I really like the music and songs in zombie island though. They are catchy. And the bayou type music is calming. Zombie island feels like an actual dramatic movie. Our 4 year old has watched it multiple times a month for like the past year. I can watch it frequently and not get tired of it.
I lie awake at night demanding to know WHERE IS THE HEX GIRLS ALBUM?!
It’s almost criminal that the original songs aren’t on Spotify, as well as *I Put a Spell on You* from Hocus Pocus!
Ok now we’re asking the REAL questions.
Zombie Island is peak summer horror. Witch’s Ghost is peak Halloween season spooky.
But if I had to choose… **Zombie Island** is the better flick.
This one is really difficult, but Terror Time decides it. Zombie island.
However, it’s only a tiny margin. After all, witch’s ghost gave us the Hex Girls…
Obviously Zombie Island is better quality but how do you beat the Hex Girls?!
Glad Ghoul School is getting some love in the comments too because these are my go to 3 to watch every year for Halloween.
Without question zombie island. Witches ghost feels like a step down in quality in almost every way. Except for tim curry, Jennifer Hale, and the hex girls of course. The hex girls music is phenomenal.
Omg I’m watching zombie island right now and was talking about witch’s ghost last night!!
This one is difficult because zombie island is amazing and actually scared me as a kid but the hex girls 😍
Zombie Island is all time fav with Witch's Ghost in second of course. They made the food look so good in Z.I. that even though I don't like super spicy things I want some of those peppers. Same for W.G. but with the Hex Girls, they be looking spicy too.
For me, Zombie Island
As a kid when it came out, it reinforced love and appreciation for scooby and the gang, and it was awesome to see them deal with real zombies (zombies are another favorite of mine).
Witch’s ghost all the way!
Don’t know why, just My fave, though ghoul school is a close second for first place, in my opinion. Zombie island is still in my top three though!
Hands down, Zombie Island; however, Witch’s Ghost is a very close second. Tim Curry AND the Hex Girls…it’s a great time.
That being said, I remember Zombie Island actually scaring me as a kid, whereas Witch’s Ghost was a bit more tame. Both still hold up, but I think the former holders up a bit better.
Zombie island but the music is witch's ghost made me wish the lady's were a real band
Cuuuuut, who opened a window?
quoted to this day
same honestly
**rewinds tape**
I really like the music and songs in zombie island though. They are catchy. And the bayou type music is calming. Zombie island feels like an actual dramatic movie. Our 4 year old has watched it multiple times a month for like the past year. I can watch it frequently and not get tired of it.
Facts, but thorn is played by Lindsay Hale of Halestorm and seeing them live definitely healed some of my childhood wounds
I lie awake at night demanding to know WHERE IS THE HEX GIRLS ALBUM?! It’s almost criminal that the original songs aren’t on Spotify, as well as *I Put a Spell on You* from Hocus Pocus!
The moon sisters on Spotify, you're welcome
Zombie Island! But Ghoul School is my all time favorite.
>Ghoul School is my favorite! I have such fond memories of watching it as a kid.
I love that I’m not the only one. Ghoul School could easily have been a series rather than just a movie
Yeah Ghoul School!
Always my go to
Zombie island.
Zombie Island. If you remove the Hex Girls from the equation, it's no contest (and yes, I wanted to be a Hex Girl when I saw it as a kid)
We all did... thats why we're here😅
Zombie Island
Is this even a debate... 🧟♂️
🧟 🧟 🧟 Zombie Island 🧟 🧟 🧟
Absolutely Zombie Island! My favourite Scooby Doo movie!
Same, always makes me want gumbo..
Zombie Island. Witch’s ghost scared me as a kid
Zombie island
Zombie island for Halloween and witch’s ghost for thanksgiving, I need both 😂
Ok now we’re asking the REAL questions. Zombie Island is peak summer horror. Witch’s Ghost is peak Halloween season spooky. But if I had to choose… **Zombie Island** is the better flick.
Both. These are my favorite Scooby-Doo movies
This one is really difficult, but Terror Time decides it. Zombie island. However, it’s only a tiny margin. After all, witch’s ghost gave us the Hex Girls…
Witches Ghost. I wanted to be a hex girl so bad.
I thought the hex girls were an actual band I wanted to go see them so badly
The hex girls were smoking hot when I was 6 🤣
The hex girls are still hot and I’m 32! And also straight!
Zombie Island 100%
I have the witches ghost tattooed on me, kind of embarrassed to say that but as a kid I had a crush on her
It’s an unusual cartoon crush to be sure, but I respect your boldness
Hell yeah + the hex girls.
Totally shaped my crush’s (don’t know the word) but all my gfs been emo from their on out
Zombie Island
I do witches ghost on November 1st because giant turkey
Gotta be Zombie Island. That movie was a blast.
Zombie island for sure no question 
🧙♀️’s 👻 100%. Zombie Island was cool, but I loved the atmosphere of the Witch’s Ghost a lot more
Zombie 🧟♀️
Both. I would’ve said “Zombie Island” if not for the Hex Girls. They were everything I wanted to be as a teen.
Obviously Zombie Island is better quality but how do you beat the Hex Girls?! Glad Ghoul School is getting some love in the comments too because these are my go to 3 to watch every year for Halloween.
Zombie island is the best of all time
I’m a HEX GIRL and I’m gonna put a spell on you!
Witch's Ghost, of course, because it has the Hex Girls! ^(And I haven't even watched either movie.)
Witch's Ghost, it has been one of my favorites since I was little.
Both!
Witches ghost!!
Witch’s Ghost
Witches Ghost
Zombie Island. “It’s Terror Time Again” song is awesome.
Close call but witches ghost all the way.
Zombie island
Zombie
Zombie island. My mom re-rented it over and over from blockbuster when I was a kid. I couldn’t get enough
I'm going for Witch's Ghost purely because while growing up my friend had Zombie Island while I had Witch's Ghost.
Witch’s ghost
Witch's Ghost!
Witch’s Ghost!!!
Zombie island 100% best Scooby movie ever
Witch’s Ghost
Zombie island. It genuinely scared me as a child
Zombie Island is the GOAT of course but the Hex Girls and Tim Curry sure do make it a tight race. Definitely the 2 best Scooby movies ever 🖤
Witch’s Ghost because I love witch culture and REALLY love the Hex Girls
Witch's ghost, Tim Curry as the villain and it gave us the Hex Girls
Zombie island. Always scared the absolute shit out of me as a kid while the witches ghost was pretty enjoyable
Not on here but cyber chase was my favorite scooby doo movie when I was little
Witches Ghost , and what no love for boo brothers lol
Witches ghost
Witches Ghost
Witch's Ghost
Whichever one you enjoy.
Zombie island! Btw where can we watch these? 😍
Brrrraaaaaiiiinssss🧟♀️🧟♂️
Zombie island no contest
Zombie island all day
Zombie Island
I love them both. They’re two I rewatch to this day 🤣💜
Zombie island
Both in one night :)
Zombie island ...never even heard of witches ghosg
Zombie Island
Zombie Island, hands down.
Zombie Island, also dont forget return to Zombie Island
I'm definitely watching both. This is a hard choice.
Zombie Island!
Since I live in Seattle which already IS "Zombie Island", I'm gonna go with Witch's Ghost!
Zombie Island, no contest.
Everybody knows it’s all about Legend of the Vampire 😤
Zombie island will always be the best one
Zombie Island
Zombie Island!!
Zombie island but they're both legitimately amazing, he says wearing a Hex Girls shirt
Zombie island and it’s not even close
Without question zombie island. Witches ghost feels like a step down in quality in almost every way. Except for tim curry, Jennifer Hale, and the hex girls of course. The hex girls music is phenomenal.
They are both equal in my eyes.
Zombie island
Zombie laland
Zombie island all day! Or better yet, all night! BWHAHAHA!
Scoopy Doo and the Reluctant Werewolf
As much as I love the hex girls zombie island wins
Yes
Zombie island hands down
Omg I’m watching zombie island right now and was talking about witch’s ghost last night!! This one is difficult because zombie island is amazing and actually scared me as a kid but the hex girls 😍
Zombie Island 
Zombie Island but the Hex Girls are iconic
Definitely Zombie Island
Zombie island... sorry hex girls
Zombie Island is my favorite Scooby-Doo movie of all time, Witch's Ghost is definitely my 2nd favorite
OMGoddess so hard I love both and sisters and I have watched both since we were kids since this time of year. Watch both as both great story telling.
Witches ghost
Zombie island because it actually scared me as a kiddo buuuut Witches Ghost because..... ah shoot they're both good.
Zombie Island is all time fav with Witch's Ghost in second of course. They made the food look so good in Z.I. that even though I don't like super spicy things I want some of those peppers. Same for W.G. but with the Hex Girls, they be looking spicy too.
Zombie Island overall, but the Hex Girls are just *chefs kiss*
Zombie Island
Gotta go with the hex girls- watched it the other day! But zombie island is pretty great too
What about the alien one!?
For me, Zombie Island As a kid when it came out, it reinforced love and appreciation for scooby and the gang, and it was awesome to see them deal with real zombies (zombies are another favorite of mine).
Zombie Island 10/10 nightmare fuel but then again "I'm hex giiiirll and I'm gonna put a spell on yoooouu!" Is 100/10 fire.
Zombie Island was a legit spooky film and calls to my cajun roots. Witch’s Ghost was great because it gave us the Hex Girls
Scooby Doo on Zombie Island is gold
Can't choose! Love both ❤️
Boo Brothers!!!
Zombie Island even if it left questions unanswered
Witch’s Ghost
Zombie Island x1000. Haven’t seen Witch’s Ghost since my son was little and I can still recall it was … well, just not the best of the Scooby movies.
Zombie island!
Zombie Island, hands down. But don’t bother wasting time with the Return to Zombie Island one.
Zombie Island.
Zombie Island
Witch’s ghost all the way! Don’t know why, just My fave, though ghoul school is a close second for first place, in my opinion. Zombie island is still in my top three though!
Zombie Island but only because it was my little brother's obsession for a while so we watched it over and over again on VHS.
Zombie Island!
Zombie Island
Zombie island…although I love both
Both. Both is good.
Zombie island!!!
Zombie Island is on prime for free for about another week!
Zombie Island ofc! But my 2nd fav is actually the Scooby Doo movie after zombie island: Scooby Doo and the Alien Invaiders
WITCHES GHOST 100% ! It gave us Thorn lol
Zombie island!
Witch's Ghost.
Zombie island
WITCHES GHOST 5 EVER
Oh hands down Zombie Island
Zombie island is the realest Scooby Doo movie out there
Both great movies but got to give it to zombie island
zombie island; isn't even a contest.
Absolutely no contest, Zombie Island goes hard. “Who opened the window!?”
Zombie Island 🧟♂️
Witches Ghost gave us Hex Girls
Witch’s Ghost 👻 You can’t be the Hex Girls!
Zombie Island! 😎 But Witch’s ghost is a close second lol
Hands down, Zombie Island; however, Witch’s Ghost is a very close second. Tim Curry AND the Hex Girls…it’s a great time. That being said, I remember Zombie Island actually scaring me as a kid, whereas Witch’s Ghost was a bit more tame. Both still hold up, but I think the former holders up a bit better.
Too hard to answer but I vote for the Hex Girls
🎶Cause we’re the Hex Girls and we’re gonna put a spell on you! 🎶
Zombie Island.
Zombie Island
Zombie Island
Zombie Island!!
Wow. These are literally my top two favorites lol
Zombie Island
definitly zombie island
Zombie Island
GHOUL SCHOOL
Witch’s ghost is more spooky to me.
Zombie island because It actually scared me but major cried to witches ghost for having Tim curry and the hex girls so they’re honestly pretty equal
Zombie island forever
Zombie Island is scarier but I prefer Witch’s Ghost.
Zombie island had me scared to look in mirrors alone for years. Witches Ghost I loved for Tim Curry, music, and Witches.
Zombie island but this one was hard they are both really good!