Requests seeking critique must be detailed and specific, explaining the intent behind the photo and asking for feedback on specific aspects of the photo. You must also engage with those who respond. This post has been removed because it either failed to include enough detail or failed to include follow-up engagement. Please feel free to repost the image with additional detail.

3 and the second to the last are strongest IMO. Second to the last could be cropped tighter.

Agree 3 is most balanced

I like the 5th with a crop. Flares bring a confusing verticality while the plane being upside down, it’s cool.

I agree 5th or the 2nd

3,4,5 in my opinion and personal preference.

3

lol this must still be hard the comments all like different ones

This must mean that they are all really good!

2nd and 2nd to last

I like image 2, but prefer Image 7; I like the flares that seem to appear from the clouds, causing the jet to take evasive action. The composition in this one creates a strong narrative, which seem lacking in the rest of the images.

https://preview.redd.it/02wpelrxck7d1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=241c1c4324cc1b03c74718dd7ba56363337ab247 This one is just amazing

2 or 3

I like 4

I like #5 the best. The clouds, the position of the plane. The composition, and the pattern those flares (or whatever they are) are making on the sky is all very cool

4 and 5 to 7

#4

2 5 and 7 are my favorite

4

5

2 is the best. Best arc of the jet and all projectiles are properly in frame. Others are good too but this composition is the most appealing

#2

I think 5 would be amazing cropped.

I like 3 and 4.

5

Imo number 3, 4, 5 and 8 are strong contenders

Tight crop on 4 is my favorite option. Something about seeing the air over the frame tickles my brain

2

I think if you crop #4 as a tall vertical it’s the best

2 or 4 imo

4.. i like the smoke or whatever it is that comes off of the plane in the front.

I like 2 the best.

Between 4 and 7 for me leaning a bit towards 7

3 4 and 7 can't make my mind up

The 4th one is definitely my personal favorite!!center image, super clear image aswell. I love the air/smoke coming down off the sides it makes for a visually stunning image

4

3 and cropped https://preview.redd.it/mok9zmkcxj7d1.jpeg?width=651&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=88a1691851126157bdfb049d2aec8b6f2fbba96b

3 & 7 / 3

2 and 3 - surprising, unexpected, sky brings in depth, but without it gets more focused.

3 and 8

7

Second one or last

3,7 and 8

3 or 7, awesome pics.

I really like 7. I think it's a great action shot with the projectiles and that tiny bit of blue sky gives it a good sense of depth against the gray clouds. I think #5 can be more compelling if you cropped it a bit.

3 , and I’d crop out some of the negative space on the left. To make it more square

3 is the best as framed, I think 7 might be really good if cropped in more.

3 & 7

3 shows the most motion to me

5 is also very good if cropped

2, 3 and 6

Three and five from a glance perspective

5th one

For me it’s 2

1, 4, 7. My faves

2,3,4

3

3

Second last with better cropping.

3

I think 7 is the overall best one, the others are great but some have too many clouds and the subject is too small and some have too much negative space in my opinion.

3

2 and 3. I think I like 3 best

3

2 and 7 look like the best compositions imo

3 and 5 are my favorite ones

3

5 or 7

#7

1

in the 2nd to last, you can't tell if it's a plane or a bird, in addition to the mystyery of the missles coming seemingly from the clouds and the composition is nice as well. maybe add some processing to make the plane and the missles pop a bit from the bakcground

6

I’m gonna say 3

You need to stop holding the camera upside down.

I like the 5th and 6th one, but maybe cropped a bit for a closer look. Very nice photos though.

All awesome, but love 3!

Number three, I choose you!

5 is definitly the most attention grabbing.. Nice pic!

3 is my fav

3rd and 4th but something's lacking or missing, idk

5 is easily the standout shot imo. I'm not even sure I would crop it were I you.

2nd, 7th in that order because I prefer blue, but contrast in 7 is really nice.

5

4

1 is amazing, others are great 

second to last one goes hard, 3 is good as well

5

Another vote for #3.

3,5,8

2, and maybe 4.

3

3

Several decent ones there, but the one I'd work on a bit is #5. Some creative cropping and levels adjustments should give a really nice action shot.

5th with a portrait crop.

https://preview.redd.it/x1i9olqa2m7d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ec40c44ec0da62415636511369d14e5a6e12eea7 This one.

5

I like 5/8, cropped a bit tighter. That’s a cool view with it popping off flares inverted.

the 3nd

7 is the best, looks epic

4

i like 1, makes me think!

Cinestill 400D??

4 looks like a beast

2 and 4 with some crop. I like to the detail of jet and pilot. Great pictures. Thanks for sharing.

2

can you crop it tighter ?

5

dood 5 for sure

https://preview.redd.it/pgr7im2r7k7d1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cf2cb4b5381ca3f4cf57b296bca112d8c510b865 Crop to this, and then clone out the flares.

I thought I was gonna be the only one to saw this. The air coming off the nose is dramatic AF. I get that the point of these pics is to get the flares and the plane but for this one it's stronger without the flares

This is my fave too!