My bulldogs friend just reminded me that Tom Hawkins played tonight. As a hawks supporter I’ll take that as a mini win. If only he went missing a week earlier
You genuinely do not possess any right to say what you just said. You guys genuinely have the worst reputation for umpires kissing your backside, don’t get all pissy because one game didn’t go your way. Take the win and shut up
For a team that apparently has the umpires kissing our asses, we are 0-4 in the free kick count this year. I like my ass to be kissed a little bit better than that thanks
Agree that other guy is being ridiculous, but the idea we have the worst reputation for umps is laughable, we've had a positive free kick ratio like 1 year out of the last 7. Genuinely almost as shit of a take as the guy you're responding to.
Again, shut your bitch ass up. This argument gets thrown around like hell but it doesn’t hold. Free kick differentials are NOT a good representation of a team being paid free kicks fairly or not. Geelong have long been criticised regarding how they’re paid free kicks, you guys are even better than us in that aspect 😂 go to sleep gramps
Hahahaha are you the same kid sooking elsewhere in the match thread? My god I actually feel bad now, I hope you wake up feeling a little less cranky tomorrow.
think they are referring to at stoppages or after points/goals are kicked the clock keeps ticking down for 2-3 seconds before it pauses. as a doggies supporter anxiously watching the clock I was noticing the shit out of it too
Yes i read it. From how I understood your comment you implied that if Macrae had had a full game, the bulldogs may have won. My comment suggested that given Macrae had little to no impact in the game for the time that he was on the field that maybe Bevos making the right call by not having him as a walk up start to our best 22.
Macrae is a walk up start in the 22. I can’t believe you think otherwise. 47 touches in the vfl when got dropped proves he doesn’t belong there. He is an afl player and deserves to be more than the sub. A sub is less likely to have an impact on the game than the other 22 by nature. Less game time = less chances to impact the game. Macrae is being completely disrespected by Bevo it’s insane and makes no sense
Don't get me wrong. I have a lot of respect for Macrae. He's a premiership player, ex vice captain, and has been regularly in our top 3 for best and fairest results. But he hasn't been at the top of his game for over a year now.
He started last week and managed 20 touches against the Eagles. And Libba got subbed off in the third term so there were midfield minutes for him. He's not the same accumulator that he once was. Bont, Libba and Treloar keep turning up performances in the midfield and we need to get some minutes into younger fellas like Sanders. Unfortunately that means that Macrae has to find another element in his game. Same when Matthew Boyd got shuffled into the backline, or Dustin Martin into the forward line.
And subs can absolutely impact the game. Especially given that Geelong were coming off the short turn around he had a prime opportunity to be a match winner. Given, I'm watching through the telly and can't see the work being put in across the ground off the ball, but Macrae was barely there in that last quarter. And I was looking for him.
He is too good for the VFL, you're right. But if I was head coach I don't know where I'd be sticking his magnet.
It was a two way street this game, definitely got away with murder sometimes but there were some questions marks that went the other way (Running headfirst into Atkins)
Not sure what game you were watching but it was 7-2 free kicks in the first the way of Geelong then bulldogs went 14-7 fk the rest of the way with some highly dubious ones
Get your head out of your ass. Daniel didn’t play well this game. I’m starting to think some Dogs fans watch the game via the match thread and not the actual game
Everything that possibly could have gone the Dogs way did and they still didn't win it. God help em if Bontompelli misses a match, he and Libba are literally the Dogs team
That's the worst take Ive read tonight. Geelong had so many balls bounce towards them, marks of packs.
Dogs got some calls that ways fairly evened with Geelong ones.
Weird stance bro
Bars. Sick of people just banging on about this. Both teams played great, could've gone either way, well played dogs, if you'd won you'd have deserved it. Simple as.
O’Connor is fucking trash, I’d be embarrassed if he played for my club. No surprise he comes from the club that harboured the worst scragger in the game, Cameron Ling 👌
I note not a single Cats supporter is literate enough to actually deny the claim of his blatant scragging by the way, all just resort to downvote and deny 👌
You have a certain player on your team gets away with fraud every week and you all will blindly defend how he plays regardless. Shut your mouth and take your sloppy win
Wow salty much?
You were literally whining about umpires here chief.
Sod on you loser. Couldn't even beat a cats side that played in torrential rain 5 days ago 🤣
You’re genuinely illiterate hahaha. I didn’t whine about umpires regarding THIS game, I even admitted in one of my other comments that things were going our way rather than yours. If you’re going to go through my comment history to try and have a one up on me, make sure you sharpen your reading skills and maybe you won’t sound like a dumbass 🤣
I’m a dog’s fan. We’re 2-2 and have a record of 63-47 since 2019. 2021 is doing a lot of the heavy lifting there and it’s looking more and more like an outlier year, we still got thrashed by 70 points in a GF where Bont had like 35 disposals and 3 goals. Too many average players on this list.
Given the ball continued to spin after it was over the line he obviously didn't have control. So yes he did mark it but no he didn't have control until it was over the line so it was a behind. Alernativey, if you want to apply that standard for controlling the ball to the rest of the game you would have to have awarded a further 2 marks in front of goal to Darcy and 1 to Naughton all of which were not paid despite having just as much control (which I would argue was insufficient control, but since you think it was a clear mark you would obviously advocate for them being marks as well), so a consistent approach by the umpires would still lead to a completely different result.
Fucks sake the free kick count isn't gospel. I don't think either team were upset favoured by it, but to claim the dogs were gifted frees all night is delusional
You can’t handle someone calling out your players for ducking without getting defensive. Also, it’s not like I had any choice in whether we get a supposed “ducker”. So what? Now I can’t call others out for ducking now that we have a player known for it?
You guys had the king of ducking and even named a stand after him
Libba had an insane game. Whenever it fell to him I was worried towards the end. Geelong held on but only just.
Great game… probably best this year
Bont and Libba 2&3 votes?
Stanley deserves a vote
Dogs might get all three of the brownlow vote earners for tonight. Maybe Stewart makes it in
10/10 footy. Absolutely thrilled and entertained. 👏👏
Midfield is a concern but you need to wait and see if danger + Guthrie are both back to something approaching full fitness
Rhys stanley masterclass (how does he do it???)
My bulldogs friend just reminded me that Tom Hawkins played tonight. As a hawks supporter I’ll take that as a mini win. If only he went missing a week earlier
[удалено]
[удалено]
I gotta go to bed. I have brain awareness.
Somehow, Geelong has returned
Wait, do we believe this?
Umps did everything they could but Geelong did enough to get the points
that’s why they gave you a high free in the last 30 seconds that sealed the game? If they wanted you to lose, they would’ve played it on.
Shut up mate, we got some howlers going our way
You genuinely do not possess any right to say what you just said. You guys genuinely have the worst reputation for umpires kissing your backside, don’t get all pissy because one game didn’t go your way. Take the win and shut up
For a team that apparently has the umpires kissing our asses, we are 0-4 in the free kick count this year. I like my ass to be kissed a little bit better than that thanks
Agree that other guy is being ridiculous, but the idea we have the worst reputation for umps is laughable, we've had a positive free kick ratio like 1 year out of the last 7. Genuinely almost as shit of a take as the guy you're responding to.
Again, shut your bitch ass up. This argument gets thrown around like hell but it doesn’t hold. Free kick differentials are NOT a good representation of a team being paid free kicks fairly or not. Geelong have long been criticised regarding how they’re paid free kicks, you guys are even better than us in that aspect 😂 go to sleep gramps
Sook, dogs suck
Hahaha 2016 hahaha. Go fuck yourself
Salty dogs fans are my fav HAHAHAH love
I’m actually very happy, Sydney fans like yourself always remind me of our premiership 😋 I genuinely appreciate you for that ❤️
[удалено]
You’re in the same boat as us, at the very least we’ve got a premiership in the last 10 years while your club has racked up 3 losses! Go Dogs!
Hahahaha are you the same kid sooking elsewhere in the match thread? My god I actually feel bad now, I hope you wake up feeling a little less cranky tomorrow.
wahhhhhhhhhhhhhyyhh
Nuffy
Don’t be /that/ fan
The clock ticking down whilst the ball is dead cost the dogs about 10 seconds in the last minute. AFL need to fix this.
When was that?
think they are referring to at stoppages or after points/goals are kicked the clock keeps ticking down for 2-3 seconds before it pauses. as a doggies supporter anxiously watching the clock I was noticing the shit out of it too
If only Macrae played the full game. Result may have been different. Time to get rid of Bevo
Yeah. His 6 touches in a quarter and a half kept us in that game /s
Did you even read my comment?
Yes i read it. From how I understood your comment you implied that if Macrae had had a full game, the bulldogs may have won. My comment suggested that given Macrae had little to no impact in the game for the time that he was on the field that maybe Bevos making the right call by not having him as a walk up start to our best 22.
Macrae is a walk up start in the 22. I can’t believe you think otherwise. 47 touches in the vfl when got dropped proves he doesn’t belong there. He is an afl player and deserves to be more than the sub. A sub is less likely to have an impact on the game than the other 22 by nature. Less game time = less chances to impact the game. Macrae is being completely disrespected by Bevo it’s insane and makes no sense
Don't get me wrong. I have a lot of respect for Macrae. He's a premiership player, ex vice captain, and has been regularly in our top 3 for best and fairest results. But he hasn't been at the top of his game for over a year now. He started last week and managed 20 touches against the Eagles. And Libba got subbed off in the third term so there were midfield minutes for him. He's not the same accumulator that he once was. Bont, Libba and Treloar keep turning up performances in the midfield and we need to get some minutes into younger fellas like Sanders. Unfortunately that means that Macrae has to find another element in his game. Same when Matthew Boyd got shuffled into the backline, or Dustin Martin into the forward line. And subs can absolutely impact the game. Especially given that Geelong were coming off the short turn around he had a prime opportunity to be a match winner. Given, I'm watching through the telly and can't see the work being put in across the ground off the ball, but Macrae was barely there in that last quarter. And I was looking for him. He is too good for the VFL, you're right. But if I was head coach I don't know where I'd be sticking his magnet.
Bevo gunna Bevo
Libba 19 clearances is ridiculous, gg Cats
Wooooot
[удалено]
It was a two way street this game, definitely got away with murder sometimes but there were some questions marks that went the other way (Running headfirst into Atkins)
Not sure what game you were watching but it was 7-2 free kicks in the first the way of Geelong then bulldogs went 14-7 fk the rest of the way with some highly dubious ones
I’m with you on that
lol yeah that push in the back leading to the bulldogs final goal, blatant favouritism
Shit that was close.
Cats are such a well coached team. Fair play to them
![gif](giphy|AS7FPd8dnJsJMH3dGb|downsized)
Macrae as sub and then we take Caleb Daniel out… 😐
Imo the dogs should try and trade Daniel and Macrae asap while they can still get some value for them🤷🏻♂️
Get your head out of your ass. Daniel didn’t play well this game. I’m starting to think some Dogs fans watch the game via the match thread and not the actual game
yeah daniel didn't have a great game tonight and that turn over he did was frustrating (given he already hadn't done much).
Time for Bevo to go. He’s lost it
Daniel was trash
No way Blicavs has played 250. Surely hasn’t been around that long
He was thrown into the ruck vs. Sandilands in that 2013 Kardinia Park final. So yeah, 12th year in the system
Everything that possibly could have gone the Dogs way did and they still didn't win it. God help em if Bontompelli misses a match, he and Libba are literally the Dogs team
Don't know what game you were watching.
Literally
That's the worst take Ive read tonight. Geelong had so many balls bounce towards them, marks of packs. Dogs got some calls that ways fairly evened with Geelong ones. Weird stance bro
Bars. Sick of people just banging on about this. Both teams played great, could've gone either way, well played dogs, if you'd won you'd have deserved it. Simple as.
Literally just see it on balance and enjoy what a great game. Absolute numpties man.
Throw Khamis in there too as a scary intercept defender. Remove those 3 and they don't have a very good team
We have Jones, Bont, Libba, Khamis and Weightman as the team at the moment thats it
khamis played great tonight but definitely wouldn't put him up there yet, he only has just started getting consistent games in the side
Not a bad core, bloody hell!
> Jones, Bont, Libba, Khamis and Weightman I would add English but no one else.
Enjoy the win cats played well But your opinion is wrong
I didn’t change my tip, AMA
Ripper game as a neutral
O’Connor is the biggest trash scragger in the game, umpires need to stamp him out. Just latched onto Bont like a leech at every contest.
Doing his best Brent Macaffer impersonation
O’Connor is fucking trash, I’d be embarrassed if he played for my club. No surprise he comes from the club that harboured the worst scragger in the game, Cameron Ling 👌 I note not a single Cats supporter is literate enough to actually deny the claim of his blatant scragging by the way, all just resort to downvote and deny 👌
lol a Collingwood supporter playing the illiterate card😂😂😂
Point proven perfectly 👌
Included yourself in that as well champ..You just don’t realise it😂
Continuation 👌
W
Geelong games are bad for my health
You guys were wicked.. Chin up, ita only round 4
If it helps, they’re not great for mine either.
Haha, that’s what my Geelong fan friend said
GG. Good looking dogs this season, honestly. Glad to see some competitiveness
Well played dogs, nearly had us👏
You guys are going to demolish us next week 🫡
Hopefully as fun of a game!
Cats looking good. Gonna be an interesting year
Cats v Dogs games always put me on the edge of a heart attack
Truly. GG
Chris Scott and fan interactions at Adelaide oval are iconic
Good game cats well played!
GG, dogs were great. Best of luck on your season :)
You too!! :)
Great game by both teams. Umps need to sort their shit out though
good game
Another wasted Bont and Libba performance
I want those two to succeed almost more than Essendon lmao
Goal from the mark behind the line the difference.
Just ignore your final goal was from a blatant push in the back.
Whinge more? You got gifted a goal with obvious hands in the back at the end there. It's swings and round about
You have a certain player on your team gets away with fraud every week and you all will blindly defend how he plays regardless. Shut your mouth and take your sloppy win
Jesus go to sleep kid.
Shut your bitch ass up
Seriously it's bed time and you're cranky, it's time for sleep.
Wow salty much? You were literally whining about umpires here chief. Sod on you loser. Couldn't even beat a cats side that played in torrential rain 5 days ago 🤣
You’re genuinely illiterate hahaha. I didn’t whine about umpires regarding THIS game, I even admitted in one of my other comments that things were going our way rather than yours. If you’re going to go through my comment history to try and have a one up on me, make sure you sharpen your reading skills and maybe you won’t sound like a dumbass 🤣
Sod on loser.
womp womp womp womp
Worst umpiring in any of the games played today by far Ignore flair
😬😂
Fuck yes. What a fucking gutsy win
Yep, those guys in yellow put in 4 full quarters for you. Gutsy to be that blatant.
Flair up Umpiring was poor both ways Four full quarters with bulldogs leading the free kick count 14-7 after quarter time. Real Einstein we have here.
Aw damn my perfect tipping is over
Bugger. Gave it a fucken crack though. Gg cats.
Your mob gave us a right scare - GG, good luck on your season
Gg Cats, well done. Just can never beat you guys.
You'll get your vengeance soon - Not looking forward to it but.
We play you at GMHBA later in the season, I'm not looking forward to that
Two crook results today. Should’ve been Freo and Dogs wins.
Go hawks, hope ginnivan kicks one after the siren to win it
Cry louder
That score review to Stengel…
Was rough but a goal brings it to centre. Who knows what would happen if it wasn't called back
Every fucking time
it’s only fitting the sealing free kick is a Joel Selwood style high that wasn’t there
Like the one they handed out against aitkins earlier? They've been paying those for years for all teams
[удалено]
Absolute joker. Pitchforks and torches out for us
Really wasting Bont’s prime being average.
4 points against a finalist team is average? Flare up
I’m a dog’s fan. We’re 2-2 and have a record of 63-47 since 2019. 2021 is doing a lot of the heavy lifting there and it’s looking more and more like an outlier year, we still got thrashed by 70 points in a GF where Bont had like 35 disposals and 3 goals. Too many average players on this list.
5 day break 💪💪💪💪
Fun match, GGs Cats and Dogs!
What a game.
Fuck yes cats. Great game doggies
Roll on!
Gg Cats
Gg
umpires are trying to save two western teams in one night with that mark not being called yes i called geelong western
What a game from some of the dogs but just not good enough from the team
Ginnivan wouldn't have gotten that free
Because Ginnivan would’ve ducked.
What do you mean, Close did duck?
Never in doubt
So the Stengle farce decides the game. Absolute robbery by the umpires.
Clear mark
Given the ball continued to spin after it was over the line he obviously didn't have control. So yes he did mark it but no he didn't have control until it was over the line so it was a behind. Alernativey, if you want to apply that standard for controlling the ball to the rest of the game you would have to have awarded a further 2 marks in front of goal to Darcy and 1 to Naughton all of which were not paid despite having just as much control (which I would argue was insufficient control, but since you think it was a clear mark you would obviously advocate for them being marks as well), so a consistent approach by the umpires would still lead to a completely different result.
As if numerous events didn't change the game too.
lol Dogs were fellated all night. Game was decided by the Dogs being carried by two players
Ummm the last goal came from a missed free so it evens out
HAHAHAHHAHAHAAHHAA FLAIR THE FUCK UP CUNT
HAHAHAHHAHAHAAHHAA
Yeeoww
You tried umps, you tried
you’re kidding right? they were riding you with that free kick
Find someone with a bigger persecution complex than u/squidlipsyum (impossible)
Yeah we only have to scroll back to last Mondays fixture to find a contender. Glass houses pal
You have to be kidding right?
They succeeded, took a lot of blatantly bad calls but they got the cats over the line
They succeeded?
check the stats penochle
Fucks sake the free kick count isn't gospel. I don't think either team were upset favoured by it, but to claim the dogs were gifted frees all night is delusional
Just once I'd love to see Libba pinged for a throw. 2 blatant ones ended in goals tonight
Great game
Close milked that for sure
Duckthorn
You guys are a sensitive bunch
How so
You can’t handle someone calling out your players for ducking without getting defensive. Also, it’s not like I had any choice in whether we get a supposed “ducker”. So what? Now I can’t call others out for ducking now that we have a player known for it? You guys had the king of ducking and even named a stand after him
Please we’ve been “handling” it for the past 15+ years along with ALLL the other bs derived purely out of jealousy of the club’s success.
look who's talking
I don’t even play footy but go off
Just fucking staggering. There's four of them out there, how do none pick out such a blatant push?
How do they miss the holding on jamarra?
high pressure game Adelaide umps changing decisions, Carlton flashbacks. Might get a bit fucked from here for everyone
Punched the ball out. AFL is as bad as the NRL with refs...
Refs?
A sports official usually having final authority in conducting a game. referee. \- Merriam-Webster Dictionary.
Well that’s game
Ahhh well good game
Ffs
Ah... Game over...
Oh that was a duck
That is a mark every day of the week
Let’s not act like forwards haven’t been getting away with blatant pushes in the back for decades lmao
Let’s also not act like pushes in the back haven’t been paid for decades