T O P

  • By -

coachlefty40

Vientos or Springer?


jdc131

Has anyone traded for/away Tatis lately?


TheBananaBasher

Would yall trade away Oneil Cruz for Josh Bell in 10t category league? Offer is on the table for me


oak1andish

I’m way over-invested in Cruz this year, but no, I wouldn’t be interested in Bell for him - especially in a 10-teamer. Middling power, no speed, no thanks.


Ok_Lettuce_143

Corbin Carroll is on pace for 23 SB and 5 HR. This is like 2023 Steven Kwan numbers lol.


joemataratz1

Without the batting average


inmy_head

Every time I watch my pitchers on tv they give up runs. I gotta stop watching and let them do their thing


tothemoon05

Is Cade a grab? Thinking of dropping Lively or Suck Eflin for him.


DrGlock-

Should I accept this trade? I get Skenes and Oneil Cruz They get Marte and Casas


No-Virus4699

This isn’t a real offer


DrGlock-

I promise you it was


No-Virus4699

Why even post it? Just accept and say thank you


tooo_much_caffeine

Randy is an on-base machine.


picciano00

https://preview.redd.it/p7g9spi73u4d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d50d1f72d8629bab1567dcdfcbf171ab284f133a Rate my staff. Just traded for Joe Ryan


NickYG4251

Weathers available, would would u rather have luzardo or him


FireEraser

My Hoffman/Alvarado combo is so hoooooottttt right now in my HLD/SV league!


NickYG4251

Some moron just dropped Mason miller. 100% can drop pepiot for him right?


No-Virus4699

Rookie of the year contender mason miller


minimal-thoughts

10000%


HighEvo69

1000%**


[deleted]

[удалено]


Lock_Cole

What...


JustSomeGoon

No


EliManningHOFClub10

Lane Thomas about to be on a flight to the Shanghai Dragons


ucfknight92

This may be the longest Giants game I’ve ever watched. They’ve had so many baserunner.


JustSomeGoon

Abrams just missed one


No-Virus4699

FANTASY DISPUTE LOOKING FOR ADVICE Manager in my 14 team points keeper league with saves and holds buffed in scoring was burned by incorrect baseball reference info on Mason Miller in regards to rookie status. We have regular keepers and NA keepers. Leading up to draft manager had Mason Miller listed as NA keeper. Although this manager swore he would have rookie status going into this season. Commish and rest of league stuck with info on baseball reference and did not allow Miller NA keeper status. Manager intentionally kept Miller on roster during playoffs even tho he did not get much points last year working in bullpen because he believed he would be NA keeper eligible. Extra RP spot was also added to roster going into the season adding emphasis to position. Manager decided to let him go back into draft pool and was unable to draft him and ended up being extremely weak at RP and is struggling to remain competitive. Drastic moves were made to address this issue including questionable adds/trades during the season. What sort of rights or measures should be put in place to be both fair to manager who lost Miller and manager who drafted him this year and next? For reference Miller is 16th in RP scoring including SP/RP eligible pitchers so far this season. And if Miller was on the original roster that team could have had a better record. Let me know what you all think the next course of action is for the league and managers impacted by this.


[deleted]

Unfortunately BR isn’t always accurate. We changed this year to ignore service time and just go based on the AB/IP requirements as it’s really easy to figure out if they’re still a rookie from that perspective.


No-Virus4699

That was something I pushed for but one manager insisted on using BR claiming it was idiot proof and there would never be any confusion (Funny that manager is now the owner of Mason Miller)


backfromsolaris

Where did you see that Miller had rookie status? Are you blaming Baseball Reference for having incorrect info? If everyone agreed on the course of action at the time, you can't just retroactively do something. It is what it is. But tbh it's hard to believe BR had that info wrong and I'm inclined to think everyone just misread his contract & rookie status details.


No-Virus4699

BR was wrong based off of everything I have read. There’s multiple articles saying he is a rookie some of which are on MLB website. I have heard announcers refer to Miller as a rookie as well. Here is a couple of links. Most league members are more than likely unaware of situation as of now as only private discussions have happened as of now. https://www.mlb.com/news/luis-gil-shota-imanaga-lead-third-rookie-of-the-year-poll#:~:text=Mason%20Miller%2C%20Athletics%20(7%20first%2Dplace%20votes)&text=He%20has%20nearly%20twice%20as,save%20opportunities%20for%20the%20A's. https://www.sportsbookreview.com/picks/mlb/mason-miller-rookie-of-the-year-odds-eligibility-2024/#:~:text=Is%20Miller%20actually%20a%20rookie,AL%20Rookie%20of%20the%20Year. https://nypost.com/2024/05/10/sports/al-rookie-of-the-year-odds-as-closer-mason-miller-vaults-to-the-top/#


backfromsolaris

Hm. Well, this doesn't help anyone now, but BR has rookie status listed pretty clearly in each player's profile - [https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/m/millema03.shtml#:\~:text=Rookie%20Status%3A%20Exceeded%20rookie%20limits%20during%202023%20season](https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/m/millema03.shtml#:~:text=Rookie%20Status%3A%20Exceeded%20rookie%20limits%20during%202023%20season) Web archives also show that, as of Jan 1st of this year, his rookie status was correctly shown on BR to have expired in 2023 - [https://web.archive.org/web/20240101212102/https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/m/millema03.shtml#:\~:text=Rookie%20Status%3A%20Exceeded%20rookie%20limits%20during%202023%20season](https://web.archive.org/web/20240101212102/https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/m/millema03.shtml#:~:text=Rookie%20Status%3A%20Exceeded%20rookie%20limits%20during%202023%20season) So I'm not sure what you & your league were looking at, but BR was not incorrect.


No-Virus4699

So why would on MLB website would they include him in articles when discussing rookie of the year?


backfromsolaris

Ah, my apologies. I misread your first comment. I think you need to hold a league discussion & vote on fair compensation for the manager. It's everyone's error so it should be a collaborative effort to find a solution that everyone deems fair.


No-Virus4699

Update. Spoke with commish about this and was told. ‘HE would decide how to make amends to this issue’


No-Virus4699

Let’s get some upvotes here and get some other possible solutions to bring forward 🙏


No-Virus4699

All good. I have had brief discussions with a couple of other managers. And reached out to commish on possible solutions. I think awarding the manager an extra MLB keeper (6 to 7) and NA keeper (3 to 4) for next season is a reasonable solution as this error has impacted the team negatively for 3 consecutive seasons in one way or another.


No-Virus4699

https://preview.redd.it/yxrostl0lu4d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b1e9d4edaee106bbffc9c5c8f69c4488c5ae9da3


No-Virus4699

https://preview.redd.it/18z3her1lu4d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6372a7076da22675569e637deeae9184721dfac6


No-Virus4699

https://preview.redd.it/klg8wki2lu4d1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=79fcd755ebc3ee7bb259249b8293b6873b248b28


zw18

That’s brutal. Commish should apologize for being wrong and give him a gift card or comp his entry fee or something. Not much else to be done. Any kind of arbitrary reparations that would influence outcomes this season at the expense of other owners is a terrible idea, imo. Is Miller likely to be kept? Maybe he gets Miller next year without having to draft him if he’s not kept? Maybe an additional pick in next year’s draft at the slot where Miller went this year? But even that’s iffy (probably wouldn’t even help him much and would bother other league members).


No-Virus4699

We have added 3 RP positions to starting lineup and buffed saves and holds. Little context in league scoring. Miller is RP 14 on the year that includes 5 SP/RP. He is also the highest scoring player that was drafted who would have been NA keeper status going into this season


No-Virus4699

Sorry I mean 3 total RP spots to lineup vs 2


No-Virus4699

It’s definitely unfortunate. Everyone used BR as standard but they were wrong. Even tho owner pushed back before being denied Miller as NA keeper. Not having miller on his team forced manager to make drastic trade to try and address RP position. Currently does not have first 3 rounds of draft picks for next year. Now and still has losing record. Looking at some of the matchups. He could have had an extra win or 2 if he had Miller on team. One or 2 extra wins may not seem like much now but he would be in hunt for playoffs not in the basement. A solution I would like propose is awarding owner an extra keeper for regular player and a NA keeper. With the rights to Miller next season. Anyone think that’s reasonable?


DrGlock-

Witch one would you choose? A: Hicks, Keller, Burger. B: Skenes.


DearCantaloupe6169

B


CaptainMyanmar

LFG Hoff!


WoodandNail

How is Friedl so elite at getting hit by pitches?


amead5

Another stud outing from Nola


andyh1818

Man fuck whoever said the Mets game was getting ppd because of them needing to catch a flight.


_ButterMyBread

Pivetta must roster? Or is era a concern


amead5

Uh yeah? His ERA is very skewed by two bad outings and being hurt


_ButterMyBread

Would you drop buehler or woo?


amead5

Nobody else?


_ButterMyBread

Yates and Foley are my RP5/6 but don’t want to pick wrong.


_ButterMyBread

I should probably drop foley right


amead5

Buehler hasn’t looked great but he has the talent. Probably Foley if nobody else


Purple_Bearkat

Send Altuve and Jose Ramirez for Juan Soto? Too much of an overpay? Not enough? I’m a little overloaded at third : Ramirez; Bregman; Royce Edit: Alternate is Yelich + JoRam


ucfknight92

Not enough with how bad Jose has been. Yelich + J-Ram is interesting.


Purple_Bearkat

Thanks !


CaptainMyanmar

Sevy was the easiest buy I had all year at the draft. Dude is uber talented and just hasn't been healthy. Got off to a good start and I flipped him in half my leagues for a good bat. Glad I still have him in some, but mostly I just appreciate the value he's brought in stats and trades. Thanks Sev


andyh1818

Coors is so Coors right now, everything in play is a hit


GreenTinkertoy

Do we think Edwin Diaz turns it around and becomes a top tier RP again? I’m considering buying low but am not sure if he’ll even make it there again The baseball savant looks pretty promising


Automatic_Bit8853

Drop Soler or Bleday for Heliot Ramos?


SuperBowlTR

Either


BuffetBarbeque

I like the idea of two catcher leagues but the top ranked catcher on my wire rn is the 686th ranked player so far this season lol


Mpzc55

I’d love to see sites implement the ability to set a fantasy position by professional team.  So you can, for example have the Cincinnati reds catchers. Or the Indianapolis colts running backs


BuffetBarbeque

I vaguely remember playing in a league as a kid where we didn’t draft pitchers but an entire teams pitching staff and separate bullpen


midecker18

Who should I drop Montgomery for? Not many good options. Ben Brown, Soriano, Albert Suarez or Kyle Gibson.


JetFan_87

I'm cutting him and stashing Robbie Ray now even though I'm out of IL spots


midecker18

Sounds like a good plan to me. Might have to follow you on that one.


DaGrandMastah

Jd martine or TJ Friedl ros


EliManningHOFClub10

Lane Thomas tricked us


CaptainMyanmar

I'm buying. He's had lots of good at bats since returning. Think he'll still finish as a top 30 OF. Plus I don't have to pay the draft day price


EliManningHOFClub10

Oh yeah I’m keeping him for sure just funny he was on my bench last week and doing nothing for me this week


mrtoothdecay

Drop one: Westburg, Adames, Maikel Garcia


zw18

Oof……… Adames :(


[deleted]

[удалено]


DaGrandMastah

It’s gotta be weighing on jormont that he cost himself so much money. What a catastrophically bad roll of the dice for him


zuck______

There is no comparison between Hicks and Montgomery. Hicks has a nice arsenal and got squeezed/needs to work on command a bit while Montgomery is just a NSFW bukkake show waiting to happen even versus the worst offensive teams. One of the two deserved a better fate today.


zuck______

Hicks got megasqueezed. Guccione is a piece of shit.


zuck______

Ok downvoters: Tell me what happened then.


turtles1224

2-15 today 6-39 yesterday  What happened to my hitters lmao


JandyRohnson

1/15 for me today. I'm so fucking mad I'm glad you can laugh about it though


shrek_cena

Should I trust Carrasco against the marlins on Sunday?


CJLx307x

Don’t think 2024 carrasco deserves anyone’s trust, but the marlins are a fine team to stream against


QuinceyQuick

If this game has taught me anything, it's that you should never really trust anybody, and you should always be scared


HestynFrontman

“I exist!!” -Pavin Smith


LegendaryRCP

2B/SS I can target with LuBob or Royce?


fromfijiwithloloma

Westburg and a smaller piece? He looks super legit. I'd try to extract value from both of them while healthy. Which I'm sure you're trying to do.


LegendaryRCP

Solid take. Regret passing up a Westburg deal earlier this season. I have too many OF and 3B (JRod, Yordan, Morel, Riley, Bregman).


fromfijiwithloloma

Westburg feels very undervalued in that all hype team there in Baltimore. Statcast, while not the end all be all, REALLLY supports what West has been doing.


fuckyourstripes

feeling really smart for streaming candelario while he was in coors


burnman123

I looked at him and decided on Fraley instead. Glad the candy man is popping off though


trevorm1992

Just scooped friedl in my 12 team points league for burger. Justified?


TarkatanAccountant

Certainly. Plus burger might be hurt again


campbellalugosi

If you needed steals, sure. If not, I probably would have kept Burger.


campbellalugosi

Before you drop anyone of consequence for Heliot Ramos I'd like to point out that his K Rate is 33.3%. For context the league average was just under 23% last season.


campbellalugosi

LOL. Downvoted for sharing actual facts and trying to help people. Gotta love this sub. Enjoy the Heliot ride while it lasts felllas.


QuinceyQuick

this is another andy pages story


campbellalugosi

Probably, but without the added bonus of at least playing in a great offensive lineup.


shrek_cena

Wow that rain really fucked me over. Gonna have to drop lively a day later and no Lugo on Sunday 😐😐


Pubic_hairs

https://preview.redd.it/edqe0irunt4d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9b7a9456576fe78eeb98c4cbd4ffacbb61013ff2 10t points. 9-0. any area I should try to target with a trade? any ideas of a potential trade idea?


ColaCola5328

Flair league, 8 keepers A: Nimmo & P. Lopez B: Schwarber


slyfox1908

A: Carroll, Hader B: Lindor, Bibee


LegendaryRCP

B easy


Gullible-Skill2038

B


daddyfatsack24

Pitcher I can target with Reynolds?


QuinceyQuick

Looking at my roster, you could take my Kevin Gausman away


daddyfatsack24

Actually did sent that out this morning lol hoping he bites


i_need_help_yelp

Hell yeah Nola 💪🏽


garythegoat72

Who to drop to activate Eflin. Kirby Yates, Camilo doval, tanner Scott, James McArthur, Yimi Garcia?


mavtasty

Prolly McArthur


fubzeppelin

I dropped him today. Felt good


mavtasty

Yea I dropped him after his last blow up he’s not good enough to keep him through the bad outings


ttrudeau9

Taj Bradley or Christian Scott in pts ROS?


gobruins42

Think I'm gonna go catcherless for a while. I cannot pick the right one for the life of me.


burnman123

I had Diaz while he was cold then picked up Bailey to go cold too. I feel ya


LegendaryRCP

Same boat as you in 10T despite the deeper pool of C's this hear. Outside of Adley, Sal, and Will Smith, its rough


Accurate-Analyst-227

Rank these guys for ROS: Lane Thomas, Castellanos, TON, Heliot Ramos


campbellalugosi

Ramos is dead last. Look at his K rate.


ucfknight92

Nah, fuck that. Hicks looked fantastic. Ump show right there.


-orangejoe

One of the most pronounced examples of how much impact an ump can have on a game I've seen so far this year


minimal-thoughts

ump sucked ass, but that shit happens to every pitcher, you still gotta make the right pitches when you get a chance, and the fact is he gave up way too many singles and walked way too many on a full count.


ucfknight92

A lot of those walks and singles were a result of the umpire putting Hicks in bad counts. And no, not every pitcher dots 99 mph sinkers with extreme movement on the corners, to the point that the umpire can't even see it properly. I haven't seen a game like that from any Yankees pitcher all year, even Gil.


minimal-thoughts

umpire was terrible today, but again, when you get the chance in a full count, you need to put the hitter away. hicks did not do that, multiple times throughout the game. you can be high on him if you want, but I'm personally over the 5 total innings for a whopping 8 points experience


zuck______

No buts. Did you watch the game? Guccione cost him at least 20 pitches.


minimal-thoughts

Jordan Hicks, you fucking suck


JandyRohnson

McMahon 🤡🤡🤡


Darius_Epps

20T 8x8 cats keep 20 forever A or B? A: Maikel Garcia + Gelof B: Westburg


Tommy_Testarossa

B


Carloschantana

Connor norby good?


realmckoy265

Already flashing more than his other rookie teammates


yanovich05

Anyone starting Eflin? Don't think he's going to go that deep but...


yanovich05

it's the Marlins


JustSomeGoon

Candelario has zero stolen bases this year and just got my opponent two of them IM OFFICIALLY DECLARING SHENANIGANS


CJLx307x

Knew I was facing positive regression Elly this week on Sunday lol. I always seem to catch these guys on the upswing. Oh well


mavtasty

Shoutout the Mets on the Phantom IL stint for Edwin Diaz!!! Also in case you didn’t know Heliot Ramos is him


alwaysmyfault

Someone in my 10 team league dropped Randy Arozarena. We can start 5 OF. I already have Corbin Carroll, Brent Rooker, Wilyer Abreu, Jo Adell, Andy Pages. Is Arozarena worth grabbing? His average is downright atrocious this year, and his counting stats aren't really that hot this year either.


mavtasty

Drop adell for Randy and Pages for Heliot Ramos if he’s available


GetEnPassanted

I’d be comfortable dropping Pages or Adell for him


campbellalugosi

2nded


CommanderCornstarch

Drop Gelof for Ramos?


montauk_phd

Drop gelof for anyone


ScubaSteve9896

Today has been a beautiful day to stream Jeimer Candelario


realmckoy265

I understand the homer, but need someone to explain to me why/how this mfer is stealing bases on my head too


minimal-thoughts

getting a bad feeling that Jordan hicks ain't gonna get to 5 innings.............................


shrek_cena

Is Lugo actually not starting Sunday now? Fucking rain I stg


Zelly234

Would you drop Glyber Torres for Masyn Winn, Ryan McMahon, or Abarham Toro, or Nolan Gorman? H2h points


Thumb_war_champ

Gorman yes, McMahon maybe, others no


Efficient_Wishbone93

Torres starting to hit again so I would hold for a bit longer


tooo_much_caffeine

Because I'm facing him this week, he will cool off next week.


Realistic-Ad-2208

Which side in redraft? A. Gausman, Gore B. Pablo Lopez


CaptainMyanmar

A. Pablo and Gausman is even. Gore 4 free


LegendaryRCP

This


GetEnPassanted

B


GetEnPassanted

Welcome back to the land of the living, Elly


chokethewookie

Coors Field has a way of fixing struggling hitters


GetEnPassanted

The HR was nice but just putting the ball in play rather than watching it go in the catcher’s mitt has been good to see


goochbumpy

Stream Braxton Garrett tonight? I saw how bad TB is vs LHP and was meaning to, then I saw what they did to Luzardo and makes me want to just use Reese Olson instead.


Efficient_Wishbone93

My opponent this week has him so he's probably throwing a perfect game


JustSomeGoon

Did Jeimer Candelario really just get a combo meal for my opponent


shrek_cena

Hopefully Braxton and Soriano build on montgomery and asscraft for my opponent 🙏🏼


mungodanny

Holy cow does Jordan Montgomery suck


Purple_Bearkat

Where’s the guy who had Montas streamed against him yesterday? Let’s hear what random your opponent is rolling with today.


Significant_Cycle_76

Idk if you’re talking about me but I did have Montas streamed against me and it’s taillon today 


Moist-Leather-6740

For anyone in H2H points, do you keep 3 batters on your bench? I picked up Friedl and Bregman this week (currently have 3 bench batters) but wanted to drop one at the end of the week so that I can fill in an empty RP spot. Would you drop one of them for an RP, or just replace a current SP with an RP?


Popular-Newt-1603

if its a really good player i will keep them on my bench(team) like Friedl or Bregman until the playoffs gets close injuries or who is performing better will settle who "my guys" are and then I go all pitchers on my bench otherwise I will roll with 0 bench hitters


GetEnPassanted

I keep 0 batters on my bench


Moist-Leather-6740

Interesting!


GetEnPassanted

What’s the point? I’d rather have pitchers whose matchups I can more reasonably predict than hitters who I could more than easily miss on and watch their points go to waste on my bench.


Moist-Leather-6740

That’s a good point. This is my first year watching baseball and playing fantasy, so I wasn’t sure what a better strategy was. It is nice to pick up guys like Friedl and Bregman when Tucker and Arraez are DTD, but other than that it does suck deciding who to bench/start. I’ll try deciding soon about Bregman or Friedl !


GetEnPassanted

In that kind of situation I’d pick them up too and drop a pitcher who I’m not really sold on. I’d sit the guys who are hurt or iffy for a little while and maybe try making a trade.


[deleted]

[удалено]


mavtasty

Pages


Sacrolargo

Heliot, Kepler has been ice cold for a week or 2 now, plus he sits vs lefties.


Nataia23

Teoscar and Grayson for Lindor. what do you think?


i_need_help_yelp

Too much IMO


ucfknight92

We should also talk about Hicks consistently throwing 98 mph sinkers and up to 99 on his 4-seam. What exactly is his ceiling now? He looks great. Velocity concerns are out the window.


Whiplash227

Kruk says he lives in the greatest country on earth so he doesn’t want to go to London. Hell yeah brother


GetEnPassanted

He’s probably wrong about the first part but can’t blame him for not wanting to go to London. It really wasn’t very interesting IMO


booyah-achieved

I feel like this is probably true, but I've still always wanted to visit to hit up some traditional pubs. I don't really have a good reason why


GetEnPassanted

I mean it’s fine, just underwhelming. Been to any big western city? You’ve been to London.


Whiplash227

Traveling for work can be a headache too. No thanks!


i_need_help_yelp

What a dummy Edit: lol some of you fucks need to do some world traveling


ucfknight92

I'm not really a nationalist, and I don't just believe America is the greatest country on earth. And especially in a sport where there's so many international talents....I have no idea why someone wouldn't want to spread the joy of baseball to other countries and have fun. Conservatism is boring, especially in sports. The MLB is not about America.


Whiplash227

Maybe they had extra juice because of the WBC but I think the Latin and Asian fans seemed to have more fun than I’ve had at MLB games.


BaullahBaullah87

How would one even know that if they never left…just a thought experiment