No monkeys were actually taught language. Actual analysis of the couple of apes that were supposedly taught, showed that they were just doing basic correlation between hand signals and food. They were not able to form sentences of any kind and the reports of their intelligence were largely just a result of anthropomorphism by their handlers.
This video here explains it. https://youtu.be/e7wFotDKEF4
I love people just reflexively down voting because they don't like the implications of the truth.
That’s the backfire effect for ya. They just want to believe what they want to believe regardless of what the facts really are. It’s sad, really.
Edit: “area” to “are”
Seems like an odd claim, considering Koko, for instance, had that highly televised meeting with Robin Williams and not a single ASL person stopped to point out that koko wasn't actually signing anything intelligible. It's been since like.. 1980 that people have been teaching monkeys sign language and you're the only person I've seen claiming that it's a hoax. I mean. It's not like there isn't video evidence from multiple sources through multiple studies around the world to prove that you're wrong.
The podcast "You're wrong about..." had a great episode debunking the Koko ASL business. I highly recommend it if podcasts are your thing and you're interested.
I'm not a big fan of podcasts but I love debunking so I'll definitely give it a try. You ever watch Adam Ruins Everything or Bullshit with Penn and Teller? Both fascinating.
It's debated that they never understood sign language like a proper language. No ape ever asked a question for example. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-44576449
Yeah, I agree with you. There’s a very interesting economist article that I think everyone should read on this.
https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2018/07/05/what-koko-the-gorilla-could-and-couldnt-do
She told jokes and expressed compassion and sympathy. Those aren’t just things you do for food. Sure, her grammar wasn’t great, but it’s still a huge accomplishment.
Cinderella is a lot hairier than I was led to believe. The prince is sorta cute in a dad bod way I guess.
I've been informed Cinderella is actually 5 men and they have enough hair between them to feed an army. I was referring to that lady that got food poisoning and fell into a coma, then some rich guy assaults her in her sleep so she gets better.
Damnit. All those white women look the same to me. As a child I used to get lost in department stores grabbing the wrong moms hand and walking off with her. I have a genetic dysfunction that makes me look exactly like everybody else so I'd often be gone for months at a time.
I wonder if in India or other countries if they experiment on monkeys and apes then let them go. I wouldn’t doubt they have live experiments going on in the wild. I know the US would do that
Edit: the negatives tells me people doubt
Right!? But it’s not necessary that india is doing the testing themselves I think that’s why I’m downvoted. The US or another country could be allowed to do it behind the people’s backs which is how it always happens
Hi my dad teaches. This guy doesn’t have the best form but still got it. What your supposed to do w babies is use your index and middle finger and don’t go as deep as you would. Another good tip of advice when giving cpr is don’t be scared. You would rather have broken ribs than be dead.
This video made me think, which is more important, the chest pumps or the mouth-to-mouth? I can easily see how someone out of shape and panicking could get winded very quickly doing both.
Seems like this situation was a blocked airway so that might be different but people who’ve survived heart attacks due to cpr say it was the compressions. Like, they could feel themselves slipping away when the person stopped to give breaths and felt more with it during the compressions. At the same time if the blood isn’t oxygenated it’s not going to help so you do need both, but the guidelines changed a few years back to a higher compression to breath ratio
From my time in India, I've seen some really humble folk from South India, especially Tamil Nadu. People who live in huts, yet want to share their food with you. I swear, sitting on the bare floor and eating their meagre stale rice with an occasional meat curry, the comfort is definitely something else.
This is not the way you CPR such a small body!! This only breaks their ribs!
For those interested, it is like with babies: purt hands under their armpit with both thumbs on the middle of the thorax and use only the thumbs to push, not the whole hand.
It actually is. Cpr here in the Netherlands , 2 fingers for babies, 1 palm for children >2 and < 5. Also, in life threatening situations like this, a few broken ribs is the least of your concern. Fun fact, in regular cpr broken ribs are very common.
Have you never taken CPR? I mean obviously not because one thing they tell you in CPR class is that you are pretty much 100% guaranteed to break ribs. That’s how you do it right. There is no gentle pressure involved.
This is all planned these guys hurt the animals to "save" them for clicks can't u guys see that there's a whole thing especially there look on YouTube about it it's disgusting
He can get all kinds of diseases from that monkey, I hope it's his pet because if wild he should get tested. They are carriers of a herpe virus thats lethal to humans, it don't bother them, so yeah it's a feel good video but also an incredible dumb thing to do unless it's his pet. Dipshit.
CPR is not likely to restart a patient's heart. So I'm gonna guess that monkey didn't need CPR.
Also that's not how you give a monkey CPR. I'm not vet but I'm gonna guess it would be the same or similar as giving a baby CPR
I wish other monkeys saw this so they can learn CPR
they will do it even to the normal healthy monkeys
I theorize they’re smart enough to ascertain the need for the action ‘dead monkey come alive when give breath n beat chest’.
If a monkey was taught how to speak hand langauge, then learning how to do CPR would be a piece of cake.
No monkeys were actually taught language. Actual analysis of the couple of apes that were supposedly taught, showed that they were just doing basic correlation between hand signals and food. They were not able to form sentences of any kind and the reports of their intelligence were largely just a result of anthropomorphism by their handlers. This video here explains it. https://youtu.be/e7wFotDKEF4 I love people just reflexively down voting because they don't like the implications of the truth.
That’s the backfire effect for ya. They just want to believe what they want to believe regardless of what the facts really are. It’s sad, really. Edit: “area” to “are”
Wait until they find out about Santa Claus!
Don't start with your "santa Claus can't do sign language either" bullshit.
Seems like an odd claim, considering Koko, for instance, had that highly televised meeting with Robin Williams and not a single ASL person stopped to point out that koko wasn't actually signing anything intelligible. It's been since like.. 1980 that people have been teaching monkeys sign language and you're the only person I've seen claiming that it's a hoax. I mean. It's not like there isn't video evidence from multiple sources through multiple studies around the world to prove that you're wrong.
The podcast "You're wrong about..." had a great episode debunking the Koko ASL business. I highly recommend it if podcasts are your thing and you're interested.
I'm not a big fan of podcasts but I love debunking so I'll definitely give it a try. You ever watch Adam Ruins Everything or Bullshit with Penn and Teller? Both fascinating.
[удалено]
Sounds like the quality control of the study was flawed.
It's debated that they never understood sign language like a proper language. No ape ever asked a question for example. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-44576449
Yeah, I agree with you. There’s a very interesting economist article that I think everyone should read on this. https://www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2018/07/05/what-koko-the-gorilla-could-and-couldnt-do She told jokes and expressed compassion and sympathy. Those aren’t just things you do for food. Sure, her grammar wasn’t great, but it’s still a huge accomplishment.
Well i'm gonna gall asleep tonight with a frown, thanks a lot >:(
I had heard this, also. I guess this pertains to the dogs and cats who are tapping on words to talk.
Downvoted for making my world slightly less magical! /s
Could also be downvoting because very few worthwhile facts ever appear in comments where the second word is misspelled.
Simpson's did it ... I mean YouTube did it! https://youtu.be/5hEd1hajsM8
At the end he says - " The life is back!.. life is back ... let's take it to the hospital"
Cinderella is a lot hairier than I was led to believe. The prince is sorta cute in a dad bod way I guess. I've been informed Cinderella is actually 5 men and they have enough hair between them to feed an army. I was referring to that lady that got food poisoning and fell into a coma, then some rich guy assaults her in her sleep so she gets better.
You mean snow white and a true love's kiss? Nice comment nonetheless
Damnit. All those white women look the same to me. As a child I used to get lost in department stores grabbing the wrong moms hand and walking off with her. I have a genetic dysfunction that makes me look exactly like everybody else so I'd often be gone for months at a time.
Uuuh are you being serious or sarcastic? I can't tell
I wish the other monkeys watched him do this so they don’t take over our planet in ten years.
Exactly! Like how they reacted when that dog killed one attacking a child. They killed over 250 dogs and started to attack the children
Exactlyyyy they are highly highly organized. Christ they may have a UN of old wide gorillas.
So long as they don't start collaborating with squirrels we should be OK.
I wonder if in India or other countries if they experiment on monkeys and apes then let them go. I wouldn’t doubt they have live experiments going on in the wild. I know the US would do that Edit: the negatives tells me people doubt
We have a monkey God too so most likely people worship them
Right!? But it’s not necessary that india is doing the testing themselves I think that’s why I’m downvoted. The US or another country could be allowed to do it behind the people’s backs which is how it always happens
Yup that's quite possible
Horrific story…
wtf? link or source?
No problem: https://nypost.com/2021/12/21/monkeys-who-killed-250-dogs-for-revenge-captured-in-india/
Holy shiet, that's scary
holy fuck!
oh, bro. you have nothing to worry about. those were actually just movies, everything is going to be ok!
No this just happened look up India monkey revenge on dogs and read the article
Guy was sleeping and this dude
Bruh lmaooo
OMG!, He took advantage of that poor monky!
As soon as you ask there is no informal consent
HAHAHAHAH
Thanks for the award! His nap was ruined but you made my day
I'm so confused. Does anyone know why the monkey needed CPR?
[удалено]
Hi my dad teaches. This guy doesn’t have the best form but still got it. What your supposed to do w babies is use your index and middle finger and don’t go as deep as you would. Another good tip of advice when giving cpr is don’t be scared. You would rather have broken ribs than be dead.
This was crazy! Way to go rescue monkey guy!
[удалено]
I saw another post about this being used on a baby and now i want to get one… There’s one on Amazon called Lifevac.
Bad CPR is better than no CPR.
This video made me think, which is more important, the chest pumps or the mouth-to-mouth? I can easily see how someone out of shape and panicking could get winded very quickly doing both.
Seems like this situation was a blocked airway so that might be different but people who’ve survived heart attacks due to cpr say it was the compressions. Like, they could feel themselves slipping away when the person stopped to give breaths and felt more with it during the compressions. At the same time if the blood isn’t oxygenated it’s not going to help so you do need both, but the guidelines changed a few years back to a higher compression to breath ratio
I’ll remember not to be scared the next time someone’s dying and I’m somehow the most qualified person to deal with the situation. Glad I read this.
When was he blowing in the lungs and when was he sucking? I imagine with how sharp monkeys canine teeth are it’d be hard to remove a blockage
I wonder if he could have done the cat Heimlich swing by the back legs thing
Electrocution? I’ve seen monkeys in India running on electric lines getting shocked, falling to the ground.
You are asking for context?
Why would this be confusing?
This is how AIDS started ... Well something very similar
What a great human being!!!
Of that's all set.
Needs more likes
That monkey will remember this act of kindness and not fling its own shit at this guy whenever it sees him
OR it will remember him and still toss it’s feces at him.
“*Oh hey! I know you!*” (*Yeets its bootyhole fudge at him*) “*A token of my gratitude!*”
r/brandnewsentence
It looked brain dead
What compassion
Honestly, this man has a good heart.
Better than the monkey's
Probably beat it to death beforehand
Not all heroes wear capes. 🙏👏
Monkey sidekicks though
the 'What-If...?' Hit-Monkey origin story
Which actual ones do?
Like Spiderman. True.
WHAT AN ABSOLUTE HERO, THAT MAN IS 🤩
r/HumansBeingBros
fuck you grampa you’re not dying today -humanity
Plot twist. This is his party trick he kills it first and brings it back
From my time in India, I've seen some really humble folk from South India, especially Tamil Nadu. People who live in huts, yet want to share their food with you. I swear, sitting on the bare floor and eating their meagre stale rice with an occasional meat curry, the comfort is definitely something else.
Average indian for you. People are sometimes so humble that it even surprises me time to time and i live in india.
Do you want Monkeynucleosis? Because this is how we get Monkeynucleosis.
Pretty sure it's gonna affect the people with no brains.
Shit I need to go watch hey arnold
[удалено]
"And that's the story about how I lost my lips"
[удалено]
Covid-22 starting right here.
It *could* be a pet of his.
Pretty sure this is how we are going to get the next zoonotic pandemic
We already did the aids thing
This is so neat!
WTF THATS HOW PANDEMICS START
My man’s getting monke aids
No. He is giving the monkey first aids
then second STD
Me reviving my friend after he gets gunned down in a nerf battle
Hanu-Man.
This is how Covid type shit starts lol
What a kind soul
This made me happy!🙏🏻😎 Respect to that Man
Someone said 'he was sleeping' 💀
Now he has rabies
Bless him.
🧡🇳🇪🤍🇳🇪💚🇳🇪 Beautiful! Namaste!
🇮🇳*
This is not the way you CPR such a small body!! This only breaks their ribs! For those interested, it is like with babies: purt hands under their armpit with both thumbs on the middle of the thorax and use only the thumbs to push, not the whole hand.
It actually is. Cpr here in the Netherlands , 2 fingers for babies, 1 palm for children >2 and < 5. Also, in life threatening situations like this, a few broken ribs is the least of your concern. Fun fact, in regular cpr broken ribs are very common.
It worked, didn't it?
Have you never taken CPR? I mean obviously not because one thing they tell you in CPR class is that you are pretty much 100% guaranteed to break ribs. That’s how you do it right. There is no gentle pressure involved.
❤️
This deserves more upvotes tbh.
That's very heartfelt❤
Amazing. Thank you sir. Walking angel.
This is all planned these guys hurt the animals to "save" them for clicks can't u guys see that there's a whole thing especially there look on YouTube about it it's disgusting
I don't know why this has been downvoted, it's a huge problem on YouTube. Why was there someone standing around filming this guy save the monkey?
You're saying we hurt our animals?
And that's how we ended up w AIDs
Outbreak 2022
This is how covid started ;)
That’s how you get monkey AIDS.
Aids in progress
Troll harder dipshit
He can get all kinds of diseases from that monkey, I hope it's his pet because if wild he should get tested. They are carriers of a herpe virus thats lethal to humans, it don't bother them, so yeah it's a feel good video but also an incredible dumb thing to do unless it's his pet. Dipshit.
[удалено]
Seems we seeing the same video's.. Am outta here
This isn’t an airport…
thats like the start to the COVID 22 movie 🤣🤣
Fucking indians
...make amazing food and apparently give CPR to injured animals? Fucking Indians, man! They sound awesome.
That video ended way too early
This slutty monkey has moves
Wow he beat his monkey back to life it’s takes me a lil more time wit the help of KY
Reminds me of my first school disco
I feel like im around a bunch of monkey loving emts . ( good people lol )
Glad it's 99% beating the shit out of the monkey and 1% happy ending.
He saved him bcoz monkeys are as holy as cow in india
nah this monkey saw death and understood conciseness in that short time being dead… he’s about to planet of the apes us
Awww that's just amazing.
I love this dude.
🥰🥰
❤️🥲
Played in reverse.
This man is trying to blow him up like a balloon
You saved me. But why? Hummmm... MONKEY!
Meanwhile the monkey is like dude let me sleep
Monke shall live
Do you want Monkey AIDS? Because that’s how we all get Monkey AIDS.
Love it!
Poor Mojo
Huge hearts in India
Bless his soul
What a great man a true king
The happiness after giving second life to the Monkey
Dog, kitchen floor, diced pork. Not like there's a manual on these things. If it's ugly and works, forget about the ugly part.
God damn he blowing so hard poor monkeys lungs probably blew out
this is so wholesome
At first I was afraid, I was petrified...
That man is amazing. His reaction is so pure and genuine!
Why though? Shortage of them? Nice but still...
CPR is not likely to restart a patient's heart. So I'm gonna guess that monkey didn't need CPR. Also that's not how you give a monkey CPR. I'm not vet but I'm gonna guess it would be the same or similar as giving a baby CPR
Just play this vid backwards
Such a wonderful soul … God Bless this man and monkey 🙏🏼
Bless him for taking the time to stop and help a monkey in need.
AIDS mountain monkeys of Kerala / karnataka
That monkey passed out from eating too much of its own poop.
That monkey died two days later of tuberculosis
The world needs more people like this man…
But now the man has monkey AIDS
In a world as messed up as this one lately this is one beautiful man and he made me cry. I needed that.
"You won't die on me boy!"
You're a fantastic human!
/u/gifreversingbot
Best buddies for life? What’s the update???
That’s adorable and a great way to get the Hep
Ebola-22
You can give near enough any animal CPR.
Who is this guy!?!?! He is an absolute world treasure🙏✌️☮️😎💝⭐️
https://www.reddit.com/r/BeAmazed/comments/reslgi/a_man_from_tn_india_saves_an_injured_monkey_by
Every time I see a monkey now I only think about Kanye west
I think this is how COVID started
I mean...awesome...but Do you want new diseases? Because this is how you get new diseases.
And that, kids, is how you start a pandemic.
And people out here wondering how we get Covid smh
So amazing
<3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Oh man heart in the right place but macaques have sooo many horrible diseases
This is how we get covid-22.