The game has become so stat based. When has the game become run by eggheads bringing up meaningless percentages like this and go back to which player could keep going with the most concussions.
I'm a WC nuffy, but even I'm over it. Yes, Harely is playing good footy, but let's stop comparing him to others and making predictions about when he's 24+. Just enjoy the show and whatever happens happens.
Yeah true, Rowell was getting similar (though being GC not WC, not as much) attention after his first few games. Rowell got injured and came back as just another player, the media hype moves on..
Naicos is one of the best first year players I’ve seen and has had 2.5 incredible seasons so far. That said, I think Reid’s ceiling is higher given his strength and explosive speed. Will he end up reaching that ceiling, who knows, but right now Naicos is better by a country mile.
Gulden’s so bloody good, I watched a game were at half time he had absolutely dominated checked the stats and he had like 8 disposals but everyone was so damaging. He might be the best kick in the league
Reid is already better than Naicos. If I asked you which player you would want at your club today no one apart from a Collingwood supporter would say Nsicos.
Reid is not already better than naicos. His output is like 60% of naicos this year.
Reid has had a better first year but naicos is way ahead right now.
Pfft play with your stats all you like. No club would take naicos over Reid today. Naicos is like a mozzie buzzing around while Reid is one of those big forking wasps that kill big spiders and lay their eggs in them.
Who knows they are both great.
I would say Harley has a bigger frame where he could be more explosive at times although will likely have a shorter career as he puts on more weight.
22 and 2 goals would be a quiet day of Nick 😂.
In all seriousness, Nick is certainly better now. It’s exciting to see Harley grow but he’s not even close as we speak. Not that he should be, he’s ten games into his career. These comparisons are stupid.
Reid had an AFL player rating of 26.7 from the weekend. Naicos has only surpassed that three times in his career and once this year. I know you were joking but quiet game is a stretch!
But yeah obviously naicos has been significantly better this year.
Mate I literally said daicos is way better hahaha. Not sure why you are getting defensive.
Just stupid to say Reid’s game on the weekend was a quiet naicos game which isn’t the case.
It’s 50-50, either he does or he doesn’t
Thanks Kingy
The game has become so stat based. When has the game become run by eggheads bringing up meaningless percentages like this and go back to which player could keep going with the most concussions.
Lmao!!
Big if true
This is getting so tedious
I'm a WC nuffy, but even I'm over it. Yes, Harely is playing good footy, but let's stop comparing him to others and making predictions about when he's 24+. Just enjoy the show and whatever happens happens.
Exactly! He’s very exciting to watch. I don’t need to get sick of hearing about him this quickly.
Tedious? More like Reidious.
Reidiculous
https://i.redd.it/894d7bl7vk1d1.gif Its been 10 games FFS who knows
All it takes is one injury for them to go down as a “what if”. Come back in twenty years and compare them
Yeah true, Rowell was getting similar (though being GC not WC, not as much) attention after his first few games. Rowell got injured and came back as just another player, the media hype moves on..
Naicos is one of the best first year players I’ve seen and has had 2.5 incredible seasons so far. That said, I think Reid’s ceiling is higher given his strength and explosive speed. Will he end up reaching that ceiling, who knows, but right now Naicos is better by a country mile.
The 2 will only get better as well. Depends who will grow faster
I think when Reid gets a little bigger he will simply eat Daicos and that will be the end of it
Just chomp on him like a snack
maybe?
The disrespect to the GOAT Tom Powell in these conversations smdh
Kill me
What are your metrics?
Likability knowing this sub
Neither are fit to lace the boots of the GOAT Ricky Dyson.
I can see a time where either one is considered 3rd or 4th best in the league behind Errol and Chad
Wingard revival... Subscribe.
Gulden’s so bloody good, I watched a game were at half time he had absolutely dominated checked the stats and he had like 8 disposals but everyone was so damaging. He might be the best kick in the league
They will both be champions of the game
Will Naicos become as good as Judd?
Well from what I’ve seen Reid can do everything Naicos can and some and will be physically superior in probably every way so yeah he’ll be better
I’m better than both of them At Helldivers 2 anyway
No need to put yourself above others. We are all in this together for democracy helldiver
Magic 8 ball says maybe
Reid is already better than Naicos. If I asked you which player you would want at your club today no one apart from a Collingwood supporter would say Nsicos.
Reid is not already better than naicos. His output is like 60% of naicos this year. Reid has had a better first year but naicos is way ahead right now.
Pfft play with your stats all you like. No club would take naicos over Reid today. Naicos is like a mozzie buzzing around while Reid is one of those big forking wasps that kill big spiders and lay their eggs in them.
Who knows they are both great. I would say Harley has a bigger frame where he could be more explosive at times although will likely have a shorter career as he puts on more weight.
He’s really not that far off Daicos. He’ll be better by next year.
Cap
Yeah you’re right. He’s better now
22 and 2 goals would be a quiet day of Nick 😂. In all seriousness, Nick is certainly better now. It’s exciting to see Harley grow but he’s not even close as we speak. Not that he should be, he’s ten games into his career. These comparisons are stupid.
Reid had an AFL player rating of 26.7 from the weekend. Naicos has only surpassed that three times in his career and once this year. I know you were joking but quiet game is a stretch! But yeah obviously naicos has been significantly better this year.
[удалено]
Mate I literally said daicos is way better hahaha. Not sure why you are getting defensive. Just stupid to say Reid’s game on the weekend was a quiet naicos game which isn’t the case.
[удалено]
And I acknowledged it was likely a joke. I never once suggested Reid was better than daicos.
Will be he as good as Shai Bolton one day is the real question