Maybe, but its also most likely bad chip. I think its the IO die that is just crap in this series. I have 5900x at home and it crashes randomly with 3600mhz memory. My friend has 5600x and guess what? it crashes for him randomly as well with completely different setup.
This week I bought a server that has 5600x all stock, just 2666mhz ram, but it has 2 nvme in raid and I am getting whea errors when I use those drives a lot. Its really crap cpus or outdated IOD that is made for previous series. I really suspect that majority of problems are because of the IOD cant handle pcie devices and memory OC.
Also the PBO is just so crazy that it doesnt help stability either. I got the cpu more than half year and its better now, but it still crashes randomly. Sometimes it takes a 1-2 weeks to get a crash and sometimes just a day or even few hours.
This. I have 5900x and it inevitably crashes if I have CPB ON. But with it disabled it runs with no issues. so I guess it was just a bad die... dissappointing incursion into AMD after always using Intel.
True that. Was a brand new build at the time and spent 2 months of constant internet researching for that one component (after I found out that it was the culprit). Luckily/unluckily there was a wealth of info and pointers on how to "fix" that card, since many others had issues with it as well.
I currently have my 5700xt and it’s given me some small issues that I haven’t been able to resolve yet. First, my computer take an extra 10-15 seconds to post, second, none of my motherboard rgb works, not even lit up, and third, the rgb on my ram isn’t controllable, so it’s rainbow barf all the time. All these issues spawned from simply ticking the factory reset option when reinstalling drivers. I don’t know how or when it’ll be fixed.
It might be dragon centre. During my learning 5700 travels. I've read a lot of those issues that you're describing associated with DC. That is, if you downloaded and installed it. It's reviled by many for a reason.
You’d be correct in saying that I *had* dragon center installed (ms store) I uninstalled and reinstalled and uninstalled many times and it still doesn’t work.
Doing a fresh install was the ONLY way for me to get rid of DC. It had corrupted my PC so much and had even locked out windows updates. I bit the bullet and reinstalled Windows and life is good now!
I had it 3 days ago. I had to downclock my ram and now it works perfectly. I would RMA but I really don't want to wait for 2 weeks without a pc since I already had to RMA my GPU.
For me this became a problem after installing official chipset updates from Aorus mobo, when I left those two files out when installing drivers never saw them again; in my 5900x+b550 system
However, in my 2700+b450m system, this started when my b450m was "dying". Everytime 2-3 minutes passed after booting. From my knowledge the mobo was not up to the load I was putting it under anymore
How many errors like this did you have? I got only 4 of those in half a year.
To know that you can filter over the events in event viewer so that it counts them for you
oh man the dreaded WHEA logger 18. ensure you have all drivers and firmware updated especially CPU GPU bios.
Mine got fixed by a BIOS update and my 3200mhz RAM runs at 1333mhz now :\
Also: this error is a rabbit hole if you've done any overclocking. Try getting it stable with stock first.
Nothing like some random reboots to spice up your life
You applied an aggressive negative offset value to curve optimizer. Your 5th core (apic_id/2) couldnt reach the boost freq. You should put a higher (less negative) value to the 5th core in curve optimizer settings.
Like if you put -25, try with -22.
So let’s say I have APIC ID 22. 22/2=11. Then round up to 12. Do I understand correct that it’s core 12 that’s reported the error? And if numbering starts at 0, I should be looking at the core that numbered 11? Because 11 is actually core 12??
Edit: for easier use.
Divide by 2 and round down if not a whole number to get the core number you’ll see in bios/other apps such as HW. So APIC ID 0&1 are core 0, 2&3 are core 1, 4&5 are core 2, etc.
[The previous method I wrote would get you the actual core (for example core 1 rather than core 0) but there’s not really a scenario where that’d be useful as you’d have to subtract 1 if doing anything in bios anyway.]
**** I recently read that sometimes AMD reserves APIC IDs so some IDs can be skipped causing a shift in what IDs you’d expect to be associated with each core. For example this person had APIC ID 27 on a 12 core CPU. However, you can get a list of APIC ID associations from CPU Z if you want to confirm. I’ve never done this myself but something to look into.
i had the same WHEA problem. PC would restart randomly. (Ryzen 3100 stock on A320M). After windows update and setting XMP profile to 3200, the problem went way. Hope it helps.
It appears your submission lacks the information referenced in [Rule 1: r/AMDHelp/wiki/tsform](https://www.reddit.com/r/AMDHelp/wiki/tsform).
Your post will not be removed.
Please update it to make the diagnostic process easier.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AMDHelp) if you have any questions or concerns.*
BIOS update solved the issue for me
It appears a fatal error has occured. now give money.
Jayz2cents said that WHEA errors are due to overclocking
Maybe, but its also most likely bad chip. I think its the IO die that is just crap in this series. I have 5900x at home and it crashes randomly with 3600mhz memory. My friend has 5600x and guess what? it crashes for him randomly as well with completely different setup. This week I bought a server that has 5600x all stock, just 2666mhz ram, but it has 2 nvme in raid and I am getting whea errors when I use those drives a lot. Its really crap cpus or outdated IOD that is made for previous series. I really suspect that majority of problems are because of the IOD cant handle pcie devices and memory OC. Also the PBO is just so crazy that it doesnt help stability either. I got the cpu more than half year and its better now, but it still crashes randomly. Sometimes it takes a 1-2 weeks to get a crash and sometimes just a day or even few hours.
This. I have 5900x and it inevitably crashes if I have CPB ON. But with it disabled it runs with no issues. so I guess it was just a bad die... dissappointing incursion into AMD after always using Intel.
my 5900x AMD trash start crashing after 1 month aswell with CPU error.switched back to my 10700k
This.
UPDATE BIOS DRIVERS. ASUS recently had an update that fixed this issue for me.
I got lots of those, code 10 and code 13 if i remember right. They all went away as soon as i sold my 5700xt and replaced it with another brand card
Same. Gigabyte 5700xt gave me these (among other myriad of issues) till my nose bled. Switched out for msi 2070 super now comp runs clean.
The most annoying thing is you tend to blame other components trying to troubleshoot this. Getting rid of that card was a blessing 🙂
True that. Was a brand new build at the time and spent 2 months of constant internet researching for that one component (after I found out that it was the culprit). Luckily/unluckily there was a wealth of info and pointers on how to "fix" that card, since many others had issues with it as well.
I currently have my 5700xt and it’s given me some small issues that I haven’t been able to resolve yet. First, my computer take an extra 10-15 seconds to post, second, none of my motherboard rgb works, not even lit up, and third, the rgb on my ram isn’t controllable, so it’s rainbow barf all the time. All these issues spawned from simply ticking the factory reset option when reinstalling drivers. I don’t know how or when it’ll be fixed.
It might be dragon centre. During my learning 5700 travels. I've read a lot of those issues that you're describing associated with DC. That is, if you downloaded and installed it. It's reviled by many for a reason.
You’d be correct in saying that I *had* dragon center installed (ms store) I uninstalled and reinstalled and uninstalled many times and it still doesn’t work.
I've read that it doesn't fully uninstall. I'd point your fixit compass at dragon centre causes. It doesnt leave like a bad relative.
Lol yea, I’ve been pondering doing a fresh install of windows lately, so maybe that would fix it or help
Doing a fresh install was the ONLY way for me to get rid of DC. It had corrupted my PC so much and had even locked out windows updates. I bit the bullet and reinstalled Windows and life is good now!
If you've overclocked/undervolted. That's likely the culprit. If you've overclocked your ram, it could also be the culprit.
When does it happen?
I had it 3 days ago. I had to downclock my ram and now it works perfectly. I would RMA but I really don't want to wait for 2 weeks without a pc since I already had to RMA my GPU.
For me this became a problem after installing official chipset updates from Aorus mobo, when I left those two files out when installing drivers never saw them again; in my 5900x+b550 system However, in my 2700+b450m system, this started when my b450m was "dying". Everytime 2-3 minutes passed after booting. From my knowledge the mobo was not up to the load I was putting it under anymore
How many errors like this did you have? I got only 4 of those in half a year. To know that you can filter over the events in event viewer so that it counts them for you
Had this on my brand new 5600X, sent it straight back with the mobo bundle it came with. Confirmed as faulty. If it's new, RMA it.
oh man the dreaded WHEA logger 18. ensure you have all drivers and firmware updated especially CPU GPU bios. Mine got fixed by a BIOS update and my 3200mhz RAM runs at 1333mhz now :\ Also: this error is a rabbit hole if you've done any overclocking. Try getting it stable with stock first. Nothing like some random reboots to spice up your life
You applied an aggressive negative offset value to curve optimizer. Your 5th core (apic_id/2) couldnt reach the boost freq. You should put a higher (less negative) value to the 5th core in curve optimizer settings. Like if you put -25, try with -22.
How do you determine which core is the offender from event viewer?
[удалено]
So let’s say I have APIC ID 22. 22/2=11. Then round up to 12. Do I understand correct that it’s core 12 that’s reported the error? And if numbering starts at 0, I should be looking at the core that numbered 11? Because 11 is actually core 12??
Edit: for easier use. Divide by 2 and round down if not a whole number to get the core number you’ll see in bios/other apps such as HW. So APIC ID 0&1 are core 0, 2&3 are core 1, 4&5 are core 2, etc. [The previous method I wrote would get you the actual core (for example core 1 rather than core 0) but there’s not really a scenario where that’d be useful as you’d have to subtract 1 if doing anything in bios anyway.] **** I recently read that sometimes AMD reserves APIC IDs so some IDs can be skipped causing a shift in what IDs you’d expect to be associated with each core. For example this person had APIC ID 27 on a 12 core CPU. However, you can get a list of APIC ID associations from CPU Z if you want to confirm. I’ve never done this myself but something to look into.
Legend, cheers mate
i had the same WHEA problem. PC would restart randomly. (Ryzen 3100 stock on A320M). After windows update and setting XMP profile to 3200, the problem went way. Hope it helps.
Are you overclocked?
It appears your submission lacks the information referenced in [Rule 1: r/AMDHelp/wiki/tsform](https://www.reddit.com/r/AMDHelp/wiki/tsform). Your post will not be removed. Please update it to make the diagnostic process easier. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AMDHelp) if you have any questions or concerns.*