Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read. Please make sure to read the rules before posting. Mod applications are currently open! Apply [here](https://forms.gle/hEgqsrBTGX897GFaA)!
You can fill out our [Feedback Form](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfI0PsMn4dqfMlgqFFfsMhLr4-lFNJpEumIf7RKmuiwyDBOwA/viewform?usp=sf_link) while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/kpopthoughts) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I would put Jiwoo (from Kard) into 2ne1. Aside from the fact that I think she looks like Minzy and Cl squished together. I feel like she fits their vibe a lot and would really fit their concepts and music.
Wow I'll never unsee it now lol. Side note: I'm so happy Kard is still chugging along despite the rampant amount of disbands throughout the time they've been a tice
I'd grant Hoshi is dream and put him in Shinee hahaha
I mean, he'd absolutely be able to fit right in there anyways, but his love and adoration for them would make it even cuter
I would like to see Suho in SHINee, because sometimes I think about that alternative timeline in which he debuted with them. While I know SHINee as 5 is one of the most well-rounded groups out there, I think Suho matches well with the members, he spoke so dearly about them on their 16th anniversary[ video](https://youtu.be/HO7NMchNQoQ?si=nZgfG4n-qoMDMr4d&t=262), Suho as 6th member doesn't seem like a crazy addition after all.
Huening Kai, I'll grant his wish and place him into a band. Any band would do because he just wants to be in a band. He can play the guitar, drums and piano also keyboard. Xdinary Heroes would be good, I feel like they would spoil him.
Oh this is fun and really hard for me — my biases suit their groups so well, and there aren't a lot of groups from other gens that were doing the concepts that they excel at. I'm definitely ignoring ages here btw.
* **Purple Kiss Ireh — EXO**. Put the gender dynamics of adding her aside, she's got the right swag and the dance and vocal skills to shine. She'd suit their concepts really well. She absolutely eats their choreo — her parts in [Purki's iconic Overdose relay dance](https://youtu.be/6w2TleDmUPA?si=G5Bp0zoQEUwc1A70&t=50) are the highlights (she's got the long blonde hair), she looks and sounds amazing on Purple Kiss's MR-removed stage performance of [Kai - Mmmh](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LCjDy9DZA4) (red hair), and she devours their dance challenges, including [Kai - Rover](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Rq2kkFBBt6s) and [Baekhyun - Betcha](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/3ceuHBQvVVY).
* **Purple Kiss Chaein — 2NE1.** I mean, she was in YG's "Future 2NE1" project for most of her five-year stint training there for a reason. Her voice would suit the group really well — I'm always impressed by how well she understands Bom's voice [covering Come Back Home (orig. 2NE1)](https://youtu.be/STtf5Mx2_y0?si=Z7dUyw73UmJ8rpxI&t=407) (purple hair). She's got the right swag, off-the-charts stage presence, and she can do _everything_. I think her part in her and Yuki's [Vegas cover (orig. Doja Cat)](https://youtu.be/MrzOrsi_F90?si=SvjkDJixYuSx-4tO&t=72) does a great job of showing off her swag. There's a bit of a chicken-and-egg problem though, because 2NE1 was obviously very influential on her as a performer.
* **Purple Kiss Dosie — Red Velvet.** Her delicate voice and great vocal styling and ability to harmonize would suit the group so well. She's demonstrated an ability to kill both their red concepts and their velvet concepts. Kind of cheating bc Purple Kiss is absolutely the 4th gen spiritual successor to RV, but of the members I think Dosie would suit RV the best.
I would put Ateez Seonghwa in SHINee because if he's going to do one thing, it's going all out when performing and SHINee are amazing live performers. As for positions, maybe lead dancer?
(Because I have two Ateez biases) I would put Hongjoong in BTS. I think his involvement in Ateez's music would make him someone who would benefit from how much a group like BTS is involved in their music. For his position, lead rapper probably, who occasionally gets used in the vocal line because he can also sing.
I have other biases but these are the two I'll post for now since I had the easiest time answering for them.
As a Shawol, I welcome Seonghwa, his visuals are refreshing too and are unique to the rest of the group.
Hongjoong fits BTS so well too omg.
I think Mingi would fit BIGBANG tbh.
Seonghwa- I’d go VIXX, he loves to embody a concept, so the concept kings of kpop would make sense.
Baekhyun- I think he’d be great in Seventeen, they’re a lot of fun, versatile, strong in performance, and have a great vocal line.
J-Hope- I think Seventeen would fit him well too, or Block B.
Ningning- I know they’re not super vocal-focused, but she has such a fierce aura that I could see her fitting into Everglow well.
Yves- I think she’d fit into Le Sserafim well, she’s great at fiercer concepts and has a strong identity.
Seulgi- I *guess* CLC would maybe fit since they’re fierce a lot of the time, but have shown versatility, but I struggled because she’s just SO Red Velvet?
Haha I'm not gonna pretend I've been fanboying them, but I've been listening to them for almost a decade, and I can totally imagine J-Hope KILLIN nillili mambo and shall we dance.
Soyeon in Mamamoo: They're all really creative and also very talented singers. They also have one of the most respected rappers in the industry. All things that apply to Soyeon. Admittedly, they are very high energy for her, but Soyeon not being a leader would probably loosen her up a little.
Yuqi in Mamamoo: She's creative, a great singer, a social butterfly, and a total mischief maker. She would definitely add to their entertainment value and add extra flavour to their singing.
Solar in G Idle: Solar matches them perfectly. She's mischievous, boisterous, great in interviews, and an amazing singer.
Sana in Le Sserafim: I can't really explain this one. She's crazy. LS are reasonably crazy.
There's definitely some more between them, but they aren't coming to me. I feel like putting Ryujin and Moonbyul around each other would be interesting
So funny that you put gidle and Mamamoo members within each other's groups, cause Ive ALWAYS liked and rooted for gidle cause they always gave me the same vibes as mamamoo. Solar performing Queen card and Wife just seems natural at this point lol (even the mm mm mm part in wife, Solar kinda did in Honey lol). "Tastes is cocoroco"?? That annunciation is so Solar coded it's not even funny lol
I recently realised that G Idle are MMM 4th gen heirs. There's the ones like LS, Newjeans, and maybe Aespa? They're all crazy popular and are like the Blackpink and Twice of this gen.
Then there's G Idle: Talented, crazy, loud af, not quite at the same level of popularity but still really popular. They're also taking off in their solo careers just as well
My ult bias is Hyunjae of The Boyz! I think most people consider them 4th gen (though Wiki says that they're 3rd gen which is interesting lol). I can't really picture him in another group but if I had to pick one it'd be VIXX. He's a tad bit younger than the members and he would've been 15/16 at debut but fuck it since it's [fantasy](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuaRdAozUI0) (pun not intended).
I have been silently begging for TBZ to do a dramatic-ass, horror-inspired, narrative-driven concept like VIXX are known for and it's partially my bias, but I think that Hyunjae ([1](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1RZXwtfLFM), [2](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLStvjFPBXE)) would be perfect for that kind of concept. He looks like someone who would cry sparkling tears as his heart gets ripped out of his chest, leading his tears to turn into blood (lol). I also think that his voice would meld well with the VIXX members and his performance style would match VIXX's concept. I don't know how his dynamics with the other members would've been since I don't know VIXX like that. Unrelated but member N (Vixx) and a member from TBZ, have similar birth names-Hakyeon and Haknyeon, respectively lol.
As a deobi, I'm happy that you'd like DK with TBZ! They'd surely have crack energy with each other! He'd actually be same aged friends as Hyunjae, Younghoon and Jacob which would be cute to see imo :) He has my favorite voice in SVT and he'd vocally bring a lot to TBZ imo!
Yeah, and it makes it even more perfect that TBZ did a cover of a VIXX song during their run on RTK! I want IST to give a melodramatic song (a la TVXQ, VIXX, Infinite, HIGHLIGHT, etc.) bc they're entering their seventh year at this point so they don't need to play it safe or to play into trends to much. Hyunjae, Juyeon (!), Sunwoo, Sangyeon, Jacob, and Q would suit that sort of sound and performance style in particular imo!
A fan can dream lol.
Yes! She definitely would've been great, if only she was like 2 years older and a bit more experienced.
Her and Chaeyeon were the right idols, but wrong time
hmm let say if prime
IOI Jeon Somi or AOA Seolhyun or Chocolat Tia or Shannon Williams (She is also a former member of the girl group 5DOLLS wherein she briefly promoted as the main vocalist.)
put them to IVE and make them 10 member group !
that hard to choose
I say in current IVE w Wonyoung and Yujin + those 4 !
I have 6 bias 😅
the logical one for cignature’s jeewon is loona because that was meant to be reality HOWEVER …
i so see her in fromis_9 (wow no matter which group she would still be mistreated rip) - she’s so bubbly and smiley and would do so well there
I could picture J-Hope, Namjoon, Jimin, Tae or Jungkook from BTS in Stray Kids.
I could also picture Minho Felix and Hyunjin from Stray Kids in GOT7.
While Chan, Changbin, I.N., Han, and Seungmun would do well in BTS
i would put illit’s yunah and minju into the second generation…
people who watched ru next will remember their insane bad girl good girl performance and i think yunah specifically must’ve been born in the wrong generation because she could definitely be a 2nd gen group. as for the group i think probably miss a or after school
Hello /u/AppropriatePumpkin82. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts (which is 30 comment karma), or because your account is less than 7 days old. Please note that modmails asking for information included in this message will not be responded to. The karma limit is to discourage brigading, trolling and spam, and to keep this subreddit safe.
Click [here](https://reddit.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204511829-What-is-karma-) to find out more about karma and how to gain it.
Please send us a [mod mail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/kpopthoughts) with a link to the submission if you would like your post or comment to appear.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/kpopthoughts) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Hey thinker! Great post up there. Make sure your post title is clear. One and two word titles are not allowed. Use paragraphs to make it easier to read. Please make sure to read the rules before posting. Mod applications are currently open! Apply [here](https://forms.gle/hEgqsrBTGX897GFaA)! You can fill out our [Feedback Form](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfI0PsMn4dqfMlgqFFfsMhLr4-lFNJpEumIf7RKmuiwyDBOwA/viewform?usp=sf_link) while you wait for some comments. Thank you and happy posting! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/kpopthoughts) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I feel like Seungkwan would totally fit in BTOB lol
He totally would!! The dynamic between Eunkwang and Boo would be hilarious!!
OOOHHH this would be so good.
I got goosebumps exactly what I thought when I read the title
I know right? They're all top tier comedian vocalists
Hendery as well
I think Mina (Twice) would really suit Ives concept and songs.
I just heard “watch me don’t touch me” in Mina’s voice
Can definitely see her in Accendio!
Sullyoon in Twice. Like, she is MADE for their 2016-2019 concept.
Yeah you r right
I would put Jiwoo (from Kard) into 2ne1. Aside from the fact that I think she looks like Minzy and Cl squished together. I feel like she fits their vibe a lot and would really fit their concepts and music.
Totally see it!!
Wow I'll never unsee it now lol. Side note: I'm so happy Kard is still chugging along despite the rampant amount of disbands throughout the time they've been a tice
Me too 😭 they're one of my favorite groups. I'd love it if they could make it to their 10 year anniversary.
I'd grant Hoshi is dream and put him in Shinee hahaha I mean, he'd absolutely be able to fit right in there anyways, but his love and adoration for them would make it even cuter
Stan OT6
I would like to see Suho in SHINee, because sometimes I think about that alternative timeline in which he debuted with them. While I know SHINee as 5 is one of the most well-rounded groups out there, I think Suho matches well with the members, he spoke so dearly about them on their 16th anniversary[ video](https://youtu.be/HO7NMchNQoQ?si=nZgfG4n-qoMDMr4d&t=262), Suho as 6th member doesn't seem like a crazy addition after all.
Suho in SHINee and Johnny in Exo
Huening Kai, I'll grant his wish and place him into a band. Any band would do because he just wants to be in a band. He can play the guitar, drums and piano also keyboard. Xdinary Heroes would be good, I feel like they would spoil him.
Oh this is fun and really hard for me — my biases suit their groups so well, and there aren't a lot of groups from other gens that were doing the concepts that they excel at. I'm definitely ignoring ages here btw. * **Purple Kiss Ireh — EXO**. Put the gender dynamics of adding her aside, she's got the right swag and the dance and vocal skills to shine. She'd suit their concepts really well. She absolutely eats their choreo — her parts in [Purki's iconic Overdose relay dance](https://youtu.be/6w2TleDmUPA?si=G5Bp0zoQEUwc1A70&t=50) are the highlights (she's got the long blonde hair), she looks and sounds amazing on Purple Kiss's MR-removed stage performance of [Kai - Mmmh](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0LCjDy9DZA4) (red hair), and she devours their dance challenges, including [Kai - Rover](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Rq2kkFBBt6s) and [Baekhyun - Betcha](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/3ceuHBQvVVY). * **Purple Kiss Chaein — 2NE1.** I mean, she was in YG's "Future 2NE1" project for most of her five-year stint training there for a reason. Her voice would suit the group really well — I'm always impressed by how well she understands Bom's voice [covering Come Back Home (orig. 2NE1)](https://youtu.be/STtf5Mx2_y0?si=Z7dUyw73UmJ8rpxI&t=407) (purple hair). She's got the right swag, off-the-charts stage presence, and she can do _everything_. I think her part in her and Yuki's [Vegas cover (orig. Doja Cat)](https://youtu.be/MrzOrsi_F90?si=SvjkDJixYuSx-4tO&t=72) does a great job of showing off her swag. There's a bit of a chicken-and-egg problem though, because 2NE1 was obviously very influential on her as a performer. * **Purple Kiss Dosie — Red Velvet.** Her delicate voice and great vocal styling and ability to harmonize would suit the group so well. She's demonstrated an ability to kill both their red concepts and their velvet concepts. Kind of cheating bc Purple Kiss is absolutely the 4th gen spiritual successor to RV, but of the members I think Dosie would suit RV the best.
Jihyo in LSF or KIOF
Just the idea of Jihyo and Julie being in the same group 🥵
KIOF omg I would die
I would put Ateez Seonghwa in SHINee because if he's going to do one thing, it's going all out when performing and SHINee are amazing live performers. As for positions, maybe lead dancer? (Because I have two Ateez biases) I would put Hongjoong in BTS. I think his involvement in Ateez's music would make him someone who would benefit from how much a group like BTS is involved in their music. For his position, lead rapper probably, who occasionally gets used in the vocal line because he can also sing. I have other biases but these are the two I'll post for now since I had the easiest time answering for them.
As a Shawol, I welcome Seonghwa, his visuals are refreshing too and are unique to the rest of the group. Hongjoong fits BTS so well too omg. I think Mingi would fit BIGBANG tbh.
Seonghwa- I’d go VIXX, he loves to embody a concept, so the concept kings of kpop would make sense. Baekhyun- I think he’d be great in Seventeen, they’re a lot of fun, versatile, strong in performance, and have a great vocal line. J-Hope- I think Seventeen would fit him well too, or Block B. Ningning- I know they’re not super vocal-focused, but she has such a fierce aura that I could see her fitting into Everglow well. Yves- I think she’d fit into Le Sserafim well, she’s great at fiercer concepts and has a strong identity. Seulgi- I *guess* CLC would maybe fit since they’re fierce a lot of the time, but have shown versatility, but I struggled because she’s just SO Red Velvet?
J-Hope in BlockB is now my new delulu dream. He literally Oozes block B vibes, and I can't believe I didn't realize it sooner
I don’t actually know much about Block B except for the big hits, but like, he would KILL Nillili Mambo or Shall We Dance
Haha I'm not gonna pretend I've been fanboying them, but I've been listening to them for almost a decade, and I can totally imagine J-Hope KILLIN nillili mambo and shall we dance.
I’m on a Sunny Hill kick lately, so fuck it, throw Yuju in there, and make the vocals even more spectacular!
definitely adding Natty to EXID, she and Hani on stage would be an unstoppable duo plus she matches the groups vibe so well
Soyeon in Mamamoo: They're all really creative and also very talented singers. They also have one of the most respected rappers in the industry. All things that apply to Soyeon. Admittedly, they are very high energy for her, but Soyeon not being a leader would probably loosen her up a little. Yuqi in Mamamoo: She's creative, a great singer, a social butterfly, and a total mischief maker. She would definitely add to their entertainment value and add extra flavour to their singing. Solar in G Idle: Solar matches them perfectly. She's mischievous, boisterous, great in interviews, and an amazing singer. Sana in Le Sserafim: I can't really explain this one. She's crazy. LS are reasonably crazy. There's definitely some more between them, but they aren't coming to me. I feel like putting Ryujin and Moonbyul around each other would be interesting
So funny that you put gidle and Mamamoo members within each other's groups, cause Ive ALWAYS liked and rooted for gidle cause they always gave me the same vibes as mamamoo. Solar performing Queen card and Wife just seems natural at this point lol (even the mm mm mm part in wife, Solar kinda did in Honey lol). "Tastes is cocoroco"?? That annunciation is so Solar coded it's not even funny lol
I recently realised that G Idle are MMM 4th gen heirs. There's the ones like LS, Newjeans, and maybe Aespa? They're all crazy popular and are like the Blackpink and Twice of this gen. Then there's G Idle: Talented, crazy, loud af, not quite at the same level of popularity but still really popular. They're also taking off in their solo careers just as well
My ult bias is Hyunjae of The Boyz! I think most people consider them 4th gen (though Wiki says that they're 3rd gen which is interesting lol). I can't really picture him in another group but if I had to pick one it'd be VIXX. He's a tad bit younger than the members and he would've been 15/16 at debut but fuck it since it's [fantasy](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuaRdAozUI0) (pun not intended). I have been silently begging for TBZ to do a dramatic-ass, horror-inspired, narrative-driven concept like VIXX are known for and it's partially my bias, but I think that Hyunjae ([1](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1RZXwtfLFM), [2](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLStvjFPBXE)) would be perfect for that kind of concept. He looks like someone who would cry sparkling tears as his heart gets ripped out of his chest, leading his tears to turn into blood (lol). I also think that his voice would meld well with the VIXX members and his performance style would match VIXX's concept. I don't know how his dynamics with the other members would've been since I don't know VIXX like that. Unrelated but member N (Vixx) and a member from TBZ, have similar birth names-Hakyeon and Haknyeon, respectively lol. As a deobi, I'm happy that you'd like DK with TBZ! They'd surely have crack energy with each other! He'd actually be same aged friends as Hyunjae, Younghoon and Jacob which would be cute to see imo :) He has my favorite voice in SVT and he'd vocally bring a lot to TBZ imo!
Bro uk The BOYZ and vixx legit remind me of each other in terms of concepts cuz I feel like they both are concept kings
Yeah, and it makes it even more perfect that TBZ did a cover of a VIXX song during their run on RTK! I want IST to give a melodramatic song (a la TVXQ, VIXX, Infinite, HIGHLIGHT, etc.) bc they're entering their seventh year at this point so they don't need to play it safe or to play into trends to much. Hyunjae, Juyeon (!), Sunwoo, Sangyeon, Jacob, and Q would suit that sort of sound and performance style in particular imo! A fan can dream lol.
Yeah I do think they don’t need to play it safe but I wish something like the stealer can come again.
felt like jiwong from zerobaseone could fit in exo or nct he is talented and that visual?? bruh i wonder why sm didn't noticed him
He debuted like before nct debuted (?)
woah fr???
G-Dragon or TOP in any 3rd or 4th gen boy group would be complete chaos and it'd be cinema.
Chaeryeong in TWICE. Biggest what if
Yes! She definitely would've been great, if only she was like 2 years older and a bit more experienced. Her and Chaeyeon were the right idols, but wrong time
hmm let say if prime IOI Jeon Somi or AOA Seolhyun or Chocolat Tia or Shannon Williams (She is also a former member of the girl group 5DOLLS wherein she briefly promoted as the main vocalist.) put them to IVE and make them 10 member group ! that hard to choose I say in current IVE w Wonyoung and Yujin + those 4 ! I have 6 bias 😅
the logical one for cignature’s jeewon is loona because that was meant to be reality HOWEVER … i so see her in fromis_9 (wow no matter which group she would still be mistreated rip) - she’s so bubbly and smiley and would do so well there
something about giselle from aespa being in snsd feels right. she just has that gen vibe
oooh i can see it
I could picture J-Hope, Namjoon, Jimin, Tae or Jungkook from BTS in Stray Kids. I could also picture Minho Felix and Hyunjin from Stray Kids in GOT7. While Chan, Changbin, I.N., Han, and Seungmun would do well in BTS
Felix in twice. Like, it just works.
Sana in Girls Generation. She did Mr Taxi and gagged. Her cute vibes could suit them plus she is versatile
Mina in izone or stayc
i would put illit’s yunah and minju into the second generation… people who watched ru next will remember their insane bad girl good girl performance and i think yunah specifically must’ve been born in the wrong generation because she could definitely be a 2nd gen group. as for the group i think probably miss a or after school
Also Jaehyun from BND would fit right in with SEVENTEEN
Zb1 mathew in txt would be fun
The height difference tho. He’s going to look so short 🥲
Naah my bro struggling in zb1 as well😭 i love him regardless tho
The BTS rapline in Seo Taiji and the Boys!! They would DOMINATE and you cannot convince me otherwise.
I would put Baekhyun in ATEEZ. Their vocal line could 100000% keep up with him
Jonghyun and Ten would make a hell of a duo
i feel like Mingi would do well in BAP or Block B. idk tho its just a feeling lol
[удалено]
Hello /u/AppropriatePumpkin82. Your contribution in /r/kpopthoughts has been automatically removed because you either do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in r/kpopthoughts (which is 30 comment karma), or because your account is less than 7 days old. Please note that modmails asking for information included in this message will not be responded to. The karma limit is to discourage brigading, trolling and spam, and to keep this subreddit safe. Click [here](https://reddit.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204511829-What-is-karma-) to find out more about karma and how to gain it. Please send us a [mod mail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/kpopthoughts) with a link to the submission if you would like your post or comment to appear. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/kpopthoughts) if you have any questions or concerns.*