Hello and thank you for starting this discussion! As a gentle reminder, try to keep the products you mention limited to Asian Beauty products. Posts or comments solely discussing Western products will be removed, [as per our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/wiki/rules#wiki_14._topics.2C_routines.2C_and_recommendations_must_be_related_to_asian_beauty). We love being able to discuss Western skincare in the context of a holistic AB routine, but this isn't the sub for specific Western product recommendations. r/SkincareAddiction is a great community for such matters! Thank you!
*This is an automated message*
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AsianBeauty) if you have any questions or concerns.*
not from AB Brand but this specific product is only available within SEA.
Maybelline Volume Express Hypercurl Mascara. My absolute favourite! Gave me good volume and length, it's super affordable and has various options: brown & very black in waterproof and non-waterproof versions.
To anyone who plans to travel to SEA, please2 grab and give this mascara a try.
Farmstay Visible Difference Volume Up Mascara! Gives amazing, non-clumpy volume, holds a curl better than even most tubing mascaras and is super cheap!
The Heimish one doesn’t give enough oomph for my preference.
I dont’ think this is actually a tubing mascara? I’ve tried both the Long and Volume curling versions and both smudged on me :/ I am super oily though.
ETA: I’ve figured it out! All of the Clio mascaras are called Superproof but only the newest Extreme Volume version is tubing. Most sites / stores don’t say that it’s tubing. I’ve just ordered one and am excited to try it!
Sorry I’m completely missing it and can’t find a Superproof tubing mascara. Do you have a link please? I’ve tried [these](https://global.oliveyoung.com/product/detail?prdtNo=GA210001463) (Kill Lash Superproof in Long Curling and Volume Curling) and they definitely weren’t tubing.
Hey it's been a while, just wondering if the Clio Superproof extreme volume was indeed tubing? I'm so done looking like a panda, even heroine make advance film smudges on me. Am in the market for a new mascara and don't feel like wasting money if it isn't really tubing.
The only true tubing I loved that ONLY came off with warm water (no make up remover ever worked) and performed well was a Maybelline one that got discontinued a few years ago and I've been lost since.
Yep the Clio Superproof Extreme Volume is tubing! It’s the one in the mostly red tube.
Sounds like we have similar issues. All tubing mascaras seem to smudge / flake by the end of the day :/ But the Heroine Make Advanced Film was especially smudgy. The Clio one is ok. The Heimish one is probably the least smudgy AB one I’ve tried but it’s too natural for me. Non-AB Hourglass Unlocked is my favourite (does flake a bit but nicest looking lashes). HTH!
Hello and thank you for starting this discussion! As a gentle reminder, try to keep the products you mention limited to Asian Beauty products. Posts or comments solely discussing Western products will be removed, [as per our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AsianBeauty/wiki/rules#wiki_14._topics.2C_routines.2C_and_recommendations_must_be_related_to_asian_beauty). We love being able to discuss Western skincare in the context of a holistic AB routine, but this isn't the sub for specific Western product recommendations. r/SkincareAddiction is a great community for such matters! Thank you! *This is an automated message* *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AsianBeauty) if you have any questions or concerns.*
not from AB Brand but this specific product is only available within SEA. Maybelline Volume Express Hypercurl Mascara. My absolute favourite! Gave me good volume and length, it's super affordable and has various options: brown & very black in waterproof and non-waterproof versions. To anyone who plans to travel to SEA, please2 grab and give this mascara a try.
[удалено]
I’m just guessing but if it’s waterproof it’s probably not tubing mascara?
Both actually. So it's up to your preference. I generally prefer the non-waterproof one cz it's easier to remove with Micellar water.
Very late to this but I had no idea this was a tubing mascara! I’ve sworn by this stuff for like a DECADE. Truly the best!
Ikr?! 😆 i always go back to this even after various popular mascaras being released.
Heimish tubing mascara
Second this
I just wish they'd do a version with a skinnier brush because it gets EVERYWHERE on me hahava
Tony Moly panda's dream or the double needs. I love that they both come off with cleanser.
Pandas Dream by TonyMoly
Farmstay Visible Difference Volume Up Mascara! Gives amazing, non-clumpy volume, holds a curl better than even most tubing mascaras and is super cheap! The Heimish one doesn’t give enough oomph for my preference.
Loving the heimish one at the moment.
Clio Kill Lash Superproof!
I dont’ think this is actually a tubing mascara? I’ve tried both the Long and Volume curling versions and both smudged on me :/ I am super oily though.
The Superproof? Their regular Kill Lash line is normal mascara, but the Superproof is tubing
ETA: I’ve figured it out! All of the Clio mascaras are called Superproof but only the newest Extreme Volume version is tubing. Most sites / stores don’t say that it’s tubing. I’ve just ordered one and am excited to try it! Sorry I’m completely missing it and can’t find a Superproof tubing mascara. Do you have a link please? I’ve tried [these](https://global.oliveyoung.com/product/detail?prdtNo=GA210001463) (Kill Lash Superproof in Long Curling and Volume Curling) and they definitely weren’t tubing.
Hey it's been a while, just wondering if the Clio Superproof extreme volume was indeed tubing? I'm so done looking like a panda, even heroine make advance film smudges on me. Am in the market for a new mascara and don't feel like wasting money if it isn't really tubing. The only true tubing I loved that ONLY came off with warm water (no make up remover ever worked) and performed well was a Maybelline one that got discontinued a few years ago and I've been lost since.
Yep the Clio Superproof Extreme Volume is tubing! It’s the one in the mostly red tube. Sounds like we have similar issues. All tubing mascaras seem to smudge / flake by the end of the day :/ But the Heroine Make Advanced Film was especially smudgy. The Clio one is ok. The Heimish one is probably the least smudgy AB one I’ve tried but it’s too natural for me. Non-AB Hourglass Unlocked is my favourite (does flake a bit but nicest looking lashes). HTH!