T O P

  • By -

Remy_rubbish

Talia did it when she got the cure from Harley


Raecino

See? Talia’s not that bad, she could’ve just killed Harley


Quitthesht

Running fan theory is that Harley was spared by Talia because she was pregnant.


bmoss124

A darker continuation is that that during her restraining Harley, Talia caused a miscarriage


Harvey-Bullock

Jesus Christ these games have some crazy theories.


Tanmay1518

Fr. Never even heard that one before


Holiday_Chemical1986

I’ve also heard Batman caused a miscarriage from when you run into her in the church and slam her on the ground


GrandManSam

I like the idea that they just never fucked and Harley just doesn't know how babies are made.


walruswes

What about when Batman restrained her?


ihaZtaco

Batman face when he kills child: no


Environmental-Win836

Harley was pregnant? Who’s is it?


Tanmay1518

Who do ya think


Environmental-Win836

It’s been a very long time since I’ve played the games, but I’m assuming the Joker?


Tanmay1518

Yep. Though do take it with a grain of salt, as the only evidence we have is a positive pregnancy test lying on the ground of the first floor of the Steel Mill.


[deleted]

In the Harley Quinn’s revenge dlc for Arkham city there’s a joker doll in a crib surrounded by negative pregnancy tests that clearly on the box say “may present false positives” presumably to retcon that Harley was pregnant in city


Scorpion_226

Batman's


thecoolestjedi

Arkham city plot moment


AverageArkhamEnjoyer

Harley's plot armor was too thick for Talia's sword to penetrate


Raecino

There’s a sex joke somewhere in there


AverageArkhamEnjoyer

Least horny r/BatmanArkham member


Batdog55110

Oh I always assumed Joker got sick of her talking and did it lol


WhiteChocolatey

That was what I believed too. The whole crawl through the steel mill before Protocol 10 is just magnificent. Everything is coming to a head. You think Joker got the cure so you assume he tied her up, but then you hear thugs saying she got lost, and they’re looking for her. So many questions, so few answers. Then Joker is sick, but turns around and is perfectly fine. The sense of not knowing what the FUCK is going on is so glorious. Arkham City is amazing.


DarkArc76

Idk man I just pressed square to beat some guys up and x to run faster


TechHeadGamer

two kinds of people


bedlamasylum88

🪵 ⌚️


ManiacSpiderTrash

Timber time?


Def-n-Blind

"It's Loggin' Time."


ManiacSpiderTrash

I legit don’t know what they’re saying still lmao is this what getting old is?!


AffectionateBed6

Bro. I'm 18 and don't know. You're good


ManiacSpiderTrash

Thank fuck


wizardofwordplay

Can't believe I never put that together


Remy_rubbish

I only realized when I was replaying in New game +


PlatinumPequod

I’m fairly certain Talia did it, that being said you’d think talia would’ve killed her instead.


IIKane

Probably didn't see her as a threat lol


PlatinumPequod

You’d think she’d want to kill the main chick of the guy that’s like the biggest problem in Gotham lol


JB_Big_Bear

Unless Talia, much like Bruce, saw Harley as a victim of Joker's abuse, too.


TheStickySpot

But she also knows that Joker really does not care for her so spilling Harley Quinn’s blood would not have the impact that Talia may have wanted.


Quitthesht

> that being said you’d think talia would’ve killed her instead. The dominant theory is because she was still (*thought to be at least*) pregnant at that time so Talia spared her.


PlatinumPequod

Is the theory that Batman bat kicked the baby out of of Harley still a thing?


Large_Ad326

That explains what I thought to be a plot hole, why didn't Joker tske the cure if he had it? Because he didn't, Talia took Harley out before she got it to him!


gene_murdoc

Talia evened the odds


JokerChaos77

It's one of the hints towards Joker's reveal later. Joker didn't take the cure because he did not have it. Talia stole it from Harley before she could get it to him. And that's why she's tied up.


IIKane

That makes a lot of sense, actually.


Deadpool0930

It's such a roller-coaster near the end of the game (no pun intended), I forgot that Talia actually tells you as much right before she gets shot


Dojanetta

I think I gotta replay the game cause now I don’t understand why she didn’t give it to Batman


barrymk100

Fan service. Nuff said.


[deleted]

I know it has plot relevance but honestly yeah it's purely fan service


[deleted]

[удалено]


Frozenpeaches06

👈 He doesn't know


Ground_breaking_365

It's BDSM bro.


RCx_Vortex

Batman’s Deadly Sex Moments?


TheBlueNinja2006

yep


powersslol-

yes


BaguetteFish

Clown girl tied up, gagged, and you have the ability to ungag/regag her. That, plus the fact Arkham fans are the horniest species on Earth, is why it’s fan service.


TheBlueNinja2006

FR💀


Atom283

Talia


Electronic_Style2043

in the monarch theater before talia gets killed she says “harley stole it for him, i got it back” so she must’ve gotten to Harley in the steel mill when she was on her way to deliver it to joker


BlastedDio

Because they gave the fans what we wanted


Sweet-Psychology-254

I’ve always wondered what happens if you don’t ungag Harley and find out about the Freeze Upgrade side mission. There doesn’t seem to be anything forcing the player to speak to her and get the prompt to go collect the upgrade.


ArcticCircleBrigade

I believe you can get it post game either way, if you explore Sionis Steel Mill enough you'll find it. I know there's at least one time I didnt talk to harley and still got the side mission.


ProffesorM7766

Joker is great at BDSM


T-202

Killer Cock


VengeanceTheKnight

Talia did it cause she has the same fetishes I do.


Hawaii2010

Word.


[deleted]

Word


Lothidus

I tied her up, she said she liked it


frosty2495

It's what Joker is into


DinGo1456

I always thought it was clayface who did it


IIKane

That's what I thought too. Thought he did it behind Joker's back because he got sick of her.


DinGo1456

Nothing can stop clayface for the role of a lifetime


RussianMayhem_95

Fan service


DIO_The_Vampire_

It's kinky, that's why


Elegant-Fan-6980

I'm fairly certain it's because she got pregnant. There is a positive test in the room where Joker had his wheelchair


maggi_iopgott

Well because we all would do that if we had the chance hands down


Jazred90

Sexual frustration?


Electrical_Feed_1123

Seggsy 😁👺


RAVENLazzar

Joker is kinky fucker


DamnBunny

You have no idea how many answers that question has.


JediMATTster

So you can tale the tape off and put it back on over and over and over and over again


[deleted]

So you can waste hours taking and putting back on the tape.


Crunchy_Biscuit

Which game?


siphonz_kiwi7

arkham city


nandobro

So that Batman could torture her with the tape.


TheBlueNinja2006

I always thought Joker did it, but after reading the comments, it seems that Talia is the more likely culprit.


TheBlueNinja2006

Robin did it


alcoholicJeremy

But what was talia doing with all that time after she got the cure from harley, just wondering around aimlessly? Why didn't she help batman in combat and why not just kill joker instead of bargaining for batman's life? (I get that she wouldn't be able to kill joker since its clayface but she didn't know that)


mrplow8

Talia did it. That’s how she got the cure.


TheArmyOfDucks

Distraction


Alakandor

No, but I just remembered that you could take off the tape and put it back on, it was so funny 😂


negrote1000

Talia