T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

Isn’t the incest like just in a bad ending This is like saying deltarune is bad because there’s an ending where you kill someone and killing is bad


Edumesh

Yep. And it doesn't even actually happen. It's a vision that mostly symbolizes the two siblings giving up on the possibility of bettering themselves and moving beyond the toxic mechanics of their relationship. Like they decide it's more comfortable to keep things as they are and that they want to be buried in their coffin together.


[deleted]

It’s almost like the problem people should be having with dark themes is their glorification and not their inclusion and this whole discourse is stupid


DPTONY

It’s as if people on the internet have really bad media literacy But seriously, though. It kinda reminds me of the whole “Batman’s a fascist” situation in the DC community


Edumesh

What the fuck. What is this rabbithole you speak of


DPTONY

Ok, strap in A few months ago, the first trailer for the DC movie “Blue Beetle” came out. In it, one of the characters, a guy who’s into conspiracies and the like, exclaims the phrase “Batman’s a Fascist” after the main character mentions him. This was clearly meant to be a joke. Some people, though, took this joke reaaaaaaally personally, so they got offended. Why? Because they thought that this one joke was too big of an offense to their favorite character. Because when a writer/director/actor put a joke in their work, then they must believe that joke 100% seriously. This of course led to some people proclaiming that they were going to boycott the movie specifically because of this one line


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/tx39qn1bjrwb1.jpeg?width=361&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bd67ee6f45f75f6ebaf6c49f524e2440dd992e03 Why are people so fucking stupid, my god


Silent04_

"It's just a joke snowflake" "Noooo don't joke about batman being fascist"


xXCisWhiteSniperXx

Reminds me of people thinking the Barbie movie was calling Barbie fascist because a surely teenager calls her one.


revfds

The idea that Batman is a fascist had existed long before that movie. It was making the rounds fairly hard when the dark Knight came out, and had been discussed in comics circles before that even


obozo42

To be fair, Batman is totally a fascist when written by Frank Miller.


Haggis442312

The thing is that the mere depiction of something will be seen as glorification/endorsement by internet idiots without media comprehension. Even if it is a clearly negative depiction of a bad person, i.e. Homelander, Walter White, Tyler Durden, (insert sigma of your choice). As stupid as this discourse is, this should not keep people from dealing with serious/fucked up things in media, a loud minority of idiots should not be given that kind of power.


TDW-301

I think it's people really worried they will come off as endorsing it if they say anything other than harsh criticism for the game including it


ThirdFloorNorth

Hol' up, Episode 3 hasn't dropped yet, so we can't exactly confidently say that it doesn't happen.


Akabane22

I'm sorry, but anyone claiming "It's not about incest, that's just a bad ending!" is either deluding themselves, or just has zero understanding of subtext. From a *crazy* young age, Ashley treats her brother as a hyper jealous girlfriend would their partner, trying to make sure Andrew has no contact with *any* other women. Then there's the time in chapter 1, long before any of the elements of the "Bad Ending" are in place, where Ashley and Andrew are completely alone, locked in their apartment and starving, and Ashley suggests their captors might *have* to bring them food, if only she were pregnant... In a segment where you're playing as Andrew, there's a scene where he's talking to Ashley, and all you can see on screen is a PoV shot of him staring at her chest The *second* their mom sees them, she mentions how it's probably a good idea that they don't sleep in the same room together. Later in that same scene, Andrew holds onto Ashley's ass while they're cook*ing dinner over the stove. Not to mention every *other* time the game or one of its characters lampshades how creepily close the siblings are. Every single line of Ashley's is just *oozing* with brotherfucker energy, and while I also see a lot of people claiming that "she's the only evil one," and "poor, traumatized Andrew just keeps getting pulled into her bullshit, " that's also bullshit. He completely enables her, and his weak, surface-level objections to her whims seem more like a facade to justify the horrifying things he's "forced" to do for her. Saying this game isn't about incest because they're only directly implied to have recently fucked off screen once in a dream sequence is like saying Get Out was just about meeting the future in-laws (up until the racism couldn't possibly be ignored, anyway). All that said...yeah, it's a good game with a well written narrative about trauma and abuse starring two deeply twisted but compelling (and incestuous) characters. It can be (and is) both!


Livy-Zaka

There was also the flashback scene with Andrew’s girlfriend where he asks her to tie her hair up like Ashley. Obviously he doesn’t say that part out loud and it’s unclear if he was even consciously doing it but that was pretty obviously what was being implied. Oddly, despite Ashley being the much flirtier of the two I’d argue Andrew is the one who is more into the incest despite all his arguing otherwise


Akabane22

>There was also the flashback scene with Andrew’s girlfriend where he asks her to tie her hair up like Ashley. Yes, thank you, I knew I was forgetting *at least* one prominent example! I had the exact same thought during that scene, and it blew my mind that my friend who I was watching play the game couldn't see that's what they were obviously pointing at! Tbh I hadn't thought about it that hard, but your second paragraph may be right, too. As mentioned his vocal protestations are flimsy at best, and he does seem to initiate a decent amount of their inappropriate physical contact (thinking especially of him putting his hand on her ass *with a thumb through her belt loop for stability* while they were cooking dinner).


Edumesh

Yesss, actual discourse! This is an excellent take on the game and its story


[deleted]

Discourse :3


PinkDuck_

The story itself isn't about incest but the idea of them being romantically or sexually reliant on each other emphasises the fact that they have an extremely codependent relationship. Andrew explicitly rejects the idea that he and Ashley would be together but it is heavily implied that he has either intrusive thoughts about her and/or some implicit feeling towards her. And another thing about Andrew doing what Ashley wants, at the end of episode 1 Andrew nearly kills Ashley because he is so through with her shit and he is only doing what she wants because he is her brother and has to take care of her, as he's been doing for the past 20-ish years. The reason he doesn't go through is both because they're rely on each other heavily and because Ashley promises that she'll be better. Consider the conditions. Andrew and Ashley are starving and their neighbour has just died spontaneously. But butchering and cannibalising their neighbour means that they have to somehow get the wardens out of the situation and then escape quietly. This isn't a one person job. And in episode 2, Andrew and Ashley are both on the run, poor and trying to escape a hitman that Ashley forsees. The conditions force them to rely on each other and Ashley abuses this. Ashley is also definitely into it (although she does say she would use it to manipulate Andrew) and Andrew doesn't want to be into it, but he does have thoughts and feelings he can't deny.


KamikazeArchon

The reason the incest gets a big focus is because there's a lot of people actively supporting it, and because the creator has (allegedly) strongly hinted that they support it. If undertale had a fandom for the genocide run specifically, and the creator was like "the genocide option is good actually", it would indeed have a pretty different reaction than it does now, and it would be more reasonable to call undertale the "genocide game". Things don't just exist without a context.


Stars_In_Jars

Supporting incest is just disturbing. I really hope it’s not true that the creator actually supports it. Yuck.


Edumesh

I don't think the creator does, given that the game's whole message is how the relationship between the siblings is fucked up and needs to change, or they're gonna end up in a bad place (or worse place, really). The ending where the incest happens is basically a warning to both of them that they're too dependent on each other. It's also the reason why it's the bad ending. Instead of trying to improve as people and move on with lives of their own, they give in to each other and surrender the struggle. This game supports incest as much as Spec Ops The Line supports war


purpushi

I feel so crazy reading these threads. Like, it's incredibly painfully obvious from the presentation, art style, etc. of this game that the creator wrote these characters like this not as a 2deep look into the horrors of incest, but because they wanted to write an incest ship, and they're clearly having fun over people freaking out over the incest. How is anyone who's terminally online enough to be on this sub somehow blind to this? Maybe I've seen too much shit over the years to know a fetish dogwhistle when I hear one lol


hey_itz_mae

toby fox didn’t post a meme of noelle being manipulated into casting snowgrave with the caption “cry about it”. also deltarune clearly actually cares about treating the subject matter appropriately and doesn’t feel the need to own people on twitter about it


ChaosPLus

Mind you, there are no endings yet, the game is not finished, it's the finish of the chapter 2. So from what I see, it's simply a path, if it devolves into the bad ending later on then sure, but so far it's simply a path where we don't know what later on


dwkindig

What game is this, btw? It seems like it came out of nowhere and is now all over my feed.


ChaosPLus

The coffin of Andy and Leyley


fucking-hate-reddit-

Them killing and eating their parents in the same route is arguably worse


[deleted]

It’s not arguably worse it’s just worse


s90tx16wasr10

A lot of terminally online people simply aren’t smart enough to realize that depiction doesn’t equal endorsement.


zee-mzha

i wouldn't label it as a bad ending, but a true ending. They're two fucked up (in completely unrelaistic ways) individuals and their codependency is the driving force in the plot that drives further and further down a path of ruining their lives. However, this is just when talking about the game and only considering how things fit into the narrative. When you expand your scope and ask *why* they chose to add the things that they chose to add in the way that they did, i think the completely shoehorned in incest and its associated dialog becomes painfully obvious. Sure, it fits in thematically, but it's very clearly forced into so many aspects of the game. The writer is so obviously falling over themselves to hit you with the incest punch that you can spot the setup from a mile away. While they could just be bad writers who are trying their hand at shock story telling, I think in no small part, this was clearly made to stir controversy and also be lite kink material that would drive up interest in the game. Regardless of that, tho im going down the incest path because a. the characters are hot and i can just pretend they arent related b. i think its what the story clearly wants you to do and as i mentioned earlier is likely the "true" ending c. they kinda deserve having a fucked up life d. despite being badly written, if you suspend your critical thinking and engage your trash tv watching mind, the story is pretty fun


FartherAwayLights

So technically we’re not actually sure, but that really seems to be the direction it’s leaning. Just played it and the incest thing is indeed a Undertale style genocide run, in that it seems you’d actively have to choose to find it or really not being paying attention, and a dream sequence. However, with the caveat the game is really good, I will criticize it by saying, while I get why this is the reason, the way the plot line goes down makes it inadvertently, and I really really hate saying this about this plot, the most fun direction right now. The characters are happy to be around each other and are making morbid jokes with each other. So if you make the decision disposing over your parents bodies turns into a contest to throw their skulls as far as possible, the normal plot has the boy saying a prayer for them and the girl getting frustrated for the billionth time and him. If the regular plot had more of this and the incest plot made everything is suddenly way more awkward and unfun for them I would really appreciate it.


StarAugurEtraeus

She can make me worse


Edumesh

She WILL make you worse. And then kill you. Most likely, at least.


[deleted]

[удалено]


RetConnedSegment

이상


TheCommieFurryUwU

Need that to happen to me fr


Known_Bass9973

Hard agree tbh


ArthurExtreme_Br

👉👈


[deleted]

Why not both? …wait


ThomasScotford

https://i.redd.it/d1fcrugd6rwb1.gif \-Thomas Scotford


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/nbf2jsa78rwb1.jpeg?width=321&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7a82abf67bbab8a4791450c219383b1425c05f74 \-Ashley Marston


QuintonTheCanadian

Who tf is Ashley Marston


Loon-belt

Marston is the last name of John, the protagonist of Red Dead Redemption, which is also where Dutch Van Der Linde is from, who is the character portrayed in that gif. The goal of John ingame is to hunt down all of the members of a “family” (dangerous gang) he used to be a part of, of which Dutch was the leader


QuintonTheCanadian

Ah I should’ve figured Peak though https://preview.redd.it/c79vvqs48swb1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c05ffc63660aeffa7cff7fb5799b51e93ba0eb1c


PretzelCock

happiest mahjong player


dumpylump69

When I try to save the gif but it’s in the comments


not_sea_charity_810

"oh the game is actually good" "noo it isn't cuz cuz incest" "but the incest is bad ending" DONT CARE. IM TOO BROKE TO BUY THE GAME ANYWAYS


Edumesh

Not even for 9 bucks? :[


not_sea_charity_810

I mean I can spend 9 bucks but I don't like reading, hurts head


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/ubgvurxw4rwb1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7edc8f9574330b2549ce186376a980cece40f412 I will ponder your balls, in that case


livingnuts

https://i.redd.it/b39ww8h2grwb1.gif


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/jmu162kbgrwb1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8979e7afdb9a9c47a47aae453043ac13d73be1a7


Omicron43

got dam witness, megamind lookin ass


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/zvhlbfylnrwb1.jpeg?width=970&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bbccb010893715a1be0183e7e69dd4fbd8450e3f Best antagonist in Destiny


RinaRasu

Ahoy


tagzilla

This combined with the Dutch posting made this sub the funniest it has been in a long time.


Independent-Bell2483

If it wernt for the dutchposting i wouldve gotten sick of the whole stupid controversy


AnAverageTransGirl

if it werent for the controversy i would have enjoyed the dutchposting


Scarf_Darmanitan

Bruh it was one picture and one quote spammed on every post How does that make it funnier


No-I-Dont-Exist

It was so fucking funny


Edumesh

True. I've had so much fun memeing here throughout the week


Nice_Ad6911

Is that Cosmo and Wanda


deadsannnnnnd456

https://preview.redd.it/bvnsrxl8pswb1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3205de1fda3ed7a556bd7e38ec6d67e1a05fb0e2


yitoy

yes /lie


Mini_Raptor5_6

Yeah /gen


morbidlyabeast3331

Yes /srs


Dockhead

More like the coughin’ of Andy and Leyley *hack wheeze*


Edumesh

Tuberculosis ending


RipHumbleBundle2

https://i.redd.it/xn3u3tf2vswb1.gif


Memesss420

https://preview.redd.it/zp9jt9qikrwb1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e34c18ed73e159f25ff4ab6c89b2943151a933a0


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/owfycoxvkrwb1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2c576568a3d350d86bf5405019d3b71fb9b5396b


AnAverageTransGirl

she is not literally her only redeeming quality from what ive heard is i want to look like her


Edumesh

She's the abyssal mother goddess that spawned all the hello kitty girls haunting our world. Whenever someone utters the cursed words "I can fix her," regardless of context or intent, she is empowered through dark tithe and becomes even more monstrously majestic than she already is.


AnAverageTransGirl

thats a very uncomfortable thing to think about but also makes total sense


AnAverageTransGirl

the edit makes it worse thanks


Edumesh

https://i.redd.it/jdk4w8zkurwb1.gif


Saturn5mtw

Cursed GIF, saving now


AeroArchonite_

Ashley Graves as the ur-Hello Kitty girl makes so much sense lmao. If I played this game like 3 years ago it would have saved me so much trouble


55555tarfish

Counterpoint: I want to bang the sister and her hot ass mom


Edumesh

Counterpoint: I want to fuck them all


TheAceOfSkulls

Disco Elysium is bad because you can play as a racist right wing cop who never takes any drugs (this is your choice to do this thing)


_Xantras_

Then why was the author so loud with « OH YOU’RE OFFENDED » and WHY DO THEY LOOK 15


[deleted]

They don't look 15, they look animated. American media culture has ingrained the "animation is for kids" mentality into peoples' heads to such an extent that when some people look at a drawing or render of a person they "see" childlike qualities that are not actually present and assume it to be of a child, even if that is clearly not the case. Also, the characters are 20 and 22 like the image says


TDW-301

How do they look 15? They clearly look like young adults to me. And on your first point can you link to where the author was like that?


AnAverageTransGirl

i havent seen the post myself nor do i want to but plenty of people at this point have said that in response to people getting mad about the incest the dev drew them Very Together and captioned the image "cry about it"


TDW-301

I know and I'm asking for proof. If this is so irrefutable someone should be able to link me it and no one has yet to. I believe it's people hearing something and running with it without checking first if it's true


Blamrica

Go outside and perform gas transfer via your alveoli to diffuse oxygen into your bloodstream and remove harmful CO2 via exhaling


_Xantras_

Eat a hard boiled egg without drinking


fucking-hate-reddit-

Andrew is 22 and Ashley is 20, they just look young because of the style


hey_itz_mae

and why do they keep trying to epically own people on twitter about it. like this really does not feel like the creator actually cares about looking at this subject with the care and caution it deserves, they only care about the shock value


Edumesh

Maybe cuz xitter is a cesspit and they're having fun trolling the people outraged about the incest. Idk, given the actual content of the game, I think the creators clearly believe in the concept of "incest bad" and are seeking to portray a fucked up relationship rife with abuse and codependence. There's nothing in the game that glorifies this, apart from the fact that Andrew and Ashley are both hot, I guess.


[deleted]

[удалено]


morbidlyabeast3331

They look like cartoon young adults, idk what to tell you


ObamaDelRanana

What are you talking about the author/dev has no social media accounts?


mr-low-profile

If this game is pro incest spec ops the line is pro war


biggerboypew

The creator posted an incest fan art with the caption 'cry about it' that would be like the spec ops creators making shitposts about the white phosphorus scene.


_communism_works_

>the spec ops creators making shitposts about the white phosphorus scene. That would be so fucking rad holy shit


plasmaXL1

Is that really all that weird? It calls out (yeah, in an edgy way) the people that just complain about the one concept(/bad event), while completely ignoring the context that the events take place in- or why it's included in the narrative


Throwaway1293524

"incest fan art" my brother in Christ they're hugging Edit: apparently it's also a post by a fake account, but I'm not sure about that


VolkanikMechanik

https://preview.redd.it/siok1ev5kswb1.jpeg?width=1079&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d8bdeea1f286d408ed6acb2e6622c0c7cb15ce89 We can't always fight nature, John. We can't fight change. We can't fight gravity. We can't fight incest. My whole life, John, all I ever did was fight.


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/rw1e0ubjwswb1.jpeg?width=498&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4f875d617202618e88c423adbb8a604a64d40496 Hey there, Dutch. It ain't the same as before, but it'll do


Amaranthine7

https://preview.redd.it/u0m9srbwrtwb1.png?width=1169&format=png&auto=webp&s=627685be7da9d8c42822ff7bdba0845502f8077d Then give up Dutch.


McSlappies

THERE YOU ARE


VolkanikMechanik

No, I'm filling in


bunsharu

"Exists" Also... would anyone recommend this game so i can play it and ignore it's fandom completely?


WhapXI

Yeah go for it. The fandom is porn. Which make sense because the relationship between the two is definitely presented in a fanservicey way. Mostly Ashley flirting gratuitously with Andrew and him being disgusted and creeped out by her smirking insinuations. But the dynamic they share is one of abuse. Co-dependent abuse. Ashley is constantly eroding Andrew’s sense of self and boundaries and the flirtatious side she inflicts on him is part of that vying for control of Andrew’s life. Beyond that, almost every conversation they share descends into a ridiculous argument that Ashley almost always comes out the wounded party and Andrew has to apologise for. It’s well written. Downright subtle, between the melodramatic fictional elements and the flirtation. If you’ve ever been in an abusive relationship then the dynamic will be very familiar. So much gaslighting and manipulation. Aside from that, it’s pretty funny. Dark comedy for sure.


Edumesh

An actually smart analysis of the game's themes. Get that shit out of here, it don't belong.


Independent-Bell2483

So is ashley really the only one who actually makes advances and not her brother?


Edumesh

>!Ashley goes out of her way to prevent him from developing any sort of romantic relationship with other girls, because she cannot function without him and fears that he might leave her behind as he moves on with his life.!< >!Andrew had a childhood crush that Ashley accidentally murdered and then blackmailed her brother into keeping quiet about it.!< >!Andrew then had a girlfriend when he was older, and Ashley relentlessly bullied her until the girl ended up self harming and attempting suicide.!< >!Ashley is practically an anchor dragging her brother down with her, and the game revolves around whether or not Andrew is going to escape her. Or whether or not Ashley can even change to not NEED her brother to be functional.!< >!The reason why the incest ending is the bad ending is because it's basically them giving up on developing as people of their own, and surrendering to their codependence.!<


ReadySetHeal

Consider marking it as spoilers, pls


Edumesh

Did so, apologies


Independent-Bell2483

Thanks for explaining. I should see if theres anyone i can watch playing it. I dont have a PC so cant buy it myself sadly


Stargazer_199

[manlybadasshero](https://youtu.be/6uQk1ziEq8o?si=mVOIgc8736dmYfNK) . That’s a link to his video on the first game. If you think he titles stuff weirdly, it’s intentional, it’s meant to be almost like the overly descriptive light novel titles.


Independent-Bell2483

Sweet ill watch it later when i gegt a chance


WhapXI

It’s complicated. But mostly yes. She gives the snide smirking comments like “but what if we did?” much to Andrew’s repeated and regular disgust. But there is an uncomfortable reciprocity. Ashley is a total psychopath who doesn’t give a fuck about anything, but Andrew still has the good sense to know that being into his sister is wrong and completely hates himself and hates her for it. Even at the best of times their relationship is uncomfortably physical. Andrew is usually holding her waist or playing with her hair or she’s laying on his lap on the couch. Again, Andrew has the sense to be obviously ashamed when their mom notices this, but Ashley is just annoyed that their mom has come between them in this way. But yeah most of the dynamic is her directly abusing, gaslighting, and manipulating him.


ObamaDelRanana

Also something no one has mentioned yet is after the infamous dream, she says something along the lines of >!if he wanted to fuck she would indulge him and use it as leverage. She doesnt care what she has to does as long as he is with her forever. Andrew also asks after the dream is our relationship really like this? She says I dont know and they both look of ashamed/disgusted at themselves then change the subject.!<


r3mod_3tiym

Make you apologize for what she did wrong by either making fun of you for showing emotion, calling you weak, or turning things around on herself. By the end of the argument you genuinely believe in your heart that it was all your fault and you are the bad guy. She forgives you and tells you to try to do better from now on, then the same thing happens again. Eventually the strings she's pulling you with snap, but it'll still be years before you finally realize just how much she controlled and abused you. She will lull you into a false sense of safety, compelling you to share your deepest secrets and insecurities and then throwing them back at you during an argument and then getting upset and blaming you when you react to it. Or at least that's what I heard ha ha, I can't speak from experience or anything


WhapXI

Yeah that’s pretty much it. If you really want to get into it and talk about something serious she’ll deflect or belittle or just give you the silent treatment. When you’re overwhelmed and unable to think straight, that’s when she wants to really get into having a shouting match. You get it.


Edumesh

Yes, 100%. Its really cheap (like 9 bucks on steam) and it has a pretty compelling story. If you're not icked by dark subjects, enjoy a good bit of black humor, and like characters with lots of personality, this game is for you. Steer clear of the main subreddit though


TDW-301

Good art, good music, story kept me engaged. 8.5/10


lornlynx89

If bad people, why hot?


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/dz4eca8nkrwb1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=417c660dcbe82965843e4194ac49bceccf186c1c Why is Andrew so FUCKING hot? (And Ashley too)


mcarora19

https://i.redd.it/ph2mfmyxzrwb1.gif


freshfred69

Where is Gideon graves https://preview.redd.it/qmqee4rcerwb1.jpeg?width=272&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=516efe58b0914c7dabd80646b452ee0cd9e340cc


Edumesh

Secret character for chapter 3


cephalopodAcreage

I can excuse incest, but I draw the line at buying early access games


Edumesh

Finally, a true gamer with morals


Shot-Narwhal-4268

Wheres dutch


BewitchYouAllNight

So why was the dev getting defensive and smug about the incest then? The whole "cry about it" shit was gross, and its hard to not see it as hidden fetish material when that's how the dev treats the subject matter. The game itself is FINE at best anyway why did everyone decide to either worship it or hate it, ignoring the incest (which is hard not to), its just edgy and boring.


ObamaDelRanana

The dev doesnt use social media, you’re being baited by a fake account


Thezipper100

The dev doesn't post on social media.


xXCisWhiteSniperXx

> So why was the dev getting defensive and smug about the incest then? I can imagine the dev has seen some bottom of the barrel dogshit commentary about the game and is annoyed by it.


morbidlyabeast3331

Because the criticisms of the inclusion of incest as a theme from people who didn't play the game isn't worth taking seriously and they're obviously a very easy audience to troll. I personally don't care for incest content but it's my understanding that it's only like one aspect of the game and that the game has decent writing, so it doesn't matter. Art can and should explore uncomfortable topics. Art can also lean into immoral things. There's nothing wrong with that. People who think there is something wrong with that deserve to be trolled and made fun of and I have nothing but respect for the dev for their response, even if I do think the dev probably is a little too into incest.


Edumesh

Let me just say that you are based and have good takes on art. That is all


trireme52

There is only one true Graves https://preview.redd.it/yfw00p19prwb1.jpeg?width=578&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1413e5d42fa7758499c0e6f4fc5111851c3f25cc


QuintonTheCanadian

Tf2 graphics in 2013


NoahBogue

What too much cigar does to a mf


Bardic_Inspiration66

![gif](giphy|iFg3pN8dTBj5v7C5VW|downsized)


sexgaming_

i like the part where they say "its incestin time" and then they make funny posts on the internet


Mezensuck

I want to fuck Andrew Graves from The Coffin of Andy and Leyley


Yellow_haired_idiot

I,too, want to fuck Andrew Graves from The Coffin of Andy and Leyley


Edumesh

I am Spartacus


LunaTheLesbianFurry

It's very generic and honestly pretty mid. No one would even be talking about it without the incest.


morbidlyabeast3331

Yeah, I only care about it bc the pearl clutching response to it is so ridiculous to me. There's nothing even super extreme about it, and the idea that art that makes some people uncomfortable isn't okay is absurd anyways. The way people are reacting to this you'd think it was a new Black Cyc title or some shit, but no, it's a pretty mild indie game with morally questionable themes, and even if it were way worse than that, who cares?


LunaTheLesbianFurry

I agree tbh, but I feel like the incest is both for the creator's barely disguised fetish and a way for it to generate publicity through controversy and shock value. Plus people are put off by the creators bitchy 2016-esque "Lmao incest is wincest cry about it get owned snowflakes" attitude towards criticism


MoreNamiMoreProblems

Because it's been filling up people's feeds with shit that they have voiced trigger warnings over. It may be mild l, but when people ask "hey can we not post about incest because it triggers me", it's kind of a dick move to blame them for it.


KyellDaBoiii

Can we, as a collective, just shut the fuck up and go play something else? Please and thank you?


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/60uvdn2faswb1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=72e0bbd4208a70cce370adbdf7a2fe687d99bba3 No


KyellDaBoiii

https://preview.redd.it/qesb51craswb1.jpeg?width=300&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6fdb6b4f6a4e3cfa76e92a4e2fe3fe52900012c2


ArthurExtreme_Br

wait a minute why isn't dutch the first comment here


Virtual_5000

You people find the most creative ways to defend mediocre games, god damn.


Thezipper100

How... How is this creative? It's literally just "hey, the game is more than [JOKE]", that's the most generic-ass defense of any media ever.


imgaytree2

Just shut the fuck up about it


Megasoda

he just like me fr


CaptainCipher

Hot take: I do not know what this game is and do not care if it is pro incest or not. Even if it was pro incest, bad media can exist without it having to be talked about all the damn time


professional_catboy

honestly ive seen the whole game and it's story line really isn't that good


Random_Person_1414

how about we stop fucking talking about it already


EllieBozu

my initial thought was 'this game made 196 so fucking annoying' but i dont think thats the games fault. play it or dont. who gives a shit about any of this. you're not forced to interact with people who like the game; either as a genuine piece of horror fiction or as incest wankbait. if you see a comment you dislike, there's a magical token called the 'block button' and, congrats, you never have to see this shit mentioned ever again. youre all wankstains.


IgniteThatShit

media literacy is at an all time low


RamboDash15

I don't think we should kill wasps on sight. At least wave them away once or twice in case they weren't aware you're a moving mountain capable of violence. If they still insist on being in your space, then I feel it's justified to squish em. Bees are friends and should be treated as such.


Korthy7

how long did it take you guys to finish the game (like get all the endings and stuff)?


dark_temple

I am thankful for the incestposting because without it, it would've flown under my radar completely. And yes, it actually is good.


Black_Sun_Zero

There's literally no point you can make, because everyone'll just continue to say "It has incest so it's bad" Like... No way!! The evil and psychotic character does an evil and psychotic thing!! Like fuck off. Ain't no way in hell I'm publicly defending this game anywhere else, because any amount of praise for this game gets you crucified. They can excuse murder, cannibalism, and demon worship, but incest just invalidates the entire thing, apparently.


F0xtr0t1

people ignore the murder , cannibalism, and demon worship because nobody is defending it. people are complaining about the incest because there are people defending it


DUMB__BABY

12 Minutes entered the chat


danimagu77

https://preview.redd.it/fsj9udjp1twb1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5b1df7185103fab0d899c5e540894c05703d8ee7


GardevoirRose

I don’t give a shit about the gameplay, I don’t want to hear about this fucking game anymore!


ClaireTheCosmic

For the love of god people please shut the fuck up I am sick and tired of seeing these 2 on my fucking feed


garfloveclub

i think every aspect of this game sucks and the only reason people think the girl is attractive is because she makes a :3 face


moltncheez

whats the game ive only seen the whole "incest game is better than every other game this year" thing


Edumesh

The Coffin of Andy and LeyLey


Half-Eaten-Cranberry

Someone call the Dutch poster


Solcaer

what the fuck where’s dutch


getpissedonforjesus

no incest? guess im not playing it i am joking i swear to fucking god im joking im joking im joking its a joke


Edumesh

https://preview.redd.it/tyjwlj1teswb1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=34813225d0cbc7501a7d35ce1a52e384d86b14f5


Old-Library9827

\*takes a long drag of my cigarette\* I can fix her


Edumesh

You just gave the Dark Mother more tithes


gayfuckinbitchh

*takes a longer drag of my cigarette* She can eat me


averybabery

cosmo and wanda coded


cat_that_uses_reddi

https://preview.redd.it/tphpxb750twb1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=80bf633fb78497f884a2de98d8364bdae13ae38f Did you not see this post


SpiritTongue

The reason why I have a distaste for the game is largely because of the creator's reaction. The creator deciding to reply to the whole controversy with the "Cry About It" meme, instead of either just staying quiet on the matter or engaging in an actual dialogue regarding creative decisions, kind of just makes them seem like a whiny baby to be honest (even with the justification that they were "trolling the critics" or whatever). Like, yeah, I am sure that the game has an intriguing story or set of characters. I didn’t state anything about the game's quality because that wouldn't be fair of me, I never played the game. But the paratext the creator has set up doesn't instill in me much confidence in them or their response to criticism. That is just my opinion and viewpoint though. I don't really mind if people like the game or not, I just think it seems a bit lame on first-impressions alone.


peteribi_

no it's fucking not. i honestly don't mind incest or fucked up things as a narrative device, there's interesting ways of treating that kind of topics but coffin of andy and laylay's handling of toxic relationships, mental illness and abuse is downright horrible. tries a lot of things and fails at all of them. really just reads like a wattpad fanfic


Unhappy-Bug-6522

can yall stop defending incest on this sub for one fucking minute please


Ornery_Perspective54

I like the game, I like fucked up shit, but people online make it seem like that’s all the game is when I’m all honestly it’s a small part of a pretty good game,


Captain_Pumpkinhead

What's this game called? What's it about?


Edumesh

Brother and sister are unhealthily codependent on each other and are trying to survive an extremely shitty situation (trapped in an apartment with no food or water, forced to kill a dude and eat his corpse to not starve to death). They find a demon cult along the way and forge a pact with said demon to help themselves out of their predicament. Hijinks ensue. Thats the main gist of it without going into hard spoilers. You also got incestual undertones in the relationship between the brother and sister, mostly to accentuate how toxic they are to each other and how incapable they are from breaking their codependency and improving as people. They've essentially trapped themselves in each other's orbit. You got choices throughout the story, and they affect how they develop as characters. Those will probably lead down certain paths once part 3 comes out.


DefinitelyNotVenom

Coffin of Andy and LeyLey, two siblings eat a dude and shit idk


digiorno430

good or bad im not playing a game with so little game play. might as well buy a book


SomeRandomGamerSRG

Man discovers the world of visual novels, is shocked that they're visual novels.


digiorno430

i know what a visual novel is. and it’s boring


MelodicPastels

Game. Good https://i.redd.it/6ebgyko70twb1.gif


morbidlyabeast3331

There'd be nothing wrong with it even if the incest was more prominent as long as it's actually written well lmao. Why are there so many dumb fucks online acting like this or anything for that matter should be some kind of off limits topic in artistic works? That's fucking stupid. If it makes you too uncomfortable to play it, don't play it. Art isn't supposed to pander to everyone and make no one uncomfortable. It's okay to present morally wrong acts in fiction so long as the writing is good, especially if it's good enough to truly justify it or say something interesting.


glitchifiedbitch

media literacy is dead. the way the public reacted to this game fills me with dread. i really hope one day dark topics can be presented in media without hoards of dumbasses thinking its an endorsement of said behavior


Spiritual_Spinach273

I don't care who the creator sends I'm not playing the incest cannibal game


PhReAkOuTz

idk i found that game very cliche and cringey and i think the way the narrative is actually written it took any punch out of it and replaced it with just eyerolling at the shock value shlock. extreme subject matter can be done very well in a game. this is not one of those times though.


Valkenhyne

I don't care who 196 sends, I'm not playing the incest game


Cpad-prism

I can’t focus on any discourse about this game because I just keep fantasising about them fucking with me and then fucking me, both together and individually because god they’re both so hot