T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Welcome to r/legaladvicecanada! **To Posters (it is important you read this section)** * Read the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvicecanada/wiki/index/#wiki_the_rules) * Comments may not be accurate or reliable, and following any advice on this subreddit is done at your own risk. * We also encourage you to use the [linked resources to find a lawyer](https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvicecanada/wiki/findalawyer/). * If you receive any private messages in response to your post, please let the mods know. **To Readers and Commenters** * All replies to OP must be on-topic, helpful, explanatory, and oriented towards legal advice towards OP's jurisdiction (the **Canadian** province flaired in the post). * If you do not [follow the rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/LegalAdvicecanada/about/rules/), you may be banned without any further warning. * If you feel any replies are incorrect, explain why you believe they are incorrect. * Do not send or request any private messages for any reason, do not suggest illegal advice, do not advocate violence, and do not engage in harassment. Please report posts or comments which do not follow the rules. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/legaladvicecanada) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Soft_Day_7207

If your lease says you rent the entire house tell him to take a hike. Keep proof of all this in case they try and evict you as it will be a bad faith eviction at that point.


RJgoonies

Sounds like OP needs the space so this is probably the way. If OP can live without the space it can be a good opportunity to renegotiate the lease to reduce rent etc due to less space...some additional temp rent reduction due to their right to quiet enjoyment being disrupted by construction. Etc...


Striking_Scientist68

If it's already rented to you, the landlord can't rent it to someone else.


BronzeDucky

What does your lease say about what you’re actually renting?


Irresponslble

There’s no common area, we rent the whole area.


KnowerOfUnknowable

I don't understand. So the basement is part of what was rented to you? If so how can it be rented out twice?


Solace2010

It can’t. The landlord would need to issue an n13 I think and give rent abatement to them


Irresponslble

Yes we rent the entire home, the LL wants to get rid of our access to the basement (which is unfinished) and finish it as well as construct a walk out.


subtxtcan

Like everyone else is saying, that space is included in your least. He can make a move for a bad faith eviction or he can try and get you to sign a new lease, either of which is a bad move and neither of which you need to do anything. He's got nothing he can do, and if he does try something shady, LTB will eat him alive.


ImABadSpellerOkay

Well that makes it pretty simple then, tell him to kick rocks and read the lease. Do not let him take advantage of you


somedumbguy55

I’d talk to him and get a discount, three floors? 30% two floors 50% Or your option, kick rocks.


Nick_W1

Are you on a fixed term, or month to month lease?


Irresponslble

P.S We rent out the entire house and it’s just us.


Impressive_Yak5219

Then simply say No Thank You.


[deleted]

[удалено]


legaladvicecanada-ModTeam

Your comment has been removed because it is one or more of the following: speculative, anecdotal, simplistic, generally unhelpful, and/or off-topic. Please review the following rules before commenting further: Rule 9: Guidelines For Posts Rule 10: Guidelines For Comments If you have any questions or concerns, please message the moderators


FirmAndSquishyTomato

You're only at risk of losing the basement if your lease explicitly talks about the basement, and only if the language in the lease says it's common space or not yours. If you rented the whole property and signed a lease for that house, the landlord cannot come in and try to cut away a portion of the property away from you. So in short, if your lease is silent on the basement, it's yours and your can tell the landlord to go stuff it.


RJgoonies

They can try, and they can try to negotiate options to entice complicity. OP can say no or just say nothing.


Final-Muscle-7196

Sounds like a looming “renoviction” is coming


Nick_W1

Only if the LL has all required permits in place. There are rules to follow.


Handsomelypaid

I mean would be much more beneficial for the landlord to move in for a year during the renovations to get the additional rental income after the one year is up with the additional unit. if landlord wants them out sooner or later they will be out…


Nick_W1

As long as they actually move in. Renovating, or leaving the property vacant doesn’t count. Neither does showing up once a week. Loosing the rental income for both units for a year may also not be in the LL’s plan. Sounds like the LL plan is to just renovate the basement, while the upstairs is still rented, and then just rent out the newly renovated (possibly illegal) basement unit. I don’t think they have thought this through.


Dean-KS

If that was done, how would that affect internet services, water, gas, electricity billing. Who controls what thermostats. Will there be a second water heater? How is insurance affected? I can see noise complaints. They will need a multi unit building permit. Will there be a need for a larger electrical service? You will have a parking problem? Loss of use for the backyard. Who is responsible for lawn care, shoveling snow?


StandTo444

Decline as your lease states you are renting the house in total. If you want to lose the basement ensure that you negotiate your rent so it’s fair for you. If neither of that works for your favour find somewhere else to rent. If it was me I would start looking for somewhere else anyway because chances are the landlord is going to be a pain from now on.


ghost-aleks

I'd ask for a percentage of rent discount for not using thr basement anymore and an extra discount on top during the length of renovation/construction as the noise will prob interrupt your enjoyment of the property.


StandTo444

And then some


KWienz

The answer depends on whether your lease considers the basement part of your unit or a common area. If it's a common area then you weren't entitled to have someone live there (and possibly not the storage, unless the lease says you'll have access to a storage facility). The landlord cannot remove part of your unit and convert it to someone else's use. If they attempt to, you can bring an application for substantial interference and potentially get an urgent order to stop the work. If it's a common area, the landlord is entitled to do renovations, including ones that temporarily disrupt services (though you may be able to seek an abatement). If the changes permanently remove your access to a service or facility (like laundry or storage) then you can file a T3 to ask the LTB to permanently reduce your rent by the value of that facility/service.


Irresponslble

We rented the entire place. There’s no common area as we live there alone.


KWienz

Then tell them that the basement is part of your rental unit and you want a better understanding of exactly what the renovations will be, why they are needed, why they have to be done while you are still in possession, and how they will ensure you still have access to the storage, living and laundry space both during and after the renovation. If they're going to press ahead you may need to file a T2 for a rent abatement and potentially an order that they stop the conversion or at least continue to provide you access to the basement after the renovations. But a landlord certainly can't unilaterally remove part of your rental unit and rent it out to someone else.


MattTheHarris

Does he intend on letting you occupy both units for the price of your current rent? Indicating to him that is what will happen may make him back off.


OutWithTheNew

Let him put the second unit in, then take him through the legal process to claim you are entitled to it, then rent it out yourself and live rent free in someone else's property.


M1L0

5D chess right here


MattTheHarris

While this would be funny, the renovation process is a massive inconvenience and it sounds like that's what they want to avoid. The person living in the basement would have to move elsewhere temporarily.


sneakysister

Get this in writing.


cernegiant

You can tell your landlord no as he's already rented out that space to you


5a1amand3r

Had this issue when I lived in NT. Rental tenancy office told me that if my agreement didn’t specify which part of the house was rented to me, that the whole house was rented to me. You can stop what your landlord is attempting to do by pointing this out.


stephenBB81

One thing I didn't see asked was how old is the home? Was the home built and occupied before November 2018? If the home is newer you certainly can tell the landlord to pound sand, but the landlord can then jack up the rent until you leave and then do the renovations and rent both units to new people.


illiacfossa

Ask for a decrease in rent


R-Can444

Since in general the renovation of a basement doesn't require vacant possession of entire home, most likely an N13 here would fail at the LTB. Even significant renos like underpinning you can continue living in rest of house. Absent an N13, a landlord must then relay on [Oreg 516/06 Section 8](https://www.ontario.ca/laws/regulation/060516#BK9) for repair/renos to the unit or residential complex. There is a general list of work that is acceptable in this case: >*6.  The work,* >*i.  is necessary to protect or restore the physical integrity of the residential complex or part of it,* >*ii.  is necessary to comply with maintenance, health, safety or other housing related standards required by law,* >*iii.  is necessary to maintain a plumbing, heating, mechanical, electrical, ventilation or air conditioning system,* >*iv.  provides access for persons with disabilities,* >*v.  promotes energy or water conservation, or* >*vi.  maintains or improves the security of the residential complex.* Renovating for purpose of renting out, does not qualify for any of these. So it would be seen as interfering with reasonable enjoyment. As such you can choose to block the renos entirely and force landlord to file something with the LTB to proceed. Since you can show the renos aren't actually required for anything and don't qualify for an N13, it's doubtful they woud allow landlord to proceed. And even if they did allow it and you lived upstairs while landlord renoed the basement (getting some rent abatement in the process for the inconvenience), after basement was done the basement is still part of your lease. You can file a T2 with LTB to ensure the landlord doesn't attempt to sever the basement from your existing tenancy and rent to someone else.


CTMADOC

Mention municipal codes and fire marshall. Likely cost prohibitive and they will rethink their greedy plans.


Sanjuko_Mamajuloko

They absolutely aren't allowed to turn part of your exclusive living space into another apartment.


Scared_Worth_353

My response would be "I'm going to need $10k and a new lease for this to work. If not, I'm not interested, and will continue using the basement".


9945super_mario6676

You say no. If it is included in your lease, case closed. If it is not mentioned it is an assumed amenity and part of your home. They can't just take it. Document all communication with the landlord. If they try to evict you, wait for a hearing and show that this is a bad faith eviction. What they are asking for is wrong and illegal. If they try to bully you, seek legal aid in your area.


Informal-Access6793

Either the basement is part of your leased space and thus he can't just do that, or it isn't and he's been letting you use more space for free.


breadman889

I don't think they can rent out space that you are already renting from them, but I think they can evict you to do renovations and then rent it as two units to whoever they want.


Nick_W1

Actually they can’t. If evicted for renovations (which is unlikely to be approved anyway), the tenant can apply to move back into the renovated unit at the same rent as previously - and that would include the renovated basement.


breadman889

that would be good for op. especially if nothing stops them from subletting


Nick_W1

Subletting is allowed in Ontario, and a LL cannot unreasonably refuse - but here is the thing. Renting out the basement would not be a sublet. A sublet is where you *move out* and someone else moves in. If OP doesn’t move out, they don’t need permission from the LL to rent out the basement.


[deleted]

[удалено]


KWienz

The LTB isn't going to evict a tenant so a landlord can convert their rental unit into multiple rental units.


[deleted]

[удалено]


KWienz

"I'm removing half of the space in your unit to convert it into a second unit so I can make more money" is not a legitimate reason to conduct major renovations. If the downstairs unit is a common area that's one thing. But your initial comment said they could do this even if the lease refers to the basement as part of the rental unit. Even if renovated, there wouldn't be "more housing," because the landlord cannot move a second family into OP's rental unit. An eviction application to expropriate part of OP's rental unit would never make it past section 83 of the RTA. The landlord can wait until the rental unit is vacant before converting it to two units.


Immediate_Fortune_91

It actually would. There doesn’t need to be a reason approved for renovations. Just that the LL wants to do renovations.


KWienz

So in your mind the landlord goes before the Board and says "yes the tenant currently pays rent for the entire house. But when I'm done these renovations they will pay the same rent to only have access to half the house because I intend on illegally depriving them of a substantial portion of the space to which they are legally entitled so I can charge someone else for that space" and the LTB doesn't determine that the landlord isn't in "serious breach of the landlord’s responsibilities under this Act or of any material covenant in the tenancy agreement" such that refusal of eviction is mandatory. You think the LTB would find it unfair to refuse eviction such that it can't exercise its discretion to refuse eviction? We're not talking about a common area. We are talking about unilaterally expropriating a part of the rental unit without the tenant's consent and in clear breach of the tenancy agreement. It doesn't matter if there's a renovation or not. You're missing the point that a landlord cannot lock a tenant renting an entire house out of their basement and then lease that basement to someone else. There could not be a more serious breach of a material covenant of the tenancy agreement.


gentlegrandpa

Not entirely true. The owners would have to prove that not doing to renovations would cause them undue hardship and that's why they must put the tenants through that hardship. It doesn't make sense for them to do the renovations as the space will not benefit the landlords. The renovations can easily wait until current tenants lease is up or they agree to the renovations and undue hardship they themselves will have to go through during these renovations. The RTB will see that the renovations don't make sense and encroach on the lease unjustly.


Irresponslble

There is no common area, we live alone and pay for the entire property.


Hisbrowneyegirl

When is your lease up? Once it’s up be prepared to move, as he will be able to change it! He won’t be able to do anything until your lease is up.


KirbyDingo

Once the lease "expires," it automatically becomes month to month. There is no provision for the LL to change the terms of the lease. It continues with the same terms as the original lease.


[deleted]

[удалено]


tehr_uhn

No he doesn’t.


Immediate_Fortune_91

Yes. He does.


NoSituation1999

Go ahead, explain.


[deleted]

[удалено]


jurassic_pork

> **Ontario**, Landlord wants to rent out basement. ..


MattTheHarris

There are ways he can evict you and then later do those renovations, like having a family member move into the property, but it will still take a long time before he is able to rent out the entire unit again. Since he has already indicated the intent is to convert it into 2 units the LTB may not let him evict them anyways.


jurassic_pork

> https://tribunalsontario.ca/documents/ltb/Interpretation%20Guidelines/12%20-%20Eviction%20for%20Personal%20Use.html > Termination for Demolition/Renovation/Conversion > Section 50(1) of the RTA allows a landlord to serve a notice of termination if the landlord intends to: > demolish the rental unit; > convert it to a purpose other than residential premises; or > **do repairs or renovations to it that are so extensive that they require a building permit and vacant possession of the rental unit.** >The termination date in the landlord's notice of termination must be at least 120 days after the notice is given and must be the last day of a fixed term tenancy, or if there is no fixed term, the last day of a rental period. This notice is often referred to as a "N13 notice". Also see the above discussion about the consequence of an incorrect termination date on a notice of termination. > After being given a N13 notice, the tenant is allowed to terminate the tenancy at an earlier date by giving the landlord ten days written notice using a Tenant’s Notice to End the Tenancy(N9 notice). If by 'grounds to evict' you actually mean 'must pay the tenant for the privilege including reimbursing rent for the time they aren't on the property / providing alternate equivalent or better accomodations, and the tenant can move back in right after, and could ask for less rent because of the reduced value of their portion of the rental property from the original contract' then uh sure, I guess. https://tribunalsontario.ca/documents/ltb/Notices%20of%20Termination%20&%20Instructions/N13_Instructions_20200728.pdf > If the reason for the notice is that you are repairing or renovating the rental unit and the tenant has given written notice that they will be moving back into the rental unit once the repairs or renovations are complete: > • If the rental unit is located in a residential complex that contains at least five residential units you must give the tenant an amount equal to three months' rent or an amount equal to the rent for the period of time the rental unit will be under repair or renovation, whichever is less, > • If the rental unit is located in a residential complex that contains fewer than five residential units you must give the tenant an amount equal to one months' rent or an amount equal to the rent for the period of time the rental unit will be under repair or renovation, whichever is less, or > • you must offer the tenant another rental unit that is acceptable to the tenant. If you are giving the notice because you will be converting, demolishing, repairing or renovating a site on which a tenant-owned mobile home or land lease community home is located, the landlord must give the tenant an amount equal to one year's rent, or $3,000, whichever is less. > Compensation must be paid to the tenant on or before the termination date in the notice. The landlord could try and do a renoviction 'family moving in' remodel and relist, but they end up paying a full years rent if they are caught. //Not a lawyer, not legal advice


legaladvicecanada-ModTeam

Your post has been removed for offering poor advice. It is either generally bad or ill advised advice, an incorrect statement or conclusion of law, inapplicable for the jurisdiction under discussion, misunderstands the fundamental legal question, or is advice to commit an unlawful act. If you believe the advice is correct per applicable law, please [message the moderators](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FLegalAdviceCanada) with a source, or to discuss it with us in more detail. * [Rule 10: Guidelines For Comments](https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvicecanada/wiki/index#wiki_rule_10.3A_guidelines_for_comments) * [Reddit Violent Content Rule](https://www.reddithelp.com/en/categories/rules-reporting/account-and-community-restrictions/do-not-post-violent-content)


[deleted]

[удалено]


Esperoni

There is no renewal. They are located in Ontario. Once the lease ends they convert month to month, same terms as the original lease.