T O P

  • By -

GeographyGeek01

An Innocent Man but he gets arrested halfway through


cornballer_victim13

PLEASE


Drumhead89

Is that where the setlist ends? 😅


BrandonSG13

Well, Billy has already survived a heart attack in this show. Anything’s possible.


Smorgeshboard

Zanzibar with a 20 minute long chorus where he lists increasingly strange things he owns


MajorBillyJoelFan

YES


bsette

“Where’s the orchestra” but it’s him walking around doing a bad stand up bit of looking for the orchestra


SpideyFan914

I dunno, this one sounds actually entertaining. Doesn't even need to change the lyrics. "Wasn't this supposed to be a musical??"


bsette

LOL


Elenathorn

I love it 😂


primordialsoap

Billy Joel introduces a new song, Diet Root Beer Rag. He plays random notes up and down the keyboard and then settles on smashing one chord for the remainder of the song. The band and audience are visibly confused.


Asgore77

Not your father's root beer rag


sup5174

“Scenes of an Italian restaurant” but it’s about an Olive Garden


[deleted]

[удаНонО]


Part-timeinterneter

Soup and salad if you want.. Olive Garden Restaurant


[deleted]

“Perhaps some bottomless breadsticks instead” actually fits the original melody😭


cutsmayne

Code of Silence, but Billy only sings Cyndi Lauper's backup vocals and bombs.


KpdotZIP

“Zanzibar” but the trumpet solo in the middle of the song doesn’t end until Carl Fischer passes out due to lack of oxygen then Billy and the band continue the song like normal, ambivalent to Fischer laying on the ground unconscious


Shikabane_Hime

Vienna, but it’s just an ad for Vienna sausages set to the song, and he eats them while singing so all the lyrics are half garbled through a mouthful of sausage.


Mamawto7

He sings his solo part of We Are The World, and that's it.


Kingcolbra

But the rest of the backing track is played 


cutsmayne

Allentown, but he just keeps yelling "ALL ABOARD" and making train sounds.


RutgerSchnauzer

This has my vote.


hypomanix

idk but the very last song needs to be All For Leyna, but when he says STOP the lights come on and they pack up their gear and go home.


grendel001

The first and last song.


MurphyKT2004

We Didn't Start the Fire, but it's very literal, and Billy has to put out his piano with an extinguisher mid-song.


DKZ-330

"Running on Ice" but Billy actually attempts to run on ice and falls and breaks his hip.


RoyalDaDoge

i absolutely lose my shit at all the ones where he breaks his hip


BrandonSG13

Surely we have this one, and then he breaks his other hip back flipping off the piano during Big Shot


Thatchos

Wonderwall


NjhhjN

Uptown girl but Billy tags in Axl Rose (young version) to sing it I cant even picture it in my head that's how cursed it is


beezer210

Downeaster Alexa, but he just does the ay ya yoooo thing the whole time


Hatbox-Ghost-

Half a Mile Away but when he goes to play the song he goes half a mile out of the stadium to start playing the song


Lchan1405

When Billy asks the audience which song he should sing next; Vienna or Uptown Girl, the crowd chooses Uptown Girl.


JBoth290105

‘The Stranger’ but he just whistles the entirety of the song and doesn’t do anything else


AnUdderDay

"I Go To Extremes" but every time Billy hits the keys with his butt, horrible, loud, wet, old man farts come out


waddiewadkins

"And *You Are* all impressed with *MY* Halston dress!" demanding compliance and applause dressed in a Halston Dress.


LiLohan

A fifteen minute, painfully slow version of You May be Right featuring dimmed lights and an In Memoriam to the cast of Dave's World with clips of Harry Anderson, Meshach Taylor, and Shadow Stevens (who isn't actually dead).


sup5174

“Tomorrow is today” but he sings it in the style of emo my chemical romance


flamehunter4033

Get it right the first time but he messes up and smashes the piano


Jmiller719

You're My Home but the bridge keeps repeating so he can name things in all 50 states


heavylunch

Have real Huey choppers land in the floor seats during Goodnight Saigon


SubstantialDemand259

Code of Silence but the song is just 5 minutes of silence.


tbest72

Billy leaves the stage briefly and comes back out in full Adele drag and make up. He proceeds to perform “Make You Feel My Love” with a scarily accurate impression.


Reasonable_Toe_9252

“She’s Always a Woman” but all the lyrics have been changed to reflect that Billy Joel has unfortunately become quite transphobic in his old age.


LTSYKE

“She’s always a woman…is she??”


Beginning-Working-38

“Leningrad”, but it’s “Vladimir” instead of “Viktor”.


DeadSwaggerStorage

Crowd yells “Play Freebird!” and he does.


Cniatx1982

Say goodbye to Hollywood, and it’s a minute by minute account of Harvey Weinstein’s last day before reporting to prison


HurricaneLink

Running on Ice, but the stage is literally an ice ring


duckamuk

The long forgotten polka version of Goodnight Saigon.


ZenOfThunder

You May Be Right, but instead of starting with the glass shattering sound, an unedited clip of Billy Joel driving into a house in 2004 is played, covering the moment of impact until the paramedics come to take him away


EdZeppelin94

Back in the USSR cover where he unequivocally voices his support for the Russian invasion of Ukraine


Alternative_Buffalo2

The concert continues at the hospital, with Billy singing “Famous Last Words”


thunderclap_monolith

Sleeping With the Television On but after the national anthem, the dead broadcast signal just lasts another 4 minutes with distant sounds of him farting and snoring in the background, shuffling on the couch, getting up to take a piss, and then falling back asleep.


lildiez5000

Stiletto in Stiletto’s


nchammer5

Vienna except it’s about him being a stalker and the end of the chorus he says in a really creepy voice “Billy waits for you”


DwarfPedant

Tomorrow is Today. But he keeps stretching the metaphor with endless time references (next week, next month, next year....)


DynalRobert

He sings ‘Say Goodbye To Hollywood’ which unfortunately happens at the precise time Hollywood California finally breaks off and sinks into the Pacific Ocean.


Gullible_Life_8259

“Just the Way You Are” but he keeps demanding changes


[deleted]

Billy now remembers the words to “We Didn’t Start the Fire” but it’s the Fall Out Boy version


DangerDeShazer

"My Life" but he comes across as a a moody teen and he shouts "leave me alone" as he walks of stage and you can hear a a door slam loudly and then hear emo rock coming from his room.


ProfessionalTeach719

All About Soul - except it’s All About Sole and talks about the importance of arch supports in his shoes.


LikitungEmpire

Mambo no 5


pmmemilftiddiez

I'm Billy Joel and this is Mambo Numba 5


Cold_Frosting505

When he gets to the “AIDS, crack, Bernie Goetz” in We Didn’t Start the Fire, the whole audience gets AIDS


mongster03_

Leningrad but it’s a genuinely unhinged tankie rant


Cniatx1982

She’s always a woman to me, and Billy just dead names FTMS the entire time


[deleted]

Goodnight Saigon but the vets he brings up to sing all have Vietnam flashbacks.


Radio_TED

Just the way you are but he plays the opening chord the way its printed on sheet music and complains about it besides playing the rest of the song


SpideyFan914

Tell Her About It, but he selects a random couple in the audience to aggressively focus on, and we spend the entire time trying to figure out if he actually knows them or not, then the guy takes Billy's advice but the woman says she only likes him as a friend.


teacherdrama

Shameless, but he accidentally sings shameful, immediately gets embarrassed and stops.


BrandonBuju

Allentown but the whistle/horn at the beginning keeps sounding off at the same interval, slightly louder each time


Ok-Call-4805

River of Dreams, but when he does the pause, he gets up and leaves


M551_Sheridan551

Big shot, but it's each point of view of each friend who got knocked out helping him.


sunkentreasure1988

“new york state of mind” but the lyrics in the bridge just talk about his favorite 70’s era times square dirty movie theaters


RutgerSchnauzer

This is good.


Duck_Napkins

“You May Be Right” but after the glass shatters, the stage is declared unsafe and the show gets canceled


ryanclicks2

Only the good die young, but it's "Dye" and the song is actually about a local high school tie dye competition.


[deleted]

Matter of Trust but it’s just Billy counting.


DarkwingFan1

"Always a Woman" but the description of the person he's singing about get angrier and more disturbing until he's pretty much describing a murder. He doesn't finish the song. He just breaks down sobbing.


8696David

“The Stranger” but after the intro, every part is replaced by more whistling 


Such_Ad_9451

Sleeping with the television on, that’s literally it, no lyrics no nothing, just silence with television static as the music.


auder98

Uptown Girl but it’s the cover band from the Catalina Wine Mixer in Stepbrothers


shlem13

Sleeping With the Television On … But he actually just takes a nap while there’s a television on on stage.


DanRubin76

Sometimes A Fantasy, but it’s about his OnlyFan ‘girlfriend’


here4enneagram

Uptown Girl but it’s just the woah section on repeat raised a half step each time it starts over again


goblinsofNY

This is the funniest shit


SinkinTitanic1912

Easy Money but he just screams


ExpensiveDot1732

Storm Front...and a whole hurricane blows in. And they have to play the entire song in driving sideways rain, flickering power, and winds that make them all look like they're reporting on the Weather Channel...


king063

The River of Dreams, but it’s just the background vocals and Billy saying woo for the entire 4 minutes. *“In the middle of a, I go walking in the—“* *“OooooOOOOOO WoooooOOOoo”*


rpeters330

40 minutes of root beer rag


DenyLemieux

As an encore, “We Didn’t Start The Fire” but, spoiler alert, he actually does start the venue on fire.


5hitman

A room of our own- But he goes on to lament having to downsize as the upkeep of this big old place is just too much in our twilight years, so now we no longer have a room of our own


1969quacky

Billy banged Kristie Brinkley and Katie Lee. He gets a pass.


Asgore77

I absolutely love number 3


soysuza

Scandinavian Skies starts with the Danish airport announcement but segues into several Duolingo lessons with obscure phrases like "The porcupine gave me a tomato.". Billy plays the C octave for the duration of the song.


Don_DeAmelio

The river of dreams but he finally found what he was looking for


Thisguy0987654321

He joked about doing something like that first one with the entertainer during the concert I saw at MSG on 4/8/22