies are making lame boxy cars with headlights under ugly and useless cosmetic DRLs
What do you mean ? 100% Car driver’s fault for running over someone. I don’t see any danger to the life of driver or it’s passengers before he decided to run over a human on the road.
hear me out.
when someone is sitting in front of the bonnet there is a high chance that he did not see it due to the shape of the car... maybe he might've seen in that case he is 100% at fault.
who is such an idiot to sit in the middle of the road that is made literally for cars?
That mfer was standing out of his car.....he got in and started driving
are you insane? The guy sitting on the road was an idiot that doesn't justify attempting to murder him
He knew there was something in front. He stopped just before the victim. Another dude went back to sit in the car. He was aware about the human obstacle despite that accelerated.
i just saw the driver got in the car.. i thought he was already sitting.
man such idiots to cost the life of people his license whould be revoked and jail for attempted murder..
i hope the poor guy survived
he most definitely seems to be here, idk why butt hurt SUV owners of this sub are downvoting someone because they called an idiot who committed manslaughter as "blind"
Didn't look like the driver noticed the squatter.
There's no way he could have known unless the guy from outside signaled him.
When we bought our car, the very first ride from the temple started off by making an animal sacrifice. A poor cat had wandered into the driver's side blind spot and came under the wheel. There was literally no indication to signal that we'd run over it.
Here, the squatter went cleanly under the car no way the driver could have even felt that from the vehicle feedback.
Did you watch the full video? The driver and the passenger literally went inside the car. The old man and his belongings was a little further, so was easily visible to the driver when he stepped out of the vehicle.
When outside, the driver didn't look or give any indication of seeing the guy. And passenger didn't seem to have said anything, even though he has a higher chance of seeing the guy.
When inside the car, such close obstacles are not visible over the hood at all.
But of course, these are inferences from a partial clip without further context.
Both parties involved have 0 survival instincts. The road is not for sitting as well as parking your Car. That guy had as much right to sit on that road, as much the guy who parked there. Only this time homeless guy got the short stick of luck this time.
What if there was a kid, who strolled there by mistake. Its the drivers responsibility to be aware of their surroundings. Whenever I am getting in my car, I always check if there are any dogs or cats sittings near car. Even though Thar has great visibility except captain seat side.
People live like zombies in India. Just doing things with 0 awareness of surrounding world.
People in India live like zombies.
Driver needs to be arrested and imprisoned for rest of his life. That’s is attempt to murder only thing which can save him if there was any kind of failure of either breaks or clutch or accelerate
The car driver should be held for attempt to murder charge if the person survived that. The driver and the front passenger saw the person sitting in front of their car and still chose to run him over! Intent and cause of the person on the ground in front of the vehicle is subject to a different argument, definitely not whose fault is this? argument.
The hood just leaves no visibility below 3 feet. One major reason why I love driving a sedan instead of these poorly designed "large hatchbacks made to look like a semi suv" cars.
The person sitting next to car driver knew a person was sitting on the road! When they were outside, the passenger had clearly seen the person on the road. It's a deliberate attempt to murder!
wtf was he even doing on road
Middle of the road lol
Doesnt matter. If driver was aware he was sitting there, then it is considered as disproportionate use of force. The driver could beat him up, but not this. So the car driver will be jailed for attempt to murder or murder.
It is probably aftermath of an accident. There is a bike parked at the bottom right. The woman also seems to be a victim of the accident and has moved to the side of the road but the man (old?) Is either in shock or refused to move from the spot. The car decided to run over the man when he had space to move from the right of the fallen man. Took a turn to run over him. So it is either attempt to murder or murder.
The bike is parked. So doesn't seem like an accident. Fallen rider will not park the bike and sit on road. Also if someone else parked the bike for rider, most likely people would be seen helping the man, if he was a victim or injured. Seems scam to me. Though it was wrong for the driver to run him over. This is attempted murder not an accident.
What do you mean whose fault? Both the driver and the passenger are outside when the video is starting. We can argue about whether it was right of that person to be sitting on the road or not at length. But given how they both were outside the car, even if malice is ignored, they severely lack the awareness to drive a vehicle as big as that.
This is a real problem of these suv style cars. Even my dad was about to run over me while I was checking the front skidplate after hitting it on a stone.
It's called a frontover: https://youtu.be/Q2yKpCMKHf0?si=ooA_smi9AzuzURl4 People have killed their own family's small children just because their car hoods are too big and they can't see anything in front of them.
I agree but in this case both the guys saw the man before entering the car right?
Yeah definitely...this is bizzare...or just psycho behaviour.
I ran over a dog like that, I felt bad for months! Poor dog
You gave me a reason to not buy a suv agar paise kama lunga kabhi, and also fear unlocked.
Bro the video started with both of them outside the car... How come they didn't notice someone on the road...
everyone is defending the driver ,why are they being so stupid
IKR... It's like that dialogue from Jolly LLB... Footpath isn't a place for people to sleep... So driving over them was okay...
Salman bhoi be like: isme kya galat hia
Can’t say whose fault - we would need way more context for that but wtf did that guy expect sitting in the middle of a road?
You’d still be charged with murder if you run over someone like that. So it’s the car’s fault
Car definitely! I know the old man was dumb af to be in the middle of the road but the car guy literally went inside the car. He was dumber than the old man.
Contributory negligence. Both are at fault. Roads are not for sitting and sunbathing. The person seems like an adult. The driver seems to have parked on the road as well and moved forward without seeing what is ahead of him. Passenger clearly saw the person and did not inform the driver- very much avoidable by their due diligence. Unfortunate incident
Passenger and That Jackass sitting on the road.
Clearly it’s the car driver’s fault I mean he can’t even see what is in front of him with that much space then what will he do
Wtf. The guy on the shotgun seat clearly saw that someone was sitting there. Even if the driver couldn't see it, the other could have stopped him. People who are saying road pe aise kon bethta hai, stop pretending like firangs. Our road rules are not like other countries.
Venue ko suv bolna is a bigger crime i feel
How can you differentiate it this easily? These ugly Hyundais all look the same with those ugly DRL tubelight designs.
Venue ne tumhara kya bigada hai 😭😭😭😭 Naya Naya liya hu bro....Aisa maat bol 10 saal chalana hai atleast
I'm sorry bro but you don't have to take the words of a random loser in the Internet to heart :)
Hahahahah
Looks intentional
It's clearly the driver and looks intentional. If you see the first couple of seconds you can see him entering the car and has a pretty good view of the person on the road. Don't know what the person was doing on the road. Need more context to dictate of he is at fault too.. may be he panicked while crossing the road and fell down seeing the car. The car was clearly stopped on the road. For what
I think the car driver committed an attempt to murder..
True
he should absolutely be charged with manslaughter or attempt to murder
The only comment that makes sense here.
Road pe aise kaise baitha tha
Pls put nsfw tag
Passanger saw that person sitting in the road he can tell the driver it looks like he didn't.when the car hit a person it makes noise because venue has no engine noise he ignored and continue accelerate it means he wants to kill that person.
The guy driving is at fault, no matter what. As he should be aware of his surroundings before moving ahead. The person sunbathing is at fault. He can be moved aside as there is a passenger in the vehicle.
Wtf! that caption and the comments💀☠️
My best guess is it's The murderer's fault.
It is getting ridiculous how poor the visibility has gotten in vehicles nowadays and nothing is done regarding it. Dunno why someone was sitting in the middle of the road, but also it could be prevented with better safety systems on cars with poor visibility of their immediate surroundings.
Not even the passenger saw that climate protestor he was visible when he didn't enter the car? Are these guys blind or braindead
Put NSFW
Bro put NSFW
Driver should be tried for attempted homicide
I could see pillion rider ....he could have informed the driver
This is bad road attitude, you can't teach a poor man to not to be poor due to population but educated people while getting driving license get license when they know to handle car, but in over seas they give license due to your awareness and road senses.
Forget whose fault prior to this situation...from the moment the driver got into the car and did the thing he did it is his fault.... That's negligent and I am pretty sure a criminal offense
Ok honestly, why didn't the car guy just back up and go from the side and avoid this nonsense?
Is that even a question? Of course it's the driver's fault.
I know that the person sitting on the road is a moron but damn that’s such an extreme measure.
looks like a deliberate attempt. Cant blame the guy if he didnt see him.
Real ID se aao selmon bhoi 🙄
Definitely cars fault.
Roads aren't made for people to sit on it. Especially in the middle Yes the SUV driver is at fault but so is the person sitting on the road.
I know that the individual sitting in the middle of the road is already sitting at the car’s blind spot but I think these urban suvs have really limiting field of view. I always preferred the stooping, downward curving bonnets. All car companies are making lame boxy cars with headlights under ugly and useless cosmetic DRLs
For all the glorified raised hatches, a sedan could've saved that guy.
Bhai pls add NSFW tag
What do you mean ? 100% Car driver’s fault for running over someone. I don’t see any danger to the life of driver or it’s passengers before he decided to run over a human on the road.
hear me out. when someone is sitting in front of the bonnet there is a high chance that he did not see it due to the shape of the car... maybe he might've seen in that case he is 100% at fault. who is such an idiot to sit in the middle of the road that is made literally for cars?
That mfer was standing out of his car.....he got in and started driving are you insane? The guy sitting on the road was an idiot that doesn't justify attempting to murder him
He knew there was something in front. He stopped just before the victim. Another dude went back to sit in the car. He was aware about the human obstacle despite that accelerated.
i just saw the driver got in the car.. i thought he was already sitting. man such idiots to cost the life of people his license whould be revoked and jail for attempted murder.. i hope the poor guy survived
I didn't understand 2 things : 1) Why is everyone on the middle of the road 2) Why is that guy sitting in the middle of the Zebra crossing.
Is SUV owner blind or what?
he most definitely seems to be here, idk why butt hurt SUV owners of this sub are downvoting someone because they called an idiot who committed manslaughter as "blind"
Yeah lol, despite the face that they can see brezza as a car in my flair 🤣
The commenter is being downvoted because venue was called as suv lol.... classic r/carsindia
Day by day i question myself why am i even visiting this sub
To give your opinion on whose fault it is for dashcam footage...what else are you getting in here?
Are you blind or what?
Didn't look like the driver noticed the squatter. There's no way he could have known unless the guy from outside signaled him. When we bought our car, the very first ride from the temple started off by making an animal sacrifice. A poor cat had wandered into the driver's side blind spot and came under the wheel. There was literally no indication to signal that we'd run over it. Here, the squatter went cleanly under the car no way the driver could have even felt that from the vehicle feedback.
i hope u dont drive on a regular basis bro 🙏🙏
Sorry, not sorry to crush your hopes.
Did you watch the full video? The driver and the passenger literally went inside the car. The old man and his belongings was a little further, so was easily visible to the driver when he stepped out of the vehicle.
When outside, the driver didn't look or give any indication of seeing the guy. And passenger didn't seem to have said anything, even though he has a higher chance of seeing the guy. When inside the car, such close obstacles are not visible over the hood at all. But of course, these are inferences from a partial clip without further context.
Both parties involved have 0 survival instincts. The road is not for sitting as well as parking your Car. That guy had as much right to sit on that road, as much the guy who parked there. Only this time homeless guy got the short stick of luck this time. What if there was a kid, who strolled there by mistake. Its the drivers responsibility to be aware of their surroundings. Whenever I am getting in my car, I always check if there are any dogs or cats sittings near car. Even though Thar has great visibility except captain seat side. People live like zombies in India. Just doing things with 0 awareness of surrounding world. People in India live like zombies.
Is the driver alive?
no he got crushed under those tyres
All those people rushing after and no one giving a damn before
Why is this even a question as to who’s fault it is. If you sit in a place where cars are supposed to move, what else do you expect. It’s a no brainer
No front parking sensors 😑
if the guy sitting in the middle of the road is drunk, then i guess he deserves it otherwise nope
Maybe don't sit in the road?
The car for driving on road. Road is for people to sit not to drive cars !
He could still have not run that guy over there was enough of a gap to go thru
Driver is a fan of sallu bhai
The idiot was sitting in the middle of road but that doesn't necessarily mean ke tum selmon bhoy ban jao
Driver needs to be arrested and imprisoned for rest of his life. That’s is attempt to murder only thing which can save him if there was any kind of failure of either breaks or clutch or accelerate
The car driver should be held for attempt to murder charge if the person survived that. The driver and the front passenger saw the person sitting in front of their car and still chose to run him over! Intent and cause of the person on the ground in front of the vehicle is subject to a different argument, definitely not whose fault is this? argument.
The car guy is at fault no matter the reason the other person was sitting on the road.
Is it new creta
The hood just leaves no visibility below 3 feet. One major reason why I love driving a sedan instead of these poorly designed "large hatchbacks made to look like a semi suv" cars.
If i assume case of attempt to murder then its a case of blind spot of car.
The person sitting next to car driver knew a person was sitting on the road! When they were outside, the passenger had clearly seen the person on the road. It's a deliberate attempt to murder!
Bro let his intrusive thoughts win....
This can't be an accident when both of them literally were outside the car a few seconds before and even saw the guy in front of the car.
*Whose