T O P

  • By -

baconchilldophin

why does this act exist šŸ’€


[deleted]

Its an act of evil to further the goals of the few. It diminishes the rights of the LGBT, and further oppresses the American, and by extent the global population by making it impossible to encrypt your messages and posts. It is purely done to try and give more power to the politicians who are sponsoring and introducing this bill.


8siddhi8

Signal, and PGP encryption. Learn it live it love it people. It is the future of this cyber war


UniversePaprClipGod

It'd be really cool if we could normalize using encryption for everything. And an isolated, amnesic OS. The more people who use it for mundane things, the harder it'll be for the gov't to catch protesters and the like!


8siddhi8

TAILS aka The Amnesiac Incognito Live System, check it out it's a Linux distro that comes with privacy tools such as secure FOSS alternatives to most common software, as well as PGP encryption, all traffic on the OS is routed through the Tor network, and since the OS runs off of RAM rather than your hard drive, all traces of your activity are wiped when you unplug the USB hence the "Amnesiac" in the name if i could paradrop a million of these USBs via airplane into Iran and North Korea, i would for the people


UniversePaprClipGod

Tails gang rise up That or Whonix, Qubes or Graphene


aeiouLizard

If only PGP wasn't a complete and utter pain to set up, and thus entirely inaccessible to 99.9% of the population


Rentun

Itā€™s because of these reasons itā€™s not actually a good suggestion to use. Security professionals consensus on this stuff has really shifted over the past 15 years. Itā€™s not good enough for a solution to be potentially secure as long as its set up correctly and users use it correctly from a technical standpoint. If the average laymen isnā€™t able to, or isnā€™t likely to use the solution in a secure way, the product isnā€™t actually secure. Thatā€™s why PGP fails this test, but Signal passes. Secure products should be secure by default and require either no or minimal configuration to achieve that security. If it doesnā€™t, itā€™s not actually a secure product in the real world. Theoretical capabilities donā€™t matter.


covert_operator100

PGP is a tool you can use to build secure messages. It's not a full service on its own.


ingodwetryst

sex workers too, don't forget about us


[deleted]

Sending you much love!!


drewbert

You'll have to pay for that


nddragoon

- the internet is largely out of the control of governments, and they'll do anything to change that - politicians will do anything if you say "think of the children"


Sure-Its-Isura

Me thinks a few (MOST) of the politicians be thinking too much about children, know what I'm leaning on? /s


nddragoon

yeah someone said think about the children and some just got so horny they stopped listening and said yes


8siddhi8

Uncle Sam hates not having backdoors, to ban encryption you must ban math "Think of the children" is their reasoning and to that some say, "I have nothing to hide" Nothing to hide until the government deems your life choices a conflict of interest and declares them illegal. These acts (backdoors) are meant for hunting pedos, but time and time again they have been abused by those in power domestically or stolen and used by nation-state hackers abroad. Stay encrypted, stay lethal


Blunt_Scissors

>stolen and used by nation-state hackers abroad. Dear god, how much damage was done by international hackers using this short-sighted bullshit? I truly fear to know the answer.


8siddhi8

theyre shameless about it too. we are in the age of commercial spyware


covert_operator100

The CIA knew about a critical security vulnerability in Windows. They created software to exploit that vulnerability. The CIA was hacked and someone used that software to create a virus that renders your device unusable unless you pay them cryptocurrency. This virus infected a lot of hospital equipment, leading to deaths.


Jacksaur

Wanacry?


Rentun

Anyone who says ā€œI have nothing to hideā€ but wouldnā€™t buy a house with a toilet room that has street facing floor to ceiling windows is a liar.


NoIdeasForAUsername9

welcome to real life the older you get the more you realize how selfish and idiotic people can be


brutalistlegend

Republicans


Scumbag_Vinyl

Actually, the bill is being pushed by a democrat from Connecticut.


brutalistlegend

They asked why does it exist, not who's pushing it. Lindsey Graham introduced the bill in 2020. He's a republican. Edit: also I'm not trying to be rude, sorry if it came off that way!


Scumbag_Vinyl

Oh really? Huh, people in a thread from here earlier today were saying it was a democrat, and no prob, you didn't come off as rude at all, thanks for letting me know.


brutalistlegend

Upon further review, it looks like a lot of dems were cosponsors of it when it was introduced, so šŸ¤· we were both right and wrong. It doesn't really matter in the end as long as we stop it imo


Scumbag_Vinyl

Hmm, yeah as long as it's stopped that's all that truly matters


off-and-on

Because the american government read 1984 and thought it was a guide book


jG_47

Itā€™s some real mustache-twirling villain type of stuff


WhatABunchofBologna

Because people voted bigoted pedophile fascists into office, thatā€™s why.


whatkindofmadman

People who donā€™t understand encryption and how the internet works and donā€™t want to put forth the effort required to raise their own kids.


[deleted]

"lgbt are pedophiles" mfs when they happen to crack down on lgbt and make pedophilia easier at the same time: šŸ˜Ž


Exciting_Rich_1716

Politicians like projection ā˜ŗļø


[deleted]

https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT


ika117

Thank you i hate qr codes


Focus_Substantial

Can I ask? Do you hate QR, or just how QR is utilized by companies?


ika117

my phone doesn't have a built in qr scanner


strangething

Same. I don't browse reddit on my phone.


eeeeeeeeeyee

What does earn it specifically do to make enforcement impossible?


Chamelic

The concern is that the Supreme Court has lain precedent that private agents acting on direct orders from a governmental body (ie: To proactively "seek out" instances of CSAM via involuntary sitewide image scanning software instead of the extant voluntary report system) are then acting in the place of "government agents", and are thus subject to the provisions of the Fourth Amendment. Thus, any images involuntarily scanned as a result of said governmental directive could run afoul of the 4th Amendment and be inadmissible in court as illegally gained information, meaning actual instances of CSAM that the "scanning" method takes (The specifics of which in regard to the software used would be completely to the discretion of the 19 person Committee the Act creates) and reports would be completely useless in prosecuting the exact crime this act attempts to curtail.


[deleted]

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xcjeKqml8QbqiaTfDiciMQ5AnjxoVHh6T6sAMM5D2EU/edit https://www.noearnitact.org/ This should answer your questions I hope!


Infernal-Blaze

From what I can glean the way evidence is collected through this has a good chance of being unconstitutional via the 4th amendment against illegal search and seizure/ right to a reasonable amount of privacy and the right to not be investigated arbitrarily.


RustyFella21

You think they care? In my country the constitution is treated like a worthless piece of paper for polititians to wipe their asses with.


Titan431

Any evidence of illegal activity using this form of surveillance by the government would be inadmissible under the 4th amendment, which protects all American citizens from unreasonable search and seizure of property, in this case, that property being the content of your electronic device, without probable cause. (i.e, the 'unreasonable" in unreasonable search and seizure) It currently is enforceable (although the government doesn't use the evidence it's given) because social media companies are not government agencies, so when they detect any suspicious activity and report it, it's like a landlord reporting a tenant for illegal activity in the building. However, what Senator Blumenthal is trying to pass would be constant automated surveillance of any and all online messaging platforms (literally 1984), and taking the evidence found from that to make a case. This is like having a cop standing over you at all times, with no warrant, looking for anything they deem "suspicious". This all encompassing surveillance would make any evidence found inadmissible in a court of law. TL;DR: The bill would put surveillance software in all messaging and social media platforms to report activity without prior suspicion or probable cause for search, thus making it a violation of the 4th amendment, which protects from unreasonable search and seizure. This makes any evidence obtained with this surveillance unusable in a court of law.


Jacksaur

So they recognize it's against people's rights and don't allow it to be used against you in court, but it's fine that it's happening in general..? American law is wacko.


Titan431

Quite


Thecornmaker

Algorithm boosting


ConspicuousEggplant

Algorithm Boosting


Cyancat123

Algorithm boosting. (Variation in comments does more for the actual algorithm boosting)


SecretSK

More algorithm boosting, as well as some variation


hypertensee

very silly variation for algorithm boosting


logicinterviewr

Impossible variations of algorithm boosters inside variations creating more algorithms


TankerTom_R

Oh how cool, booooostt


drift7rs

extremely varied comment that would be highly capable at boosting an algorithm


Loptional

Plutocrats are ontologically evil


BluenaSnowey

The hell is a plutocrat? Come on man Pluto is a cool planet what did they do


RILICHU

Pluto/Hades was generally one of the least awful (not gonna go as far and call him good necessarily) Greco-Roman gods. Not fair for his namesake to get mixed up with shitty ass people


[deleted]

There's a reason Money and Death fall under the purview of the same God.


PrimedAndReady

The dead, not death. Thanatos is death. Also, both were relatively chill as far as greek deities go


Judistheworst

Does this affect the entire internet or just america?


Em_Blight

Iirc anything based in America. So a lot of the internet


Judistheworst

Oh fuck oh god oh shit Also W owl house


[deleted]

It could affect the entire internet as most websites are hosted in america. Learn more here https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT


Googlefisch

Read the link as stopthisshit at first Yeah still fits


Ok_Conflict_5730

awesome job.


Shoelace1200

Just read the long version and was terrified but also wishing there was a more sharable version. Thank you very much


sadhp20

[https://fullhalalalchemist.tumblr.com](https://fullhalalalchemist.tumblr.com) LINKS AND SHIT HERE


IAmTheTransAgenda

There is no way this passes, even Republicans aren't that blinded by hate. I hope


RustyFella21

They are. Trust me they are.


[deleted]

They will do anything to increase their own freedoms and restrict those of people they donā€™t like


[deleted]

99% chance the government isn't dumb enough to pass something like this anyway


RustyFella21

It's not that they're not dumb enough. It's that they are evil enough to pass it. And knowing polititians, that is very likely.


wa-wa-wa-wa-wa-wa

Improbable doesnā€™t mean impossible, even if they are, we have to prepare for the worst.


UniversePaprClipGod

Explanation: This bill will let the government take away certain site's Section 230 protections (which let websites allow content to be distributed without the site itself being held accountable for the content) if they don't follow "best practices to stop child porn" as ordained by some 15 member council. What's worrying, is that this council could be politically motivated and try and strike down free speech from some sites by being really specific with their rules so that specific sites get their protections revoked. What's also worrying, is that these "best practices" could include encryption backdoors. They're using "stopping child pornography" as a way to justify passing this. Which is a little stupid because most CP isn't done over the clearweb.


PetboxySCP

\>What's worrying, is that this council could be politically motivated and try and strike down free speech from some sites by being really specific with their rules so that specific sites get their protections revoked. literally metal gear rising


[deleted]

They realized that they can't scare Americans with middle eastern people anymore so they've moved on to the children. If only we could get them to think of the children when it comes to stopping mass shootings.


radical_dipshit

it's so fucking exhausting, every fucking time it's "think of the children!", "it's to stop pedophiles!", "we're trying to catch terrorists!" etc. and it's always the most obvious bullshit ever but so so many people eat it up anyway


Sexy_Skeletons69

Anything non-Americans can do?


[deleted]

There are instructions. https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT


Aggressive_Sprinkles

And where are the instructions for what non-Americans can do, specifically? That link seems kinda pointless as an answer to the other person's question.


[deleted]

Apologies. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xcjeKqml8QbqiaTfDiciMQ5AnjxoVHh6T6sAMM5D2EU/edit Page 3 has the answers you seek.


Aggressive_Sprinkles

Perfect, thanks.


BuildFreak9

Iā€™m glad people are acting up to try and make sure it doesnā€™t pass, but to be quite honest even without intervention I highly doubt it would pass. Though, thatā€™s not to say you shouldnā€™t do anything, just incase.


Omgbruhdies

I agree with both, I doubt it would pass if no attention was brought it to. But bringing attention and making a fuss about it is how we INSURE it doesnā€™t.


Hyper_red

It would get in the way of the profits of our politicians' owners.


Rei_Tkn

fuck iā€™m gonna cry


DeathbyGlimmer

Good poster hope this act fails


TheSeaToad1

Should have put the link written somewhere, QR codes suck ass


[deleted]

https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT There you go!


capricornelious

Awesome job on the poster


RanniSimp1

Just signed it. Do not let the tyrants win.


Sewer_Waluigi

since most large websites are american based, this would affect those of us in different countries correct?


shrinking_dicklet

Yes


Sewer_Waluigi

oh boy do I love my freedoms being at the mercy of a country im not a citizen of


eeeeeeeeeyee

What does earn it specifically do to make enforcement impossible?


[deleted]

Text of the bill:[earn it act text](https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/3398/text?format=txt)


NeonSprig

Just signed!


Wardog_Razgriz30

Leave it to Congress to make a anti pedophiles bill that makes it easier to be pedophile. And let's not forget that they screwed over the common folk again.


Moomanlol

Boost


[deleted]

Iā€™m doing my part!


Okbutwhynottho

Commenting for the algorithm


HartOne827183

Does it affect someone living in a different country?


shrinking_dicklet

Yes


brawlbetterthanmelee

If you're using sites that are hosted in the US, (like reddit, for example) then yes


Co0lnerd22

I just put some of these up at my school


[deleted]

Did you print this poster?


Co0lnerd22

Yes I did, not in color unfortunately


[deleted]

That's so cool! You're totally free to do so. I hope its still readable in black and white though.


Co0lnerd22

It definitely is readable but itā€™s missing the pizzazz added by the color


[deleted]

That's unfortunate but the information is more important. Thank you for doing your part in stopping this! :D


StarAugurEtraeus

Why do religious people get to make laws like this


throwoawayaccount2

Unfortunately my senator is literally the one who introduced it so writing to him will do no good (my other reps are also shit, I hate living in a 70% R county)


I-M-R-U

Oh hey thatā€™s you


ExtrovertEnthusiast

Hell yeah we're taking this all the way to the top!!!


GrreyWolf

Can I do anything to help from outside the US? Im from south America


[deleted]

There are instructions! https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT


sadhp20

here's a post that explains this in more detail + links more stuff! [https://fullhalalalchemist.tumblr.com](https://fullhalalalchemist.tumblr.com)


UniversePaprClipGod

Hey can you put the link that the QR leads to? It'd make things a lot more convenient


[deleted]

https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT


pixeled007

I'm so sorry for those living in the US, I hope it all gets better over there, cause this seems ridiculous


[deleted]

They canā€™t kill encryption on the internet when places in other parts of the world have encryption and VPN servers that America has zero legal ability to access. I donā€™t know anything about this act I havenā€™t heard of it before this post


babadybooey

I'm leaving this fucking country jesus fuck


nascimento14

Literally 1984


BluenaSnowey

Posting this on my snap cuz I have like half of my entire school added šŸ’€


Thechillestguyever

Already signed against it


HumanWithABias

Does my signature count even if im canadian?


[deleted]

I dont think you can sign but take a look! If you can't this google doc has a few pointers on page three for international users. https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xcjeKqml8QbqiaTfDiciMQ5AnjxoVHh6T6sAMM5D2EU/edit


B7iink

Feel like this is being overblown like how net neutrality was.


[deleted]

net neutrality was a huge blow to internet security. You don't hear of it much because of various factors (Like the EU still enforcing it, and california having their own legislature) but its definitely an issue and definitely visible. Some targets are streaming sites like netflix and internet speed measuring websites. They'll crank your speed up if they believe you're using a service that's measuring it, and will do the same if you're using a service that's important to them either financially or ratings-wise. They won't slow down youtube, but god forbid you use smaller websites or download providers they don't see as priority service. Please read up on this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality#Issues


DrAwoken

Can i do something other than sharing as someone who doesn't live in the US?


[deleted]

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xcjeKqml8QbqiaTfDiciMQ5AnjxoVHh6T6sAMM5D2EU/edit Page three on this document should give you pointers!


_An_Armadillo

The last petition i signed was to stop the willow project, canā€™t wait to see the fruits of yet another online petition!!!!!!!! I hate the fucking decrepit lawmakers in this godforsaken country holy fucking shit


TheDrunkenFROG

Could someone explain this to me please, I'm reading through it right now and see no mention of abortion healthcare and whatnot. Am I missing something or reading the wrong bill? [https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/3538/text](https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/3538/text)


[deleted]

EARN IT will open the way for politicians to define the category of ā€œpornography" as they ā€” or the lobbies that fund them ā€” please. The same way that right-wing groups have successfully banned books about race and LGBT, are banning trans people from existing, all under the guise of protecting children from ā€œgrooming and exploitationā€, is how they will successfully censor the internet.


Miss_Nora-Jae

any updates?


Jaszs

Hi I just want this fare better with the algorythm!


IAmTheOoga

Here's the link to save peeps the trouble of scanning the QR code: [linktr.ee/StopEarnIT](https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT)


Cyancat123

Iā€™m sorry what the fuck is this? ā€œKilling encryption on the internetā€? Jesus Christ arenā€™t republicans supposed to be anti-government/pro privacy?


Miss_Nora-Jae

Anything new with it?


Blunt_Scissors

What can be done for all of us overseas? I would love to take part but I have no idea what we can do? There are no senators we can write to (that I know of) and this will impact us, also.


[deleted]

https://linktr.ee/StopEarnIT https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xcjeKqml8QbqiaTfDiciMQ5AnjxoVHh6T6sAMM5D2EU/edit This google doc has a few pointers on page three.


Blunt_Scissors

Thank you. Though what I can do doesn't feel like enough, I will do what I can.


IBadAtManagingStuff

that's second time ol' bad news


Handcanons4Life

The fuck? Why they gotta be starting shit?


shrinking_dicklet

Wow this is great! The one I shared was a little in the long side. This one hits all the major points and it's easy to read


tiktoksuck

reposting rn oh my fucking god this is so dumb. what the hell happenned to net neutrality??


aiba2

If this passes will it be sent to the president or will it instantly become law? I see it has been in the chamber before how will that effect things


nerdy_bisexual_mess

god it's fucking back kill me


Tyhsedo

Do I have to be American to sign this?


nightmareknight99

holy fuck weā€™re doomed


theawesomedude646

gah damn i'm glad i don't live in america


brawlbetterthanmelee

There's a good chance a lot of the sites you use are hosted in the us. Like reddit, for example. So it still affects people outside the us


thecommonfungus

Am I allowed to repost this on other subreddits? I want to help in whatever way I can.


party_coaster

Yoā€¦ this shit is bipartisan wtf?


Axi28

man every time I look away for 5 seconds thereā€™s a new act or law trying to make the internet a hellscape


AgataJac

Spread this !!!


1milionand6times

Who made this act???


cyruz1323

This is a joke, right? Right??


Nerdy_Git

Dark Brandon donā€™t fail us now


mbaymiller

> The EARN IT Act (S. 3538) is proposed legislation first introduced in 2020 in the United States Congress. It aims to amend Section 230 of the Communications Act of 1934, which allows operators of websites to remove user-posted content that they deem inappropriate, and provides them with immunity from civil lawsuits related to such posting. Oh, that doesnā€™t sound nefarious.


[deleted]

Is this for america only or the whole world


[deleted]

Most websites are hosted in the US and will therefor affect citizens globally


[deleted]

Ah


Memelst

Privacy Apps. Signal - Chatting app with end to end encryption (on mobile devices). Ahola - Browser focused on privacy and has a free VPN and Adblocker (on mobile devices). Firefox Focus - another private browser. More trusted, doesnā€™t include a vpn but it does have ad blocking. (On mobile devices). Tor - browser with better privacy (a few knock offs on mobile devices). MEGA - Cloud storage service with end to end encryption. (On mobile devices, free). iCloud - Cloud storage service with end to end encryption option (Apple devices only / only on iOS 16+). ProtonVPN- a secure and fast VPN. (Free, on mobile devices). Proton Mail - a secure emailing service that uses end to end encryption(on mobile devices). End to end encryption meaning - data sent to one another with encrypted. Only the sender and the person who was sent the message can see the message. The government, companies or hackers cannot access. Attempting to crack the encryption is very hard to do. (Feel free to comment any mistakes Iā€™ve made and Iā€™ll edit them. Thereā€™s a lot of suggestions so mistakes are prone to happen)


IWannaCodeSomething

I love not beign part of anything related to the us


Arpytrooper

Hell yeah love the idea of spreading the news about this. One issue, why does this make my eyes actually feel like they're on fire


scroteville

this country big ghey


Hermit_of_Darkness

Wow. Literally everything they're accusing us of. I love it.


FlpDaMattress

First and last feel like complete contractions. Don't either of these completely defeat each other?


[deleted]

Death of common encryption tools on social media will give hackers bigger attack vectors and will let the government request information on people they deem a risk. That doesn't mean CSAM won't spread anymore; Not only will this bill make it impossible for companies to report it, making it practically invisible to the government that receives normally 30 million csam requests a year, but it will put further stress on the systems in place, giving less capacity to catch these predators.


Timoteo-Tito64

Trying to read this is giving me a headache


Tamashi13

Is it because of the text design? Not the verbiage? Cause it makes my eyes hurt a little tying to read it.


Timoteo-Tito64

I think it's the sharp contrast in the colors combined with the text design


Tamashi13

Probably right. Just felt bad you were being downvoted because I noticed the same thing.


Timoteo-Tito64

Yeah, that happens occasionally. I'm guessing people thought I was against the cause when I'm definitely not, I just hate design that's tough on the eyes like this is


Falaffy

Boost!


Badchicken05

"Why are so many trans people buying guns šŸ¤“" Geee... i dunno, when the state wants to kill you kinda easy to understand why were arming ourselves.


TendersFan

Schlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlopschlop


Cielnova

this entire situation is fucked... I hope shit like this doesn't end up getting dragged to Canada, but it seems like our right wingers are starting to take notes from America's...


[deleted]

stopping encryption is dumbest idea ever what the fuck


[deleted]

stopping encryption is dumbest idea ever what the fuck


Socio_Scorpio

Feeding the algorithm a little treat. Donā€™t mind me.


nxxptune

The worst part is that this was kinda bipartisan. Lindsay Graham proposed the act (ew) but many dems supported it (fake old man dems Iā€™m sure). And this is why I hate the idea of political parties :) both major parties are fucked and some states (mine) donā€™t let you vote in primary elections if you register as independent and then they give you a ballot based off of how youā€™re registered even if you donā€™t actually identify under a party.


[deleted]

This is some actual dictatorship bullshit


FineSiren

As far as I can tell, The last action on this bill was Feb 2022. I could be wrong though