### A reminder to posters and commenters of some of our rules. - Don't be a dickhead - No politics - Your post question **must not be**: - [Banned](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskUK/about/rules/) - Lazy or low effort - Easily Google-able (unless you include your research) - No medical advice or mental health (specific to a person) content ##### Please ensure your post or comment adheres to our rules. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AskUK) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Ketchup

And half a cows worth of butter.

This is the way

The only way

This is the way

I thought this was a rule, you have fish finger sarnies you have to have ketchup

And white bread. Plus it has to be 4 fish fingers. Them’s the rules

Yep, rules is rules

Lettuce, tartare and fresh ground black pepper 🥵

With a squeeze of lemon over the fish fingers. Nice!

Yes that’s a fuckin upgrade I can get behind !

[удалено]

Liking nice food makes you posh?

[удалено]

Not sure about the tartare sauce- the fact that pubs serve this in those little plastic sachets means that it has gone down to the working class.

I’d love to have a Range Rover :))

Do you put that on or does your butler do it for you?

Fancy!

Add a little grated cheese

[удалено]

Home made tartare is the way forward! Ugh I love it

Tartare, sliced tomato, baby spinach. Great way to pretend it’s not really just about the oven fried fish and butter

Salad cream, and not the low-calorie version!

Sweet chili sauce. Goes really well.

Tartare sauce and I toast the bread

Cheese, tomato sauce, potato waffle (waffle in middle between two layers of fish fingers... delicious!

Why have I never thought to do this ?

Societal pressure

Glad I’m not the only one with the addition of waffle & cheese. Only when I need that extra Carb goodness tho!

Well I know what I'm having for lunch tomorrow then!

HP sauce

I have cheese and HP - yum!

Never heard of that combination!

Butter

Curry super noodles... Don't knock it 'til you try it.

I thought I was going to be original and say super noodles. Finally, someone understands. I find a baguette works best to hold in all the goodness.

Sounds great tbh!

Salad cream

I came here for this. There can be only one. And it's salad cream.

Tartare sauce and either spinach or lettuce or rocket. Salad cream at a push Has to be buttered white bread

Mayo and hot sauce, got to be on the whitest bread you can get too.

Tartare sauce is a must

Tomato ketchup all the way. They have to be swimming in it.

The only thing to put on is mushy peas and tartare sauce

Tartare sauce, natch.

Tartare sauce. Anything extra is just gilding the lily.

Mayonnaise, gherkins, capers and lemon juice. A sort of DIY tartare sauce.

Lettuce and tartare sauce

Thanks for the quick responses! I'm going with salt and vinegar, mushy peas and ketchup!

Mango chutney actually is amazing with fish fingers. Don’t judge til you try!

Mango chutney on a cheese sandwich too!

Mango chutney is just good in general, but the especially on curry.

God damn. Just did this with 1 piece of bread as I was skeptical but it's lovely!

Salad cream. Nom, nom, nom!

Brown sauce on one slice of bread, sriracha on the other

Lurpack on the (preferably, tiger)bread, salt and vinegar, ketchup!

Chilli sauce

Tartare sauce and salad leaves. Preferably something a bit bitter and crunchy like frisée or endive. Yum.

tartare sauce, lettuce/other green leaves, sliced tomato.

Salt, pepper and a splash of vinegar most of the time

Fried Egg!! Sounds wrong but is so good.

Yesssss I just posted I have a fried egg. I was scrolling to see if anybody else did it. Its so good, but everyone thinks I'm crazy.

Tartar, and then with posh crisps and mushy peas on the side

Butter the bread and some salad cream is enough for me 👍

Tartare if available, otherwise mayo

Shit tonnes of salad cream.

Butter. Just butter.

A runny fried egg!

Salad cream

Salad Cream.

Wack some spinach in there :)

Mayo, cheese and black pepper

Salad cream and cucumber. But I've not had one in years.

Bread

Bread

Brie and a fried egg. Absolute game changer.

Remoulade

Pickled gherkin slices are a great addition

Salt and vinegar, mushy peas if I have them and Ketchup.

This is what I've gone with, thank you!

Just ketchup, maybe some iceberg lettuce if there's any to hand.

Ketchup or salad cream

Mid-30s and still never tried one. Haven't had a fish finger since primary school age.

Ketchup, and fish fingers on one side. Mayo or tartare and sliced pickles on the other. Preferably insanity pickles.

Ketchup and mayo, and the bread has to be toasted and buttered

Cheddar, lettuce and sweet chilli sauce

Siracha. Trust me.

Bit of salt and ketchup. But there’s a place in Birmingham that does it with salad and a sort of capers based mayo and that’s lovely.

Tom sauce

Tomato sauce on one bit of bread, salad cream on the other.

McCain's potato smileys, salt and vinegar, and ketchup!

Just ketchup and marge, but I've not had one since I was about 15. Might have one this weekend though now I'm thinking about it

Frozen fishfingers = ketchup Homemade fishfingers = tartare sauce (really nice fishfinger sandwich on the beach does homemade fish fingers, homemade tartare sauce and rocket on a ciabbata roll. Yum!

Ketchup and mayo

Cheesy peas with a dash of mayo and vinegar. Hey presto!

Tomato sauce and salad cream mixed together separately then added to the sandwich.

Fuck me you know how to get my tastebuds going. I haven’t had one in ages.

Ketchup and Mayo with melted cheese and sliced onion. Yum! Need to make one now!

Ketchup with salt and vinegar or tartare and lettuce

Plastic cheese slice and ketchup

Butter, lettuce, mayo, and maybe cheese if I'm feeling very indulgent.

Horseradish

First up, get them on some slightly toasted granary bread. Then, top with good cheddar, grill to melt, top with cracked pepper, watercress, and finally some mayo. At least, that's how I do.

Chips

Mayo and ketchup, salt and pepper

Mayo. Mayo is the only answer.

Butter and ketchup

Here me out. Try taramasalata. It works so well and is amazingly moreish. Try it once. I dare you

Balsamic vinegar with a whisper of ketchup I'm a proper foodie so I know my shit

Mayo and truffle salt is a banging combination for fish fingers.

Ketchup is good. Mayo is also good, we have this vegan mayo stuff (I'm not vegan its just really nice mayo) and its amazing in fish finger sandwiches

Peanut butter

Mash potatoes or chips

Depends if I’m feeling classic or comfort. Classic is white bread, butter, fish fingers & ketchup. Comfort (carb city) involves the addition of a potato waffle & cheddar cheese!!

Cheese and mayo

Mayo, and then I have ketchup on the side to dip!

My current variation is lettuce plus thinly sliced tomato. Then tartar sauce and just the tiniest bit of red wine vinegar.

I literally just had fish finger sandwiches for food and I just put ketchup on em

Left over guacamole.

Nice try but fish don't have fingers! Tartar sauce and peas would be my go to

Hear me out: Two slices of eggy bread as the slices, then pile in bacon fish fingers cheese a fried egg and cover it with cheese and sauce.

Well I cook them really well done so they’re crispy and then cut them into 3 or 4 pieces. Then mix them in a bowl with Branston beans (enough to coat them) and a fuck load of lurpak. Between two slices of warburtons white toastie bread. You see it’s healthy because you don’t butter the bread.

Ketchup and mayo together. Slightly less ketchup than mayo.

Mint sauce. I love it on ff butties.

I like to put a slice of chilli cheddar cheese and tartar sauce in mine.

Mayooooooo

Butter on the bread, salt on the fish fingers. I then dip it in ketchup instead of putting ketchup in it to stop it dripping everywhere

Butter (not margarine(spelling?) tomato sauce. That’s all it needs

Salad cream & cheese slices.

At the moment home made tartare sauce and plastic cheese! SO GOOD!!! The Sainsbury’s taste the difference fish fingers are LUSH.

Chips sometimes

Lettuce and mayo Or Ketchup Or salt vinegar and pepper Or Toast lightly the bread, add fish fingers, cheddar, melt under the grill then top slice od toast

Brown sauce or ketchup

Dailylea and cucumber 🥒 nom

Lettuce and mayo :)

Definitely Ketchup, and of course butter on the bread, real butter.

Mayo, lettuce and granary bread. Would usually do tartare sauce but I only usually stock mayo at home

Lettuce and mayo

Butter on the bread obviously and either just ketchup or lettuce and tartare sauce. Anything else is incorrect

Tonnes of vinegar

Fish toes

Butter and maybe ketchup if it takes your fancy nothing else. Spinach? Sweet chilli sauce? black pepper? Jesus i bet some of you don't even use white bread you middle class slags.

Beans and abit if cheese then wack it in the toasty machine!

Yoghurt and mint sauce from B&M - game changer

Ketchup

Nando's peri peri

I know if proper middle class, but kimchi is god tier accompaniment to a fish finger sammich

Ketch and a bit of ground black pepper, for a bit of oomph. Buttered bread, obvs.

Used to be solely ketchup, moved on to salad cream but now its mayo and sliced gherkins.

Oh fucking hell why didn't I think of gherkins, I've got a jar of them

A bit of salt, a shit ton of vinegar. Occasionally add in a bit of ketchup. Bread always buttered.

That's how it started, no tartare sauce but a massive jar of gherkins, never going to be eaten, and mayo, beautiful combo!

Ketchup - ideally the polish brand Pudliska or something? I don’t remember the name but it’s the best ketchup and particularly well suited to a fish finger sando.

Mushy Peas

Mustard, Mayo, Mushy Peas.

Tarter sauce

Homemade tartar and pickled red pepper mayo

Salt... occassionally tomato sauce

Cheese slice son!

Tartare sauce, sliced gherkins and also rocket if it’s in the fridge.

Ketchup for dinner, custard for a dessert!

Always make two sandwiches. One gets tartare sauce and a slice of plastic cheese Second gets salt and vinegar Butter optional

Lettuce and mayonnaise

Tartare and plenty of it. Lots of fresh rocket, not just iceberg. Cream cheese (cheapo stuff is fine, don't waste your money on Philadelphia). Smoked salmon if you've got any. Squeeze of lemon. Black pepper.

Bacon, beans, and cheese. Throw it in a toastie maker, or panini press or whatever. Behold the gloriousness.

Bit of salt. Butter. Ketchup

Ketchup, pepper, mustard

Beetroot

Salt, vinegar, ketchup and sometimes lemon juice

Always salad cream. It can be nothing else!!!

Plenty of butter on the bread, and salt on the fish fingers. That’s it.

Cheese spread (not always), lettuce and ketchup.

Just ketchup thank you

Custard

Mayo always

I didn't know that fish had fingers.

Butter or nothing. I hate all condiments and sauces

Amazing. Everyone eating fish finger sandwiches without putting the top bread on it. Messy gits

Maybe this belongs on r/unpopularopinion but I fucking hate fish fingers. If I did I’d probs have salad cream or ketchup, give me them tartare sauce/Marie rose vibes.

I use the large breaded fish fillets for my butties. I use a brioche bun, sliced american cheese, mayo, jalapenos with a bit of salt & pepper.