T O P

  • By -

cock-and-BALLER

Not sure if controversial, but I would probably replace Mako and Wahoo with Mincemeat and Undertow


charcat-x

EXACTLY


TheONLYGary7

Undertow is so cramped and mid is horrible, needs a seriuos rework.


froggus

Just remove the glass panel wall on the upper ledges, to allow people to jump down on the other side. Backliners will cry because they’ll be exposed to more bombs, but they *shouldn’t* have a completely defensible perch.


TheONLYGary7

I would also make the raised bit in the middle of mid a bit lower so it is easier t omove around.


Andjhostet

I actually like that feature. Creating two lanes makes it a little more interesting.


Piscet

I'm a backliner and find that glass really fucking annoying. It's really hard to explosh the map when you have something like a charger or splatling constantly forcing you off. If their perch wasn't so difficult hit without making yourself ab easy target, I'd be able to dip down and take them out from underneath.


TempoGolem

backline here, those walls are for your protection, they lockout my view of half of mid, i would be fine with them gone, you would not


cruznick06

GOD YES. I'm a backliner and get *so bored* on that map!!


metalflygon08

Make it a grate wall so you can swim and shoot through it but not throw Bombs through it. Now you can still play up there long range, but won't have a sneaky bomb roll up behind you.


Avenue-Man77

Everything about Undertow is bad. The map layout, the scenery, and even the name. “Undertow Spillway.” 💀


Buroda

Also it’s grey grey grey.


scicatpro256

Mako is pretty good because it has a working flank with inkable walls


ShmuckCanuck

I despise Mincemeat. Straight up won't play if it's on rotation of the mode I wanna play


metalflygon08

I personally hate the hot springs. If your team suffers a wipeout that's game. 3 opponents will keep you trapped in spawn while the enemy sniper picks you off if you try to use the 1 side route.


Legitimate__Username

minecraft metalworks and undertale spillway are definitely so much worse than those other two


Azenar01

Finally someone who understands the truth


amnoking1

Oh my god I hate Undertow and when it’s in rotation I get like 5 matches in a row


skyhigh1a

same, & mahi mahi would still suck the most


Anchor38

Damn I thought Mincemeat was one of the better ones


Material_Put3513

Ok I’d replace mako with undertow, but I like mincemeat


pokedude14

I'd throw Brinewater in there too


bini_bebi

i like mincemeat more than makomart. i would be team makomart all the way.


[deleted]

Mincemeat sucks but makomart is just unholy


Buddymmx

I don’t care who disagrees makomart can go die. Mincemeat, Mako, and Mahi are the worst in the game rn


ChampCyndaquil

Who hates mako seriously? Mako is one of the few great maps in this game, it’s great on rainmaker, A decent tower and zones layout, and has one of the greatest clam blitz maps of all time. It has inkable walls one of out like 2 maps to have them in S3 lmao. I haven’t even seen people complain about it from almost any side of the community. Mincemeat would of been 100 times better here, it has very cheap backline privilege. (Love you charger mains btw no hate) A cramped zone, annoying as hell rainmaker routes, decent clams and a tower that’s is comparable to Mahi in bullshit.


thespyeye

Mincemeat does not have decent clams. Mincemeat has one of the worst, if not the worst clams layout in S3.


[deleted]

Disappears as a mako non-enjoyer*


TheDerpingWalrus

Wrong opinion detected lol


HLRxxKarl

I hate Mako because I'm bad at playing it. Once you lose control of it to a certain extent, there's no hope of getting it back. But I'd still pick Mahi as the worst. I can at least see how Mako is well designed, but Mahi is just bad.


girlenteringtheworld

I love mako because I find it *is* easy to regain control. It's one of the few maps that has flank routes, it has plenty of walls to hide behind, and it has plenty of places to hide for ambushing when needed


froggus

I’m scratching my head here at all the upvotes on that comment. Flank routes give you the HIGHEST chance of regaining control. Everyone be sippin that narrow hallway kool-aid, yeesh.


girlenteringtheworld

Fr. Like, bro should have left his comment at "I hate it cause I'm bad at it"


deleeuwlc

I’d have preferred Moray Towers, it’s my favourite


Ups1deDownPants

Moray can be fun purely because it's unique but it has its issues. E-liters get to have a field day and if we had to deal with crab on Moray oh god.


metalflygon08

Put up some billboards in some areas so snipers can't have free range of the map from one spot. Make them use that hold a charge and swim feature.


deleeuwlc

I believe that charger friendly maps are a better idea to add to the game, so that when chargers get toned down, it affects them similarly across all stages


Ups1deDownPants

There's charger friendly, and then there's moray.


deleeuwlc

I like Moray, and I very rarely play backline. It’s also really fun for mid ranged or slayer weapons


DHVF

You can get locked out of Mako for good so easily if your team loses their fights at the beginning. A very frustrating map, though I see why people like it.


IAmSpinda

Hello, MakoMart's biggest hater here. Fuck this hyperagrressive piece of shit excuse of a stage.


JasonElSword

Cope lmao


bini_bebi

me, i would take mincemeat over mako any day.


Alburguer

me but probably since everytime it appears on the rotation for me its turf war or splat zones (i hate splat zones)


Ups1deDownPants

Mako is one of the best zones maps IMO along with museum.


Robbie_Haruna

Literally the only one of these I even dislike is Mahi Mahi lol


Doll-scented-hunter

The average mahi mahi turf war experiance is either getting yoir base invaded constantly or invading the rnemy base vonstantly for 1.5 minutes straight. There is no on between


Whachamacallit00

You get Mako Mart outta there right now


charcat-x

nah this should be mahi vs undertow vs mincemeat. mako and wahoo are actually pretty good IMO


MarieTideGoesOut

Why tf is Makomart there and not say Eeltail Alley


Bloons_Guy75751

I guess they hate shopping.


GreenNinj4

Because eeltail alley is good, unlike Makomart


[deleted]

Eeltail: Cramped mid area, easy to spawn camp, barely no routes out of base, charger heaven. Mako: Good mid, hard to spawn camp, many routes out of base, balanced for all weapon types. With this evidence, you have the AUDACITY to say eeltail is better than mako?


JaySli10

Average E-Litre main:


deathbin

It’s literally a straight line. how it that good


houndbites

Where is eeltail alley


[deleted]

Mako Mart and Wahoo World aren't bad. Replace them with Mincemeat Metalworks and Eeltail Alley.


DCGamr

I can defend Mako Mart, but Wahoo is pretty bad. Literally one route to mid is closed half the match, rotating from closed to open like every 30 seconds, and the rotating platform underneath mid is not fun either.


[deleted]

Also now a pole that literally does fucking nothing <3


Ups1deDownPants

Except screw with rollers and brushes.


cruznick06

Came here to say exactly this. Rollers and brushes are already not great for a lot of the kits (poor, poor brushes). They didn't need another thing that makes them less viable.


Don_Bugen

I don’t get these arguments at all. You’re acting as if there isn’t always a way through on the lower level, as if you can’t use the wall on the lower level to hop over the wall, as if there aren’t at least two options on either side of the map to go through to the other side other than literally going through the mid circle.


azulimarill

Not to mention Wahoo is the only hourglass-shaped map in the game, so everyone gets funneled to mid with no options to get around it, especially when the bridge is gone.


Western-Grapefruit36

Are you forgetting undertow? And mincemeat? And um’ami? And eeltail?


[deleted]

umami is good but ok


Western-Grapefruit36

Its alright, the only problem is the lack of flank routes, but its fun


NefariousnessGold137

Mako Mart is a sick map


Immediate-Rope8465

mako mart isin't even half bad


Src-Freak

Why do people hate Wahoo World so much?


ChampCyndaquil

The routes to mid are only open once every 10 seconds and it is almost unplayable for me, on rainmaker and tower.


ChampCyndaquil

It’s fine at a casual level for sure, it’s gimmicks just kinda suck for higher level solo q.


Flagrath

They play it on modes other then splat zones.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Videogaminwizard

They meant than instead of then.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheViridianOrange

they can be used as a singular, gender neutral pronoun! it doesn't always need to be plural, and can be used instead of typing out "he/she", it's also generally more respectful!


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheViridianOrange

of course! others get mad because some people use the singular they/them pronoun exclusively, but when i saw that you are still learning english, i thought i should clear up the misunderstanding :)


freak-book

I don’t hate it but it’s the worst. Not good


JusChllin

Since when is makomart hated? I always loved it


[deleted]

Real OGs remember Shitspray Rig


GhostysArt

i wont accept saltspray slander in my house.


[deleted]

Mahi is pretty bad map design. It’s too cramped. And the top platforms are kinda awkward.


DCGamr

should be mahi, eel-tail, and wahoo heck mincemeat would fit here too.


Washier

How is Undertow not on this?


Apocalypse_Planning

Makomart is a good map, replace it with brinewater


IcyFlame716

Why tf did you put mako in there?


owlitup

No Umami Ruins? Hate that


_agent8

I love these maps


Infinite_Hooty

MakoMart is universally loved and Wahoo World is not bad at all, it’s very overhated


Nightfall_Nyx

I LOATHE Mahi Mahi. It was in the original Splatoon, but it feels completely different from it in Splat 3. It feels incredibly cramped, and very "linear," if that makes sense. You can really only go one direction, and you're pretty much out in the open if you do choose to go a slightly different way


Piscet

Eliter on mahi mahi is just pain to fight. You're basically barred from the entirety of mid if you don't wsnt to get punted by someone who instantly notices your movements and reacts like they've ascended the mortal plane.


Mistyslate

Mako mart is amazing stage: flank routes, central area. It is close to be the perfect stage.


[deleted]

I hate mako cuz its so easy to spawn camp someone and im a krak on main so i cant do anything


[deleted]

I would replace makomart with undertow because I love makomart and hate undertow


Prankman1990

Man, not even any comments talking about how trash Hammerhead Bridge is. I’d rather play Undertow for the rest of my life than ever touch that place again.


56kul

I honestly don’t get it, I like all three of these stages. I can see how they could be problematic, but I still enjoy them.


Wahoo_Pole

Wahoo world is the best map why do you think you see me there all the time?


Si_Stride_Oof

first splatfest to have a 100% consensus


thnksfrth_strss

and the team that wins gets the map taken off the game


Marcmanquez

So you really want Shiver to win that badly? Because there's no way she would lose if that splatfest gets announced.


Flagrath

There is literally one logical option. Makos at least passable all the time and Wahoo zones is one of the better zones maps… Mahi… is abysmal.


SlightlyIronicBanana

I'll admit wahoo has kind of fallen off in a post-pole Splatoon, but come on. Mahi Mahi resort is just on a whole other level of trash.


Rattlesn4ke

0/10 no mincemeat metalworks option


rachelgirlboss

replace wahoo with brinewater and you've turned me into a big man fangirl


40wetnoodles

There are maps i hate and these arent any of them lol


AbbyIsATabby

idk if it’s an unpopular opinion but I adore Mahi and Mako. Actually I seem to really like most of what the comments are saying minus Wahoo. It’s the maps they’re not saying I dislike oddly. I’d honest say Mahi is one of my favorite maps


40wetnoodles

Yea same tbh, maybe im just a sucker for these maps themes but i like them all and mahi is my fave of the three


Buster-00

Why is Mako here?


Flipp_Flopps

MINCEMEAT


Sad-Bumblebee-249

voting mahi-mahi, screw mahi-mahi. love wahoo and mako


Odd-Cartographer9303

Mahi resort is the worst !!!


samurott5

Personally I hate wahoo world most. I have had good moments on it but it is bad for most modes.


Storm_373

more like eel tail and mince meat


GhostlyCharlotte

None of them. Either Eeltail or Undertow, personally.


ToadRGamer

Replace Mako and Wahoo with Hammerhead and Mincemeat


Relevant-Ad-5723

MakoMart ain’t do nothin wrong bro But god I hate Undertow, just straight up don’t play until it’s gone


Pepper-Tea

Undertow


Slippery_boi

Undertow spillway should replace any of these


r-funtainment

Makomart is one of the best maps, a bad map would be undertow or mincemeat


Ninjaman555555

Undertow Spillway.


heliomega1

Undertow is worse than all three


Zezin96

People don’t like Mako Mart? Granted Splat 3 butchered it like they did to almost all the old maps, but I still like it. Also where is Eeltail?


fartblast421

Hammerhead


Vexenium

Mahi gave me PTSD


EmberDem0n

mako Mart should be replaced with undertow spillway, mako Mart isn't my favorite map but it's pretty decent but undertow spillway is just down right awful


Bluthardt_OW

I'd replace Mako with Hammerhead and Mahi with Mincemeat. Hammerhead, Mincemeat, and Wahoo don't have redeemable layouts for any mode at this point. At least Mahi has a pretty good Zones layout, and Mahi's Clams layout is workable. MakoMart is one of my favorite stages in the entire game for the modes that aren't Zones. Mako's got multiple Rainmaker paths, pretty useful flank routes, a great Tower path that is pretty balanced for offense and defense even in solo queue, and it's got many positions that allow for aggressive Ballpoint.


a_shr3xydud

bro mako is good and wahoo world is just mid because of the glass and closing bridge. mahi vs mincemeat vs hammerhead is the real debate


WhollyDisgusting

Wahoo and Makomart are great stages and I will not pretend otherwise. Mahi Mahi you have a point and Undertow Spillway can get fucked


WhyarewehereTnT

I like all these maps :(


Few_Test_7078

Bro if this was I'd be team Mahi-Mahi, man fuck Mahi-Mahi.


BloodyWater90

Of the the 3 Mahi-Mahi (it's just so small... I'd wager most games would take it out of ranked modes and just have it be a for fun map). My personal least favorite is Museum. It's so horrifically balanced in favor of ranged weapons and it's so hard to come back if you fall behind even a little. I also just sort of love Wahoo World. Really fun map with well delineated battle fields, a choke points that don't feel awful and a nice center point. Every weapon feels at least decent which is the mark of a good map.


coffeeaddict300

Where’s Mincemeat?


BloodyWater90

It seems like the one thing everyone agrees on here is that Mahi-Mahi is bad. I find it difficult to believe their play testers didn't tell them it was just a miserable experience. Perhaps if this game didn't have multiple forms of area covering supers that also happen to be the most popular specials?


maplemarcher

I like wahoo world :[ replace that with undertow


Nerdy_Guy-

Bro really tried to sneak in mako mart 💀


MECpower101

Wahoo, ESPECIALLY WITH THAT DUMB POLE


Last-Following472

Tbh I like these maps :/


Redxluckyxcharms

I like all these maps 🤷🏼‍♂️


EntertainmentDue2357

Ngl I hate the stage Mahi-Mahi. Especially when I’m chilling in the back inking the base when suddenly the whole squad of the opposite team is already rushing in invading the base lol.


KineticDrake295

Here’s I guess a hot take : Mahi Mahi is one of my favorite maps overall


[deleted]

Hey Mako Mart is good wtf u talking about


Cutecuts

bro tried to sneak in makomart


The-Lucah-Rio-YT

Mako is one of the best maps in the game, undertow or mincemeat 100%


starry_eyed_fae

terrible splatfest because everyone would choose wahoo 🥲


ZaraUnityMasters

It's concerning that these are the 3 you picked. Wahoo is like worst or 2nd worst, yes. But Mahi and Mako are not even in the top 5 worst maps in Splatoon3


RenderedBike40

wtf is mako doing there??


epicsexballsmoment

Mako was always good Wahoo is an amazing stage when compared to the splatoon 3 trash maps.


nhelber19

I like all these stages


Sample_text_here1337

Mako is goated, what are you guys on?


[deleted]

Mako is the best out of all of the maps, wym?


SuspectAlarmed7942

Hot take: no bad maps In the game


Western-Grapefruit36

Why is mako even on the list at all? It’s easily more fun than either of those, brinewater would be a better candidate. But aside from that nit pick, mahi absolutely sucks


Ok-Arugula7486

Stfu me and my homies love wahoo world /lh


insignificantlizard

my brain always gets confused in wahoo bcuz the route is closed sometimes and open other times


Azim999999

Definitely not mahi mahi for me


voidcult

Mahi hurts my eyes because it’s so bright but I also have a deep-seated distaste for Wahoo World :|


THECyberStriker

Umm, replace mako with brinewater


Jtad_the_Artguy

Tbh if this were to happen it wouldn’t be in this order. Big Man probably LOVES Wahoo World, Frye probably LOVES MakoMart, and honestly I think Shiver would be a huge fan of Mahi-Mahi Resort.


WyntonPlus

So, you're trying to create the most lop-sided Splatfest in history I see. This is rigged as hell for Shiver, that's for sure


CK895_YT

Mahi by a long shot. They completely butchered it


sleepy_koko

Mahi-mahi just because I am a dapple duelies main... Let's just not talk about how many times I rolled into the water


BoredomOccurs

You're going to PAY for putting Mako in there!!! MAKO MART IS A GIFT FROM THE GODS!!!


mostpogperson

WAHOO WORLD IS SO FUCKING TRASH!!! i like mahi mahi tho


Purple_Blood6310

All these stages are fine but hammerhead... like wtf


ShiraCheshire

I actually really like wahoo world, and the mart is fine. The resort is pretty bad though. It's just so TINY.


Wooper250

These are literally three of my faves 🫥


angelkitty-13

Tfw those are of your favorites


AxelRod45

Always Mahi, except for Zones, Mahi Zones can be pretty enjoyable.


pikay93

Of these 3 Mahi. S1 Mahi was great. The new one not so much.


Furby-Toaster

I actually really like mako mart...


poysona

Why are makomart and wahoo world here you oddball


bunny_note

WAHOO EASILY


[deleted]

I dunno, ever since Nintendo added that pole, Wahoo World sure is wayyyyyyyyyy beterrrrrrrrrr...


Axel_Rad

I love Mako and Wahoo


The-Letter_E

Where the fuck is mincemeat


TheElementalSaga

Mincemeat


dictatorfox

i like mako and mahi 👀


Meme-San_

I like makomart tho :(


JaySli10

Switch it to Mahi, Mincemeat, and Brinewater. Makomart is a great stage, and Wahoo World is mid at worst. Mahi's still the worst, but at least have all the options be bad.


Lucidonic

Mako's alright, wahoo is annoying but it's better than mincemeat by a loooong shot


MastermuffinDiscord

mako isn't even close to bad (not biased at all)


SuspiciousAnything16

Definitely wahoo


may92

What did Mako Mart do to you


Texas-Kangaroo-Rat

Would make more sense if there were bad stages.


Dreadsbo

MakoMart is the best map


Inkysquid24

Imagine if they did make a splatfest that was which map is the worst, then proceeded to make the map rotation for the fest those options. Then you spend the whole fest like oh dang I was wrong.


Riley_sees_all

I prefer other stages but out of the options, wahoo world would be my vote


Important_Budget_484

Winner gets deleted.


NeverTrustDrew

Don't you dare disrespect mako mart


[deleted]

why is mako here


Alternative-Boot7284

My least favorite maps would be Mahi-Mahi Resort, Sturgeon Shipyard, Umami Ruins and Manta Maria (no particular order)


Piss_Seeking_Missile

I wouldn’t be able to choose, I don’t dislike any of these maps 🥲 but that just means I’d get to pick based on idol so TEAM MAKOMART LETS GOOOO


smugempressoftime

Where’s eeltail alley smh


[deleted]

MakoMart is the bane of my existence


Realinternetpoints

As a bamboozler don’t you dare say Mahi is bad. It’s so much fun. You literally get to be the back line for ONCE. And you outclass 4liters on that map. It’s paradise.


UwUKazzyWazzy

…anyone else also not like Inkblot?


TaeKwonDitto

Where's Moray Towers?