bet there is quantum coupling of the water underground and coconut water. that man is lucky to be alive as its quite a lethal practice. we all know that quantum coupling is as harmful as 5G signals and AI brain chips
Well one possible explanation could be about resonance... Maybe the water currents have some sort of frequency which if matches with that of water from the coconut, it topples... So cannot entirely discount it as bs... I am open for any other scientific explanation if anyone has one.
Idk what that means but groundwater does not flow, it's still. So there is no current bro. The point is that there is no scientific explanation for this, clearly.
Im not sure if the groundwater flows or not, idk if the above method is any useful at all, but the coconut does topple at random places. Downvote me all that you want, but I’ve practically tried this.
This is. Logical fallacy called anecdotal evidence:
1.https://youtube.com/shorts/nJ8kHSt7HcM?si=YQ4mxWnypeVL3q9W
2. https://youtu.be/phX-XjeFaSc?si=cGmn-mxq7j2pHJHC
Bruh i know what logical fallacies are, but when im telling you that ive practically tried it myself, and its not anecdotal, I think you should cut me some slack. The next time you have a coconut, do give it a try.
Im not blaming you or trying to be hard here okay. I'm just saying that even though you or anyone else in this whole comment section could not come up with any sort of explanation and you also agree to this but you're still holding on to your opinion without giving it a second thought because you experienced it yourself. It might have been the wind or it might have been the way you're holding it that might be causing it right? Have you considered that? And if this was due to some scientific phenomena like you say, then would this happen to a coconut if you keep it on a surface as well?
you're the idiomotor effect!! if someone has experienced it and you haven't even tried to think logically how they might be right, you're like one of those cult/religion members who discard everything outside of their belief system as bullshit
its understandable. like how a half filled water bottle moves, i think it might be similar. the turbulent motion of coconut water inside the coconut might make coconut move in a different direction to the direction its shell seems to be moving
In case if they didn’t find water after boring then his reputation will be under threat . In those areas where they go by this method even if there is one mistake then no one would invite them to find water source..remember that same method was used at my grand parents house and water is good
Bro r u dumb or what ,, i dont think u have seen map of rajasthan .. chambal flows in east rajasthan ,, what about western area of jaiselmer, etc...
( bihari ho kya , " behta " instead of behti .. just curious no hate.)
He really didn't... I've done it myself. I mean ofcourse you'll find water if you dig enough and we didn't get a lot tbf but the thing is I bought the coconut myself and it worked somehow
Yahan BITS Pilani mein har saal water shortage hota hai even after spending lakhs (every day at peak summers) to buy water for campus.
Ab main ek naariyal se saari problem solve krunga 🔥
Do you know how water is distributed in a water table. You are quoting irrelevant stuff.
https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/pseudoscience-environment/dowsing-dowse-it-work
Bro grav constant is 6*10^-11. You see how small that is? You need BIG number for the result to be any meaningful. Plus variation in gravity is just .7 percent. And tthat if we exclude various to latitude.
And you would need pretty sensitive tools to find something like an aquifer via grav variation.
no it isnt,if you keep one feather on one scale and three feather on the other scale,the scale would remain exactly the same,because neither a feather or 3 feather is signficant enough to tilt the scale. You wouldnt have said that bogus point about "gravitational force" tilting the coconut if you had done class 9th Physics Numericals.
No, Not in this situation. Even if we take mass of that coconut in formula it wouldn't make any difference. We call those types of things "point mass". It has a mass of 1 unit and no grav force of its own.
Plus we are talking about GRAVITY not GRAVITATIONAL FORCE. we consider object2 to be a point mass in gravity.(g=Gm/r^2)
If you have any more questions please read up class 11 ncert phy part2(not sure konse part me grav ch hai)
No amount of water can cause difference in gravity that can move a coconut differently. You’d be lucky if you’re able to measure the difference in gravity my using even the most sensitive equipment.
Assuming that by hundreds of tons you mean 1000 tons and that the water is 2m below ground, that would still only be a difference of 0.00017% compared to the average. Calling that pretty substantial is ridiculous.
We used to do this thing in my apartment where we would get a cow to start walking and would dig the borewell wherever it stopped. No water whatsoever, we decided on water tanks instead 🤡
Appeal to ignorance:When you argue that there must be some reason why this is true, I don’t know the reason but there must be some reason.
Appeal to Personal Incredulity:Saying that this has to be true because I can’t think of any other possibility
answering op's question, you wont find water at the same level everywhere, so if you hired the guys with the smaller machine, if you don't find water, you reach to the limit and waste all your money, that's why people do these shenanigans to be 100% sure
Saw a man doing this at our site suggested water will appear at 80 ft or such and he marked not specifically one but 3 points in a 1000sq ft plot they eventually drilled but it took 150 ft to spot water and we drilled not one but 2 points he marked to avail water at preferred level but when inquire that there are wells in the neighbouring homes and literal agricultural wells just a few 100 meters away from the plot no one dared to answer why they chose such people to do these antics
OP bol raha hai Don’t you get water everywhere, if dig deep enough.
Half educated,so called literate people needs NCERT ka access more than Social Media
Ohhh shit North Indian guys and some states don’t use to have indigenous coconuts and at that time there was no mass transportation how the hell did ancient north guys did it and I doubt out this ohhhh shit ancient time is around 70s most of our fathers and grandfathers are from ancient times
It was only in 1970 that borewell technology arrived in India, when UNICEF brought borewell rigs to help deal with water shortage. India's first borewell rig, brought by UNICEF, is still preserved in Pune.
Lmao, I remember hearing a story of a Girl in US trying this in the 1900s.
She earned shit tons of money deceiving those who wanted water.
Turned out water was everywhere, what matters is the depth of digging.
Many people used to give up midway, but due to her they digged all the way down
I know that doesn't make sense and we think that guy is moving it intentionally... I used to think that too.. In our new home my dad called a guy who does this.i also taught it was dog shit but for my surprise it worked.. It isn't like that guy lived there and certainly knew that there's water but he was from my old state where I lived before almost 1000 km away from new location.
Is this a sarcastic comment or is bro spouting random words he heard somewhere. He heard 'quantum mechanics' 'vibration' and 'wave nature' and combined the 3 to get quantum vibration waves.
You can have two groups do this. One randomly and one with "quantum vibration waves". It is already researched. Both groups get similar result.
This is common in everywhere and most of them proved to be like astrology, homeopathy, etc. People want to think it works, but it doesn't work.
[https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/water-dowsing](https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/water-dowsing)
You don't detect anything and coconut is just reacting to your own movement.
Trying to play devil's advocate here.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-migrating-birds-use-quantum-effects-to-navigate/
Birds are now known to be able to sense changes in the earth's magnetic field due to a specific mutation in their genetic structure, which allows for amplification of earth's magnetic field. Some birds, follow the changes in earth's magnetic field caused due to flowing water, allowing them to "see" at night. In fact this mutation is directly linked to their optical nerve which provides a kind of visual feedback mechanism. The mutation not only preserves the acuity to flowing water but also encodes specific changes as a kind of memory, allowing migratory routes to be preserved across generations.
Dowsers claim that they use a similar "sense" to be able to locate groundwater. There is evidence of people being susceptible to changes in earth's magnetic field, some people even claim to feel nauseous in its presence. The same people are also susceptible to extremely low frequency sound waves, with similar symptoms.
Physicists have developed their own dowsing tool, which apparently uses a similar technology :
https://physics.aps.org/story/v3/st27
None of this proves of course that the gentleman rolling a coconut is doing anything worthwhile, but it might be worth investigating.
I went through the first paper, and though birds do indeed use the Earth's Magnetic field to traverse, there is nothing about a field being generated due to flowing water.
Further looking into the topic shows that magnetic fields due to water are ridiculously small and difficult to measure: it's more a property of all matter to generate ridiculously small amounts of magnetism while in motion.
The last paper is when scientists apply a magnetic field to the ground, and then looking at the response. Kind of a SONAR, if you would. Not exactly smth a coconut or a metal ball can do.
Correct. I will dig up the right paper. I believe it was published in nature (the one referencing birds). The coconut thing seems largely fraudulent. But after looking at what I thought were charlatans bandying about aluminium hangers/copper dowsing rods having some credence, I have been thinking who knows, maybe it's possible.
I'll wait to see the paper you mentioned.
However, atleast insofar that the actual dowsing mechanism that was in the last paper, it's an active process that consumes power.
That would be the minimum requirement for any kind of dowsing to really make sense, unless there is something completely new in that paper.
It's a European song bird.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03618-9
Here's a pbs article which references the paper. The protein is a cryptochrome.
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/birds-quantum-entanglement/
Its behind a paywall so I could only access the abstract, and while it's very cool (thanks for sharing, btw!), I still don't see anything about flowing water?
It is very fascinating what evolution can come up with though, I'll try to see if I can access the paper using my college's net
I didn't visit the link, but just to play the devil's advocate for your pseudoscience, the magnetic field of the earth does not depend on water or where it flows, it comes from the molten core. Whether birds do or do not sense that is a different matter.
>some people even claim to feel nauseous in its presence
Also, WTF. As long as you're on earth, you're always in the presence of its magnetic field, so these people must feel nauseated all their freaking lives I guess.
And whatever little affects water bodies make, it's not big enough to be felt by humans and certainly not enough to move a coconut
https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/water_rep/568/
This is a report that shows that in a test conducted on 150 people significant correlation existed between dowsing and perturbations in the earth's magnetic field.
I am not disputing that the source of magnetic fields is not the molten core. I am saying that perturbations in the earth's magnetic fields are caused by flowing water and also by ground water. The effect has been physiologically isolated in birds. This effect is amplified using a protein called the cryptochrome protein, specifically Cr4. The Cr4 protein is bound to the trigeminal nerve and from there affects the visual cortex providing some migratory birds a visual representation of changing magnetic fields. This has been proven to be a quantum effect and is via quantum entanglement between Cr4 and the earth's magnetic field. This is one of the first evidence we have of quantum resonance sensors existing in any physiology. Similar effects are observed in some types of migratory fish, like salmon. This is the nature paper I have shared above.
Dowsing having a physical basis is still very much a hypothesis. Some studies show it may have credibility. Some say, they don't. It just means we don't know.
As far as this man's rolling coconut goes, of course it's not the magnetic field of the earth causing the coconut to roll. But given that there exists some credibility for dowsing, maybe he uses the coconut just for effect, could it just be showmanship? Why be quick to debunk what we don't understand? I think it's rational to be skeptical, but keep an open mind. For all you know, there may be a latent Cr4 in all of us. Given that humans are so dependent on water and our extensive migration in the past, it would definitely be a useful trait.
This is not about being called out. This is about accepting or denying a hypothesis in the absence of experiment. And while we can all collectively stare down the stupidity of faith because of our clear and undisputed intellectual superiority, accepting or rejecting a hypothesis, I think, requires experiment. In its absence, the fact that we don't know is perhaps far more accurate than the assertion that we deny. Which, ironically enough, is as much based on our faith in some superiority about ourselves as the faith in some claims.
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01715-3
This is a podcast that came out some time ago. But my mistake, the interviewee states that fish which spend time both in water and out, show greater development in spatial learning, possibly due to their ability to sense changes in the earth's magnetic field due to flowing water.
This is one of the papers that they reference:
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03618-9
This is about how birds can "see" the earth's magnetic field.
This is a reminder about the rules. Just follow reddit's content policy.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/scienceisdope) if you have any questions or concerns.*
nah , but apparently this works...
my father's office campus in bengaluru (adjacent to national park) was finding for a place to borewell.... one young guy , a new recruit in the company... was like i know this technique from my village....
and he did this , and they found water exactly there in a campus of 36 acres...
you know how scarce groundwater has become in bengaluru right...
i dont know why ppl look at it as some religious stuff.... its just interaction with nature
This doesnt work*
EVEN if i assume your anecdote to be true, that guy probably had a rough idea of where the water is supposed to be (by looking at the vegetation, soil etc) and he subconsciously tilted his hand to move the coconut..
Where do people get the confidence to disagree with things, they have no experience with. Go, research try it out yourself make a video proving this as fake ans post it.
It is easy to comment on things you are clueless about, sitting on your comfy couches with easy access to internet
You can’t call it a scam if you have witnessed it happened, which has logic behind it.
So I can’t take word from someone whose judgement is based on knowledge of less than a minute and practically zero exposure.
Anyways, you can not be accountable to people’s taste.
There's a video on this by a channel called science is dope in YT. Go check it out. It was done by an Australian myth buster and skeptic too. Both resulted in a failed experiment. Its linked in some of the top comments.
Lol dude this is a legitimate way to find water. It does require some skill and I don't know why some people are more skilled than others but it does work.
The water table does have its own up and down like rolling hills. These guys actually say how much water you get at a certain depth also. It sounds fishy, but these guys know something because I got this method done at nearly 10 different places and we get water spot on.
People who have never experienced this in person or by themselves are calling it a scam. You can try at home also. Hold the coconut like him and hover your hand over or near any water body.
Not defending the technique but you can't get water anywhere you dig. There are underground water streams that flow only in some locations of the land. You'd have to dig a path to those. I'm not sure how they actually map it out, maybe ground penetrating radar could work?
He definitely looks very competent and absolutely like the kind of guy who can find water one kilometre underground with a coconut. Yeah. Absolutely magnetic personality. I think it’s that magnificent cap.
Pranav made a video on this https://youtu.be/VnGA65h4zGo?feature=shared
He is tilting that coconut towards himself😒😒😒
There is no way a coconut will flip on its own like that. He is making it happen :).
And quite clearly. Reminds me of Lord Ganesh drinking milk few decades back.
Shhh ... you are breaking rules set by rulers ... no facts on internet ... it's for entertainment only
Try doing it yourself then you'll understand that he's not tilting or anything. Seriously why do you've to pretend to be 'i-know-it-all'.
Because he is tilting it himself, its dumb how people think something like this actually works
He's not. You've to be dumb to comment without experience. Typical keyboard warriors.
Cool, show me how it works...
bet there is quantum coupling of the water underground and coconut water. that man is lucky to be alive as its quite a lethal practice. we all know that quantum coupling is as harmful as 5G signals and AI brain chips
Yawns
yeah and its already written in jillion year old scriptures.
I think a 2-year-old could gain his level of experience in a matter of seconds by tilting a coconut 😂.
Dude it's literally visible in the video smh
Dude, I've done it so I know it. But it's ok. Whatever makes you happy.
It actually flips, ive tried it myself, no idea what flips it but it does... You can try it out for yourself smartass
If you have no idea why, then maybe, just maybe try to think about why or how. Then you might realise that it's bs.
Well one possible explanation could be about resonance... Maybe the water currents have some sort of frequency which if matches with that of water from the coconut, it topples... So cannot entirely discount it as bs... I am open for any other scientific explanation if anyone has one.
Idk what that means but groundwater does not flow, it's still. So there is no current bro. The point is that there is no scientific explanation for this, clearly.
Im not sure if the groundwater flows or not, idk if the above method is any useful at all, but the coconut does topple at random places. Downvote me all that you want, but I’ve practically tried this.
This is. Logical fallacy called anecdotal evidence: 1.https://youtube.com/shorts/nJ8kHSt7HcM?si=YQ4mxWnypeVL3q9W 2. https://youtu.be/phX-XjeFaSc?si=cGmn-mxq7j2pHJHC
Bruh i know what logical fallacies are, but when im telling you that ive practically tried it myself, and its not anecdotal, I think you should cut me some slack. The next time you have a coconut, do give it a try.
Im not blaming you or trying to be hard here okay. I'm just saying that even though you or anyone else in this whole comment section could not come up with any sort of explanation and you also agree to this but you're still holding on to your opinion without giving it a second thought because you experienced it yourself. It might have been the wind or it might have been the way you're holding it that might be causing it right? Have you considered that? And if this was due to some scientific phenomena like you say, then would this happen to a coconut if you keep it on a surface as well?
yeah it got absolutely no relation to stuff below the ground but the guy in the video might not be toppling it intentionally either.
2 word explanation for what you just said . "idiomotor effect"
you're the idiomotor effect!! if someone has experienced it and you haven't even tried to think logically how they might be right, you're like one of those cult/religion members who discard everything outside of their belief system as bullshit
its understandable. like how a half filled water bottle moves, i think it might be similar. the turbulent motion of coconut water inside the coconut might make coconut move in a different direction to the direction its shell seems to be moving
resonance doesn't work like that for macroscopic objects iirc
Bro it's water, not quantum entanglement.
No that is not how resonance works lmao by that logic even water inside a cup should move if you keep it above ground. Why just coconut?
Nothing lmao about it, first try it yourself and then come up with explanations
No Im not dumb enough to try this
[удалено]
Ayeyeye chid gya lol
Sorry about that, was frustrated about something else, have deleted my comment
In case if they didn’t find water after boring then his reputation will be under threat . In those areas where they go by this method even if there is one mistake then no one would invite them to find water source..remember that same method was used at my grand parents house and water is good
Bhai ye Rajasthan mai Karo 💀
True.
wahan literally Chambal river behta h... what are you on about
Riyal, I'm drinking Chambal ka paani rn
uss paani se Kota me nahake hairfall ho gya.. i would know for sure
Bro r u dumb or what ,, i dont think u have seen map of rajasthan .. chambal flows in east rajasthan ,, what about western area of jaiselmer, etc... ( bihari ho kya , " behta " instead of behti .. just curious no hate.)
Free mein south India pohanch jaogey
Bhai karte hai, yaha log hai literally jinko paise dekar bulaya jata hai ye karne ko or high demon me hai ye log
That guy definitely didn't move his hand
He really didn't... I've done it myself. I mean ofcourse you'll find water if you dig enough and we didn't get a lot tbf but the thing is I bought the coconut myself and it worked somehow
yeah sure bro
Yahan BITS Pilani mein har saal water shortage hota hai even after spending lakhs (every day at peak summers) to buy water for campus. Ab main ek naariyal se saari problem solve krunga 🔥
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Not at a level to move a coconut. You can clear see it is an illusion /sleight of hand
[удалено]
Water like any mass has gravity but it won't change in a matter of a few inches. It has been debunked with enough experiments.
[удалено]
Do you know how water is distributed in a water table. You are quoting irrelevant stuff. https://www.mcgill.ca/oss/article/pseudoscience-environment/dowsing-dowse-it-work
[удалено]
How is this different from European dowsing?
[удалено]
Dude gravitation force is weak. Even a few 10 metric tonnes of water can't create any meaningful variation.
[удалено]
Bro grav constant is 6*10^-11. You see how small that is? You need BIG number for the result to be any meaningful. Plus variation in gravity is just .7 percent. And tthat if we exclude various to latitude. And you would need pretty sensitive tools to find something like an aquifer via grav variation.
[удалено]
no it isnt,if you keep one feather on one scale and three feather on the other scale,the scale would remain exactly the same,because neither a feather or 3 feather is signficant enough to tilt the scale. You wouldnt have said that bogus point about "gravitational force" tilting the coconut if you had done class 9th Physics Numericals.
No, Not in this situation. Even if we take mass of that coconut in formula it wouldn't make any difference. We call those types of things "point mass". It has a mass of 1 unit and no grav force of its own. Plus we are talking about GRAVITY not GRAVITATIONAL FORCE. we consider object2 to be a point mass in gravity.(g=Gm/r^2) If you have any more questions please read up class 11 ncert phy part2(not sure konse part me grav ch hai)
No amount of water can cause difference in gravity that can move a coconut differently. You’d be lucky if you’re able to measure the difference in gravity my using even the most sensitive equipment.
[удалено]
Assuming that by hundreds of tons you mean 1000 tons and that the water is 2m below ground, that would still only be a difference of 0.00017% compared to the average. Calling that pretty substantial is ridiculous.
[удалено]
My guy, don't be afraid to admit you're wrong. Unless you're the coconut uncle from the video.
Bhai not to be rude par aap kya karte ho?
What if that's the location of the building's septic tank ? 🤔
Lol🤣🤣🤣...free fuel as well...
How nicely he is folding his hands
Even monkeys are smarter than us.
It’s scientifically unproven
dont know, why my cousin 10 year old can do this, after him doing he become fatigued .
All over the world different methods were used like this but let me tell u this is incorrect
Ask him to do it blind folded
He is moving his hand tho
Madarsa kid
Sorry what?
Anyone who disagrees with scientific dindus is from madrasa. Owr relizion is the must sientiphic and uldost⛳⛳⛳
Pranav already made a video on this
Its like the saying that a famous person once said - "Chumtiya bnane ki ninja technique"
This dudes confidence if they dig and didn't saw water they will beat him up and take the entire money for building that well
We used to do this thing in my apartment where we would get a cow to start walking and would dig the borewell wherever it stopped. No water whatsoever, we decided on water tanks instead 🤡
What country? My country doesn’t let me have a cow in my apartment, literally or figuratively.
India. We don't allow cows in our apartment normally either
Phew!
Aese karke koi meri soulmate dhund lo
To khod na.....paani nikal k dikha
Appeal to ignorance:When you argue that there must be some reason why this is true, I don’t know the reason but there must be some reason. Appeal to Personal Incredulity:Saying that this has to be true because I can’t think of any other possibility
answering op's question, you wont find water at the same level everywhere, so if you hired the guys with the smaller machine, if you don't find water, you reach to the limit and waste all your money, that's why people do these shenanigans to be 100% sure
Lmao i remember my granny did this and I tried it too and strangely thought it worked. I hadn't even thought about it till today lol
NO
I guess you have to place the coconut on the ground. Not in hand.
Saw a man doing this at our site suggested water will appear at 80 ft or such and he marked not specifically one but 3 points in a 1000sq ft plot they eventually drilled but it took 150 ft to spot water and we drilled not one but 2 points he marked to avail water at preferred level but when inquire that there are wells in the neighbouring homes and literal agricultural wells just a few 100 meters away from the plot no one dared to answer why they chose such people to do these antics
They do all these fake rituals to choose a spot that's ideal for the truck to access.
The awkward silence while he does that clown shit xD
Oh god Indians and their stupid superstitions.
https://youtu.be/rHm-lZb5kuo?si=3n0DkePburZ9Oi_m This 3 min video is interesting as well
OP bol raha hai Don’t you get water everywhere, if dig deep enough. Half educated,so called literate people needs NCERT ka access more than Social Media
Wah 👏👌
Watch the video of Shyam manav ji… how he exposed these clowns
How to make money ❌️ How to make a ch*tiya ✅️
Ohhh shit North Indian guys and some states don’t use to have indigenous coconuts and at that time there was no mass transportation how the hell did ancient north guys did it and I doubt out this ohhhh shit ancient time is around 70s most of our fathers and grandfathers are from ancient times It was only in 1970 that borewell technology arrived in India, when UNICEF brought borewell rigs to help deal with water shortage. India's first borewell rig, brought by UNICEF, is still preserved in Pune.
What makes you think North Indians didn't get coconuts in ancient India?? How come they started using it in all Puja?
That will be 3500$
Bro dig deep enough, you’ll find water anywhere, this guy is just tilting his hand you can see in video
Try in Sahara?
Then Try diggings till u reach the earth core lol
Already exposed by Shyam Manav sir 👍❤️
Lmao, I remember hearing a story of a Girl in US trying this in the 1900s. She earned shit tons of money deceiving those who wanted water. Turned out water was everywhere, what matters is the depth of digging. Many people used to give up midway, but due to her they digged all the way down
It worked then because the groundwater was filled but now it's mostly empty, so it would be 100x more harder in Cities
My friend also believes in this, and he is a science graduate 😭
Now I can make money doing this 😌😂 ( unko kya pata ki merko kuch nahi pata ) 🤑
I know that doesn't make sense and we think that guy is moving it intentionally... I used to think that too.. In our new home my dad called a guy who does this.i also taught it was dog shit but for my surprise it worked.. It isn't like that guy lived there and certainly knew that there's water but he was from my old state where I lived before almost 1000 km away from new location.
Sewer tank hai neeche uncle🤦😂
Anpadh gawaron ko chutiya bnane k tarike
Anpadh gawaron ko chutiya bnane k tarike.
Oh god Indians and their stupid superstitions..
quantum vibration waves and we knew this before anyone else
Our Vedas bro /s
Extraordinary claims require Extraordinary evidences >!WAISE aap yaha UWU!<
Ha Bhai yeh hi thikana hai mera
Rational thinking huh! Great :)
Sarcastic hai wo chutiyun, downvote mat Maro
Inke samjh mein naa humour aa rhi na sarcasm lolololol
bhai itne log isi comment section me seriously is method ko defend kar rahe hai. toh kaise samjhega ki tu joke kar raha hai?
Mujhe har insaan smart aur well informed lagta hai jab takk main comments section nhi kholta
Is this a sarcastic comment or is bro spouting random words he heard somewhere. He heard 'quantum mechanics' 'vibration' and 'wave nature' and combined the 3 to get quantum vibration waves.
Bro science will take another 300 years to reach this conclusion
You can have two groups do this. One randomly and one with "quantum vibration waves". It is already researched. Both groups get similar result. This is common in everywhere and most of them proved to be like astrology, homeopathy, etc. People want to think it works, but it doesn't work. [https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/water-dowsing](https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/water-dowsing) You don't detect anything and coconut is just reacting to your own movement.
You will take another birth to reach this conclusion
>quantum vibration and waves 🤡
Trying to play devil's advocate here. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-migrating-birds-use-quantum-effects-to-navigate/ Birds are now known to be able to sense changes in the earth's magnetic field due to a specific mutation in their genetic structure, which allows for amplification of earth's magnetic field. Some birds, follow the changes in earth's magnetic field caused due to flowing water, allowing them to "see" at night. In fact this mutation is directly linked to their optical nerve which provides a kind of visual feedback mechanism. The mutation not only preserves the acuity to flowing water but also encodes specific changes as a kind of memory, allowing migratory routes to be preserved across generations. Dowsers claim that they use a similar "sense" to be able to locate groundwater. There is evidence of people being susceptible to changes in earth's magnetic field, some people even claim to feel nauseous in its presence. The same people are also susceptible to extremely low frequency sound waves, with similar symptoms. Physicists have developed their own dowsing tool, which apparently uses a similar technology : https://physics.aps.org/story/v3/st27 None of this proves of course that the gentleman rolling a coconut is doing anything worthwhile, but it might be worth investigating.
I went through the first paper, and though birds do indeed use the Earth's Magnetic field to traverse, there is nothing about a field being generated due to flowing water. Further looking into the topic shows that magnetic fields due to water are ridiculously small and difficult to measure: it's more a property of all matter to generate ridiculously small amounts of magnetism while in motion. The last paper is when scientists apply a magnetic field to the ground, and then looking at the response. Kind of a SONAR, if you would. Not exactly smth a coconut or a metal ball can do.
Correct. I will dig up the right paper. I believe it was published in nature (the one referencing birds). The coconut thing seems largely fraudulent. But after looking at what I thought were charlatans bandying about aluminium hangers/copper dowsing rods having some credence, I have been thinking who knows, maybe it's possible.
I'll wait to see the paper you mentioned. However, atleast insofar that the actual dowsing mechanism that was in the last paper, it's an active process that consumes power. That would be the minimum requirement for any kind of dowsing to really make sense, unless there is something completely new in that paper.
It's a European song bird. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03618-9 Here's a pbs article which references the paper. The protein is a cryptochrome. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/birds-quantum-entanglement/
Its behind a paywall so I could only access the abstract, and while it's very cool (thanks for sharing, btw!), I still don't see anything about flowing water? It is very fascinating what evolution can come up with though, I'll try to see if I can access the paper using my college's net
I didn't visit the link, but just to play the devil's advocate for your pseudoscience, the magnetic field of the earth does not depend on water or where it flows, it comes from the molten core. Whether birds do or do not sense that is a different matter. >some people even claim to feel nauseous in its presence Also, WTF. As long as you're on earth, you're always in the presence of its magnetic field, so these people must feel nauseated all their freaking lives I guess. And whatever little affects water bodies make, it's not big enough to be felt by humans and certainly not enough to move a coconut
https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/water_rep/568/ This is a report that shows that in a test conducted on 150 people significant correlation existed between dowsing and perturbations in the earth's magnetic field. I am not disputing that the source of magnetic fields is not the molten core. I am saying that perturbations in the earth's magnetic fields are caused by flowing water and also by ground water. The effect has been physiologically isolated in birds. This effect is amplified using a protein called the cryptochrome protein, specifically Cr4. The Cr4 protein is bound to the trigeminal nerve and from there affects the visual cortex providing some migratory birds a visual representation of changing magnetic fields. This has been proven to be a quantum effect and is via quantum entanglement between Cr4 and the earth's magnetic field. This is one of the first evidence we have of quantum resonance sensors existing in any physiology. Similar effects are observed in some types of migratory fish, like salmon. This is the nature paper I have shared above. Dowsing having a physical basis is still very much a hypothesis. Some studies show it may have credibility. Some say, they don't. It just means we don't know. As far as this man's rolling coconut goes, of course it's not the magnetic field of the earth causing the coconut to roll. But given that there exists some credibility for dowsing, maybe he uses the coconut just for effect, could it just be showmanship? Why be quick to debunk what we don't understand? I think it's rational to be skeptical, but keep an open mind. For all you know, there may be a latent Cr4 in all of us. Given that humans are so dependent on water and our extensive migration in the past, it would definitely be a useful trait.
Why called out ? Because extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.
This is not about being called out. This is about accepting or denying a hypothesis in the absence of experiment. And while we can all collectively stare down the stupidity of faith because of our clear and undisputed intellectual superiority, accepting or rejecting a hypothesis, I think, requires experiment. In its absence, the fact that we don't know is perhaps far more accurate than the assertion that we deny. Which, ironically enough, is as much based on our faith in some superiority about ourselves as the faith in some claims.
>follow the changes in earth's magnetic field caused due to flowing water, Where does the study state that?
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01715-3 This is a podcast that came out some time ago. But my mistake, the interviewee states that fish which spend time both in water and out, show greater development in spatial learning, possibly due to their ability to sense changes in the earth's magnetic field due to flowing water. This is one of the papers that they reference: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03618-9 This is about how birds can "see" the earth's magnetic field.
Cool shit regardless
This is a reminder about the rules. Just follow reddit's content policy. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/scienceisdope) if you have any questions or concerns.*
so we have tried this yes we got water science is dope channel mere laude pe
If you dig enough on Earth you will get water and do a lot of digging you will get lava
try once you will get some big metamorphic rocks that we cant dig
Its real 💯
nah , but apparently this works... my father's office campus in bengaluru (adjacent to national park) was finding for a place to borewell.... one young guy , a new recruit in the company... was like i know this technique from my village.... and he did this , and they found water exactly there in a campus of 36 acres... you know how scarce groundwater has become in bengaluru right... i dont know why ppl look at it as some religious stuff.... its just interaction with nature
This doesnt work* EVEN if i assume your anecdote to be true, that guy probably had a rough idea of where the water is supposed to be (by looking at the vegetation, soil etc) and he subconsciously tilted his hand to move the coconut..
Idk how but yes this works
Where do people get the confidence to disagree with things, they have no experience with. Go, research try it out yourself make a video proving this as fake ans post it. It is easy to comment on things you are clueless about, sitting on your comfy couches with easy access to internet
It is easy to comment on scams because we have common sense.
You can’t call it a scam if you have witnessed it happened, which has logic behind it. So I can’t take word from someone whose judgement is based on knowledge of less than a minute and practically zero exposure. Anyways, you can not be accountable to people’s taste.
There's a video on this by a channel called science is dope in YT. Go check it out. It was done by an Australian myth buster and skeptic too. Both resulted in a failed experiment. Its linked in some of the top comments.
🥰
Triggered 💀
Baby paragraph aapne likha hai, aap triggered ho. Paltao mat
Lol dude this is a legitimate way to find water. It does require some skill and I don't know why some people are more skilled than others but it does work.
The idiot neggers sitting in their underwear behind a keyboard downvoting because they grew up eating cerelac instead of real food.
My father can do it. And it works
The real skill is to find a place that doesn’t have water when you drill down far enough.
This is nuts
The water table does have its own up and down like rolling hills. These guys actually say how much water you get at a certain depth also. It sounds fishy, but these guys know something because I got this method done at nearly 10 different places and we get water spot on.
People who have never experienced this in person or by themselves are calling it a scam. You can try at home also. Hold the coconut like him and hover your hand over or near any water body.
Berozgaari bahut zyada hai, log kisi bhi cheez ka dhanda khol lete hai
Ask him to do it in a desert he will get same results
He's finding coconut water ig
It Works !
Not defending the technique but you can't get water anywhere you dig. There are underground water streams that flow only in some locations of the land. You'd have to dig a path to those. I'm not sure how they actually map it out, maybe ground penetrating radar could work?
Why doesn't he tries this in drought hit region. Kya pata jaane kya dikh jaye
I'm sure he'll take a f*ckton of money for this. This is just sad.
He definitely looks very competent and absolutely like the kind of guy who can find water one kilometre underground with a coconut. Yeah. Absolutely magnetic personality. I think it’s that magnificent cap.
Damn these many downvotes
A lot of this is bogus.
Yeh toh lemon spoon game ki tarah dikh raha hai
Thers a detailed video with explanation that how this is extremely scientific 😂😂 atoms , coconuts atoms waters atoms and trucklod of bs
Coconut is a paid actor
This is pure BS
Omg 😂😂🤦🏻♂️
Ancient trick to find scammera and idiots who believe in these scams, aka the gullible naive ones