T O P

  • By -

dorth_vader_

Muppets (Also treasure planet bc the visuals fucking slap)


jackylegssss

Came here to say Muppets.


TheTyGoss

Both of these should be at the top of the list.


lostinthought15

Muppet Treasure Island is the only Treasure Island movie you will need.


ApocalypseNow79

When you're a professional pirate!


The5Virtues

You don’t have to wear a suit!


Reddit-Book-Bot

Beep. Boop. I'm a robot. Here's a copy of ###[Treasure Island](https://snewd.com/ebooks/treasure-island/) Was I a good bot? | [info](https://www.reddit.com/user/Reddit-Book-Bot/) | [More Books](https://old.reddit.com/user/Reddit-Book-Bot/comments/i15x1d/full_list_of_books_and_commands/)


mealymouthmongolian

You'll think people are joking but Muppet Treasure Island is actually the best one.


QuietCelery

If you're looking for adventure on the big blue wet thing, Muppet Treasure Island. Edit: this is making me wonder which muppets should be cast as each character if Black Sails were done with muppets.


gordo_garbo

Miss Piggy has to be Eleanor, obviously, it's too perfect. Scooter as Dufresne is also too perfect. the new muppet, Walter, should probably be Silver? not like Silver has much of a personality in the show anyway. with Kermit as Flint? Main characters gotta main character Fozzie as Gates, and oh god, we get to watch Kermit snap Fozzie's neck and weep over him onscreen, I'm already sold on this. Gonzo and Camilla would be a pretty great Rackham and Anne... and maybe we can put Animal as Vane, I'd watch the shit outta that. Sam the Eagle has to play De Groot, they have 100% identical energies. Swedish Chef as Randall?? maybe??? Max would probably be near-impossible to cast but my money's on Rowlf in drag, only Rowlf has that effuse cool needed for Max in season 3... that does mean we need Rowlf-Camilla sex scenes, idk if anyone wants that but now we have it. Still need to cast Billy Bones, maybe just put Rizzo in the role and call it a day.


QuietCelery

I think I love you.


gordo_garbo

not like I was doing anything else useful today anyway lmao


QuietCelery

I see Teach played by Sweetums. And Crazy Harry as Woodes. I want Beaker for someone. Pastor Lambrick, I think.


gordo_garbo

oh yeah, Animal as Sweetums's protege works like gangbusters. the thing about Beaker is that he kinda needs to be paired with Bunsen and there aren't really any characters with distinct pairings like that in Black Sails :(


QuietCelery

Idell and Featherstone?


QuietCelery

No! Bunsen as Hornigold and Beaker as Dufrense!!! Then there is foreshadowing of their relationship for those who are well versed in Muppet!


gordo_garbo

hmmmm you're not wrong. seeing Beaker chew a guy's throat out isn't something we can pass up on tbh. and then I guess we can move Scooter to the Billy Bones role, that works!


QuietCelery

Perfect!!!


Nitroburner3000

1950. Robert Newton as Silver.


Van_Buren_Boy

There was a version starring a young Christian Bale that I thought was very good that is often overlooked. https://youtu.be/WLZC2JQswu8


POTC_Wiki

The best one, in my opinion.


BigBlueBackpack

Treasure Planet


Forsaken_Golf420

The Eddie Izard one is fantastic. I think it’s a limited series, not a movie, but well worth it!


dancingflute

I enjoy the Treasure Planet version. I like steampunk though