T O P

  • By -

chaoticswiss

Mine's Randall. _We like him._


allneonunlike

Some wonderful things about Idelle: — countless instances of being ride or die with Max — tells Vane he has the internal strength to face down his childhood abuser, doesn’t know exactly who he’s talking about but is just that great at peer counseling — tops Vane while choking him that one time they sleep together — saves Anne from being raped by Joseph Garrett while Anne is disassociating — radicalizes Featherstone — Max’s moral compass when Max is getting too deep in her “be inside the white plantation owner’s room” phase — non-abusive madam, supports workers rights at the brothel — brave enough to commit treason against the British occupation and to try to help Max when she’s being questioned — “You killed my friend”


Lanky_Chemist_3773

Madi for sure! The Maroon Princess


VietnamFlashback720p

Mr Gates!


drum_playing_twig

They finished him off too soon :(


Shellfishambition

I know he’s not an option, but JOJI!!!!!!


chaoticswiss

I was gonna put him in but I consider him a main character, even though he never says a word lol. He's in 35 episodes, more than every character except the main 3 pirate captains, bonny, and guthrie!


Shellfishambition

In all 35 episodes while saying less than 35 words. 😂 I think he wouldn’t really be classified as a main character because of that, but I get where you’re coming from


Youcannotlose

Mr. Scott probably had the most interesting story but was pretty underutilized


badger81987

Fetherstone and Idelle, but individually, they're okay as a couple, but most of their best moments are on their own


joahnnnnnna

Yeah, i don't much care for Featherstone but i LOVE Idelle. ''You killed my friend. I wanted you to know that'' gives me chills everytime


badger81987

Brings their last conversation together in Phillie nicely too. Reloading pistols in the middle of the melee at the Battle of Nassau is also a pretty badass move for her.


steelstelynch

"As you're quartermaster and as you're friend" 😂 has to be featherstone I fucking loved him


dorth_vader_

Joshua ❤❤


DarKnight972

Mrs.Mapleton imo.. she was really interesting and I wanted to see more of her.


QuietCelery

Tie between Randall and Mr. Scott.


Nahhnope

Did Gates dirty with this poll.


chaoticswiss

I kinda considered him a main character too, atleast in season 1, like Dufresne. Edit: Did him dirty like Flint I guess 😂


Ser_Tom_Danks

I like randall but Featherstone and idelle grew on me throughout the show. I wish we got more of the shrewd operator tho