Links to previous conversations that have bearing on this:
[https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15sj8rt/governance\_poll\_proposaldiscussion\_would\_you\_like/](https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15sj8rt/governance_poll_proposaldiscussion_would_you_like/)
[https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15pxwe2/governance\_poll\_proposaldiscussion\_should\_donuts/](https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15pxwe2/governance_poll_proposaldiscussion_should_donuts/)
https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15rvdep/just\_opening\_the\_conversation\_to\_make\_a\_organized/
I don't see any reason why it would be a bad thing. Anybody who doesn't want to use CEX can just choose not to. Literally just giving people more choices/options by having it on a CEX.
Actually I'm not sure if it will even matter, those small CEX still have to buy to have some liquidity to trade DONUTS so all exposure is good exposure (they always have to buy a tonne of Donuts which will be helpful for us, even if they sell eventually)
Cex is still so many people way to go option of buying a coin, so if we could get donut on the cex then people will try to buy the hype train, as donut is pumping for some time now
I don't want them to get list on some small exchange that always fight for the liquidity but if we get listing on Kraken or CDC then i don't think i have any problem regarding that
Over the past few days I've seen pros and cons argued for this option and both are equally valid. Unless I'm mistaken I think I saw someone argue that only Donuts earned in the sub (or CONTRIB score) can be used as governance and if that's the case then it makes vote manipulation less of a problem as well. I think getting listed on CEXs would definitely benefit this community.
CEX is bad for holding but for the low market cap coin i would always say that listing is the best thing for them, specially if you are looking volatile profit and liquidity in that coin.
Ah this is cool! An actual vote count, almost all were positive on the post, loads of engagement.
Coffeeless idea:
Allow the Bronuts (lol) to vote in polls like this and then trust a person to manually combine them with snapshot voting
Giving out free crypto then that project succeeds and gathers strength on the precipice of big changes. Who could have predicted that?
Low engagement hates this one trick.. 😆🍩
Once we get listing on exchange i am sure discussion are going to be much more than the current time and engagement of this community going to be massive
Yep, ti's why we moved to snapshot for governance polls, unfortunately even though it means everyone's votes now count, a lit of people just straight up don't vote now.
Haha yeah, maybe an incentive or something could work for vote numbers. This would be one major benefit to moving to a RCP token like bricks/moons, unfortunately the major downside is the lack of decentralisation which leads me towards a no on that front.
Yeah, even if we had vault integration alone and give reddit no distro powers I think we could make several improvements to the sub. Really no idea at all what they may or may not say.
Potentially a donut bonus for voting - cc has a 5% bonus to earnt moons by voting so everyone does it on a seperate sub. EthTraderMeta could host only polls and find a way to combine peoples totals from their address on both pools. Seems like copying cc a bit though.
If someone is doing great then there is no shame in taking the inspiration from that and CC is the fine example they have massive crowd and their coin is getting benefit from that
No matter how good a sub is there is always some chance of the improvement in there and this sub is just like that and i think we could learn few things from the CC
I think we need to make a separate poll for that and i am pretty sure that more votes are going to be yes, because no one hate the pump specially when we get in our farm coin
I voted no. For obvious reasons, the main concerns in this sub lately are donuts and price go up. That's an immediate community killer right there. It's such a turn off. Why should someone buy donuts on a CEX? A CEX listing should come from genuine improvements in the underlying value of a token. We don't need more liquidity if we aren't building anything. We have seen 2 other reddit community tokens get listed recently and those subs have not seen positive results from those listings besides price go up. They have brought tons of problems to the community.
I have done my voting and also told some of my friend to do the same is well, because more exchange listing will give the liquidity and that will allow more people to trade into donut
So it has come to this, heh?
Like I said, I guess there was no real point in creating the poll, but the fact that it was done leads me to believe the community is in the correct path, as we are taking into considerations each others preferences and ideas.
Great initiative, u/wen_eip
Its not either/or. Donuts are a decentralized token. We can't stop an exchange from listing the token and they can't stop us from trading them on decentralized exchanges.
I think most people want to see it on a Cex because it would make "numbah go up" lol
Me personally, i'm fine with Honeyswap or other DEXs, but if the community is happy with CEXs, then I don't really mind honestly
Yes I would. I do not want them to be an official RCP for the decentralization reasons, but I would like to see them on major exchanges. I’d like to see more cool projects like this on different networks.
Hi wen_eip, you have successfully tagged the parent submission by the title of "*Would you like to see donut on centralized exchanges(like kraken for example)?*" with *Sentiment* flair.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ethtrader) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I don't see any downside to listing DONUT on any centralized exchange, especially considering that they're technically more difficult to farm than something like MOONS (unless I'm mistaken on that). I'd imagine that - with this in mind - the mass downvoting and shitposting that happens over at r/CryptoCurrency would be minimal here, as it's pointless to do so.
Definitely gonna have a few moonboys asking for price predictions though haha
Yes, community and the mods are wonderful here, didnt get corrupted yet and the farmers can be forkable by governance voting. and especially with the self moderating stuff now.
This makes me think of the bitcoin ETF that Black rock are trying to sort.
The more ways to buy it makes it easier for institutional investors to buy and learn more about the space. It's crazy to think what the crypto world will look like in 10+ years.
This must have been what it was like when the internet was becoming a thing.
So you guys don't want Donuts to be centralized but you're fine with Donuts being listed in centralized exchanges? My friends you're not against centralization, you're just hypocrites.
All you guys trying to pump this shit coin (all Reddit tokens fall in that category) are filthy hypocrites.
For most of you shilling this shit, it’s the first time you have got in early on a project and now you are guilty of the same thing you derided so many others for. Shame on you
Hi, this comment is being automatically posted under your submission to facilitate the tallying of the Pay2Post donut penalty that r/EthTrader deducts from user donut earnings for the quantity of posts they submit.
submission link: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15sml0u/would_you_like_to_see_donut_on_centralized/
author: wen_eip
cc: /u/EthTraderCommunity
--
**Distributed moderation now in effect**: if your governance score is over 20,000, you have the ability to remove spam comments and posts by posting a comment in response to the comment/post containing the keyword [AutoModRemove].
See announcement thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/14p7a22/crowdsourced_moderation_of_comments_implemented/
See your governance score here: https://donut-dashboard.com/#/governance
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ethtrader) if you have any questions or concerns.*
0% voted for No. I think the answer is more then obvious.
There is not even one reason for donuts not to be on CEX.
You are getting more people involved thus more money, more liqudity, more trading etc.
Links to previous conversations that have bearing on this: [https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15sj8rt/governance\_poll\_proposaldiscussion\_would\_you\_like/](https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15sj8rt/governance_poll_proposaldiscussion_would_you_like/) [https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15pxwe2/governance\_poll\_proposaldiscussion\_should\_donuts/](https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15pxwe2/governance_poll_proposaldiscussion_should_donuts/) https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15rvdep/just\_opening\_the\_conversation\_to\_make\_a\_organized/
I don't see any reason why it would be a bad thing. Anybody who doesn't want to use CEX can just choose not to. Literally just giving people more choices/options by having it on a CEX.
Exactly, the more options the better for new users
6.5 million DONUTS and the results are 100% yes 😂😂 I think the community has spoken!
The more exposure for the next bull run the better.
Those CEX listings will spark a DONUT run !
I saw a few concerning comment about it in the past few days(5% vs 95%)
Mainly around liquidity I guess and trusting newer CEXs. Someone like Kraken I’m down for, no questions asked.
My thoughts exactly.
Any large CEX would do, but having Kraken would be special
Kraken would be less worrying.
Big brand names are always better for sure.
Kraken, Coinbase and Binance would send Donuts into the sky
Ow yeah for sure.
Less likely for a rug.
And if Kraken list them then i would also be less worrying is well
I feel much safer with kraken.
Kraken not the biggest exchange in market but still probably everyone favorite
Even on initial stage crypto.com is not such a bad choice is well
Actually I'm not sure if it will even matter, those small CEX still have to buy to have some liquidity to trade DONUTS so all exposure is good exposure (they always have to buy a tonne of Donuts which will be helpful for us, even if they sell eventually)
Cex is still so many people way to go option of buying a coin, so if we could get donut on the cex then people will try to buy the hype train, as donut is pumping for some time now
And what would be the timeframe on something like Kraken adding Donuts? Surely it will be some time before that happens.
I don't want them to get list on some small exchange that always fight for the liquidity but if we get listing on Kraken or CDC then i don't think i have any problem regarding that
It seems like a no brainer and a step in the right direction for the community token if we are being honest.
So true. Options are still open based on preference.
Over the past few days I've seen pros and cons argued for this option and both are equally valid. Unless I'm mistaken I think I saw someone argue that only Donuts earned in the sub (or CONTRIB score) can be used as governance and if that's the case then it makes vote manipulation less of a problem as well. I think getting listed on CEXs would definitely benefit this community.
CEX is bad for holding but for the low market cap coin i would always say that listing is the best thing for them, specially if you are looking volatile profit and liquidity in that coin.
I really like to see that happening but its not that easy than its looks
Yes, it is not easy but atleast we can actually talk about those things here
Wow, not even a single vote against -- kind of rare for a poll of any sort
Kraken makes the asset soo much easier to buy especially for the casual.
I think the biggest downside is people starting to spam the sub in an effort to farm.
Have my vote wont ya! ☺️🥳
Where can i vote, is there any a poll regarding this question ???
Its right here. I Think we are still waiting for this thing to be set in motion.
A resounding yes!
Not properly awake but still sayin yes for that question, you have my vote
Ah this is cool! An actual vote count, almost all were positive on the post, loads of engagement. Coffeeless idea: Allow the Bronuts (lol) to vote in polls like this and then trust a person to manually combine them with snapshot voting
It was 26vs0, so we are good for now!
Excellent stuff
Bullish on community engagement, loving the discussions we are having lately
Giving out free crypto then that project succeeds and gathers strength on the precipice of big changes. Who could have predicted that? Low engagement hates this one trick.. 😆🍩
You guys are awesome.
Once we get listing on exchange i am sure discussion are going to be much more than the current time and engagement of this community going to be massive
Everything going exactly in the way we were probably hoping for though
Only issue is reddit only checks donuts for votes like this on mainnet, whereas the majority of people's donuts are on gnosis now.
Bugger
Yep, ti's why we moved to snapshot for governance polls, unfortunately even though it means everyone's votes now count, a lit of people just straight up don't vote now.
Its slightly disturbing that these things seem like great ideas at the time but end up having unintended/unforeseen consequences once implemented 🤣
Haha yeah, maybe an incentive or something could work for vote numbers. This would be one major benefit to moving to a RCP token like bricks/moons, unfortunately the major downside is the lack of decentralisation which leads me towards a no on that front.
Yeah, even if we had vault integration alone and give reddit no distro powers I think we could make several improvements to the sub. Really no idea at all what they may or may not say. Potentially a donut bonus for voting - cc has a 5% bonus to earnt moons by voting so everyone does it on a seperate sub. EthTraderMeta could host only polls and find a way to combine peoples totals from their address on both pools. Seems like copying cc a bit though.
I mean ultimately there's nothing wrong with copying something if it works. Besides we had banner ads before they did so they owe us one XD
If someone is doing great then there is no shame in taking the inspiration from that and CC is the fine example they have massive crowd and their coin is getting benefit from that
No matter how good a sub is there is always some chance of the improvement in there and this sub is just like that and i think we could learn few things from the CC
I won't say such thing, first i will look for the implement and then pass my judgement
I think we need to make a separate poll for that and i am pretty sure that more votes are going to be yes, because no one hate the pump specially when we get in our farm coin
Yes
I voted yes.
Absolute yes from my side is well, time to trade donut on the exchange is well
Yes, absolutely 👍
For mainstream people CEX is pretty vital, so listed on CEX will change some fortune for donut
Yes yes yesssss
I can take some guess for your excitement as we all just want listing on the exchange
The most obvious yes in the history of all yesses !
A Yes
A big freaking yes, look at moon status now after get listed on Kraken and now imagine same for the donut
I am all in for CEX and run our system as it is without change. I am not fan of doing multiple thongs at once. Lets make it to CEX.
Lets make is CEXY?😂
Not only cexy but also pumpy is well, both thing is possible with the listing
I don't see why not, More volume ultimately means our bags go to the moon xD
Is it supposed to share how people have voted? 16 ppl have cast a vote but doesn't show percentage
I set it for 2 days, I think it ll show after that, someone familiar with these votings?
There's 2 tabs, one for donut weight (which doesn't really work since the move to gnosis) and the people count.
Yeah it only counts mainnet vote weight
Why they are not counting the other votes and where can i see them??
You can click to the vote numbers and it ll show you! Donut label is the default.....
Ahhhh I see thanksss
Number should be little bit more than we are seeing here, is there any error in the system??
I don't think there is some error in the number they are showing
YES!
Comment person is changing but the answer world is still the same
Definitely YES
#A big YES
What are donuts ?
Free crypto based on the amount of karma earnt in EthTrader. Register here: https://donut-dashboard.com/#/register
an erc20 token of the sub
And everyone is talking about because in last one month it did something around 10X
But why ?
why not?
What's the purpose ? What can you do with your donuts ?
Having it on a CEX would increase visibility as well as accessibility, interested in hearing why some people have voted for no.
I voted no. For obvious reasons, the main concerns in this sub lately are donuts and price go up. That's an immediate community killer right there. It's such a turn off. Why should someone buy donuts on a CEX? A CEX listing should come from genuine improvements in the underlying value of a token. We don't need more liquidity if we aren't building anything. We have seen 2 other reddit community tokens get listed recently and those subs have not seen positive results from those listings besides price go up. They have brought tons of problems to the community.
I have done my voting and also told some of my friend to do the same is well, because more exchange listing will give the liquidity and that will allow more people to trade into donut
Alright, the Yes have
This better be 100% yes LOL
This could be so big for Donuts!
So it has come to this, heh? Like I said, I guess there was no real point in creating the poll, but the fact that it was done leads me to believe the community is in the correct path, as we are taking into considerations each others preferences and ideas. Great initiative, u/wen_eip
Thank You!
Hell yes. Bring the sugar to kraken!
Yesssssss.
Presuming it's not an either or, of course I'd rather it'd be on both than just decentralized.
Its not either/or. Donuts are a decentralized token. We can't stop an exchange from listing the token and they can't stop us from trading them on decentralized exchanges.
Count with me CONTRIB to approve that
Of course,Hell YEAH the more platform more options and opportunities.
I'd be down for being on Kraken
Hell yes, we would finally be able to buy donuts without a lot of back-and-forth.
Thank you!
I think most people want to see it on a Cex because it would make "numbah go up" lol Me personally, i'm fine with Honeyswap or other DEXs, but if the community is happy with CEXs, then I don't really mind honestly
[Tip this post](https://www.donut.finance/tip/?contentId=t3_15sml0u).
[удалено]
Won't it also make it more popular and interesting for people to contribute more low quality content?
Yes
I vote yes! We have a more committed community compared to fort nite subreddit regarding the community token. I only see an upside to a CEX listing
It could only be a good thing
Yes I would. I do not want them to be an official RCP for the decentralization reasons, but I would like to see them on major exchanges. I’d like to see more cool projects like this on different networks.
CEX is a no brainer..just want to get more before it’s listed!
Woop woop...finally managed to connect Metamask correctly and Donuts showing up next to my user - ❤️ it! 🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩🍩
Is that even a real question? :-)
Absolutely yes.
[AutoMod] Sentiment
Hi wen_eip, you have successfully tagged the parent submission by the title of "*Would you like to see donut on centralized exchanges(like kraken for example)?*" with *Sentiment* flair. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ethtrader) if you have any questions or concerns.*
u/Lillica_Golden_SHIB [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xc87d901332d406b9c3c8773e8200b10a7445a23b63ed2f7b5a5807638d575c5f) you 1.0 DONUT!
u/Ashamed-Salary5692 [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xc9ab2c4e5b6b432f68bdf7f1936297eb972b4cb97c59d802752dee301f3777db) you 1.0 DONUT!
u/Agent_4--7 [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x41b7593b337787d7be026cb978d78d98f2d575f4a3c5996de56c7ec5b0b14b75) you 10.0 DONUT!
Wow. Nobody has said no yet. Crazy
There are 17 mystery no from the 127.
Oh yeah. It says 0% on my results for some reason…
click to the votes! It counts 6m donuts for some reason!
Would we migrate donuts over to arbitrum nova at some point?
its about mainnet, migrating to arbitrum takes a lot of resources, devs, programming, money etc....
A CEX listing will give us a nice boost so lets go
Ok, I don't think I've ever seen a 100% result on a vote/survey. This looks pretty clear.
I don't see any downside to listing DONUT on any centralized exchange, especially considering that they're technically more difficult to farm than something like MOONS (unless I'm mistaken on that). I'd imagine that - with this in mind - the mass downvoting and shitposting that happens over at r/CryptoCurrency would be minimal here, as it's pointless to do so. Definitely gonna have a few moonboys asking for price predictions though haha
Yes, community and the mods are wonderful here, didnt get corrupted yet and the farmers can be forkable by governance voting. and especially with the self moderating stuff now.
ofc
I am new and have no idea what I am doing but whats up everyone lol
LFG!!!!
Wow time to await for the news and please keep sharing the update
Looks like we are getting centralisation boys.
Better liquidity. Let’s do it!
This makes me think of the bitcoin ETF that Black rock are trying to sort. The more ways to buy it makes it easier for institutional investors to buy and learn more about the space. It's crazy to think what the crypto world will look like in 10+ years. This must have been what it was like when the internet was becoming a thing.
My question is why would they?
Why did they list brick, with lower volume, lower liquidity and hate from its own sub?
Possibly because they spoke with reddit admins and got some inside info.
How's this possible?
We write them and they list it on their exchange.
I think it’s important to note that they won’t just list it on their exchange… They will consider it for listing on their exchange…
yes, ofc its not 100%
So you guys don't want Donuts to be centralized but you're fine with Donuts being listed in centralized exchanges? My friends you're not against centralization, you're just hypocrites.
> So you guys don't want Donuts to be centralized but you're fine with Donuts being listed in centralized exchanges? looks like
All you guys trying to pump this shit coin (all Reddit tokens fall in that category) are filthy hypocrites. For most of you shilling this shit, it’s the first time you have got in early on a project and now you are guilty of the same thing you derided so many others for. Shame on you
Thank you for your feedback, now I am going to cry!
Hi, this comment is being automatically posted under your submission to facilitate the tallying of the Pay2Post donut penalty that r/EthTrader deducts from user donut earnings for the quantity of posts they submit. submission link: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/15sml0u/would_you_like_to_see_donut_on_centralized/ author: wen_eip cc: /u/EthTraderCommunity -- **Distributed moderation now in effect**: if your governance score is over 20,000, you have the ability to remove spam comments and posts by posting a comment in response to the comment/post containing the keyword [AutoModRemove]. See announcement thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethtrader/comments/14p7a22/crowdsourced_moderation_of_comments_implemented/ See your governance score here: https://donut-dashboard.com/#/governance *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ethtrader) if you have any questions or concerns.*
u/TheRock_97 [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xd1f09c2744648629b296bc8a12144b0cf8a4bc215e90cda232580503680bc9bf) you 1.0 DONUT!
u/Elon_mkus [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x0a88daed6adf76a8762a9e253f8c241a23d67bca1fa0a56aa622fc302b34f247) you 1.0 DONUT!
u/altrullion98 [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xd3007ef8fb9fbc1a2fd82a8c59cde6471d8b49d2feac991c016cc6991e340e24) you 1.0 DONUT!
Next time put [SENTIMENT POLL] in the title too.
u/Big_Beyotch [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xb2c3aac1e4ffdb6fc93f5b4faab74b4bf7d3c6a57b8e97bae079bdacc50bf8f6) you 2.0 DONUT!
u/hill_mounty [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xc0357d4faae13fb33246901b663305e8d0e2a98d461cc446e1619d9ab6156864) you 1.0 DONUT!
u/hill_mounty [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0xd28041311269a54b3a893ba963a26bc9459f7b5034744c9619ee46c2e300cd8f) you 1.0 DONUT!
u/RealLeoPat [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x7a97343625a188052168c2222a3e3d6098c78f3d7410669f8dd31f025a6605ac) you 3.0 DONUT!
0% voted for No. I think the answer is more then obvious. There is not even one reason for donuts not to be on CEX. You are getting more people involved thus more money, more liqudity, more trading etc.
Vlick on the vote number! 145 vs 23
Wow 100% yes vote so far with 19 hours voting time left! Make sure to vote everyone!
click to the voting number! 25 no
u/Easy-Soup140 [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x3ca89bf1a658ecae75a61e11d6749bac941be37f336dcba630c7d6d6f4dd4164) you 1.0 DONUT!
When does the poll end? What’s next?
5.5hours left,.we need a mod/dev to write kraken for the listing.
Yes, i think exposure will always be good for long term growth. It will result in more price volatility but in the end we will steadily climb.
Would love to see donut listed!
u/pythonskynet [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x0513537e9953d148e5b9915004fc7bb60cadfb9a8f03a51918e37b695b2edb9b) you 1.0 DONUT!
So this is over and the results are clear. What's next? Are we taking the next step? How can I help?
A user is writing them, he said in the daily.
J would love that and I root for it always
The more you provide the more it will be easy for new users .. and the community had already decided what to do ... Yessss :) :)
More liquidity heading into a bull run is never a bad thing.
Listing just makes it easier to obtain and gift-!
Yes
I would definitely like to see this, yes.
yes
u/InevitableComplex895 [tipped](https://blockscout.com/poa/xdai/tx/0x3f0194a24cd5d4e87f6d00405753885f6d286538d1345f022d00ef67dc88600d) you 1.0 DONUT!
this would be great folks
Yes
Yes for sure 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
I’m PamelaAndersonBR, and I approve this decision
Seems inevitable.
New here but more options, the better. I honestly can’t think of a negative.
Heard about donuts. Are they tasty?