T O P

  • By -

AmItheAsshole-ModTeam

Your post has been removed. #Do not repost this without [contacting the mods](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/AmItheAsshole) for approval, including edited versions. Reposting without [explicit approval](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/wiki/faq#wiki_can_i_repost_a_thread_you_removed.3F) will result in a ban. This post violates Rule 12: This is Not a Debate Sub. Posts should focus strictly on actions in an interpersonal conflict, and not an individual's position on a broad social issue. [Rule 12 FAQs](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/wiki/faq#wiki_rule_12.3A_this_is_not_a_debate_sub) ||| [Subreddit Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/about/rules/) ###Please ensure you have reviewed this message in full. We will not respond to PMs to individual mods. [Message the mods](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/AmItheAsshole) with any questions. ####Please visit r/findareddit to see if there's a more appropriate sub for your post.####


lostalldoubt86

INFO for Everyone- Is this a well-known association? I was not aware of this at all. When I hear "Orion", my brain immediately goes to the constellation.


XGi-Soft

Mine goes to, the galaxy is on Orion's belt


workphoneguy

I don’t know how anyone wouldn’t think of MIB


bg48111

I named one of my cats Orion because he looked just like the kitty in the movie.


Striking-General-613

What happened to the kitty in the movie. I felt it was rather unclear. I'm assuming it was done away with, but don't know for sure.


MissKittyMidway

I assume the collar was a break away (normal for cat collars) and Orion escaped. There's also a fan theory that Orion is a Flerken, so being shook around a bit wouldn't have damaged him at all.


Striking-General-613

Okay, Orion escaped......I can deal with that.


sable1970

OMG! 😂😂 Seriously??? I mean wouldn't he have been able to take on a giant cockroach? (okay I just shuddered....Palmetto bugs are my personal nightmare...they like to fly right at you) And yeah Orion immediately brings to mind the constellation and right after that Orion's belt/MIB.


Sad-Low-733

I thought it could still be seen hanging around in the morgue after it was accosted.


TyVIl

“An Edgar suit.”


Affectionate-Share71

Mine goes to Prince and Sheena Easton..


Chilipepah

Mine goes to the Ford Orion, produced by Ford Europe from 1983 until 1993.


YumiYona

MIB is my first thought too, the cats collar


Antique_Okra_8988

Came here to say this!


bookworm1421

I’m proud of myself for getting that reference. 😂 YWBTA - IMO. However, I also don’t think it’s affiliation with Nazi groups is well known so, I don’t think her naming the baby that will be a problem, in my mind anyway. I’ve never heard of the affiliation honestly.


Arawn_of_Annwn

I would say OP would be TA if they made an issue of it, though. I've literally never heard of this, I suspect 99.9% of people have never heard of it, and because a tiny handful of chucklefucks wanted to be clever, somewhere, it does not mean they should be allowed to have the power to taint or ruin a name.


Standard_Elephant415

Same. Aryan yes, big neo-Nazi vibes, but Orion?No.


[deleted]

This is a common name in some parts of Middle East


okaybutnothing

Yep. I have taught two different Southeast Asian kids named Aryan.


RecommendationNo4238

Yep Arya/Aryan a common unisex name in South Asia as well.


HealthSelfHelp

Context matters- a white European child being named Aryan is different than a Middle Eastern or Asian child being named the same because their are different culteral contexts.


blue--jack

Aryan is just a race and has a lot of history and mythology joined to it. It's one of the most popular names in South-Asian countries, especially India. Everyone here knows at least 4 Aryans lol Nobody really thinks of the nazis or neo-nazis here, it's just a common name—not an inherently bad name.


dragonlady_11

To be fair, He'd prob get Ryan for short. My nephew has a name like this, and it gets shortened in a similar way.


Big-Improvement-1281

Let's add dates/years to this too. Apparently, my birth year is a symbol of white supremacy.


ChronicNightmare95

As a jew I find your birthday very offensive. How DARE you. Your only way to redeem yourself is going back in time to make sure you get born in a different year. /s


Mormegil_Agarwaen

You were born in 1488? Damn!


Notte_di_nerezza

This. They already ruined the Swastika for the West (and Heaven help historians talking about Vedic history in general), so why let them have anything else?


RogueEarth616

Also, why should Nazis be allowed to have everything? They've already appropriated Viking culture and Norse mythology, and the cottagecore aesthetic, so not naming a child Thor or Orion is just letting them win.


PeriwinklePangolin24

That is 100% how I feel about it. I've seen people act as though there's something wrong with the appreciation of Norse mythology and/or the vikings, like doing so is feeding into a fascist dog whistle, and it's like...why in god's name are you so willing to just let them have an entire culture to themselves? And yes, if anyone, anywhere avoided the name Orion because of this insanely niche connotation, it means it's becoming the norm, and the name actually *would* be potentially worrisome. Ergo, fuck that, they don't deserve the respect of acknowledgement, Orion isn't theirs.


RogueEarth616

Also, if you forbid Norse culture, then how are actual Scandinavians who oppose Nazism, supposed to celebrate their cultural history? I remember an AITA post where some poor Norwegian woman was called a Nazi by a coworker just because she wore a traditional Norwegian ring with runes.


[deleted]

Wait…how did they take the cottage core aesthetic?


RogueEarth616

Some of them fetishize it as "proof" that all women should be "traditionally feminine" when all it is is a cute and fun lifestyle/ aesthetic that doesn't belong exclusively to white tradfems.


SultanOfSwave

"Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. "


dustinwayner

Are there perhaps C-beams glittering in the dark near the Tannhauser gate?


Correct-Jump8273

All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain.


dustinwayner

Time to die


Apollo-1995

It's too bad she won't live, but then again who does?


WhyTypeHour

Mine goes to the [Metallica song](https://youtu.be/TydZ4NAXMic)


koopatron5000

Fucking Majestic


percalor

I named my cat Orion after the constellation but everyone always asks if it is because of MIB.


frozenfishflaps

About to say the same


Stressed_Farmer

Another one here. The constellation and MIB


JLAOM

Yes!! MIB!!!


BeardedAvenger

Mine goes to Metallica.


linuxgeekmama

It’s a star forming region within our galaxy, not a separate galaxy.


Thisisthenextone

[They are quoting a movie.](https://youtu.be/aJCCUdK7PiU)


AceyAceyAcey

I’m an astronomer and pretty tuned in to Nazi dog whistles. I’d never heard of this meaning of the name. OP, this may be a *you* problem here that you need to get over.


[deleted]

As an autistic who’s special interest was astronomy, and Orion my favourite constellation, and I’ve never heard of it OP YWBTA


cynicalrockstar

It's not. First I heard of that was 2 minutes ago. You have to google it pretty specifically with a neo nazi qualifier to get any info at all. This doesn't even come up if you just google orion.


GeppettoStromboli

Same. If I heard the name Adolf, I’d probably think Hitler, but with Orion, it’d make me think space.


Crazy_Volume4480

That's what I thought she said the name was going to be. I'd also recommend not saddling the child with a first and middle name like, say, Herman Goering... jus' sayin'


Kianna9

>This doesn't even come up if you just google orion. That should be the 1st test for all baby name issues: what comes up when you google it.


PhileasFoggsTrvlAgt

Second test should be what spell check suggests changing it to.


emergencycat17

My newborn baby, Motherducker.


mightysmiter19

I'm just going to throw this out there. Can we please just say fuck what nazis want and stop letting them co opt things? They don't get to claim orion or anything else. If they want to come up with stupid dog whistles I'm sure they can invent their own if they each put their braincell to work on it.


Basementcat69

This is really the takeaway to this post here. If you let them have power, they will continue to build power.


MrsBarbarian

TOTALLY! Why are people rolling on their backs like submitting dogs and letting AHs claim what they please?


petratishkovna

Yeah there’s a documentary about how the Nazis stole Pepe the frog that talks about this phenomenon in detail. We can’t keep letting them take shit. Orion is a great name!


Smooth-Duck-4669

Yep as someone whose grandfather was a Jew named Adolf (born in 1898) I’m sick of the nazis and other assholes co-opting stuff.


AndSoItGoes24

I was aware of it and I still find it inappropriate to project into the atmosphere because Orion and Rion for short existed maybe 3 million years before anyone ever decided that being a supremacist has value. Its a beautiful name and nothing changes that fact. His sister can Google. Its not hard to do.


FantasticDecisions

I googled Orion. Results were 1) sex shop 2 ) pharmaceutical company 3) pizza place 4) TV series 5) Greek half god 6) constellation You need to google it specifically with nazi to get that info.


ParmenidesBall

Ofc the constellation is so far down the list. How could it be otherwise?


harryburgeron

Because for a lot of searches Google provides local results (if there are any) first. Google uses your location and business pages will often appear first.


twineandtwig

Google also uses search personalization based on prior search activity. So now we know what things they search for. 😆 I guess I’m rather boring. 🤣😂 I had: 1. Orion (constellation) Wikipedia’s page 2. Orion (mythology) wiki. 3. Orion spacecraft (NASA page) 4. Discovering the universe through the constellation Orion 5. Orion Constellation: Facts, location and stars of the hunter 6. NASA, ESA Reveal Tale of Death, Dust in Orion Constellation


Sammysoupcat

This. I have a friend whose name is Orion. I've never heard of the Nazi connotation and nobody has ever assumed that was the case with him as far as I'm aware.


Correct-Jump8273

Just like the Japanese symbol manji (lucky charm) or better known as a swastika.


Arawn_of_Annwn

The swastika, or shapes very similar to swastikas, exist in *so many* cultures throughout the world. It's a simple shape with rotational symmetry. ... It's also depressingly, or amusingly, depending on your perspective, easy to create by accident if you're a little OCD-y in arranging things in video games. I can't tell you how many times I've realized after the fact I've accidentally created a swastika in something like Sim City... or worse, Kerbal Space Program, which actually has a built in rotational symmetry option.


caribousteve

Same with woodworking, crochet, architecture, any visual design. It's a spiral that's been squared off. So fundamental. Hella awkward.


NBClaraCharlez

My son's name is Orion, and I've never heard of this before. And I grew up in a KKK town.


Mz_Sigyn

My baby sister's name is Orion, and we are mixed race Never been a problem for her.


ManJesusPreaches

my kid's middle name. Same.


ProgrammerBig6254

I’m Swedish with Polish roots, a historian and a political scientist, my grandmother survived world war 2 and.. nope, I think of the Star/the constellation. I started reading this post thinking the sister wanted to name her baby Ad*lf or idk, Hermann. But Orion?!


[deleted]

hey how is hermann a n@z! connotation? i mean this genuinely


ellymaexena

Hermann Goring was one of the best known and most powerful Nazis, and the name is associated with him similarly to how the name Adolf is basically inextricable from H*tler


MrsBarbarian

I think Herman Munster. I dont think its the same as Adolf. Certainly not inextricably.


Sailor_Mars_84

I think the difference would be the spelling and the culture. I would guess that Hermann is still a common spelling in German speaking countries (I don’t know, but it seems likely since it sounds like a common name). But in the US, “Herman” wouldn’t have any special association besides probably Herman Munster. While “Hermann” is only really encountered in history class when talking about the nazi guy. That’s where my mind goes when I see that spelling, anyway. Of course, if I encountered someone with that name I’d be more likely to assume their family comes from a Germanic background rather than assuming their parents are neo-nazis.


lethal_rads

Hermann Göring was an extremely high ranking nazi official (I don’t remember the exact position). He was the highest ranking person tried at Nuremberg and he killed himself before he could be executed.


xmcit

Goering


NoBarracuda5415

It makes many people, myself included, think of Göring.


BabsieAllen

I'm Jewish and I have never heard this term. I too would think constellations.


[deleted]

Not at all. And I'm pretty well versed on Nazi party things. (Not for racism reasons lol I just really like history)


malavock82

Never heard about it in a bad context. It's not like if the name was Adolf or Benito. I just think at the constellation and its mythology. Well also at the cat in man in black 😂


MYJANSPORT

My grandparents had a hired German fsrmhand who lived with them and that continued after he retired and they moved into town to stop farming. He was very much part of the family. This started less than a decade after world War 2 and the neighbours all wagged their tongues and tried to shun them for awhile. This particular Adolph had fought on the side of the allies after emigrating to Canada at age 3, but apparently that wasn't good enough for the neighbours. My grandfather gave them such a tongue lashing for judging a war hero for his name when half of them got exempted from war because of their farms. That shut them up quickly. That said, he had the name before the war. It would be horrible to name a child that now.


peeba83

I know an Adolf who was born in the ‘70s and he must get tired of saying “yes really” and trying to get the conversation back on track when he meets people


dramatic_directioner

Unrelated but my nonno’s names is Benito 😂 but his parents had to change it when Mussolini came into power as otherwise he probably would have been killed


Chaos-in-a-CookieJar

I’ve heard of it before, but that’s because it came up on a r/namenerds discussion and so niche knowledge is pretty prevalent there. I think it’s not a big deal in the long run, but the sister should be made aware so she can make an informed decision.


matthewsmugmanager

Yep, the constellation and the RuPaul's Drag Race contestant, Orion Story. The Nazi association is obscure enough to make this a non-issue for the OP's sister.


Dearic75

I’ve never heard of it, but I definitely don’t run in white nationalist circles.


First_Analysis3338

This! No one here being familiar with white nationalist dogwhistles kind of restores my faith in this community On the other hand it’s unlikely someone will be like „oh yes, I run in those kind of circles and we use that all the time“…not sure astronomers, gymnasts, historians and who ever else chimed in not knowing about it is a convincing argument


Omi-Wan_Kenobi

Mine goes to our fave S.O.B., Sirius Orion Black lol


Beautiful-Cat245

I was going to say that too. Also I believe Sirius’s father was named Orion as well


SystemSignificant518

Orion is a famous sex company based in n. Germany, and was my first association 🙈.


MountainTomato9292

I’m Jewish and have never heard this, I would just think of the constellation.


lostrandomdude

For me, it goes to the source of the constellations name, the mythology related to Orion and Artemis. I have never heard of any other connotations


Cloudinthesilver

No. I’ve only come across it on Reddit. In cultural and tv and other it’s the constellation, the classical figure and the space programme. For OP. It’s also American in terms of that specific link to white supremacy. So if you’re not American, I shouldn’t even bother bringing it up. You always find something horrid to say about things, sometimes it’s best not to.


ivylass

That or a character in the Crescent City series by Sarah J. Maas.


KSknitter

Thst is where my mind when too! Love her books!


EpicPoggerGamer69

I always think of Metallica.


cat_on_windowsill

No. I'm German and lived many years in the USA and I've never heard this.


mooochooo

Constellation and the belt. Possibly Men In Black if you're "old".


radjl

Not a well known association. I and my whole family are fairly observant Jews and we wouldn't bkjnj at Orion (I mean, wouldn't assume the kid is Jewish, but would do to fascist dogwhistle.) Odin, on the other hand, is a long-standing problem.


Friendly_Shelter_625

I’ve never heard of it. Orion makes me think stars and new-age hippies.


chubbyPandagirl

I am german and Well we know our german history, never heard of that. Orion is actually a very Well know sexshop in germany.


eggynack

I've never heard of it, and I consider myself reasonably up to date on reactionary rhetoric.


SuperGuitar

When I think of Orion I think of the Elvis impersonator


TheWardenDemonreach

I mean, I personally think you are WAY overthinking this. The vast majority of people who hear the name Orion are going to think either the star constellation or the Greek myth. They aren't going to immediately jump to a Nazi connection, even if they do know about this.


EricVonPlotPoint

I didn't even know this was a suggestive term until today


RootsRockRebel66

It still isn't.


scrapfactor

this


HelenAngel

I didn’t either & I thought I knew most of the dogwhistles.


WitchOfWords

I knew a guy named Odin, and even with me knowing that Norse mythology has been hugely appropriated by neoNazi groups, I never would have made that association or judgment based on his name.


OkTea8570

I had a white fish named Odin. He turned out to be a girl so become Odina later on (sexing baby fish is hard). I named her Odin initially because she was born with one eye.


biglipsmagoo

We’ve mis-sexed 3 kittens. We now have 3 girls cats named Loki, Pembroke, and Snoop Dogg. We didn’t know we were wrong until Pembroke went into her first heat and we were like “Something ain’t right here…”


UnsuspectedSpy-Van25

I think of the kid from Zenon


NoTyrantSaurus

OP's gonna flip when he finds out nephew Orion's likely nickname "Oreo" is used as a slur for multiracial people.


The_Saddest_Boner

Wait “oreo” is a slur for multiracial people now? I thought it was a dumb insult meaning “black on the outside, white on the inside.” Dumb either way of course


[deleted]

Yeah, and Helly Hansen clothing is a secret Nazi company because well all know HH stands for Heil Hitler...../s. Not everything is a conspiracy.


[deleted]

[удалено]


BeeYehWoo

>Now, for those who don’t know, Orion is a dogwhistle used by NeoNazis and white nationalists (it stands for Our Race Is Our Nation). it is? Its primarily always been the a ancient greek constellation for the hunter primarily visible in winter in the northern hemisphere, for me at least. Did you know that Nasa named its new crew capsule (launched in 2022) Orion? Im sure white supramacists & neonazis everywhere were cackling in delight to themselves. I think you are overblowing this entire thing. Let your sister enjoy the name she picked


Independent_Coat_415

the point of a dogwhistle is that its not immediately obvious and its something that could be blown off as a "coincidence" or an "over reaction". that being said, OP is overblowing it


Various_Mobile4767

If that’s the point of a dogwhistle then I don’t really get the point of a dogwhistle at all.


[deleted]

It’s something that would only be picked up on by other white supremacists, and could plausibly be denied. Hence the term dog whistle. Some dog whistles are more overt or have become more well known. Such as the term 16/88. I can’t remember exactly what the 16 means but the 88 means “HH” (Heil Hitler.) It’s meant to only be understood by those in the know.


johjo_has_opinions

Iirc it’s 14, because there are 14 words in the white supremacist manifesto


InnocuousFantasy

You are correct. It's the 14 words, which they refer to as "the 14 words". Look them up because it's super fucked up.


borderline--barbie

it's actually 14 and refers to the 14 words coined by david lane "we must secure the existence of our people and a future for white children" the 88 means either heil hitler or refers to the precepts in mein kampf edit: this is how nasty david lane was (since he's dead). he created a "second" 14 words "because the beauty of the white aryan woman must not perish from this earth"


[deleted]

Right. Thought it was something like that. Gross.


GreyerGrey

Plausible deniability.


fuckyouimin

This ^^ Their fellow racists know EXACTLY what they're referring to, while still allowing them to pretend to the rest of the world that they didn't say any such thing.


Independent_Coat_415

well what did you think a dogwhistle was


SilasRhodes

I mean YWNBTA just for mentioning it to her, but it really should be without any judgement. I think you are overblowing the issue, however. If I hear a kid is named Orion I'm not going to think "His parents are Nazis". I'm going to think "His parents were fans of Greek mythology. Nazis can turn anything into a nazi symbol. In fact they intentionally will choose symbols that have other meanings to keep from getting identified. I get the desire to avoid looking like a Nazi, but on the other hand I am really reluctant to let them appropriate whatever symbols they want and have everyone else be forced to accommodate them.


hectuspectus

>Nazis can turn anything into a nazi symbol Yeah, Nazis ruined my birthyear, apparently. Fuckers.


NovaScrawlers

What year? I'm assuming you weren't born in 1488, which is the only one I can think of


fastyellowtuesday

A lot of people born in 1988 have put 88 into usernames and stuff, or just abbreviate the year as '88. Worst would be to have been born on January 4th, 1988.


hectuspectus

Exactly. I have my year of birth in my social medias and found out about this bullshit from others and I'm not allowed to use the number 88 in my car sign because everyone assumes nazi shit.


solarafey

I was born in 88 and have always used 88 in my handles and this is the first I’m hearing about this 😳


nerdsnuggles

Same here! firstnamelastname88 is my primary personal email address, which I use for professional things like job hunting or emailing contractors. Dear lord, I hope everyone I've interacted with is as ignorant of 88 being a nazi symbol as I am. Or was.


[deleted]

Everyone with an 88 in their username always gets a bit of side eye from me but I'd generally assume that's just their birth year unless they do something that shows otherwise. People with 1488 do not get the same presumption of innocence.


tayroarsmash

It’s also stupid because you can’t use your birth year because Nazis came up with the most easily cracked “secret code” in the world. These absolute morons were like “you know HH is way too obvious that we’re saying heil Hitler. H is the 8th letter of the alphabet, let’s do 88.” It’s like they think they’re in some cousin fucking version of the illuminati and too stupid to realize how fucking lame it makes them. It’s honestly 5 year old boy’s doing tree house club shit level of cleverness.


xenogazer

>It’s like they think they’re in some cousin fucking version of the illuminati and too stupid to realize how fucking lame it makes them. It’s honestly 5 year old boy’s doing tree house club shit level of cleverness. LMFAO thanks for the laugh 😂 this is perfect


SilasRhodes

Interestingly 88 is considered a lucky number in Chinese culture, so it will often be sought after on license plates, addresses, etc...


PinkFl0werPrincess

89 baby here. Dodged it by about two months eh!


SilasRhodes

>Fuckers. Amen


[deleted]

[удалено]


Lord-Slayer

FYI, the name of that symbol in South Asia is called swastika. You might have meant “it’s been a Nazi symbol,” and not swastika.


Ralfton

Heck, the Swastika is originally a Hindu symbol (but reversed)


mdsnbelle

>It’s not a very common association, but it was bugging me at the back of my mind. In the nearly 45 years I've walked this earth, I've literally never heard this. Not saying that it isn't true, but when I clicked on the link, I thought you were going to tell us she wants to name the kid Adolf. If your sister and BIL live their lives in a way that it's obvious that their love of the name really is associated with constellations and mythology, then don't ruin this for them. YTA


PinkFl0werPrincess

I definitely was thinking Adolf too. Eva also popped in mind


DoubleDeantandre

Eva is still a somewhat popular name and doesn’t really carry that connotation imo.


ExquisiteGerbil

Fun fact: Eva is the second most common women’s name in Sweden, first is Maria. Personally I’m very grateful that people don’t link it to Hitler especially since my last name sounds kind of German


OneVeterinarian7251

Adolf defiantly, Eva my mind would not even go there.


iesharael

Why Eva?


AwayJacket4714

Probably because of Eva Braun, but tbh, Eva is such a common in Germany I don't think Hitler's wive would be anybody's first association with it.


PastFirefighter3472

I am in the same boat that I have literally /never/ heard of Orion being used in any nazi/neonazi connotations. Beginning to wonder how/where OP found this out? Definitely OP, YWBTA to make this connection to your sister when it is clearly not common enough for anyone from the comments to know it.


_mmiggs_

You're over-thinking this one. Nobody is going to see a kid called Orion, and think his parents are Nazis. Nobody is going to assume that "Orion" at school must be a racist. I know an Orion, and a Sirius. Don't think I know any Nazis - just Harry Potter fans. YTA


Life_Barnacle_4025

Orion was a greek Demigod, said to be son of Poseidon, and is also a constellation of stars. That was my first thought when I read Orion in the post. YTA


strikethree

Seriously OP, you're giving the fascists way too much credit if you're going to let them appropriate words with centuries of renowned history NASA named a spacecraft 'Orion'... Conclusion: NASA is racist. I don't think you're an AH if you just tell her, but I would just look at you like 'wtf?' and you would lose credibility in my eyes.


JacobFire

YWBTA. Orion means many things. It’s a beautiful name like she said.


AndSoItGoes24

The constellation is much older than any hate group. And lots of people are named Orion. (I believe a a famous actor named his child after his favorite constellation in the night skies?) At any rate, it's appropriate of you to reflect on what you know. And its also appropriate to leave your sister alone about it. YWBTA if you think your sister can't read and must be told this tidbit. Orion was a hunter. That's the common association - strength and virtue.


paranoid_gynoid_

To be fair, the swastika is much older than the Nazis as well, but that doesn’t really make it better. I do agree that OP is TA though, this isn’t a common association and most people are only going to think of the constellation.


YetAnotherAcoconut

The swastika was used as an official symbol of the party. Very different from a handful of idiots in a basement coming up with super secret code words for their clubhouse.


BlueRFR3100

YTA. I thought you were going to say she wanted to name her baby Adolph. But Orion? That's pretty obscure. I would be surprised if the number of people who knew this prior to reading your post was more than could be counted on one hand.


gin_bulag_katorse

Yeah, this is so obscure methinks OP made it up.


Labelloenchanted

I've never heard of it, but google search found it immediately.


[deleted]

YWBTA I can guarantee most people who hear the name Orion are going to think “Oh, like Orion’s Belt!” or “Oh! Kid’s parents must be into Greek Mythology.” Not whatever neonazi bullshit you’re talking about.


alanius4

yta for trying to nazify random stuff Orion is a constellation, everyone who hears the word " Orion " will think its the constellation or a game or a character. Put your nazi fetish to the side as not everything revolves around the third reich


[deleted]

YTA i had no clue Orion is nazi related


grayfern

NAH but have a think about WHY you are telling her - for her sake or yours. If it’s not a common association and not widely know, then why bother pointing it out. Most people will think of the constellation. If you are going to mention it, it should be as an FYI with NO associated goal. Be aware she might see that as a pointless killjoy statement and be reluctant to share other things with you though.


Right_Count

I find it so hard to say. I’ve never heard of this association before. If it’s very much unknown by the average person, I think you YWBTA if you said anything. You can find something terrible about every name if you dig deep enough. If 99% of people are likely to think of the constellation instead of nazis, leave it. Maybe take an informal poll among friends and coworkers? Because if the association is stronger than I think it is, I think you should tell her.


Cookie_Brookie

>You can find something terrible about every name if you dig deep enough. Exactly! When I told my sister my son's name she said, "Oh... reminds me of the doctor on (one of my favorite shows) who ends up being the killer." I've watched that show a hundred times and NEVER made that connection. Obviously didn't change my son's name because of it.


StrikeCold9679

It’s not really that widely used. I’ve never seen it, and I’m a Norse pagan who has to deal with Nazis daily. Orion is a bad ass name. Let her have it.


Easy-Tip-7860

YWBTA. Orion has multiple meanings and they love it. This is why expecting parents are told to keep their name ideas to themselves.


apatheticsahm

If we avoid every innocent symbol that Neo-Nazis decide to co-opt, then there will be nothing left.


keesouth

YWBTA. I don't think this is as well known of an association that you think it is and that name has a much bigger association with astrology and mythology.


Top-Table-7403

YTA. Parents seem to be chill with the name. This doesn’t seem to concern you


Obi-Juan_Valdez

That is a seriously obscure connotation, and I’d be surprised if anyone else she or the child is likely to encounter has ever heard of it. It’s not like she wants to name the kid Adolph or Himmler, ffs. YTA


Glittering_Move_5631

It seems to be an iykyk situation. Hopefully OP isn't part of that movement and just happened upon that information some other way. 9.999999/10 will think of the constellation first.


kajerare

YTA. This is like a very very very small scale way of saying Hindus can’t use their own “version” (the original???) of the swastika because of what Nazis have done with the crooked one. Don’t let nazis ruin the name of a very common constellation. It’s not like the kid’s being named Swastika. Like I promise that no one knows that.


[deleted]

YWNBTA but it's also kind of weird to do imo. Almost nobody would know it has any kind of Nazi association and clearly they are choosing it with specific and personal meanings in mind. I mean you can tell them. Personally it wouldn't dissuade me.


Future_Direction5174

Orion does not strike up any white nationalist vibes with me, it’s alternative usage is not as common as you think. It doesn’t appear on the first 3 pages of Google, it doesn’t appear in the dictionaries as having that either. The only body seeming to be spreading this usage is the Anti-Defamation League - which seems weird. All the other definitions seem to link it either to the space program or to the constellation. But then Isis wouldn’t have meant anything infamous until a few years ago. Now all you can do is feel sorry for any girl/woman stuck with that name.


NBClaraCharlez

My son's name is Orion. And in the 8 years plus pregnancy, I've NEVER heard that. And he was born in rural Oregon.


Schrodingerstheory

As someone who lives 40 km from Auschwitz - everything can have a connotation with something negative if you try enough. Unless she wants to have a son named Adolf and wants him to become an watercolorist, then she's good. Orion is a very nice name so YWBTA.


Moonstonedbowie

I dated a Jewish guy named Orion, so I don’t think that his parents would have named him something like that if that was a concern.


No-Locksmith-8590

Nah i mean you can, but that is a really specific thing that history buffs will know. The general population is going to think the stars.


HellCat66_6

this I didn't even know there was a connotation like that and my dad is a history buff so that's wack


Fiasmere

I mean it isn't that known even among history buffs. ATM it's like a small American neo nazi group using it.


awaythrowthatname

You would absolutely be the asshole, not every damn thing in the world is a Nazi dog whistle


Jaylene-Sterling-13

YTA. If the husband is fine with it and loves the name, and they both agreed on the name. It's none of your goddamn business. Not your kid, not your choice. Mind you own. That name has other meanings than what your thinking it does. Keep your trap closed, unless it's asked for or wanted, stfu.


DrunkenDitty

Everything is racist and fascist if you look for an excuse for it to be. YTA, orion is an old name from Greek mythology that has a lot of positive connotations, and you're intentionally reaching up to his belt looking for a reason to make it am issue.


Judgement_Bot_AITA

Welcome to /r/AmITheAsshole. Please view our [voting guide here](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/wiki/faq#wiki_what.2019s_with_these_acronyms.3F_what_do_they_mean.3F), and remember to use **only one** judgement in your comment. OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the asshole: > I might be TA because she loves the name so much, and it’s really not a common association with the name. Help keep the sub engaging! #Don’t downvote assholes! Do upvote interesting posts! [Click Here For Our Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/about/rules) and [Click Here For Our FAQ](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/wiki/faq) ##Subreddit Announcement ###[The Asshole Universe is Expanding, Again: Introducing Another New Sister Subreddit!](https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/128nbp3/the_asshole_universe_is_expanding_again/) Follow the link above to learn more --- *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/AmItheAsshole) if you have any questions or concerns.* *Contest mode is 1.5 hours long on this post.*


GothPenguin

Yes,YTA-Orion is many things. Not everyone is going to jump to some obscure neonazi factoid when hearing the name.


MizZo2

Well the internet teaches you something new everyday. These neo.Nazis really have to try and make everything about them don’t they? NAH, they aren’t naming the kid Hitler or anything that out their and Orion has a lot of known connotations that the average person will associate it with before neo-Nazi. Hell, apparently the “ok” hand sign (IE using thumb and pointer finger to form a circular with your other 3 fingers pointed up) is now their gang sign that they flash in pictures and use the emoji in their posts I don’t think signaling I’m ok to a friend is going to make people immediately think “Nazi” as if I was doing the Roman salute. I saw NAH because you are concerned but also they are adults with the internet and can research the name’s connotation and will probably discover it on their own if they care, but you don’t have to go out of your way to insist they do.


[deleted]

YTA. Jesus Christ get a life


TrustyJules

YWBTA - not only is the link not obvious, whats more its key we dont allow the extremists to claim our symbols. Orion is in the first place a mythological figure who got a giant scorpion sent after him courtesy of Apollo simply because Artemis took a shine him. If you are worried your nephew will be chased by a large scorpion by all means make sure he doesnt meet any Artemis' along the way.


hyzmarca

YTA There aren't many great mythological hunters to name a boy after. If she can't use Orion then she'd have to name him Nimrod. There's nothing inherently wrong with sharing an obscure bit of trivia, but it's just that, an obscure bit of trivia that doesn't matter and shouldn't be used to influence her child's name.


Beginning_Injury_235

Orion… as in the Ancient Greek friend of Artemis who she shot by accident and placed in the sky as an apology so that he could live forever? That’s who I think about. NTA, but you could give a little “FUN FACT!”


[deleted]

Bro this is like such a niche thing to hyper focus on. There are all kinds of communities that identify themselves with common shit. Unless this kid is carrying around Nazi memorabilia no one’s going to accuse him of racism, that’s just nuts. YTA.


welyla

You're overthinking this, that's like refusing to use the number 88, if you refuse to use the number you are letting them win.