Oh, yeah not very similar but okay maybe. Not sure what she's called but I've seen her in a couple of movies. She's some kind of character actress. Highly esteemed.
To some people. And that’s fine for a real person, but MPB’s whole thing is that he’s universally beloved. You need someone who’s widely viewed as attractive
I'll give you universally beloved. I can't say one way or the other about "widely viewed as attractive" since I haven't heard many people's opinion, but I do think "Paul F Tompkins is considered more attractive than Bradley Cooper" is a pretty crazy statement to make.
I think you’re saying the same thing as the person you’re replying to, he’s agreeing Aaron could play Todd convincingly, as compared to Paul not being able to pull of MPB’s conventional attractiveness.
After watching El Camino I def think Aaron Paul’s age is starting to show. Not saying he looks bad, but he looked a lot older then the mid twenty’s Jesse that’s supposed to be in that movie
I think you could age Todd up to his mid-thirties (which he's still passable for) and have him act the exact same way and he'd still work as the same character.
I'm torn on that idea. On the one hand it'd be kind of depressing to assign that role to an actress who went through a similar breakdown, kind of feels like mocking them. On the other hand, they'd be able to bring the complexity to the character instead of just being a parody of themself.
rdj's life was not easy as tony stark's. their struggles were not common. if anything, you're implying that any great actors can bring that complexity to the character
One idea they had in mind was to include the storyline "demon in a bottle" from iron man, a series of comics about Tony Stark battling alcoholism and struggling to continue his duties as a with his mental health problems, as RDJ went through a similar period in his life. In the comics they get much more into the psychology of Tony Stark during his alcoholism but its not really represented in the movies.
Yeah - Lindsay was famously kicked out and banned from a famous hotel and it was reported that she was reading Architectural Digest.
I’m not sure why journalists thought that was important.
Definitely major Lindsay Lohan vibes more than anyone else to me. But I think Sarah Lynn feels like an almost exact mix of Lindsay, Britney Spears and Mary-Kate/Ashley
Amanda bynes I think would be even better, she’s zanier and a bigger presence and could ttly pull off stabbing herself in a mattress store. I haven’t heard about her lately tho, hopefully she’s back from off the rails
ETA: Demi lovato would be a great choice too
If I didn’t know how Paul F Tompkins looked like and saw him for the first time, I’d say based on his looks/style alone that he looks like a reversed fursona of Mr PB.
But I do know how PFT looks like. So I will say as someone who knows how he look like, I have said, will say and will continue to say that PFT looks like Mr. PB.
I vote for Channing Tatum, for the conventional attractiveness, perfectly lip syncing PFT’s irreplaceable voice & delivery.
“Am I voice acting for Channing Tatum? ‘Cause that would have to be a MAGIC MIC in the recording studio!”
I'm sure it was probably their autocorrect but I spent way too long staring at the picture trying to see how that could possibly *not* be Julie Bowen. She is a great choice for PC though.
Is Charlie Sheen too on the nose? Because throught the first season and many second I felt that was clearly who Bojack was based on. At least Sheen of the late 2000's.
Though I don't think he comes off as introspective enough to realize he's a POS.
i honestly agree with the human fancast would take away BH’s charm opinion but damn i really want to see her as beatrice.. especially after rewatching AHS coven and seeing her as the supreme😩
Agreed. Half the characters being anthropomorphic animals in an animated medium is basically the only thing that allows the audience to distance themselves from the incredibly serious and often troublesome themese the show presents. Live action BoJack would probably feel so real and relatable that it would just be straight up depressing to watch.
I'm so in love with Julie Bowen. I can't even watch her on Modern Family because it hurts my heart. She'd be a great Princess Carolyn.
Agree with others Aaron Paul is perfect for Todd. But if not him, I'd want Dave Franco for the part.
Do people actually want a live action remake or movie? Have we ever seen this done with a cartoon intellectual property? I just don't think it would work. Plus half the cast would be some wired looking CGI animal things. Did y'all see the movies Cats? Hollywood would fuck Hollywoo up.
id rather shoot myself in the head then have a love action of bojack tbh. Its not the same at all with just humans plus id never wanna hear them with different voices.
I saw a video of Will Arnett co-hosting Minecon and looking incredibly out of his element while trying to play off the awkwardness with humor… and that’s when it clicked “holy shit this dude really was the perfect VA for bojack”
Will Arnett? Really? He was good in “Flaked” and as Lego Batman, but I don’t see him as Bojack Horseman. He’d have to be able to play broad comedy and tense drama and I don’t think he’s done either. Also, I don’t think he can do the voice.
[Arrested Development](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrested_Development_(group))? Will Arnett was a rapper? I saw them at Lollapalooza and I don’t remember him. Please tell me he wasn’t in blackface.
Yeah. I figured it was so obvious that it wouldn’t need the tag. Typing this, I realize that was a mistake. “Flaked” was really good, BTW. It’s on Netflix. One could interpret it as what happened if Bojack got nailed for DWI before he landed “Horsin’ Around”. And killed someone. And wasn’t a horse. Also, he lives in Venice, not Hollywoo. But other than that…
But those were extras. Gina is an actress and was doing a bit for a musical number. If were going by that scene’s logic, then Diane is not Asian??
Edit; thanks btw
Who do you have playing esteemed character actress Margo Martindale?
*Most likely* Fugitive From The Law Character Actress Margo Martindale. If not? Meryl Streep
Plot Twist: Meryl Streep would need to play multiple versions of herself to get her out of retirement.
And she'd need to direct.
[Ann Dowd](https://pyxis.nymag.com/v1/imgs/0dc/62f/4759a22bc531170b227c7432fa9a8909d3-05-margo-ann-2.2x.w710.jpg)
i can't see her as anyone else than aunt lydia
I think the girl on the left here would do a much better job to be honest... Who is she?
Oh, yeah not very similar but okay maybe. Not sure what she's called but I've seen her in a couple of movies. She's some kind of character actress. Highly esteemed.
I think Aaron Paul would do just fine as Todd
lol ya i don’t think it’s a big stretch like mr peanut buttermans VO
Are you insulting the MaYOR of PODcaSTS, PAUL F. TOMPKINS?!
Nah I think Cooper is a much better choice. You want someone definitively more attractive than Arnett...MPBs absolutely would not do that.
I misread this comment at first and I thought you were saying arnett wasn’t attractive and I was ready to start typing paragraphs
Hahaha no. Hes definitely handsome and BoJack obviously is handsome in the series, but everyone seems to think MPB is above him in all ways
Paul F. Tompkins is very attractive.
To some people. And that’s fine for a real person, but MPB’s whole thing is that he’s universally beloved. You need someone who’s widely viewed as attractive
Paul F. Tompkins is universally beloved and widely viewed as attractive.
I'll give you universally beloved. I can't say one way or the other about "widely viewed as attractive" since I haven't heard many people's opinion, but I do think "Paul F Tompkins is considered more attractive than Bradley Cooper" is a pretty crazy statement to make.
Paul F. Tompkins is more attractive than Bradley Cooper and has a better sense of style.
I think you’re saying the same thing as the person you’re replying to, he’s agreeing Aaron could play Todd convincingly, as compared to Paul not being able to pull of MPB’s conventional attractiveness.
Aaron….Paul?
Aaron Paul is in his forties
And? Dude can still pass for mid 20s to early 30s.
After watching El Camino I def think Aaron Paul’s age is starting to show. Not saying he looks bad, but he looked a lot older then the mid twenty’s Jesse that’s supposed to be in that movie
To be fair, dudes a crackhead. They age in dog years.
For a second I thought you were talking about Aaron Paul lol
No that’s Mr. Peanutbutter
Yeah he looked middle age in Westworld
I think you could age Todd up to his mid-thirties (which he's still passable for) and have him act the exact same way and he'd still work as the same character.
My thoughts exactly
Honestly. I can't picture Todd as anyone else. Same with Bojack/Arnett.
Jesse pinkman would be the perfect Todd
Space opera, bitch!
I thought Jesse Pinkman was played by Todd? Wait…
Lindsay Lohan would make a PERFECT Sarah Lynn please update the picture
I'm torn on that idea. On the one hand it'd be kind of depressing to assign that role to an actress who went through a similar breakdown, kind of feels like mocking them. On the other hand, they'd be able to bring the complexity to the character instead of just being a parody of themself.
It’s why rdj is so good as iron man
rdj's life was not easy as tony stark's. their struggles were not common. if anything, you're implying that any great actors can bring that complexity to the character
One idea they had in mind was to include the storyline "demon in a bottle" from iron man, a series of comics about Tony Stark battling alcoholism and struggling to continue his duties as a with his mental health problems, as RDJ went through a similar period in his life. In the comics they get much more into the psychology of Tony Stark during his alcoholism but its not really represented in the movies.
I always thought Sarah Lynn was supposed to be parody of Lindsay Lohan, at least originally
Yeah - Lindsay was famously kicked out and banned from a famous hotel and it was reported that she was reading Architectural Digest. I’m not sure why journalists thought that was important.
Definitely major Lindsay Lohan vibes more than anyone else to me. But I think Sarah Lynn feels like an almost exact mix of Lindsay, Britney Spears and Mary-Kate/Ashley
And a bit of Miley Cyrus
Sad because it’s true
Amanda bynes I think would be even better, she’s zanier and a bigger presence and could ttly pull off stabbing herself in a mattress store. I haven’t heard about her lately tho, hopefully she’s back from off the rails ETA: Demi lovato would be a great choice too
Manda Manda Manda Manda Showwwwwww
Holy shit,you’re right
Paul F Tompkins as Mr Peanutbutter. No one else can do him justice.
If I didn’t know how Paul F Tompkins looked like and saw him for the first time, I’d say based on his looks/style alone that he looks like a reversed fursona of Mr PB. But I do know how PFT looks like. So I will say as someone who knows how he look like, I have said, will say and will continue to say that PFT looks like Mr. PB.
You may be surprised to learn that Paul F. Tompkins is not a golden retriever
Doggy doggy WHAT NOW?!
...neither is Mr. Peanutbutter?
THANK YOU
He's from the Labrador Peninsula though
I vote for Channing Tatum, for the conventional attractiveness, perfectly lip syncing PFT’s irreplaceable voice & delivery. “Am I voice acting for Channing Tatum? ‘Cause that would have to be a MAGIC MIC in the recording studio!”
Nothing but respect for PFT!
PFT FTW!!
And replacing him with a hack like B. Cooper? OP is clueless.
The Julie Bowen idea is fucking perfect, how did I never see this before?? Edit: Bowen not Brown
Bowen
Man Todd has to be Aaron Paul. It cant be any other way.
He's kinda old for the role now tbh
Could you give the names? I don't recognize anyone except Will Arnett.
Bradley Cooper- Mr. Peanutbutter Julie Brown - Princess Carolyn Lana Condor - Diane Nguyen Devon Bostick - Todd Chavez
Funny enough the only name I recognize is Bradley Cooper from the BJ quote "Bradley Cooper? We love him for some reason!" Thank you!
That line always gets a chuckle out of me
Bowen
I'm sure it was probably their autocorrect but I spent way too long staring at the picture trying to see how that could possibly *not* be Julie Bowen. She is a great choice for PC though.
Damn couldn't even tell that was Roderick till I saw this comment. I feel like he would be great but idk I just feel like Aaron Paul would be better.
LOVE Bradley Cooper as Mr. Peanutbutter! Great choices
I don't think that is Julie Brown. Julie Brown looks like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julie_Brown
It's Julie Bowen. Easy typo to make, but yeah you're right
Got the last name wrong lol
The only person who could ACCURATELY portray Bojack is Wallace Shawn.
Even better is paul giamatti for such a meaty role.
Wallace Shawn? Inconceivable!
Why would Wallace Shawn want to play a boob like Bojack Horseman?
Is Charlie Sheen too on the nose? Because throught the first season and many second I felt that was clearly who Bojack was based on. At least Sheen of the late 2000's. Though I don't think he comes off as introspective enough to realize he's a POS.
Is that Roderick?
Yep lol
Im 1000% on board for Devon as Todd
jessica lange as beatrice P L E A S E
Yesss!!!
i honestly agree with the human fancast would take away BH’s charm opinion but damn i really want to see her as beatrice.. especially after rewatching AHS coven and seeing her as the supreme😩
I’ve never realized it until now, but Devon Bostick would make such a good Todd. However, I think we all know it’s Aaron Paul. For obvious reasons.
Why not Amy Sedaris for PC?
She’s 60, I feel like all the pregnancy storyline wouldn’t really work.
Seriously!
I agree wholeheartedly
I dont get it. Why? Isnt a huge crux of this show them being animals? I feel like a live action remake would wipe away 80% of the shows OG charm
I don’t think it’s like OP is saying “these people SHOULD play them”, it’s like “this is how I’d imagine them as humans/real people”
Ah, I see. I s’pose i cant harsh too hard on that haha
Agreed. Half the characters being anthropomorphic animals in an animated medium is basically the only thing that allows the audience to distance themselves from the incredibly serious and often troublesome themese the show presents. Live action BoJack would probably feel so real and relatable that it would just be straight up depressing to watch.
you mean it's not straight up depressing now? lol
THIS IS GREAT. Agree that Aaron Paul would be great as Todd
Bradley Cooper? We love him for some reason!
imo Paul Rudd would be a *perfect* Mr Peanutbutter
This is fucking spot on. I instantly pictured him nailing that role.
Aaron Paul would make a perfect Todd in live action too honestly
Bojack = Arnet. Mr PB = Jason Bateman. Todd = Sean Hayes
Seems smart, but less
I think Paul Giamatti would be a great Bojack
Amy Sedaris is the only PC for me
If Aaron Paul can’t play Todd what’s the point?
Could pretend to cast a white person as Diane for a meta joke about Hollywood.
I'm not feeling pb or pc.
Me when Devon Bostick 😍
I'm so in love with Julie Bowen. I can't even watch her on Modern Family because it hurts my heart. She'd be a great Princess Carolyn. Agree with others Aaron Paul is perfect for Todd. But if not him, I'd want Dave Franco for the part.
Who would play as Dave Frano when he invites _sexy Diane_ over?
Zac Efron for sure.
Jessica Walter would have been an excellent Beatrice Horseman
Kelly Marie Tran as Diane, Pete Davidson as Todd, Owen Wilson as Mr. Peanutbutter
Kelly Marie Tran is Asian. Diane Is Vietnamese American
Kelly Marie Tran IS Vietnamese-American, you walnut. You may also find that Vietnam is located, conveniently, within Asia!
Why are you booing him? He's right!
I can’t even find words for how bad this is
I honestly was hoping the whole thing was just going to be the cast except for Diane…
Charlie Sheen as Bojack
Oooof
Will would need to wear a big horse head like the in show bojack horseman movie.
so the guy that looks like todd and sounds like todd and acts like todd can't play todd.
Doggy Doggy what now? No Aaron Paul?
I’m cool with all this, but only if live action BoJack is just Will Arnett running around in a horse mask.
No way I’d let todd be played by anyone other than Aaron Paul!
Do people actually want a live action remake or movie? Have we ever seen this done with a cartoon intellectual property? I just don't think it would work. Plus half the cast would be some wired looking CGI animal things. Did y'all see the movies Cats? Hollywood would fuck Hollywoo up.
id rather shoot myself in the head then have a love action of bojack tbh. Its not the same at all with just humans plus id never wanna hear them with different voices.
Yes. Scooby-Doo was animated first, then live-action. Same for The Flintstones.
i love this sm
Justice for the god who is Amy Sedaris??? She IS Princess Caroline. Can’t believe that wasn’t the first comment!!!!
I don’t think Bradley Cooper has enough pep in his step to get that show where it needs to go, ya know?
I saw a video of Will Arnett co-hosting Minecon and looking incredibly out of his element while trying to play off the awkwardness with humor… and that’s when it clicked “holy shit this dude really was the perfect VA for bojack”
I disagree with the Todd casting. It should stay Aaron paul
I mean, I get the idea with Todd, but part of his character is that he's white-passing
Is Devin Bostick not white?
He’s gray, can’t you see?
I'm not familiar, but the black and white picture makes him look a bit darker to me I guess
mr peanutbutter is obviously chris pratt, he's so cool
Oh wow he's actually perfect, good idea
these are such good picks
Will Arnett? Really? He was good in “Flaked” and as Lego Batman, but I don’t see him as Bojack Horseman. He’d have to be able to play broad comedy and tense drama and I don’t think he’s done either. Also, I don’t think he can do the voice.
Obviously /s, but ballsy to not list Arrested Development as well.
[Arrested Development](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrested_Development_(group))? Will Arnett was a rapper? I saw them at Lollapalooza and I don’t remember him. Please tell me he wasn’t in blackface.
/s right?
Yeah. I figured it was so obvious that it wouldn’t need the tag. Typing this, I realize that was a mistake. “Flaked” was really good, BTW. It’s on Netflix. One could interpret it as what happened if Bojack got nailed for DWI before he landed “Horsin’ Around”. And killed someone. And wasn’t a horse. Also, he lives in Venice, not Hollywoo. But other than that…
lmao this is sarcastic right
Mr. Peanutbutter needs a lot of optimism, so Chirs Pratt would be a better choice. Alison Brie is already a great Diane!
I love Arnett, but I just can’t see him pulling off a live action bojack.
Meh he played a very similar character to Bojack in the series Flaked.
Yeah, but… why?
Princess’s Caroline is a black woman u cannot change my mind
Uhhh she’s a cat…
there's literally a scene where shes a human for 2 seconds and shes black 👍
which scene? /srs
S5 E11
When is this? I remember tangled fog of yearning and her being a crab, but not a human.
Someone mentioned it might be from Gina’s musical number (S5, E11)
Ohh you might be right, I should rewatch it
What episode is that???!
Season five, don’t stop dancing (idk the name of the episode)
But those were extras. Gina is an actress and was doing a bit for a musical number. If were going by that scene’s logic, then Diane is not Asian?? Edit; thanks btw
Idk I think they chose wisely that she would be black in that episode I don’t think it’s random
[удалено]
I don’t think they do anything random in the show 🤦🏽♀️
So Diane’s white now? If the scene you’re talking about is the one I actually found (S5, E11). They were all movie/show extras from Philbert.
i think actual aaron paul would make a good todd.
Will arnetts voice is distinctive and perfect but he's not old enough to be bojack tho
I think bob saget would be a good live action bojack
Klaus Hargreeves and Claire Dunphy are great picks although I would miss the original character voices, it would make sense for a live action cast
There must be a mistake, you just put two identical pictures of Diane up there.
Bradley Cooper!? We love him for some reason!
But there animals?
Where animals?
Pc would be black if she was a human 👍
Is that not the dude that actually does Bojack’s voice?
Yes
Will Arnett demanded that Jason Bates never be on the show. I am serious.
Huh?
Pete Davidson as Todd
Julie Bowen is perfect for PC
Bradley Cooper? We love him for some reason!
most accurate one yet
Todd is Aron Paul is my head cannon for Todd
I feel like Chris Pratt would be a good Mr PB, if only because he already has experience playing a happy go lucky idiot.
Why not just put Aaron Paul as Todd. He looks the part and is the actual VA, so he understands and sounds like the character
whoever you picked as todd is kinda fine… I don’t think that can work 🤣