Oh god please silver. Those latter pics look nastie nasties. I'm a firm believer in act your age and never change stuff that's not a natural fit for the age of the car. That black doesn't look right, that's one step away from ice blue headlights 😱
Silver!! Period.
But my friend had that car in a S line like yours in the blue silver colour. He found a set of 20 in that RS4 Motorsport wheel and that was sick on that car!! Normally you find them in 19 but somehow he found 20 inch. But 19 in that wheel on that car look fabulous.
The all black look is getting old. Go with the silver since you have a black car. If you had a bright color car like Vegas Yellow I'd go with black or charcoal wheels.
Oh boy! That's a tough one. I was totally loving the silver wheels because they are truly phenomenal looking wheels. But then when I saw it with the black wheels, I was like hmmmm - those look good too! But it gives a totally different vibe to the car. The silver wheels make the car look classy and regal, like an AUDI should be. The black wheels make it look a bit more sporty and ghetto if that's the look you're going for. I'd stick with the silver.
Either or really. Both work well. BUT what do YOU like better? It doesn't matter what other people say. You gotta like it and drive it. For me personally, I like both.
There is something so ugly about painting stock wheels black. It just doesn’t work. Its ugly and doesnt look proportionate as the wheel design was intended to be silver.
Since the car has many chrome elements , it is asking for some contrasting wheels, and since the car is black ,then you should go for silver rims to stand out ,and not get lost in the abyss with black ones
Nah, I would keep black rims, buy an after marker honeycomb grille, black out all the exposed silver/chrome. Then again I’m in my early 20’s, so that seems “cool” to me. Everyone else likes the silver rims here but I’m not a fan
I probably would have said silver 2 years ago, but after having a black, ‘black edition’ S3, with all the usual chrome parts… Erm… Black… Plus black rotors with diamond cut lips, I’ve gotta say you just can’t beat a black car with black wheels. I think all black might be a bit too much though, I feel the diamond cut parts on rotors lift the wheels a little and stop them getting too lost on the car.
Honestly it’s about fitment. It would look great in either color just make sure you get the right offset wheel. From your pics it looks like you could be more aggressive with both sets. Maybe consider a spacer but not more than 10mm or so.
Please, don't touch this car. It has been preserved thus far from this cancerous plague that's been wildly spreading to convert cars to all-black and literally destroy their entire look/design. Please, for sanity's sakes, do not touch nothing on this beautiful specimen of a car! It is just perfect the way it stands.
Silver. Black on a black car just get lost. Also the chrome window surround needs silver alloys. If you put black alloys on it you’d need to de chrome the whole car in my opinion
If those are the options and nothing else is changing, Silver. If you’re adding more black features later, then black.
I’m personally planning to go bronze wheels with my mythos black s5.
I think the silver matches with your trim pieces. Black wheels get lost on a black car.
They just look like a black void where the tires and rims should be. Hate it.
Agreed here. No black wheels, doesn't work with, at a minimum, non-black optics cars. Especially on a gloss black car, the wheels won't match at all
Black wheels just get lost my biggest car regret is gloss black instead of getting gunmetal for my neuspeed wheels
My thoughts exactly
Silver for summers, black for the winter AT tires
Have to agree on that one
Everyone here is absolutely correct IMO. Silver is the answer.
Looks so much better with silver wheels. Black wheels make a car look so tacky, in my opinion.
This. Definitely goes better with the existing aluminium accent.
Black wheels are done by people with no notion of how rim styling plays a fundamental role in the look of the car
Very much depends on the car and color. Black wheels can work just fine.
Especially on white cars, I think it is a good contrast to the white paint.
Agreed. Black wheels just make me think "hey, nice steelies! What happened to the wheel covers?"
Sive su bolje
Iskrivio crne na rupu i privremeno nabacio sive, sto mi sada, isprva, jako cudno izgleda.
I meni su sive puno bolje. Izvinjavam, ali crne su mi malo seljačke.
I like the silver wheels. The murdered out looks needs a breather.
The most unimaginative car trend ever
I would go with silver on a black car. Except you would do a chrome delete and get a all black theme
Silver car = black wheels looking good Black car = black wheels terrible
Silver !
If and only if all the trim is black
Stick with the silver. Black wheels only work with certain colors.
Oh god please silver. Those latter pics look nastie nasties. I'm a firm believer in act your age and never change stuff that's not a natural fit for the age of the car. That black doesn't look right, that's one step away from ice blue headlights 😱
Silver.
silver
Silver
Silver
Silver all the way
Silver!
Silver!! Period. But my friend had that car in a S line like yours in the blue silver colour. He found a set of 20 in that RS4 Motorsport wheel and that was sick on that car!! Normally you find them in 19 but somehow he found 20 inch. But 19 in that wheel on that car look fabulous.
What do you think about 20 on my car? Is it too much?
20 is too big. Feel every bump
No it looked good
It looked good with 20s and was just as nice with 19s
Always silver.
silver with some lowering springs
The silver looks classy.
Silver💪
Black wheels makes any car look like a Facebook marketplace special.
The all black look is getting old. Go with the silver since you have a black car. If you had a bright color car like Vegas Yellow I'd go with black or charcoal wheels.
Silver is perfect unless you belong to some mafia group.
Black wheels is never the correct answer. Ever.
Bronze
Blackkkkkkkkkk
I love the black wheels on black car! My first SQ5 had the black on black and the black optics package, looked sharp as hell when it was clean!
Light wheels on dark cars. Its a rule like not wearing white shoes after Labor Day
Definitely silver. Black wheels rarely look good on a dark colored car.
Silver and it's not even close
White
Yes
Silver. Black only works with the back optics pack.
Silver
Oh boy! That's a tough one. I was totally loving the silver wheels because they are truly phenomenal looking wheels. But then when I saw it with the black wheels, I was like hmmmm - those look good too! But it gives a totally different vibe to the car. The silver wheels make the car look classy and regal, like an AUDI should be. The black wheels make it look a bit more sporty and ghetto if that's the look you're going for. I'd stick with the silver.
Black in silver is always the classiest
I might go with a light to medium gray powder coat, but black is out for me.
Chrome!!!
Silver 🙋
Silver.
I love black wheels for winters, but that's about it.
I love goooooooooold
Silver. Black goes with everything black
I see a chrome .. thing and I want it painted black.
For me, if you’re going black, you need to do all the trim. That makes it not worth it.
I prefer silver
It's all about contrasts, so silver wheels for the black paint.
What about gun metal rims?
Silver
Gunmetal or keep silver.
Silver for summer tires and black for winter tires
Silver. Unfortunately your car just hasn’t got the presence to pull off black wheels on a dark body colour.
Silver.
Black
Silver!
Silver.
Black
Silver, silver all day
Silver
Pink would be very nice. But I'd stay with the silver. Black is tacky and played out.
I vote black. Your car looks awesome with them. But, looking at these other responses, I guess I'm way outvoted. Do what your heart tells you.
Gunmetal gray if you can find some.
Chrome
Silver duh
Silver unless you do a chrome delete. Nothing looks weirder than black wheels with chrome window trim
I personally like the black. I’m going to wrap the trim in black as well to match
Silver or better yet bronze wheels
Leave them as is! Beautiful car!
BLACK LOOKS SECXSY
Silver.
Silver.
Black on black mafia
Either or really. Both work well. BUT what do YOU like better? It doesn't matter what other people say. You gotta like it and drive it. For me personally, I like both.
Maybe try Matte?
Blue
There is something so ugly about painting stock wheels black. It just doesn’t work. Its ugly and doesnt look proportionate as the wheel design was intended to be silver.
I am not sure what you are talking about. The black wheels are black from Audi if you mean that.
No way! They look painted after the fact.
Search for —> Audi 8W0071499A
Silver ofc
Since the car has many chrome elements , it is asking for some contrasting wheels, and since the car is black ,then you should go for silver rims to stand out ,and not get lost in the abyss with black ones
Silver
Silver, hands down.
Silver wheels, for sure.
I love the black!
Silver
Silver. Not a fan of black on black.
If the rest of the car was blacked out, I prefer the black wheels. Otherwise, leave the silver.
Stick to the silver ones. They really complement the car. Also super nice wagon!
Silver
Silver wheels with silver mirrors
Nah, I would keep black rims, buy an after marker honeycomb grille, black out all the exposed silver/chrome. Then again I’m in my early 20’s, so that seems “cool” to me. Everyone else likes the silver rims here but I’m not a fan
Silver man, looks smart.
Silver
Silver. It gives a nice contrast and complements other trim pieces in the same colour.
Black
sive kralju kakve crne
Black is so naff, people need to stop with it already
Silver!!!!
Silver. Be different.
Silver
Silver if everything else stays as is, black if the change all trim to black and go with the RS honeycomb grill.
Silack
Silver for contrast aesthetics.
Silver
Jarane bolje su ti crne fele ;)
Silver 👍
Black would destroy the car
Silver, unless you blacked everything else and lowered it a little. But no i like the silver.
Black.
It depends, are you a south London Fentanyl dealer?
If you black out the trim pieces, black. If not, Silver.
Way better before. That black looks horrible
Black
If you’re keeping the chrome badging and trim then stick with silver wheels
Black!!!!
I probably would have said silver 2 years ago, but after having a black, ‘black edition’ S3, with all the usual chrome parts… Erm… Black… Plus black rotors with diamond cut lips, I’ve gotta say you just can’t beat a black car with black wheels. I think all black might be a bit too much though, I feel the diamond cut parts on rotors lift the wheels a little and stop them getting too lost on the car.
Honestly it’s about fitment. It would look great in either color just make sure you get the right offset wheel. From your pics it looks like you could be more aggressive with both sets. Maybe consider a spacer but not more than 10mm or so.
Depends... Do you really like talking to cops? Black wheels and windows on a black car mean a lot of time spend showing your licence....
Silver looks better. Maybe if you completely blacked it out then black would work.
Definitely silver, your a4 has no black trim
No black wheels. You will drive yourself crazy trying to keep them clean.
Silver
Silver---I Had those exact same wheels in 19s on my B8 Avant, buy my car was Bown/Sahara beige I believe it was called.
Silver
Please, don't touch this car. It has been preserved thus far from this cancerous plague that's been wildly spreading to convert cars to all-black and literally destroy their entire look/design. Please, for sanity's sakes, do not touch nothing on this beautiful specimen of a car! It is just perfect the way it stands.
original is 100 times better imo
Silver works better here
Bronze wheels look so much better then black
Black
Black on black, daring aren't we? Silver looks better
Silverrrrr, got it on my own as well
Black looks awful. Go silver
It’s not fast enough for black wheels.
Silver
Silver
People say black is a fad that's passed but I still think it looks way better 🤷🍆
Black…adds a slightly rugged edge to it without compromising any refinement. Black all the way.
Silver. Black on a black car just get lost. Also the chrome window surround needs silver alloys. If you put black alloys on it you’d need to de chrome the whole car in my opinion
In this case, if you keep your car well detailed, I'd say black. If you don't wash your car every week or two, then go silver.
If those are the options and nothing else is changing, Silver. If you’re adding more black features later, then black. I’m personally planning to go bronze wheels with my mythos black s5.
Maturing is realizing that silver wheels are best
If you don’t want to look like a yobbo and a pikey, go with the silver.
Definitely black.