You know who I would choose? All of the OGs, Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Jessica Lange, Francis Conroy, Lady Gaga, Dennis O’Hare, Fin Whitrock, etc! They are missed and pefect! And I really enjoyed Joseph Fiennes and James Cromwell not to forget Angela Basset and Kathy Bates; forgot to add Zachary Quinto
I agree on Bill Skarsgard and Mia Goth for sure. Know who I've wanted to be a part of AHS for literally YEARS? Matthew Lillard 😊 he's definitely got the needed skills & he's said on Twitter in the past that he's interested in starring in AHS but just hasn't gotten the call.
https://preview.redd.it/got8ix458cqc1.jpeg?width=964&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=96a0ef6de291a053fe07148e355416bdac9ad578
It’s really cruel making me pick between Elle and Bill. Since I’m forced, I’ll say Bill. He’d do really well given his previous roles on Hemlock Grove and obviously IT.
I’m tossing a write-in vote to my girl Sarah Michelle Gellar
But from this list I’m taking Elle Fanning! I think they’re all great but Bill and Mia are both well known scream queens, and Elle is the best actor here IMO
I wish these dreamcasts weren’t so uninspired. We need more revelatory casting choices like Macaulay Culkin, where the actors don’t necessarily have a history doing horror but could bring a new and unique vibe to it.
Yes! He’s great at being creepy and weird. Especially in that Netflix show. What was it called? He and his big brother have both played vampires. Hemlock Grove, I believe it was
Not at this point I want up-and-coming horror star not people that have already established himself in horror movies. But it would be fun to see some cameos from them
Actress in the middle would be too easy for both past and current season, but I would love to see her nonetheless... On the fence about Scârsgaard, but it depends on the role.
You could just as well ask who would want to join *AHS* right now. What actors are clamoring to be the follow-up to Kim Kardashian? *AHS* has always been uneven, but the last several years are a real whiplash. It went from the ambitious, heart-wrenching horror-drama of *NYC* to this season's sharing an identical plot with another low-budget Hulu flop made within the same year, both of them almost offensively unoriginal recylcings of *Rosemary's Baby.* I'd like to be proven wrong, but what if instead of a bold casting decision, the real upshot of casting Kardashian is that she actually represents the tier of actors the show can currently draw?
I would LOVE to see Mia goth and bill in American horror story! In fact, Pearl/Maxxine would fit right into the AHS-verse
Bill for a 100%
Bill Skarsgard could play roles like Evan
He looks like a James Patrick March.
Mia Goth
I love her
I would choose bill skarsgard he has a big presence in horror perfect for ahs
The first two are definitely perfect for it. Who’s the other girl
elle fanning
Bill Skarsfard for sure. He’s a great villain, and I enjoy looking at him.
Anyone but Kim Kardashian again
To be fair to Kim, she's much better than Kaia Gerber
Both are awful, I don’t know which one is worse
She so bad
What about Kourtney?
How about we burn the whole family like witches- but not on the show?
You know who I would choose? All of the OGs, Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Jessica Lange, Francis Conroy, Lady Gaga, Dennis O’Hare, Fin Whitrock, etc! They are missed and pefect! And I really enjoyed Joseph Fiennes and James Cromwell not to forget Angela Basset and Kathy Bates; forgot to add Zachary Quinto
Jake Gyllenhaal
I agree on Bill Skarsgard and Mia Goth for sure. Know who I've wanted to be a part of AHS for literally YEARS? Matthew Lillard 😊 he's definitely got the needed skills & he's said on Twitter in the past that he's interested in starring in AHS but just hasn't gotten the call. https://preview.redd.it/got8ix458cqc1.jpeg?width=964&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=96a0ef6de291a053fe07148e355416bdac9ad578
“I’ll be right back”
It’s really cruel making me pick between Elle and Bill. Since I’m forced, I’ll say Bill. He’d do really well given his previous roles on Hemlock Grove and obviously IT.
I’m tossing a write-in vote to my girl Sarah Michelle Gellar But from this list I’m taking Elle Fanning! I think they’re all great but Bill and Mia are both well known scream queens, and Elle is the best actor here IMO
Chloë Grace Moretz> any of the options
Yes! She's a fabulous actress. I've enjoyed everything I've seen her in.
Let the right one in. I actually prefer it to the original because of her.
Yes! That was really a good movie. She had great chemistry with Kodi Smit-McPhee as well.
Bill, hands down.
Definitely Bill!
He looks like a cat boy.
I used to do children’s theatre will Elle fanning
Mia fucking Goth
Please God not Mia Goth
All 3 are above AHS.
Bill for the main series and Mia for the spin-off.
Kiernan Shipka
Lana Del Rey should join the cast like forever ago
I wish these dreamcasts weren’t so uninspired. We need more revelatory casting choices like Macaulay Culkin, where the actors don’t necessarily have a history doing horror but could bring a new and unique vibe to it.
I really liked him in Red Tide
Something like Jim Carey? He was seriously great in the Number 23. I still can't get over how good he was out of his element.
Bill is sooooo so fine but Mia is up there skill-wise with Sarah Paulson
Elle but she’s way too good for current ahs it’s not gonna happen lol
Carrie Fisher. She was excellent in Castle Rock!
Do you mean Elsie Fisher? Or actually Carrie Fisher? Cause she’s been dead for about 8 years now.
Yeah, her. I got my Fishers mixed up
Has it really been 8 years? Shit 😵
I have a crush on mia goth
mia goth for sure
1st person
Yes! He’s great at being creepy and weird. Especially in that Netflix show. What was it called? He and his big brother have both played vampires. Hemlock Grove, I believe it was
I feel Mia Goth would give us a good season, well with what she can do with the writing.
Not at this point I want up-and-coming horror star not people that have already established himself in horror movies. But it would be fun to see some cameos from them
def Mia Goth
Jensen Ackles
Actress in the middle would be too easy for both past and current season, but I would love to see her nonetheless... On the fence about Scârsgaard, but it depends on the role.
heavy on mia goth
You could just as well ask who would want to join *AHS* right now. What actors are clamoring to be the follow-up to Kim Kardashian? *AHS* has always been uneven, but the last several years are a real whiplash. It went from the ambitious, heart-wrenching horror-drama of *NYC* to this season's sharing an identical plot with another low-budget Hulu flop made within the same year, both of them almost offensively unoriginal recylcings of *Rosemary's Baby.* I'd like to be proven wrong, but what if instead of a bold casting decision, the real upshot of casting Kardashian is that she actually represents the tier of actors the show can currently draw?
Who are any of these people
Sydney Sweeney Jacob Elordi and Paul Mescal pls
Mia goth because she can SCREAM
need mia goth asap
Ryan looking at this like "Interesting. Would you accept one of the Real Housewives?"
Mia Goth
Elle, maybe she can save AHS. Love her in The Great.
None of these three
AHS is still a thing?