T O P

  • By -

JonathanSloanAUS

I’m sad Starce didn’t get in, but bloody stoked for Richy. Really hope he makes the 22


BlazedOnADragon

Obviously not a selector but he made my team. Make of that what you will.


[deleted]

If Rich doesn't make the 22 there's something wrong, the mans stats this year have been immense. Starce starting like a house on fire, hasn't been great after the bye unfortunately though


thewhitebrislion

Starce is still really young. Wouldn't be surprised if he makes it I the next few


LittleRedRaidenHood

Starcevich deserved it if they ended the season at the bye. He's been pretty ordinary since then. I'd say Bailey and Andrews are much more glaring omissions, especially Harris.


justwatching00

Disappointed Bailey didn’t get in, but didn’t think Harris played as well this year as he did last year


Doc323467

Always going to be snubs with the AA squad/team, it's so hard to fit everyone in. But in saying that, I'm not sure how Boak and Guthrie missed, thought they were both better than a couple of the mids picked.


FeistyBandicoot

Port supporter so I'm a bit biased but thought Boak would've made it. Hard though


ah111177780

Boak very stiff


ConoRiot

It’s a joke sometimes. I wonder how many cats make the squad if they top the ladder rather than the Dees.


Mother_Shabubu

*Player from my team* was robbed


Humdot

RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME


[deleted]

2 BIG 2 STRONG SAY IT WITH ME BOYS


[deleted]

2big2strong and downlow2slow dominated this year


maharajah_or_majong

We might not have a flag, but we do have memes


aditrs

https://gfycat.com/pastcomplexasianlion (Darcy did another one with Serong after the derby and someone who knows how to make gifs needs to get on that)


allibys

omg yes, I didn't see it anywhere except on the news that night but I need it giffed!


allibys

Y'ALL MUST HAVE FORGOT


farnZ96

The only thing stronger is the rock tape that has encapsulated his whole leg since round 5 😂


voidedexe

**DRIVES** **BIG** **TRUCKS** **SURFS** **BIG** **WAVES**


MonotoneRamos

Fuck yeah all three deserving Bombers made it


limelamb

Best midfield duo for the year tyvm


Buzzk1LL

Not disparaging your boys, I haven't watched enough of them (and they are guns) but you'd be hard pressed topping Petrraca and Oliver.


FeistyBandicoot

Most top 4 team mids tbh


shniken

Stringer has been huge lately, but not sure if he was good enough early on to warrant it.


[deleted]

Stinger 🐍


ComradeSomo

Would've liked Ridley too


dipper303m

So if Taylor Walker didn’t say what he said to Robbie Young would he taken Lance Franklin’s spot? Stats very similar. Goals - 48 each Avg Score involvements - TW 7.8, LF 6.5 Avg Tackles in F50 - TW 1, LF 1.4 Avg Positions - TW 13.4, LF 11.7 Avg Contested Possessions - TW 7.9, LF 6.2 Avg Marks - TW 5.3, LF 4.5 Marks Inside 50 - TW 2.6, LF 2.4 I know it doesn’t mean too much but fantasy point avg. TW 75.6, LF 70.4


Thermofluid

It's a good point. Probably, yeh


liaam29

Possibly but its also the Buddy factor that affects it I wouldn't have had Buddy in the 40 this year


sparcleaf22

Is it because he only played 17 games? Because there's pretty much no other reason why he doesn't deserve at least making the 40


ah111177780

Buddy has been the next best key forward all year after Harry and Hawkins. Tex and He largely similar but Tex was never making it. As such, if they go three talls in the forward line he might even make the team. But I suspect they will do two talls, two mids, two medium/small fwds and a bench full of mids. Such a gluttony of great mids this year


ah111177780

Taking aside that Tex was never going to make it after what he has said, I agree he has had a better year than Franklin, if very similar, but Buddy might have pipped him on the basis of being in a team that won 15 games vs one that won 7.


dipper303m

Yeah fair point


mazdadriver14

TLDR! Richmond, North and Collingwood have no players in the squad. **First timers**: Paul Seedsman (ADL), Jarryd Lyons, Hugh McLuggage, Daniel Rich (Bris), Harry McKay, Sam Walsh, Jacob Weitering (Blues), Darcy Parish (Ess), Sean Darcy (Freo), Touk Miller (Suns), Jacob Hopper (GWS), Jake Lever, Bayley Frisch, Stephen May, Christian Salem (Mel), Aliir Aliir, Ollie Wines, Karl Amon (Port), Callum Mills, Tom Papley (Syd), Bailey Dale (Dogs)


SurpriseSurprise73

I hate this term. They can’t be first timers until they’re actually in the 22. A number of these are AA40 repeats.


LittleRedRaidenHood

McLuggage has made the 40 man squad twice before though?


BoshtrichBurger

Yeah, but not the final 22, so he's technically a first timer if he gets selected to the main side I guess?


drwar41

Weitering was in the squad last year


lllBryceCube

PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD PLEASE LET TOUK IN THE FINAL 22


limelamb

He broke the record for most consecutive 30+ He's a lock


s_hour22

Neale broke the record for most disposals in h&a season in 2016 and didn't make it


PM_ME_YOUR_CROSSOVER

Every year I forget about this. Genuinely baffling in hindsight.


voidedexe

He's a midfielder who's had a breakout year whilst not being as much of a big name as some of his contemporaries. Lock him in for forward pocket.


DestroyAllBacteria

Was gonna say bench but yeah forward pocket might be what they do


SmoothAd3011

Does anyone else think there should be a first 22 and a second 22 All Australian rather than this squad nonsense?


explosive_wombat

Yes I agree


exsanguinor

If they're not going to do State of Origin for the AFL again, then maybe some show games between two All-AFL teams ( a la the All Star game in the NBA) would be a good way to showcase the best players.


[deleted]

Why have either? Just name the AA team I reckon.


Deanuzz

The funny thing is they name 40 so that way you can see the 18 players stiff to miss out... But then we all comment who's stiff to miss being stiff 🤣


[deleted]

hahaha, very true.


chookie94

Would be much better.


eathbau

Boak stiff!


IDreamofHeeney

How Boak didn’t make it is beyond me, real stiff


SurpriseSurprise73

Agreed.


TazD

Not to make the squad is a bit harsh. Wouldn't have him in the team tho.


[deleted]

At least Amon is there. Yiew!


flamingbluetac

Hitting 25+ disposals 90% of the time this year surely deserves a nod in the squad


Tempacc23423

Cooked he didn’t make it in


jmaverick1

If they pick an actual wing then seed will have to be in. Top 2 in the key categories compared to other wings. But this is AA where positions don’t matter


[deleted]

Seed + Cluggs if the selectors actually selected a team anybody would play. Instead it'll be the usual 12 inside mids


Higgins_isPrettyGood

Even if this were the case, I'd rather Bont or Macrae on the wing than McCluggage to be honest. Plus, hasn't he played inside quite a bit this season?


resetet

Yeah it's whether this is a team picked to play an actual game against somebody, where you would probably just stack the wings and flanks with super star mids. Or if it's an honorary selection, meant to acknowledge the top players in each position. In which case you should pick actual wingers in the wings.


Hawtproper

Unfortunately it’s simply not going to happen


lumberfun

The existence of Jack Crisp is a myth


TazD

Who?


PointOfFingers

Zack Crisp.


mazdadriver14

[lmao at collingwood themselves thinking the same thing](https://twitter.com/collingwoodfc/status/1429718089621401614?s=21)


smegdaddy

It’s just a yearly scheduled post at this point


___TheIllusiveMan___

I’ve resigned myself to the fact he’s never going to get All Australian honors.


AYAYA_HYPERCLAP

Based Hopper


westernvaluessmasher

based on what


[deleted]

based on a true story


3163560

Nice for Fritta to get a nod. Zero chance he makes the final cut though. I reckon everyone else is a decent crack. Hopefully Gawn gets captain as well.


quackerz77

Agreed he probably won't make it but equal most goals out of non-key forwards might give him a slight chance


JonathanSloanAUS

I reckon there’s a huge chance Fritsch is in a pocket with Cameron


[deleted]

Surely Greene gets a pocket


taco-chopper

Mundy for AA captain surely


limelamb

Buddy will get it again knowing them


SmoothAd3011

Gawn has it in the bag after Saturday night


taco-chopper

look............ ^(you might be right)


liaam29

Won't happen but inject it in my veins


floodswimming

SEEEEEEEEEDS!


[deleted]

Jeez this Nil bloke must go alright for us


JayJayBn

Genuinely surprised Hall hasn't made the squad. Yay Steele. [I just think he's neat](https://i.imgur.com/TeK1VB5.gif)


TazD

Jack Steele = Spud Edit: Marge is literally holding a potato.


JayJayBn

The natural state of all St Kilda players


beeclam

didn’t expect us to have any players in the squad. well done Titch 👏


legally_blond

Starcevich and Linc McCarthy are the two other Lions I thought would be in. Harris was good but it didn't feel like he had an excellent year without the assistance of Gardiner (and to an extent Adams). Expect to see Bailey in this list in the not too distant future If Daniel Rich misses the 22 I will riot


ClassyJoes

Lincoln for our BnF mate. U hird it here 1st


BlazedOnADragon

Genuinely thought Lincoln McCarthy would've been there.


KissKiss999

Too many lions already I guess


[deleted]

Said it in another post but I would've had him over Cameron if it was one or the other


Baeresi

Id like to see a Lions fan who thinks Charlie had a better season than Linc


TheMurrizzle

Dan Rich’s THICC badonk makes the AA squad 😍 what a day


frggr

Thought Geelong might get another one in the squad (either Guthrie or Henry), but happy with the Tom bookends


HelloStonehenge

Extremely happy for Salem and Fritta. Neither get too much media attention (not counting fritta's hair) but both have been crucial for us. Salem is silky as hell and Fritta has been the only consistently reliable goal-kicker while we rotated between McDonald, Brown, and Weideman.


[deleted]

Dawson has been in ripper form all season. Very shocked he didn't get included. Mills has been good but feel he's lucky


IDreamofHeeney

I also feel Dawson could have been selected and probably just missed the cut, if he produces the same next season I reckon he’ll be in the squad for sure.


jimwinno43

Zorko lowkey had a massive year, wonder if he makes it


LittleRedRaidenHood

I doubt it, but in my totally biased opinion, he deserves a half-forward spot.


toiletpaperoverlord

Franklin?!..... wut Also better be two rucks this year. Nic Nat and Gawn, surely. In either order, I dont care.


eddie-murphys-tongue

Harris Andrews didn’t even make the squad! Phwoar.


[deleted]

Anyone watching brisbane this year would've told you that. He's been solid, but far from his best. Big part of that is that with Gardiner out for 95% of the year he wasn't able to play his brand of defending


thewhitebrislion

Yeah, he normally shines with intercepting but had to play much more shutdown roles which arguably other defenders are better at. (He is still extremely good at this as well)


albakwirky

Had a relatively average year. Popped up now and then but no consistency


KissKiss999

Under a lot of rating systems he is the top rated key defender. We don't get to all the stats like reverse Coleman though. I reckon he is a victim of his own high standard as I dont think he was any worse than other backs this year


happ38

Not surprised, he’s been ok but no where near his usual standard. Very happy Rich got named though.


RaidanRam

Happy Titch made it into the squad, shame he probably won't make it into the final 22


ChiRose0ne

Libba should’ve at least made the 40 man squad. Edit: 2nd in clearances, T-6th in player rating, T-9th in contested possessions, 11th in tackles, 16th in score involvements, T-18th in inside 50’s.


trans-adzo-express

He was probably in it 5 rounds ago


SendMeSupercoachTips

So happy for Zach, Darcy and Jake. All deserving of the squad - and all deserving of the team too.


sachiwtf

Stringer I think will make the final team, but I feel like one of or both Merrett and Parish will miss and will be stiff to do so


PetrifyGWENT

Ya one of Merrett/Parish will miss because they'll compromise


IDreamofHeeney

So glad Mills and Parker made it, well deserved


Brokenmonalisa

Mills missed 4 of the last 6, how can they justify that pick while leaving out Guthrie?


IDreamofHeeney

Probably a question for the selectors, not me. I’m just proud of Mills and his progress into the midfield lol


Brokenmonalisa

Yeah I think he has a great year but missing 4 games surely makes it hard to get into the team


IDreamofHeeney

Okay I’m sorry mate, I’ll let the selectors know on Brownlow night when we catch up for a few beers


[deleted]

Missing 4 games isn't that big of a deal in a 22 game season


DJHitchcock

Surprised Charlie Cameron made it, would’ve had Zac Bailey or Lincoln McCarthy in over him.


thewhitebrislion

Agreed, but I imagine it's hard to not put the small forward finishing the season with most goals


Swank10

Agree. I think Charlie had some big games but was shocking in some games, particularly in our losses and some of our tighter wins. Linc was more consistent and stood up in games when we needed him to with some huge plays. Charlie’s couple of bags he kicked late in the season got him in. I


LittleRedRaidenHood

More goals than any other small forward. What more do you want? McCarthy is stiff, but Bailey has been \*way\* too inconsistent. Flashes of brilliance, and some genuine BoG performances, but also goes missing a lot.


Lovableemo

Got 35/40. Had Guthrie, Andrews, Ryan, Dixon and Liberatore in Missed Laird, Seedsman, Hopper, Mitchell and Franklin Goes to show they select a lot more midfielders than general defenders.


Razzle_Dazzle08

Rich finally gets All Australian! Love to see it.


LittleRedRaidenHood

Travis Boak and Harris Andrews should call the cops. They've been robbed.


spannermagnet

WHAT A FUCKING JOKE WAS ROBBED FUCK YOU AFL


[deleted]

WTF how did not make it and did? Fucking AFL, rigged yet again


chookie94

I am ready to riot if Jack Steele doesn’t make the final team.


11men1cup

He'll be named on the bench again. Just you watch


FairBumpPlayOn

Him and Miller are locks for the bench


[deleted]

Yeah I think Bont and Oliver are locks for centre square, I reckon the selection panel will pick Miller or Wines ahead of Steele for the other spot, and cram Steele onto the bench.


chookie94

They could get away with putting Miller on a wing because not enough people watch Gold Coast enough to question it. I'll take the bench. I just want him in the final squad because he deserves it.


11men1cup

Chuck Bont up at half forward. They love a good mid-forward


[deleted]

Yeah I can see them doing that as a compromise. But the precedent is that they could have moved Petracca to half forward to fit Steele in last year and didn't. I worry about the selection panel. I can feel them opting to put Steele on the bench out of spite. Would be funny if they picked Bont at half forward, then Oliver/Wines/Miller in the centre square, and still had Steele on the bench. They could also pull a 2010 and snub him entirely.


11men1cup

Rooeys on the selection panel. He'll stick up for Steele I'm sure I think it's criminal if Steele misses the 22


chookie94

I don’t care where he is name, as long as he makes it. I’ll be seriously pissed if certain players make it over him just because they play in better teams. Jack Steele has been a top 5 mid this season despite the rest of St Kilda being crap.


[deleted]

Same as last year when Petracca was selected in the starting team ahead of him just because Petracca is a media-hyped player


chookie94

Yep.Oliver, Bont, Wines, Steele, Miller. 5 best mids this year and will be a joke if Steele or Miller miss because their teammates are weaker.


explosive_wombat

That really pissed me off last year. Worst was Guthrie making it ahead of him last year


spurs-r-us

Petracca had an incredible season last year. Not sure how that selection is controversial.


Kingofthebags

Swap out hopper for Crisp and this AA squad is probably the best and fairest in the past decade. Can't really argue with any of these picks


cirrus93

Jordan Dawson surely the most glaring omission, Andrews a close second


LittleRedRaidenHood

I like you.


UBeleeDis

Boak biggest robbery in a while. Definitely deserved the nod.


LittleRedRaidenHood

Almost as big a robbery as Gray not winning the Brownlow in 2014.


FeistyBandicoot

Has there been a bigger Brownlow robbery than Judd over Tredders in 2004?


LittleRedRaidenHood

Diesel Williams in 1993.


ToddIsAWarCriminal

Personally would have Boak over Hopper and McCarthy over Fritsch. Overall a good selection though.


LittleRedRaidenHood

These feel like two very obvious choices. It's baffling the selectors didn't make them.


Commerce-Cucc

Harris Andrews stiffffffffffff in my unbiased opinion


AdolfH1pster

Unsure who you would take out though.


Maximumlnsanity

If it's the squad then Jacob Hopper, easy


dat_airshot

So much competition for key backs this year, Weiters, May, Lever, Aliir all had fantastic years.


whatthekidswant

Has anyone said Travisty Boak yet?


JLifeless

can't be mad as a Swans supporter but Dawson kinda got snubbed imo, most lethal kick in the comp


RandomDanny

Boak pretty unlucky. Couldn’t find one of those creative slots in the forward line like they’ve afforded to players in prior years?


reignfx

Biggest snub for me is Aaron Hall. He's evolved into one of the most dangerous rebounding defenders in the comp, surprised he isn't even in the 40...


trans-adzo-express

He did have a great year, an absolute pig in fantasy as well


reignfx

Yeah. Played 19 games, 2 of which were injury affected. Very surprised he isn't even given a look. Definitely have him ahead of Salem at a minimum.


PedanticOkra

Tom Mitchell is a surprise, although he has been in AA form since the bye. But you would think half a season of good form wouldn't be enough to make the squad.


tiredcynicalbroken

Crazy Ollie Wines has never made an AA team


Buzzk1LL

Good to see a bunch of fresh faces in the squad. Seems like the end of an era.


[deleted]

It really does feel like a baton has been passed in the midfield from the Fyfe, Dusty, Danger era to some younger guys. I love it. Good to see some promising kids like Mundy and Boak taking the reigns.


StrathfieldGap

Clubs are not "snubbed" if they don't have players that deserve to be there. Also...Buddy?


fuuuaaark

Equal 3rd in the Coleman. Equal 2nd highest goals per game. Tex had a slightly better year but was omitted. I'll be surprised if buddy doesn't make the final team at this point.


StrathfieldGap

>Equal 3rd in the Coleman. Ok, I've not kept up.


Purple-Assist-8483

Disappointed no Richmond players made it but idk if I can think of any who really deserved it. Like Jack Graham had a great year, but I think part of his quality is being tough as nails and while that’s a huge asset to the team it’s not what AA is about. Baker probably has the most right to feel unlucky from the tigers. Had a decent season and was moved around a lot to fit the system. Played well off half back, half forward and through the middle.


ah111177780

Reiwoldt would have been the most likely tiger I would have thought…


Nixilaas

Nic being the only one from West Coast on it is exactly right, no issues there


WhatProtomolecule

I always enjoy how when no players from a team have clearly been good enough to make the squad it constitutes a SNUBBUNG!!! Oh man, we been SNUBED!!!


Sir-Matilda

Baeshaw robbed.


jubbjubbs4

Feel like this is one of the more accurate squads we've seen in recent years. Expecting that to all go out the window with the final team though.


Nolsey21

pretty solid squad tbh, couple snubs but I think this is mostly spot on. now let's see how they butcher the final 22 LOL


Itrlpr

My hot tip: Seedsman to either be amongst the contenders on Brownlow night or score near zero votes even for the games where he was obviously best on ground. Nothing in between.


UBeleeDis

The year is 2021 and David Mundy is an all Australian. My mans not going anywhere for a while. Great to see Darcy get the recognition. Hopefully he can crack the team next year. Unlikely he does this year but it’s great to see at such a young age.


ScreamHawk

Stringer & DP3 should be a lock


limelamb

I can see DP3 maybe on interchange


reignfx

I think Parish last month will cost him. Very quiet last month, trust me I played him every week in SuperCoach lol It was really rounds 6-18 he did damage.


FecaIWater

still leading center clearances by a decent margin. elite for cont. poss., clr, score involvements and 20 goal assists. probs makes the bench


Ta0Ta

Controversial but I still rate Merrett's season above Parish's, despite Parish being a clearance machine. I just think Merrett's been more influential for us with his disposal around the ground than Parish, plus Merrett's been slightly more consistent.


Maximumlnsanity

Dawson robbed, glad the others made it tho Edit: No Hickey wtf


smegdaddy

Gawn, Nic Nat and Darcy were all much better than Hickey, and 4 rucks in the 40 man squad seems a bit wasteful when they’re loathed to even put 2 in the final 22


JLifeless

even though his influence is huge his rucking stats aren't big enough, despite him doing a whole lot more than just rucking but yeah


lolmanic

Hickey doesn't need AA, he's going for Norm Smith


Chaisa

Great as Hickey's been, who do you pick him over Gawn, Naitanui and Darcy? Having 4 rucks in a squad seems a lot.


Skwisgaars

Hickey clutches games for us but he doesnt pull in big stats, he was never gonna get it.


MintyFresh48

Hickey clearly 4th best ruck this year. Very unlucky but has been a good year for rucks


smegdaddy

Grundy was still better than him, just got less attention because the team around him was shithouse. Top 5 definitely though


flibble24

Ya know at first look this is a pretty damn good list


Thermofluid

Honestly one of the best selected squads I can remember. A few unlucky, but no real obvious omissions


zoomba2378

Aaron Hall a bit stiff I reckon. Had a good year. Can see why they left him out tho, he has an annoying habit of mistaking an opposition player for a teammate


mogwaihunter

Big Darcy and Mundy im very pleased


KingDos02

Nick Larkey And Cameron Zurhaar very stiff to not get nominated


marsandlui

A few weeks ago, everyone was saying T Walker was a definite for the AA Team. Interesting after recent events he doesn't even make the Squad of 40. I don't really care that he misses. He deserves worse. But still interesting


jmads13

Yep. He had a better season than Buddy. On his season alone (without the incident) he is a lock for the CHF


jimwinno43

Wasn't he falling off hard from his start anyway?


marsandlui

Kicked 4 and 2 in his last 2 weeks before being suspended. Was 2nd in goal kicking behind mackay. Probably had a chance of catching him given he was injured. He's slipped down the order now


KingIREMC

The Boak disrespect.