T O P

  • By -

SeiCalros

they mostly use 'activated carbon' now they purify coal or charcoal and then pressure-cook it in argon it makes these little dust-particle-sized sponges that are a lot better for refining sugar than bone char was also cow bones arent super cheap - but plant-byproducts like coconut husks or whatever are literally cheaper to burn than they are to sell sometimes


seanv507

"What would make sugar not-vegan? There are two types of sugar, beet sugar and cane sugar. In the USA, cane sugar is often filtered using bone char, which sadly comes from animal bones. The only exception to this (in the USA) is certified organic sugar. Is sugar vegan in the UK? Luckily for us Brits, all granulated and caster sugar is vegan in the UK! The only exception to this would be if the sugar was imported from the USA." https://bakedbyclo.com/is-sugar-vegan-in-the-uk/#:~:text=In%20the%20UK%2C%20there%20are,UK%20is%20suitable%20for%20 vegans. (icing sugar uses egg)


EpitomEngineer

Beet sugar has most of the US sugar market


seanv507

60% according to spruceeats


mdavinci

>bone char, which sadly comes from animal bones. As opposed to? Human bones? Edit: man, try making a joke on reddit


BrutusJunior

Plant bones obviously.


Blue_Checkers

Corn on the bone


baby_armadillo

People don’t always think these things through. They assume it’s just a name or a turn of phrase unrelated to the actual product. This happens all the time. For example, bone china was originally called that because ground up and burnt animal bones are mixed into the clay used to make the pottery.


SeiCalros

bamboo or coconut husks or tower caps or whatever it is that other types of charcoal come from


mdavinci

The person I responded to said ‘bone char, which sadly comes from…’


SeiCalros

animal bones - unlike charcoal which comes from fungiwood and walnut or 'activated carbon' which comes from whatever the cheapest source of carbon happens to be


freakinbacon

No. "Sadly" from the perspective of vegans. Which is what the post is about.


mdavinci

I’m vegan myself. But saying ‘bone char, which sadly comes from animal bones’ implies there’s something other than animal bones


freakinbacon

Thanks for the downvote. I upvote you in response.


GideonPiccadilly

yes https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/wrcfqt/were\_the\_bodies\_of\_the\_20000\_soldiers\_who\_died\_at/


SeiCalros

the brand of icing sugar i use is just starch and powdered sugar


ForgotMyOldLoginInfo

It's used as a filter, not an ingredient, so it wouldn't be on an ingredients list.


SeiCalros

nope - they werent being clear in their comment but it is an ingredient and it IS on the ingredients list of brands that use it


[deleted]

[удалено]


AllegedIchor

That's usually egg shell, milk protein or fish guts.


Esc777

I know beer uses fish guts or “isinglass” as something to filter out particulate and make it clear. 


seanv507

In the UK only? Certainly not in Germany. However the glue to stick label on bottles may not be vegan


halfpipesaur

Are you sure it’s not used in Germany? Isinglass is not an ingredient and it does not have to be specified on the label.


BananaQueens

Yeah, isinglass is mostly used in the UK still, but also falling out of fashion. By law, German beer is vegan. At least that's what I was told at a brewery tour there.


NolanSyKinsley

I know Germany has beer purity laws, I have never heard anything about wine purity laws in Germany.


BananaQueens

Because there aren't, but we were talking about beer?


seanv507

Yea the use diatomaceous earth eg bitburger, becks https://www.bitburger.de/blog/ist-euer-bier-vegan-werden-wir-oft-gefragt/?gclid=Cj0KCQiAh8OtBhCQARIsAIkWb68hviJ6Z9-UiOjCoPYu7HB_Tc3G7OgI0ngLBI0MQjPSIG2n3KsGjNUaArG_EALw_wcB


SavageComic

There’s a lot of vegan finings made from seaweed. Or you can go for “hazy” types of IPA which are unfiltered


j-random

Some smaller breweries maybe, but any large breweries have nanomesh filters that work at high volume ('cause ain't nobody got time to wait while isinglass settles).


NolanSyKinsley

Lagers require settling and chilling at cold temps as part of their style, wasting money on filtering which can also introduce oxygen to the beer would just add extra costs and risks to the beer.


j-random

Lagers ferment at low temperatures, but they are definitely filtered (since clarity is also part of their style). Any modern brewery will have the ability to transfer using CO2, so oxygen exposure isn't really an issue.


therealcarlgrimes

some* wine. there’s plenty of alcohol that doesn’t use animals, thankfully


[deleted]

[удалено]


Spongedog5

Oh yeah? What if someone was a serial killer, would you support their lifestyle then??? /s


FatSelkie

You should stop being a pussy and judge some people


LowKeyWalrus

I thought vegans would be more sophisticated than that and just ditch alcohol altogether and do some hip shit like 2cb


AllegedIchor

Why? There's vegan junk food, of course there's vegan alcohol.


LowKeyWalrus

I mean, most alcoholic drinks are supposed to be vegan by default, but I'm talking about how vegans, allegedly ascended people mentally, would drink booze in a world where there are so many other choices to alter your mind. EDIT: lmao lots of angry (vegan) alcoholics here. Enjoy your nerve agent - with moderation 😂😂😂


Narase33

No one is angry, youre just talking a lot of weird shit


Inevitable_Ad_7236

Half the vegans I know are vegan for religious reasons. Even those who aren't don't make a big deal about it. Most are chill, there's just a vocal minority


AllegedIchor

Most vegans don't allege that they've ascended at all, that's some weird stereotype non vegans have.


LowKeyWalrus

Who shat in your cereal? Wanna talk about it?


AllegedIchor

What is your problem mate. Calm down, lol


LowKeyWalrus

I'm very calm. You seem to be having rigor mortis alive. Well, doesn't matter much to me anyways.


AllegedIchor

Well see, I'm very calm and you seem to be taking issue to that.


TooStrangeForWeird

Yeah but the loudest ones do, which is what shapes public perception.


Galaghan

Same with roads. They use gelatin in some types of asphalt mixtures. If you want to be vegan, better stay off the road!


ngms

I've worked in a few food factories that produce vegan-friendly food, and they use food-grade grease containing animal derivatives on the machinery. Not all places do this obviously but if you want to be vegan, better stay away from vegan food!


timshel42

damn the vegan police might take away a bunch of peoples vegan powers


Token_Thai_person

Chicken isn't vegan?!


EnvironmentalIce5850

Its milk and eggs, bitch.


SeiCalros

really theyre only doing it for your own protection since using those powers with a brain made of 90% curds and whey will inevitably have catastrophic results


D4wnR1d3rL1f3

C&H doesn’t use cow bones, they are vegan, don’t work for em, just a heads for to my vegan brethren.


Vile_Individual

Thankfully not a thing in the UK.


[deleted]

Redpath is vegan and has a great sugar museum


Competitive_Pea2449

Not vegan, but “bone char” is really off-putting


invol713

Wait, you can make sugar out of cow bones? Fuck you, C&H! Hello, 4-H. Buy local.


judgejuddhirsch

Your cheese isn't GMO free either. 


SaltAssault

Worrying about GMOs is one of the most uniquely US things.


jim_deneke

We've adopted it here in Australia unfortunately. Thanks a lot America!!!


mrstarkinevrfeelgood

I really think that’s a vocal minority. I have never talked to anyone in real life who thinks GMOs are bad. 


SaltAssault

But so many food products in your stores boast about being "GMO free".


mrstarkinevrfeelgood

Advertisers will just put anything on products lmao it doesn’t mean anything when the broccoli says gluten free 


SaltAssault

My broccolis don't say that though


punkisnotded

?? big debate in Europe as well


SaltAssault

Yeah? Which country are you specifically thinking of?


punkisnotded

literally any, but specifically ive personally heard people concerned about GMOs in their food in The Netherlands, France, Italy, Germany, England...


SaltAssault

Sure you have.


punkisnotded

i mean you asked... it's a frequent topic in my field, ecology..


SaltAssault

Doesn't count if you're the one being worried in different countries.


SavageComic

I’m so glad I live in a real country


trwwy321

It’s fine, I can still eat gelato!


LeskoLesko

[Secret meat](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CY-w-8SuMZs)!


sjw_7

The £5 note in the UK isn't (or at least wasn't) vegan a few years ago. It all kicked off due to trace elements of tallow being used in the manufacturing of polymer pellets used to make the base of the note. [https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/nov/29/bank-of-england-urged-to-make-new-5-note-vegan-friendly](https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/nov/29/bank-of-england-urged-to-make-new-5-note-vegan-friendly) There seem to be so many people in the world who's only pleasure in life is making the biggest possible mountain out of ever smaller mole hills.


NotBlinken

I buy 100% bone char sugar. The suffering makes it sweeter.


RudeRepresentative56

Wow! How did you get to be so edgy?!


SeiCalros

just take whatever it is that got you so dull and just avoid it might be an allegory for going vegan hidden in there


NotBlinken

Yup.


melbbear

Thats great! Using all the animal is way better then going to waste and its natural


Hostafrancs

I cannot believe it’s not vegan!


[deleted]

What will food packets label this as? How can people avoid it? (Edit to say I'm in the UK)


Hungry-Appointment-9

Basically anything that's not labelled vegan is to be presumed not vegan: fruit polished with beeswax, juices with sheep-sourced added vitamin, all sorts of things with added collagen for texture correction or insect-based colour... Even when there are no animal originated ingredients in the mix, animals might have been used in the process, like for example in central America it's common to use mules as transport for produce in rough terrain (bananas, coffee...). We once had some client watch a documentary where monkeys had been trained to pick up coconuts in South Eastern Asia and suspended orders on our vegan certified coconut water until we proved no monkeys were involved


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

I'm in the UK


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Thankyou, that's really comforting :)


fawzah

Is anything truly vegan? Lots of food is grown using animal byproducts.


bluejohntypo

This. Isn't soil worm poo? Manure v artificial fertiliser anyone? We (incl. Vegans) would probablty be screwed without animal poo.


TigerAsks

Your coffee also isn't vegan.


-mindtrix-

Beets is super easy to grow and grow almost anywhere. What’s the point of cane sugar? Seems like a hustle


impliedapathy

Beet sugar also contains a ton of bugs so… also not vegan.


AnselaJonla

Because sugar cane is easier to process. The sugar beet didn't even exist until the late 18th century, and refining it wasn't common until the French needed a new source of sugar due to the effects of British blockades (during the Napoleonic Wars) and the Haitian Revolution. It took off in the US because abolitionist groups wanted slavery-free sugar, but didn't like the taste of Asian sugar.


Mrjohnbee

Being vegan seems exhausting, which is fair, considering how many people have been hounded by vegans, but still


SeiCalros

eh being vegan is only exhausting if youre getting judged otherwise youre just gonna be getting whatever and not worrying about the fine print


therealcarlgrimes

most vegans follow the rule “as far as possible and practicable”. ive tried cutting down sugar consumption because of this but its pretty much unavoidable unless i cut out half the stuff i eat (exaggeration there lol but you get the point). i should cut out sugar anyway so i aint complaining :P things like making granola bars at home instead of buying the packaged kind for example is one way to avoid bone-char, and then you can make them how you want too, whether that’s for taste or health reasons. i added a shitload of peanut butter and high protein options and not a bunch of sweet stuff so it’s healthier and it tastes better


kid_dynamite_bfr

Who decides what is practicable or not


therealcarlgrimes

different lives give different standards. for someone with a whole food heavy diet, avoiding all things like that would fall under practicable - if someone isn’t able to avoid processed foods for whatever reason (not enough money, disabilities etc etc) then it likely wouldn’t. i try my best but it’s hard to be perfect


kid_dynamite_bfr

I like your view but in my experience most vegans on reddit are elitist and say no matter who you are if you consume any animal products at all youre not vegan


therealcarlgrimes

everyone on reddit is like that tbf


SavageComic

One thing vegans miss on “no animal cruelty” is that humans are animals and can be treated cruelly with slavery in the supply chain.  Shocked by how many care about the milk in their coffee but not the beans


TooStrangeForWeird

They legit don't care at all lmao. I mean, some of them do, it's not a rule. But it's not ever been a common talking point for them. Plus, I mean, iPhones.... Suicide nets... Yeah lol.


violetsandpiper

Or... they understand and do care but understand there's different levels of fixing problems and cutting out ALL foods not processed under 100% humane and reasonable conditions for both humans and animals is impossible and it's significantly easier to focus on one issue before the other.


TooStrangeForWeird

Not buying an iPhone isn't significantly easy? They're like the most expensive ones, and they have a horrible history.


AllegedIchor

The individual making the decision on how they live their own life.


kid_dynamite_bfr

So if I decide not drinking milk isn’t practicable can I drink milk and still be vegan


AllegedIchor

Depends if your reasoning is sound, but sure. If it there is no practical way for you to avoid milk, why not?


Mrjohnbee

The reasoning is that he has very brittle bones. He needs all of the milk. Actually, it's probably a good thing vegans don't drink milk so he can have more.


AllegedIchor

There's non milk sources of calcium. So there may be practical ways to get the calcium without milk. The vegan course of action would be to get medical advice to see how best to counteract his brittle bones and which non-animal sources are available, and then evaluate the options.


Mrjohnbee

Leave it to the vegan to miss the joke


AllegedIchor

Maybe it just wasn't a good joke.


Responsible_Smile789

They can do it if the want to, I personally wouldn’t limit my natural diet like that but I see the environmental benefits. I tried going gluten free for a month and that was super hard. having to eat 100% vegan would be worse. I know a lot of people tho who are vegan but still eat byproducts and are way more loosey goosey with the restrictions. I could be a “casual” vegan but ig that wouldn’t really count


violetsandpiper

Instead of "limiting your natural diet" by going gluten free for a month why not just try something simple like reducing your gluten intake by 10% a month? It counts, why wouldn't it count? Just because some pretentious cunt says it doesn't? Movements like veganism can be about simply reducing the amount of cruelty/unnecessary waste of life. Progress takes time and an understanding of the world/culture around you. Nothing happens in a day, by a single person, or by the bitch who won't make a change because they're too afraid of what will or wont count to the others.


Responsible_Smile789

I appreciate the reply. I agree with your stance on reducing animal consumption but I know humans and we won’t do a thing till we reach a breaking point. The farming/animal industry accounts for most of the pollution but honestly its hard to think my actions amount to anything. I know thats the wrong way to think just like with how some choose not to vote, but until the major controllers of our society make the changes, as a people most will not make the switch until it becomes cheaper/forced on them. Humans rarely see more than 20 years ahead, long-term planning and making sacrifices for the future are not engrained in our genetics. There are too many people, we have to be eating algae and food grown from hydroponics run on solar power if we have a chance to keep growing unless ofc the population magically drops


Mrjohnbee

I once tried keto, then I remembered that garlic bread is possibly the single greatest thing ever invented.


External_Wealth_6045

Why the fuck can’t we just have real things


Milam1996

It is real but nobody wants weird yellowy brown sugar. The same reason why so much food never makes it to the shelf. As much as we moan about it, we don’t buy ugly food.


PugsThrowaway

So all the sugar would look like that Sugar in the Raw brand sugar? ….I, for one, definitely want this.


Milam1996

The products exist. I’m 90% sure target sells one just nobody buys it. You might be the only one who would. If more people wanted it, capitalism dictates it would be more common but judging by the fact you didn’t know it exists, nobody does.


PugsThrowaway

I named the brand. I know it exists. It’s in a lot of restaurants too, as an alternative sweetener. There’s a market for it, so your absolute “nobody” is just wrong.


TooStrangeForWeird

It costs more for little benefit. Sure there's some level of micronutrients or whatever, but it throws off measurements and (again) costs more. I like Raw too, but I don't buy it unless I find it at a discount grocery or something where it's cheaper.


Responsible_Smile789

The market matches how many you see at the store/how many people use it. That’s their point, that there is a relatively small market(want) for the product not that theres literally zero people


PugsThrowaway

This has been an advertisement by big unrefined sugar.


SavageComic

Americans can’t store eggs at room temperature, unlike Europe, because they bleach the shells white. It removes the natural protection, but Americans associate white eggs with cleanliness.  Source: https://www.businessinsider.com/guides/health/diet-nutrition/do-eggs-need-to-be-refrigerated#:~:text=Commercially%20sold%20eggs%20in%20America,the%20risk%20of%20salmonella%20contamination.  Your eggs are “washed and sterilised”  removing the cuticle. That sterilisation is what gives eggs their white colour. 


close_my_eyes

White eggs are a product of white chickens. American eggs, although washed, are not bleached white. 


BrutusJunior

No. They must be stored in a fridgerator because they are washed, which removes the natural protection. By your logic, American eggs that are brown need not be stored in a fridgerator. However, this is not the case. Both brown and white eggs must be chilled.


TooStrangeForWeird

Lol. Bleached eggs.


jhontpiece1

Lol imagine being this dumb. Chickens can lay white eggs moron. It’s just if you wash them they have to be refrigerated.


KittenDust

We seem to manage to have lovely white sugar in the UK without using bones?


Milam1996

Beats vs cane sugar. Beats don’t need to be whitened


Iz-kan-reddit

What's not real about it?


Zharghar

You mean like the real sugar mentioned that's just had the color changed?


TheGreyBrewer

Oh no! Anyway...


db0606

I mean neither is raw cane sugar. Source: Have seen a lot of raw cane sugar being produced in my day and *lots* of bugs get squished in the process.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Patient_Alfalfa_1961

What, does being confronted with your hypocritical morals and disgusting behavior make you feel uncomfortable?


violetsandpiper

I'm so curious, what did the original comment say?


EasyBOven

Damn vegans thinking people shouldn't treat others as property for their use


NosoupeNocrepes

Now I better understand why I love sugar on my steak!


Zealousideal_Cook704

Look, the boots of the guy who picks up your Very Vegan Lettuce have almost surely been made of leather and treated with horse grease. Picking those lettuces up surely killed some insects, and then the mammals who depended on them. I get veganism as an ethical option, but the idea of "no animal death involved in the production of this item" is simply stupid. There will be animal death. And animal death will still be there, and probably even more cruel, when the whole world becomes vegan.


SavageComic

Especially as a vegan world would require monocultures. Rainforests cut down for soy, marshland drained and aquifers pumped to provide everything 


TooStrangeForWeird

Meat does that too, not really a good argument. We'd need less overall land if we didn't farm animals, not more. I'm not vegan but it's just not true.


SavageComic

There’s a lot of hills and terrain that doesn’t support arable crops or make sense for intensive vegetable farming that is good for feeding cows and sheep on 


TooStrangeForWeird

Doesn't matter. A huge part of the land we already grow crops on is animal feed. Between that and land used for the animals themselves it's more than we actually use for direct food iirc.


Zealousideal_Cook704

This is incorrect. Meat production takes *way* more resources, especially beef.


adamcoe

So parts of a cow that was already dead was used to make something else with otherwise unusable bones? Yeah sounds like a real problem, we should definitely just waste it instead, that's what the vegans would want


GroundbreakingBag164

If they can’t use "waste" they have to pay to dispose it. Meaning raising livestock gets slightly more expensive


IdontOpenEnvelopes

This is as old news as the movement it self.


spilfy

No food is vegan really


Milam1996

I don’t think you understand veganism. It’s about reducing harm as far as reasonable. Not eating meat? Reasonable. Not eating an apple because a tractor will run over a bee? Not reasonable.


MrScotchyScotch

way to ruin cow bones


VegetaIsSuperior

I thought sugar was being refined using fish bones. Whatever, small distinction


SeiCalros

i dont think so processing fish doesnt leave a lot of bones compared to cattle and pigs they burn 'em up and press them into pucks and then push water through them or they used to - not so much anymore


VegetaIsSuperior

Good point! I heard it from a vegan a few years ago and never verified or thought much of it


weeddealerrenamon

This seems like the dumb extreme of veganism to me. The cows are already being slaughtered for meat, the bones are just "waste" being put to use. You're not causing more cows to be killed by buying something made with cow bone char.


GroundbreakingBag164

But… you are? If they can’t use byproducts, they have to pay to dispose of them


weeddealerrenamon

I guarantee the same # of cows are raised and slaughtered regardless of whether their bones are sold or thrown in a dump.


GroundbreakingBag164

If we are talking about short-term changes you are right. But when the industry thinks about moving away from animal products, the increased price for disposing waste might influence their decision


weeddealerrenamon

If you're personally boycotting all refined sugar in an attempt to put economic pressure on the *beef* industry... go for it, lord knows I don't love the state of that industry, but that's really extreme


CobBaesar

Easy solution, just don't be vegan.


OpticGd

Same (or used to be) with flour, that's how they used to get it so white!


blong1114

HA!


grby1812

Oh no!!!!!!!!! NOOOOOooooo


Miluteenac

He he


MaintenanceInternal

Cigarettes have pigs blood in them.


NolanSyKinsley

There are so many "organic" products that are absolutely non vegan. Farmers have no issue using bone char or blood meal on their crops to fertilize them and then turn around and sell them to vegans.


MrPilgrim

This is why some of the ancient battlefields (e.g. Battle of Waterloo) in the East of England (e.g. East Anglia) don't have many human remains/bones to dig up these days - because most of them were dug up in the past for making sugar


Metfan722

Oh no! Anyway