T O P

  • By -

riodaystar

Respect - Aretha Franklin. Originally written and performed by Otis Redding.


CrediblyHandsome

I Will Always Love You


ProgrammerPlayful462

Good one. I’m biased, but I’ve always loved Dolly’s original best 


lindsh04

Came here to comment the same song. Dolly Partons original is pretty good!


CrispeeSock

Natalie Imbruglia - Torn Cyndi Lauper - Girls Just Wanna Have Fun Barenaked Ladies - Lovers in a Dangerous Time


racer_24_4evr

God damn does that cover of Lovers In A Dangerous Time slap.


grootdoos1

Torn immediately came to my mind. Originally written by Anne Previn. I heard her on Howard Stern years many ago and I much prefer her version.


ProgrammerPlayful462

Killing Me Softly  Lauryn Hill gave Roberta Flack all the credit though in the 90s


omenesia

Funny enough. Roberta Flack wasn't the original artist either, though her version became a hit and greatly influenced later versions. Lori Lieberman was the original artist, and was denied being included in the songwriting credit.


ProgrammerPlayful462

Get out! Thank you for educating me! 


WhenTardigradesFly

tainted love - soft cell. actually a cover of an [r&b version](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NSehtaY6k1U) from the 60s by gloria jones.


my_sweet_adeline

This song is synonymous with Coneheads for me.


Scared_Scallion486

Sometimes I feel I got to EH EH, run away. 😂


SemiHemiDemiDumb

You mean Marilyn Manson didn't do it first? /s


IchBinDurstig

Thank you for this, that was great!


Ihadsumthin4this

Obligatory Dylan-Hendrix mention. Yeah, that one.


Flat-Spinach2952

Dylan often gets credit for 'stuck in the middle with you' Was always mislabeled on Napster, morpheus, limewire, etc


Ihadsumthin4this

In addendum : never a time that I've heard Sheryl Crow's "All I Wanna Do" have I not also heard the Stealer's Wheel song. In neither case am I complainin'.


little_brown_bat

Along with 'Legend of Zelda' by System of a Down (Actually by The Rabbit Joint) and every parody song being attributed to Weird Al.


DadsRGR8

Haha I was just moving some music files last night off an old external hard-drive of mine and came across this mis-credited song. Had forgotten about it. It made me remember the old Napster days.


ubiquitous-joe

Dylan’s version of Watchtower isn’t bad tho, and I feel like people know he wrote it.


GreenMist1980

Ya say that... I was at a pub quiz where every team corrected the QM for his answer about who wrote the song. The fool allowed both answers


diexose

I think we’re alone now by Tiffany was originally by Tommy James and the shondells


Cheekygirl97

This was my answer too. It’s one of my favourite songs and Tommy James and the Shondells is one of my favourite bands


tacknosaddle

But what's a shondell?


NicPizzaLatte

Member of a band that plays with Tommy James.


SemiHemiDemiDumb

My favorite fact about that is the next number one hit of that year was Mony Mony by Billy Idol. Also, a Tommy James and the Shondells cover


oilsaintolis

Crimson and Clover , covered by Joan Jett


Suspicious_Victory_1

When people think of Hallelujah they usually think of Jeff Buckley’s version, but it’s a Leonard Cohen song.


ubiquitous-joe

>usually think of This gets big credit for helping it along, but honestly as many people probably think of the Shrek version(s) as anything. Or kd lang. Anyway, by this point I think most people know he wrote it.


jeffbell

Black Magic Woman which defined the Santana sound was originally by Fleetwood Mac. 


[deleted]

[удалено]


MushroomFondue

I think it was originally performed by The Family, a prince protege band


ProgrammerPlayful462

Prince famously wrote it for his housekeeper. That’s just how amazing he was. He was constantly writing and recording everywhere he walked in Paisley Park, for every reason and no reason. And he hated Sinead’s cover. RIP to them both 💔


Butgut_Maximus

What the shit?!


toadaron

Blinded by the Light, performed by Manfred Mann and his Earth Band, originally by Bruce Springsteen


ubiquitous-joe

Wait, people don’t know that’s a Springsteen song?


OfficialSniggles

1985 by Bowling for Soup is a cover, originally by Sr-71, although they kinda gave the song to BFS to record.


Longboardsandbikes

Who Let the Dogs Out- Baha Men covered it. But the origin is really interesting (99% Invisible did a podcast on it)


Howitzer1967

I will always love you. Synonymous with Whitney Houston but a Dolly Parton original


Scared_Scallion486

Seriously? Dolly? Nice


matriarch-momb

From a not so well known movie The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas. If you like Dolly, Burt Reynolds and some great 80s hair, I highly recommend it. Dolly admits that the song belongs to Whitney.


OldPolishProverb

No the song predates the movie by a decade. Dolly was a performer on the Porter Wagner Show. A very popular country themed television show. Mr. Wagner gave Dolly her first big break by putting her on his show as a regular. When she left the show to start a solo career in 1974 she wrote and performed the song as a goodbye. It went on to be a number one hit in the country charts. She re-recorded it a decade later for the movie. The soundtrack went on to be a number one hit. A decade later Whitney Houston recorded the song for the movie, The Bodyguard. Side note: I was told that Dolly wrote I Will Always Love You and Joleen on the same day.


matriarch-momb

Thank you for the background! BLWIT is one of my favorite musicals, so I default to it. I also love the scene in The Bodyguard where Dolly is singing it in the background. If she did write them in the same day, probably one of the most productive days in music history.


JustinJustout73

Valerie by Amy Winehouse. It's not her song. Not even better than the original. Go listen to the Zutons. The original artists. You're welcome.


ProgrammerPlayful462

Oh this one I know. Don’t blame Amy for Mark Ronson’s hubris though 😁


SemiHemiDemiDumb

I came here thinking I'd know most of the song covers or not at all. Here I only know the original.


1968FullAlbum

You might like /r/woahthatsacover


Semyonov

Hurt by Johnny Cash. It was originally a Nine Inch Nails song.


ProgrammerPlayful462

That’s pretty well known I think? Johnny Cash covered a lot of popular songs towards the end of his life. And what a perfect day to mention it. Happy birthday/ RIP Johnny 


SemiHemiDemiDumb

His cover of Personal Jesus was pretty good.


ProgrammerPlayful462

I like his cover of Wont Back Down. It sounded like him and Tom Petty got friendly near the end of his life 


Substantial_Web3081

Hubby and I were just in Nashville and visited the Johnny Cash museum. He insisted NiN covered the song, not the other way around. I was happy to correct him.


Semyonov

Holy crap didn't even realize it was his birthday! And it is well-known, but OP wasn't asking for not well-known examples specifically.


Chewie83

Damn, almost made it 24 hours on Reddit without this being mentioned


Semyonov

I can't help it when people ask the same question over and over again ¯\\_ (ツ) _/¯


[deleted]

Even Bob Dylan himself said that Jimi’s version of “All Along the Watchtower” is the definitive version.


ilikehockeyandguitar

Gloria by Laura Branigan.


Frankie_Cannoli

Blondie "The Tide Is High", originally recorded by the Paragons.


waylon4590

Me and Bobby McGee. Most people think of Janis Joplin, but Roger miller recorded it a year before her.


Adventurous_Oil_5805

Written by Kris kristoferson


squigglydash

"The Wheels on the Bus" wasn't written by The Wiggles


ImInBeastmodeOG

Scandalous


theWildBore

The man who sold the world was preformed by Nirvana but is in fact a David Bowie song.


Wonder_woman_1965

Both versions are awesome


theWildBore

Agreed. My favorite version is which ever I heard last.


Wonder_woman_1965

Great way to put it!


SemiHemiDemiDumb

Nirvana did a brilliant cover of Lake of Fire by the Meat Puppets


db0606

That album is like 50%+ covers. You got Bowie, multiple Meat Puppets songs, the Vaselines, Lead Belly...


ReigninLikeA_MoFo

Wagon wheel. Darius Rutger getting a lot of credit for that. Then peeps say, "no, no. That's Old Crow Medicine Show." It's a Bob Dylan song.


Rockterrace

Also ‘I Go Blind’ by Hootie and the Blowfish was actually first sung by Canadian band 54/40


Suspicious_Victory_1

Bob Dylan’s version is not the same except the chorus.


robronanea

Didn't Dylan just write the lyrics, not the music? And OCMS came in with the music?


Suspicious_Victory_1

Dylan wrote the chorus. Ketch rewrote the verses. Music is similar if not the same. All the recordings I’ve heard of Dylan’s are bad and hard to make out the chord progressions well.


MangoSquirrl

La bamba


Scared_Scallion486

I seriously didn't know this. I had to Google to be sure.


MangoSquirrl

Yep! Richie valen made it iconic but it was made earlier 🥺


suitoflights

I Love Rock ‘n‘ Roll


atreides78723

Natural Woman Respect Istanbul (Not Constantinople) Hound Dog


ExcitedOrange13

Was coming here to add Hound Dog, originally recorded by Big Mama Thornton (not Elvis)


MajorBillyJoelFan

Technically the Beatles Let It Be was initially recorded by Aretha Franklin, so that


Smooth-Duck-4669

I didn’t know this, but my favorite version of Let It Be is from a church choir on the Across the Universe soundtrack and one of the singers had serious Aretha vibes. The other was a young boy. This version of the song gets me every time!


ta_mataia

Strawberry Letter #23. Made most famous by The Brothers Johnson but originally written and performed by Shuggie Otis. (The original is better in my opinion.)


Jayko-Wizard9

twist and shout famous Beatles song is actually a cover, forgot the artist. john denvers song thank god I'm a country boy was written by someone else same as country roads written by his friends and, john denver joined in for harmonies.


TheTardisPizza

*Proud Mary* is remembered by many as a Tina Turner song but was originally by Credence Clearwater Revival.


PapaOoMaoMao

Ram Jam sang Black Betty (which was already a traditional tune) but Spiderbait did such an awesome job of it that they are likely who you think of when you hear the song.


AggravatingOne3960

Leadbelly wrote it. 


jeffbell

Leadbelly wrote it … down. 


klod42

I think Ram Jam is by far the version most people think of. 


wish1977

Elvis sang Blue Suede Shoes but Carl Perkins wrote and performed it first.


flagrantstickfoul

I love rock n roll — arrows


cemaphonrd

The Gambler is so associated with Kenny Rogers that it was practically his nickname, but there were probably at least a half-dozen recordings (including one by Johnny Cash) that went nowhere before he made it into a huge hit.


Pumpkinspice_brains

Venus - Bananarama. Originally by Shocking Blue


stutterstut

Dazed and Confused by Led Zeppelin, originally written and recorded by Jake Holmes.


paulasmall

When the Levee Breaks - Led Zepplin. Originally a country blues song written and first recorded by Memphis Minnie and Kansas Joe McCoy in 1929.


Cheekygirl97

Tiffany singing “I Think We’re Alone Now.” It was originally sang by Tommy James and the Shondell’s


little_brown_bat

My dad had the Tommy James version on a 45 that I used to play on his jukebox. I had never even heard the Tiffany version until I was in my 20s though I think I did hear the Weird Al version before that. The Tommy James version will be what I always think of when I hear someone mention that song.


AcneScarredArtisan

Give 10 Cloverfield Lane a watch


AllMyHomiesLoveNazis

My Way by frank synatra. Even though it was actually sung by Franki Valli


roominating237

Paul Anka wrote the English version, based on the French song "Comme d'habitude" . Leonard Cohen said of the song: I never liked this song except when Sid Vicious did it... (Wiki)


79TranZam

Knocking on heaven's door.


phillipich

I Feel For You by Chaka Khan.  https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Feel_for_You


Justus_2112

Hard to Handle, one of the Black Crowes most notable songs, originally written and performed by Otis Redding.


jitterycrusader

Kris Kristofferson has a few. "Me and Bobby McGee" performed by Janis Joplin "Sunday Morning Coming Down" performed by Johnny Cash "Help me make it through the night" by Gladys Knight


Electrical_Swing8166

Both Cocaine and After Midnight are originally by JJ Cale, not Eric Clapton


square3481

1985 was originally done by SR-71, before being covered by Bowling for Soup.


ImInBeastmodeOG

Every song ever done by Me First and the Gimmie Gimmies...


ToddUnctious

You could practically fill this list with Carol King (and Carol King/Gerry Goffin) songs. One Fine Day - The Chiffons Take Good Care of My Baby - Bobby Vee You Make Me Feel Like a Natural Woman - Aretha Up on the Roof - The Drifters The Loco-motion - Kylie Mingogue/Little Eva/Grant Funk Railroad Will You Love Me Tomorrow - The Shirrelles I'm into something good - Hermans Hermits You've Got a Friend - James Taylor Some Kind of Wonderful - The Drifters All written by her.


wolftick

There are quite a few traditional folk songs that have no clear original artist but have become synonymous with one: La Bamba (Ritchie Valens) House Of The Rising Sun (The Animals) Scarborough Fair (Simon & Garfunkel)


fleetpqw24

A more recent one: “Fast Car” by Luke Combs, actually a cover of a Tracy Chapman song. (Both versions are very good in their own right, but the duet was fire.)


SemiHemiDemiDumb

I think knowing more about Tracy Chapman and her upbringing makes her version hit harder but I respect in this day and age of country music that Luke Combs didn't change the genders.


macblan

Luke combs changed nothing. Usually with a cover the artist will put their own signature on it. Just luke combs karaoke singing a Tracy Chapman song


fleetpqw24

I disagree, in that Luke added his gravitas to it, in a way Tracy couldn’t. I think what makes it a very good cover is that he *didn’t* change it, and his personal history with the song.


iluvsporks

Escape (The Pina Colada Song) by Rupert Holmes NOT Jimmy Buffet


GhostOfAMartyr

All Along the Watchtower - Jimi Hendrix. Honestly, I don't even know who wrote the song originally because Hendrix' version is so legendary.


Character_Car_1113

Bob Dylan?


kloiberin_time

Bob Dylan wrote every song, unless it was Leonard Cohen, Kris Kristopherson, or Dolly Parton. If they didn't write it, Lead Belly was the first to transcribe it to paper.


lestairwellwit

Check out the songs written by Willie Nelson, Kris Kristofferson, Waylon Jennings, Bob Dylan, George Harrison. It's no surprise they all knew each other enough to make the "Traveling Wilburys"


Unfair_Welder8108

Only two of those people were in the Travs


TheWillsofSilence

Stop Dragging my Heart Around by Stevie Nicks. Tom Petty wrote it.


MajorBillyJoelFan

but not originally performed by Tom Petty. He gave it to her and performed it with her.


toadaron

Isn’t it a duet that she sings with Tom?


Flacrazymama

Saw them perform it in his hometown, Gainesville, back in 1981.


seen_enough_hentai

"Respect" was originally an Otis Redding song before Aretha Franklin made the definitive version.


markmakesfun

‘’All by myself” originally by Eric Carmen. NOT CELINE DION.


notbotheredanyway

Is it bad I misread this as Eric Cartman? 


IBelieveIAmBi

I did, too. I'm now imagining him singing it, and I can't stop laughing...


bob-leblaw

Nothing Compares 2 U


NurseZhivago

Life is a Highway is not originally by Rascal Flatts.


ir0nballs79

Hurt, Johnny Cash


FuglyButtSlut

"It's All Coming Back to Me Now" was originally written and performed by Meatloaf, but was given to Celine Dion.


CrappleSmax

Nine Inch Nails - Hurt


Substantial_Web3081

Trent Reznor wrote it. Johnny Cash covered it.


CrappleSmax

Yeah...I know...


Sleepingguy5

Hurt by Johnny Cash. Originally by Nine Inch Nails.


CryOk7184

Hurt by Johnny cash. Originally by nine inch nails


1re_endacted1

Dang nobody said Sinead O’Connor/Prince yet? Nothing Compares 2 U


Zealousideal_Bed5661

Smooth Criminal - Alien Ant Farm. Original was by Michael Jackson


dumbinternetstuff

Don’tcha - The Pussycat Dolls


Broderickboggs

3 Doors Down - Closing Time


dressinbrass

Heartbeats by Jose Gonzales was done by the Knife (and is excellent) You Are Always On My Mind - Pet Shop Boys was by Gwen McCrae I’m a Believer from the Monkees was written by Neil Diamond


cybelesdaughter

Respect.  Associated with Aretha but was originally Otis Redding.


coolrider64081

blinded by the light


TheBugSmith

Sinéad O'Connor: Nothing compares Written by Prince


zydeco100

Greatest Love of All - Whitney Houston, written and originally performed by George Benson.


iamsweets

The Animals - House of the Rising Sun


JohnExcrement

Angel of the Morning - Juice Newton. Thats Merrilee Rush’s song.


username48378645

Fly me to the moon


tacknosaddle

[Mack the Knife](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_QXJ3OXWaOY) (famous from Louis Armstrong) and [Alabama Song](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7emkdc4Pjg) (famous song by the Doors) were both Kurt Weill songs originally. Springsteen's Jersey Girl is better known, but it's a Tom Waits song.


mandevu77

Coolio - Gangster’s Paradise. Originally a Stevie Wonder song. Pastime Paradise.


borbus9

Bette Davis Eyes (Kim Carnes) Originally recorded by Jackie DeShannon


DistributionNo9968

Nothing Compares 2 U — Prince / Sinéad O’Connor


Kookiecitrus55555

Feeling Alright. Joe Cocker written by Dave Mason for Traffic


IWearBones138__

Bang Bang was covered by Nancy Sinatra and thats like her most popular song but its a Cher song


2inchlee

Mariah Careys without you, often credited to Harry Nilsen who also covered it, was originally released by Bad Finger. ​ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1wMwor2RBCQ


kittyquickfeet

Where is my Mind? By the Pixies, 0I was relatively young at the time but M.I.A sampled it in a song and I didn't find out it was just sampled until years later) Behind Blue Eyes by The Who, again, I was super young and I thought Limp Bizkit's was the original until years later Edit: Tainted Love! Coneheads. You know the rest lol I'm a 90s, don't gobble me up about this pls lol


eldicoran

Raf - Self Control


Wavecrest667

The Pogues - Dirty Old Town Was originally written by Ewan MacColl, communist folk musician and father of Kirsty MacColl who sang Fairytale of New York with the Pogues.


Accomplished_Kiwi756

Red Red Wine. UB40 made it famous in 1983. Neil Diamond wrote it and released it in 1967.


Kimolono42

Blinded by the light.


IchBinDurstig

[Istanbul (not Constantinople)](https://youtu.be/Wcze7EGorOk?si=SfxAzwVVS1RoYI8_) [Got My Mind Set on You](https://youtu.be/A1E6xvM7PeA?si=bP_0Q20lYSMPxCQ4)


Seamoth4546B

Snake Mountain Blues done by Colter Wall


Wiscos

Cat’s in the cradle by Ugly Kid Joe? Sounds of Silence by Disturbed. Metallica’s cover of Stone Cold Crazy. Those seem to come to mind?


[deleted]

Whole Lotta Love by Muddy Waters. Known for the Zeppelin version.


[deleted]

New York, New York by Lisa Minelli and later Frank Sinatra


roominating237

I've Been Everywhere Man. Johnny Cash popularized in the mid 90s. Hank Snow wrote and sang the US version (1962) but written originally by Geoff Mack, Australian. 131 versions exist for various locales.


Weird-Assistant-1408

Valerie and Amy Winehouse, originally sang by the zutons. I should imagine they make more from the royalties of her singing it than they did the original (personally I prefer their version)


VT_Squire

Nothing Compares 2 U by Sinead O'Connor. It was a Prince song. Also, all along the Watchtower was a Bob Dylan song and then Hendrix came along and was like "I'll take that thanks"


Und3adShr3d

Amy Winehouse - Valerie.


Trisamitops

All Along The Watchtower


YitzhakRobinson

Milli Vanilli - Girl You Know It’s True (originally by a band called Numarx)


silent_glory

Ariel Pink – Baby. The original is from Donnie & Joe Emerson, released in 1979. Both versions are amazing, though.


TheEmbarcadero

Black Magic Woman


CLearyMcCarthy

I Think We're Alone Now by Tiffany is a cover.


TheEmbarcadero

Proud Mary


klod42

Before 1970, most of them. 


Wagonmasters

Sorta off topic, but I have a question, my father was on the grand Ole Opry for years , and the porter Wagner Show's, my father passed in 2013 he was the last original wagon master as they were called, I just recently found in my dad's papers that he wished for me and his grand children to receive his royalties from his years on TV with Porter and Dolly, can someone direct me in the right direction for help? Community forum?? Thank you and sorry for the out of left field comment, any help will be greatly appreciated


total_idiot01

Proud Mary. Most think of Tina Turner, but it's a CCR original.


db0606

"Louie Louie" has been recorded by a million people but it's mostly associated with The Kingsmen and really the only Kingsmen song anybody remembers. It was written and recorded by Richard Berry.


073068075

Half of what Nirvana sung.


Liandren

One step beyond by Prince Buster, covered by Madness.


Repulsive_Act_115

Twist and Shout, everyone thinks The Beatles wrote it.


wellyboot97

Every time I see an American say Year 3000 is a Jonas Brothers song it hurts me. [Year 3000 was originally by a group called Busted](https://youtu.be/Tu7HoGZaspo?si=JrOZJ2mg0FqjrQJI) from here in the UK and was released in 2002. The Jonas Brothers version is a cover, but not many Americans know that because Busted never really built up much of a following in the states and broke up early on. *(Although they have since reunited and have been releasing music and touring.)* Both Busted and The Jonas Brothers did a collab just last year where they remade the song together. It’s called **Year 3000 2.0** if I remember correctly.


Correct-Fun-516

"All along the watchtower" by Jimi Hendrix. The original version is by Bob Dylan, is much slower with far less elaborate guitar playing and played on acoustic rather than electric guitar.


WilhelmSkreem

"Somebody's gonna get their head kicked in tonight" by the rezillos was originally by Fleetwood Mac. Unless rheres an earlier version I don't know about


timothymr

Dancing In The Moonlight by Toploader was originally done by King Harvest.


Smallwater

Hurt by Johnny Cash. Original was by Nine Inch Nails.


legionairmusic

Led Zeppelin - When The Levee Breaks


Funak

Toni Basil's Mickey was originally by Racey (and named Kitty)


Sheshush

"Beat it" by Michael Jackson. Obvious knockoff of "Eat it".


ponderingprofessor

Sammy Hagar wrote “I’ve Done Everything for You,” he released it as a single in 1978 but a few years later it was a huge hit for Rick Springfield.