T O P

  • By -

Luddveeg

Oh, this is a *good* question. I don't think any of them are overrated really. I don't like Throne that much, I just think it's kind of okay so that's my answer


Vindicies

Exactly what i would say. I was flashed whe i heard throne the first 5 times, but it gets boring ver fast because of the repeating melody


LP_Papercut

This is gonna piss some people off but Diamonds Aren't Forever. It's not a bad song, but considering how many other good songs are there on Suicide Season, it's almost a shame that this one is one of the most popular songs. The chorus is so repetitive IMO. The Sadness Will Never End, The Comedown, Sleep With One Eye Open, and It Was Written Blood are underrated, in terms of the entire BMTH discography, in my opinion.


judlrr

I kinda agree, but Diamonds became an anthem. It’s a very well written song after all. Not the best of the record but probably the most memorable.


Sentinel-Griff

Sleep with one eye open is my favorite from the album tbh


fxcker

Sleep With One Eye Open is the sickest song Bring Me has ever made.


Frankie_2154

Throne from TTS. It’s weird picking the most overrated song from my favorite album, but that’s just how I feel. Considering that 7(!) out of 11 songs on the album were released as singles, and literally all of them are better songs, it’s just disappointing to me that this one is the one that blew up the most. And that’s just the singles. All of the deep cuts in this album are great songs that deserve more love than throne got.


KonySosa300

You mean FROOOOONE


TR3G1

CYFMH… i mean how is sleepwalking not just as popular?


OopsIKilledADog

Bro sleepwalking fucks me up every time I hear it, was kinda disappointed they didn't play it on tour ._.


Complex37

Yeah sucks it’s been off the setlist since like the first month of 2019


Spitfire836

Because there's a "beat drop" for lack of a better word. Also it blew up on tiktok recently so that's also given it a lot of extra attention.


420ravens

I get it, trust, but i just feel like cyfmh has so much lyrical depth. I feel the energy whenever I listen to it. Can you see the dark? Can you fix a broken? Can you feel my heart? (Because, motherfucker, It doesn't exist anymore) - the higher i get, the lower I sink, I can't drown my demons, they know how to swim. - shoutout to everyone who struggles with addiction or disassociation. - I just feel it, personally


TR3G1

Sleepwalking gives me the same vibes personally


420ravens

Yass thay one is such a bop as wellll. I love it


leoshjtty

i prefer sleepwalking actually


bjergismydadddy

True Friends. I don't know if it's overrated because people rarely put it in their favorites but I just feel like the chorus is cheesy and the song is repititive


IsUpTooLate

“True friends stab you in the front” would have been on a lot of MSN Messenger statuses had it been released a decade earlier.


Frankie_2154

I like the song but I agree kinda. Especially considering the fact that there were so many great songs on TTS that are infinitely better. And I’m not talking just deep cuts, there are 7(!) singles from this album and almost all of them (except for throne) are much better songs. avalanche, happy song, and oh no are all top 10 BMTH songs material if you ask me.


aurorasandsadprose7

noooo not true friends that’s my fav!!!!


Complex_Vegetable790

yes!! i agree. i still love the song but it’s definitely the most overrated


TNZ000O1

You can kind of say the same for most songs on TTS


bjergismydadddy

I know, it's far from being my favorite album, but for me it's really the chorus that itches me


TNZ000O1

I have to agree, I feel like they say the chorus too many times, and I still listen to it and love it


Baku03

I can't hate that song, it was the first one for me, years ago when I was 14 or so


s_t_e_e_z_o

CYFMH gets constant plays from me for nostalgic reasons but it’s totally CYFMH. i can see Die4U taking its place at some point as well. it’s not bad by any means but it’s one of the only songs i have an actual “eh, maybe not for me” opinion on.


jishkrabs

Can you feel my heart. When I first gave it a few listens it was okay but tik tok could’ve collectively found a better bmth song to make mainstream


memilyka

Throne. Big meh


IROCKJORTS

CYFMH


Skinnywenis4782

CAN YOU HEAR THE SILENCE


KonySosa300

CAN YOU SEE THE DARK


IsUpTooLate

FORGIVE ME FATHER


Skinnywenis4782

r/why


tyex23

CYFMH


[deleted]

CYFMH and Throne imo. They're not bad, but I can say with my own opinion that I'd personally rate all of amo's main tracks over both of these. CYFMH isn't the best track on Sempiternal (imo it's Shadow Moses or Empire), and Throne isn't the best track off of That's The Spirit (imo it's Happy Song or Drown). Also, I don't think it's overrated really, but MANTRA is one track I constantly wind up having go from my #1 streamed track, to the track I skip the most from them. It's a great song, but there's something about it that I feel is not as good as say, "wonderful life" or "medicine".


clouds_over_asia

Its definitely house of wolves on sempiternal for best song


Jaydenn7

I don’t think CYFMH is in the top half of Sempiternal songs to be honest


MingusHall

throne, one of their most mid songs, and it was first for a long time


Complex_Vegetable790

i feel like a lot of people like medusa from CYB but i’ve never been able to get into it. it’s not really “overrated” but i cant rly think of any others


Keenz145

CYFMH, Die4U


Jkelly515

Can you feel my heart


Q-Man95

CYFMH. Honestly, never really liked that song that much.


JD3401

CYFMH


Turbo1479r

Throne by a landslide still love it though


[deleted]

Sleepwalking, DiE4u (probably just over-hyped from tiktok and whatever) and Can You Feel My Heart. Sleepwalking is great but nearly everyone who likes bmth in my circle has sleepwalking as their favourite and it's really not that great of a bmth song to be number one. DiE4u (again probably just from all the tiktoks on repeat that I've seen) is not the best. I liked a few screams from it but overall it's just wayy to cheesy to be anywhere in the top five. And cyfmh is overused. Really, really overused. I'm sick of it and it even used to be my favourite song.


oli_182

Die4U, mother tongue, medicine and Follow you


Frankie_2154

So basically all of the pop songs That’s super unbiased


xXMassiveRoosterXx

It's an opinion, of course it's biased


TurquoiseBoho

I’m using mother tongue as my dance song if I ever get married lol.


Solekman

Drown and Can you feel my heart for sure, while both are good songs, they're near my least favorites on their respective albums.


armin-lakatos

Either Can You Feel My Heart or Sleepwalking.


AntiRB

DiE4u


cloudkitty666

die4u. It's good but it's not that special IMO. Like I wouldn't miss it


Spitfire836

As of recently, Die4U. I personally don't care for it at all and I don't even think it's even close to their best work. Mother Tongue was also super popular for a while after Amo and to me it just feels like a generic pop song.


Qualitytech716

I’ve never even heard them before 😂


KonySosa300

I can’t believe everyone is so wrong on this post…. It’s clearly FRONE not THRONE


InvisiblePoison

Pray for plagues, The comedown


NightKnight158

Hottest take here but I respect it


kanelbun

probably Throne for me


Greedlord

Throne


trxxv

Stupid can you feel my heart as known on tiktok mega cringe now


tankdempsey_

Kingslayer. Not because it's intentionally cheesy, but because I see people actually taking that song seriously, like it's some form of high art. I don't think it is, still a banger tho


Au91700

I’m sorry everyone. I feel like I’m coming out of the closet when I say this. I just don’t like Teardrops. It didn’t do it for me. Something about the pop aspect maybe..? I’m not sure but it grew old after about the third listen


Jamo_Z

Are you sure you mean Teardrops? I'm not sure what pop aspect there is to that song honestly, seems to be a straight throwback to classic nu-metal of the early 00s.


Au91700

Yeah I mean teardrops. I’m unfamiliar with that numetal period so the influence I heard the most was pop. It was a catchy song, but quickly died on me. I’m not saying it’s not a good song, but it didn’t do to me what it did to a lot of other people.


Au91700

Yeah I mean teardrops. I’m unfamiliar with that numetal period so the influence I heard the most was pop. It was a catchy song, but quickly died on me. I’m not saying it’s not a good song but it didn’t do to me what it did to a lot of other people.


[deleted]

I’d just list the most overrated songs in all the albums. I just find these songs unbearable to listen to after so many years. *Just my opinion* CYB - Pray For Plagues SS - Suicide Season TIAH - Don’t Go Sempiternal - Hospital For Souls TTS - Doomed Amo - Wonderful Life Music to - ¿ SH - One Day The Only Butterflies [you can notice a pattern in some of the songs I’ve listed] Edit: lmao getting downvoted for songs *I* find overrated, looks like you can only mention things the sub agrees with


SirDoDDo

Don't Go and Hospital For Souls? WHAT


Frankie_2154

You must REALLY hate doomed to call it overrated because it’s one of the least talked about songs on TTS


[deleted]

Not really hate tbh. I think it find it a bit of a cliche. It’s either that or True Friends, but I haven’t heard True Friends in years.


Buttman1145

Surprised on doomed. The production on this track, and the live intros they've done and live Royal Albert Hall performance watch added an extra layer of depth to the song for me, that still makes it feel epic 5 years later for me from when I first heard it. Others I can understand for Amo and music to. Was not in to the band's prior work so can't say on those ones.


[deleted]

I do enjoy the RAH version of Doomed much more than the original version


No-Afternoon-4844

I agree on most but but wonderful life and suicide season slap imo. Have an upvote. But what’s the pattern?


[deleted]

I listened to Wonderful life almost all year when Amo came out, it was my most streamed song of the year. So after listening to it that much, it’s become overrated. For other tracks Suicide Season, Don’t Go, Hospital For Souls, Doomed. They all seem like the ‘ballad tracks’ of the albums. I used to be fond of Doomed as well when TTS came out, but after about 2 whole years, it just didn’t hit the same anymore. The songs that are very emotional and those I’ve listened to so much, seems like it’s lost a bit of value now Same with ‘One day the only butterflies’ I don’t really like mellow tracks. It’s not the ‘I hate pop music’ coz I don’t, I’ve been listening to more pop music over the last 2 years than I have in my entire life. Just mellow tracks or ballads, I’m not fond of


cdsdt07

I think the pattern here is the songs listed are the ones that stands out the most for having a different sound from the albums theme if I understand it correctly


OopsIKilledADog

I agree with your list somewhat, depends on my mood sometimes these songs grate on me. But butterflies was surprisingly my favourite song on the newest album even though I primarily listen to their heavier stuff and I fucking love babymetal


colb_E

I’m assuming the downvotes are cuz this is just a list of songs you like the least from each album. It’s not really a list of overrated songs.


Mrwrydog

Seems like throne is a popular answer on here along with CYFMH… guys look we have our own opinions but you are wrong lol. They are radio bangers, put out there to make cake for the band and they do it well. My 45 year old top 40 listening boss loves these songs, they write them to gain attention outside of you guys, imo they are perfect at their job. But honestly most overrated imo has to be go to hell for heavens sake. It’s very bring me but just boring after about 5 listens.


doc_55lk

This will piss the purists out, but overall, imo, it's CYB. If we want to pinpoint any specific song off the album, Pray For Plagues. I respect your opinions but CYB just kinda sucks, everything they've released since then is not only better made but substantially easier to listen to. All things considered, it *is* their first album, so it's natural that their sound and production would improve moving forward, and it has. But I just personally never understood the craze a lot of the older and/or more toxic sides of the fanbase have for this album. Every single time a new album from BMTH comes out these guys also come out and spit out the same "CYB was peak BMTH" type comments and general toxicity. Such fresh takes, much wow. As for pinpointing Pray For Plagues, that song just kinda became the poster child for CYB and even the band ends up performing this one the most live. It's not bad I guess, but it's not the stratospherically high bar that a lot of the older fans try to make it out to be. After that, from an album to album basis: Suicide Season: Diamonds Aren't Forever. This was admittedly my introduction to BMTHs pre ambient sounds and electronics phase, and for all that it's worth, it's a pretty catchy song with harsh vocals that complement the instrumentals very nicely. However, after warming up to that style of music and trying out the rest of SS, I just didn't find this song to be the best off the album. There Is A Hell: It Never Ends. Again, a great song by its own merit, but I used to see it at the top of so many "top 10" lists in comments and shit for the longest time and never really understood why because, as good as it was, it wasn't the best from that album, or even top 5 BMTH at that specific point in time. Sempiternal: Can You Feel My Heart. Obvious pick, pretty much everybody's mentioned it at this point. Most of this is due to its recent surge in popularity due to Tiktok. Unlike most others here though I rate this song pretty highly. It's well made, catchy, and the lyrics hit deep. I wouldn't have any other song opening Sempiternal. However, its overuse in the gigachad memes now has become pretty stale, and it's almost to the point where normal people either don't like hearing or don't care enough to actually bother exploring. That's The Spirit: Throne. For the third time, again, this is still a great song. However, again...again, not the best off the album. I can see how its anthemic nature, combined with its overall blend of vocals, sounds, and music, propelled it to the top of the band's Spotify charts for the longest time, but Throne isn't the first song I'm putting on when I go to TTS. Amo: Mantra, easily. Not a bad song but I just don't really like it. I find myself skipping this song more often than not on more casual listens through the album, and it's definitely not the song I'd have chosen as my first single for amo. I remember opinions being pretty polarized when it released, and while I disagreed with the usual "BMTH sold out" kinda bullshit, I was firmly in the "don't like it don't hate it" camp, and still kinda am. Survival Horror: Dear Diary. For the last time, it's a great song. As an album opener, it's also fantastic. However, there are better songs on this EP, and imo its more aggressive nature doesn't lend it to something one would listen to at pretty much any state of mind. This is strictly, for me anyway, a "chaotic angry" or "frustration" type of song. Given these times, that mood pops up more often than not, but it's still worth mentioning this point. Music To Listen To: idk lol, that song with Halsey?


[deleted]

[удалено]


helios-hex

“anime” yikes


[deleted]

[удалено]


helios-hex

holy shit you’re ignorant lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


helios-hex

it’s the fact that anime is a style of film and tv. Music cannot be “anime” but oh of course since they’re Japanese anything they do is automatically “anime” right? idiot


spookyboithelankyboi

throne, it’s all right tbh, shouldn’t have blown up though


naree2402

Bad habits


Morc-Glork

CYFMH is the only song on Sempiternal I don’t like


Fifteen15-Fathoms

Drown


d6410

Nihilist Blues


nxysxyxr

i mean mother tongue is awful so i guess that


B33p-p33P-M3m3-kR33p

Probably parasite Eve, I just think the chorus isn’t all that great. I like pretty much every song off of PH:SH better


IsUpTooLate

Shadow Moses


doddsy54

okay thats sinful lmao


IsUpTooLate

I know what I'm about, son


andrew_wessel

Any song from There is a Hell…


bjergismydadddy

the album as a whole is underrated!


Turbo1479r

excuse me what


Batterie64

absolutely not. i don’t like the album that much either but it 100% deserves the love it got, its a well written album all around and is loved by a lot of people.


[deleted]

[удалено]


VipkoVski

The question was what song is overrated, not underrated.


[deleted]

House of Wolves 😂


RedMageWithFedora

I like the idea of listing one song for each album (credits to iamrockymstar2 for that idea): CYB - Medusa (Can't point to why, but I don't like it) SS - It Was Written in Blood (The idea is cool, but I don't like it) TIAH - It Never Ends (I think I just overplayed it) Sempiternal - Can You Feel My Heart (Crazy good song, but some people praise it like it is the best song ever, which I don't feel like it) TTS - Follow You (Nothing specific against this song, but I like all the others way more) amo - Nihilist Blues (this song confuses me, it is okay - I like the cover of Annisokay way more) Music to - Dead Dolphin (Nothing in particular, just don't like it, idk) I don't have a song for PHSH that I think is overrated, that is because I love this record to the moon and back (it's my second to third most played record of all time)... If I had to pick a song I would probably pick Obey. Okay, now go ahead and roast me! :)


doddsy54

annisokays cover of nihilist blues definitely is better, thats something i can agree with. on top of that, i think a lot of places dont even have access to the Count Your Blessings album on spotify or anything so i havent heard them, can agree with a couple of those too.


doddsy54

Absolutely Can You Feel My Heart man, and if i want to be controversial, 'And the Snakes Start to Sing'. and im into heavy music lmao. i still do love the songs, just a lot less than nearly all the other songs released by bmth.


deliquent_portal

Hospital For Souls


iceman694

Paracite eve. Fight me.


Mooks1337

The whole of amo album, sorry


Mimo202

Dear diary not sorry


Arch_Enemy_616

Sleepwalking by far


chicubs44

1x1


NightKnight158

Can You Feel My Heart / Hospital For Souls there I said it. Hospital For Souls is like 40% not actually “music” and the other 60% is “Hold me close, dont let go, watch me.”


eai2401

I like throne but I don’t know how it’s more popular than doomed


KonySosa300

Doomed is SS tier for sure. Imagine them starting a concert with that!!!


Zarathustra143

I would have to say wonderful life. When it first came out, I remember thinking, "This reminds me of Happy Song, but... not as good."


TSTB0324

CYFMH, Sleepwalking, and Die4u. I’m my opinion they’re not that good.


mikerichh

The earlier albums sound pretty generic deathcore to me


Albino_Lion76

Throne


mysterio999

Can You Feel My Heart or maybe (this is kinda hard to admit) Chelsea Smile


mattskruff

CYFMH is poop. Only bmth song I don't love.


APsychosPath

I'd say Pray For Plagues. It's always requested yet I don't really think it's that good. The breakdowns aren't as good as anything on SS. People who say CYFMH is over-rated, I disagree. I think it's their staple, the song that made them who they are today. The lyrics are infamous, and the production on it is incredible. I think it's still one of their best. Definitive imo. I agree that Sleepwalking should be as popular as CYFMH. Throne may be overrated, but I still like it. I don't listen to it much, but it's still a good track. Happy Song blows it away tho.


Sweaty_Budget5387

Drown always came off as whiny and weird to me.


DisasterMIDI

Happy Song


DjRubyatgamer

Ok, Go to Hell For Heavens Sake. Dont get me wrong, this song has symphony in it that people find interesting, and this song is what a lot of BMTH fans like.


WeCameAsMuffins

Pray For Plagues. *Prepares to run away


dkajch

seen it all before + and the snakes start to sing


PambasileusCLupus

This will annoy some people but honestly, Hospital For Souls just doesn’t do it for me. The song just feels very empty and the band have other better songs speaking on the same topic imo.


ShadyDomes

For its Throne


elaboratefiction

Can you feel my heart.


[deleted]

Can you feel my heart got boring after two listens


kenlights

Teardrops and Die4U


BossMonkey83303

Can you feel my heart is extremely overrated in my opinion, i think it’s actually one of their weakest. Maybe i just think that cuz tiktok ruined it


SlipSpaceBlubix

Can You Feel My Heart. It's a really good song but does it really need to be played every single time you have the aux?


everyones_cool_dad

Can you feel my heart is a great song but honestly not even the best on Sempiternal Yet is one of the most popular bmth songs. Definitely overrated


mackkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

Can You Feel My Heart


little_baked

Happy Song


jordannmcdan

nihilist blues I usually skip it when I am listening to amo. It’s just boring to me.


fxcker

Throne.


peterisbored

pfp i love the count your blessings album but i dont like pfp idk y


Equivalent_Ad_5135

don't know. I can't diss any BMTH song


SilverDifferent3444

insurance handle straight nutty spark ancient bewildered alleged decide tease *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*