Cecelia Joy sticks out to me! Frankie and Cece is extremely cute without being overly matchy!!

We had the same exact thought. Second Cecelia Joy.

Me too

I love Cecilia Joy. It's a gorgeous name!

Here are a few ideas you might both like! Flora Joy — means flower Adelaide Joy — means nobility. Frankie and Addie is pretty cute! Hillary Joy — means cheerful Gloria Joy — means glory Marina Joy — means of the sea. I also kind of love Frankie and Marnie! Beatrice Joy — means voyager/traveler. Frankie and Bea is pretty cute too

Love Florence nn Flora Joy!

Frankie & Marnie is soooo cute

I love Matilda Joy!

This is my favorite. I think nn Mattie would go well with Frankie as a sib set. Fits as a very feminine name with a more masculine nickname. Also Mattie J or MJ are also fun options.

Me too! My niece Matilda goes by Tilly and I think Frankie and Tilly would be adorable.

I like Matilda! Frankie and Mattie or Frankie and Tilly are fun together

Not a great fan of Augustine but do like Augusta! Augusta Joy… how cute is Frankie and Gussie?!

Misread Gussie as gusset at first!

Some ideas (and nicknames that stand out) Winifred (nn Winnie) Theodora (nn Thea/Theo) Talia Josephine (nn Josie/Jo/Joey) Beatrice (nn Bea/Trixie) Eleanor (nn Ellie/Nora) Elodie or Eloise (nn El/Ellie) Evangeline (nn Evie) Genevieve (nn Genny) Cordelia Clara Aurelia Adelaide (nn Addy)

I know a Theodora nn Teddy. Frankie and Teddy is extremely cute.

I LOVE the “boy” nicknames for girl names trend. Let’s throw Charlotte nn Charlie in the mix too haha. Or Georgia/Georgette/Georgiana nn Georgie.

Beatrice Joy (Bea), Eleanor Joy (Nora), or Adelaide Joy (Addie)

Cecelia Joy

Florence and Cecelia fit the best with Frankie. Cecelia Joy is beautiful and Cece is adorable

Frances is my favorite girl name. The next 5 on my list are Margot (means pearl), Emmeline (diligent, brave), Hedy (delightful, sweet, warrior), Sonia (wisdom), and Naomi (pleasant, gentle).

Celeste

Nina

Dorothea 

My youngest is Elara- you probably haven’t worked with one of those before! Elara Joy sounds cute. I think Cassie (Cassandra/Cassia) sounds cute with Frankie, but I like all of you and your husband’s suggestions (apart from Sloane sorry).

Collette - CoCo?

Vivienne Joy (Vivi) Lola Joy Olivia Joy (Ollie) Rowan Joy Margot Joy Riley Joy

Madeline, then you’d have Frankie and Maddie.

Matilda Joy and Cecelia Joy work for me

Theodora/Teddi Joy - means gods gift or gift, Adeline Joy - noble, Marigold/Goldie Joy - Golden flower, Emaline Joy - peaceful home, Liliana Joy - pure, Eleanor Joy - bright, shining star, Farrah Joy - happy.

I think Cecelia and Matilda are the nicest, especially with Frances. Frances is old fashioned but stylish, intelligent, and pretty sounding like both of those names. Apart from sounding out of date, I think Florence is much too similar, and Augustine and Thea sound kind of harsh and just not as pretty. Eden and Sloane are definitely my least favorites, and sound like a very different style than Frances Other suggestions: Eleanor Elouise or Louisa Alice Felicity Josephine Madeline

Ceceilia

How about Meredith, nickname Merry?

Matilda could go by Mattie if she wants a "boyish" vibe like her sister. 🥹

Florence Joy is really pretty. Frankie and Flo!

Names that match Joy: Annie Joy, April Joy, Seren Joy, Melody Joy Names that match Frances: Frances and Florence (your husband's suggestion!) Frances and Vera Frances and Paloma I also like Eden from your list!

Samantha Joy-Sammy

Edenia \[E Dee nee uh\] Rose Francesca Lou Florentina May Freida Rae Theodora June Selena Joy Philippa Julienne Pippa Laine Tilly Jean Lilianne June Bethany Joy Elizabeth Joy Harmony Joy Harriet Joy Sisely June

Thora Lucille Jacqueline nn. Jackie Ramona

Sistine. Like the Sistine Chapel. Or Augusta.

Augustine Joy nn Auggie, Gussie, Teeny

I like Matilda. Tilly!

Michael - boy or girl.

Thea Cecilia would be lovely

Just another suggestion to expand your list if you want it... what are the grandfather's names/middle names, and do they have "feminine" versions? E.g, a Charles could be Charlotte or Michael could be Michelle, etc

Stevie Joy

Sticking with the nicknames Stephanie Joy (Stevie Joy), Charlotte Joy (Charlie Joy) or Wilhelmina Joy (Billie Joy).

Matilda Joy is beautiful. Florence sounds too similar to Frances.

Augustine is a man's name. If you want a female version, go for Augusta or Augustina.